Chapter Text
They do finally finish their conversation on families that same January, one night—it seems they always talk at night—maybe a week after Bilbo’s recovered, both from his fever and his anger at Thorin’s pressing for details. Looking back at it, the anger was probably unfair. After all, he never gave Thorin the chance to say no to him. He just poked around the man’s house, without permission.
He can’t help it. It is a weakness he has always had, since he was small and used to go visiting relatives—until recent years, he’s always had an awful lot of relatives. Left to his own devices, he’d open their drawers and cabinets, wander from room to room, toast in hand, fingers sticky with jam, munching and . . . well, snooping is probably the right word for it. He became accustomed to snooping. It’s nearly irresistible, to be in someone’s house and amongst their belongings, and if they’re not around to watch you do it (though even when said relatives were just in the next room, Bilbo had always been good at staying unnoticed, had always been the smallest of his cousins) the urge to snoop is overwhelming. Besides, Bilbo thinks, Thorin can’t have minded that much, or surely he would have trained Erebor to bite anyone who so much as cracked the spine of a book. It seems the sort of thing Thorin would do. But Erebor, for all his watchful stares, hardly so much as barked when Bilbo snooped.
When his mother died, and their bedroom was finally empty, that was the first time he did not want to go around opening drawers, pulling things off of shelves. And yet he had to, for the lawyers and for the last few relatives and for the auction houses. It had to become almost automatic. Reach out a hand, grab, place in box. Tape up box. Move on. If he stopped to think about what he was packaging up to be sold in some antiques mall, he would have more than just dust in his eyes.
Why are people so ashamed of crying, anyway? At twenty-three, Bilbo still cries at least once every two weeks. Sometimes more. Never loudly, and never in front of people, but it’s a physical reaction to emotion, just as valid any other. He’s tried punching walls before and all it got him was bloodied knuckles. Crying is far easier.
Thorin probably never cries. Thorin probably punches walls and doesn’t even bleed.
When they talk about families again, then, it is beyond surprising that things go as well as they do. A conversational failure by other people’s standards it may be, but for them, it is success. Perhaps both of them are just tired, too tired to argue, to do anything more than speak in low voices, some re-run of Lonesome Dove on the television and a bottle of whisky not-quite-forgotten beneath the couch. Bilbo has his feet tucked beneath him and a hand hanging down to rest atop Erebor’s sleeping head. The dog is warm, warmer than he in his two sweaters and Thorin’s quilt, tossed down from the loft earlier in the evening. Thorin has his socks off, his head tilted back against the couch, his shoulders sunk into the cushions, legs on the coffee table. They are as far away from each other as it is possible to be on such a small couch, which is to say, not very far.
“Your father sounds like a good man,” Thorin says, speaking more to the open ceiling than to Bilbo’s face. Hanging on twine and binder-clips from the exposed beams is a series of sketches for his latest hypothetical restoration project, some abandoned church in a town no one has ever heard of. Not on any map. That is Thorin’s life’s work, though. Doing things far away, in forgotten places. Bilbo wants to ask what the point is, but he can’t answer that question for himself and knows he has no right.
“He was. A good man. He was always . . . patient. Kind. He, um”—Bilbo pauses, licks his lips—“he taught me a great deal.”
“I think,” Thorin says, “my father could have learned from him. If their paths had ever crossed.”
And they both know that would never have happened, but still, the sentiment is there. That has to count for something, right?
Bilbo is warm and sleepy. He feels nearly at ease—a feeling that has, only very recently, stopped terrifying him every time he catches himself in the midst of it. It doesn’t make sense now, talking about his dead parents, that he should be at ease. Normally, he would have quietly fled the room and quietly been sick in the toilet, by this point in the conversation. Normally, no one would notice. Here, though, now, Thorin is looking at him, straight at him, piercing blue bright against the dimness of the garage.
“What I miss most isn’t anything in particular,” Bilbo says, blinking, because he’s beginning to suspect he’s under some sort of spell. “You know, people ask you . . . but what do they know? Afterwards . . . I hated everyone.”
“Bilbo, I don’t think you’re capable of hate.”
“I am,” Bilbo assures him, and tries to force his mouth to cooperate into a smile, to belie the words he speaks. “Someday, you may even see it firsthand.”
“Don’t say that.”
“You think too much of me.”
“And you think too little. Have some fucking confidence.”
Bilbo laughs a little, helplessly. The sort of laughter—and he recognises this—that people do when they have lost control of things. If only it were that easy. “At the funeral,” he says, slowing his breath, “I had to give a eulogy, right, and of course when my father passed away I was still in high school, I was seventeen, and my mother . . . she stood there next to me. Held my hand. It was—God, embarrassing, in a way, probably, but also the only thing I wanted at that moment. I mean, the only thing that was conceivable to have. Obviously, if it had been po—” Bilbo breaks off, clears his throat. He runs his fingers over Erebor’s brow. “But then last summer I had to do the same for my mother. And I . . . I couldn’t even get the words out.”
Thorin shifts on the couch, sets a hand on Bilbo’s leg. Because he hasn’t bothered to sit up, his hand lands somewhere halfway up Bilbo’s thigh. In a way, the awkwardness of it is more reassuring than the gesture itself. Thorin’s fingers tense, briefly, and then relax. He doesn’t move his hand.
“But there wasn’t anyone else around to say them, so I had to. Man up, right?” Bilbo wipes at his eyes with a sleeve—apparently, this week is a three-timer. “You’re always telling me . . . And I know, I know that it’s just . . . how life goes. You get older, your parents die. It happens to everyone. And it’s not as though it was any surprise. She’d—she’d been sick for a long time. And people said it was better that— Perhaps I’m just being selfish. But I don’t think . . . Hell, Thorin, I don’t think I’ll ever be over it.”
Thorin doesn’t say anything at first. His fingers tighten a little on Bilbo’s leg again. “Having time to ‘prepare’ doesn’t help. People say it does, but it really, really doesn’t.”
On the old television’s screen, Gus is fighting the Comanchero gang. Night falls, and then there’s silence across the scene. Bilbo fidgets, plays with the cuff of his sweater. Tries not to look at Thorin’s hand, at his leg, at both of them, together.
“You don’t have to be over it,” Thorin says. He fishes the bottle of whisky out from under the couch with his other hand and takes a swig. “Whoever tells you that is an asshole. Losing a parent—both parents—it’s not something you just stop thinking about.”
“Last time I asked you about your father you threw a plate at my head,” Bilbo says, and he reaches out for the whisky without turning to look. Thorin passes it to him and he drinks, a larger sip than he meant. It burns his tongue and throat, smooth and strong. “What do you have on hand this time?”
“I . . . Nothing. Shut up.”
“So I can ask you about him, then?”
“No.”
“You told me he went mad,” Bilbo says, and holds the whisky out of reach when Thorin puts a hand out for the bottle. Deflecting, deflecting. He cannot talk about his own parents any more. Not tonight. If he can crack Thorin’s story, though—he feels, in some way, that it would help. “Told me that you were going mad, too. Should I be expecting you to . . . go the way of your father?”
“No,” Thorin says, his voice a growl. “Fuck. That won’t happen. I refuse to let that happen.”
“If I give you the whisky back, will you tell me about him?”
“No.” But Thorin takes the whisky from Bilbo anyway. He swirls it in its bottle, staring at the amber liquid. “I won’t be able to make you understand.”
“Try.”
“I said no!”
“Thorin, you owe it to me to try.” Bilbo wants to tell himself it’s not the tears in his eyes that convince Thorin to break his silence, but it probably is.
Pathetic.
“I could make it sound heroic,” Thorin says, still tilting the whisky bottle in his hand. “Tell you he died in combat. That’s what I used to tell myself. He was combative as hell, all right, but he never— Damn it, Bilbo, I don’t even know how he died. Just know he’s dead.”
Thorin’s father was called Thrain, the son of Thrór, and Bilbo almost makes a joke about how both their families favour first-names of the same letter. Thorin doesn’t talk much about his grandfather, just says that he took the loss of their home hard, far harder than anyone else, and died not long after. Died somewhere far away, and when Bilbo asks how they’re certain Thorin says, “They sent us the body,” but won’t say who “they” were. Or perhaps, given the way his eyes narrow and his face gets hard, “they” still are. Out there, somewhere, tormenting Thorin by their very existence. Bilbo’s read his share of stories and it’s all very darkly poetic, the exiled man dying in disgrace. Exiled king, usually. But of course, this is real life, Thorin’s life, and there are no kings.
Thorin tells Bilbo that his family went south after losing Erebor, south where it was either farmland or desert, with nothing in between. Miles and miles of dry grass plains and black, worthless rock. He tells Bilbo about their days living as traveling salesmen, moving from town to town, working odd jobs. Homeless, essentially. Thorin never finished his schooling. Had a mother, a younger sister, and a kid brother to look after. Learned to weld when he was fifteen, worked in automotive repair shops, hung around construction sites and got paid under the table for installing grain elevators and rigging windmills.
His father—Thorin’s voice only cracks once—before he died, had become an alcoholic, consumed with rage over the injustice of losing their home. Obsessed with gaining it back. Again he’s making it sound like a battle, and Bilbo can’t understand, because from what he knows it just sounds like the land went bust and they had to move on. Who is there even to fight?
“Before,” Bilbo says, aiming for tact but probably falling short, “you said something about an invasion.”
“Yes.”
“Was it, um, government? Bureaucracy, that sort of thing?”
“No.”
Thorin’s fingers are white around the neck of the bottle. Bilbo clears his throat and tries again. “I don’t understand,” he says, “why you couldn’t just go back and try again.”
“It’s the desert,” Thorin says, as if that’s an answer.
“You were . . . fighting the desert?”
“No. Yes. In a way.” Thorin sighs and drags a hand across his face. His beard needs a trim and there’s graphite smudged across one cheek. He looks exhausted. “This really isn’t something I talk about.”
“Thorin, I’ve been here for six months now and out of everyone I’ve met—fellow cohort mates, professors, everyone—you’re the only one . . . the only person I can ever actually talk to. But I feel like you don’t trust me. You demand, you argue, and fine, perhaps you don’t like speaking about your family, but I know almost nothing about you!”
“You know enough.”
“No, I don’t.”
“This isn’t a quantifiable thing. Knowing somebody. You don’t get to decide when it’s enough.”
“If I don’t, who does?”
“No one.”
“So we just talk around each other for the rest of the year, and then you faff off to some stupid old castle, and I never hear from you again? No. No, Thorin, I can’t— Please don’t make me do this again.”
“Do what?” Thorin asks. “And what the hell do you mean, ‘faff off’? I don’t ‘faff.’ I don’t even know what that is.”
“Don’t make me lose someone again,” Bilbo says, interrupting. “Not just when I thought that we were getting somewhere, you and I. Finally.”
“We are,” Thorin says, and turns suddenly to look at Bilbo, his eyes still just as blue. “We have gotten somewhere.” He frowns. “Haven’t we?”
“Then please, talk to me. I . . . want to feel that this goes both ways.”
“What does?”
“Our relationship,” Bilbo says, and cringes. “Friendship.”
“I don’t have friends.”
“I’ve noticed,” Bilbo says, dryly. He pulls a throw pillow around from behind him, holds it against his chest. “In all seriousness, though, I can’t help . . . I can’t stop wanting to know more about you.”
“You’re too damn curious.”
“I’m just trying to understand you.”
“Not some puzzle to be solved.”
“No, that’s not what I meant. It’s . . . been a long time since I’ve felt that I understood anyone. You could be my first.” Bilbo lifts his head and smiles, hesitantly. Thorin looks him in the eye for a long while, lips pressed into a tight line, and then flushes and knocks his head back against the couch again. Closes his eyes.
“You’re hopeless,” he says, but some of the tension leaves his shoulders. “Absolutely fucking hopeless.”
The mountain, Erebor, is a lone peak, surrounded by desert. When Thorin’s family delved into the mountain to re-start the mine, they found a spring. In the desert, water is wealth. With a river flowing out, down the canyon and into the lake some miles away, Erebor turned green. High limber pines, quaking aspen, sage underfoot everywhere. Standing tall above the grass plains and red-rock canyons, Erebor thrived.
The lakewater was no good, contaminated by minerals from the soil, a beautiful blue-green to look at but impossible to drink. Still, people had settled along its edges, trying to eke a living out of the marshland while above them Erebor’s river flowed, and its streams of silver grew, and now Bilbo starts to see where the envy might’ve come in.
“You can’t imagine,” Thorin says, “what it’s like out there. Such broad, open spaces . . . nothing, for miles around. Windmills. Cattle. But no industry, and farming requires irrigation and that’s expensive. Most people can’t afford it. And then there we were, with everything you could have wanted. It’s not like we didn’t share—we tried to reach out. Had great markets and fairs, held feasts. But it wasn’t enough, I guess. They never accepted us there, on the mountain, succeeding where too many others had failed. I think it seemed like we were . . . lording it over them. Ivory tower mentality, and all that, except when people talk about that here it’s all academia and accessibility and out west it means you’re a target. Giant fucking bulls-eye, right where everyone can see.”
Thorin’s hands are in his hair now, twisted, and his feet are planted on the floor. Erebor whines and shifts to lay across them. Thorin doesn’t even blink. “I can’t just go back. There’s nothing now to go back to. I told you they torched the land.”
“Yes, but . . . surely you could have rebuilt? Even if the neighbours didn’t like you—”
“You’ve never seen a brush fire, have you?” Thorin asks, and shakes his head. “You’re such an—You’re so naive. They didn’t come knocking on the doors, give us all fair warning. They didn’t just drive us out and then burn our houses one by one in neat little rows. They set fire to the mountain, Bilbo—all of it. Eight thousand feet of flame.”
“Oh, God,” Bilbo chokes out, but words are pointless. He hesitates, reaches out, and then withdraws his hand, fingers flexing uselessly in his lap. He’s never been good at offering comfort. For all that Thorin is standoffish he’s also inexplicably good at the physical, at hands on shoulders or tops of heads at precisely the right moment, and Bilbo can’t compete. So he just listens.
“We were still down in the mines,” Thorin is saying. “A lot of us . . . didn’t make it out. I was near the surface. One of the first ones to realise what was happening. Not that it did me any good. I tried to sound the alarm, get everyone out, but— I was just a kid, Bilbo. I was fucking fourteen years old and they burned my home and my family with it. And I couldn’t a goddamn thing to stop them.”
“You keep saying ‘they,’ ” Bilbo says, his voice tight, asking questions because he does not know how to offer comfort and because he really is too damn curious. One of these days, it is going to wreck him. He knows this. “Who did this to you?”
“Does it matter?” Thorin asks. “There was an inquiry, years later. Never found anything. Fire caused by lightning strike, the official reports said. I thought . . . I thought I saw someone, just before the flames caught, but afterwards I couldn’t be sure. Wanted to blame it on anyone, just to have someone to get revenge on, but there was nothing we could do. All the ash and the—the bodies . . . it all poisoned the spring. Whatever didn’t burn died. The mines caved in. We lost all our tools, too, so even if anyone’d had the strength to try to open up the mountain again it would’ve been hopeless. The land’s ruined now. We’re ruined.”
“But . . . did no one come to help? All of you there, they must have known how many people lived on the mountain . . . surely someone would have come?”
“They came,” Thorin says, and the bitterness in his voice is so clear it makes Bilbo’s stomach twist. “They came to watch it burn, and when we called to them from the flames they turned away.”
“Who would do that? Why?”
“I told you, Bilbo. Envy.”
“That’s not a reason! Not to let people die!”
“You have more honour than their entire breed.”
“Sorry, breed?” Bilbo asks. “What do you mean?”
“My father had a certain . . . subset of enemies, among the lake-dwellers. They resented us for breaking the natural order of things, or some such bullshit. I mean they didn’t like us mining,” Thorin clarifies, when Bilbo looks at him with raised eyebrows. “Eco-journalists, only interested in documenting crises. They don’t care about people. Only about the trees. I hate all of them.”
“Is there even such a thing?”
“I hate a hell of a lot more than you do.”
“I don’t doubt that. I was doubting the . . . eco-journalists.”
“I don’t want to talk about them,” Thorin says, and because he says “want” rather than commands, Bilbo doesn’t press the matter. Instead, he asks,
“So when you say you want to reclaim Erebor—”
“I’m starting from nothing. Less than nothing. We don’t even have the deeds to the land anymore. No one was very concerned with paperwork when there were kids on fire.”
Bilbo feels like now might be the time, after all, to go throw up.
“I have to take it back,” Thorin says. “I owe them that much.”
“Owe who?”
“My family. Everyone. They’re counting on me.”
“Surely you can’t do it alone.”
“You’re the last person I need doubting me.”
“No, I don’t, I just meant . . . isn’t there anyone who can help?”
Thorin shakes his head. Sighs, deflates, presses his hands to the back of his neck. “There are some who would. If I asked them.”
“Ask.”
“I can’t.”
“Then, I’ll ask for you.”
“You? Yeah, right.”
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
“We’re out of whisky.”
“Thorin,” Bilbo says. Pleading? Warning? He doesn’t even know.
“Bilbo,” Thorin answers, matching his inflection, mocking.
Bilbo, as usual, caves first. “Look,” he says, reaching for the remote. “It’s late. Let’s just finish the show, and get some sleep.”
Sleep comes before the end of Lonesome Dove, and neither of them make it upstairs to the bed—Thorin’s bed, though Bilbo had won ownership for the night via rock-paper-scissors—and when morning breaks, late, cold and grey and foggy over both of them, a new kind of understanding has settled in.
Like the morning sun your eyes will follow me.
As you watch me wander, curse the powers that be.
‘Cause all I want is here and now,
but it’s already been and gone.
Our intentions always last that bit too long.
They eat breakfast without speaking, each fearing that the other will break the moment first.
----
Thorin’s advisors aren’t happy. Bilbo walks in on them mid-morning, late April—the twenty-ninth of April, to be precise, and Bilbo almost didn’t come to the studio at all—and while they’re not quite yelling at him, because yelling at any student is frowned upon and yelling at Thorin is probably tantamount to suicide given the man’s temper, they’re certainly annoyed. They’re taller than him, Bilbo observes, but Thorin seems bigger, leaning against his drafting table with crossed arms and a scowl. He has a black eye, again.
Bilbo is a natural lurker and it seems a shame to waste an opportunity, so he hangs back in the doorway and holds his breath.
“You’re not taking this seriously,” a thin man, bearded, wearing argyle, says.
“We’re on your side here,” another says, this one a woman with a sharp bob, a maroon dress. “We want you to get hired.”
“I have standards,” Thorin says, typically argumentative.
“Well, lower them,” the man says. “Look, your work is outstanding, no one’s denying, but you can’t expect to make a living doing this sort of thing. There simply aren’t any positions for . . . medieval castle restoration.”
“I don’t care,” Thorin says. “I have other things on my mind.”
“Yes, I’ve noticed,” the man says.
“Your weekend tutorials,” the woman says, “does anyone ever come?”
“Yes,” Thorin says.
“Besides you?”
“Yes.”
“So you’ve had practice teaching the practical skills,” she says, and makes a note in her composition book. “We do sometimes hire on students as lecturers—”
“No,” Thorin says. “I’m not staying here.”
“Beggars can’t be choosers, so on, so forth,” the man says. “You have to compromise.”
“There are some things that are too important to compromise.”
“Is it this argumentative nature of yours that gets you into so many fights?” the woman asks.
“I don’t get into fights.”
“Oh, so then you run into doors?”
“No.”
The man raises a hand to the woman’s elbow, gentle but his meaning is clear: Let it go. For now, at least, it seems that they are going to. “Compromise,” the man repeats, as they head for the door. Bilbo just manages to slip behind a coat-rack and there he waits for them to pass. After a minute or two—after enough time for Thorin’s fists to unclench—he walks in.
“Not done yet?” Thorin asks, but then lifts his head and says, “Oh. You.”
“Hello.”
It’s as if they hardly know each other again. As if everything has been undone, or rather, re-done, except with different details. Bilbo supposes that’s what happens. At least, it seems to happen to characters in literature, and given that he doesn’t have any other basis for comparison and definitely doesn’t have anyone to ask, that’s his current operating theory.
Bilbo slides up onto a stool at the table across the aisle from Thorin’s and pulls out a sheaf of papers—notes for an essay he is meant to be writing, photocopies of passages of Benjamin on story-telling and memory. These are all things he used to know. The past-him, before Saturday re-wired his mind.
Thinking about that is making him blush so he says instead, “Bad morning?”
“You heard?”
“Kind of hard not to. They came . . . very close to shouting.” Bilbo folds a few pages back. “You restrained yourself admirably, though. Good on you.”
“Shut it,” Thorin says, but he’s smiling a little and he’s started re-arranging the paints on the table, so that’s progress.
“I don’t have class until two-thirty so I thought I might read here for a bit. If that’s all right.”
Thorin makes a noncommittal noise and wipes paint on his pants, three streaks of grey against the tan-brown of his Carhartts. They match the streaks of grey in Thorin’s hair, premature, just at the temples. Bilbo hadn’t noticed it until Saturday. Hadn’t been close enough to notice.
It proves fantastically difficult to get any work done. Thorin is cleaning and—shockingly—whistling. Bilbo doesn’t recognise the tune but then, why would he? Thorin is always the one bringing new music into play. His sleeves are rolled and Bilbo can see bruises on the tanned skin as Thorin washes out brushes and stacks reference magazines. Bruises that weren’t there two days ago. Getting into fights. Running into doors. Whatever it is that Thorin is doing, it’s leaving marks.
“So . . . no job offers yet?” Bilbo asks.
“Rejected soundly, four times in a row. Got the letters this morning.”
“Sorry.”
“I didn’t want those jobs.”
“But you need a job, Thorin. Somewhere.”
“I have a duty.”
“Duty doesn’t pay for dinner,” Bilbo says, and then clamps his mouth shut. Those aren’t his words—they have always belonged to his father. But his father is gone, and apparently something of the old Baggins conservative mien has found its way into Bilbo’s own mind. It is slightly horrifying, actually, to be so practical and yet at the same time spend so many of his weekends curled in bed, reading novels.
Well. Apart from last weekend. Which he is emphatically not thinking about.
“I don’t care. Like I told my advisors, I really don’t care. I don’t want to argue about this with you.”
“No, I don’t— I don’t want to argue either, Thorin.”
“Good.” They go back to their own silences, Thorin organising stacks of scrap foam-core and Bilbo idly marking pages. The stereo is unusually quiet, so quiet Bilbo can’t make out the tune.
“You will tell me, though, right?” Bilbo asks, after a while.
“Tell you what?”
“When you’re leaving. You’ll . . . say goodbye. Won’t you?”
“ ’Course I will,” Thorin says, and Bilbo has never yet known him to lie, not really, but there’s something about the way he says this now that cannot be believed.
“Promise?” Bilbo asks.
“I’ll tell you,” Thorin says. Not really an answer. But then, Bilbo wasn’t really expecting one. He will have to be vigilant, he realises, if he is to keep this thing—whatever it is that they have going—alive. He will have to haul himself out of the gradschool daze and pay attention.
At least it will give him something to wake up for in the mornings.
“Come for dinner tonight,” Thorin says, suddenly right in front of Bilbo. His hands are on the drafting table, their fingertips stained with paint, a piece of twine looped around one wrist. He smells like damp dog and stale beer and Bilbo is starting to put together last night’s probable chain of events. He can picture Thorin pacing the garage, Erebor pawing at the door, the two of them walking into town in the rain. So maybe Bilbo wasn’t the only one having doubts, afterwards.
Does the black eye figure into that story, somewhere?
Are the doubts enough to tear this all down, all these walls they’ve built and—more recently—all these doorways?
“What?” Bilbo says, after it’s been a minute and Thorin hasn’t moved, after he remembers that there was a question in there, somewhere, even if it wasn’t phrased like one.
“Dinner. Come. I’ll pick you up. Just— Will you?”
“Of course, but—”
“Great,” Thorin says, and Bilbo thinks, That’s the first time I’ve heard him say that. His ears are warm the rest of the day and if he cannot say exactly why, at least no one asks him to explain. There are some perks, it seems, to not having friends.
They have dinner that night, and then every night that week. Somehow, despite all the opportunities, neither one of them manages to bring up the fact that in another week, maybe two, three at the absolute most, Thorin will be leaving.
Every day, Bilbo waits for a goodbye.
