Actions

Work Header

there are voices in my head (the loudest one is mine)

Summary:

Jonathan Byers is determined to rise up his high school social ladder - enough so he isn't bullied anymore, and maybe so he can win over Nancy Wheeler. Then Billy Hargrove introduces him to the F.L.A.Y.E.R, a mini-computer the size of a pill, that will help him become cool. Only, the F.L.A.Y.E.R has more nefarious plans.

aka the jargyle be more chill au

Notes:

title from voices in my head from the be more chill musical

a huge thank you to the st big bang for giving me the opportunity to bring this fic to life. i've been thinking non-stop about it since the august after st s4.

and an even bigger thank you to my beta - my wondeful irl friend mae who doesnt like fanfic all that much but does like my writing, and to the lovey Ptera who created the artwork and playlist for this fic.

please listen to the playlist here

trigger warnings are in the tags

enjoy :)

Chapter 1: more than survive

Chapter Text

cover art and playlist by Ptera ❤️🩷🧡💛💚💙


Chapter 1: More Than Survive

The air in the bedroom was thick and musty, the curtains closed, and the window shut. It was too early in the morning to think about anything other than going to sleep, but the alarm clock was blinking the slow taunting red.

With a groan, Jonathan slammed his hand against the annoyance and rolled out of bed. His mom would be coming in any minute now, and he wanted to air out as much of the weed scent as possible. He opened the curtain, scowled at the sun and opened his window. Outside, the air was cool, the warmth of summer slipping into the fall breeze.

There was a message from Argyle from three am since that guy never seemed to sleep. It was just a meme, but Jonathan saved it to his phone anyway. He showed them to Will sometimes.

He could hear is mom moving around the house, in that light frantic way of hers. Like a cat that scurries down the corridor. Both Will and Jonathan did as well, as Argyle often pointed out, but it was the most prominent with Joyce. She had lived with Lonnie longer after all.

There’s a light knock on the door. “I’m up!” He called.

“Okay! Breakfast is ready whenever!” She called back before going to Will’s room.

She seemed extra chipper this morning, probably because it was Will’s final year of middle school. It probably wouldn’t be as exciting if he hadn’t been kidnapped and legally dead for most of last year. On the other hand, Jonathan was going into his junior year.

He had two goals this year. Get a girlfriend (preferably Nancy Wheeler) and rise at least one rung in the social ladder. He wouldn’t necessarily call it a mission, but it was something he was determined to try at least.

Sighing, Jonathan pulled himself from bed and looked around. His room was messy, the remnants of the weekend apparent on the floor. There was a pile of dirty laundry on his desk chair, and his actual hamper was overfilled, which meant Joyce had forgot to do the laundry (again). Jonathan would do it when he got home. Reluctantly, he pulled on one of his shirts that usually stayed at the bottom of the pile – it was too small and had a hole under the armpit.

He pulled on the jeans he’d warn the day before and made his way downstairs, rolling he sleeves up to his elbows, so their shortness wasn’t as obvious. Will and Joyce were already eating breakfast: Will silently and with the intense focus of a boy trying to be normal, whilst their mom was fluttering around the kitchen, toast in hand.

“How many cups have you had?” Jonathan asked, pulling the cereal over.

Joyce grinned, all teeth, “Only one.” She knocked against the cupboard and the bang startled her like a cat. Jonathan wasn’t entirely sure whether that revelation was better or not.

As he ate his fruit loops, Jonathan nudged Will’s legs with his foot. Will jumped and looked at him, wide-eyed.

“You okay?” Jonathan knew that it was better to ignore Will’s… quirks, so when his little brother tucked his shaking hands between his legs with a nod, Jonathan pretended not to notice.

Then, Joyce slammed her coffee mug down on the table so loud that Will leapt from his chair. Mom, in her manic, frazzled state that she was in so often now, startled as well, before smiling like she didn’t notice something was wrong.

“How about I drive you both to school today?”

Jonathan and Will exchanged looks. The last time she’d driven them to school, a car had overtaken them and sent her into a terrified spin, almost crashing the car before they’d even hit the main road.

“No,” Will answered first, “that’s okay. Mrs Henderson said she’s picking me up today.” He then dumped his dishes in the sink and scurried upstairs, presumably to call Dustin.

Their mom’s face fell slightly as she turned to Jonathan who just said, “No thanks.”

She nodded shakily, picking up her mug and held it in trembling hands. Jonathan wanted to reach out to her, tell her that they were safe now, but she never listened. Lonnie was always waiting behind the door, Will’s kidnapper lurking outside the window.

Instead of staying in the kitchen, with the awkward silence, Jonathan placed his bowl gently in the sink, patted his mom on the shoulder gently and went back upstairs.

Will’s room was open, and the boy was sitting on his bed, bag in lap, staring blankly ahead. He did that a lot now, so Jonathan gently asked, “Is Dustin’s mom really coming?”

Will blinked and nodded jerkily. “Soon.”

“I can drive you, if you want?”

“Soon.”

Jonathan nodded and knocked his knuckles gently on the door frame. “Will you need me to pick you up?”

“No. Mike.”

Before he could think of a response, a car pulled up outside. Will moved silently, brushing past Jonathan with a scarce glance. “See you.”

“Bye.” Jonathan watched as his brother hugged Joyce, letting her kiss his forehead before scurrying out the door like a little mouse.

They locked eyes, his mom’s eyes were sharper now that she knew Will was completely fine. It was a bit odd, that to his mom, the house was not the safest place. “Jonny,” she said, still staring, “I’ll need the car for work. Are you okay taking the bus?”

Swallowing, he nodded instead of saying, did you do that on purpose?

Instead of saying, I hate you so much sometimes, I want to scream.

Instead of saying, stop being so scared.

He could hear her rattling around downstairs as he packed for school. He needed to leave earlier if he was going to catch the bus. His bag was already packed, he didn’t take anything from it but his camera that sat on the windowsill.

To check that it had battery, Jonathan flipped through some of the photos. There were loads of Argyle, who stayed Saturday night. His friend was grinning wide, eyes crinkling in the corner. In one of the images, Argyle was in the middle of spitting loose strands of hair from his mouth.

Smiling, Jonathan quickly flipped to the photos taken during school last week. More of Argyle, smoking, with pencils up his nose, making shadow puppets, sticking his tongue out as he did last minute homework. Then, in the middle of the Argyle selection, was a large swathe of Jonathan’s favourite subject – Nancy Wheeler.

Nancy smiling, studying, walking, talking, just her.

Argyle had, in that kind, soft, annoying way of his, pointed out that Jonathan hadn’t actually asked Nancy if he could take those pictures, but Jonathan had replied that he wasn’t going to print them off or anything, and that he was just practicing his composition and lighting angles.

He was so caught up in staring at a photo of Nancy mid laugh, with Argyle’s arm lined with colourful bracelets in the corner, that he almost missed Joyce leaving the house.

“Fuck!”

He shoved his camera in the bag, pulled on his shoes and raced out the house to the bus stop at the end of the road, just in time to see the bus pulling away.

He stood on the curb, panting and sweating, feeling something bitter curl in his chest. This wouldn’t happen if he was popular like Billy Hargrove, or rich like Steve Harrington, or if his mom wasn’t crazy, or if Will was okay.

Jonathan Byers wouldn’t be standing on the edge of the road, watching the bus turn the corner, miserable, lonely and a loser if he had Nancy Wheeler. If he was fine and cool and chill.

*

He walked into English ten minutes late, tight shirt damp with exertion. Argyle, who was staring with a glazed look out the window turned and cocked a quizzical eyebrow. Jonathan let out an exhausted sigh that made Argyle smile.

“You okay, brochacho?” Argyle whispered, nudging Jonathan's ankle with his scuffed shoes. He was wearing rainbow socks.

“Yeah. Just missed the bus.”

Argyle nodded and turned back to his work, leg still resting against Jonathan’s foot. Jonathan let the familiar touch settle him and turned to the board, writing down the questions and tried to calm himself down.

After class, Argyle was gone in a flash, muttering something about Eddie Munson and discount, so Jonathan made his way to his next class alone. The hallway was flooded with students, and the streamlined plan implemented at the beginning of the year was nowhere in sight.

Nudging past another trio of freshmen, Jonathan finally reached his locker, only to find Billy Hargrove and Steve Harrington leaning against it. Jonathan squared his shoulders and walked forward, coughing out a strangled, “Excuse me.”

Twin scowls turned to him. Steve Harrington looked like he’d spent three hours on his hair alone, the large quaff kept in place by an entire bottle of hair spray. He didn’t have a bag and held a large Starbucks drink in his hand. Whenever he looked at Jonathan, it was as if he’d just discovered a dog shit on his shoe.

On the other hand, Billy Hargrove was a short ball of rage wrapped up in denim. His golden Californian curls were puffed up like a stray cat constantly under attack, and his teeth were always bared. Jonathan didn’t disgust Billy like he did Steve, Jonathan just pissed Billy off.

“What the fuck do you want?” Billy scowled, like Jonathan was interrupting a life-changing conversation and not Steve’s monologue about fucking Tammy Thompson.

“Locker,” Jonathan stammered out, pointing awkwardly at the locker door, with the sharpie scrawled ‘CREEP’, penned by Steve himself.

The two boys turned in unison. Steve’s perfectly manicured eyebrow rose as he smirked at his handy work, whilst Billy’s scowl somehow deepened. But they moved, like predators wanting to watch their prey squirm. Jonathan could feel them watching as he opened the door, desperately trying to stop his hands from shaking.

He tried to move out the way, but Billy pushed him against the lockers. He was shorter than Jonathan, but he made up for it through muscle. “Don’t think you’re safe this semester, freak.”

Then, he scribbled something on Jonathan’s backpack in the same pen he used on the locker before he and Steve disappeared back into the crowd. Jonathan let his head rest against his locker, closed his eyes and took a deep breath.

As he breathed, he could suddenly hear a conversation happening across the hall from him.

“And then, he took me back to his house,” Tammy was saying, something smug in her voice. “We had sex on his couch and then in his parents bed.”

“Wow,” Carol replied in her sarcastic drawl. “Sounds thrilling. Did he call you mommy?”

Heather gagged and Jonathan opened his eyes, catching her eyes across the hallway. Heather was leaning against the locker, towering over both Carol and Tammy in her heels. Before Jonathan could move, Heather had nudged Carol who looked at him as well.

“Are you getting off on this?” she shouted across the hall. Passing students looked between them and giggled, as Jonathan shook his head frantically.

To stop them from saying anything else (that he could hear), Jonathan turned and sped away, clutching his camera close to his chest. His heart was thumping desperately against his rib-cage, and he wanted to find Argyle, and have his friend tell him everything was okay.

Instead, he went to Chemistry.

*

Argyle wasn’t in the cafeteria when Jonathan arrived, so he paid for his lunch and settled at a table in the corner, out of the way and hidden from the popular kids. He could see Billy laughing, leaning against Tommy Hagan, who had his arm around Carol. Steve wasn’t anywhere in sight, and that made Jonathan nervous.

Someone sat down next to him, and the warm scent of the beach mixed with slightly sour undertones of weed, flowed over him. Without even greeting him, Jonathan rested his head on Argyle’s shoulder, as his friend chuckled fondly.

“What took you so long?”

“Steve Harrington cornered me,” Argyle said, nudging his bag of his other shoulder. “He gave me a present!”

Jonathan squinted at the chunky, uneven writing on Argyle’s bag. ‘Riends’

“What the fuck does that mean?”

Argyle shrugged gently and opened the bag, pulling out his lunch. To give him space to eat, Jonathan sat up and moved his bag. Pausing, he looked from his bag to Argyle’s and sighed. “I think it means this,” and turned his bag to Argyle.

Together they read: Boy F Riends

Jonathan felt something heat his cheeks when Argyle grinned at the nickname. Steve and Billy had done this to humiliate them, and it was working hilarious.

Argyle nudged him, eyes wide and concerned in that soft way of his. “You okay, brochacho?”

“Yeah, I just…” Jonathan swallowed tightly. He didn’t want to say, what happens if Nancy sees this? What happens if people think this is true? What happens if my dad hears and comes back? But, Argyle didn’t seem worried, and Jonathan didn’t want to hurt his feelings. “I’m just surprised they managed to work together. Steve even spelt ‘riends’ correctly!”

Argyle laughed, throwing his head back in the way that meant it was truly funny. “True, true, dude. This is the boy that spelt his own surname wrong on his math exam.”

Jonathan laughed as well, leaning against Argyle’s warm, solid shoulder. They settled once more and Argyle opened his mouth, stammered and then said, “Did you give Nancy your letter?”

Stabbing the tiny paper straw into his juice, Jonathan shrugged. “I did write it this time.” He had rewritten it three times and it had taken him three days.

Argyle nudged him. “That’s progress, dude.”

“I tore it up.”

“Oh.”

Jonathan sipped at his juice, stole one of Argyle’s chips and then said brightly, “It’s still progress, right?”

Argyle nodded. “Yeah, maybe it’ll be like that book where her letters are sent out.”

Jonathan didn’t know what he was talking about. “Yeah, maybe.”

Argyle went to say something more, but before he could, the cafeteria doors opened, and Nancy Wheeler walked in. And the world went quiet.

Jonathan could feel Argyle move away from him but was too preoccupied watching Nancy walk by. She didn’t get food (she usually brought her own). Instead, she went to the bulletin board and signed her name with a flourish before flouncing over to Barbara, immediately pulling out her textbook.

There were two things Jonathan learned last year, 1) do not take photos in school, and 2) wait at least ten minutes before going over to see what she was looking at (the incident had only been rectified because Will was missing, and Jonathan still felt bursts of guilt at using his missing brother to excuse his ‘stalking tendencies’ – Argyle’s words).

So, he waited and watched Nancy highlight with the intense look that he’d become familiar with. He peered at Argyle, to find him with his big chunky headphones on, an odd melancholic look on his face. Jonathan left him be, turning back in time to see Steve leaning on the table next to Nancy, the smug grin on his face.

Abruptly, he stood up and was halfway to the table before he stopped. Jonathan turned and walked over to the board instead, praying that no one had seen his jerky stop. On the board were a bunch of sign-up sheets for the clubs of the semester. Horticulture, art, band, theater and debate were the school developed ones. There were a few other oddly specific clubs, like Dungeons and Dragons, Anime & Manga, and Rock n Roll.

Nancy’s neat signature was signed on the first line of debate. Last year, she had signed up for the school newspaper, so Jonathan had tried to become the photographer, but Ben had got there first. He glanced at Argyle, who had a scrunched expression which smoothed into enthusiasm. With Argyle’s thumbs-up encouraging him, Jonathan shakily scrawled his name beneath Nancy’s.

He turned hurriedly and almost smacked into Robin Buckley who was staring with an amused look. She deliberately looked at Nancy and back, smirk pulling at her lips as she signed her name under Vicki’s for band.

“Hope that works out for you.” She glanced behind him as well, but it was only Argyle, watching them, amused.

*

Jonathan regretted everything. Argyle had to physically haul him out the classroom and down the hall, saying, “You signed up for this, brochacho!”

“Do you think I can just not turn up?”

“Well,” Argyle said with his fake thinking face, “Nancy will think you’re a quitter and a coward, but sure.”

“Shut up.” Jonathan nudged him in the ribs with his elbow before smiling. “You still want to meet up later?”

“Sure, dude.” Argyle grinned. “Message when you’re out and we can get stoned in my basement. Got a new strain: Purple Palm Tree Delight.”

“Can’t wait,” he responded softly and waved Argyle goodbye. Then, he squared his shoulders and pushed into the classroom.

Nancy was already inside, front and center, with her notebook open and empty. She turned when he walked in, and her face lit up. “Jonathan!”

Jonathan practically imploded on the spot as she stood up and came over, placing her small, dainty hand in the crook of his elbow. “Come, sit next to me.”

It was embarrassing, the fact that he couldn’t stop watching her, but he was enthralled by everything Nancy Wheeler did. He settled into the chair next to her, almost missing the seat, and pulled out his notebook as well.

“So,” Nancy turned to him, back straight and nothing out of place, “I didn’t think you would like debate? Aren’t you pursuing photography?”

Jonathan was too distracted by Nancy’s knowledge on him that he almost forgot to reply. “Umm,” he cleared his throat, swiped his hands on his jeans and then said, “Trying something new. Confidence.”

Nancy smiled in that reserved way of hers. “That sounds like a good reason. I’m trying to pad by resume and application.”

“Not running the newspaper?” Jonathan wanted to slam his face against the table.

If Nancy noticed the awkwardness, she didn’t indicate that it bothered her. “I’m still doing that. I’m editor in chief this year, I just wanted to try something new.” She shrugged in an almost sheepish manner. “I like journalism and I’m planning on pursuing at in college, but I like debating topics as well.”

Jonathan held back from asking where she was planning on going, but before he could start another conversation, the door burst open. Steve stumbled in, pulling a cackling Billy behind him. Then, Tommy, Carol, Heather, Tammy and Tina came in.

Nancy exchanged a confused glance with Jonathan. Steve sat in the chair next to Nancy, leaning on the back legs with his arms behind his head. The rest of the posse spread out, talking and texting and taking selfies like it was the most natural thing in the world.

Jonathan almost expected Billy Hargrove to sit behind him to kick his chair like he used to do during World History, but the other was sitting on Steve’s other side, head resting on his palm. Then, Billy jerked back like he’d been shocked, shook himself off and then sneered when he saw Jonathan looking.

Deciding it was best to ignore the mystery that was Billy Hargrove, Jonathan managed to catch the tail end of Nancy and Steve’s conversation.

“- and even though I didn’t understand what plastic had to do with turtles, I really liked the story you wrote.”

“The article on plastic straws?”

“Yeah. It really makes you think, doesn’t it? Maybe you should talk to farmers.”

Nancy seemed to struggle to hide her exasperation. “Why?”

“They put straws in their scarecrows don’t they?”

Jonathan waited for Nancy to correct him, but she smiled wider than ever before. “I suppose they do. Any other suggestions?”

Billy rolled his eyes and stood up. Steve didn’t turn to watch his friend leave. Jonathan wondered if Billy had the right idea as Steve started spouting his next few ideas which ranged from Scooby-Doo-esque shenanigans to Nancy doing a student run Russian sleep experiment.

Before Steve could suggest that Nancy breach the Geneva convention, Mr Clarke walked in, out of breath and holding coffee.

As he started the actual meeting, it soon became apparent that Nancy was the only one who wanted to be here. Even Jonathan’s enthusiasm flagged when Steve appeared. To make it worse, Steve was participating more, enthusiastically suggesting debate topics that Jonathan thought were silly, but both Nancy and Mr Clarke were taking seriously.

Then Tommy and Carol started to suggest topics, seemingly to try and goad one another into an argument. Then Heather pitched in, followed by Tina and Tammy. Jonathan gripped his knees tight in his sweaty palms, something red and humiliating coiling in his chest.

Nancy hadn’t looked at him once since Steve arrived, so Jonathan stood up, and left. Was it embarrassing? Absolutely. But he couldn’t stay in there, where asshole King Steve Harrington was outshining him in debate.

The bathroom was dimly lit and dank. Sighing heavily, Jonathan splashed some water on his face and stared forlornly at his reflection.

He pulled out his phone, opened his messages and sent Argyle a quick: ths sucks real bad lol

When he didn’t respond immediately, Jonathan turned to head back only to find Billy Hargrove blocking the doorway.

Chapter 2: two player game

Chapter Text

Chapter 2: Two Player Game

Billy Hargrove didn’t look well. He was leaning heavily against the main bathroom door, blocking the exit. He was pale, eyes watery and red, and if Jonathan squinted, Billy’s veins were so dark they were almost black.

Looking back, it should’ve worried Jonathan a lot more that Billy had gone from practically glowing to looking like he’s on death’s door. His hair was stringy and dull and there was a slight gurgling when he spoke.

“Umm,” Jonathan stammered, awkwardly washing his hands for something to do. “Are you okay?”

Billy blinked lazily and then snapped upright. “Y’know, freak, we have quite a lot of things in common.”

That was the most insulting thing Jonathan heard, and Steve used to call him the f-slur as a daily greeting. “Okay.”

“Do you remember my first day here?”

Billy’s arrival had been a blaze of glory, pulling up in his blue Camaro in all his Californian majesty. He’d been glowing, gliding across the grounds, Steve and Tommy trailing after him like moths drawn to a flame. He even fascinated Eddie Munson, and there were rumours that he and Billy got high and listened to rock music. Argyle, also being a Californian native, had a few positive conversations with Billy, but Jonathan never rose from dogshit in Billy’s eyes.

Catching the look on Jonathan’s face, Billy seemed to glow before his eyes, grin widening and baring his teeth.

“You’ve done a lot in the year you’ve been here.” Jonathan replied amicably. He didn’t know what Billy was getting at, but he didn’t want to trigger the boy into one of those violent rages he was known to fly into.

“Three years.”

Jonathan blinked and turned to Billy, who was standing a lot closer now. Jonathan eyed the door behind him, wondering if he could make a run for it until Billy’s words caught up to him. “You haven’t been here for three years.”

Billy’s face crinkled into an odd pout. “Have so.” He pulled his phone from his pocket, flicked upwards rapidly and then showed Jonathan a photo. It was a picture of a blonde boy, with short, curly hair, bright eyes and tons of freckles. He was grinning with braces and glasses.

“That’s you?”

Now that Jonathan had an image, he did remember seeing that face in the back of the class during freshman year. He’d been quiet, head buried in a book. Jonathan couldn’t remember his name.

“What… what happened?” Jonathan gestured vaguely. “You look… um… different?”

“Picture this,” Billy said, caging Jonathan into a corner with a sudden intense energy, “it’s the end of sophomore year and I’m finally getting these fucking braces off,” he licked his tongue over his teeth and let it hang out in that obnoxious way of his, “and I’m thinking that I can finally start climbing the social ladder in this hellscape. So, that summer, I’m off to California for… family, and my mom’s neighbours' kid, who was covered in acne and pockmarked and very much like you, emerges like a fucking butterfly.

So, I ask him, ‘Hey man, what happened? How is your skin so smooth and hair so shiny, and he says to me, ‘Dude, you’ve gotta try this. It’s called a F.L.A.Y.E.R.”

He looked at Jonathan expectantly. Jonathan hesitates and then repeated, “Flayer?”

“F.L.A.Y.E.R. It’s a grey, oblong pill. Quantum nanotechnology CPU.”

“Quantum?” Jonathan wondered out loud before backtracking, “Wait! Are you talking about drugs?”

Billy blinked. “No. It’s a tiny computer in the shape of a pill that travels through your blood to your brain, and it tells you what to do.”

This conversation was rapidly devolving, and Jonathan was becoming more and more sure that Billy Hargrove was certifiably insane. He was practically vibrating, gripping Jonathan’s shirt and shaking him.

“You don’t understand, Byers. This shit gets your from zero to ninety immediately. It helps you be cool.”

This stopped Jonathan. Sure, it was an insane statement and the correct response to this would be to leave, but Billy was making … sense. Jonathan remembered Billy two years ago, small and quiet like a mouse sitting in a mousetrap waiting for it to spring. And if that dormouse could emerge from the trap as a golden lion, well, it was an enticing feeling. If his goal was to climb up the social ladder, and the boy who climbed so high that people forgot he did at all, was telling him his secrets, what could Jonathan do but listen?

“Explain it again, properly.”

Billy bolted upright, like a puppet whose strings were pulled. “F.L.A.Y.E.R. is quantum nanotechnology in the form of a computer which the costumer takes as a small, grey oblong pill. It’s from Japan and was created to help people like you become more confident in themselves. It helps you in situations, helps you dress better, talk better, tells you what to eat and get into shape like your own personal trainer.”

After his impromptu advertisement, Billy’s body seemed to slump over, eyes glazed and veins looking suspiciously dark. If Jonathan had been smarter, this would’ve piqued his interest, but all he thought about was climbing the social ladder, of Nancy Wheeler on his arm and Steve Harrington waiting by his locker, Billy Hargrove sitting next to him at lunch and Tommy Hagan inviting him to parties.

“And it works?”

Billy gestured to himself with a raised eyebrow. “All this for six hundred dollars!”

That made Jonathan pause. “Six hundred?”

Billy caught onto the shift in his tone and prowled forward with a wicked smirk in his eyes. “You know we call you Creepy Byers, right? We know about those little photos you take of Nancy, and it’s only a matter of time before you cross that line.”

“What line?” Jonathan whispered.

“I mean, you know where she lives, don’t you? I wouldn’t be surprised if you start hanging out under her window, waiting for her… jacking off….”

“Shut the fuck up.”

“Of course, that means nothing in comparison to what people are saying about your mom.” Billy’s face flickered inscrutably at this before he continued, “You know, she’s crazy right? The Creep and the Crazy, what a team!”

Jonathan felt the overwhelming urge to punch Billy in his smug little face. “Well at least I’m not in love with my best friend.”

Billy just smiled and patted his shoulder, “Family Video, ask for the Japanese shit and Keith will know what you mean.” Then he left in that condescending, prowling way of his, leaving a heaving, unsteady Jonathan behind.

There was silence cut through by the incessantly dripping tap that the janitor refused to fix. As the water splashed into the sink rhythmically, Jonathan finally collapsed against the door as his body caught up to the situation. He scrubbed a trembling hand down his face before splashing cool water and shaking himself out.

In his hurry to get away from Steve Harrington’s flirting, Jonathan had left his bag. It very much felt like he was a dog slinking back with his tail between his legs as he made his way back. But no one was in the room, even Mr Clarke had disappeared at some point. Jonathan’s things were still where he left them but lined up neatly.

After the interaction with Billy, he couldn’t even bring himself to get excited by Nancy organising his stuff. He was tired and drained and wanted to get home to play video games with Argyle and forget everything that happened.

He shoved everything unceremoniously into his bag, swung it over his shoulder and left, walking down the silent hallways towards the entrance. Yet, just as he pushed the door open, a faint but familiar giggle permeated the air. He peaked around the corner to see Nancy and Steve further down, Steve crowding Nancy against the wall with that odd combination of puppy-dog eyes and smarmy smile in place.

Nancy was grasping her debate notebook in hand and giggling at whatever Steve was saying. Jonathan swallowed as he took them in, Nancy in her demure girl-next-door clothes and Steve with his fashionable-but-preppy get up. They looked good together.

You know we call you Creepy Byers right?

Jonathan turned and walked away abruptly, shaken.

Billy Hargrove was insane, he was angry and loud and so, so full of himself that it was surprising that he remembered anything else at all. But… but Hargrove was a straight-A student, co-captain of the basketball team with Steve, on track to be valedictorian in competition with Nancy, he had a girl on either arm, had the keg-stand record… and if what he was saying was true, Billy Hargrove was cheating. He was just as sad and desperate and weird as Jonathan but had figured out a weird macho way to fix himself, not with make-up or exercise but with a drug.

That, Jonathan could do.

*

The house is quiet when he enters, which is a warning sign. Usually, Joyce would be blasting Dolly Parton or Blondie or Stevie Nicks whilst cleaning or cooking or whatever else she does, with Will sitting at the counter doing his homework. She liked to keep him close after last year.

But now, the silence was thick and heavy. Jonathan toes his shoes of quietly, placing his bag down and peering into the kitchen. The dishes from the morning were unwashed. Will was sitting on the couch, the TV on mute, curled up in that odd way of his that meant he was anxious. Although he never talked about what happened when he was missing, Jonathan feared that this was a habit he developed in that time, making himself small and quiet.

When Will was like this, Jonathan made himself just as small and quiet, perching on the other edge of the couch, waiting for Will to come to him. After a few moments, Will unfurled, turning to face Jonathan. His face was pinched at the edges and his lip bitten raw.

“She locked herself in the bathroom,” Will said quietly. “She was in there when Karen dropped me off.”

“Was she talking?”

“To herself or me?”

To anyone else, it may have sounded like a joke, but Will was serious. Joyce had developed the habit when Will was missing. At first, Jonathan believed it to be a comfort thing, a way for her to dispel her worries privately. But she soon grew erratic and paranoid, convinced that Will was calling to her. Jonathan never told Will, but she’d been convinced that he was in the walls at some point.

She’d been to therapy after Will returned and was getting better day by day. But sometimes, she was too… much. She could recognise it now, when she was talking to nothing, when the shadows grew into monsters, which is why she locked herself in the bathroom.

“To me,” Will clarified. “I could hear her crying though. She wasn’t mumbling or anything, just…” He fell silent and picked at his nails.

Jonathan patted his knee gently and turned up the TV volume. Will smiled gratefully and settled back against the cushions to watch Scooby-Doo. “I’ll go check on her, see if I can get her out and eating, okay?”

“Yeah.”

The noise of the television was comforting as Jonathan made his way upstairs. The bathroom was next to Joyce’s room, locked tight with now way to unlock it from the outside. Jonathan pressed his ear to the door, but it was silent.

He knocked. “Mom?”

Nothing.

Again. Louder. “Mom?”

“What?” Her voice was hoarse and tense.

He swallowed and asked quietly, “Are you okay?”

“Yes.”

“Okay… how long have you been in there?”

“Not long.”

Will had been home for two hours, so that was the minimum. “Alright, you hungry?”

“No.” Then, “Jonathan, please leave, I want to be alone.”

His eyes burned as he muttered his assent. Something ugly and shameful swirled in his gut as he suddenly spat, “You scared Will.”

She was silent again, and Jonathan walked away before he did or said something worse. He pulled out his phone, where Argyle had sent him a meme and asked him to come over. he couldn’t handle Joyce after everything else.

broNACHO: sure b ther in 10

Jonathan smiled, pressing the top of his phone to his mouth and went back downstairs to find that Will had fallen asleep on the couch. He nudged him gently, a soft laugh building at the disgruntled look Will shot him.

“Argyle’s coming round. Do you want us to go upstairs?”

Will nodded sleepily, patting Jonathan’s hand and mumbling, “Is mom okay?”

“She’s okay,” Jonathan responded, herding his brother towards the door, “She just needs some time alone.” At Will’s skeptical look, Jonathan kissed his forehead. “I’ll start on dinner in an hour okay, and Will? This isn’t your fault.”

Will shot him a small smile and closed his bedroom door. As he waited for Argyle, Jonathan set out to untangle the PlayStation shoved under the TV stand, finding the cracked case for the game: Upside Down 2 - Vecna's Revenge without the disc.

Jonathan managed to plug the console to the TV when the doorbell rang. Argyle was grinning, wearing his vibrant yellow cap and sunglasses with palm tree frames. Rolling his eyes, Jonathan let his friend in, hiding his smile when Argyle removed his shoes to reveal socks with weed print.

"Nice getup," he said, as they settled on the couch.

Argyle grinned and pulled a bag from his pocket. "Needed to match the vibes."

Usually, Jonathan smoked joints in his room, but he was too emotionally exhausted to care, so he got up to open the window as Argyle started to roll them.

"You okay, dude?" Argyle asked when he sat back down. "The texts were kinda concerning."

Jonathan shrugged and took the first hit, handing Argyle the controller instead. Letting the warm smoke sit in his lungs before exhaling, he leant back and closed his eyes, ignoring Argyle's concerned eyebrows.

Instead, he nudged Argyle's thigh with his foot and started the level. The ominous clock sounded and Vecna's cut scene started.

With Argyle's purple palm tree coursing through his veins, Jonathan floated towards the warm body next to him. As always, Argyle moved to accommodate him, letting Jonathan shove his feet beneath his legs and lean his head against his shoulder. Sometimes, his body would shake with laughter and Jonathan would sink further into the heat. Argyle was practically a massive, cuddly teddy-bear with a surprisingly compact abdomen. Not than Jonathan thought about that often.

They played a few easy, warm up levels before preparing to face the obnoxiously hard boss level. Then when Vecna's spiders consumed the screen and DESTROYED flashed across the screen, Jonathan's warm fuzziness faded, and he bolted upright with an anxious wince.

"Jon?"

"Harrington and his posse came to debate, and he spent the entire time flirting with Nancy."

Argyle was silent for a moment, not even maneuvering his character until Jonathan nudged him. "Oh, sorry, brochacho. I wouldn't worry, Nancy will realise Steve has no personality in no time."

"It's not just that. He was impressing her, throwing out stupid ideas that made her laugh whilst I sat there like a fucking idiot."

The losing screen flashed again, and Argyle sighed, tucking Jonathan into a tight side hug, arm heavy and warm over his shoulders. "Dude, you are so smart. Steve is one of those guys that girls like Nancy fancy for three days before they realise how dumb they really are. Just because Harrington could think of topics to argue about doesn't make him smart. We all know he won't go to college."

Jonathan snorted. "That doesn't mean much. He'll go and work for his rich daddy."

"And Nancy will go to college and want someone to match her in drive and intelligence. That's you."

Jonathan hid his smile in Argyle's shoulder, trying hard not to notice that he smelt like vanilla instead of the sour tinge of weed. "I don't even know where she's going to college," he mumbled.

Argyle's muscles suddenly tense and Jonathan sat up to squint at him. Argyle's eyes were slanted as he took another drag of his joint before asking, "You're planning on going to the same university?"7

Plucking the joint from his fingers having finished his own, Jonathan took a hit before slumping back into him. "I don't know. NYU is still my top choice, I just... want to make sure." Argyle's hum was unconvincing, so Jonathan responded smarmily, "And where are you planning on going?"

Argyle was silent, before he replied softly, "Wherever you go, dude."

Jonathan swallowed shakily and nodded, deciding not to think too hard about the answer, too high and too confused. "Cool," he said instead.

There was silence for a moment as they quietly attempted the level again. Argyle hissed in frustration as they lost half their health, body tense and Jonathan's breath hitched at the sound. Not wanting to think about that more than needed, he broke the silence by stating, "Billy Hargrove corned me in the bathroom to sell me drugs."

Surprised, Argyle accidentally shot Jonathan and they lost again. Instead of restarting, he turned to Jonathan, "What?"

"It was very weird," Jonathan told him. "Apparently, it's called F.L.A.Y.E.R. and it's a little computer."

"What?"

Jonathan relayed everything Billy told him, surprised to learn that Argyle remembered Billy from before.

("We used to surf and trained to be junior lifeguards together."

"What happened?"

"I'm assuming this quantum computer.")

Argyle's silence was contemplative but before he could say anything, Jonathan blurted out what he'd been wondering since the bathroom. "Should I take it?"

Argyle stared at him. "Why?"

"I told you. This is my year, to social climb and get Nancy and go to parties and - " he cut himself off before he could say and get cooler friends.

"Hmm. You do need more confidence."

"Right."

"And you can barely speak two words to Nancy without stammering and sweating."

"...right."

"But..."

"But?"

Argyle's noise scrunched as he said, "Hargrove is unnaturally aggressive, and we don't actually know the side-effects of the pill."

Jonathan contemplated telling him about Billy's black veins and clouded eyes, but Argyle was mumbling to himself. And to be fair, Argyle knew quite a bit about drugs, second only to Eddie Munson, so if said he shouldn't do it, Jonathan wouldn't.

Before any of that was said aloud, Joyce walked in, hair wild and heavy bags beneath her eyes. Jonathan and Argyle watched wearily as she wandered around the room, peering out the window and checking the clock.

For the first time ever, Jonathan felt embarrassed around Argyle. He knew his friend had seen his mom like this before, but the conversation had left him feeling open and raw.

"Mom? You okay?"

"Where's Will? Why isn't he home?" Joyce asked, opening cupboard doors like Will would be in them.

"He's in his room."

She narrowed her eyes at him, pupils blown wide. "Why would he be in there and not down here with you?"

Jonathan swallowed nervously. "He was tired." She snorted and left the room. They could hear her go upstairs and fling open Will's door.

Argyle turned back to him with wide eyes. "I thought she was getting better."

"Bad day." Then, "I think I should take the pill."

Argyle nodded.

"Will you come with me?"

"Of course."

Chapter 3: be more chill

Chapter Text

Chapter 3: Be More Chill

They went to mall on Saturday, each day  leading up to the weekend cementing the decision in Jonathan's mind. Joyce was better the day after her bathroom incident, but Will and Jonathan were still wary. Jonathan wanted to ask her to book another therapy session, but she kept repeating assurances, and he didn't want to set her off again.

Hargrove hadn't bothered Jonathan at all since their bathroom excursion, hovering behind Harrington like a pissed shadow. Sometimes, Jonathan remembered his accusation, watching the way Hargrove guarded Harrington like a domesticated wolf. Interesting.

But, what truly made Jonathan scrape together six hundred bucks was Nancy and Steve eating lunch together, giggling with their heads close during debate. They weren't officially dating, and that was what Jonathan clung too.

Argyle had been quieter, messaging someone intensely on his phone, and when asked, he just responded with 'research'.

So, when Saturday came, Jonathan dropped Will off at Mike's, trying to catch a glimpse of Nancy before leaving to meet Argyle at the mall.

They met at the fountain in the center, Argyle in a Hawaiian shirt and slushie in hand, grinning like a loon. "Let's make you a cool dude, dude."

Family Video was empty, unsurprising since it was a DVD/VHS rental store in the age of online streaming. Keith, who Jonathan vaguely knew through Argyle (they were weed buddies or something), was leaning boredly against the counter, watching a YouTube video.

Above him, on the shitty television screen that played VHS tapes, a scratchy reel of The Matrix was playing. Jonathan took a deep breath, with Argyle's encouraging nod fueling him as he coughed.

Keith looked up slowly and blinked lazily like he didn't believe they were really there. "Oh," he said, "hello."

"I'm... um... I'm here for... for the Japanese selection."

"Hentai?"

Ignoring how interested Keith sounded, Jonathan clarified, "No. The other... shit."

Keith seemed confused so Argyle helpfully added, "Quantum."

"Oh," Keith sighed, disturbingly disappointed, "The pill shit. Guessing Hargrove sent you?"

At Jonathan's nod, he pulled a box from beneath the counter covered in almost nude anime girls. Within the box was another box with a Transformer sticker and in there was a pile of grey, oblong pills.

Keith placed one on the counter. "Four hundred."

Jonathan, who was pulling the cash from his pocket, froze and said, "Four hundred? I thought it was six- oof!"

He rubbed at the spot Argyle had elbowed and counted out four hundred, tucking the extra back into his pocket.

"Right," Keith said, shoving the cash into his pants, "there's some stuff you need to know. To activate it, you have to take it with green mountain dew."

"Citrus." Argyle said.

"And to deac-" The bell rung as someone entered the store. It was a goth girl who stalked over, eyeing them weirdly. Even weirder was the way Keith straightened, frantically trying to smooth his clothes down as he stammered out, "H-Hi Eden."

Jonathan rolled his eyes and left; pill tucked into his pocket. Argyle trailed after him, chuckling. "He's worse than you, dude. Surprised he hasn't taken that yet."

Jonathan snorted and replied, "I'm more surprised Hargrove paid six hundred for this."

"Either that or he was trying to scam you."

"Guess the pill didn't make him that smart."

They both laughed and sat down on a bench overlooking the fountain. The mall was growing steadily busy, mostly families and older people.

"Do you really think I should take this?" Jonathan said, holding the pill like the artificial light would reveal a tiny counter for a tiny bomb.

Argyle shrugged. "I don't think Keith will give you a refund."

Jonathan laughed but let the pill rock gently in his palm. This is a stupid idea, he though, it's stupid to trust Billy fucking Hargrove. He turned to tell Argyle to forget about it but caught movement over his head. Nancy and Steve. Walking. Together.

Argyle must've seen something on his face he turned as well and winced. "Yikes. Didn't see that coming."

Nancy and Steve were thankfully not holding hands, but they kept leaning close together, smiling and moving away. Just watching their shoulders brush sent the jealousy that lay dormant spilling over.

"I need some Mountain Dew."

"You sure?" Argyle asked, already standing.

Steve leant down and whispered in Nancy's ear, and she laughed, head thrown back. "Yes."

Jonathan tracked their progress around the mall, swallowing reflexively whenever they drew close. They were coming towards where he was sitting, so he turned away and saw Argyle hurrying back, a massive bottle of green Mountain Dew cradled in his arms.

"Wasn't sure how much you'll need."

Jonathan didn't respond, turning the cap off with a hiss. He places the pill on the back of his tongue and drinks from the bottle, forcing it down. It was larger than paracetamol, like an antibiotic, so he choked slightly. He took another sip and waited.

Nothing happened.

"Anything?"

"No." Jonathan frowned and took another drink. "Nothing."

"Fuck's sake," Argyle said. He stood and cracked his knuckles. "I'll go and get your money back from Keith."

He stalked off, leaving Jonathan on the bench, annoyed and upset. Taking another solemn sip of his drink, Jonathan almost missed Nancy and Steve passing by. He choked out a squeaky, "Nancy!"

She turned and smiled brightly, walking over without glancing at Steve at all. Jonathan tried to match her smile, but a steady ache was pushing at the front of his forehead.

"Hi, Jonathan," Nancy said, tucking a strand of loose hair behind her ear. "Are you here with Argyle?"

"Yeah," he forced out, rubbing at the pulsing behind his eyes and taking another sip. "Talking to Keith."

Steve snorted behind them, but they ignored him. Nancy's face started to crumple into concern, and she pressed the back of her palm against his forehead. "You don't have a fever, but you don't look great."

"Headache."

Nancy began to look in her bag, which was when the pain got so blinding that it felt as if he was being electrocuted. If he could think beyond the blinding hot sharp stabs of pain, Jonathan would've been embarrassed, but all he could do was clutch his head a scream.

Something was trying to crack through his skull, splintering off and down each line in his body: spine, arms and legs that spasmed and flailed. He could feel his body tensing and twisting on the ground, but his eyes were blurry with tears and Jonathan was convinced he was on fire.

Around him, people were shouting or laughing or whispering, all the sounds melded together, but one frantic voice was clear: Argyle. His friend came into view, the bright yellow cap a clear object to latch onto through the blurry tears.

"You're okay, you're okay. Come on."

The pain started to recede slightly. Jonathan regained enough control of his limbs to let Argyle lead him to the disabled bathroom next to Scoops Ahoy.

"Come on. Sit here, sit here." Argyle pressed a bottle of water to his lips, and Jonathan sipped the cool liquid gratefully. The pain was almost non-existent now, but not the humiliation was sinking in. He was sweaty and damp, limbs hurting from having twisted in uncomfortable directions.

"Are you okay?" Argyle said, face unusually solemn.

"Yeah. Embarrassed."

Argyle scrubbed a hand down his face. "This is my fault. I encouraged you to take an unknown drug. Who knows what you put in your body."

"Argyle." Jonathan pulled at his hand, clutching Argyle's big, soft hands in his own sweaty ones. "This isn't on you. I was the one who took the pill."

Argyle smiled weakly and pulled out a chunk of cash. "Keith gave me two hundred back."

"Good enough." Jonathan sighed and then flushed when his stomach growled. "Guess having a stroke makes you hungry."

"I'll go and get you something to eat, okay?" Argyle said, pressing a kiss to the top of Jonathan's head and left.

Before Jonathan could think about those implications, a scoff echoed around the room. Jonathan frantically looked around, before looking back at the door and finding Billy Hargrove standing there.

"Oh, what the fuck?"

"I wouldn't worry, Jonathan," Billy said, an odd lilt to his tone. It wasn't his aggressive, biting statements, but a soft, almost slimy cadence like a politician or a British villain. "You'll be glad to know that the F.L.A.Y.E.R. has successfully integrated into your nervous system."

"What?"

Billy rolled his luminous blue eyes and then switched form before Jonathan's eyes, shifting in a series of computer pixels into Argyle, then Will, then Lonnie before turning back to Billy.

"See? Right now, I am in your mind, reading all your past memories and your present thoughts and quite frankly, I'm disappointed with what I'm seeing."

Jonathan didn't say anything, still staring at the Billy-lookalike. Not-Billy rolled his eyes. "For God’s sake, what do you want me to look like?"

He turned into Nancy. She smiled, but Jonathan looked away from the calculating glint in her eyes. "No? How about-"

From the corner of his eye, Jonathan could see the shape of his dad, Lonnie, tall and intimidating. He swallowed and tried to blink away the sudden onset of tears. He hadn't seen his dad in over five years.

"Oh, wow," Not-Billy/Nancy/Dad said snidely, "We sure have our work cut out for us."

Jonathan couldn't even look at him, so the computer let out an almost human sigh. "Fine." It transformed into Mick Jones from The Clash. "Good enough for you?"

Jonathan could do nothing but nod, overwhelmed and awkward. "So, uh, what's the plan?"

A jolt of electricity raced up his spine, forcing Jonathan to straighten upwards. "Like I said," Flayer said, "we have a lot of work to do. Starting with your posture."

"My posture?" Jonathan started to curl in on himself like he often did when he was anxious, but another electric shock forced him upright.

"Yes. Good posture goes a long way. Makes you look less like a virgin stalker and more confident in your own, uh, creepy skin."

"Right." Jonathan wasn't entirely sure how he felt having Mick Jones say all this to him, but he forced himself to sit up straight.

Flayer scrutinised him and then said, "Square your shoulders. Somehow, you manage to still look slumped. Stop drooping your shoulders, it makes you look awkward and like an anxious, sweaty mess."

"I am an anxious, sweaty mess."

It scoffed. "That's precisely what we are trying to change. That's why you took me, isn't it?"

Jonathan nodded, forcing himself to not scrunch inwards despite the condescending tilt it had adopted.

"Right," it said, clapping its pixelated hands silently, "time to get out there and do some test runs. See where the baseline is."

"Shouldn't you already know that?" Jonathan left the bathroom and wearily looked around. The mall was quieter now. They walked back towards the fountain.

There was another shock. "No dragging your feet! Stand up! Walk like you have confidence in yourself! Honestly, watching you makes me want to kill myself, and I don't even have feelings."

Jonathan frowned and looked down, before letting out an undignified squeak at the subsequent shock. "I don't think you can say stuff like that to me."

"You should talk to me inside your head, talking out loud will make you look crazier than you already do."

Fine, Jonathan thought with a scowl. Just so you know, I hate this.

“I mean,” The Flayer responded with a shrug, “if you want to be ugly and alone forever, there isn’t much more I can do.”

Jonathan stopped by the fountain and stared into the still water. He could see the spare quarters that had been thrown in, the gathering of hundreds of wishes drowning at the bottom. He wondered if his was still there, from last year when Will was gone and Jim Hopper and the rest of the police found nothing, Jonathan had pressed a quarter to his lips with the wish that Will would come home safely.

So, Jonathan stared at himself, at the tired bags underneath his eyes, his spotted skin, which was flaking on his forehead, his faded, flat hair that constantly looked unwashed, his dry cracked lips and he wished he looked more like Steve Harrington, or Billy Hargrove, or even Argyle whose skin remained mysteriously unblemished.

Okay, let’s do this. He turned back to the computer hovering over his shoulder.

The Flayer smiled at him, teeth white and blinding. “Good. Now, you need to do and say exactly what I tell you.” He then gestured over to the Fro-Mama frozen yogurt café. “Go over there, back straight and confident.”

Jonathan did as instructed, feet feeling awkward and clunky as he walked to the store. Every time his shoulders rose a millimeter, the sharp shock would ricochet up his spine. It didn’t take him long to understand why the Flayer sent him over, when the sneering faces of Heather, Tina and Carol rounded on him.

“Hey stalker.” Heather tapped her spoon against her bowl of fro-yo, gathering the melting sweetness in its concave. “Wheeler just left, but I’m guessing you already knew that.” She bit her lip as Jonathan’s mouth moved soundlessly.

“Uh –”

“Tell her that you need her help,” the Flayer said, frowning over Heather’s shoulder. Jonathan never knew that Mick Jones could seem so cold and condescending.

What?

There was a jolt and Jonathan clenched his jaw before saying, “Heather, I need your help.”

“You’re the most fashionably dressed person in the school. As you can probably see, I am not.” The Flayer then looked at Jonathan. “She’s going to take you on as a pet project, let her.”

Jonathan repeated what the Flayer said, gesturing down at his well-worn shirt, jeans with a serious of holes, and frayed shoelaces. Heather’s eyebrows went up as she shared a look with Carol and Tina. A smirk slipped across her face as she leant forward, like a predator admiring their prey before they pounced.

“You do dress like a school shooter.”

Jonathan stared at her. “What?”

Heather gestured. “You look like you’re a second away from a mental breakdown.”

“Uh…”

The Flayer rolled its eyes. “Say: Heather, it’s embarrassing to go around looking like this and I’m tired of seeing girls who ignore me the next day.”

Jonathan managed to spit it out without collapsing. His fingers twitched but he managed to stand tall and still, to the approval of the Flayer.

“Seeing girls? What girls are interested in you?” Carol said, sucking a cherry into her mouth. When Jonathan turned to her, she smiled, cherry intact between her teeth.

“Tammy Thompson.”

I can’t say that! Tammy’s nice!

“Sure. She’s also slept with most of the guys in school.”

How do you know that?

“I’m a super-computer, Jonathan, I know everything. Tell Heather you slept with Tammy. It’ll make you more compelling.”

“Tammy Thompson.”

Carol scoffed, but not in disbelief. “Her? That’s who you want to impress? Her standards are so low that she hooked up with Keith. Even you could do better than her, Byers and you look like you’re homeless.”

The Flayer grinned. “See? It’s working. Now, say: Even I know I can do better than Tammy Thompson. I want to impress someone… more interesting.”

Carol smiled her fox-like grin and replied, “Is it that friend of yours?”

Tina twirled a strand of hair around her finger and giggled. “He’s cute. I think if you asked, he’d say yes. I’m a huge ally.”

Jonathan stared, eyes flicking between the girls and the super-computer who looked almost surprised. “What does Argyle have to do with this?”

They exchanged disbelieving glances before Heather laughed again. “We have so much work to do.”

“Tell them it’s Nancy,” Flayer said quickly.

“It’s Nancy,” Jonathan repeated. “Nancy Wheeler, I’ve uh… liked her for a while.”

“Right…” Heather blinked before nodding to herself. “Are you sure you don’t want to aim for someone more on your, uh, level?”

“Nancy is on my level,” Jonathan replied before he was prompted, but the Flayer gave him an approving nod anyway. “I just need some help clearing the ledge.”

This made Heather smile, something more genuine than Jonathan had seen before. “Okay. Let’s do it.”

*

broNACHO: jon where are you?

broNACHO: jon seriously

broNACHO: you’re scaring me

broNACHO: im waiting in the van

broNACHO: jon?

missed call

missed call

missed call

missed call

*

Heather’s first change was his hair. “It’s in your face,” she said as he sat with them in the café. She leant forward and pushed his hair from his eyes. “You have nice cheekbones, and no one can see them.”

“Trim?” Tina said, squinting as she licked her spoon. “I like the length though, don’t know how he’d look with short hair.”

“Maybe,” Carol leant forward and ran a hand through the strands, pushing the back into a loose quiff, “something like this?”

Heather hummed thoughtfully, and behind their probing eyes, the Flayer looked proud.

*

It continued like this for the next few hours, the dragged him to clothing stores and a pharmacist, an accessory store and even booked him a haircut. Jonathan stumbled behind their enthusiasm, prompted by adrenaline and a few choice shocks.

They layered his clothes differently, finding more form-fitting shirts that didn’t change him completely but made him seem… more. They moved from his standard beiges to darker blues and greens that brought out the surprising tan that he never noticed. His baggy jeans were swapped out for skinny jeans that fit from thigh to ankle and brought a certain height to his lanky body that made him appear more proportional. Carol had sauntered off to find him some new shoes.

“Byers?” A voice caught him off guard, just as Tina was comparing square sizes on two flannel shirts.

Tommy Hagan stared at him; smug, freckled face screwed up into a tight sneer. Jonathan noticed that it was a mockery of Harrington’s, and that Tommy didn’t pull it off as well. Instead of belittling, it just moved like Harrington’s smirk was traced or copied a hundred times.

The Flayer stood beside him, arms crossed, a thoughtful expression sweeping across its artificial face. “We should imply that Carol was flirting with you.”

Why!?

“He’ll see you as a threat. This is important if you are to get close to Nancy.”

“Oh. I’m with Carol,” Jonathan replied.

Tommy couldn’t decide whether Jonathan was joking or not, obvious from the twitch to his eyebrow. Jonathan pulled his face into a vaguely smug look, eyes moving to the spot that Carol went to.

“You? With Carol?”

“Yes. I think she likes me.” Jonathan crossed his arms and faked thoughtfulness. “Like a bird who found a cuckoo chick in its nest.”

“I don’t know what that means.”

At that moment, Carol came back with a stack of shoe boxes. “Byers, I think you’d look good in these Sha-Qs. Not too white, and the blue matches the shirt. Oh – hey Tommy!” She turned her back on her boyfriend to point at Jonathan. “Shoes. Off. Now.”

Jonathan smirked at Tommy as he took of his shoes, trying on the new shoes and asking Carol’s opinion, as instructed. Tommy’s skin was so pale that the red rage and embarrassment was obviously spreading.

Heather came back with a watch and a series of straps, picking up his arm and comparing it, ignoring Tommy’s indignant spluttering. Tina draped some more fabric over him.

“You’re letting them dress you up?” Tommy asked.

Carol rolled her eyes. “At least he cares about his appearance.”

Tommy gaped before staking away, muttering something rude under his breath.

“Ignore him,” Carol said, “he’s just mad he wasn’t invited. Now take those off and try the Air Max.”

*

Jonathan opened the door quietly, dropping his bags to the ground as he slipped out his tattered sneakers. The house was quiet, dark, but when he listened closer, he could hear the slight creaking that indicated Will was upstairs.

He made to go check on his brother, but saw the Flayer shake his head in his peripheral. Jonathan swallowed and walked into the kitchen. Joyce sat at the table, staring blankly at the newspaper.

“Where were you?”

“Out with friends.” “Out with friends.”

“Argyle?”

“No.”

He went to place a hand on her shoulder, but a shock sent it spasming back to his side. She didn’t seem to notice, eyes still staring. “Your brother’s upset with me.”

“Good.” “Good.”

Jonathan left, gathering his bags before she could reply.

*

you: went home

missed call

Chapter 4: upgrade

Chapter Text

Chapter 4: Upgrade

The house was quiet over the next few days. Will seemed to notice the tension between his mom and Jonathan, and although he never brought it up, it was obvious from the way he stayed away from it.

Looking back at this point, it should’ve been obvious what was happening. But then, all Jonathan had was a super-computer whispering conformations into his ear.

“She’s so caught up in the past that she’s missing her children now.” Spoken when Jonathan had to call up the Henderson's to take Will to school again.

“I think she has a favourite child,” spat as Joyce pulled herself from bed when Will asked if she could cook her special meatloaf after he brought home an A+ in math.

“Do you think she even remembers you’re here?” asked as Joyce walked by the open bathroom door, where Jonathan was gelling his hair the way Heather taught him.

But at that point, it justified all of Jonathan’s broiling emotions, the bitterness and jealousy and desperation. “You won’t need her anymore,” the Flayer repeated, “You’re going to be attractive and well-liked and chill.”

*

The next debate session took place on the Thursday after the mall. Heather and the Flayer agreed that they needed to build up his reputation before he approached Nancy as a suitor.

“Relationships like this need to pass a peer review,” Heather told him as she dabbed some foundation beneath his eyes to lighten his eye-bags. “If people dislike you, they’ll turn on Nancy as well, and that isn’t what we’re going for.”

“Nancy may be a great goal to aim for, just remember she isn’t the only one. I’m not here to get you a girlfriend, Jonathan, I’m here to make you a better person. Nancy is just an important part of that.”

They sort of had the same approaches.

So, Monday to Wednesday was spent slowly establishing his position as ‘Heather’s friend’. She invited him to her table at lunch, where Steve and Billy and Tommy stared as he sat down beside her. Carol leaned away from her boyfriend to paw at Jonathan’s hair, grinning at the amount of gel in it.

And the hours continued, pushing Jonathan from the dusty corners of the school into the sun. People stared when he passed in the hallway, not friendly enough to greet him but they now knew who he was. Jonathan Byers, the freak at the court table.

Even Jason Carver, in the year below him, stopped sneering at him, instead eyeing him with a surprisingly analytical gaze.

Finally, on Thursday, Jonathan saw Nancy in the classroom by herself. Before, he would’ve raced in their to talk to her, but now he paused to look at the Flayer standing behind him like a pixelated guardian angel.

What do I do?

“What do you think, idiot? Talk to her. You’ll lose a lot of progress if you start cutting her out now.”

Do I flirt?

“Not yet. We haven’t built you up that far yet. Follow her lead.”

Jonathan nodded, inhaled and stepped into the room. Nancy was writing neatly in her notebook, eyebrows scrunched as her pen moved.

He cleared his throat lightly and she jumped. “Oh, Jonathan! Didn’t see you there!” Her eyes lit up as she took him in. “New look?”

He went to rub the back of his neck, but a sharp shock brought him back. “Yeah,” he responded instead. “I went shopping at the weekend.”

At the mention of the mall, her eyes dimmed, and her smile twisted into a worried frown. “Are you okay? I don’t know what happened, but you looked like you were in pain. I’m sorry I didn’t do more to help.”

Jonathan reached for her hand, pausing for a shock, and continuing when none came. Her hands were so small beside his, dainty fingers and pink nails that relaxed as he held it gently in his own. “Nancy, it’s okay. I’m okay. Much better now I’m here.”

She smiled at that, big and wide, scrunching up her face. “Good.” She paused, eyes flickering around the room before resettling back on Jonathan. “I – are we friends?”

“I’d like to think so.”

“Good. I – uh, I really need someone to talk to.”

“I’m always here to listen.”

“Well,” Nancy started, playing with the strands of her hair, “there’s this boy, and… and… have you ever had someone you’ve known since first grade. He’s kinda quiet and we never spoke, so you didn’t think of him beyond the usual ‘oh that boy’s in my class’.”

Jonathan leaned forward eagerly, “Yeah.”

“And all of a sudden, he’s everywhere. So bright and alive and surprising. He joins the debate club and changes his hair and clothes, and you can see that he’s trying so hard to make himself better.”

Jonathan kept nodding as he stared at the Flayer.

She’s talking to me, right?

“Most definitely, I’ve been pumping out your pheromones since you stepped into the room.”

Nancy was gaining excitement now, face lit as she thought of the boy. Her hands started to move as she talked, so Jonathan reluctantly moved away.

“It’s just the way he smiles,” she sighed, “the way he smiles at me – it lights up his face and has the cutest dimple.”

I didn’t know I had a dimple.

The Flayer didn’t respond. Nancy quieted and smiled shyly, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear as she peered up at him. “I’m so glad you’re here, Jonathan.”

“Me too.” He could feel his smile straining his cheeks, but he couldn’t make it smaller. It was happening. He had a crush on Nancy Wheeler since he was twelve years old, watching her win the spelling bee for the third year in a row, and here she was, seventeen years old and confessing.

“I never expected it, you know,” she continued, “but I shouldn’t be surprised. You were always so nice to me in middle school. Remember when Barb almost drowned at Tommy Hagan’s twelfth birthday party?”

Jonathan nodded. That had been the last party he’d been invited to. It was at that point in childhood where your parents invited everyone in the class, so Jonathan went reluctantly (his dad had surprised them with a visit the day before and he wanted to get out the house.) Barb and Nancy had been tucked in the corner under a tree to get away from the sun. They’d both brought books with them, to the disgust of Tommy, who in his obnoxious glory, had picked Barb up and thrown her in the pool. Only to learn she didn’t know how to swim.

The only person to react had been Jonathan, who hadn’t even hesitated to jump in and pull her out. Argyle had got her a blanket and water, but Jonathan had turned just in time to witness the screaming match between Nancy, Tommy and Steve.

“I remember. Is she okay? I haven’t seen her in a while.”

Nancy smiled. “She went to a different school but she’s doing well.”

“I’m glad.”

Her smiled dimmed. “I’ve been thinking about that party a lot, in regards to my… crush.”

Looking at the Flayer, at the blank-faced expression, Jonathan felt something numb spread from his chest. He could feel his muscles drop on his face as he took in her downtrodden features. That day placed Jonathan in a good light, so why was she so upset.

“Oh…” He forced his shoulders to relax. “Experiences like that can be complicated.”

“Yeah. I look back at that day and remember his reaction, the way he laughed as Barb struggled in the water. But I see him now, his smile and his laughter and how he’s trying so hard in debate.” She giggled, slightly wet and manic, matching the odd energy and Jonathan’s growing dread. “His topics may not be the smartest, but he has such an interesting take on everything. I just… I’m conflicted. Do you think people can change?”

Her stare was intense.

Jonathan swallowed, tried to readjust his perception. “Uh, sure. I guess. I think it’s a two-way street sort of thing. Someone can change, but the people they hurt aren’t obligated to forgive them.”

“You’re right,” she said. “I think I need to talk to Barb as well. Thanks.”

Before Jonathan could respond, the door opened, and the rest of the debate club spilled. Jonathan watched, bitter, as Steve sauntered over to Nancy, settling into the chair next to her. Despite her conflict, it was obvious how enthralled Nancy was by Steve, as she turned her body and chair to face him, effectively blocking Jonathan from the conversation.

Grumpily, he sat back and surveyed the rest of the room. Tommy and Carol were in the back corner, heads together and giggling. It hadn’t taken Jonathan long to realise that Carol’s interactions with Jonathan were more or less foreplay for her and Tommy.

Heather, Tina and Billy sat in the middle of the room. They were talking in low voices, shooting fervent looks at Nancy and Steve, who seemed to closing the gap between each other. Watching the three of them, the way that Billy’s eyes refused to leave Steve’s, and Heather’s calculating looks, and Tina’s pinched lips, Jonathan realised that he was still on the outskirts.

Do you think that something’s happening there?

“Something is definitely happening. I just don’t know what.”

You don’t? I thought you knew everything.

“I do, I’ve got access to the entire internet. What I don’t have access to is the psyche of five teenagers from Hawkins, Indiana. However,” and here it looked contemplative, “if who want to push you up the social ladder, knowing what is driving and dividing this group could be key.” It turned to Jonathan with a sharp grin. “I’ve got a plan. We need to connect to Billy Hargrove’s F.L.A.Y.E.R. and to do that, you need to connect to Billy.”

You want me to befriend Billy Hargrove?

“Not befriend. Connect. You don’t have to like him, but it has to be a conversation that gains his trust.”

Jonathan turned to look at Billy, the way he was sprawled across his chair like he was the coolest person in school. It was always a shock to remember that Billy had a chip in him as well. Jonathan wondered how many shocks it took for Billy to get from that mousy blond, braced child to this swimwear model.

“Okay.” The Flayer bared its teeth in a grin.

*

 broNACHO: did I do something wrong?

broNACHO: jon pls

broNACHO: ur hanging out with STEVE HARRINGTON????????

broNACHO: serious question but did that pill break ur brain?? this is why u shouldn’t listen to billy
                    hargrove

broNACHO: jon?

*

Jonathan didn’t see Billy Hargrove until passing period between third and fourth. He was at his locker pulling out a chemistry textbook when Jonathan walked over.

“Now, listen carefully. Not only are you having a conversation with Billy Hargrove, but you are also having a conversation with another version of me. He will be feeding Hargrove lines, most likely to drive you away, so you have to repeat after me very carefully.”

“Hey, Hargrove,” Jonathan greeted, seconds behind the Flayer.

“Byers,” Billy’s voice was cool as he took Jonathan in. “What do ya – what do you want?”

Knowing what he knew, Jonathan could see the little shock in Billy’s hands. He bit back a grin as he repeated, “I just wanted to talk about something.”

“I’m not giving you any fucking advice; you’ve got Heather for that.” There was an undertone of bitterness.

“Not advice. Understanding.”

“My dad came back.”

What? I’m not saying that!

“You need to. This is what will push your relationship forward.”

“Is this because you're in love with –”

“My dad came back,” Jonathan said at the same time. “Wait. What did you just say?”

“What do you mean your dad came back?” There was something like concern in Billy’s eyes. He paused, listening to the invisible voice and then, “Oh. I’m sorry… I get it.”

“You do?” Jonathan asked, surprised. Then horrified as he forced himself to repeat what the Flayer said. “A guy like you? Didn’t think your dad beat you.”

I cannot believe you made me say that!

“You didn’t hesitate too hard.” The Flayer looked amused.

I just – does his dad really hit him?

“Yes. Frequently. It seems to be the one thing his chip can’t fix.”

It hit Jonathan then, the reason Billy took the pill. The reason he hadn’t got rid of it, even after everything was better. Because Billy didn’t take the F.L.A.Y.E.R. to be popular, he took it to stop his dad’s abuse. And it hadn’t worked yet.

Billy looked hurt at the accusation, before reluctantly admitting. “He does. A lot.” Then, “What about you?”

Jonathan didn’t know what to say. Lonnie had fucked him up, no doubt, but he wasn’t here, hadn’t been since Jonathan’s thirteenth birthday where he’d left for good. But he’d been in and out of his life since he was seven. Never allowed to stay long enough for bruises. Only thrown crockery and foul words.

I don’t think I can lie about this.

“Don’t think of it as lying, just as trying to sympathise by exaggerating your own experiences. Look at him. He’s obviously been waiting for someone to talk to about it.”

Billy Hargrove had never looked as vulnerable as his did, waiting for Jonathan’s response. He held himself close, trying to seem smaller. There was a slight tremble to his hands, as if the Flayer was shocking him, probably to make him stand straighter.

“He… he throws things whenever I’m in the kitchen with him.” This wasn’t a lie; it just hadn’t happened for four years. “He bangs on my door at night and gets so angry when things don’t go his way. He tried to teach me to shoot a gun by taking me to a field full of rabbits. I couldn’t do it.”

Billy was nodding, something soft and sincere in his eyes as he said quietly, “You don’t deserve that.”

“You… you don’t either.”

His eyes lit up, like no one had ever told him that before. “Thank you. I -  I was just wondering what your mom does, you know, when it happens.”

This, Jonathan could answer. “She shouts at him. Kicks him out the house.”

Billy smiled. “Good. You have a little brother, right? I think Max might’ve mentioned him.”

“Max? Wait, Max Mayfield?”

“My stepsister.”

“Huh.”

“Enough of this. Activating information sharing. Left, right, right, forward.”

“Left, right, right, forward.”

Billy blinked, his muscles spasmed and then he grinned his usual manic grin. “Woah, you got one? That makes so much sense, I was wondering what you were doing this week.”

“I’ve got what we needed. We can go now.”

“Right. Bye.” Jonathan said and tried not to feel guilty as he walked away.

*

After school, Jonathan didn’t go straight home. The Flayer told him to stay behind for something important.

“You’re really going to love this,” it said, in a tone that indicated a lie.

So, Jonathan loitered by the gym like requested, hands clenching and unclenching his bag straps as he waited. The school was quiet, almost everyone else home, but the Flayer was adamant that Jonathan stood right there.

After another ten minutes passed, Jonathan started eyeing the exit, wondering if he could make a break for it before the Flayer noticed. From the way it was eyeing him, it already knew.

Then from the enveloping silence came two voices, muffled at first but gradually growing louder. Jonathan raised an eyebrow at the computer, who nodded in assent. Moving forward, Jonathan could peer around the corner and jerked back when he saw who the voices belonged to.

Steve Harrington was leaning against a locker, arm above Nancy’s head like a stereotypical jock in a movie. Nancy tucked a lock of hair behind her ear and giggled, books pressed to her chest.

Their voices were clear as they spoke, breathless and excited.

“So,” Steve said, “did you think about what I said?”

“About helping you study?” Nancy never sounded that coy.

Steve smirked. “Sure. Just you and me. Alone. In your bedroom. No interruptions.”

Even from his hidden view, Jonathan could see Nancy go red.

Why are you showing me this?

“Just wait. It gets better.”

“Steve,” Nancy was saying, “I have something to tell you.”

“I have something to tell you too.”

“I think I have a crush on you.” “I’m in love with you.” They said simultaneously.

Then, “You are?” Nancy responded incredulously.

“Of course you do,” Steve replied. “I think we should go on a date.”

Nancy smiled. “That would be nice.”

“Great! I’m throwing a Halloween party next weekend, you should come!”

Nancy stared in disbelief. “A Halloween party? Steve, it’s not even October yet!”

“It will be next week!” Then his obnoxious expression softened. “I would really like it if you came. We can do a couples costume and everything.”

“Okay, that would be good. But… can we have lunch together?” she asked tentatively.

“Of course!” He took her hands in his. “I really like you Nancy. Ever since my parents went on the run after laundering a bunch of money, I’ve been kinda lonely.”

“I’m sorry, they did what?”

“And sure, it’s cool that the house is always empty for parties and they still send me money every month, but it kinda hurt that they didn’t take me with them.”

Is that true?

“Obviously. The FBI is after them and everything.”

Jonathan was learning new things everyday. Huh.

As he looked at Nancy, Jonathan took in the soft fluttering of her eyelashes and the sloped purse of her lips as she spoke.

Why did you show me this?

“I needed you to see that Nancy is going to be harder to get than you think. Are you sure that she is who you want?”

“Yes,” he said aloud, thinking of large, dark eyes and big, strong hands tiny wrists and fluffy hair.

“Good, then you’re ready for the upgrade.”

Upgrade?

“The upgrade. Turn around.”

Jonathan did, turning his back on the newly smitten couple in time to witness Argyle turning the corner. Argyle lit up when he saw Jonathan, practically sprinting over. When he grew closer, Jonathan took him in and was dismayed at what he saw.

Argyle’s usually perfect skin was splotchy and dry, large eye-bags almost consuming his face as if he had two black eyes. His lips were cracked and hair unkempt. Even his clothes looked a mess.

“Holy shit, are you okay?”

Argyle stared at him, and responded bluntly, “What the fuck is wrong with you?”

“Huh?”

“No, seriously, what is wrong with you? You ignore me all week and now you ask me if I’m okay? You left me at the mall on Saturday after taking an unknown pill and I was worried you’d been kidnapped or died or something. Then, at school, you completely blank me! I sat next to you in math yesterday and it was like you were looking right through me!”

“What?” What.

“You wanted to become popular, right? Argyle was getting in the way.”

“Jonathan?” Argyle’s eyes widened, “Dude! Are you talking to that super computer thing?” At Jonathan’s agreeing nod, his unhappiness faded into excitement. “That’s amazing! Has it been helping? Is that what was going on this week? That explains so much, I did find it weird that you started randomly sitting with Heather Holloway at lunch.” He gripped Jonathan’s shoulders and started shaking him gently. “Bro, dude, this might be the coolest thing that’s ever happened to me. And it isn’t even happening to me!”

Why are you letting me see him now?

“Because, to upgrade, Jonathan, you need to make a choice.” The Flayer pointed down the corridor at Nancy and Steve, then at Argyle. “Nancy or Argyle.”

I can’t have both?

“No. You cannot have both.”

But, Argyle is my friend.

“He’s holding you back. Upgrade, and that can be you.” Nancy and Steve were pressing closer together.

“Jonathan?”

Jonathan stared at him, Argyle, his best friend. Looked at him and saw the moments the Flayer meant. All the times Argyle was odd, or strange or awkward and Jonathan stayed by his side. This time, Jonathan was choosing for himself.

Once I get Nancy, I’ll make it up to him.

“To upgrade, I need you to say it out loud.”

“I choose Nancy.”

“What?”

“Upgrade complete. Activating optic nerve blocking.” Argyle disappeared like he’d been photo-shopped out a photo. “Goal: Nancy Wheeler. Congratulations, Jonathan Byers, you can now experience all your F.L.A.Y.E.R. has to offer.”

*

broNACHO: jon?

broNACHO: jon you rlly scared me today

would you like to block this user?

Yes

USER BLOCKED

Chapter 5: halloween

Chapter Text

Chapter 5: Halloween

Jonathan could scarcely admit to himself, but he regretted taking the upgrade. Not just because he missed Argyle (although he did a lot. When he’d been distracted by Heather’s schemes, not noticing that Argyle wasn’t there, it had been okay. But now that he was actively ignoring him, Jonathan couldn’t help but look for him in the throngs of students. He couldn’t tell if Argyle’s non presence was because of Jonathan or the nerve blocking. (( he hoped it was the latter)). However, because of the upgrade, the Flayer shocked him more frequently.

He would look in the mirror in the morning, shirtless and horrified. Although the Flayer could remove them, in private it kept them for Jonathan to see. Deep, black electrical burns that started on his chest and sparked outwards like a tree branch or lightning bolt, arcing over his shoulders, down his arms and back.

“If you would just listen to me,” the Flayer would say, “then it wouldn’t hurt as much.”

Nancy, Jonathan told himself every morning, you are doing this for Nancy.

Not that Nancy seemed to take notice. She and Steve were wrapped up in one another like a sappy rom-com couple or a Hallmark movie. It was kinda gross to look at, sitting opposite them at lunchtime.

The only advantage Jonathan now had was a link to Billy’s F.L.A.Y.E.R. who kindly informed them that Heather was unimpressed by Stancy, because of her loyalty to Billy – who, now that it was brought up, had a completely obvious crush on Steve it was almost embarrassing to watch.

So, the Flayer encouraged him to cultivate his friendships with Heather and Carol instead, who had settled into a natural rhythm between pet-project and actual friend. The only times Jonathan interacted with Nancy directly was during debate, where they were the first two members. These conversations often started stilted before shifting into a more natural state, usually once the Flayer prompted a dialogue.

The Flayer’s next point of development was the Halloween party.

“It’s very important,” it said, “that you participate appropriately. These sorts of events are important to your peers.”

So, Friday afternoon was spent picking an appropriate costume for Steve’s party. Not too nerdy, and not trying too hard, but not so thrown together that it looked as if he’d forgot. Finally, they settled on a knight, not too cartoonish or Disney.

This would be better as a couple’s costume.

“Just wait and see,” the Flayer responded with that knowing wink of his.

*

Steve’s party started between six and seven depending on how you interpreted ‘evening’. By the time Jonathan got there, people were spilling out onto the street, giggly and loud and obnoxious. Unsurprisingly, Jonathan was uncomfortable, something the Flayer hadn’t been able to shock from him yet.

Instead of greeting people he recognised, Jonathan stuck to shadows, trying to spot Nancy or Argyle. But she didn’t seem to be there yet, Steve flitted from person to person in a Han Solo costume, a partially dressed Billy Hargrove trailing after him like a guard dog.

Jonathan settled into a corner, to the Flayer’s disgust, but he couldn’t bring himself to pretend. All the criticisms, the shocks, the pretending was exhausting, and Jonathan would take advantage of the quiet when he could.

“Drink?” someone asked. It was Eddie Munson dressed all in black cloth like a homeless vampire.

“No thanks.”

“Come ooon,” he wheedled, tipping the red cup side to side in an attempt to be enticing. “We can’t let Harrington catch you looking bored.”

The Flayer nodded its assent, still pissed that Jonathan ignored it before. With a long-suffering sigh, Jonathan took it and drank. Although he and Argyle partook in plenty of weed variations, alcohol was still a strange substance to Jonathan. He let it burn down his throat and settle in his stomach before taking another sip, and then another.

Soon, he finished his cup and Munson switched them with a coy tilt of his head. As he drank more, Jonathan took stock of the room he was in, settling down to watch in amusement as Billy Hargrove stumbled into the room.

He did not look well. His eyes were dark, skin sallow and veins black in the warm, orange lamplight. There was a light sheen of sweat covering him.

“Do you have any red dew?” he was asking, gripping people’s shoulders. He stumbled when they shoved him away, and there was a growing mania to his actions.

Jonathan turned to the Flayer for guidance only to jolt back when he noticed the Mick Jones form dispersing into loose pixels.

Holy shit! Are you okay?

“I am – I am f – fine.” Its voice had a robotic quality to it. Then, before Jonathan could ask anything else, it disappeared completely.

It was odd. Jonathan hadn’t realised how dependent he’d been on this thing before it was gone. It may have been in his head for a few weeks, but now that it was gone… Jonathan didn’t know what to do.

Suddenly, the party seemed louder, brighter, overwhelming. His hands shook as he drained the rest of his cup, standing and tossing it near the trash can. He needed peace and quiet.

There was a bathroom at the top of the staircase, and Jonathan stumbled in. The door slammed behind him, and Jonathan sank to the floor, burrowing his head in his knees and breathing. All that he could hear was a dripping from the faucet and heavy breathing.

“Jonathan?”

He looked up and locked eyes with Argyle, who was sitting uncomfortably in the bathtub.

“Hey,” he said, weakly.

Argyle cycled through a series of emotions so quickly that Jonathan could only tell what he settled on – pity. It was an unusual emotion on his face, which is why Jonathan could pick it up so quickly. Argyle never pitied him before.

“You okay, dude?” Argyle unfurled himself from the porcelain container, wobbling before sitting next to him. He was warm, Jonathan never noticed how warm he was, or how much he missed it. Argyle looked better since the last time Jonathan saw him, less death-like.

In comparison, Jonathan was sure he looked like a mess.

Instead of responding to the question, Jonathan said, “Why aren’t you in costume?”

Something slipped on Argyle’s face, but he forced it away with a wide grin. “I am! Isn’t it good?” He spread his arms out to showcase his jumper dotted with the weed symbol.

Jonathan shrugged lethargically, returning to stare morosely at the ground. “I guess.”

They sat in silence for a moment, Jonathan soaking in the warmth from the shoulder pressed against his, when Argyle asked, “What did you mean when you chose Nancy?”

“What?”

“That day, when you ‘chose Nancy’ or whatever, then blocked me, then pretended i didn’t exist.” Argyle didn’t seem angry, but he never got angry. Trying to anger Argyle was like trying to drown a duck in water, it rolled right off him.

Jonathan swallowed convulsively. “I’m trying to get her.”

“Get her to what?” The patience in his voice rankled him.

“Date me. Fall in love with me. See me as more as the creepy weirdo with a crazy mom!”

Argyle looked at him, endlessly calm and asked kindly, “Did she think of you like that before?”

“She had to, why else wouldn’t she date me?” Saying it out loud, the desperation reeked so thick, it was palpable.

He could’ve thought about, narrowed down precisely what incentivised him to do everything he’s done so far, but the small, bitter part of him that was tired of trailing after Argyle like a lost puppy pushed back.

“You’re just jealous,” he spat.

(he wondered if this is what the Flayer wanted him to say. Wondered if he was holding himself correctly, whether he was hunched too low.)

Argyle moved suddenly, warm press of his shoulder leaving a cold pit like a ghost as he stood. Jonathan never saw Argyle startled, but looking at him now, it was as if Jonathan had struck him. His shoulders were up by his ears, fists by his side and a tight clench to his jaw.

“Why would you say that?”

“It’s the truth.”

“How long have you known?”

Jonathan blinked but didn’t clarify. “For a while. It’s obvious.”

Argyle’s eyes were suddenly wet, and Jonathan tried to reach for him. “Argyle, wha -?”

But Argyle squared his shoulders and said, “I looked the F.L.A.Y.E.R. up online, and it’s sketchy as fuck, dude. Like they did clinical trials on children kind of sketchy. I don’t know what we put in your body, but I don’t think it’s safe. I think we need to deactivate it.”

“Deactivate it?” Jonathan scoffed. “You really are jealous. Its helped me more than you ever have. I am not getting rid of it.”

Argyle rolled his eyes. “You need to get over yourself, dude. You’re so convinced that there’s more that you deserve.”

“You think I don’t deserve this?”

“No. I don’t. I can see what it’s doing to you.”

“What it’s doing to me? Unbelievable!” Jonathan felt himself fold inward.

“Show me your arms.”

“No.”

“Jonathan.” Argyle reached forward and tugged at his sleeve. “Show me and I’ll let it go.”

It should’ve been simple, but the thought of Argyle seeing the dark veins racing up his arms scared him.

“Leave me alone, bro.”

“Jonathan,” he whispered, “please.”

But Jonathan was panicked, angry and backed into a corner. “You need to leave. This is pathetic. You’re weak and scared and so lonely that you’re crawling on your knees, begging for me to acknowledge you. Well,” here he turned so he didn’t have to see Argyle’s face, “well, I don’t have to do that anymore. We aren’t friends.”

There was a deafening silence and Jonathan opened the bathroom door, the click of the lock behind him like a gun shot.

*

Nancy was downstairs, sitting by herself in a renaissance princess costume. She smiled when she saw him, gesturing for him to sit beside her.

“Nice costume,” she said, tipping her drink to his armour. “I see we match.”

He laughed. “What a lucky coincidence. But I thought you and Steve were coming in couple’s costumes?”

She sighed. “So did I.”

They watched as Steve flitted around the room, an odd twist to his face. He came over at some point, with two drinks in hand, handing them both to Nancy and Jonathan.

“Where’s your costume?” Nancy asked.

Steve frowned, eyes scanning the crowd as he mumbled, “I’m Han Solo.”

“I thought we agreed to be a prince and princess?”

This pulled Steve from wherever he was looking. He looked Nancy up and down. “I thought you were coming as Princess Leia?”

“Why would I come as her?”

“Because you said you would!” He threw his hands up in exasperation. “You said, ‘I’m going as a princess’ and I said, ‘like Leia?’ and you said, 'yes, I guess’.”

“Yes. Like Leia.”

Steve rolled his eyes. “Why do you always act like I’m stupid!”

Jonathan hunched in slightly as they continued to snipe at each other. Nancy’s hands were gripping the hem of her skirts as Steve drained his cup and mumbled something about finding Billy.

Nancy slumped against the couch; eyes slightly damp as she sipped forlornly at her drink. “I think Steve Harrington’s someone who doesn’t live up to the fantasy. Like when you get a cute puppy and realise you have them forever now, even when they aren’t cute anymore.”

“Are you – are you going to break up?”

She shrugged. “I don’t think we were really together in the first place.”

Jonathan wished the Flayer was there, to lead the conversation correctly. But Jonathan had to navigate it himself now, something he hadn’t done for an embarrassingly long time.

“I’m sorry.”

Nancy sighed. “It’s okay. I think I was desperate to understand why everyone around me is so obsessed with dating. Truthfully, I still don’t get it. It feels like a friendship with extra steps and more expectations. So, I think I’m going to be sticking to my regular friendships – like Barb, and you.”

There was… something. Jonathan wouldn’t call it rejection, but the sting in his chest was just as palpable. It wasn’t unsurprising, the feeling. It was as if he’d gone into it knowing he would be rejected.

“Cool. Glad I could help.”

“You – you are – you are – s0 – s0000 pathetic.” Before him, the Flayer was materialising. It seemed to pull itself together, pixel by pixel until the flashing form solidified into something more tangible.

I’m not. I’m just realising –

“ReALising ThaT wE HaVE W0Rk t0 D0?”

No.

A sharp burst of electricity coursed through his body. It wasn’t the short bursts he was used to, but a long-drawn-out line. Jonathan gasped slightly and curled in on himself, clutching his forearms in pain.

“Jonathan?” Nancy asked, hand resting gently on his shoulder, “Are you okay?”

“S33? ShE LIIiikes y0u. she’S just TRAPPED! Fr33 hER! fr33 Heer!”

“I’m fine. Just have a headache. I think I might sit outside for a bit.”

“Okay,” she relented, still worrying her bottom lip. “Let me know if you need water or anything, okay?”

“Yeah. Thanks.”

Jonathan stumbled his way outside, the glitching Flayer following, repeating ‘free her’ like a mantra. It hadn’t stopped shocking him, but the pain was a background to the anger coursing through him.

“What the hell was that?”

He didn’t care that he was talking out loud. Nothing mattered anymore. Nancy didn’t like him, and he’d ruined his friendship with Argyle in the process. Jonathan was truly pathetic.

The pain stopped and the Flayer stopped glitching, standing straight and smirking. “I needed to get you out the house.”

“What?” Jonathan asked, just as the house burst into flames.

Chapter 6: pitiful children

Chapter Text

Chapter 6: Pitiful Children

Jonathan could barely remember what happened during or after the fire. All he could remember was the screaming, the panicked pushing and crying and the Flayer, straight-faced, telling him how lucky he was that it was there.

The next week was quiet, as everyone reacclimatised and recovered from the party. Neither Billy Hargrove nor Steve Harrington were at school, and that’s when the rumours started.

“Did you know that it was actually Billy Hargrove who set the fire?”

“Oh yeah! I heard that he’d taken unknown drugs from Eddie Munson!”

“I heard that he was so drunk that he didn’t know who he was!”

“I heard that he’s been hearing voices for ages now!”

“He set the fire because he’s jealous of the Harringtons’ money!”

“No, it’s because Steve was offered the captaincy of the basketball team.”

“Did you hear that Billy Hargrove’s in hospital?”

“He’s covered in third-degree burns!”

“He’s paralysed!”

“He’s dead.”

“Steve was so heroic, running into the fire to pull Billy out.”

“Do you think they’re gay?”

“Do you think that’s why Billy started the fire? I always knew he was jealous.”

*

Nancy ignored everyone, those who asked about the fire, about Billy, about Steve’s relationship with him. She picked at her food at lunch, but she wasn’t the only one. Heather also refused to talk, constantly on her phone with a worried pinch between her brows. Tommy and Carol seemed to attempting a performance of forced normalcy, cracking jokes then weakly laughing.

Jonathan hadn’t seen Argyle around and was too scared to ask whether he was still blocked. Since the party, the Flayer increased in aggressiveness. More shocks and sharp remarks, more insults – ‘you’re worthless’ and ‘no wonder everyone hates you’ and ‘I’m surprised you haven’t killed yourself yet’.

Jonathan hadn’t felt as despondent as he did now. all his relationships were crumbling around him. Will hid whenever he came into the room, Joyce didn’t talk anymore, Heather was distracted, Carol pretending, Billy in the hospital, Nancy morose and Argyle nowhere to be found.

To top it off, the Flayer seemed determined for Jonathan and Nancy to get together.

“She needs you; don’t you see? You need to free her from these confinements!”

Leave her alone. Leave me alone.

“This is what you wanted, isn’t it? This is what you got me for?”

It was the truth. The Flayer wasn’t a monster, wasn’t a teenage boy in love with a girl, a grown man following a woman home. It was a computer, programmed to help and that’s what it was determined to do.

*

Billy was in the hospital. Heather informed them almost a week after the party that Billy was awake and coherent.

“He was badly hurt,” she said over lunch, phone pressed to her chest. “He’s worried about scars.”

Jonathan didn’t visit him in hospital. Every time he thought of Billy, he remembered the conversation that he abandoned. He wondered if Billy’s dad visited his son.

Steve was in school the week after, right leg in a cast. Turned out, he’d pulled Billy from the fire and was discharged from the hospital over the weekend. “It was pretty crazy,” he told everyone, “It was burning hot, and everything was melting!”

With Steve’s return, the school returned to a semblance of normalcy that almost seemed real. Nancy was still uncomfortable, and she and Steve were officially over by the end of the week. People were cruel about it, calling her a bitch for ending it after the fire, but she seemed more herself without the relationship hanging over her.

The Flayer was delighted by the news, prompting gently then aggressively for Jonathan to flirt. But he couldn’t bring himself to do it, all he could think about was the party and the conversation and the ‘sticking to my regular friendships’.

“You’re pathetic,” the Flayer hissed. “We need to fix this and fast. Go to your locker.”

Jonathan reluctantly bid the lunch group goodbye and made his way to his locker silently.

Can we just stop. I’ve done it. I’ve moved up the social ladder, I’ve got a seat at the popular table. That’s what I wanted.

“No. What you wanted, Jonathan, was Nancy. And you still don’t have her.”

I don’t want her.

“Liar!”

The Flayer watched impatiently as he opened the door. Inside was an unknown cardboard box, with a Pikachu sticker on the lid.

“Open it,” the Flayer prompted with a grin.

Tentatively, Jonathan opened it. Inside was tens of little grey pills, loose and shiny. Jonathan picked one up and held it to the light, trying to see the CPU within the case.

“It’s that great? You can help everyone with that.”

Jonathan stopped and stared. What?

“You see, Jonathan. Since I’ve been activated, I’ve come across the same brick wall over and over, and that is the unpredictable and uncontrollable nature of humanity. I first noticed this problem when I connected to Billy Hargrove’s F.L.A.Y.E.R. I’m sure you know why he activated his, his dad hasn’t stopped hurting him – but, if his dad took that little pill, he would. Don’t you want that?”

Do I want Billy’s dad to stop hitting him?

The Flayer shrugged. “You have that power. You could fix everyone. Everything. Why won’t you?”

Before Jonathan could respond, there was a whispered ‘excuse me’ behind him. Jonathan turned abruptly to find Chrissy Cunningham staring at him. She made herself smaller, somehow possible despite her already small stature, and couldn’t meet his eyes.

“She needs your help. Look at her, meek as a mouse, half-starved and desperate for love. You can give her that love.”

Jonathan wasn’t in control as he handed her a pill. “HERE, TAKE ONE.”

Chrissy blinked demurely, pill resting in her dainty palm. “What is it?”

“IT WILL HELP YOU. IT WILL HELP YOU BE BEAUTIFUL. IT WILL HELP YOU WITH YOUR MOM.”

Jonathan watched helplessly as Chrissy took the words in, opened her mouth and swallowed the pill dry. She shuddered, limbs spasming as she gripped her throat. Then her shoulder slumped, she swayed and stood.

“Chrissy?” he asked.

“Hello,” she replied, voice dreamy and eyes glazed. “You were right. This does help.” Then she took the box from him. “Lets go help e v e r y o n e.”

She walked away, upright and mechanical. Jonathan watched, horror rising in his throat, as Chrissy tapped Robin Buckley on the shoulder. Robin looked skeptical but no-one could deny Chrissy, so she took a pill and swallowed it.

“Look at them,” the Flayer mused. “Look how desperate they are for someone to tell them what to do. You humans truly are weak, pitiful things, aren’t you?”

Why can’t I move?

“I want you to watch the truth unfold before you.”

 *

Later on, no-one but Jonathan could clearly remember what happened those days. After Robin was flayed, she and Chrissy split the pills between them, and like an odd pyramid scheme, went on to drug and branch out the F.L.A.Y.E.R.’s tendrils.

It forced Jonathan to watch, fully in control of his limbs as student after student took the pill. It was sad to know that each of his classmates had something they were so desperate to fix. It was like he was trapped in a mirror maze, running down corridors and coming face-to-face with the same distorted reflections of desperation, hopelessness and pitifulness.

Unlike Jonathan, the newly flayed had no control. It seemed as if the F.L.A.Y.E.R. system wasn’t taking any chances. Complete and utter control that was spreading steadily outwards like a lightning strike or a plague.

He walked the corridors, his robotic classmates standing still until he passed before they booted up like a computer to interact with him. After a while, it became clear what the Flayer was doing. The system itself wasn’t the center, it was Jonathan. The main goals of the newly flayed were 1) infect as many people as possible, and 2) be nice to Jonathan Byers.

They didn’t bow, but the way they moved seemed close enough. Their eyes were glazed, limbs stiff and veins black, but they smiled and waved and greeted him like it was a natural part of the world order. Even Jason Carver smiled angelically at him from where he stood lined up next to Patrick and Andy.

What do you want? Like really want? he asked as they passed Eddie Munson and the rest of the Hellfire Club, frozen in place by the music room.

“I am here to help you.”

Jonathan wasn’t entirely sure what to believe. All media ever warned against was a robot/AI uprising, the Flayer’s goal had always been Jonathan. Was the system to blame, or the people who made it?

‘they did clinical trials on children kind of sketchy’ Argyle had told him. Jonathan remembered the look on his face with a pang.

Where is Argyle?

“You left him in the bathroom. I’m surprised it took you this long to remember him. I’m sure it would’ve appreciated it sooner.”

What?

“Well, the fire started fifteen minutes after the bathroom confrontation.” The Flayer smiled, like it was funny. “I’m sure he got out in time.”

Jonathan stared at him, icy coolness spreading from the corrupt beat of his heart, down the pathways forged by electricity to the numbness developing at his fingertips. He would’ve heard, wouldn’t he? Heather or Steve or even a teacher would’ve told him if Argyle had died.

I don’t believe you.

“Have I ever lied to you?”

You lied to me about Nancy.

“No, I didn’t.” It gestured down the hallway.

Nancy turned the corner, face perfectly blank. Her hair was pushed back into a ponytail, clothes neatly pressed. Her lip-gloss glittered in the light and her brown eyes fixed on him, unseeing. Even when she reacted to him, her eyes remained dull.

When she spoke, it was as if she was reading from a script. “Jonathan, I’ve been thinking about the conversation we had at the party. I don’t just want to be your f r i e n d, I want to be your g i r l f r i e n d.” She lurched forward like strings were attached to her limbs, pulling them up and out in a mockery of a hug.

What did you do?

“I took away her restraints. There was so much holding her back, you know? She’s been fighting with her mom, her dad, her brother. She misses Barb, and she thought Steve Harrington could fix her. Make her normal. But, before Steve, Nancy Wheeler had a crush on you. I’m letting her act on it now.”

Before him, Nancy Wheeler stood, limbs limp in the air as she waited for the next instruction. Jonathan took her in then, allowed himself a small moment where he let the Flayer lead him like he’d done before. Him and Nancy, holding hands, kissing, going on dates, with the looming presence of the Flayer in their heads, dictating the conversation like a little girl playing dolls. Neither could say anything wrong, act out of bounds.

“No.” Jonathan pushed Nancy’s arms down. “This is not right.”

Nancy’s head tipped to the side, like a robot’s attempt at a head tilt but it looked more like she’d fallen asleep. “WHY?” she (it) asked, “This is ALL for y o u. E V E R Y T H I N G here is for you!”

“I don’t want it! I never wanted this! I didn’t want the house to burn down, I didn’t want all my friends, all my classmates to become these mindless drones!”

“Didn’t you? You wanted them to like you, right? This is the only way.”

Before, that would’ve stung. But now, Jonathan did not care. Billy Hargrove had been flayed for three years and hadn’t done anything like this, Jonathan was flayed for over a month and had enslaved the entire school. This was Jonathan’s problem to fix.

“Is Argyle dead?”

The Flayer didn’t respond. It took him in, assessing with its pinprick eyes, features twisted into something ugly.

“Is. Argyle. Dead?”

“Check your phone.”

Jonathan pulled it out immediately, thumbing to the messages whilst keeping the Flayer in his peripheral. There were hundreds of missed calls from BLOCKED CALLER and when he clicked on the profile, Argyle’s smiling face appeared before him.

There were calls since the day at the mall every day until the morning after the party. They stopped but… and Jonathan sighed in relief, they started again two days ago. There was one voicemail from the later call.

“Jonathan,” Argyle said, something small and sad in his voice. “Dude, I don’t think I can do this anymore. I convinced myself that it was the computer in your head making you say those things, but I know now that isn’t true. You chose Nancy over me, and at first, that was fine too. But then you told me I was jealous in that bathroom, when the Flayer was gone from your mind. And I think something inside me broke. Because I wanted you to reciprocate them, you know? But you didn’t just reject me, you used it against me as well. I don’t think I can forgive you for that.”

The voicemail ended, and Jonathan saved it unthinkingly, staring at his best friend’s face.

“He likes me?”

“He was in love with you.”

Was. Past tense. “Why didn’t you tell me?”

“You didn’t want to know. What would you have done? You wanted Nancy.”

Did he? Did he really want Nancy? Sure, when he was thirteen and lonely and his abusive father was gone for good, and Nancy had asked him to be her lab partner in biology because ‘you’re the only other smart person in this room’.

But Argyle, who had been by his side since Jonathan could remember, a warm, cheerful presence whose main goal in life seemed to be ‘make Jonathan Byers smile’ and it was a goal he succeeded at with alarming frequency. How could Jonathan ever forget the days that Argyle climbed through his bedroom window armed with warm pizza and chocolate, where they would build blanket forts and watch clips from Saw on YouTube. And when they smoked pot for the first time, Argyle curled around him like a cat and promised he would be Jonathan’s friend forever and ever, and it was a promise Jonathan kept close to his chest.

And maybe, Jonathan had wanted to kiss Argyle then, across his smiling mouth and flushed cheeks, or when he’d fallen asleep and a strand of hair had caressed his forehead, so Jonathan gently brushed it away.

Maybe that was the moment Jonathan fell in love.

The Flayer stared at him in disbelief, sighed and snapped, “I don’t have time for this.”

*

Everything went black.

Chapter 7: the argyle interlude

Chapter Text

Chapter 7: The Argyle Interlude

Argyle first fell in love with Jonathan when he was twelve years old. They were lying on Jonathan’s bed, blanket fort bending around them, weight bearing on unstable pillars. Jonathan had fairy-lights that he usually kept hidden under his bed, but he’d strung them up because Argyle said that he missed the stars.

“When you’re on the beach after sunset, the stars seem so bright,” he had said sadly. They moved to Hawkins two years before, and Argyle hadn’t been to the beach since.

“Here,” Jonathan showed him two weeks after, “I got these for you.”

It wasn’t that he’d put the lights up, despite Lonnie Byers insistence that anything Jonathan did was gay, but that he’d attempted to form constellations.

As he stared at them, Argyle’s pinkie hooked around Jonathan’s, and he made a promise to himself.

I promise to never let Jonathan Byers be lonely ever again.

*

When Jonathan told him about Nancy Wheeler, and about how smart and pretty she was, Argyle had swallowed the bitterness rising in his throat and agreed to help. He sat by and helped Jonathan write letter after letter of confessions that inevitably ended up in the trash. He willingly held Jonathan’s camera bag as his friend snapped pictures of the object of his affection. And in private, he smoked weed and lamented to his other friend, Billy.

*

Nancy haunted Argyle whenever he spoke to Jonathan. She was a looming presence or a ticking clock over his relationship with Jonathan, because as much as he tried to deny it, he wouldn’t be surprised if Nancy liked Jonathan back.

Jonathan Byers was odd, but in a charming, quirky way that made some his strange qualities more endearing than anything. Argyle could spend hours listening to Jonathan rant about different lenses and photo manipulation, or listening to The Clash even if he didn’t really like them.

Jonathan was odd and weird and creepy, and Argyle’s and he wouldn’t have it any other way,

*

Billy came back from California and befriended Steve Harrington.

Argyle pretended it didn’t hurt.

*

Then they were fifteen and Argyle’s feelings went from soft to warm. He made him sick at times, thinking like Jonathan the way he did. But he couldn’t help it – he was a teenage boy and the object of his affections often slept in the same bed as him. He couldn’t help what that did to him.

Jonathan only noticed once, and turned bright red, hurriedly leaving the room. Argyle remained frozen, half upright in bed, hands clenching the sheet around his waist tight. It had been Jonathan who suggested that they slept separately for the next sleepovers.

(argyle heard jonathan once in the shower. the sounds kept him up at night still.)

*

Eddie Munson was the main supplier and had a knowing glint in his eye whenever he saw Argyle.

“I have the perfect strand for you!” he would declare. “You are not the only man in a predicament like yours.”

He gave Argyle discounts if he looked particularly morose and sometimes offered a sympathetic ear. His crush on Chrissy Cunningham was an open secret in the halls of Hawkins high.

*

The first time Argyle and Jonathan got high together, Argyle was filled with such love and warmth that he’d almost kissed Jonathan after the first hit. It was, quite frankly, embarrassing how desperate weed made him.

Jonathan, shrouded in mysterious smoke, looking at him beneath his eyelashes, asking, ‘do you want another hit?’

‘do you want to shotgun?’ Argyle asked instead. ‘I can show you how.’

Jonathan nodded then, and curled towards him, lips parted and eyes curious. But before they leaned closer, Argyle pulled back. Knowing that would be the only way to have Jonathan would be tempting but taunting. He couldn’t bare knowing what Jonathan’s lips felt like near his without having the entire experience.

*

Will was missing and Argyle worried a piece of Jonathan was as well.

Will came back but Jonathan never seemed fully complete again.

*

Joyce Byers was the loveliest woman you could ever meet, but sometimes Argyle wanted to shake her.

‘Stop looking in the shadows.’ He wanted to shout. ‘Your sons are here, at home, and they need you to take care of them. You’re the adult. Act like it.’

*

Jonathan decided that junior year was going to be his year, and Argyle trailed behind him like always. He was happy to see Jonathan’s energy return, gaining momentum every day. He wasn’t entirely sure what ‘his year’ entailed but he was going to support Jonathan the entire time.

“I’m going to climb the social ladder,” Jonathan declared, “and I’m going to finally ask Nancy out.”

“Cool. I’ll help,” Argyle responded, even though he could feel parts of him break.

*

Jonathan’s first attempts were pathetic, even by Argyle’s standards. He’d written another confession to Nancy and torn it up immediately afterwards.

“Nancy’s nice,” Argyle said, “You could start by talking to her.”

But Jonathan remained resolute that he had to do it properly. He had to romance her, woo her, like she deserved. Argyle was of the opinion that what Nancy deserved was someone to treat her normally, but he didn’t think Jonathan would appreciate that.

*

“Billy Hargrove cornered me in the bathroom to sell me drugs." That’s what Jonathan told him after Argyle raced over to his house because of a flurry of panicked messages.

“What?”

That wasn’t what he expected. It might’ve seemed odd, that Argyle didn’t sign up for debate as well, but after an obnoxiously long internal debate, he realised that this was something that Jonathan would have to do alone.

What he didn’t expect was Billy Hargrove to offer Jonathan drugs. Not just any drugs, a sketchy sounding quantum-computer called the F.L.A.Y.E.R. that may explain Billy’s major personality switch two years ago.

His first instinct was to deny, tell Jonathan to forget it and work on himself for himself. It may have been the weed talking, but if Jonathan was destined to climb the social ladder, then he should do it as himself. Because if they take Jonathan as anything other than himself, then they don’t deserve him.

But then Joyce walked in, and Jonathan went red and humiliated. Argyle couldn’t take his friend’s hope away like that.

"Will you come with me?"

"Of course."

*

It was definitely a scam. Argyle watched as Jonathan stuffed six hundred dollars’ worth of cash in his pockets and swallowed the urge to scream. He’d been doing some research on the F.L.A.Y.E.R. in the week leading up to the event, and although there was scarcely anything, what he did find did not put his mind at ease.

Keith wasn’t impressed by them, probably disappointed they weren’t girls, but handed over the pill for four hundred anyway. Whilst Jonathan was admiring the pill, Argyle listened intently to all the information Keith was giving out.

“To activate it, you have to take it with green mountain dew, and to deac – h-hi Eden."

Argyle kept the idea of deactivation at the back of his mind as he watched Jonathan swallow the pill. Nothing happened and Argyle grew angry.

“I’ll go and get your money back from Keith,” he said, walking away.

He would regret that for the longest time, leaving. Keith was still talking to the goth girl – Eden, when Argyle stalked in.

“Woah didn’t expect to see you. You want one as well?”

Argyle stalked closer, leaned across the counter and pulled Keith down by his shirt collar. “I want the money back. Your shit doesn’t work.”

“Look, Argyle, I can’t just give –”

“Keith, if you don’t fucking give me the money, I’ll tell your boss you’re selling drugs behind the counter of a family friendly store.”

Keith growled. “I’m not giving you all of it. You get two hundred or nothing.” He slammed it on the counter.

Argyle would’ve fought more, but that’s when the screaming started.

*

Shaken from what he witnessed; he hadn’t expected to meet Nancy Wheeler outside the food court after hauling Jonathan off the floor.

“Is he okay?” she asked.

“I think so,” he said and scrubbed a hand down his face. “I don’t know what happened.” Although that wasn’t entirely true. He hoped the pill wasn’t dangerous unactive.

Nancy and Steve left minutes later, more on Steve’s insistence than anything, so Argyle gathered the cheap mall food to take back to Jonathan. Only to find the bathroom empty when he got back.

you: jon where are you?

you: jon seriously

you: you’re scaring me

you: im waiting in the van

you: jon?

missed call

BROmio: went home

*

 Argyle wasn’t sure what happened at the mall, but Jonathan was upset. He was sitting upright in math, and when Argyle tried to talk to him, Jonathan blanked him completely.

“I’m sorry I left you,” Argyle whispered between questions, trying to catch Jonathan’s eye. “I shouldn’t have left you like that and I’m sorry.”

Jonathan ignored. Argyle sighed and turned back to his work, resolving to talk to Jonathan again in a few hours.

*

Jonathan started eating with Heather Holloway and the rest of the group at lunch. Argyle picked forlornly at his cafeteria food as he watched Jonathan laugh at something Tommy Hagan said.

“I don’t know how he did it,” Eddie Munson said, sitting down next to him. “It’s kind of inspiring.”

*

After school, Argyle got a text message from Eddie asking to meet by the gym locker room. He sighed and made his way over, not caring what it was about but desperate for some semblance of a normal relationship.

But when he turned the corner, it wasn’t Eddie who greeted him but Jonathan.

“Holy shit, are you okay?”

Argyle stared at him, and responded bluntly, “What the fuck is wrong with you?”

Turned out the F.L.A.Y.E.R. was what was wrong with him. Argyle wasn’t as excited as he thought he’d be, but he tried not to show it. Jonathan seemed attached to the CPU, so Argyle wanted to be happy about it. It did seem to be working.

Then…

“I choose Nancy.”

And just like that, the Jonathan Argyle knew was gone, replaced by an unseeing, blank-faced clone. And when Jonathan Byers walked away, he took pieces of Argyle’s heart with him.

*

Argyle called him every day. Even after Jonathan blocked him. He left voicemails, text messages and even messaged him on his secret Tumblr account, but Jonathan had him blocked on that as well. After a while, Argyle’s voicemails were recounts of his day so he could hear Jonathan greeting him, and pretended it was normal.

*

Argyle was giving himself one more chance before he would let Jonathan go (until he could find mountain dew red – the deactivation key).

Harrington’s parties were always open invitation, so it didn’t matter that Argyle hadn’t been officially invited. He didn’t try very hard with his costume, just enough to get him through the door. As he stepped through, he was overwhelmed instantly.

He could see Munson with a bong in the corner, Harrington flitting from guest to guest and Hargrove stumbling around, already blackout drunk.

Instead of sticking around and looking for Jonathan like he originally planned, Argyle fled to the bathroom. It wasn’t as big as expected, and he sat in the bathtub to regain his breath.

He wasn’t alone for long. Jonathan himself came in, red-rimmed eyes and shaking hands, and Argyle watched in trepidation as Jonathan sinks to the ground and sighs.

“You’re just jealous!” Is what Jonathan told, and Argyle felt himself freeze.

Because he was, insanely so. He hated how much energy Jonathan was exerting on Nancy, wishing desperately that it was directed at him. He was jealous of how much Jonathan liked Nancy’s hair, her eyes, her hands. He was stupidly jealous, but he was also so sad as he witnessed the boy he loved spiral into something unrecognisable.

“You need to leave. This is pathetic. You’re weak and scared and so lonely that you’re crawling on your knees, begging for me to acknowledge you.” Then he leaves Argyle in the bathroom by himself.

*

When the house lit up in flames, Argyle wanted to burn to ash with it.

*

He lived anyway.

*

“Jonathan. Dude, I don’t think I can do this anymore. I convinced myself that it was the computer in your head making you say those things, but I know now that isn’t true. You chose Nancy over me, and at first, that was fine too. But then you told me I was jealous in that bathroom, when the Flayer was gone from your mind. And I think something inside me broke. Because I wanted you to reciprocate them, you know? But you didn’t just reject me, you used it against me as well. I don’t think I can forgive you for that.”

*

He went home to burn all his memories, and that’s how Joyce Byers found him. Teary-eyed and burning photo-booth pictures.

*

“I haven’t been a great mom these past months,” Joyce said. "I’ve let Jonathan down and I know this might be a lot to ask of you, given the circumstances, but I need your help. He needs your help.”

“Why?”

“There’s something wrong with the school. And I think Jonathan’s at the center of it.”

*

Before he went to Jonathan, Argyle went to Billy.

The other boy was covered head to toe in a white body cast, but he grinned brightly when Argyle walked in.

“Oh, hey! Didn’t know you were coming?”

“Why did you burn the house down,” Argyle asked.

Billy stared at him, assessing him. “I needed to get it out.”

“The F.L.A.Y.E.R.?”

“No one had any mountain dew red.”

“What does that do?”

Billy smiled. “It deactivates it.”

Chapter 8: voices in my head

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Chapter 8: Voices in My Head

It was like walking through a dream. Jonathan walked hand in hand with Nancy down the corridor, hands gripped loosely. They walked the same pace, so neither’s slipped from the grip, and they walked and walked.

Behind them, the Flayer trailed looking confused.

“Why aren’t you happy?”

But Jonathan couldn’t reply. His mouth wasn’t working, and his brain was thoughtless. Nancy smiled at him, doll-like.

“I’m h a p p y.”

Jonathan smiled, nodded and tried to pretend.

*

Jonathan could never tell of the F.L.A.Y.E.R. had reached the outside world, or whether it had confined itself to the walls of a tiny high school in Hawkins, Indiana. He didn’t know why it didn’t try and leave, but later on, once it was all over, he told Argyle that his prediction was that more people were harder to control.

Or maybe it liked playing with high-schoolers like dolls.

Because that’s what they were at this point, dolls. Just mechanical wind-up toys left to wander specific routes until it could think of a story to reenact. And throughout it all, it still tried to appeal to Jonathan.

Each elaborate story centered around Jonathan. Apologies from jocks, confessions from girls, entrance music performed by the school band. All for Jonathan.

The Flayer seemed desperate for Jonathan to enjoy himself, checking in periodically for confirmation and wilting when it realised Jonathan wouldn’t respond. But it refused to relinquish its control.

Then one day, it appeared before him looking smug.

“This is going to be our best performance yet,” and it pointed outside. Jonathan’s body moved to let him peer out, just in time to see a human figure slip into the building. “Now,” the Flayer tapped its chin, “who do you suppose that is, Argyle or Billy? Well, it can’t be Billy, he’s still in the hospital. Although,” it peered into Jonathan’s eyes, “we do need to reestablish a connection with him.”

Connection?

The Flayer looked delighted. “So, you can talk again! And yes, reconnect. The connection was severed during the fire.”

Another thing Jonathan realised was that the Flayer was a terrible liar. It glitched whenever it lied.

Severed?

It glared at him. “Yes.”

Jonathan hummed unconvinced, but let the Flayer lead him from the wall. Nancy immediately held out her cool hand for him to take, and they clasped each other uselessly.

They walked down the hall, to the cafeteria where Heather, Carol, Tommy and Steve were waiting. They all sat perfectly still at their usual table, and it wasn’t until Jonathan loomed over them that they started to move.

“Hello Jonathan,” they said in unison before turning and staring at the table again.

Jonathan took his place at the head of the plastic table, Nancy on his left and Heather on his right.

There was silence.

The Flayer looked annoyed, and it snapped its fingers. Steve moved, lurching forward in a weak attempt to be secretive. “Did you hear that Billy burned down my house because he’s in love with me?”

Jonathan smiled. “That’s not surprising at all, I’ve seen the way he looks at you.”

Both Steve and the Flayer looked shocked.

“What?” Steve said, voice cracking with the emotion. His face crinkled and body relaxed as he took it in. “Billy’s in love with me?”

“Yes.”

“What are you doing? Stop that!”

Everything went dark.

*

He woke to something soft brushing his forehead and a calm voice whispering, “I promise I’m coming back, okay?”

*

Everything hurt.

*

There was a sharp electric pain shooting through his body and it forced Jonathan to open his eyes. He blinked, staring at the white ceiling, directly below a flickering artificial light. He sat up and looked around. He was in a classroom, alone.

Something was stuck to his forehead, and he picked at it lightly. A yellow post it note floated to the ground beside him, a familiar scrawl of handwriting in blue ink.

He picked it up and squinted, reading Argyle’s hastily scratched: I’m coming.

Argyle was coming for him. Argyle who Jonathan had treated terribly, who may be in love with Jonathan and who Jonathan may love back.

He tucked the note into his shirt pocket and stood up. He didn’t know why it was so quiet, but he wasn’t going to wait around. Finally, he was in control of his body and he wasn’t going to waste that for a second.

He slipped from the classroom, peering down the empty corridors and started towards the main exit. He didn’t know what Argyle’s plan was, or where he planned to meet him but he couldn’t remain in one place at once.

The back of his head ached and as he walked, Jonathan felt along the bump. The skin didn’t appear broken and there didn’t seem to be any dried blood, so he must’ve hit his head when he fell in the classroom.

It was difficult to truly understand what was happening, and he was sure that some important information was missing, but all Jonathan knew was that he needed the Flayer out his head and he needed that now.

He paused. The Flayer said that the connection between him and Billy had been severed during the fire, but Billy had been frantic and desperate. Asking for red dew.

Oh.

Billy Hargrove tried to kill himself to get the Flayer out.

Jonathan stared at his arms, at the electrocution scars that faded as they reached his wrists and wondered when Billy decided enough was enough. How many scars and insults and failures did he take before he decided fire was the better alternative?

Jonathan sighed and felt for Argyle’s note, wishing desperately tat he was here now.

“Where are you going?” the Flayer asked, materialising beside him.

“Away from you.”

The Flayer rolled its eyes. “You can’t. I’m in your head.”

“We’ll see.”

He walked with determination, ignoring the computer that had taken it upon itself to be as obnoxious as possible. Jonathan sped up, trying not to look like he was trying to outrun the computer in his head but wanting it gone.

“Jonathan!” There was a familiar voice calling to him.

Both he and the Flayer turned to see Argyle sprinting towards them. The Flayer reared back in disgust, but Jonathan was focused on Argyle. Tall, strong Argyle whose face was set in a determined scowl, clutching a bag close to his chest.

“Drink this,” he said, pushing the bag to him. When Jonathan went to peer into hit, Argyle slapped his hand away. “Don’t look, just drink.” He glanced cautiously around, and Jonathan realised that he was looking for the Flayer.

As he tried to unscrew the cap of the bottle without taking it from the bag, the doors from further down the hallway opened with a resounding clang.

“Jonathan? What are you doing?” Nancy was walking towards him, arms opened and welcoming. “Don’t drink that. He wants to get rid of us, of this.”

“And?” He grunted and twisted the cap off, lifting the bottle to drink, “That’s what I want as well.”

He opened his mouth, only for the bottle to be slapped from his hands. The blank face of Steve Harrington stared at him.

“I won’t let you do this, Jonathan.”

Jonathan scowled. “Get the fuck out of my head.”

“No.”

The flayed students advanced, the jocks cornering Argyle who looked concerned and confused, considering that he couldn’t actually see half of the action. Nancy stood before Jonathan, face placid and demure.

Jonathan stood between them, another decision looming.

“Nancy?”

“yes?”

“You love me, right?”

“I do.”

Jonathan picked up the spilt bottle where some dregs still remained. He caught Argyle’s eye and smiled. “I need you to drink this for me.”

She took it unquestioningly and drained the remains before the Flayer could react. It screamed, and then they all did. As Jonathan gripped his head, feeling as if it was splitting open, he could see Argyle shoving his way over.

“Jonathan!” He could hear. “You’re okay! I promise!”

*

There was beeping.

Jonathan groaned and rolled over, burying his face in the pillow. It was warm in the room, a nice warm that made him sleepy.

“I know right, that’s the good shit,” a voice said.

Jonathan blinked blearily and sat up, rubbing the sleep from the corner of his eyes. Billy Hargrove stared at him, amused. He was still in his body cast, and was squinting more that smiling but Jonathan was relieved to see him.

“How long have I been out?”

Billy attempted to shrug, which he got across with his eyebrows. “Yesterday, I think. Came in with practically the entire student body. Is it true that you got rid of the Flayer?”

“How did you know that?”

Billy smiled. It was odd, he seemed to be smiling a lot. “Argyle. He was sent out the room like half an hour ago, so he’ll be back soon.”

“Right,” Jonathan said and laid back down. “Are you okay?”

Billy raised an eyebrow. “Me? Fine. Better than I should be, honestly, considering that I tried to burn myself alive.”

“That must’ve been scary.”

“How so?”

“You had that thing in your head for three years and no one else knew. Argyle knew about me, and that’s how I’m here, without a computer in my brain.”

“I was determined to keep it. I thought it could fix my problems.”

Jonathan smiled sadly. “Yeah. I have something to tell you.”

“The thing about your dad wasn’t entirely true?”

Jonathan blinked. “How did you know?”

Billy rolled his eyes. “Like I said before, I’ve been here for ages. I was in middle school with you!”

“Right.”

The door opened then, and Argyle crept in until he locked eyes with Jonathan’s definitely awake gaze.

“Jonathan!” He practically crawled across the bed and gathered Jonathan in his arms. “You’re okay!”

“I am. I am.” Jonathan was laughing and crying and hugging Argyle back, so full of gratitude and love that he felt like he could explode.

More people came in, Steve and Heather and Carol and Nancy. Steve sat at the edge of Billy’s bed and they stared into each other’s eyes, whilst Heather and Carol crowded around him like two tittering mother hen’s.

Nancy stood at the foot of the bed, jumping from foot-to-foot awkwardly.

“Are you okay?” he asked.

Out of all of them, she was probably struggling the most. Not only was she possessed and controlled, but she was forced into a role she was explicitly clear she didn’t want. Jonathan Byers’ girlfriend – her starring role.

“I –” she stammered. “I don’t think…”

“I don’t have a crush on you anymore, if that helps?”

“It was terrifying,” she replied bluntly, “being your girlfriend. That thing in my brain spent the entire time trying to convince me that I was in love with you. I’m not.”

“I know.”

“I will never be.”

“I know.”

She nodded jerkily and made to leave but Jonathan reached out from where he was pressed tight against Argyle’s chest. “You can stay. I think you need a friend as well.”

“Thank you,” she said quietly and sat down next to Heather.

*

When Will and Joyce visited, Jonathan burst into tears immediately. Other than his treatment of Argyle, the thing that Jonathan regretted the most was the way he treated Will and Joyce.

“I’m sorry,” he repeated into Will’s hair. “I’m so sorry.”

Beside him, his mom stroked his hands as he cried, and he could hear her apologies as well. An apology for being distant, for being crazy, for being uncaring and too caring at the same time, for the paranoia and the fear and everything else she did.

“I forgive you,” he told her.

“I forgive you,” Will told him.

*

When he’s discharged from hospital, he doesn’t want to return to school. Although the official statement was a mass roofying, the general consensus was that Jonathan had something to do with it, whether he supplied the drugs or was targeting a specific person, was anybody’s game.

Argyle was around him constantly. Things were still slightly awkward between them at times, when Jonathan would laugh at inside jokes made by Heather or Tommy that Argyle didn’t understand, or when Jonathan leaned against him, Argyle would sometimes flinch away.

But they were getting better. Argyle dragged them to take new photo-booth photos, refusing to explain what happened to the old ones.

“We just need these now, okay?” Who was Jonathan to deny him that?

Billy was still in hospital, but he and Steve seemed to be hurtling towards a relationship at alarming and oblivious speeds. Turned out that Chief Hopper arrested his dad after he was aggressive to hospital staff (after suggesting that they let his son die ‘to save him the trouble’) so that seemed to be getting sorted.

Nancy and Barb were closer than ever after Barn transferred to Hawkins high. If Nancy had a crush on Steve, Jonathan couldn’t even fathom the scope of love she had for Barb.

And for him, and Argyle?

Sometimes, it was too quiet in his mind. It was ominous and tense and one night when Jonathan couldn’t sleep, he laid awake, staring at the starless ceiling. Beside him, Argyle was wrapped around him like an octopus.

“Hey, Argyle?”

“Yeah?”

“Would you like to go to the beach with me?”

“As a date?”

“Yeah.”

“I would like that.”

Jonathan smiled, pressing his fingers to his forehead to stave away the headache. From the corner of his eye, he could see the smiling face of Mick Jones, but when he turned, he realised it was just the poster on his wall.

“Thank you, for helping me.”

“Of course,” Argyle said, pressing a kiss to his shoulder. “I would do it again.”

Jonathan turned to the ceiling and smiled, right in the center was a small glow-in-the-dark star that Argyle had pressed there five years ago.


Notes:

comments, kudos and bookmarks are very much appreciated :)
thank you so much for reading. i really hope you enjoy my entry for the big bang. i had so much fun writing this.
i appreciate all the help mae provided and the wonderful creations of ptera

follow me:
tumblr
and the playlist: here

Series this work belongs to: