Chapter Text
When Thorin comes back from Toronto, Bilbo’s asleep. His excuse is that while it is Sunday, it’s just after midnight, and he wasn’t expecting such a quick return. His other excuse is that he thinks he’s dreaming. He’s passed out on the couch, facedown in his pillow, when he hears the creak of one of the heavy garage doors. Erebor doesn’t bark the way he would if there was an intruder. Too tired, even in his dream, to lift his head, Bilbo rolls to the side and sees someone who can’t be Thorin, because Thorin is still at the conference, hundreds of miles away. Whoever it is dumps a bag next to the table, ruffles Erebor’s ears, and pauses only briefly at the edge of the couch before climbing the ladder up to the loft. Bilbo puts his face back into the pillow and thinks he should have more eventful dreams.
When he wakes up, of course, he realises it wasn’t a dream. Thorin is at the kitchen table in sweatpants and a t-shirt and the garage smells of coffee and bacon. Bilbo pushes himself upright and wipes a hand at his mouth. He’s been, embarrassingly, drooling in his sleep. He hopes Thorin hasn’t noticed.
“Morning,” Thorin calls over.
“You’re . . . back.”
“Left after the last panel yesterday. There was meant to be a storm today, and I thought I’d beat it down here. It was basically pointless anyway, and I thought Erebor might be driving you mad, so . . .”
“I wasn’t expecting you until later.”
“Yeah, I heard. You don’t function well before coffee, do you? I made you some.”
“Thank you,” Bilbo manages, and makes his way across the cold floor to the kitchen.
“Your hair is ridiculous.” Thorin slides a mug of coffee across the table.
“Sorry,” Bilbo says, well aware of his potential for spectacular bed-head, of the rumpled state of his slept-in sweater, the hole in its elbow. He picks his glasses up off the desk and puts them on to see Thorin smirking.
“Like a bird’s nest.”
“Oh, very original.” Bilbo sips his coffee and raises his eyebrows. Thorin’s remembered that unlike himself, Bilbo doesn’t take his coffee black, and doesn’t care if that makes him unmanly.
“I’ve spent the past week being harangued about building codes. I’m out of practice with originality.” Thorin goes over to the toaster and drops some bread in, and pulls the jam out of the fridge. The fact that he’s guessed what Bilbo eats for breakfast is puzzling, again, until Bilbo realises he’s probably just looked at his stock of food and figured out what’s in short supply. Erebor comes up and noses Bilbo before going to Thorin and lying down at his feet.
“I’ll pack my things and be out of your way after breakfast,” Bilbo says.
“No, just stay,” Thorin says, like it’s the most reasonable thing in the world.
“You want me to stay?”
“The weather report was right, it’s brutal out there. I don’t feel like driving you home.”
“I guess . . . I could stay another day.” Or two, Bilbo thinks, but doesn’t want to press.
“Good.”
They don’t talk much over breakfast. Thorin’s reading a magazine, and Bilbo’s still half-asleep. But later, Bilbo makes some offhanded remark about the lack of festivity, and Thorin shoves his feet into a pair of boots and heads out of the garage, a saw over his shoulder. He comes back in ten minutes later, cheeks red and nose running, with an armful of evergreen branches, snow dusting his shoulders.
“Happy?” he asks, stomping his boots and tossing a branch at Bilbo. “It’s festive.”
“Very,” Bilbo agrees. He bites back a smile and accepts the rest of the branches Thorin shoves in his general direction, casting a glance about the garage for suitable places to hang them. “You don’t have a mantelpiece,” he says.
“What do you need a mantelpiece for?”
“Hanging stockings. Draping greenery.”
“You wear stockings?” Thorin asks.
“Hush, you.” Bilbo brushes snow from one of the branches and lays it across the windowsill. “Christmas stockings. You know, for presents.”
Thorin doesn’t reply, so Bilbo rewinds his words, plays them back. Presents. Who’s to say there will even be any? Bilbo doesn’t bring it up again. When Thorin asks him for some branches Bilbo hands them over, and Thorin ties two together and tacks them over the stove.
“Fire hazard,” Bilbo says.
“Christmas fire,” Thorin retorts. He ties another branch to the ladder and dumps the rest in a heap on the desk. “Anything you wanted to do today?”
“I have a paper I’m meant to be working on. Other than that, no.”
“It’s the day before Christmas Eve. You’re not working.”
“Well if you’re going to suggest something ridiculous like ice skating, I’ll save you the trouble.”
“Not ice skating. Ice hockey, maybe. The end of the lake might be frozen over.”
“Still a no.”
“We’re at least going out to walk the dog,” Thorin says. “He looks like he’s getting fat. Didn’t you exercise him?”
“I did,” Bilbo protests. “He’s not fat. He’s a good dog, right, Erebor?” The dog’s ears perk up and he pads over to Bilbo, tail thumping against Bilbo’s legs. “I can’t really go out in public, anyway. I was expecting to go back to my place today so . . . I don’t have any clean laundry.”
“Who cares?”
“I care, Thorin. I’m not traipsing about in the snow in my pajamas.”
“There’s a laundry room in Balin’s place, I can let you in.”
“Your landlord’s house? Is that all right?”
“Yeah, he doesn’t mind. We’ll go over after breakfast. I have some things to wash, anyway. Until then, I can just loan you something.”
“You’re a giant.”
“You’re short. It’s winter, no one will care if your clothing’s bulky, and we’re not likely to run into anyone else anyway. I’ll go see what’s clean. Relatively speaking.” Thorin’s hauling himself up into the sleeping loft before Bilbo can protest, and when a pair of sweatpants, a woolen pullover, a t-shirt, and a thick pair of socks hit him in the face, he just smiles. They smell like Thorin, Old Spice and dog and the citrus soap from the studio that Thorin steals by the bottle and brings back to his garage. “Get dressed,” Thorin calls down the ladder. “Dog walking in five.”
Bilbo gulps down his coffee and hurries to dress, sniffing his underwear and frowning. He might be borrowing a t-shirt but underwear are another thing entirely, so he pulls the sweatpants up and cinches the drawstring as tight as it can go. They still hang low and he has to roll the bottoms. He feels like a kid again. Thorin slides down the ladder and looks him over, lasting a full three seconds before bursting into laughter.
They’re just out walking around the property, and then Erebor bounds down the driveway and they have to take off after him, Bilbo’s borrowed coat flapping after him, his glasses cold on the bridge of his face. They end up doing a circuit of the lake, under the hemlocks, and it’s peaceful until Thorin bends down and scoops up a snowball. He nails Bilbo square in the back and has another in his hands before Bilbo can even react.
So they have Christmas decorations, and a Christmas snowball fight, and then they get back to the garage, shedding clothing and dripping snow. Thorin’s looking around his kitchen for some Christmas hot chocolate makings, and Bilbo notices that the pantry’s stocked enough for Christmas cookie baking. Thorin makes the drinks—actual melted chocolate whisked into a saucepan of milk, not just the powder, and a liberal amount of “festive” peppermint schnapps in a dusty bottle from Thorin’s landlord’s wine cellar—and leaves him to it, sipping cocoa and playing with Erebor’s ears on the couch, Schubert scratchy on the record player. Apparently Die Winterreise is Thorin’s idea of Christmas music; while it’s not cheery, precisely, it sort of fits. The gas oven warms the entire garage.
Evening falls and Thorin doesn’t offer to drive Bilbo back to his place, and Bilbo doesn’t ask. They pick up their laundry, all of it mixed together, and dump it onto the couch to sort it. An old movie on the television, a plate stacked high with cookies, the two of them folding shirts side-by-side—it’s all disturbingly normal. Or rather, abnormal, because how did they end up here? It’s easier not to question it, and yet it’s like an itch in the back of Bilbo’s mind, and he waits for it to fall apart.
So Christmas Eve dawns and it’s quiet, just the two of them and the dog and snow falling outside. When Bilbo tries to remember the day afterwards, it’s a blank. A pleasant, calm blank, and he is content. They can’t have done much besides sit around but there is something so comforting about that—when it shouldn’t be, not at all—and if Bilbo thinks about it too hard, his chest gets tight, so he mostly doesn’t. Eight o’clock comes around and instead of feeling nostalgic for the candlelight services of his hometown—the high white ceilings of the church and how it never snowed—now Bilbo is cross-legged on the couch, stomach full from too many cookies. Thorin is sketching at the desk, papers strewn everywhere. It feels like a place he ought to be. A moment he’d like to preserve.
“Any other . . . Oakenshield family traditions?” Bilbo asks. “For the holidays, I mean.”
The answer is a terse negative, and Thorin’s pencil doesn’t even pause.
“I just thought, you know . . . it’s Christmas Eve and I’ve been with you all day and you haven’t even phoned home.”
“Neither have you,” Thorin says.
“There isn’t really anyone to phone.”
“Right.”
“Right, as in . . . you as well?”
Thorin cracks his knuckles and doesn’t answer right away. When he does, he speaks as if from very far away. “I have—there are people I could call. But whatever I could say to them, they already know.”
“It could still be nice. For them to hear from you, that is.”
“If you’re so set on it, call them yourself. I hate phones.”
Bilbo twists on the couch and looks over at Thorin. The backlog of text messages in his phone says otherwise. Schubert—the same record as yesterday—is particularly agitated, jaunty, the baritone’s words sibilant and forceful, the piano switching modes with every phrase. Then that song ends and the next begins, and Thorin’s eyeing his ruler, his shoulders tight. Bilbo wants to ask but he doesn’t, because it’s nearly Christmas and he feels a fight coming on.
The record runs out. Bilbo’s in his sleeping bag but not lying down, cozy next to Erebor. Thorin comes over and nudges the dog aside, drops down onto the couch with a cookie in his mouth and a closed expression on his face. Bilbo’s used to him being cagey but this is a whole new level. Perhaps it’s that, or perhaps it’s the fact that neither of them seems to be able to say what they mean—whatever the reason, Thorin doesn’t climb the ladder back up to his loft. When Bilbo wakes up, it’s Christmas, and his head is next to Thorin’s hip, one of Thorin’s arms over his shoulders. For a minute, maybe two, he doesn’t move. It’s not a very comfortable position and he’s too warm, between the sleeping bag, the dog on his lap, and Thorin’s body heat, but he doesn’t move. Just blinks, one cheek pressed into the couch and his glasses askew on his nose. Erebor, with an uncanny ability to know exactly when the people around him are faking sleep, drops a heavy paw on his ear and leans over to lick Thorin’s arm.
“Get off, Ere,” Thorin mutters, but he lifts his hand to pet the dog. Or, he tries to, but his arm’s still pinned between Bilbo and the couch. Erebor barks, sounding immensely pleased with his situation, and licks Thorin again before jumping off the couch and going to lap noisily at his water dish. Bilbo sits up as soon as the dog is gone and looks straight ahead, trying to flatten his hair. “Give it up,” Thorin says from beside him. “Losing battle. No fighting on Christmas, and all that. I’m starving—let’s eat.”
Bilbo sighs, though he can’t help but smile, and fights his way out of the tangle of his sleeping bag and a leg that’s tingling from being bent all night long. Thorin’s eating a cookie by the time Bilbo makes it into the kitchen, saying something about “breakfast cookies” as if that’s a legitimate thing, but he’s also making coffee so Bilbo doesn’t argue. After two cups and some cookies of his own, Bilbo pauses. He should say something. He should at least wish Thorin a merry Christmas, but even more, he should thank him. He should give him a present, really, but it’s too late for that now. “Thanks for the coffee,” he says instead, and knows that if his mother was here, she would cringe at his lack of manners.
Nothing much happens on Christmas, and later Bilbo will think that perhaps he should start believing again in the magic of the season, because that’s a small miracle in and of itself. Thorin roasts a surprisingly delicious turkey and Bilbo cooks some potatoes and the branches over the stove catch fire, just as expected. The day after is quiet, too, just the two of them sitting around, overstuffed, avoiding the inevitable return to work. Then Wednesday comes and Bilbo can’t hide the fact that he feels he’s overstayed his welcome, but Thorin is a secret-agent-level people reader when he wants to be so he also knows that Bilbo doesn’t want to leave, and the topic just doesn’t come up. They eat leftovers for dinner and Thorin goes over to liberate a couple of bottles of red wine from his landlord’s wine cellar, laughing when Bilbo suggests they should just drive to the liquor store. “He really won’t mind,” Thorin says. “He’s practically family.”
And that’s what starts the conversation again, the one Bilbo had been so determined to drop in favour of holiday cheer. “You do have a family, though,” he says, bent nearly double in his chair, his chin atop Erebor’s head. “I can’t believe you didn’t talk to them on Christmas.”
“My family is complicated,” Thorin says, and pours more wine.
“If you’re going to quote Tolstoy at me—”
“Now you’re confusing me with you. The quoting business. I don’t do that.”
“Thorin,” Bilbo says, and has to take a deep breath before he continues. Erebor whines beneath him but Bilbo slides his arms around the dog’s neck and doesn’t let go. “I found your photo album.”
“Found?”
“Well . . . I was curious. I know I shouldn’t have, but I was looking for a book and then once I picked it up I couldn’t just put it back.”
“You should have.”
“I know, I know, but . . . were you never going to tell me that you’re married?”
“What?”
“And with children, even?”
“What?” Thorin asks again, and sets the bottle down heavily. “What the hell are you talking about?”
“The woman and children in the photographs,” Bilbo says, his eyes on the kitchen floor, following the grain of the wood. “Your family.”
“They’re not—you had no right to snoop around! I asked you to watch my dog, not investigate my life. It’s none of your goddamn business.”
“Why don’t you talk about them?”
“Family isn’t something I talk about.”
“You’ll regret that one day,” Bilbo says, because he can’t leave well enough alone, and also because it’s true. “Trust me.”
“I don’t need you telling me how to take care of my family.”
“Why aren’t they here with you?”
“They have their own lives.”
“But—”
“We’re not talking about this anymore.”
“Thorin, if we’re going to be friends, I can’t . . . I need to know more about you other than your favourite beer and what size shirts you wear and how to look after your dog.”
Thorin is quiet for a minute. He empties his glass—not a proper wine glass, something that looks like a beaker from a chemistry lab—and kicks a foot at the table leg absently. “I’m not married,” he finally says.
“Divorced, then?”
“No. Fuck, no. Look, those photographs, the kids are my nephews. The woman’s my sister. And you now know more about me than any of my cohort, so you can shut up.”
Bilbo could shut up. Or he could just keep talking. Thorin hasn’t shoved him against a wall yet, which is a good sign, so he may as well go for it, right? “That doesn’t sound very complicated.”
“You have no idea,” Thorin says, and huffs a laugh. “God, I need a smoke.”
“I got pipe tobacco in the mail once,” Bilbo says, which was not at all what he meant to say. He frowns and looks at his own glass, which is empty, and at the bottle beside it—nearly empty. “Didn’t know what to do with it.”
“Only one thing to do with it.” Thorin leans his chair back, pulls a pipe from the pocket of a shirt that’s hanging on a peg on the wall. He packs it, spins it in his fingers, but doesn’t light it.
“My parents are dead,” Bilbo blurts out, when he had meant to say, “I don’t smoke.”
Thorin just looks at him, his gaze steady despite all the wine, and Bilbo shrinks under the scrutiny. Erebor pulls away and goes over to jump up on the couch. The conversation all but dies after that, because what is there to say? By some unspoken agreement they join the dog and finish off the wine. In the morning Bilbo is more hung-over than he has been in his entire life and can’t even string a sentence together.
But while the hang-over persists, his words soon return, and because he is who he is, he tries to talk about family again. It’s a phenomenally bad idea, even after heaps of pancakes and the last of the Christmas cookies, and if Bilbo’s head had hurt a bit less, he might’ve realised it. At first it seems fine. They talk about family, the abstract concept, for a bit. Then, after at least four inquiries, Thorin caves and tells him the kids’ names—Fíli, age 9, and Kíli, age 6, and Thorin’s ridiculously proud of both of them, Bilbo can hear it in his voice—and says how they live on a ranch, a couple of horses and cows, fields of barley. His sister’s name is Dís. Bilbo asks about the kids’ father and gets a stony glare, and then he asks about Thorin’s father and gets a plate thrown at his head.
There’s no apology. Just a “We’re done here,” and Thorin folding his arms across his chest, leaning back against the sink, chin raised as if in a challenge, daring Bilbo to say anything. Erebor comes over to sniff at the broken porcelain and Thorin shouts at his dog, whose head lowers, ears flat to the sides. Bilbo gathers his things and walks to the door, his hands shaking. He pauses there for a moment, gives Thorin a chance, but gets only silence. He doesn’t want to leave, even after all this—he doesn’t want to leave. But he’s frightened, and he’s not an idiot, so he bends to lace his boots and he walks out, still wearing Thorin’s sweater as he trudges through the snow.
----
Bilbo doesn’t know whether to laugh or panic. It’s all very West Side Story: a parking lot standoff, the street-lamp flickering. Half of him wonders if the other man is hiding a switchblade up the sleeve of his leather jacket. The other half of him wouldn’t be surprised if that was true.
It all started with a map.
He goes by the name of Azog, and Bilbo hasn’t bothered questioning it. Frankly, the man’s more than a little intimidating, even in the confines of his office. A fourth-year grad student in the history department with a fine arts degree, he specialises in Anglo-Saxon antiquities, specifically in artistic reconstruction of historical maps. Tall and pale with white-blonde hair, Azog cuts a striking figure. When they first met, back in early March, Bilbo had started a conversation without even looking up, leaning over a map in a glass case and noticing only the presence of someone beside him. It was only later, when the slick reply came and the debate started, that he began to be afraid.
Despite all that, they worked surprisingly well together, deciphering old texts and leafing through the library archives. Bilbo found that if he just focused enough on the maps, he could ignore the chill that ran up his spine every time Azog leaned over him or whispered something in his ear, sliding a book across the reading room table in the hush of the room. The man has, objectively speaking, quite nice hands, the fingers long and dexterous. There’s a scar on his face, cutting through one eyebrow and down onto his cheek, and when he smiles it curls up towards his hairline. He’s someone who could be—would be—fascinating, if he wasn’t so terrifying. Bilbo spends many of their hours together convincing himself that Azog couldn’t possibly have been a murderer in his past life, telling himself that he reads too many crime novels, that it’s all a cultivated air of mystery and not an actual Russian mafia heritage. He’s not entirely successful but the archives are alluring enough and with Azog’s knowledge, the uncanny way he tracks down exactly the right documents, Bilbo’s too interested to back down.
Except now they’re here, an unusually warm night, mid-April, trading threats in the moonlight. Or rather, Azog is threatening; Bilbo is listening, and feeling increasingly like this was all a very bad idea. Wishing he knew how to re-wind time.
“You will be there tomorrow, and you will find a way to get that map to me after closing, or I can promise you that you will not like what comes next.” Azog’s leaning casually against the low wall outside of Milstein. When he came out of the shadows and waved a casual hand at Bilbo as he left the studio, Bilbo hadn’t given it a second thought. It’s nearing one in the morning and he’s had a drink in the studio with Thorin, so he’s probably not as together as he should be. All he meant to do was walk home.
“I won’t do that,” he says, the words thick in his throat. He doesn’t know if he’s sweating or if the air is just humid, on the brink of rain.
“No, I think you will.” Azog reaches out a hand, pale wrist flashing quick, and then he’s fisting Bilbo’s sweater and tugging him close. “I need that map.”
“I have to go now,” Bilbo says, and tries to take a step back. Azog doesn’t let go.
“I’ve been more than lenient with you so far. Little first-year, all alone in a new town, doesn’t know what he wants to research. I’ve . . . taken you in.”
“That’s really not—”
“There’s a system in place here. And you don’t simply walk out. Tomorrow. The map. My hands.”
“Please, I’m not going to—”
“Hey!” The shout, low and angry as it is, is a welcome relief. Azog’s eyes narrow but his grip loosens, and Bilbo sinks back. He doesn’t know who it is, until the next words come, and then the voice makes it clear. “What’s going on?”
“Well,” Azog says, his mouth twisted in a smirk. “If it isn’t Thorin Oakenshield. Hello, Thorin.”
“You get the hell away from him.”
“We’re only talking. Move along.” Azog pulls a pack of cigarettes from his pocket, lights one slowly, as if he has all the time in the world. Bilbo shivers and takes a step towards Thorin, but just one. Azog’s eyes pin him in place.
“Fuck you,” Thorin says. He moves between Bilbo and Azog, his whole posture tense. “Bilbo, get in the car.”
“We’re not done talking here, Bilbo and I,” Azog says, and blows a line of smoke at Thorin. “And this has nothing to do with you. Unless . . .” He looks from Thorin to Bilbo, back to Thorin again, and then laughs, his head tilted back, perfectly coiffed hair shining under the street-lamp. He laughs and laughs and finally says, “You’ve got to be joking. Really, Thorin? This kid? Are you that desperate?”
“Bilbo, get in the goddamn car.”
Bilbo flinches at Thorin’s tone and backs his way across the parking lot until he hits the Volvo and stumbles. It’s unlocked, because it’s always unlocked, so battered and so recognisably his that Thorin doesn’t fear anyone stealing it. After a bit of fumbling with the door handle, Bilbo falls into the passenger seat. The windows are damp from spring rain and he watches Thorin face down Azog and feels sick to his stomach. Thorin turns and his look is clear, even across the parking lot—Bilbo shuts the car door. He can’t hear their words after that, but the body language says it all. Azog too carefully nonchalant, the butt of his cigarette glowing. Like he knows a secret. Thorin with his fists clenched, leaning forward, ever so slightly in Azog’s space, not taller but broader and clearly fuming. They stand there for what seems like an age, and then before Bilbo knows it the Volvo’s driver side door is jerked open and Thorin sits down hard, pulls the door shut after him so fiercely that the entire car rattles. There are minutes, so many minutes, of tense breathing. Bilbo looks up, out the windshield, and Azog is gone.
“Are you . . . all right?” he ventures, when it becomes clear that Thorin isn’t planning on starting the car anytime soon.
“Am I—are you seriously asking me that? Am I all right? What the hell were you doing, talking to that bastard? What the fuck is wrong with you? Are you all right? Did he hurt you?”
“No, no, Thorin, he’s . . . I’m fine.”
“You never speak to him again. Do you understand me? Don’t ever speak to him. If he so much as looks at you, I swear—”
“I don’t need you mauling people on my account.”
“Not everything is about you,” Thorin snaps, and slams a hand against the dashboard. “Goddamn it. You don’t—you don’t have any idea who he is, do you? What you’re risking by even being on his radar?”
“Thorin, we were only talking. He’s smart, we’ve done some work together in the past—”
“When?”
“What?”
“When did you work together?”
“Um . . . we met back in March, so, it’s been a little over a month now? More or less. He’s working on something for this conference in Munich so I’ve been—”
“You’ve been ‘working’ with him for a month? And you didn’t think, even once, that it might be a good idea to say something to me about that? I can’t believe you!”
“Why would I tell you about my research partners? You won’t tell me about your ‘companions,’ not really, and we haven’t exactly been on the best of terms lately, in case you didn’t notice. Look, it was just work, Thorin. Like anything else. There’s no need to—”
“It’s never just anything with Azog, you don’t understand—you have to tell me these things, Bilbo!”
“Why? Why should I tell you? You’re not my father, and we’ve already established that you’re not my boyfriend, and to be honest you’re acting like an arse right now, so why on earth would I tell you anything? It’s always violence with you. Like you’re some kind of . . . Neanderthal. I don’t know why I bother.” Bilbo shrinks down into his seat and knocks his forehead against the window.
“You don’t know what you’re talking about,” Thorin says, his words slow and deliberate and somehow more painful than the shouting because of that. He starts the car, pulls out of the parking lot slowly, looking around, checking things out. With no sign of Azog, Thorin eases the rickety car out onto the road and heads for his apartment. They don’t speak on the drive, not even when Bilbo notices how Thorin’s knuckles are white on the steering wheel, how his left leg is restless against the car door. He can’t get the smell of Azog’s cigarette out of his nose.
“Out,” Thorin says, when he pulls up to the garage, and Bilbo gets out. Follows Thorin in through the wide front doors and drops into a chair at the kitchen table. Thorin rummages in the fridge and Bilbo is expecting alcohol but it’s a glass of water thrust into his hands, and then Thorin is sitting across from him, not quite looking at him, his jaw tight. “I don’t know . . . how to talk about this.”
“With words. It isn’t that difficult.”
Thorin exhales sharply and for a second Bilbo thinks he’s going to overturn the table or something. But Thorin just closes his eyes, and his shoulders heave once, and his hand taps steadily on the table. “It is difficult,” he says. “More than you know. I’m trying, as best as I can, to tell you why. So if you could stop arguing for five minutes, I’d appreciate it.”
“Well, you do owe me an explanation.”
“I owe you an apology,” Thorin says, and they are words Bilbo has never heard him speak before. They are words he didn’t even know Thorin knew.
“What did he say to you, after you sent me to the car?” Bilbo asks, because he’s still shaken up, still argumentative, not ready to just take the apology and accept it for the novelty it is.
“You don’t need to know.”
“I’m asking you to tell me.”
“Bilbo, you have to understand that Azog and I . . . have a history. A really fucking terrible history. Whatever he said, it’s not important. What matters now is that you keep away from him, as best you can, and if he ever tries to threaten you again, you come to me.”
“So you can maul him.”
“I would like nothing more,” Thorin says, and he isn’t joking the way Bilbo had hoped.
“I don’t need you to . . . defend my honour, or whatever else you think you might be doing. He hasn’t done anything to me. What you saw was just . . . I don’t know, a bad moment.”
“I’m telling you, this isn’t about you. Until today, I didn’t even know you knew him. You shouldn’t know him, not at all. He’s not the type to—There are things about Azog that you don’t know. That I don’t ever want you to know.”
“What things?”
“Damn it, I just said, things I don’t want you to know! So I’m not going to tell you. Just drop it.”
“I think I deserve to know,” Bilbo says, and wipes at the condensation on his glass instead of looking Thorin in the eyes.
“Maybe,” Thorin says. “Maybe you do. But I am asking you to let this go. He hasn’t . . . hurt you yet. You can still walk away. I am asking you to do that, Bilbo.”
And because it is Thorin, and he is—for one of the first times, ever—asking, Bilbo lets it go. They move from the table to the couch without really talking about it, in their usual positions: Bilbo on the left with the pillows and the ragged afghan, Thorin on the right with his feet up, Erebor beneath the coffee table. They’re all drained, too worn-out to even think about moving further. Beyond that, neither of them, though they’d never admit it, particularly wants to be alone.
“Thorin?” Bilbo says, just before they fall asleep.
“Mmm?”
“I didn’t say it earlier. I was . . . frightened, and then I was just angry. But thank you.”
“Hmm for what?” Thorin shifts, his head back against the couch, body slumped over towards Bilbo.
“For saving me, back there.”
“Go to sleep.” Thorin shoves a hand against Bilbo’s shoulder, clumsy with exhaustion.
As fights and apologies go, it’s nowhere near good, but it’s the best they’ve managed so far.
