Actions

Work Header

there are voices in my head (the loudest one is mine)

Chapter 7: the argyle interlude

Chapter Text

Chapter 7: The Argyle Interlude

Argyle first fell in love with Jonathan when he was twelve years old. They were lying on Jonathan’s bed, blanket fort bending around them, weight bearing on unstable pillars. Jonathan had fairy-lights that he usually kept hidden under his bed, but he’d strung them up because Argyle said that he missed the stars.

“When you’re on the beach after sunset, the stars seem so bright,” he had said sadly. They moved to Hawkins two years before, and Argyle hadn’t been to the beach since.

“Here,” Jonathan showed him two weeks after, “I got these for you.”

It wasn’t that he’d put the lights up, despite Lonnie Byers insistence that anything Jonathan did was gay, but that he’d attempted to form constellations.

As he stared at them, Argyle’s pinkie hooked around Jonathan’s, and he made a promise to himself.

I promise to never let Jonathan Byers be lonely ever again.

*

When Jonathan told him about Nancy Wheeler, and about how smart and pretty she was, Argyle had swallowed the bitterness rising in his throat and agreed to help. He sat by and helped Jonathan write letter after letter of confessions that inevitably ended up in the trash. He willingly held Jonathan’s camera bag as his friend snapped pictures of the object of his affection. And in private, he smoked weed and lamented to his other friend, Billy.

*

Nancy haunted Argyle whenever he spoke to Jonathan. She was a looming presence or a ticking clock over his relationship with Jonathan, because as much as he tried to deny it, he wouldn’t be surprised if Nancy liked Jonathan back.

Jonathan Byers was odd, but in a charming, quirky way that made some his strange qualities more endearing than anything. Argyle could spend hours listening to Jonathan rant about different lenses and photo manipulation, or listening to The Clash even if he didn’t really like them.

Jonathan was odd and weird and creepy, and Argyle’s and he wouldn’t have it any other way,

*

Billy came back from California and befriended Steve Harrington.

Argyle pretended it didn’t hurt.

*

Then they were fifteen and Argyle’s feelings went from soft to warm. He made him sick at times, thinking like Jonathan the way he did. But he couldn’t help it – he was a teenage boy and the object of his affections often slept in the same bed as him. He couldn’t help what that did to him.

Jonathan only noticed once, and turned bright red, hurriedly leaving the room. Argyle remained frozen, half upright in bed, hands clenching the sheet around his waist tight. It had been Jonathan who suggested that they slept separately for the next sleepovers.

(argyle heard jonathan once in the shower. the sounds kept him up at night still.)

*

Eddie Munson was the main supplier and had a knowing glint in his eye whenever he saw Argyle.

“I have the perfect strand for you!” he would declare. “You are not the only man in a predicament like yours.”

He gave Argyle discounts if he looked particularly morose and sometimes offered a sympathetic ear. His crush on Chrissy Cunningham was an open secret in the halls of Hawkins high.

*

The first time Argyle and Jonathan got high together, Argyle was filled with such love and warmth that he’d almost kissed Jonathan after the first hit. It was, quite frankly, embarrassing how desperate weed made him.

Jonathan, shrouded in mysterious smoke, looking at him beneath his eyelashes, asking, ‘do you want another hit?’

‘do you want to shotgun?’ Argyle asked instead. ‘I can show you how.’

Jonathan nodded then, and curled towards him, lips parted and eyes curious. But before they leaned closer, Argyle pulled back. Knowing that would be the only way to have Jonathan would be tempting but taunting. He couldn’t bare knowing what Jonathan’s lips felt like near his without having the entire experience.

*

Will was missing and Argyle worried a piece of Jonathan was as well.

Will came back but Jonathan never seemed fully complete again.

*

Joyce Byers was the loveliest woman you could ever meet, but sometimes Argyle wanted to shake her.

‘Stop looking in the shadows.’ He wanted to shout. ‘Your sons are here, at home, and they need you to take care of them. You’re the adult. Act like it.’

*

Jonathan decided that junior year was going to be his year, and Argyle trailed behind him like always. He was happy to see Jonathan’s energy return, gaining momentum every day. He wasn’t entirely sure what ‘his year’ entailed but he was going to support Jonathan the entire time.

“I’m going to climb the social ladder,” Jonathan declared, “and I’m going to finally ask Nancy out.”

“Cool. I’ll help,” Argyle responded, even though he could feel parts of him break.

*

Jonathan’s first attempts were pathetic, even by Argyle’s standards. He’d written another confession to Nancy and torn it up immediately afterwards.

“Nancy’s nice,” Argyle said, “You could start by talking to her.”

But Jonathan remained resolute that he had to do it properly. He had to romance her, woo her, like she deserved. Argyle was of the opinion that what Nancy deserved was someone to treat her normally, but he didn’t think Jonathan would appreciate that.

*

“Billy Hargrove cornered me in the bathroom to sell me drugs." That’s what Jonathan told him after Argyle raced over to his house because of a flurry of panicked messages.

“What?”

That wasn’t what he expected. It might’ve seemed odd, that Argyle didn’t sign up for debate as well, but after an obnoxiously long internal debate, he realised that this was something that Jonathan would have to do alone.

What he didn’t expect was Billy Hargrove to offer Jonathan drugs. Not just any drugs, a sketchy sounding quantum-computer called the F.L.A.Y.E.R. that may explain Billy’s major personality switch two years ago.

His first instinct was to deny, tell Jonathan to forget it and work on himself for himself. It may have been the weed talking, but if Jonathan was destined to climb the social ladder, then he should do it as himself. Because if they take Jonathan as anything other than himself, then they don’t deserve him.

But then Joyce walked in, and Jonathan went red and humiliated. Argyle couldn’t take his friend’s hope away like that.

"Will you come with me?"

"Of course."

*

It was definitely a scam. Argyle watched as Jonathan stuffed six hundred dollars’ worth of cash in his pockets and swallowed the urge to scream. He’d been doing some research on the F.L.A.Y.E.R. in the week leading up to the event, and although there was scarcely anything, what he did find did not put his mind at ease.

Keith wasn’t impressed by them, probably disappointed they weren’t girls, but handed over the pill for four hundred anyway. Whilst Jonathan was admiring the pill, Argyle listened intently to all the information Keith was giving out.

“To activate it, you have to take it with green mountain dew, and to deac – h-hi Eden."

Argyle kept the idea of deactivation at the back of his mind as he watched Jonathan swallow the pill. Nothing happened and Argyle grew angry.

“I’ll go and get your money back from Keith,” he said, walking away.

He would regret that for the longest time, leaving. Keith was still talking to the goth girl – Eden, when Argyle stalked in.

“Woah didn’t expect to see you. You want one as well?”

Argyle stalked closer, leaned across the counter and pulled Keith down by his shirt collar. “I want the money back. Your shit doesn’t work.”

“Look, Argyle, I can’t just give –”

“Keith, if you don’t fucking give me the money, I’ll tell your boss you’re selling drugs behind the counter of a family friendly store.”

Keith growled. “I’m not giving you all of it. You get two hundred or nothing.” He slammed it on the counter.

Argyle would’ve fought more, but that’s when the screaming started.

*

Shaken from what he witnessed; he hadn’t expected to meet Nancy Wheeler outside the food court after hauling Jonathan off the floor.

“Is he okay?” she asked.

“I think so,” he said and scrubbed a hand down his face. “I don’t know what happened.” Although that wasn’t entirely true. He hoped the pill wasn’t dangerous unactive.

Nancy and Steve left minutes later, more on Steve’s insistence than anything, so Argyle gathered the cheap mall food to take back to Jonathan. Only to find the bathroom empty when he got back.

you: jon where are you?

you: jon seriously

you: you’re scaring me

you: im waiting in the van

you: jon?

missed call

BROmio: went home

*

 Argyle wasn’t sure what happened at the mall, but Jonathan was upset. He was sitting upright in math, and when Argyle tried to talk to him, Jonathan blanked him completely.

“I’m sorry I left you,” Argyle whispered between questions, trying to catch Jonathan’s eye. “I shouldn’t have left you like that and I’m sorry.”

Jonathan ignored. Argyle sighed and turned back to his work, resolving to talk to Jonathan again in a few hours.

*

Jonathan started eating with Heather Holloway and the rest of the group at lunch. Argyle picked forlornly at his cafeteria food as he watched Jonathan laugh at something Tommy Hagan said.

“I don’t know how he did it,” Eddie Munson said, sitting down next to him. “It’s kind of inspiring.”

*

After school, Argyle got a text message from Eddie asking to meet by the gym locker room. He sighed and made his way over, not caring what it was about but desperate for some semblance of a normal relationship.

But when he turned the corner, it wasn’t Eddie who greeted him but Jonathan.

“Holy shit, are you okay?”

Argyle stared at him, and responded bluntly, “What the fuck is wrong with you?”

Turned out the F.L.A.Y.E.R. was what was wrong with him. Argyle wasn’t as excited as he thought he’d be, but he tried not to show it. Jonathan seemed attached to the CPU, so Argyle wanted to be happy about it. It did seem to be working.

Then…

“I choose Nancy.”

And just like that, the Jonathan Argyle knew was gone, replaced by an unseeing, blank-faced clone. And when Jonathan Byers walked away, he took pieces of Argyle’s heart with him.

*

Argyle called him every day. Even after Jonathan blocked him. He left voicemails, text messages and even messaged him on his secret Tumblr account, but Jonathan had him blocked on that as well. After a while, Argyle’s voicemails were recounts of his day so he could hear Jonathan greeting him, and pretended it was normal.

*

Argyle was giving himself one more chance before he would let Jonathan go (until he could find mountain dew red – the deactivation key).

Harrington’s parties were always open invitation, so it didn’t matter that Argyle hadn’t been officially invited. He didn’t try very hard with his costume, just enough to get him through the door. As he stepped through, he was overwhelmed instantly.

He could see Munson with a bong in the corner, Harrington flitting from guest to guest and Hargrove stumbling around, already blackout drunk.

Instead of sticking around and looking for Jonathan like he originally planned, Argyle fled to the bathroom. It wasn’t as big as expected, and he sat in the bathtub to regain his breath.

He wasn’t alone for long. Jonathan himself came in, red-rimmed eyes and shaking hands, and Argyle watched in trepidation as Jonathan sinks to the ground and sighs.

“You’re just jealous!” Is what Jonathan told, and Argyle felt himself freeze.

Because he was, insanely so. He hated how much energy Jonathan was exerting on Nancy, wishing desperately that it was directed at him. He was jealous of how much Jonathan liked Nancy’s hair, her eyes, her hands. He was stupidly jealous, but he was also so sad as he witnessed the boy he loved spiral into something unrecognisable.

“You need to leave. This is pathetic. You’re weak and scared and so lonely that you’re crawling on your knees, begging for me to acknowledge you.” Then he leaves Argyle in the bathroom by himself.

*

When the house lit up in flames, Argyle wanted to burn to ash with it.

*

He lived anyway.

*

“Jonathan. Dude, I don’t think I can do this anymore. I convinced myself that it was the computer in your head making you say those things, but I know now that isn’t true. You chose Nancy over me, and at first, that was fine too. But then you told me I was jealous in that bathroom, when the Flayer was gone from your mind. And I think something inside me broke. Because I wanted you to reciprocate them, you know? But you didn’t just reject me, you used it against me as well. I don’t think I can forgive you for that.”

*

He went home to burn all his memories, and that’s how Joyce Byers found him. Teary-eyed and burning photo-booth pictures.

*

“I haven’t been a great mom these past months,” Joyce said. "I’ve let Jonathan down and I know this might be a lot to ask of you, given the circumstances, but I need your help. He needs your help.”

“Why?”

“There’s something wrong with the school. And I think Jonathan’s at the center of it.”

*

Before he went to Jonathan, Argyle went to Billy.

The other boy was covered head to toe in a white body cast, but he grinned brightly when Argyle walked in.

“Oh, hey! Didn’t know you were coming?”

“Why did you burn the house down,” Argyle asked.

Billy stared at him, assessing him. “I needed to get it out.”

“The F.L.A.Y.E.R.?”

“No one had any mountain dew red.”

“What does that do?”

Billy smiled. “It deactivates it.”