Actions

Work Header

there are voices in my head (the loudest one is mine)

Chapter 6: pitiful children

Chapter Text

Chapter 6: Pitiful Children

Jonathan could barely remember what happened during or after the fire. All he could remember was the screaming, the panicked pushing and crying and the Flayer, straight-faced, telling him how lucky he was that it was there.

The next week was quiet, as everyone reacclimatised and recovered from the party. Neither Billy Hargrove nor Steve Harrington were at school, and that’s when the rumours started.

“Did you know that it was actually Billy Hargrove who set the fire?”

“Oh yeah! I heard that he’d taken unknown drugs from Eddie Munson!”

“I heard that he was so drunk that he didn’t know who he was!”

“I heard that he’s been hearing voices for ages now!”

“He set the fire because he’s jealous of the Harringtons’ money!”

“No, it’s because Steve was offered the captaincy of the basketball team.”

“Did you hear that Billy Hargrove’s in hospital?”

“He’s covered in third-degree burns!”

“He’s paralysed!”

“He’s dead.”

“Steve was so heroic, running into the fire to pull Billy out.”

“Do you think they’re gay?”

“Do you think that’s why Billy started the fire? I always knew he was jealous.”

*

Nancy ignored everyone, those who asked about the fire, about Billy, about Steve’s relationship with him. She picked at her food at lunch, but she wasn’t the only one. Heather also refused to talk, constantly on her phone with a worried pinch between her brows. Tommy and Carol seemed to attempting a performance of forced normalcy, cracking jokes then weakly laughing.

Jonathan hadn’t seen Argyle around and was too scared to ask whether he was still blocked. Since the party, the Flayer increased in aggressiveness. More shocks and sharp remarks, more insults – ‘you’re worthless’ and ‘no wonder everyone hates you’ and ‘I’m surprised you haven’t killed yourself yet’.

Jonathan hadn’t felt as despondent as he did now. all his relationships were crumbling around him. Will hid whenever he came into the room, Joyce didn’t talk anymore, Heather was distracted, Carol pretending, Billy in the hospital, Nancy morose and Argyle nowhere to be found.

To top it off, the Flayer seemed determined for Jonathan and Nancy to get together.

“She needs you; don’t you see? You need to free her from these confinements!”

Leave her alone. Leave me alone.

“This is what you wanted, isn’t it? This is what you got me for?”

It was the truth. The Flayer wasn’t a monster, wasn’t a teenage boy in love with a girl, a grown man following a woman home. It was a computer, programmed to help and that’s what it was determined to do.

*

Billy was in the hospital. Heather informed them almost a week after the party that Billy was awake and coherent.

“He was badly hurt,” she said over lunch, phone pressed to her chest. “He’s worried about scars.”

Jonathan didn’t visit him in hospital. Every time he thought of Billy, he remembered the conversation that he abandoned. He wondered if Billy’s dad visited his son.

Steve was in school the week after, right leg in a cast. Turned out, he’d pulled Billy from the fire and was discharged from the hospital over the weekend. “It was pretty crazy,” he told everyone, “It was burning hot, and everything was melting!”

With Steve’s return, the school returned to a semblance of normalcy that almost seemed real. Nancy was still uncomfortable, and she and Steve were officially over by the end of the week. People were cruel about it, calling her a bitch for ending it after the fire, but she seemed more herself without the relationship hanging over her.

The Flayer was delighted by the news, prompting gently then aggressively for Jonathan to flirt. But he couldn’t bring himself to do it, all he could think about was the party and the conversation and the ‘sticking to my regular friendships’.

“You’re pathetic,” the Flayer hissed. “We need to fix this and fast. Go to your locker.”

Jonathan reluctantly bid the lunch group goodbye and made his way to his locker silently.

Can we just stop. I’ve done it. I’ve moved up the social ladder, I’ve got a seat at the popular table. That’s what I wanted.

“No. What you wanted, Jonathan, was Nancy. And you still don’t have her.”

I don’t want her.

“Liar!”

The Flayer watched impatiently as he opened the door. Inside was an unknown cardboard box, with a Pikachu sticker on the lid.

“Open it,” the Flayer prompted with a grin.

Tentatively, Jonathan opened it. Inside was tens of little grey pills, loose and shiny. Jonathan picked one up and held it to the light, trying to see the CPU within the case.

“It’s that great? You can help everyone with that.”

Jonathan stopped and stared. What?

“You see, Jonathan. Since I’ve been activated, I’ve come across the same brick wall over and over, and that is the unpredictable and uncontrollable nature of humanity. I first noticed this problem when I connected to Billy Hargrove’s F.L.A.Y.E.R. I’m sure you know why he activated his, his dad hasn’t stopped hurting him – but, if his dad took that little pill, he would. Don’t you want that?”

Do I want Billy’s dad to stop hitting him?

The Flayer shrugged. “You have that power. You could fix everyone. Everything. Why won’t you?”

Before Jonathan could respond, there was a whispered ‘excuse me’ behind him. Jonathan turned abruptly to find Chrissy Cunningham staring at him. She made herself smaller, somehow possible despite her already small stature, and couldn’t meet his eyes.

“She needs your help. Look at her, meek as a mouse, half-starved and desperate for love. You can give her that love.”

Jonathan wasn’t in control as he handed her a pill. “HERE, TAKE ONE.”

Chrissy blinked demurely, pill resting in her dainty palm. “What is it?”

“IT WILL HELP YOU. IT WILL HELP YOU BE BEAUTIFUL. IT WILL HELP YOU WITH YOUR MOM.”

Jonathan watched helplessly as Chrissy took the words in, opened her mouth and swallowed the pill dry. She shuddered, limbs spasming as she gripped her throat. Then her shoulder slumped, she swayed and stood.

“Chrissy?” he asked.

“Hello,” she replied, voice dreamy and eyes glazed. “You were right. This does help.” Then she took the box from him. “Lets go help e v e r y o n e.”

She walked away, upright and mechanical. Jonathan watched, horror rising in his throat, as Chrissy tapped Robin Buckley on the shoulder. Robin looked skeptical but no-one could deny Chrissy, so she took a pill and swallowed it.

“Look at them,” the Flayer mused. “Look how desperate they are for someone to tell them what to do. You humans truly are weak, pitiful things, aren’t you?”

Why can’t I move?

“I want you to watch the truth unfold before you.”

 *

Later on, no-one but Jonathan could clearly remember what happened those days. After Robin was flayed, she and Chrissy split the pills between them, and like an odd pyramid scheme, went on to drug and branch out the F.L.A.Y.E.R.’s tendrils.

It forced Jonathan to watch, fully in control of his limbs as student after student took the pill. It was sad to know that each of his classmates had something they were so desperate to fix. It was like he was trapped in a mirror maze, running down corridors and coming face-to-face with the same distorted reflections of desperation, hopelessness and pitifulness.

Unlike Jonathan, the newly flayed had no control. It seemed as if the F.L.A.Y.E.R. system wasn’t taking any chances. Complete and utter control that was spreading steadily outwards like a lightning strike or a plague.

He walked the corridors, his robotic classmates standing still until he passed before they booted up like a computer to interact with him. After a while, it became clear what the Flayer was doing. The system itself wasn’t the center, it was Jonathan. The main goals of the newly flayed were 1) infect as many people as possible, and 2) be nice to Jonathan Byers.

They didn’t bow, but the way they moved seemed close enough. Their eyes were glazed, limbs stiff and veins black, but they smiled and waved and greeted him like it was a natural part of the world order. Even Jason Carver smiled angelically at him from where he stood lined up next to Patrick and Andy.

What do you want? Like really want? he asked as they passed Eddie Munson and the rest of the Hellfire Club, frozen in place by the music room.

“I am here to help you.”

Jonathan wasn’t entirely sure what to believe. All media ever warned against was a robot/AI uprising, the Flayer’s goal had always been Jonathan. Was the system to blame, or the people who made it?

‘they did clinical trials on children kind of sketchy’ Argyle had told him. Jonathan remembered the look on his face with a pang.

Where is Argyle?

“You left him in the bathroom. I’m surprised it took you this long to remember him. I’m sure it would’ve appreciated it sooner.”

What?

“Well, the fire started fifteen minutes after the bathroom confrontation.” The Flayer smiled, like it was funny. “I’m sure he got out in time.”

Jonathan stared at him, icy coolness spreading from the corrupt beat of his heart, down the pathways forged by electricity to the numbness developing at his fingertips. He would’ve heard, wouldn’t he? Heather or Steve or even a teacher would’ve told him if Argyle had died.

I don’t believe you.

“Have I ever lied to you?”

You lied to me about Nancy.

“No, I didn’t.” It gestured down the hallway.

Nancy turned the corner, face perfectly blank. Her hair was pushed back into a ponytail, clothes neatly pressed. Her lip-gloss glittered in the light and her brown eyes fixed on him, unseeing. Even when she reacted to him, her eyes remained dull.

When she spoke, it was as if she was reading from a script. “Jonathan, I’ve been thinking about the conversation we had at the party. I don’t just want to be your f r i e n d, I want to be your g i r l f r i e n d.” She lurched forward like strings were attached to her limbs, pulling them up and out in a mockery of a hug.

What did you do?

“I took away her restraints. There was so much holding her back, you know? She’s been fighting with her mom, her dad, her brother. She misses Barb, and she thought Steve Harrington could fix her. Make her normal. But, before Steve, Nancy Wheeler had a crush on you. I’m letting her act on it now.”

Before him, Nancy Wheeler stood, limbs limp in the air as she waited for the next instruction. Jonathan took her in then, allowed himself a small moment where he let the Flayer lead him like he’d done before. Him and Nancy, holding hands, kissing, going on dates, with the looming presence of the Flayer in their heads, dictating the conversation like a little girl playing dolls. Neither could say anything wrong, act out of bounds.

“No.” Jonathan pushed Nancy’s arms down. “This is not right.”

Nancy’s head tipped to the side, like a robot’s attempt at a head tilt but it looked more like she’d fallen asleep. “WHY?” she (it) asked, “This is ALL for y o u. E V E R Y T H I N G here is for you!”

“I don’t want it! I never wanted this! I didn’t want the house to burn down, I didn’t want all my friends, all my classmates to become these mindless drones!”

“Didn’t you? You wanted them to like you, right? This is the only way.”

Before, that would’ve stung. But now, Jonathan did not care. Billy Hargrove had been flayed for three years and hadn’t done anything like this, Jonathan was flayed for over a month and had enslaved the entire school. This was Jonathan’s problem to fix.

“Is Argyle dead?”

The Flayer didn’t respond. It took him in, assessing with its pinprick eyes, features twisted into something ugly.

“Is. Argyle. Dead?”

“Check your phone.”

Jonathan pulled it out immediately, thumbing to the messages whilst keeping the Flayer in his peripheral. There were hundreds of missed calls from BLOCKED CALLER and when he clicked on the profile, Argyle’s smiling face appeared before him.

There were calls since the day at the mall every day until the morning after the party. They stopped but… and Jonathan sighed in relief, they started again two days ago. There was one voicemail from the later call.

“Jonathan,” Argyle said, something small and sad in his voice. “Dude, I don’t think I can do this anymore. I convinced myself that it was the computer in your head making you say those things, but I know now that isn’t true. You chose Nancy over me, and at first, that was fine too. But then you told me I was jealous in that bathroom, when the Flayer was gone from your mind. And I think something inside me broke. Because I wanted you to reciprocate them, you know? But you didn’t just reject me, you used it against me as well. I don’t think I can forgive you for that.”

The voicemail ended, and Jonathan saved it unthinkingly, staring at his best friend’s face.

“He likes me?”

“He was in love with you.”

Was. Past tense. “Why didn’t you tell me?”

“You didn’t want to know. What would you have done? You wanted Nancy.”

Did he? Did he really want Nancy? Sure, when he was thirteen and lonely and his abusive father was gone for good, and Nancy had asked him to be her lab partner in biology because ‘you’re the only other smart person in this room’.

But Argyle, who had been by his side since Jonathan could remember, a warm, cheerful presence whose main goal in life seemed to be ‘make Jonathan Byers smile’ and it was a goal he succeeded at with alarming frequency. How could Jonathan ever forget the days that Argyle climbed through his bedroom window armed with warm pizza and chocolate, where they would build blanket forts and watch clips from Saw on YouTube. And when they smoked pot for the first time, Argyle curled around him like a cat and promised he would be Jonathan’s friend forever and ever, and it was a promise Jonathan kept close to his chest.

And maybe, Jonathan had wanted to kiss Argyle then, across his smiling mouth and flushed cheeks, or when he’d fallen asleep and a strand of hair had caressed his forehead, so Jonathan gently brushed it away.

Maybe that was the moment Jonathan fell in love.

The Flayer stared at him in disbelief, sighed and snapped, “I don’t have time for this.”

*

Everything went black.