Chapter Text
By the time mid-December rolls around, Bilbo has been to the design workshop eight times. No one else ever comes; it’s always him and Thorin. Him and Thorin and the stale smell of alcohol, him and Thorin and music playing as the sun rises. They still haven’t quite figured out how to talk to each other. Bilbo thinks it is, perhaps, better that way.
Thorin has taught him about groundplans and elevations, about foam-core models and the many uses of balsa wood. They’ve tossed around theories and Bilbo’s learned how to spot an Eames chair, a house in Le Corbusier’s style, while Thorin sketches Norman arches and grumbles about limestone. Today he has his hair tied back; one of the braids that trail from his temples has escaped and swings down along his face as he slides his T-square across the drafting table. Bilbo looks up from his book on modernist architecture—Thorin dug it up from one of the studio’s reference shelves and thrust it at Bilbo, right at his chest, winding him, because of course Thorin, restorer of castles, disapproves of modernist architecture—and he watches, feeling intrusive, unable to look away. It’s cold in the studio, cold enough that Bilbo is glad for his wool socks and boots, yet Thorin is in shirtsleeves.
Technically, the university is closed for winter break. For most students this is a Saturday for sleeping in, packing up, going back to their parents for the holidays. In one week and three days, it will be Christmas. Bilbo was looking at his calendar the other day, thinking about how he would be able to get a ride back home, when the thought hit him. This is his home now. There isn’t anywhere else. Someone else will have Christmas in his parents’ house. Will wind their garlands through the hand-carved banister, will stand their tree under the highest point of the roof in the reading room, will hang their stockings on the wide slate mantel and greet carolers at the green door.
He hasn’t heard from Gandalf since October. Doesn’t know where the old man is or what he’s up to, which library archives he’s terrorising now with his obscure requests. He could be in another country, halfway around the world, or he could turn up on the doorstep tomorrow. Bilbo has a couple of cousins, somewhere. He has names and addresses, but Christmas is a time for families, and family is more than just names on an ancestral tree. It wouldn’t feel right to spend the holiday with them. Which leaves him here, with his attic and his books and the persistent, damp snow. At least, he thinks to himself, if he bakes a pie, he can eat the entire thing.
Thorin has Billy Bragg on the stereo because Bilbo had vetoed The Rolling Stones in the early morning hour. They compromised, with a classic rock guitarist but an album that’s an odd one with dry, slow-picked guitar and vocal harmonies, more lazy drums than driving beats. “He’s playing with Wilco and Natalie Merchant,” Thorin said, as if that was supposed to mean something to Bilbo. “Using Woody Guthrie’s lyrics,” he added, and that did mean something to Bilbo, something more than a name he had heard before. With the sun up and the music loud, Thorin’s booted foot tapping against the leg of his drafting table, Bilbo can look out the studio windows at the glistening streets and pretend that he is where he wants to be.
I’d like to rest my heavy head tonight
on a bed of California stars.
I’d like to lay my weary bones tonight
on a bed of California stars.
I’d love to feel your hand touching mine,
and tell me why I must keep working on,
yes, I give my life to lay my head tonight
on a bed of California stars.
“It’s Saturday,” Thorin says, after the next few songs.
“Yes?”
“Why are you still here?”
“Is it . . . not all right?”
“You’re not going away for the break?”
“No, I’m not.”
“Hmm.” Thorin flips a page in his reference book and hums a few bars of music. “Neither am I,” he says.
“I can leave, if I’m bothering you.”
“No. You’re not. Have to educate you, anyway.”
“Oh, you’re teaching me right now?” Bilbo asks, in a complete lapse from all tact. He contemplates putting his hand over his mouth before he says any more, but Thorin just turns and gives him an exasperated look over his shoulder, one braid trailing.
“The music, space cadet. Not the research. I figured you had enough practice with that. Could handle it on your own.”
“Not a space cadet,” Bilbo mumbles, and tucks his chin into his chest to break the gaze, thinking that will be the end of it.
“What’s your favourite Guthrie song?” Thorin asks then, turning back to his own project. “Don’t tell me you don’t have one.”
Bilbo thinks about it for a minute, idly running a finger along the spine of his book. Not talking is seeming easier and easier. Burying himself in the dusty pages—ironic, since it’s a relatively new book on modern architecture. “Thorin,” he says slowly, “Guthrie has hundreds and hundreds of songs.”
“One of your top ten, then.”
That’s a thing Thorin tends to do, Bilbo’s started to notice: ask questions as statements. As though he’s positive he’ll get an answer. It still takes Bilbo a minute, or maybe more, to find one. “I’ve always liked ‘Pastures of Plenty,’ ” he says. “I know it’s not obscure, and you were testing me . . . I could name you others. Just to prove it. But that one, probably, is one of my favourites.”
“It wasn’t a test.”
“Oh.”
“Of course it wasn’t,” Thorin says, and just that one line is enough to make Bilbo shrink back, hunch his shoulders, look down at his book. “But that’s a good song,” Thorin adds, his voice a bit rough. “I know what it’s like to want a—that is, it’s a good song.”
“Thanks for your approval,” Bilbo says, which earns him another exasperated look, though this one has something like fondness in it.
“Sarcasm,” Thorin says. “That’s good. You’re too agreeable.”
“I’m really not.”
“Keep it up. All right. I’m starting to figure you out, I think. If you like Guthrie, you’ll like Johnny Cash. Tell me you know him. I’ll lose all faith if you don’t.”
“Faith in what, me or your guessing abilities? And yes, I do like Johnny Cash. My father”—and his voice doesn’t hitch, but only barely—“liked him. Used to play his music as he worked.”
“Good. Faith in my abilities. Same question: favourite song.”
“You first,” Bilbo says. “It’s only fair.”
“ ‘Sunday Morning Coming Down,’ ” Thorin answers, quick, like he doesn’t even have to think about it.
“I should have guessed.”
“Well, tell me yours.”
“I think I would say, ‘I Hung My Head,’ if I had to choose.”
“Hmph.”
“Hmph? What does hmph mean?”
“It means I should have guessed. Just as you said. Should have guessed you’d pick a song like that.”
“What’s wrong with it? ‘Sunday Morning’ is about being drunk and unwashed and lonely. I should think that has more to criticise than ‘I Hung My Head.’ ”
“ ‘I beg their forgiveness, I wish I was dead?’ ” Thorin quotes. “It’s all about shame. Apologies. Ergo, weakness.”
“It’s not about that at all.”
“No?”
“It’s about . . . not knowing what to do.”
“Weakness.”
“Oh, and a song that says, ‘The beer I had for breakfast wasn’t bad so I had one more for dessert’ is advocating strength, is that it?”
“Shut up.”
“Is that your motto, then?”
“I said, shut up!” Thorin crosses the room in three quick strides and fists his hands in Bilbo’s sweater, his breath hot and close. Bilbo tries to back away but can’t. His hands are useless at his side. He closes his eyes so he doesn’t have to see the look on Thorin’s face. “Don’t talk about things you don’t understand,” Thorin is saying, which is just stupid, because isn’t that what they’re here to do, in the workshop, in graduate school in general? To talk about what they don’t understand, and, one hopes, figure it out by talking about it? That’s the whole premise of a seminar, after all.
Bilbo wants to come up with a retort, wants to be properly angry, thinks it might do him good. But Thorin is taller and has a good twenty pounds on him and Bilbo is afraid. He doesn’t open his eyes.
“It’s none of your business. Do you hear me?” Thorin shakes Bilbo, his elbows sharp in Bilbo’s gut, hunched over the smaller man. “None.”
Billy Bragg plays on, unperturbed.
I don't know what I'll do,
I don't know what I'll do,
Eisler’s on the come and go and
I don't know what I'll do.
Thorin relaxes his grip, slowly. Bilbo feels himself set back down on his stool. When loud footsteps move away from him he judges it safe to look. Thorin is standing at the windows looking down towards the lake, his shoulders heaving, his feet planted wide, one hand splayed up against the glass. The guitar is slow and surreal in the background. Bilbo’s legs are shaking too much to leave so he sits there, trying to figure out how everything went wrong so quickly when all they were doing was educating themselves.
The workshop hours pass and still Bilbo does not move and still Thorin stares out at the lake. They are, each of them, it seems, pretending that none of this has happened. Snow falls thick and wet, dirtying the windows. The music has turned jaunty and it isn’t helping. Once in a while a car passes below but for the most part they are alone.
“I’m going to Toronto on Monday,” Thorin says after what feels like hours. Bilbo doesn’t know how he’s expected to respond, so he says nothing. “Architecture conference,” Thorin adds, speaking to the window. “The whole week.”
“That’s . . . good?” Bilbo ventures. He flexes a foot, testing. If he needs to, he thinks he could run away now. He eyes the door, making certain that his path is clear.
“It is,” Thorin breathes, fogging up the glass. “Good for my career. There will be some people there to talk to.”
“Are you, um, presenting?”
“I’m part of a seminar.” Thorin finally pushes away from the window and turns to Bilbo. He keeps his distance, and his hands are in his pockets. He looks, Bilbo thinks, suddenly much younger.
“Well, then. Have a good, er, trip. I suppose.”
“I need you to watch my dog.”
There is silence then, as one song ends and another doesn’t begin.
“What?”
“I can’t take him with me. And he likes you.”
“He knocked me into the lake, Thorin. I don’t think that qualifies as liking.”
“For Erebor, it does.”
Bilbo wants to ask if the dog’s behavioural code applies to Thorin as well, if shaking him bodily connotes liking, but he doesn’t. Instead, he is practical. He is on the defensive and he knows it when he says, “I’m sure you can find someone else.”
“No. There isn’t anyone else.”
“What about that professor you rent from?”
“Gone on sabbatical.”
“What about your friends?”
“I don’t exactly have . . . friends,” Thorin says. “At least, they wouldn’t call themselves that. It’s more of an obligation thing. Duty. Look, damn it, Bilbo, that’s not important. Will you just watch the dog?”
“If they’re obligated to you, wouldn’t they watch him?”
“Half of them aren’t even on this side of the country. You won’t watch him. Fine. I’ll figure something else out.”
“You mean you won’t go to the conference,” Bilbo says, because he’s nothing if not perceptive. Doesn’t always know what to say—in fact, rarely knows what to say—but can see that there is something that should be said, which has to count for something.
Thorin doesn’t deny it. He’s packing up his desk and scowling. The album’s run out and the speakers are humming with faint static.
“Thorin, you can’t just not go.”
“It doesn’t matter.”
“It’s your career.”
“And Erebor is my dog.”
“The two are equal?”
“Of course not. Erebor’s much more important.”
“. . . Did you just make a joke?”
“If I have to qualify, then it wasn’t a good one.” He sighs and tugs his hair free from its tie. It spills over his shoulders, massively tangled. It should look, Bilbo thinks, quite stupid. How it manages not to is an impressive mystery. “It’s only a week.”
“Your dog could eat me.”
“He won’t.”
“But he could, which is the more worrying thing here.”
“You would be doing me a great favour,” Thorin says, very slowly. He looks Bilbo in the eye and at least has the decency to be a bit shamefaced.
Bilbo opens his mouth to say, “No,” except, “Yes,” comes out instead. “Yes, all right. I’ll watch your dog.”
“Good,” Thorin says. Bilbo’s starting to believe that “good” means “thank you” in Thorin’s vocabulary, or something close to it. “I’ll bring him over to your place tomorrow night.”
“Wait, no, no, that’s not—Thorin, that won’t work. I live in an attic.”
“It’s just the one week, Erebor will be fine. Take him to the park or something.”
“He’d go crazy. And even if he didn’t, I’m not allowed pets.”
“Sneak him in.”
“Your dog is bigger than I am. There is no way I could sneak him in.”
“We’ll do it at night, with a blanket—”
“Yes, and then what happens when you leave and I take him to the park? Which would be the cemetery, by the way, and I don’t know that he would really enjoy it.”
“He would. Erebor appreciates history.”
“Thorin, no.”
“Then we’re back to where we started. Me, not going.”
“I swear, you are the most—we’re not back to where we started. Not necessarily,” Bilbo says, even though the rational part of his brain is telling him that really, he’s been perfectly helpful, and he should just stop talking now.
“How so?”
“If you’re going to Toronto, I could . . . watch Erebor at your place. I mean, it would be easier, right?”
“You’d stay in my apartment.”
“Yes?”
“For a week, with my dog.”
“It was just an idea. No need to get all upset about it.”
“It’s just—I’m not really—no. No, it will work. It will. Monday, then. I’ll drive you up, sometime in the afternoon.”
“All right.”
“Good.” Thorin looks Bilbo over, head to toe. He’s done it before but it doesn’t get any less unnerving by being repeated. Then he’s gone, his bag hauled over his shoulder and his portfolio in his hand, leaving Bilbo to turn off the sound system and the lights, lock the door. As if he’s the one responsible for this space.
Walking home, his hat pulled low and his shoulders hunched against the snow, Bilbo thinks that they are, apparently, trusting each other now. It’s more than he had hoped for. If all it took was agreeing to spend a week with Thorin’s dog, he would have done it sooner.
What he doesn’t think about is the fact that it’s a week with Thorin’s dog, in Thorin’s apartment, alone. If he did think about that, he’d intimidate himself right out of going.
Monday, late afternoon, Bilbo fidgets with the strap on his satchel in the parking lot next to Milstein. His duffel is at his feet, probably over-packed. It isn’t as if he’s going to be going anywhere or seeing anyone for the next week. He doesn’t need to have five sweaters with him. Thorin rumbles up to the curb in his rusted Volvo before Bilbo can turn around, though, and then Thorin is tossing his duffel in the trunk and they are very close, inside the warmth of the car. The windows are a little fogged and it smells as if Thorin’s been smoking again.
“Look, I should tell you—” Thorin breaks off, drumming his fingers against the steering wheel as they idle at a red light. Bilbo doesn’t recognise the band playing on the car’s stereo, can’t tell if the music is gritty or if the speakers are just junk. It’s only the fourth time he’s been in the car. Once more, he thinks, and he’ll have it figured out. He doesn’t prompt Thorin to continue. They drive on, through the intersection and up along the lake.
“I went grocery shopping,” Thorin says, which is almost definitely not what he was going to say earlier. “Since you don’t have a car, you know, and I’ll be gone. There’s plenty of food.”
“Thank you.” Bilbo is surprised. He shouldn’t be, not really. Thorin’s been considerate before, in his own way. Still, he was half expecting to live off of toast for a week. Provided that Thorin had any bread in his refrigerator, and not just an elaborate collection of beer. He didn’t have bread last time Bilbo was over.
Thorin nods, and soon enough they’re pulling into his steep driveway. Bilbo hears Erebor’s deep bark as they pull up, distracted enough that he lets Thorin guide him into the garage apartment with a hand on his back. The hand drops once they’re inside. That has more to do with the fact that the dog has tackled Thorin, paws on his shoulders, and knocked him back against the wall, than any reluctance on Bilbo’s part. That alone is odd enough that it takes him a second to process, once again, that this is the dog he’s agreed to watch for a week.
“Down, dog,” Thorin says, but he’s laughing in a way he rarely does on campus, rubbing Erebor’s head and grinning at Bilbo. It only lasts a second, but it’s there. Then Thorin is clearing his throat and pushing Erebor down. “I’d say, come on in, I’ll give you the tour, but then, there’s not much to see.”
There isn’t. There’s a narrow mudroom in the front of the garage, on one side the wide double doors. A couple of pairs of boots and some jackets on pegs—after a glance to Thorin, Bilbo adds his own to the pile—a snow shovel and a trash bin. Through the other side is the apartment itself. It’s all one room, like Bilbo’s, but feels larger. Higher ceilings and proper windows. The right side is a kitchen, a table right out of the 1950s, a farmhouse-style sink, a refrigerator. The back wall is split by a door to the deck and the yard beyond. The left side of the garage has a bookshelf built in along the whole length of the wall, a window cut into its center. There’s an old television in the corner and a short, curved couch. A scarred wooden table with a light clamped to it, a high-backed chair, sheaves of papers and a couple of tubes of blueprints. A ladder to the side of the couch leads up to the sleeping loft.
Bilbo looks around, hands in his pockets, as Erebor’s tail thwacks him from behind. The poured concrete floor is cold beneath his socks. He can feel Thorin watching him and his shoulders tense. It takes a moment to school his expression into something like a smile, as if this is easy for him. He has his glasses on, his eyes too tired, and he pushes them up to rub the bridge of his nose.
“I should get on the road,” Thorin says. That’s good. It means they won’t continue to stand here uncomfortably.
“Right,” Bilbo says, expecting Thorin to turn and walk out. Instead, the man brings a hand to the back of his neck and clears his throat, then crosses his arms over his chest. Regards Bilbo as if he’s done something wrong. Bilbo shrinks back a bit and nearly trips over the dog.
Thorin clears his throat again and uncrosses his arms. He looks down at his dog, then back to Bilbo. “I’ll be back on Sunday. You might as well—it’s not as if I’m going to be here, so—no one will be using it. You know.” He waves a hand in the direction of the sleeping loft and doesn’t look Bilbo in the eye.
“What on earth are you talking about?” Bilbo finally asks, when the silence wears on and his shoulders are tense enough to hurt.
“My bed. The bed. You should, uh, just sleep there.”
“What?”
“I don’t exactly have a guest room, Bilbo. The sheets are clean, if that’s what you’re worried about. I washed them.”
“Then they’ll be clean for you when you get back. No, Thorin, I’m not taking your bed.”
“You’re not sleeping on the floor for a week. Take the bed.”
“You have a couch.”
“The couch is too short.”
“I’m short,” Bilbo says, which earns him a look from Thorin, a specific kind of look he’s been getting lately and doesn’t know how to process. He breaks it off, very deliberately, and flops on the couch, puts his feet up and clasps his hands behind his head, stretching his shoulders. Casual. As if he does this all the time. As if his heart isn’t pounding. “See? I fit.”
“Just take the bed, damn it. It’s not a big deal.”
“Thank you, but no. This is fine.” Bilbo raises his eyebrows at Thorin in a challenge. He doesn’t expect it to work.
Thorin mutters something about “stubborn half-pints” and stomps out the door. He doesn’t close it behind him and Bilbo can hear him rummaging in his car. A cold draft works its way in around Bilbo’s ankles where the cuffs of his pants are rolled and his socks don’t quite reach. A moment later something hits him in the face with a soft thud. An old Army-issue sleeping bag. “It gets cold down here,” Thorin says, as if he hasn’t just thrown something at Bilbo’s head. “At least take this.”
“Did you wash this too?”
“. . . No.”
“I’m only joking. Really. Thank you.” The sleeping bag is soft and smells of Thorin’s car. Olive green and weather-stained. A comfortable lump in his arms.
“Right. Yes. I have to get on the road,” Thorin says, but doesn’t move.
“Long drive.”
“Four hours. Less if I speed.”
“Don’t speed. Go, Thorin. We’re good. Aren’t we, Ere?”
The dog barks helpfully and Thorin sighs. “Call me. If you need anything. If anything happens. I mean, I’ll be in conference so . . . you’ll have to leave a message, but I’ll check every day.”
“Your apartment has a phoneline?” Bilbo asks, and looks around. He hadn’t noticed one.
“What? No. No one has landlines anymore. What year do you think it is?”
“Thorin, I don’t have a cell-phone. How do you expect me to be calling you?”
“What?”
“Never really needed one,” Bilbo says with a shrug. “It doesn’t matter. I won’t need to call.”
“Yes, it does matter.”
“Are you doubting my ability to care for your overly large dog?”
“Ere’s not overly large, he’s . . . If you think I’m leaving you here with my dog for a week with no way of getting ahold of you, you’re out of your mind.”
“There’s always e-mail.”
“Not good enough.”
“I don’t think you have a choice, honestly. At this point, you’re committed to the conference. And you can’t take him with you.”
“He’s well-behaved,” Thorin says, as if that’s a reasonable answer, as if Ere can simply roam about Toronto while Thorin sits on panels and goes to fancy cocktail parties. The thought of Thorin in a neatly pressed suit, sipping champagne and scowling, crosses Bilbo’s mind and he has to hold back a laugh. He doesn’t know where it came from.
“Thorin. I promise I will look after your dog. You really should get on the road.”
“Get in the car.”
“Sorry? What do you mean? I’m not coming with you.”
“We’re getting you a phone. Let’s go.”
“You’re being ridiculous. I don’t need a phone.”
“I need you to have a phone,” Thorin says, and that’s the end of the argument. Bilbo finds himself bundled into the Volvo and they’re headed down the hill, through town and out to the highway. Thorin is efficient, bordering on rude, but within the hour Bilbo has a cell-phone he doesn’t quite know how to use and feels, somehow, less apprehensive than he really should, considering. It’s dark by the time they get back to Thorin’s apartment and he doesn’t get out of the car, just tosses the keys to Bilbo and waves him off.
“Sunday,” he says. “Take care.”
Whether Thorin means that of Bilbo himself or the dog, Bilbo can’t say. He watches Thorin go, the Volvo sliding a bit as it heads downhill and out of sight. Inside, the heat is clattering, and Erebor is waiting, his head cocked to one side as if he knows something, or at least suspects. Bilbo pets him absently and rummages in his bag for another sweater, another pair of socks.
One week. Thorin will be back on Sunday, and then Bilbo will return to his attic. Wait out the rest of winter break there, with his books and his tea, his houseplant. Alone again, but that’s not unusual. This is his life now. And after Sunday comes Monday, Christmas Eve.
It should be something to look forward to. Bilbo’s always been fond of Christmas. For reasons he wants to avoid acknowledging even to himself, though, he doesn’t feel his usual excitement. Not this year.
It’s foolish and fundamentally a bad idea, but as Bilbo curls up on the couch in the sleeping bag—it’s still early, and he hasn’t eaten, but he’s suddenly exhausted—he finds himself wondering if Thorin’s conference will run long. If there might be bad weather, or heavy traffic on the route back from Toronto. Perhaps it will take him just one day longer to come home.
