Chapter Text
Thorin maneuvers Bilbo through his garage door easily. His hand is cool on the back of Bilbo’s neck and the contact is a grounding force, keeping Bilbo upright long enough to get to the couch. Thorin, it turns out, is unusually good at taking care of people. You would never guess it. He bats away Bilbo’s fumbling hands and makes short work of unlacing Bilbo’s boots. Removes his wool socks, tucks his legs up on the couch. “I’ll be right back,” Thorin tells him, and brushes his fingers against Bilbo’s hair as he walks past.
Bilbo, if anyone bothered to ask, would still say that he was fine, but he can’t deny that he’s tired all of a sudden, so tired his limbs feel heavy. It’s too much effort even to raise his head and see what Thorin’s doing. He hears running water, and then Thorin is back with a damp washcloth in hand. “Here,” Thorin says, and folds it neatly in half, presses it to Bilbo’s forehead. “Just . . . close your eyes, or something.”
“Hmm,” Bilbo says, and water drips down from his temple, runs down his neck.
“Have you eaten today?”
“I had breakfast.”
“Lunch? Dinner?”
“An apple.” It had been a lousy one, mealy on his tongue, which is always the trouble with winter fruit. “Beer, with you.”
“Damn it, Bilbo, why don’t you actually spend some of your stipend for once? Buy yourself some decent food. I know you like to eat.”
“Don’t like to eat alone,” Bilbo mumbles, and Thorin sighs.
“I’ll get you some aspirin or something. Don’t go anywhere.”
Bilbo has to smile a little, because the thought of him going anywhere is ridiculous. There’s a crick in his neck so he scrunches down until his head falls off the armrest and onto the cushion. When Thorin returns, he slips a hand under Bilbo’s head and lifts him back up, and Bilbo protests. “Medicine,” Thorin says. “Then you can lie back down.” So Bilbo puts the pills in his mouth and fumbles with the water, spilling a little down the front of his shirt.
“Sorry,” he says, letting Thorin take the glass back and lying down again. “I didn’t mean to . . . get your couch wet.”
“I think most of it ended up on your shirt,” Thorin says. He turns to put the glass on the coffee table and then his fingers are undoing the buttons of Bilbo’s shirt.
“What’re you doing?”
“I want to get your temperature down, not freeze you to death. It is still January, you know. Even if you’re burning up. Wet shirt’s not going to help here.”
“Oh.”
Bilbo lets Thorin work his arms free of the wet shirt and shivers. He reaches up to push the washcloth off his forehead and Thorin stops him. “Leave it,” he says.
“I’m sorry.”
“Stop apologising.”
Bilbo’s own memories of that night are understandably fuzzy, but he thinks Thorin may have spoon-fed him ice chips at some point, which is beyond embarrassing. He’s also about sixty-percent certain that his head ended up in Thorin’s lap at some point, and when he wakes up it isn’t to the coffee table in front of him and his feet pressed up against the armrest. He’s in Thorin’s bed, snow falling wetly on the skylight above the loft, everything mid-morning bright. It takes him a few minutes to recall that it must be Wednesday and he’s definitely slept through class.
“Thorin?” he calls, testing his voice. Low, scratchy—sounding nothing like himself. There’s some rustling from down below and Thorin’s head appears at the top of the ladder.
“Hey, space cadet,” Thorin says, and Bilbo frowns because he thought they’d left that nickname behind. “How’re you feeling?”
“Miserable.”
“You look far more with-it than last night, though.” Thorin climbs up onto the loft platform, sits down at the foot of the bed.
Bilbo pulls the sheets up to his chin, suddenly aware that he’s still shirtless, and frowns. “What did I say? Last night, that is.”
“Oh, plenty. Think you can make it down the ladder for some breakfast? I don’t want you to fall and concuss yourself on top of it all.”
“I know how to climb a ladder, thank you,” Bilbo says, trying for dignity and missing it by about a mile. It only gets worse when he fights his way out of tangled sheets—Thorin’s tangled sheets—and sees that he’s not in his jeans anymore, either.
“Here,” Thorin says, and throws a sweater at him. It’s the same one Bilbo walked out in last time, washed and folded and carefully left on Thorin’s drafting table in the studio last week. Bilbo slips it on wordlessly, smoothes it out. The shoulders hang and the bottom hem goes well past his hips but it’s just as soft as he remembers. “I’d offer coffee but I doubt you’re up to it so . . . apple juice? And you’re eating something. No arguments.”
Bilbo takes a minute to collect himself before following Thorin down the ladder. He doesn’t know where his pants are, or his socks. His toes curl on the cold rungs. His mouth tastes like week-old bread and something worse, something beneath that. Thorin slides a glass of juice across the kitchen table to him and then a plate of toast.
“Eat.”
“Thorin, really, what did I say last night? I . . . can’t really remember.”
“Drink your juice.”
“I’m sorry if I—”
“Bilbo, stop. You just answered a few questions, that’s all.”
At that, Bilbo feels his cheeks flush. Not fever again but embarrassment, because they had been talking about “life stories” before his whole Victorian-lady swooning episode back in the studio, and whatever questions Thorin asked can’t have been ones he would have wanted to answer. He rather suspects, in his feverish state, that he answered them all anyway, and then some.
Thorin spends the rest of the afternoon alternating between ribbing Bilbo mercilessly and hovering over him with bottles of water, aspirin, toast with honey until Bilbo has to actually push him away. Even though there’s still time to get back to campus before his French class, Thorin insists that Bilbo’s staying put. When the fever breaks and Bilbo can’t stop shivering Thorin bundles him into the quilt from his bed and they sit on the couch and—true to Thorin’s word—finish off Bilbo’s education Indiana Jones with The Last Crusade. It’s sort of awful and sort of fantastic, and it does wonders for taking Bilbo’s mind off things, but when the credits roll it’s all still there: shame, and apprehension. He’s never been blackout drunk, has no precedent for this sort of thing, and he can’t honestly say what worries him more, the fact that he can’t remember or what he might’ve said to Thorin.
“I need to know,” he finally says, after Thorin explains that technically there’s another Indiana Jones film but it’s not something they’re ever going to speak of, let alone watch. “I need to know what I said to you last night.”
“You told me about your parents.”
“. . . What, exactly, did I say?”
“I am sorry, you know. I told you then, but I should tell you again—I had guessed as much, a while back, but I didn’t know for certain.”
“That wasn’t fair of you,” Bilbo says. He’s not as angry as he thinks he should be and chalks it up to fever, to the softness of Thorin’s quilt around his shoulders. “Asking me questions like that when you knew I wasn’t really all together.”
“It was a fair trade, though. My story for yours.”
“You had a chance to edit yours.”
“All right, then. Tell me your version, now.”
“What good will that do? You already have your answers.”
“I want to compare.”
“No, thanks.”
“Or I can tell it to you, and you can tell me where you think I’ve got it wrong.”
“I said no!”
For as long as they’ve been arguing—nearly three months, now—it is the first time Bilbo has ever raised his voice.
The conversation’s all but over after that. Bilbo falls asleep, sometime later in the evening, and when he wakes up to use the bathroom the garage is cold and dark and Thorin is, presumably, upstairs on his bed, sans quilt. Bilbo should feel guilty at that, but as he washes his hands and looks at himself in the mirror over the sink, he feels a little smug. It serves Thorin right, he thinks, and finishes off the bottle of apple juice. Goes back to the couch, and back to sleep.
----
They’re in Thorin’s car driving north, the windows rolled all the way down. It’s the first week of May and uncharacteristically gorgeous outside, all blue skies, the weeping cherries in full bloom. Thorin is wearing these absurd cheap plastic sunglasses with neon blue frames that someone left behind in the studio. He has a bare arm hanging out the window while the fingers of his other hand drum on the steering wheel. Bruce Springsteen is loud, almost painfully so, on the Volvo’s lousy speakers, singing “Jungleland” as if his heart depends on it. Bilbo thinks he’s starting to understand now, why Thorin likes Springsteen so much. It’s something to do with the way he sings about home—like it’s a place he can’t wait to leave, but also a place he’d give anything to keep. Or to save. A place he loves for what it is but hates for what it does.
Outside the street’s on fire in a real death waltz
between what’s flesh and what’s fantasy,
and the poets down here don’t write nothing at all,
they just stand back and let it all be.
It’s imperative, somehow, that Bilbo understand. He knows this. Can feel it in his bones.
“This is good,” Thorin says, apropos of nothing, shouting a little to be heard over the music and the noise of the highway. He turns to grin at Bilbo, mouth wide, eyes decidedly not on the road.
“Look where you’re going,” Bilbo says, and ruins the mood, but he can’t help it if he panics slightly on highways. He can see the speedometer—Thorin’s doing nearly eighty.
“Relax, Bilbo.” Thorin reaches over and shoves his shoulder, ruffles his hair. Bilbo bites his lip and closes his eyes so he doesn’t see the road whizzing past.
Springsteen’s just crooning now, over rumbling piano riffs, as the song ends. Bilbo opens his eyes in time to see Thorin nodding his head in time with the music, entirely caught up in the moment. They’re driving out of town to nowhere in particular. It’s Friday, the last day of classes for the spring term, and though they both have piles of work left undone—papers and a translation project for Bilbo, the finishing touches on a scale model and four more pages of elevations plus the oral examination for his thesis defense for Thorin—they decided, mostly by unspoken agreement, that while the rest of the university blows off classes to drink on campus at some kind of outdoor concert that everyone except the grads seems to know about, they would take the Volvo and Thorin’s box of cassettes and a case of beer and get as far away as one afternoon would let them.
The lake stretches out to their right, a slick line glistening in the sun. “Few hours, we could be in Canada,” Thorin says. “Want to?”
“We can’t,” Bilbo says, because someone has to be responsible, to point out that they have liquor in the car and no passports, that the bottle cradled between Thorin’s thighs does not contain water.
“Ever been?”
“Once,” Bilbo says. “When I was very young.”
They end up just outside of some town with a Roman name—a geographic anomaly, Bilbo thinks, that there should be so many, clustered together, so far from Rome—on the back slopes of a winery, overlooking the lake. Thorin gives Bilbo a boost up and then they’re on the Volvo’s roof, the case of beer between them as Bilbo shifts awkwardly and Thorin lies back, one leg hanging over the roof-racks, like he’s done this a thousand times. Bilbo takes a drink and he lies back too, the feel of warm metal strange beneath his back.
“Bilbo,” Thorin says, hours later, when they’re sleepy with sun and both more than a little not-sober. His voice sounds further away than Bilbo’s shoulder. “As good as this is, I didn’t drag you out here just to look at some grapes.”
“We’re not looking at grapes,” Bilbo wants to say, because when he’s feeling contrary he gets logical, but he keeps his mouth shut because deeper than any desire to argue is panic, sheer and sudden.
“We have to talk.”
It’s funny, in a way, Bilbo thinks, because those are words he’s been expecting for ages now, except always from his own lips. Thorin isn’t the type to talk. He’ll glare, or throw something, or stand painfully stoic until the other person caves. He’ll cook dinner rather than apologise. Drink rather than socialise. Anything having even remotely to do with emotions is best broached with a ten-foot pole, or not at all. So why this, now?
“You know I’m leaving. Less than two weeks. And there’s no way—you have to understand that I won’t be coming back.”
There are a couple of terns out over the lake, dipping low in flashes of black and white. It hurts to follow their movements, so Bilbo closes his eyes.
“I’m not asking you to come with me,” Thorin is saying, and Bilbo thinks he must have missed something because that doesn’t understand.
“What?” he asks, tongue thick in his mouth.
“I know you have . . . things. Things to do here. A life, and all that.” Thorin clears his throat, so close that Bilbo feels the rumble. “And what I am trying—what I am going to do is not exactly a brilliant plan. I’ve been told”—he laughs a little, bitterly—“that there are some who would not deem it wise.”
“Speaking in quotations,” Bilbo says, because those words can’t be Thorin’s own.
“Yes.”
Bilbo takes a minute to wonder at that, but there is so much that he has not been told and this is just one more thing added to the list. “I knew this wasn’t forever. I think, probably, that I’ve always known. You’re not the kind of person who does ‘forever’ very well, are you?”
“Because I know that nothing is forever.”
“There you go.”
“Everyone knows that.”
“No,” Bilbo says, and sits up. It’s a struggle, but he makes it, one hand braced on the roof-rack so he doesn’t slip off. “I don’t. I don’t know that.”
“You just don’t want to believe it. But you do know it.” Thorin’s voice is gentle. Bilbo almost wishes he would yell.
“I’ve already lost . . . so much. And I know, I know you have, too, but I just can’t . . . I can’t believe that. Some things have to be forever.”
“Why?” Thorin asks. He knocks his foot against Bilbo’s crossed legs once, twice. “I have seen what comes from thinking that nothing can ever change. It isn’t pretty. To let yourself think that, to get caught up—”
“Can’t it be, though? Can’t things just . . . go on?”
“You’re asking the wrong person if you’re looking for me to say yes. It was my home, Bilbo, it was my family. My father, his father, everyone thought we were invincible. Perfection isn’t real, though, and getting too close to it only spells disaster. It ruins every damn thing it touches.”
They’re quiet after that, thinking, or not thinking. If Bilbo was a little bit braver, he’d call Thorin a hypocrite, because what else is he trying to do but resurrect the past? Bring back that “perfection” he remembers from his childhood? Even now, even with all he’s said to Bilbo about madness and how it runs in the family, about how he hates and blames that insatiable desire that poisoned his ancestors, here he is, planning to go down the same path. He hasn’t said it yet, not exactly, but Bilbo has spent an awful lot of time this past year watching Thorin and he can tell, just from the set of Thorin’s jaw, that the man is lying. Doesn’t believe his own words, and as soon as Thorin leaves his side Bilbo knows the façade will fall away.
It’s like architecture, and so it’s no surprise—Thorin builds up walls. It’s all he knows how to do. A soon-to-be-certified professional at it, in fact.
“You don’t have a home,” Bilbo says, finally, and it’s not an accusation, just him thinking aloud, but Thorin bristles anyway.
“I do,” he says. “Erebor will always be my home.”
“No,” Bilbo says, “or rather, that’s not what I meant. It’s that your home was taken from you. Whereas mine . . .”
“You could go back anytime you wanted.”
“I can’t, though. Not really. It wouldn’t be the same. And I can’t even—you at least can get properly angry about the whole thing. Your fortress, overrun. What did you expect, though, honestly, making so much out of so little? Your family had to have known. It’s like raising a beacon on a hill. It’s asking to be noticed.”
“We did nothing to deserve what was done to us!”
“Didn’t you, though? It’s greed, Thorin, even if you don’t want to say it, and I’m sorry for your loss, truly I am, but I can’t pretend to understand it. Not really.”
“Maybe I should take a torch to your apartment, then,” Thorin snarls. “So you can ‘understand’ how I feel.”
“It wouldn’t make a difference. That place isn’t my home. There’s nothing you can do to make me feel what you are feeling.”
“Don’t test me.”
Bilbo knows he’s being stupid, provoking Thorin, but he has a point here, if only he could get the words out in the right order. Ignoring the way his hands are shaking and how cold he suddenly feels, he pushes forward. “My home wasn’t taken, Thorin. It’s simply . . . gone. I always thought it would be mine someday, you know? It was a constant.” Bilbo presses a hand to his eyes, tries to squeeze out the image of a green front door. “And now it’s gone. Which I suppose is only appropriate, considering what the true constants in our world are. Death, and taxes. That’s what they say, right? Between the two of them, they’ve cost me . . . everything.” He huffs a laugh, deliberate and painfully false, and rolls on his side to look at Thorin.
Thorin’s eyes are a little red, and there’s a tinge of sunburn across his nose and cheeks. The beer is long gone by now but he’s holding an empty bottle, spinning it slowly in his hands. He won’t meet Bilbo’s eyes.
“So now what?” Thorin asks. “When I leave, what will you do?”
“I don’t know. Keep on . . . keeping on, I suppose.”
“You have a life here,” Thorin says, again, and Bilbo shakes his head.
“I have work to do here, but it’s not a life. It’s never felt more than temporary.”
“That’s how gradschool is supposed to feel.”
“That isn’t what I want.”
“What do you want?”
For you to stay, Bilbo thinks, but he can’t ask that. Thorin will leave, because he has to. There are people, more people than just Bilbo, counting on him, and they’ve been doing it for a lot longer than a year. They matter more. Of course they matter more.
“Bilbo?”
Only things I can’t have, Bilbo thinks. That’s what I want. Time, re-wound. My parents, alive. My house, mine. You, with me. “Nothing,” he says. “I don’t want anything.” Because there’s hardly anything left to lose, he reaches over and puts a hand on Thorin’s arm, warm and solid. “Just these last two weeks.”
“You have them. Of course you have them.” There’s an edge of apology in Thorin’s voice and it really isn’t what Bilbo wants to hear.
“Well, then,” Bilbo says, and forces a smile. “Come on, let’s not be maudlin. Or did you drive me all the way out here just to look at the water?”
Thorin looks as if he’s going to say something, and his other hand comes up to rest on top of Bilbo’s, but all he does is stare. Then, with a deep inhale, he pushes himself up and slides off the roof, stripping his shirt as he walks towards the water, tossing a “You coming?” back over his bare shoulder. Bilbo’s eyes trace down the slope of his back before he snaps out of it and looks down at the Volvo instead.
“Jerk,” Bilbo calls out, because Thorin’s left him on the roof and though it isn’t that high, it’s high enough. By the time Bilbo clambers down—ungracefully, over the windshield—Thorin’s in the water, nevermind the fact that it’s still freezing cold. Knowing that this is, probably, the last chance Bilbo will ever get to do this, he forces stubborn fingers through the buttons on his shirt, the zipper on his jeans, and thinks of saunas.
“Just going to stand there?” Thorin taunts as he treads water, trying to hide the chatter in his teeth. “Admiring the view?”
“What view?” Bilbo mutters, and thinks, Oh hell, as he kicks off his jeans and socks and sticks a toe in the water.
“Jump. It’s deep enough.”
“What, and you’ll catch me?”
“Sure.”
“I don’t think so,” Bilbo says, and Thorin raises an eyebrow. He takes a few strokes back to the shallows and waits. “Thorin, I’m taking my time. I have to adjust.”
“No,” Thorin says. “That’s not how it works.” And he surges up out of the water and onto shore, slipping an icy wet arm under Bilbo’s knees and another behind his neck, and Bilbo flails but it’s useless because Thorin is bigger, stronger, faster—naked, Bilbo’s brain supplies—and in seconds they’re both in the lake. Bilbo sputters and splashes towards the shore but Thorin gets an arm around his waist and drags him back, ducks him under.
“Let me go, you brute,” Bilbo gasps out when they surface, but he’s laughing. It’s painfully cold and Thorin’s grinning like a madman. Bilbo would pull away, if he could, and if Thorin wasn’t the warmest thing around. “You’re terrible.”
“This was your idea.”
“It was a bad idea. Very bad.”
“I’m going to remind you of that next time you say you’re always right.” Thorin’s chest is broad and solid against Bilbo’s back, his voice deep in Bilbo’s ear.
“H-hypothermia,” Bilbo stammers, because he can’t think straight and it’s not just the cold.
“You’ll be fine,” Thorin says, but he relents and hauls Bilbo in to shore, dumps him there on the rocky bank before pushing himself up out of the water. Bilbo shivers and tells himself to avert his eyes as Thorin wrings the water out of his hair and walks back towards the Volvo, picking up discarded clothing on the way. Instead of getting into the car, though, Thorin pulls a blanket from the trunk, spreads it on the roof, and sprawls back out up there. Bilbo gives himself a minute or two, dripping in his wet underwear, before following.
“Are you seriously doing this right now?” he asks.
“What does it look like?”
“You’re going to get us arrested,” Bilbo says, but he puts a foot on top of a tire and shoves himself up on top of the car anyway. The wind’s died down and the warmth of the car seeps through the blanket. “Indecent exposure.”
“No one’s looking,” Thorin says. “Unless you are.”
“I’m not!”
“Shame.”
“Idiot.” Bilbo can’t tell, because he is emphatically not looking, but he’s almost positive that Thorin is smirking. He feels the press of a damp knee against his own. An invitation to a truce. This is how they solve problems—they talk in circles, at cross-purposes with one another, and then change the subject, so that they’re left with no real answers, only roles they can fall back on. Thorin is the instigator; Bilbo is used to always being the one who retreats. More and more, these days, he’s wondering if there isn’t another way. Because nothing is forever, Thorin says, and when he says it, it doesn’t sound like such a bad thing.
