Chapter Text
Chapter 8: Voices in My Head
It was like walking through a dream. Jonathan walked hand in hand with Nancy down the corridor, hands gripped loosely. They walked the same pace, so neither’s slipped from the grip, and they walked and walked.
Behind them, the Flayer trailed looking confused.
“Why aren’t you happy?”
But Jonathan couldn’t reply. His mouth wasn’t working, and his brain was thoughtless. Nancy smiled at him, doll-like.
“I’m h a p p y.”
Jonathan smiled, nodded and tried to pretend.
*
Jonathan could never tell of the F.L.A.Y.E.R. had reached the outside world, or whether it had confined itself to the walls of a tiny high school in Hawkins, Indiana. He didn’t know why it didn’t try and leave, but later on, once it was all over, he told Argyle that his prediction was that more people were harder to control.
Or maybe it liked playing with high-schoolers like dolls.
Because that’s what they were at this point, dolls. Just mechanical wind-up toys left to wander specific routes until it could think of a story to reenact. And throughout it all, it still tried to appeal to Jonathan.
Each elaborate story centered around Jonathan. Apologies from jocks, confessions from girls, entrance music performed by the school band. All for Jonathan.
The Flayer seemed desperate for Jonathan to enjoy himself, checking in periodically for confirmation and wilting when it realised Jonathan wouldn’t respond. But it refused to relinquish its control.
Then one day, it appeared before him looking smug.
“This is going to be our best performance yet,” and it pointed outside. Jonathan’s body moved to let him peer out, just in time to see a human figure slip into the building. “Now,” the Flayer tapped its chin, “who do you suppose that is, Argyle or Billy? Well, it can’t be Billy, he’s still in the hospital. Although,” it peered into Jonathan’s eyes, “we do need to reestablish a connection with him.”
Connection?
The Flayer looked delighted. “So, you can talk again! And yes, reconnect. The connection was severed during the fire.”
Another thing Jonathan realised was that the Flayer was a terrible liar. It glitched whenever it lied.
Severed?
It glared at him. “Yes.”
Jonathan hummed unconvinced, but let the Flayer lead him from the wall. Nancy immediately held out her cool hand for him to take, and they clasped each other uselessly.
They walked down the hall, to the cafeteria where Heather, Carol, Tommy and Steve were waiting. They all sat perfectly still at their usual table, and it wasn’t until Jonathan loomed over them that they started to move.
“Hello Jonathan,” they said in unison before turning and staring at the table again.
Jonathan took his place at the head of the plastic table, Nancy on his left and Heather on his right.
There was silence.
The Flayer looked annoyed, and it snapped its fingers. Steve moved, lurching forward in a weak attempt to be secretive. “Did you hear that Billy burned down my house because he’s in love with me?”
Jonathan smiled. “That’s not surprising at all, I’ve seen the way he looks at you.”
Both Steve and the Flayer looked shocked.
“What?” Steve said, voice cracking with the emotion. His face crinkled and body relaxed as he took it in. “Billy’s in love with me?”
“Yes.”
“What are you doing? Stop that!”
Everything went dark.
*
He woke to something soft brushing his forehead and a calm voice whispering, “I promise I’m coming back, okay?”
*
Everything hurt.
*
There was a sharp electric pain shooting through his body and it forced Jonathan to open his eyes. He blinked, staring at the white ceiling, directly below a flickering artificial light. He sat up and looked around. He was in a classroom, alone.
Something was stuck to his forehead, and he picked at it lightly. A yellow post it note floated to the ground beside him, a familiar scrawl of handwriting in blue ink.
He picked it up and squinted, reading Argyle’s hastily scratched: I’m coming.
Argyle was coming for him. Argyle who Jonathan had treated terribly, who may be in love with Jonathan and who Jonathan may love back.
He tucked the note into his shirt pocket and stood up. He didn’t know why it was so quiet, but he wasn’t going to wait around. Finally, he was in control of his body and he wasn’t going to waste that for a second.
He slipped from the classroom, peering down the empty corridors and started towards the main exit. He didn’t know what Argyle’s plan was, or where he planned to meet him but he couldn’t remain in one place at once.
The back of his head ached and as he walked, Jonathan felt along the bump. The skin didn’t appear broken and there didn’t seem to be any dried blood, so he must’ve hit his head when he fell in the classroom.
It was difficult to truly understand what was happening, and he was sure that some important information was missing, but all Jonathan knew was that he needed the Flayer out his head and he needed that now.
He paused. The Flayer said that the connection between him and Billy had been severed during the fire, but Billy had been frantic and desperate. Asking for red dew.
Oh.
Billy Hargrove tried to kill himself to get the Flayer out.
Jonathan stared at his arms, at the electrocution scars that faded as they reached his wrists and wondered when Billy decided enough was enough. How many scars and insults and failures did he take before he decided fire was the better alternative?
Jonathan sighed and felt for Argyle’s note, wishing desperately tat he was here now.
“Where are you going?” the Flayer asked, materialising beside him.
“Away from you.”
The Flayer rolled its eyes. “You can’t. I’m in your head.”
“We’ll see.”
He walked with determination, ignoring the computer that had taken it upon itself to be as obnoxious as possible. Jonathan sped up, trying not to look like he was trying to outrun the computer in his head but wanting it gone.
“Jonathan!” There was a familiar voice calling to him.
Both he and the Flayer turned to see Argyle sprinting towards them. The Flayer reared back in disgust, but Jonathan was focused on Argyle. Tall, strong Argyle whose face was set in a determined scowl, clutching a bag close to his chest.
“Drink this,” he said, pushing the bag to him. When Jonathan went to peer into hit, Argyle slapped his hand away. “Don’t look, just drink.” He glanced cautiously around, and Jonathan realised that he was looking for the Flayer.
As he tried to unscrew the cap of the bottle without taking it from the bag, the doors from further down the hallway opened with a resounding clang.
“Jonathan? What are you doing?” Nancy was walking towards him, arms opened and welcoming. “Don’t drink that. He wants to get rid of us, of this.”
“And?” He grunted and twisted the cap off, lifting the bottle to drink, “That’s what I want as well.”
He opened his mouth, only for the bottle to be slapped from his hands. The blank face of Steve Harrington stared at him.
“I won’t let you do this, Jonathan.”
Jonathan scowled. “Get the fuck out of my head.”
“No.”
The flayed students advanced, the jocks cornering Argyle who looked concerned and confused, considering that he couldn’t actually see half of the action. Nancy stood before Jonathan, face placid and demure.
Jonathan stood between them, another decision looming.
“Nancy?”
“yes?”
“You love me, right?”
“I do.”
Jonathan picked up the spilt bottle where some dregs still remained. He caught Argyle’s eye and smiled. “I need you to drink this for me.”
She took it unquestioningly and drained the remains before the Flayer could react. It screamed, and then they all did. As Jonathan gripped his head, feeling as if it was splitting open, he could see Argyle shoving his way over.
“Jonathan!” He could hear. “You’re okay! I promise!”
*
There was beeping.
Jonathan groaned and rolled over, burying his face in the pillow. It was warm in the room, a nice warm that made him sleepy.
“I know right, that’s the good shit,” a voice said.
Jonathan blinked blearily and sat up, rubbing the sleep from the corner of his eyes. Billy Hargrove stared at him, amused. He was still in his body cast, and was squinting more that smiling but Jonathan was relieved to see him.
“How long have I been out?”
Billy attempted to shrug, which he got across with his eyebrows. “Yesterday, I think. Came in with practically the entire student body. Is it true that you got rid of the Flayer?”
“How did you know that?”
Billy smiled. It was odd, he seemed to be smiling a lot. “Argyle. He was sent out the room like half an hour ago, so he’ll be back soon.”
“Right,” Jonathan said and laid back down. “Are you okay?”
Billy raised an eyebrow. “Me? Fine. Better than I should be, honestly, considering that I tried to burn myself alive.”
“That must’ve been scary.”
“How so?”
“You had that thing in your head for three years and no one else knew. Argyle knew about me, and that’s how I’m here, without a computer in my brain.”
“I was determined to keep it. I thought it could fix my problems.”
Jonathan smiled sadly. “Yeah. I have something to tell you.”
“The thing about your dad wasn’t entirely true?”
Jonathan blinked. “How did you know?”
Billy rolled his eyes. “Like I said before, I’ve been here for ages. I was in middle school with you!”
“Right.”
The door opened then, and Argyle crept in until he locked eyes with Jonathan’s definitely awake gaze.
“Jonathan!” He practically crawled across the bed and gathered Jonathan in his arms. “You’re okay!”
“I am. I am.” Jonathan was laughing and crying and hugging Argyle back, so full of gratitude and love that he felt like he could explode.
More people came in, Steve and Heather and Carol and Nancy. Steve sat at the edge of Billy’s bed and they stared into each other’s eyes, whilst Heather and Carol crowded around him like two tittering mother hen’s.
Nancy stood at the foot of the bed, jumping from foot-to-foot awkwardly.
“Are you okay?” he asked.
Out of all of them, she was probably struggling the most. Not only was she possessed and controlled, but she was forced into a role she was explicitly clear she didn’t want. Jonathan Byers’ girlfriend – her starring role.
“I –” she stammered. “I don’t think…”
“I don’t have a crush on you anymore, if that helps?”
“It was terrifying,” she replied bluntly, “being your girlfriend. That thing in my brain spent the entire time trying to convince me that I was in love with you. I’m not.”
“I know.”
“I will never be.”
“I know.”
She nodded jerkily and made to leave but Jonathan reached out from where he was pressed tight against Argyle’s chest. “You can stay. I think you need a friend as well.”
“Thank you,” she said quietly and sat down next to Heather.
*
When Will and Joyce visited, Jonathan burst into tears immediately. Other than his treatment of Argyle, the thing that Jonathan regretted the most was the way he treated Will and Joyce.
“I’m sorry,” he repeated into Will’s hair. “I’m so sorry.”
Beside him, his mom stroked his hands as he cried, and he could hear her apologies as well. An apology for being distant, for being crazy, for being uncaring and too caring at the same time, for the paranoia and the fear and everything else she did.
“I forgive you,” he told her.
“I forgive you,” Will told him.
*
When he’s discharged from hospital, he doesn’t want to return to school. Although the official statement was a mass roofying, the general consensus was that Jonathan had something to do with it, whether he supplied the drugs or was targeting a specific person, was anybody’s game.
Argyle was around him constantly. Things were still slightly awkward between them at times, when Jonathan would laugh at inside jokes made by Heather or Tommy that Argyle didn’t understand, or when Jonathan leaned against him, Argyle would sometimes flinch away.
But they were getting better. Argyle dragged them to take new photo-booth photos, refusing to explain what happened to the old ones.
“We just need these now, okay?” Who was Jonathan to deny him that?
Billy was still in hospital, but he and Steve seemed to be hurtling towards a relationship at alarming and oblivious speeds. Turned out that Chief Hopper arrested his dad after he was aggressive to hospital staff (after suggesting that they let his son die ‘to save him the trouble’) so that seemed to be getting sorted.
Nancy and Barb were closer than ever after Barn transferred to Hawkins high. If Nancy had a crush on Steve, Jonathan couldn’t even fathom the scope of love she had for Barb.
And for him, and Argyle?
Sometimes, it was too quiet in his mind. It was ominous and tense and one night when Jonathan couldn’t sleep, he laid awake, staring at the starless ceiling. Beside him, Argyle was wrapped around him like an octopus.
“Hey, Argyle?”
“Yeah?”
“Would you like to go to the beach with me?”
“As a date?”
“Yeah.”
“I would like that.”
Jonathan smiled, pressing his fingers to his forehead to stave away the headache. From the corner of his eye, he could see the smiling face of Mick Jones, but when he turned, he realised it was just the poster on his wall.
“Thank you, for helping me.”
“Of course,” Argyle said, pressing a kiss to his shoulder. “I would do it again.”
Jonathan turned to the ceiling and smiled, right in the center was a small glow-in-the-dark star that Argyle had pressed there five years ago.
