Actions

Work Header

How the West Was Won and Where It Got Us

Chapter 6

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The fields around his home have always been green. Green and gently rolling, as far as the eye can see. Dotted with cows and fences and silos, with mill ponds and white oaks, they spread out before your eyes, unending. In summertime’s golden light, humidity slinks in and covers the land in a comfortable haze while the magnolia trees burst into stars of the palest pink. Windows are left open wide, curtains swaying. There are drinks on front porches, long nights of star-gazing with the smell of honeysuckle and forsythia in the air.

            There are funerals on Sunday mornings, with the grass still damp from last night’s rain.

            Bilbo’s suit jacket is too big. It hangs off his shoulders, the sleeves half-covering his hands, as he stands in front of a hole in the earth that he is expected to put his mother into and then simply walk away.

            It is one of those things, he thinks, that shouldn’t ever be possible.

            After the service is over he wanders the cemetery. Two men are still shoveling dirt but neither of them say anything. Bilbo blinks and forces his eyes to focus, reading lines of names and dates, all the people he does not know, will never know. Someday, perhaps even tomorrow—for people are dying every day—someone else will do the same. They will read his mother’s headstone without ever knowing the sound of her voice or the scent of her hair or how steady her hands were when she poured tea.

            Bilbo has read enough Dickens to know all about orphans. Here under the July sun he is twenty-two years old and he knows better. These are not the gritty streets of rainy London; this is not Pip’s fateful graveyard; no one is going to come and turn him into a thief; no rich benefactor has their eye set on crafting him into the perfect match for their daughter. It’s just him. Left, now, with nothing.

            Never in his life has he wanted to be as thoroughly drunk as he does at this moment. What would surely be a morning spent throwing up would be worth the few hours of pure, blank space. But he is a Baggins, the only one left. An entire lineage’s worth of propriety is entirely on his shoulders. Firm foundations, his father always said. Firm foundations make for a solid home. Bilbo finds his way back to what is still, for now, his parents’ house—he’s never quite sure how—and does not empty the hand-carved liquor cabinet. If he’s being honest with himself, whisky has never been his drink of choice. He cleans the mantel and gives the flowers from various well-wishers fresh water. He makes himself a cup of tea. It burns his tongue.

            When it grows dark enough that he can close the curtains without the neighbours’ suspicion, he puts his head down on the table and closes his eyes.

 

Bilbo wakes to a crick in his neck and warm breath on his hand. Erebor’s damp nose nudges under his hand where it’s fallen off the couch. “Morning already?” Bilbo asks. His voice comes out rougher than expected. He hasn’t dreamed about the funeral in a long time. Erebor drops his chin onto Bilbo’s thigh and eyes him pensively.

            “Right,” Bilbo says. “Right. Breakfast.” He extracts himself from the sleeping bag with some difficulty and shivers at the loss of warmth. Thorin’s floor is cold underfoot, though Erebor doesn’t seem to mind. Bilbo rummages in his bag for his slippers and pads over to the kitchen. Thorin’s fridge is surprisingly full and for a minute all Bilbo can do is stare. He had been expecting Thorin to have at least 4 kinds of beer in his fridge, and some really old hummus, and very little else. Erebor paws at his dish and Bilbo tips dry food into it absently, spilling some before he realises it. With the dog crunching happily in the background, Bilbo makes himself some toast. Slathers it with butter and jam and sits in Thorin’s kitchen, one finger idly tracing the flecks of mica in the tabletop design. In the light of day, the apartment looks different. More real. The place is clean but has piles of stuff everywhere—tracing paper rolls piled on the side table, jointed industrial work-lights clamped to most surfaces, a scrap heap in the corner of off-cuts of wood and ripped cloth and who knows what else. It’s comforting, somehow, to see a place so obviously lived-in.

            Bilbo’s contemplating more toast, or possibly an egg, when Erebor walks over to the door and looks back at him pointedly. A well-behaved dog, Thorin had said. Bilbo sighs and brushes crumbs from his fingers. Snow fell sometime in the night, just a dusting. Bilbo trades his slippers out, folding the legs of his pajama pants into snow boots, and looks over his own jacket briefly before taking one at random instead off the pegs in the mudroom. It’s cold. Surely Thorin won’t begrudge him borrowing the heavier—and longer—coat. It’s some kind of waxed cotton, weighty on his shoulders, flannel-lined and padded and nothing Bilbo would ever pick out for himself. He feels like a five-year-old, or a lumberjack. A five-year-old lumberjack. The hem comes nearly to his knees.

            Erebor paws at the door. They step outside into a morning of bright, crisp light. There is ice on the bare branches of the maple trees, frost biting the air. Erebor snaps at the steam he huffs and runs over to a tree at the edge of the yard. Bilbo stuffs his hands into the coat’s pockets and hunches his shoulders up. His fingers touch something hard and smooth and he draws out his hand to see an old-fashioned pipe in his grasp. It explains the smell in Thorin’s car, the smell that sometimes lingers on his clothing when he passes by in the studio or stands particularly close. It’s a smell far preferable to the other one that often accompanies Thorin. Curious, and having the unexpected freedom of no one watching, Bilbo investigates the coat’s other pockets. A key-ring, some loose change, an elastic hair-tie, a single glove. Half a granola bar in its wrapper, hard as a rock. A couple of crumpled receipts, most of them for the liquor store. A felt-tipped pen, two acorns, a bit of twine.

            “Half boy-scout, half trouble,” Bilbo says. He would feel guilty, if he didn’t think Thorin would do the same to his pockets, given the chance. “Come on, you,” he calls to the dog. “It’s cold out here. Aren’t you finished?” Erebor comes bounding back to him, big paws crunching frozen grass. The dog barks once, loudly, and looks up at Bilbo as if pleased. “Inside,” Bilbo says. “Go.”

            Jacket back on its peg, boots lined up neatly next to the door—Bilbo’s aware that he’s compartmentalising, and the oddly specific organisation of Thorin’s fridge isn’t helping him not too. He decides to make pancakes, if only for the possible mess the flour offers. Erebor watches some sparrows hop around the lawn while Bilbo wipes down the counter and makes a neat stack of pancakes, golden-brown and inviting. Then the dog comes over and snatches the top one off the plate. Bilbo lets out a laugh and supposes he shouldn’t be surprised. His fork is halfway to his mouth when a beeping noise interrupts. It takes him a moment to place the sound—his new phone, still somewhere in the vicinity of the couch.

            “Thorin doesn’t trust me with you, apparently,” Bilbo tells Erebor. The dog wags his tail, and Bilbo shakes his head. “I didn’t think he would actually call.”

            As it turns out, Thorin hasn’t called. He’s texted: “Made it to Toronto. Bored already.”

            Bilbo fumbles with the buttons, trying to remember what Thorin showed him. His first few attempts get him garbled letters and symbols. Eventually he manages to reply, “Your dog is eating my breakfast.” It seems only fair to let Thorin know. Bilbo waits for an answer, but none comes. Pancakes beckon. He sits back at the table to a shorter stack—Erebor’s taken another one while he was distracted by the phone—and makes a concerted effort to enjoy his second breakfast. Feeling some mixture of rebelliousness and decadence, he leaves the dishes in the sink for later and instead settles down on the couch with a book on William Morris and British Socialism. He curls into the sleeping bag for warmth and ends up horizontal with his eyes closed and the book open across his chest, still on the introduction.

            When he wakes, to the sound of his phone again, it’s dark outside and there is a heavy weight on his feet. Erebor, asleep, tail twitching lightly. Bilbo reaches down and rubs the dog’s ears, smiling before he realises it. Thorin has replied, belatedly: “Good.” Erebor must eat pancakes on frequent occasion. Bilbo leans down, tucks his head to his chest. Stretches. There’s a chill in the air and it’s very quiet. More quiet than Bilbo’s own attic, which has road traffic and downstairs neighbours. Out here on the edge of the woods, behind the house of a professor away on sabbatical, Thorin’s place is practically an island unto itself. For a reason he can’t quite explain, being in Thorin’s space and having such silence seems wrong. Bilbo tugs his feet free and switches on the light next to the couch. The lower section of Thorin’s bookshelf, near the television, is packed with records, most of them unfamiliar. Choosing it more because he recognises the name and less because it suits his mood, Bilbo slips Dylan’s Blood on the Tracks from its sleeve and sets it gently on the turntable. Erebor wakes as the music starts and shakes himself off. He looks up at Bilbo, who is eyeing the bookshelf, with dark eyes.

            “Trying to chase me off?” Bilbo asks. The dog whoofs softly but doesn’t move. “Or encourage me, eh? Which is it?” Bilbo scratches Ere’s muzzle and the dog’s tail thumps his legs. “What if I promise to put everything back?”

            Bilbo feels foolish talking to Thorin’s dog, but then, it isn’t as though anyone is around to hear. And Thorin never has to know. Bilbo picks up his phone to check for messages, wondering if Thorin has replied, but there’s nothing. Reasoning that a bit more snooping couldn’t possibly hurt anything, he runs his fingers across the shelves. Above the records are stacks of DVDs, again titles Bilbo doesn’t know. There are, of course, hundreds of books. Heavy architectural reference volumes. A whole shelf of design magazines from the 1970s. Entirely at random, Bilbo tugs a slim leather-bound book off the shelf and is startled to see that it’s actually a photo album. He’s also startled by the hole in the underarm of his shirt, showing pale skin when he reaches up. He hadn’t realised that it had worn so thin.

            The album had been embossed on its cover but someone’s scratched out whatever was tooled into the leather, leaving only a long gouge. Bilbo settles back into the couch, sleeping bag across his legs, and opens the cover. The first few pages are curiously blank, though Bilbo can see light spots where photographs once sat and the slightly yellowed edges of the rest of the paper, exposed to the air and sunlight. The first photograph is of a woman Bilbo doesn’t recognise, holding a bundle that can only be a baby. Thorin? Or someone else? Several shots of an interior, possibly Thorin’s childhood home. A toddler, all dark curls, gnawing on a wooden spoon. Bilbo suspects it’s Thorin and lets out a laugh. It’s a far cry from the man he now knows. The photographs are mostly landscapes or snapshots of things that don’t mean anything to Bilbo, with a few shots of Thorin in various ages interspersed. There’s one of him as a teenager, barely bearded. He’s holding a hammer, but the background is too dark to make out any other details. There’s a photograph of a black puppy held in hands that Bilbo knows, just from the fingers and the hard lines of the wrist, are Thorin’s.

            That realisation troubles him and Bilbo flips the page, onto a blurry shot of Thorin in black robes holding a diploma but not looking very happy. More scenery, a couple of churches. The puppy, who must be Erebor, growing bigger with each photograph. Then there’s one of a woman with two small, adorable children and Thorin looking more pleased than Bilbo’s ever seen him. Thorin has never talked about a wife and kids, and he’d have been quite young to father children who look to be about eight and five in a photo taken—Bilbo checks the date—just a year ago, but maybe Thorin is just a private person. Maybe he trusts someone enough to leave them with his dog and his apartment but not tell them about his family.

            There are plenty of other photographs to study. Some of Thorin with the kids, one blonde and the other brunette, both with wide smiles. In one shot they have toy trucks, in the next wooden swords. They are atop Thorin’s shoulders, one on each side, small hands fisted in his hair. The blonde one has a ponytail. Their mother looks on fondly and Bilbo wonders about that theory he has heard, that you come to resemble your spouse, because she looks quite a bit like Thorin. A few pages later there is a photograph of Thorin atop a mountain with someone who looks like his father. Bilbo can’t help but be curious about Thorin’s family, whom he hardly ever mentions. About why he’s out here in upstate New York all alone when the scenery in the photos looks like the West somewhere, Utah or Montana or Wyoming, all mountains and clear skies. He thinks he’s almost figured it out, almost reached a breakthrough, when Ere knocks against his knees from behind, wanting to go for a walk.

            Apparently, the dog doesn’t care that it’s past eleven at night. Bilbo realises, as he looks for a flashlight, that he’s never bothered to put on proper pants. Still in pajamas, borrowing Thorin’s coat again, he lets Erebor out and closes the door firmly behind them. The garage windows are squares of soft light against the icy darkness of the night sky. Erebor doesn’t have a leash but he seems to recognise that Bilbo doesn’t want to be left behind, or perhaps Thorin’s just trained him so well that he heels at the slightest urging. They head down the long driveway, footsteps and breathing the only sounds in the night air. When they’re far enough away that Bilbo can barely see the garage, Erebor stops and cocks his head, listening.

            “He’s out there, somewhere,” Bilbo says. The dog is looking north. As they head back to the house, Bilbo drops a hand to Erebor’s neck and leaves it there, enjoying the warmth, the company. His phone is beeping when they get back to the garage and he trips over his boots trying to answer it in time.

            “Just finished for the day. Last panelist was an idiot.” The text message from Thorin is clear on the phone’s screen but Bilbo doesn’t know what to say in response, so he leaves it unanswered. Are they making casual conversation? Is Thorin simply complaining to him because he can? Is one meant to reply to vague complaints over text message? No one’s taught him how these sorts of exchanges are meant to go. Bilbo knows, fundamentally, that he’s more than a bit technologically backwards. His parents favoured letter writing and face-to-face visits, and he went to college close enough to home for it not to matter that he didn’t have a cell-phone. He could always find a phone on campus for a brief call home, and there had never been anyone to call but home.

            Bilbo is wiping Erebor’s wet paw-prints off the floor when the phone beeps again. “Bookshelf, back of apt., 2nd row. Watch something if you’re still awake.” The idea that Thorin is bored in his hotel room in Toronto, thinking of his dog-sitter and his DVDs, is one Bilbo doesn’t know how to process. “Thank you,” he texts back, because he feels that he should say something, even if it also makes him feel like an idiot.

            “Figured you’d be awake,” Thorin replies, almost immediately. “How’re things?”

            “Everything is fine,” Bilbo writes. He crouches down in front of the shelf, runs his fingers along the spines of the DVDs. Erebor comes over and touches his nose to one, and really, Bilbo has very little preference, so he pulls it out and spends a few minutes figuring out how to make Thorin’s television cooperate. He could watch it on his laptop, but the lure of a bigger screen just the right distance from the couch is too much to resist. He’s about fifteen minutes into the film before Thorin texts again.

            “You watching?”

            “Yes,” Bilbo writes back, distracted.

            “What?”

            “The Magnificent Seven.”

            “Classic,” is Thorin’s reply, and Bilbo smiles. Of course, considering that they’re all Thorin’s DVDs, the man probably likes all of them, so his approval of this one isn’t anything special. All the same, it sends a warmth through Bilbo that has very little to do with the sleeping bag.

            “Your dog picked it,” he confesses.

            “He’s got good taste.”

            They’re silent for a while after that, as the titular seven start to get together. They’re riding into the Mexican village when Bilbo texts again. He’s finding himself thinking that this movie would be better if Thorin were on the couch too, or at least roaming the kitchen, so he pretends. “Was the whole day boring?” he asks.

            “Yes,” Thorin replies. Onscreen, Chico is yelling at the villagers. “Stop texting during the movie. You’ll miss something.”

            Bilbo moves his gaze from the phone in his hand back to the television, and dutifully doesn’t reply. He falls asleep just after two in the morning during the last moments of the shootout with an arm slung over Erebor and dreams about gunslingers and how in the end, no one really wins.

 

He wakes to Erebor’s nose on his chest and tears in his eyes. He doesn’t know where he is. It’s dim and cold. The dog’s weight is crushing his ribs so much that he can barely breathe. With a strangled noise Bilbo shoves Erebor off and sits up straight, panting. The dog whines and looks up at him from the floor. “Sorry,” Bilbo says. He reaches down with a shaky hand and Erebor licks him before padding off towards his water bowl. Bilbo runs his fingers through his hair and digs his phone out of the couch cushions to check the time. It’s nearly three in the afternoon. Still disoriented, Bilbo wipes his face on his sleeve and lets out a long, slow breath. He is on Thorin’s couch, in Thorin’s apartment, with Thorin’s dog. It’s Wednesday, the nineteenth of December.

            Bilbo makes himself a pot of coffee and a plate of toast. He feeds Erebor and straightens up the couch, folding the sleeping bag neatly as if to encourage himself to not simply go back to sleep. He ends up at the desk, books spread out before him, trying to work on his paper. He’s written four pages when his phone goes off. It’s Thorin, of course: “Send me a photo of my dog so I know he’s alive.”

            Bilbo turns in the chair and whistles for Erebor. The dog comes over and lays his head in Bilbo’s lap. Bilbo finds the camera button on the phone and takes a picture of the dog’s head, his left hand resting atop it, and his oldest jeans beneath it all. He sends it to Thorin and feels like an idiot, particularly when there is no reply. Erebor barks, just once, and walks over to the door. With a sigh Bilbo wraps himself up and they brave the afternoon snow.

            The week passes in much the same way.

Notes:

All of my apologies for not updating sooner. It's around seven thirty in the morning now and I've been up all night, for not the first night in several weeks. I'm at the tail end of the semester and things have gotten predictably hectic. This chapter is shorter than I meant but I was feeling bad for neglecting the story, so I thought I'd post at least this much for now. Thanks for your patience. I hope you're still enjoying the story. Next chapter, more of Thorin's past will be explained. Also, Christmas (which is going to be a bit odd to write, considering that it's May, but we'll see how it goes).