Actions

Work Header

How the West Was Won and Where It Got Us

Chapter 10

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

In November, late November, when they hardly know each other, Bilbo and Thorin still end up spending Thanksgiving together. Like most things, it is Gandalf’s fault, but Bilbo does not know this until later, until post-dinner and two bottles of wine, a mutual food coma on the floor of Bilbo’s attic. Thorin simply shows up at his door at five o’clock on Thursday evening, an armful of food and half a scowl. No one has ever rung Bilbo’s doorbell before and it takes him a few seconds to figure out what’s going on. When he goes downstairs to the house’s main door and wrenches it open to see Thorin there, he nearly shuts it again, right in the man’s face, but he does still have some vestige of his mother’s manners and so he stands in the entrance instead and chews his lip. “Won’t you come in,” he says, finally, but doesn’t step back. Thorin brushes past him as he enters, wiping snowy boots on the mat.

            “Going to invite me up?” Thorin asks. “Or do you typically have dinner in the doorway?”

            “O-of course,” Bilbo says. “Er, this way.”

            They make their way up to the second floor, and then up the steep set of stairs to the attic door, Bilbo fretting, Thorin thumping along. When they are standing awkwardly in the center of Bilbo’s apartment, he asks, “Did you say dinner?”

            “It’s Thanksgiving.”

            “I know . . .”

            “I brought meat. You look like you could use some. Real food.”

            Bilbo doesn’t have a proper dining table, or chairs, so they end up cross-legged on the floor, plates balanced on their laps. Thorin is militaristically efficient, setting out the food on Bilbo’s counter, pouring the wine into whatever glassware is on hand, and Bilbo—whether out of sheer surprise or persistent loneliness—lets himself be managed in the same way. They sit beneath the skylight, snow-covered and dim, and Bilbo wonders if it would be appropriate or just ridiculous to light a candle. Ridiculous, probably.

            There’s a tension to the dinner that, while not precisely uncomfortable, nevertheless makes itself felt. Bilbo doesn’t know what to say, to this man he’s known for a scant few weeks, who has made himself comfortable on the floor—and how did he know Bilbo’s address, anyway—with a turkey dinner. Then there’s the fact that it’s Thanksgiving, a family holiday, or meant to be, and neither one of them is saying anything about that. Bilbo’s barely worked up the nerve to ask Thorin what he’s doing here when the doorbell rings again.

            “You’ll want to get that,” Thorin says, when Bilbo makes a startled move.

            “What’s going on?”

            The doorbell rings again. Thorin raises an eyebrow and takes a gigantic forkful of turkey. He chews deliberately. Bilbo wavers, and at a third ring he huffs and stands to go open the door. Brushing snow off their shoulders are two men he’s never seen before. One of them is, if possible, even more intimidating than Thorin. He’s tall and bulky, bearded, hair sticking straight up, tattoos covering arms that are otherwise bare, despite the weather. The other is shorter, rounder, white-haired. He’s smiling at Bilbo while his companion frowns, and that bit of encouragement is enough for Bilbo to take a step back and let them inside.

            “Good afternoon,” the old man says. “Balin, at your service. Is he upstairs, then?”

            “ ‘Course he is.” The tattooed man brushes past Bilbo and heads up the stairs.

            “Do you mean . . . Thorin?” Bilbo asks. “Are you, um, a friend of his, Mr. Balin?”

            “You might say that.” Balin shuts the door behind him and gestures for Bilbo to lead the way. In the attic, Thorin and the other man are embracing and pounding each other manfully on the back. “My brother, Dwalin,” Balin tells Bilbo as they enter his apartment. “And you must be Mr. Baggins.”

            “Oh, no, you can just call me Bilbo. And please, sit down, though . . . wait, I’ll get you a chair.” It’s easier to fall back on formalities, and Bilbo drags his desk chair over for the old man, who is fixing himself a plate as if he’s in his own kitchen, raiding Bilbo’s few cabinets for spices, looking through his fridge.

            “There should be others here,” Thorin says. “But none of them could make it.”

            “More food for us, then,” says Dwalin, piling stuffing onto his plate. “Any beer?”

            “Just, um, just wine,” Bilbo says, and feels bad about it for a second or two until he remembers that this is his apartment, and this is an entirely unexpected party. He can’t be held responsible for not having beer on hand.

            “Ah, well.” Dwalin pours himself a mason jar of wine and sits down next to Thorin. “We’ll get some later.”

            “Later?” Bilbo blurts out, and ducks his head when they all turn to look at him. “Sorry, but . . . what exactly are you all doing here? I don’t mind the occasional guest, truly, but I do like to know them before they arrive, and I wasn’t planning for—”

            “Dwalin, at your service,” Dwalin says, between mouthfuls. “Didn’t you get the message?”

            “What message?”

            “Told us to come, said there’d be food. But hey, where’s Gandalf? Late again, that old coot.”         

            “Now, brother, be kind,” Balin says.

            “You know my uncle?”

            “He’s your uncle?”

            “Well, not strictly speaking, no. Is he coming? I thought he was out of the country, he hasn’t called in months. Are you certain he told you to come here? How do you know him, anyway?” The words come out in a rush and Bilbo has to bite his lip to stop speaking.

            “Balin is a history professor,” Thorin says, and puts a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. His palm is warm, a firm weight, just for a few seconds before he withdraws it. “And my landlord.”

            “Nothing so official,” Balin says. “I’m an old friend, that’s all. And Gandalf and I have often crossed paths. Similar interests, and that style of thing.”

            “So he’s the one behind all this?” Bilbo asks.

            “He’s always behind it,” Balin says. “Whatever it may be. Him being your uncle, I’d have thought you’d have figured that out by now.” He smiles as he says it so the words don’t sting, but still Bilbo lowers his eyes.

            “Any dessert?” Dwalin asks, looking around the apartment.

            “There are some cookies in that jar,” Bilbo says, pointing, hardly done speaking before Dwalin is there with his fist stuffed through the jar’s opening, fighting to get the cookies out. “P-please be careful with that,” Bilbo stammers. “It was my mother’s.”

            “It’s too small.”

            “Sit down, you oaf,” Thorin says, and Dwalin frowns but comes back to sit beneath the skylight. Thorin takes the jar and tips out a cookie. “Here.”

            It’s more hectic than any dinner Bilbo’s ever attended, and he’s been to quite a few, back home. They’re all passing plates around, eating with their fingers, picking at the remains of the turkey. There’s a lot of talk that Bilbo doesn’t understand, about some sort of “quest” that apparently occupies a large part of Thorin’s mind. Dwalin’s sense of humour is violently physical, though fortunately directed primarily at Thorin, who takes the punches with a grin and for the following months anytime Thorin shows up to the studio with a black eye or a split lip, Bilbo will know where it came from. Balin quietly depletes Bilbo’s meagre supply of wine, nodding along with the conversation, and casting Bilbo firm, curious glances.

            “—going with you?” Dwalin is asking, when Bilbo tunes back into the conversation. Everyone is looking at him.

            “Sorry, I was just . . .” Bilbo says, trying to rewind the events in his mind.

            “Told you he was a space case,” Thorin mutters to Dwalin, not quite managing to keep the fondness from his voice. “Nevermind, though.”

            “Have I missed something?” Bilbo asks, looking around the room.

            “Loads,” Dwalin says. “But I guess now’s not the time, hey, Thorin?”

            “I have, haven’t I?” Bilbo asks.

            “Leave it,” Thorin says, and that’s that. He’s difficult to argue with at any time, and now is no exception. Balin produces a pie from somewhere and all serious conversation is lost to clinking forks and bickering over whose slice is larger. Bilbo ends up asleep on the floor, leaning back against the counter, half-full glass of wine between his knees. When he wakes, everyone is gone.

 

---

 

When you’re contemplating how best to break your own arm, and how long a leave of absence that might possibly grant, you know there’s something wrong.

            Bilbo realises this one night, late February. The whole city is buried in snow, wet and dark. He’s up in his attic, looking out the awning windows as cars slush by on the hill. It would be quiet, if not for the headphones in his ears. Thorin’s mp3 player, still somehow in his possession. Bilbo’s phone went off earlier in the evening, startling him as he cooked dinner. Even though he had one now, it was still rare for him to use it, and almost no one had the number. Thorin did, though, and this was a text, out of the blue: Cue up R.E.M., New Adventures in Hi-Fi.

            Any particular reason? Bilbo texted back.

            Bet you’re sulking, Thorin replied.

            And he isn’t sulking, not really, but he isn’t exactly cheerful. In the days since they had spent Christmas and New Year’s together, Thorin has been developing an uncanny ability to read Bilbo’s moods, even from afar. Even when they haven’t seen each other in a while, despite living in the same city.

 

            I didn’t wear glasses ‘cause I thought it might rain.

           Now I can’t see anything.

            I made a mistake, chalked it up to design.

            I cracked through time, space, godless and dry.

            I point my nose to the northern star

            and watch the decline from a hazy distance.

 

            The album’s first song is something called “How the West Was Won and Where It Got Us.” Bilbo thinks this is an unnecessarily long title, but Thorin’s inordinately fond of this group, so he’ll let it slide. The piano’s repetitive and quiet, with some kind of high-pitched synth whine in the background, and the vocalist’s more talking than singing. It’s not something Bilbo would choose to listen to, and Thorin will later tell him that it’s not even his favourite R.E.M. song, but there’s something about it that catches in his mind. Perhaps it’s in the refrain: “The story is a sad one told many times, the story of my life in trying times.” Perhaps it’s the way the bridge is kind of out-of-tune and all over the place, and it’s all too familiar.

            Bilbo thinks Thorin probably likes the title, too. His whole end-goal is some mad quest to reclaim his home, out West. To win it back, as if they’re back in medieval times and people actually go on quests, with magic swords and familial destiny. Where will it get him, once it’s done? They haven’t talked about that. Haven’t so much as mentioned Erebor, except when referring to the dog, since that conversation just a few weeks ago. Bilbo doesn’t know how to bring it up, and Thorin won’t talk about it unless he gets a story out of Bilbo in return, so they’re at an impasse.

            An impasse. The word brings to mind a host of things: a wall, a crevasse, a crack in the land. Something that cannot be gotten over. “Chalked it up to design,” Michael Stipe sings, and Bilbo thinks about the scale model he’s started building up in Milstein. He hasn’t told Thorin yet, though the man’s probably guessed, but it’s his parents’ house, or part of it. The curved walls are a challenge—posterboard and foam-core, scored in a running pattern along the back, bent and shaped around wooden dowels. Thorin told him he should start with a paper model, no colour, Elmer’s glue and drafting tape. But Bilbo’s impatient. Has this unaccountable feeling that time is running out.

            Not all that unaccountable, really. It’s February, and in three months it will be May, and Thorin will graduate.

            So they raided the woodshop on the bottom floor, and the supply cabinets in the print shop, and whatever other rooms they could get in to. The drafting table in the corner that Bilbo uses is stockpiled with spray adhesive, scraps of cloth, balsa strips, needles and thread. Anything a model-builder could want. Bilbo has the house’s proper blueprints in a trunk at the foot of his bed up in his attic, but he’s taken the time to make his own. To use them would feel too much like cheating, and he’s figuring out that there aren’t any shortcuts in this life that lead to good ends. On Saturday morning he started building the tiny vaulted ceilings for each room, painting wood-grain in fine lines, tying black thread into mock-rigging so the whole assembly can be lifted off and the house viewed from the top. Spread open, like a puzzle or a maze.

            Building this model has been like re-fashioning a memory. The elevations for each wall took ages—silent stares and under-the-table drinking during daylight hours, long nights spent with Thorin “educating” him in music. They are nearly perfect in their detail, or as perfect as they can be in 1/8th inch scale. Each bookshelf has rows of books, miniscule spidery writing on their spines. The maps and paintings have been reproduced in miniature, down to the gold paint gilding their frames. If Bilbo was small enough, he could sink down into a velvet-covered armchair, pull the chain on a lamp with a thin paper shade, and curl up with a shred of newspaper. He could run his fingers along the sweep of the walls, trace his toes on the tile in the kitchen.

            There is one room that does not look as it should: his parents’ bedroom. The space where it should be stands empty, just bare walls, a door that only opens from the inside. Bilbo has built it this way on purpose. He does not want to remember it as a sick-bay, as a gathering place for misery.  When his mother died, he pulled the door closed, laid his forehead against it, and tried to wipe the interior from his mind.

            There are a lot of things in his mind he’d like to wipe out, if he is honest with himself. Starting with the look Thorin probably has on his face right now. Bilbo’s just texted him about the whole broken arm/medical leave theory. Apparently gradschool has been teaching him how to develop poor impulse control. The album is on its last track, piano loud through the headphones in Bilbo’s ears. “Your eyes are burning holes through me,” the song starts out, and Bilbo cringes. Again, too familiar.

            His phone rings and he drops it. Fumbling to answer, he sees that it’s Thorin. Bilbo tugs the headphones free and hears Thorin already talking.

            “. . . need to have a conversation about physical safety,” he’s saying. “Or possibly mental instability. For God’s sake, Bilbo, that’s a hell of a conversation starter. Hey, are you even listening to me?”

            “Technically,” Bilbo says, “we were already mid-conversation.”

            “You know that’s not the point.”

            They’re quiet for a bit, tense breathing over the phonelines.

            “I’m coming over,” Thorin says, suddenly. “Stay right there. Don’t move. Don’t go down the stairs.”

            “Thorin, wait, no—” Bilbo starts, but Thorin’s already hung up. Is probably throwing on his waxed cotton jacket, or maybe that buffalo check wool coat, smelling of pipe tobacco as he laces up his boots and starts up his car. Bilbo doesn’t know what to do, so he sits down on the edge of his bed and waits. Soon enough, the Volvo clatters up his street, and then his doorbell is ringing.

            “Hello,” Bilbo says, pulling the front door open. Thorin looks him over, more critically than anyone has looked at him in years.

            “Still in one piece,” Thorin says. He drops a hand onto Bilbo’s head, calloused fingers tangling in sandy-blond hair. As Thorin brushes past and heads upstairs, Bilbo realises that he’s got a military surplus duffle over one shoulder, a sleeping bag in his hand, and a friendly black shadow.

            “You brought your dog?”

            “Thought you might like to see him.”

            “Well, yes, but . . . my landlord doesn’t allow dogs, you know that. Hello, Ere.” Bilbo leans down and pats Erebor absently, still watching Thorin climb the stairs and turn the corner. He sighs. “I guess we can always hope no one will notice, right, boy? Come on.” Erebor follows good-naturedly, his paws quiet on the wooden steps. Thorin has to give the dog a boost up into the attic and then there they are, the three of them, standing together under the eaves.

            “I’ll put on a pot of tea,” Bilbo says, and turns to light the stove. Thorin catches him by the arm, pauses, and then twists his grip, pulling the arm behind Bilbo’s back. The movement wrenches Bilbo’s shoulder and sends a spike of pain through his arm, and he kicks out, on his tiptoes, trying to relieve the pressure. “What’re you doing? That hurts!”

            “Hmm,” Thorin says. “Does it hurt as much as getting hit by a car?”

            “What?”

            “Or maybe falling down a staircase? Would that do it, you think? Break that arm?”

            “Thorin, you’re hurting me.” Bilbo’s prying at Thorin’s grip with his free hand but the man is immobile. An impasse in human form.

            “You mean this isn’t what you wanted? And here I thought I was helping you out.”

            They struggle for a moment, maybe two, and then Thorin huffs and lets go, shakes Bilbo loose. “You’re an idiot,” he says, and slings his bag to the ground. Erebor whines, comes over to lick Bilbo’s dangling hand. His entire arm is throbbing dully. “An absolute idiot.”

            “I wasn’t seriously planning—”

            “Then don’t fucking say it!” Thorin’s hands are tangled in his own hair now, and he yanks them free to scratch Erebor behind the ears instead. “When you say things like that, it makes me— I don’t know what to do.”

            Bilbo sinks to the ground. Sits cross-legged right in the middle of his floor and stares up at the skylight. Erebor leaves Thorin’s side and comes over to drop his head in Bilbo’s lap, heavy, eyes big and dark. Bilbo wraps his arms around the dog, wincing at the twinge in his left shoulder.

            “I don’t know what to do either,” Bilbo says.

            “Next time . . .”

            “Yes?”

            “Next time, just . . . call me. When you start thinking about things like that. Deal?”

            “It’s not as though I go around thinking—”   

            “Do we have a deal?”

            Bilbo drops his gaze from the skylight to Thorin’s face. Beneath the messy hair and beard in need of trimming, there is the usual red tint around his eyes, but a darkness beneath them. “Deal,” Bilbo says, nodding his head.

            “Good.” Thorin returns the nod. He shakes out his sleeping bag on the floor next to Bilbo and stretches out on his back, fingers interlaced beneath his head. “I’m holding you to that.”

            This is how the three of them spend the night: Thorin’s sleeping bag and Bilbo’s quilt on the floor, Erebor curled between them, snow falling heavily on the skylight above.

Notes:

Thanks for your patience, everyone. I really do appreciate it. Summer is an atypical time for me and my schedule's gotten all turned around, so finding time to write has been tough. The Thanksgiving scene was meant to be longer but it wasn't working for me, so I started writing miserable Bilbo instead, which was much more suited to my mood. It's a shorter chapter as a consequence, but I felt bad about leaving you all in suspense for much longer than I meant to. Thanks again for being so kind to me & this story--you're all wonderful.