Chapter Text
It’s quiet in the studio, Van Morrison grainy in the background with the volume turned low, freezing rain hissing against the windows on the north side. Thorin is drafting, tiny pencil marks on his elevations as he details the interior of some ridiculous building in the style of the fourteenth century, all short huffs of frustrated breath and low, distracted humming. Bilbo is seated on the floor, leaning back against one of the long tables at the front of the room, legs stretched out in front of him. He has a slim book in his lap, Aragon’s Une Vague de Rêves. He’s meant to be translating, or at least reading, but mostly he’s just relaxing. Watching Thorin’s foot tap steadily on the rung of his stool. Watching the lights on North Campus slowly go out as the hour gets later. He’s hungry, and he’s exhausted, but this is good. This is calm. He doesn’t want to leave.
There are moments like this, when it’s just the two of them, and it’s some stupid hour of the night, so late it’s technically morning, and they’re not talking or even looking at each other but they’re in the same place, in the same time—there are moments when Bilbo aches, desperately, to find the words to say what he wants to say. He knows, though, that even if he could figure it out, Thorin would rather not hear it. Would brush it off, or turn up the volume on his stereo, or, worst of all, tell Bilbo to leave. Maybe even get angry. And he can’t lose this, this mutual ignoring of the rest of the world. It’s cowardly and it’s probably several kinds of unhealthy, but it’s the only thing keeping him on his feet.
It’s the tail end of January. Spring term. Bilbo’s meant to be figuring things out, meeting new faculty, thinking about getting his advising committee together. He’s supposed to be debating in reading groups and drinking his way through Monday night trivia at one of the bars just off campus. It isn’t that the work is too much, though he’s taking more courses this semester, trying to fit in as much as he can before something happens—because something always happens—and he can’t continue in the program. It’s a foolish fear when they’ve guaranteed him funding for five years, but he can’t stop himself thinking it. So now he’s not sleeping, but he’s reading Lacan for the first time and he’s learning French. He tells himself it’s a good thing. A step in the right direction for his career. He looks at Thorin, who practically lives in the studio, and tells himself to work harder. To keep up.
But Thorin does, actually, go home at some point. It’s usually around four in the morning, but he gets into his Volvo and he drives up to his garage and has, presumably, a life outside of school. Has a dog that he takes to the park. Has drinking partners who aren’t Bilbo, because they’ve realised by now that never ends well. Thorin talks about his “companions” once in a while. Bilbo supposes they’re like friends, but different somehow. He doesn’t ask, for fear of being mocked. He doesn’t think he could stand it if Thorin were to mock him, not so soon after spending Christmas in his company. When he realises that, it suddenly makes sense that neither of them knows what to say to the other. They haven’t yet worked out how to be sincere.
Sure, there was that brief moment, Wednesday afternoon, the day after Christmas. Thorin had been more than a little drunk and Bilbo had finished most of a bottle of wine on his own, and they were just slumped on Thorin’s couch—Thorin’s feet on the battered coffee table, Bilbo leaning against the armrest, their shoulders almost touching—and saying things that didn’t make very much sense. There had been sincerity there. But when Bilbo woke up with a headache and Thorin watching him, leaning forward with his elbows on his knees, his eyes bloodshot in the darkened room, the sincerity turned into something entirely different. Thorin had backed away, quickly, saying words Bilbo couldn’t catch. He’d thrown a blanket in Bilbo’s face and climbed the ladder to his sleeping loft, and in the morning they were both hung-over. It took two rounds of pancakes to get them talking again and even then it was only about the weather.
Bilbo could talk about the weather now, but what’s the point? It’s typical January, lousy and cold, and they both know it. It suits them, somehow, the bleak skies, the chill that never gets out of your bones. It’s a time of year when everything is only half-alive, if even that.
The studio, for all its wide open spaces and endless windows, always manages to feel cut off from the rest of the world. At least, it does when they’re there. Bilbo walks past at other times of day, taking the long route up to Goldwin-Smith or wandering up towards Beebe Lake, and the space is filled with activity. Students at every desk, worklights on, professors in and out. The shop below seems to run all hours of the day, too. Thorin told him, back in October, that Saturday mornings were always dead times. That doesn’t explain the emptiness all other hours, though the dark cloud that’s been hanging around Thorin lately might. Bilbo’s beginning to wonder if he hasn’t actually threatened someone—professors, campus security, whoever—to get the studio all to himself.
There’s probably something wrong with Bilbo, because that thought doesn’t make him nearly as unnerved as it should. Even after the whirlwind that was winter break, especially after it, being around Thorin is easy in a way that makes no sense. Absolutely no sense. Out of all the people Bilbo spends his time with, it’s completely baffling, on many levels, that it’s Thorin who manages to make him drop his guard. He knows, logically, that he should be running in the other direction, or at least keeping things on a strictly professional level—though, speaking logically, he really should’ve dropped the workshop class a long time ago, if that was to be the case—but here he is. Here they are. Still trying to make things work.
Sometime just after two in the morning, Thorin shoves his chair back and reaches his arms up, clasps his hands and twists them behind his head. “You’re still here,” he says, tipping his head first to one side and then the other.
“Still here,” Bilbo agrees, turning a page and trying to decide how to translate les requins de la folie. Folie . . .Madness, or insanity? Does it make a difference?
“Getting any work done?”
“Er, not so much.” Bilbo marks his place in the text with a finger and looks up. Thorin is bent over in the corner where they keep a small refrigerator. When he straightens up, it’s with two beers in his hand and an eyebrow raised. Asking—except Thorin almost never asks. Offering, perhaps. A second try.
“I’m done for the night,” Thorin says. “Don’t feel like driving home just yet. I close my eyes and all I see are fucking cornices. If you want . . .”
Bilbo bites his lip and thinks for a minute. On the one hand, it’s drinking with Thorin, which he knows is a Bad Plan, capital letters and all. On the other, it’s another hour or so of company, and there’s always the chance that this time, it won’t all turn sour. Apparently, somewhere along the line, gradschool has turned Bilbo into an optimist, which is actually one of the most surprising things about the whole situation. “Why not,” he says, finally. He’s halfway to standing when Thorin drops onto the ground next to him instead.
“You should come by the garage,” Thorin says. “Erebor misses you.”
“I’m sure.” Bilbo takes a sip of his beer and tilts his head, surprised. It’s not Thorin’s usual stout. It actually isn’t half bad.
“Damn dog got attached while you were . . . anyway, we still have to finish your education in Indiana Jones.”
Bilbo groans. “Can we not? It reminds me a bit too much of someone in my life.”
“I am not Indy. I don’t do hats.”
“Not you.” Bilbo has to laugh a bit at that, and takes another drink. This isn’t a conversation he had been planning on having. “My . . . sort of uncle. In a way.”
“Didn’t know you had an uncle,” Thorin says, because they may have—once or twice, during other Bad Plans—tried to talk about their families.
“I don’t. He’s not related. He was a friend of my mother’s. Or, kind of an uncle to her. The details are a bit vague.”
“And he’s like Indiana Jones how, exactly?”
“The hats,” Bilbo says. Thorin smiles a bit and rolls his shoulder again, stiff from hours of leaning over the drafting table. They’re both still tense. Testing their footing around each other.
“You wear hats,” Thorin points out.
“Wool hats. Not cowboy hats. There’s a difference.”
“Huge difference.”
“Practicality, Thorin. My hats wouldn’t fall off, if I ever had to roll under a door.”
Thorin hides a smile in the mouth of his beer bottle and knocks his head back against the wall. His hair is down and seated so close, Bilbo can spot the small braids trailing from his temples. That’s another thing Bilbo wants to ask about but can’t. Given where they are, and what sorts of fashions students and townspeople alike sport, it shouldn’t seem so out of place, but this is Thorin. The man lives in dirty jeans and flannel shirts, battered Carhartts and Henleys and leather boots. The beard makes sense but the fact that his hair is down past his shoulders, let alone braided, is just odd.
“I’d like to see you try,” Thorin says, and Bilbo has to blink himself back to attention.
“Try what?”
“To roll under a door.”
“Not going to happen.”
“You are small. It might be easier.”
“It would not be easier.”
“It’s an impractical design, though. The doors should really close upwards. Harder to leap through the top. Or close faster, at least. Or all at once, when there’s a whole line of them.”
“Remind me to not let you design any temples of death.”
“Doom, Bilbo. Temple of Doom.”
“Temples of any kind.”
With a sound too derisive to be properly called laughter, Thorin says, “You might have it your way, after all,” and takes a long drink.
“What do you mean?”
“I’ve been applying for jobs for months. Nothing.”
“Well, I mean, it’s still early, right? There’s still . . . time. Before your graduation.”
“That’s not the point.”
“I’m sure someone will hire you.”
“I can’t just sit around and wait. I have—there are things I need to do, important things, and without money, it’s hopeless.”
“What about your stipend?”
“Gone.”
“You spent it all?” Bilbo asks, not quite believing it. He hasn’t even used half of his yet. “Don’t they give you very much?”
“They do.”
“Then, what?”
“I told you. There are things I need to do and they require money. So, it’s gone.”
“What sorts of things?” Bilbo asks. “And if you say alcohol, I swear—”
“What, you’ll hit me?” Thorin asks, his voice tight. “Go ahead and try it. I don’t think it will end well. But until you work up the nerve, why don’t you tell me why you don’t want to talk about your pseudo-uncle?”
“Can we . . . not do this?”
“What, you’re the only one allowed to ask questions?”
“Please, Thorin.”
They’re quiet for a few minutes after that. Drinking, listening to the rasp of the music. Not looking at each other. It’s a bit like meditation, Bilbo thinks. Staring at a point just in front of you. Staring so hard you stop really seeing anything. He counts his breaths and thinks about self-induced trance states, about l’ivresse des religions et des stupéfiants physiques, about what the world was like in 1924 and why the first surrealists wanted, so desperately, to leave it. He drinks the rest of his beer in one go and thinks it isn’t nearly enough.
“You already know that I have family out west,” Thorin says.
“Yes.”
“The money goes to them. It’s not that they can’t—they know how to handle themselves. But they don’t have anywhere to go. To be.” Thorin leans forward, his elbows on his knees, still staring off at the distance. “Our home was taken from us.”
“Taken,” Bilbo repeats, because he’s just latching onto words now, trying to move past the sound of Thorin’s voice and figure out what he’s really saying.
“My grandfather was a good man,” Thorin is saying, as if that’s what matters. As if that has anything to do with anything. “As was my father. They just . . . didn’t know when to stop.”
Bilbo realises, probably far too late, that what Thorin is trying to do is apologise. “You don’t have to do that,” he says, and then winces, because his words are only half the conversation in his head. “Tell me your life story,” he clarifies. “It’s not my business.”
“We’ll trade,” Thorin says. “Mine for yours.”
“Let’s not.”
“It wasn’t an offer. I’m not going to let you poke around my house, ask me questions you shouldn’t know to ask, and not demand anything in return.”
“That isn’t fair.”
“Life isn’t fair. I learned that very early on.”
So Thorin tells Bilbo, in halting words, about his family. About the people from the photographs, and the place in that old map. “We had a mine,” he says. Silver, mainly, and enough to make a whole town prosper. At least, back in its day. Something about litigations and national panic, coupled with a lack of railroad access, meant that the boomtown crashed, hard. Thorin’s family came out of it all holding the title to the lands. They tried farming there for a while but the winters were harsh and, Thorin said, farming never really took with his family. It was his grandfather who decided to re-open the mine. Everyone in the next town over said it was folly—folie, Bilbo thinks, a word that seems to be following him—said that all the rich ore had been near the surface and was long gone. So Thror dug deeper.
“You should’ve seen it,” Thorin says, laughing in a way that makes Bilbo’s chest hurt. Bitter. Hollow. Echoing, like a mine. “I was just a kid but I still remember. It was . . . there we were, middle of nowhere, up on this mountain, tunnels everywhere. Searching. Every day, down in the mine. All of us. Five years old with a pick-axe in hand, lowered on a rope into the crevasses that were too narrow for anyone else.” Thorin takes a long drink, his knuckles white where they’re clenched around the neck of the bottle. “There was lead, too, but my grandfather wasn’t interested in that.”
“So he found silver, then?”
“He found it. Deep within the mountain.”
“And?”
“And what?”
“Wasn’t that . . . good?”
“At first, it was.”
Thorin talks about days of plenty in a way that makes the expression more than just a cliché. The mountain was business and sanctuary in one, a compound where relatives from all over came to gather. At first it was just a few homes but over the years it grew, surpassed even the city it had been years ago. Surpassed its neighbouring cities, too, and became the envy of the region. “Envy,” Thorin says. “It should have been goddamn pride. It was . . . majestic, Bilbo. It was glory. Like nothing you’ve ever seen.”
“We’re still at the ‘good’ part,” Bilbo says, because tact has left him. His eyes are hurting and he can’t quite figure out why, so he closes them.
“It was poison, too. It seemed endless—just keep mining, deeper and deeper. Everything else . . . wasn’t important anymore. You think something like that can last?” Thorin says. “Of course it couldn’t. It was like an addiction, like some kind of disease. And there was all that wealth, from one mountain no one thought was worth anything. They weren’t just going to let us keep it.”
“Who wasn’t?”
“Everyone.”
The way Thorin talks about it, it sounds like a war. Later, much later, Bilbo will realise that it wasn’t that way at all—calling it a war implies that either side could win, when Thorin’s family never stood a chance. In some obscure combination of government legislation and what Thorin calls an “invasion from the North” but refuses to explain, all of them were driven out.
“We lost everything,” Thorin says. With his eyes closed, all Bilbo can hear is steadiness in Thorin’s voice, and it surprises him. “The silver, the land—they torched the entire city. It wasn’t just a mine, you have to understand. It was . . . My grandfather went mad. Some years later, my father probably did, too.” There’s a brief scuffle, the sound of the refrigerator opening and shutting. Thorin sinks back to his place next to Bilbo and opens up another beer. “Hell, you already think I’m there.”
“No, I don’t, I—”
“Getting there, at least,” Thorin says, and Bilbo doesn’t argue, because along with his New Year’s Resolution to be more adventurous, he’s trying to be honest with himself these days. Although it’s possible that this time, lying would be better.
“So you’ve . . . never been home since?”
“Once or twice. But I can't stay. Not yet. I’m not ready.”
“For?”
“To take it back.”
Bilbo doesn’t ask how, can’t even begin to think of what Thorin’s trying to do. He knows about family, though, and what it means to want to return when you cannot. So he lets Thorin have his second drink in silence while he stares at the laces on his boots and tries to see anything but rolling hills. It’s stupidly symbolic, he thinks, the colours of their homes, his green and Thorin’s red, his fields to Thorin’s mountain. Now they’re here: grey, rivers.
“We had a name for the mountain, you know,” Thorin says, after a long pause. “We called it Erebor.”
Bilbo has to smile at that.
“Enough. Your turn now.” Thorin reaches out an arm to shove against Bilbo’s shoulder. His aim is off—either he’s still stiff, or Bilbo flinches. Either way, his hand ends up somewhere between Bilbo’s collarbone and neck instead. Bilbo looks over, still smiling. Thorin frowns.
“You’re warm,” he says.
“It’s warm in here.”
“No, you’re never warm.” Thorin reaches out again, brushing Bilbo’s hair back from his forehead and pressing the back of his hand against flushed skin. “You always have at least five sweaters. It’s some kind of . . . anomaly. Your own geographic climate field. You’re running a fever.”
“I’m fine. It’s probably the alcohol.”
“Bilbo. You had one drink.”
“Lightweight. You did say I was.”
“You’re not even wearing two sweaters right now. You shouldn’t be this warm.”
“It’s nothing, really.”
“You’re just doing this to get out of holding up your end of the deal. Telling me about your family.”
“Guilty,” Bilbo says, but he closes his eyes again. His forehead burns where Thorin touched it.
“Yeah, well, it’s not going to work. But right now, you get a pass.” Thorin stands and tugs Bilbo to his feet.
“Thorin, what are you doing?”
“You’re sick. I’m taking you home. No arguing.”
“I’ll just sleep here.”
“Even I don’t sleep here,” Thorin says. When Bilbo still doesn’t move, Thorin guides him to a chair and pushes him down into it. Bilbo sits while Thorin packs up their things, shuts down the studio. He doesn’t know why he doesn’t just stand up and walk home. It seems too much of an effort, but it’s not, or it shouldn’t be. “Come on.” Thorin lifts him to his feet again, and when Bilbo wavers, Thorin tucks an arm around his back and steadies him. They’re sitting at the stoplight when Bilbo focuses enough to realise that when Thorin said “home,” he meant his, not Bilbo’s. He leans against the cool glass of the window and watches the scenery blur past. He hasn’t been to Thorin’s place since Thorin all but threw him out the door two weeks ago.
