Actions

Work Header

How the West Was Won and Where It Got Us

Chapter 11

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The second time Bilbo sees Thorin, the weather’s turned cold. It’s a Friday, near the end of October, not quite a week since Bilbo first set foot in the studio up in Milstein. He’s walking back from a small organic market downtown, tea and pasta and a loaf of bread tucked into his satchel, scarf hanging loose around his neck as he climbs back up the hill towards his apartment. The skies are clear, bright blue, so bright it nearly hurts to look up beyond the flaming tree tops, red-gold with the turning season.

            This was always his father’s favourite time of the year.

            The colours turn later, some 300 miles to the south, but they do turn. Bilbo remembers stacking the woodpile with green still on the oaks, acorns crunching underfoot. He used to lie out on the deck behind the house and breathe deep, taking in the crispness of the air, filling himself with the feeling of change. He remembers banking fires and testing the chimney in the old cast-iron stove in the study with the windows open, his mother in the kitchen, apple bread in the oven. Fall is the scent of dust and wood-shavings, the start of winter’s carpentry project, the bite of saw-teeth and the grind of an awl. One winter, when Bilbo was ten or maybe eleven, he helped his father plane the wood for new desk in the library. They built it slowly, a little each day, an after-dinner project. When it was done his mother took a rag and a bottle of tung oil, wiped it into the grooves, her hair falling in smooth golden waves over her shoulders.

            This is what Bilbo is thinking about when a car rolls up beside him, engine loud, and it is Thorin in the driver’s seat, Thorin’s arm hanging out of the window. There’s a wooden boat strapped to the roof-racks and a black dog in the backseat. Thorin idles the Volvo and looks Bilbo over for a minute. “Get in,” he says, reaching over and opening the passenger door. Bilbo just stares at him, the strap of his satchel digging into his shoulder. Whatever song is loud on the stereo has some kind of high, metallic percussion and it’s all he can hear. Then the car behind Thorin pulls out, swerves around them, and startles Bilbo back into himself. He stumbles around the hood of the station wagon and gets inside. Thorin has to reach across him to pull the door shut; Bilbo’s hands are in his lap, uncertain.

            This is probably a bad idea.

            Not because he’s particularly worried—you have to care enough, to be worried—but because he doesn’t know what to expect.

            Instead of turning and heading up the hill, Thorin continues on out of town. They pass the high school, cross over the creek.

 

           Love, I get so lost sometimes.

            Days pass, and this emptiness fills my heart.

            When I want to run away, I drive off in my car,

            but whichever way I go, I come back to the place you are.

 

            “Where are you going?” Bilbo asks when they roll to a halt at a stop sign.

            “We,” Thorin says, “are going to the lake.”

            “Oh,” Bilbo says, because what else is there to say? It’s a phenomenally gorgeous day. He can let this man—still a stranger, nothing more than a name and a temper—drive him to the lake, or he can walk back to his apartment, a mile and a half, and shut himself up in his attic.

            It is, though he doesn’t realise it, a turning point. Thorin puts on the blinker, swings out to the left, and Bilbo’s life changes.

            It isn’t far to the lake. They pass under the highway, cross a railroad track, and pull into a small park along the shore. Thorin backs into a parking space and gets out of the car, opens the backdoor. The dog comes bounding out and does a lap of the parking lot before coming around to look up at Bilbo, who’s still sitting in the passenger seat. Under the dog’s curious gaze, Bilbo unbuckles his seatbelt and climbs out, holding his satchel.

            “Leave that,” Thorin says. “Come give me a hand.” He’s undoing the tie-down straps holding the boat to the roof-racks, and holds them out in a tangle for Bilbo to take.

            “Isn’t it a bit cold for swimming?” Bilbo asks, finding his voice as he sorts through the straps.

            “Not planning on swimming.” The dog’s tail is wagging and he presses himself up against Thorin’s legs. “If you stay there,” Thorin tells him, hoisting the boat onto his broad shoulders, “I’m going to step on you. Go on, Erebor. Get.”

            “Your dog’s name is Erebor?”

            “What of it?”

            “Nothing,” Bilbo says, quickly. “I like it.”

            “Didn’t ask your opinion.” Boat overhead, Thorin turns and heads for the water’s edge. Erebor follows at his heels. Bilbo ties the straps into a neat bundle and leaves them on the car’s backseat, next to his abandoned satchel. Apparently, he too is meant to follow.

            The water looks cold, dark and spreading out far into the distance. Thorin sets the boat down carefully on the rocky shore and dips a hand in. He is in jeans and a flannel shirt, heavy boots, sunglasses. Bilbo tucks his hands into the pockets of his jacket and approaches with caution.

            “This is her maiden voyage,” Thorin says, running a hand along the boat’s gunwales. “Is it yours, too?”

            “I’ll just watch,” Bilbo says. There’s a glint in Thorin’s eye that makes him uncomfortable.

            “Boring. Come on, get in.” Thorin has the boat in the water now, holding it steady as the water laps against its sides. “She’s water-tight.”

            “I’m not exactly a boat person.” Erebor is at the back of Bilbo’s knees, nudging him forward.  In the end, it is the boat itself—herself?—which convinces him. The sides bow and curve so gracefully, shiny with varnish, sanded smooth. The boat rocks as Bilbo clambers in, thinking of his father’s hands on a plane, shaping, shaping. He wonders if Thorin’s hands have done the same. He blinks and Erebor is beside him, and then Thorin is pushing off, oars dipping into the water with barely a sound.

            There’s no one else around. Thorin takes them out around the docks of the sailing school, pulling from the stern. Bilbo looks back over his shoulder and a lapful of large dog and watches him row, his back solid, arms rolling in fluid motion. They put some distance between themselves and the shore and a breeze picks up, tipping the water into white-caps. Erebor steps over Bilbo to stand in the bow, nose to the wind, chin up.

            Later, Bilbo can never remember what they talked about. They were in the boat for an hour, maybe more, and in his mind he can picture it all so clearly—wood, water, man, dog, the vivid reds and blues, trees and sky and water—but it’s like a movie with the sound turned off. Images crisp, audio mysteriously absent.

            He suspects they didn’t say much, because neither of them knew yet who the other was. Either that, or this is just a dream he has invented, to fill in the gaps. To explain why he is so inexplicably at ease around Thorin.

            When they get back to shore, Erebor knocks Bilbo into the lake and it is cold but not as cold as he expected. He treads water for a minute, stunned, while Thorin laughs and wrestles his dog.

            “All right?” Thorin asks him, crouched on a rock, extending a hand. Bilbo takes it and finds himself hauled out of the water, hoisted up as if he weighed nothing. “Damn dog. He gets excited, days like this.”

            “F-fine,” Bilbo says, once his feet are back on solid ground. “A little cold, though.”

            There’s a blanket in the car and Thorin throws it over Bilbo, then lifts the boat back up and ties it to the roof-racks. Erebor looks shame-faced, but only a bit. Thorin starts the car and switches on the heater, turning all vents towards Bilbo. He does not apologise, and Bilbo does not thank him. They just do things, each of them, sort of separately. Bilbo leans in close to the dashboard, fingers spread out to catch the half-hearted stream of warm air. He breathes in deep, lakewater in his nose mixing with the smoke-dust smell of Thorin’s car, and coughs.

            “That was good,” Thorin says, as he pulls to a stop near the cemetery—Bilbo’s common sense has returned to him, and he doesn’t want to give out his actual address. It’s probably foolish, given that he’s just been alone in a boat with this man. Anything could’ve happened. “A good voyage.”

            “I haven’t done anything like that in a long time,” Bilbo says, handing the wet blanket back.

            “We’ll do it again,” Thorin says, and drives away, Erebor’s head hanging out the back window.

            They never do.

            That probably should have been a hint.

 

---

 

In March, after Bilbo has met Azog but before he’s told Thorin about it—and long before Thorin finally tells him why Azog is to be avoided, at all costs—they’re in the studio, working through a rainy afternoon, and Bilbo asks, “Do you remember our deal?”

            Thorin’s quiet for a minute, focusing on his t-square and the compass in his hand. “I do,” he says, but he doesn’t turn to look at Bilbo. Somehow, not having to worry about eye-contact actually makes this easier, what Bilbo’s about to say, and he wonders if Thorin guessed as much and that’s why he’s doing it, or if he’s just being rude. Because it has to be said that Thorin is, often, quite rude.

            “Can I, er, take you up on it?”

            “Go ahead.”

            “I’ve been thinking . . .”

            “. . . About?” Thorin prompts.

            “What I’m doing. Here.”

            “Reading Badiou. Eating a bagel.”

            “What I’m doing . . . existentially.”

            “Oh, God,” Thorin groans, but it’s not a dismissal. Bilbo presses on.

            “Or maybe, how I’m doing what I’m doing. I feel like I’m on auto-pilot. I wake up, I go to class, I eat lunch, I go home. Read, or nap. My days all feel the same.” Bilbo toys with the staple on his handout—it is Badiou, Thorin was right, but he isn’t really reading it. “It’s as though all of this might as well not be happening.”

            “What would make it more real for you?”

            “I don’t know.”

            “If you’re going to suggest something idiotic again, like bodily harm—”

            “No. No, I don’t want . . . I just feel pointless. Anyone else could be doing what I’m doing.”

            “Sure,” Thorin says. “But they’re not. You are.”

            “Don’t you ever feel that way, though?”

            “My problem is more the opposite.” Thorin spins his compass in one hand. “No one else is doing what I’m doing. Explains why I can’t find a job.”

            “Maybe I should change my course of study.”

            “To what?”

            “I don’t know. I’ve been doing some research into Anglo-Saxon history. Battle poetry, and archaeology . . . maybe I’d be more suited to that.” He doesn’t tell Thorin that Azog is charming, in a frightening way, and is luring Bilbo farther and farther afield.

            “So change.”

            “But I don’t think it would help. Not really, I mean.”

            “So don’t change.”

            “Thorin, it’s not that simple.”

            “All you can do,” Thorin says, finally turning to look at him, “is keep going, or give up. Those are basically your only options.”

            “Are you telling me to give up?”

            “If you want to.”

            “But I can’t. I need the funding. And even if I’m . . . dissatisfied with what I’m doing, I don’t know what else I’d rather do.”

            “Then you keep going. Look, if you’re on auto-pilot for a while, then you’re on auto-pilot. You get things done. Maybe they’re shitty. Maybe you don’t care. But you’re doing something. Which is a hell of a lot more than can be said for most of my classmates. You see any of them here? No. They think they can coast by, on parental money, on family legacy. They’re here killing time.”

            “Isn’t that what I’m doing?” Bilbo asks.

            “You’re waiting,” Thorin says. “There’s a difference. Someday, you’ll get your act together.”

            “Will I, though?”

            “Now you just sound pathetic.”

            “That really isn’t what I want to hear from you.”

            “I’m not good at emotional counseling. Deal with it.”

            “I don’t want to deal with it,” Bilbo says, and there is the real problem. He crumples Badiou and stands, crosses the studio to the stereo. There’s a song that’s been on his mind these days, and it’s almost certainly the wrong song to play now—it’s too heavy, the wrong ending to a conversation they were so close to having—but he plays it anyway.

            The thing about this song is that it suits them too well. “They measure the room,” it says, and, “they know the score,” and what do Bilbo and Thorin have if not that? The boundaries are clear. “Come on, come on,” and, “We were only just beginning,” and they keep going ‘round, coming back to where they started.

 

            We have the answer to all your fears.

            It’s short, it’s simple, it’s crystal clear.

            It’s roundabout and it’s somewhere here,

            lost amongst our winnings.

           

            The thing about this song is that there’s so much potential and it just fails. There’s a resignation that’s more profound than anything Bilbo can put into words. There is no train here, not in this life, for him to catch. All he has is this room, this score. He has to make it work, but how? The bass is slow, methodical, the beat inescapable. The chorus nearly makes him cry. He is not going to go find some creative way to injure himself, doesn’t want to do anyone harm—what he wants is to not have to do anything. Not to be the one in charge of his own life. Not to have to decide what it is he doesn’t want to do.

            “Lift up your voice,” the song tells him, but what is there to say?

            When the song ends, the quiet that falls over the studio is so thick Bilbo can hardly breathe. It takes him all his strength to put one foot in front of the other and walk away. They leave the studio, both of them, separate, disheartened. They don’t speak for three days.

 

---

 

It’s quiet, when it finally happens. A Saturday night that could be any Saturday but it’s not. It’s the twenty-seventh of April. The two of them are on Thorin’s couch, Erebor curled up underneath the desk. Bilbo doesn’t really know what he would have expected—feels like he shouldn’t have expected anything—but he thought there would be more of a soundtrack. At least some old Western playing in the background. But the television’s off, and the only noise is the hum of the refrigerator and their own breathing, loud, open-mouthed. Everything registers as if in a dream: the well-worn softness of Thorin’s flannel shirt, exactly how broad his shoulders are beneath Bilbo’s hands, the way the couch is definitely too cramped for this. It’s all there, noticeable, but not really important. Think about any one detail too long and it starts to slip away.

            He’s still wearing his socks, and that should be ridiculous, but it isn’t. They’re woolen, burgundy, just a little tight around his ankles. They’re leftover from his childhood and he has become attached.

            Thorin’s fingers are rough and warm against his jaw, tracing lines down his throat. Feeling out the architecture of his body—support beams, pivot points.

            “I won’t break,” Bilbo says, and Thorin answers, his voice hoarse, “You might.”

            It’s true. He might. They don’t know, either of them, what they’re doing. Not really. Not with each other. Six months, more or less, and all they’ve done is learn how to orbit. Going in circles around each other, a push and pull that never leads anywhere.

            Well. They’re somewhere, now. Bilbo shifts his hips and one of Thorin’s knees falls between his own. They’re somewhere Bilbo has never been before. He suspects Thorin has, sometime, with someone, but he doesn’t want to ask. It just seems like the sort of thing that might’ve happened, maybe after a long night of drinking, maybe more than once. There’s a confidence about Thorin that Bilbo is trying very hard to match and he knows he’s falling short.

            Bilbo isn’t wearing his glasses. Thorin’s face and hands are in focus, close. Around his waist, things start to waver. Anything below that is a blur, muted colours, fuzzed edges. When their foreheads press together he blinks and closes his eyes.

            It’s taken a lot to get them here. He doesn’t want to look back and have it all be gone. Or, worse, look back and watch it go.

            Thorin’s hands are lower now, pushing up his sweater, at the waistband of his jeans. Tight—he’s been eating too much dessert lately. It is Thorin’s fault.

            But isn’t it his own fault, too? If he’s being honest with himself, isn’t he also responsible for this? Can he really say that Thorin has changed him, has brought him this far?

            Isn’t it more that they’re changing each other?

            Bilbo doesn’t want to be thinking about that now. He opens his eyes again, thinking about how very blue Thorin’s are, such a pale blue. “Hey,” he says.

            “Mmmwhat?” Thorin’s breath is hot against his stomach. His legs are heavy atop Bilbo’s own, pressing them into the couch cushions.

            “. . . Nothing,” Bilbo says. Thorin draws back, takes his hands away.

            “We don’t have to—” he starts to say, but Bilbo shakes his head.

            “This is fine.”

            Thorin frowns at that. Like “good,” “fine” has become a loaded word for the two of them. It doesn’t mean what you think it means.

            “I like this,” Bilbo clarifies, but can’t look Thorin in the eyes as he says it. Blushing, he turns his head, studies the fibers of the cushion instead. “Just . . . I don’t . . .”

            “I know,” Thorin says, and leans back in.

            So they still can’t put their thoughts into words. Does that matter, if now they are finishing each other’s sentences?

            Maybe, Bilbo thinks, it should.

            Or maybe he thinks too much.

Notes:

I don't have a definite number of chapters yet, but as you can probably tell, things are drawing to a close. Or rather, Thorin & Bilbo are getting closer, as is the date of Thorin's departure. What next? Your guess is probably as good as mine, haha. We'll see.

I just wanted to thank you all for reading and for leaving such fantastic, engaging feedback. I love reading your thoughts/responses, and can't even express how much my mood improves whenever I go to read comments. I'm going to go stop listening to Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds now, because Bilbo's thoughts about that song are my own, and I don't have time to sit around, staring at walls.

Hope you're all doing well!