Chapter Text
They’ve had fights before but not like this one.
The thing about it is, it’s completely unfounded. Or at least, that’s what Bilbo will keep telling himself, afterwards, still seething as he huffs down the stairs of Rand Hall. Thorin’s just being rude again, as usual, rude and overbearing and insensitive. If Bilbo used such language with any kind of freedom, he’d be tempted to call Thorin a dick.
Somewhere, two or three floors above him, Thorin has probably broken a window by now. Bilbo’s never seen him so physically angry—not even when he faced down Azog in the parking lot just two days ago. If he stopped to let himself think about it he’d probably be too terrified to move, and then Thorin might catch up with him, so Bilbo forces himself to keep breathing and concentrates on how firm the concrete steps are beneath his feet, how heavy the building’s doors are to push open. Solid things. Tangible. As far away from his usual state of near-perpetual reflection as possible.
Out on the Arts Quad the air hasn’t yet lost its winter chill. It’s early evening, with rain just beginning to streak in from over the lake, and the lights across campus are blurred. It’s also entirely possible that he’s crying. Either way, Bilbo tugs his glasses off and rubs the lenses with the sleeve of his sweater. Useless, because wool is always useless for cleaning glasses, and why isn’t he carrying a handkerchief? He always carries a handkerchief.
It’s only then that he notices his hands are shaking.
He doesn’t have it in him to walk all the way home just yet—his knees, too, seem to have lost their steadiness—so he detours over to the chapel. For some reason, being there reminds him of being home. He puts it down to the woodworking, to the roundness of windows, and doesn’t question it any further. It’s empty and dark inside, so Bilbo tucks himself into one of the pews on the east annex. Hidden in that muffled quiet that comes in sacred spaces, pressed up into a corner between brick and soft-worn wood with the painted ceilings high overhead, Bilbo closes his eyes. His left shoulder hurts from where Thorin threw him against the elevator doors. By morning, it will be bruised a dark purple.
Thorin had taken him by surprise. Came up from behind and picked him up bodily without a word, dragged him out of the library and into the hall. The single librarian at the circulation desk looked shocked but said nothing, which is most people’s default response when confronted by Thorin in one of his moods. Bilbo, not being most people, protested.
“What on earth are you doing?” he demanded, twisting around in Thorin’s grip and trying to regain his footing. That was where the elevator came in. The doors rattled when his back hit them and then Thorin leaned in close, slammed a hand on either side of Bilbo’s head.
“No, what are you doing?”
Bilbo frowned, and pushed against Thorin’s broad chest, uselessly. “I was studying, until someone came along and attacked me.”
“That wasn’t what it looked like to me.”
“What? Thorin, you’re doing it right now. What do you mean? And that hurt, by the way. That really hurt.” He tried to reach up, rub the back of his head, but Thorin crowded closer. “What—”
“I told you, and you promised— How could you do this?”
“I really have no idea what you’re talking about,” Bilbo said, getting angry himself now. “I was mid-sentence in there and now I’ve completely lost my place. And you’re causing a scene! Get off me.”
“No.”
“You’re acting like a child.”
“You’re the child! Fucking around with things you don’t understand!”
“I was just studying!”
“If that’s what you want to call it.”
“What would you call it? And get off me, I can’t breathe with you this close.”
Thorin didn’t move. His hair was tangled around his face, long and loose, and the smell of pipe tobacco was overpowering. Bilbo coughed. Thorin’s eyes were dark, narrow. He exhaled, slowly, down Bilbo’s neck.
“I said get off!” Bilbo shoved again, harder this time. It would be, he thought, just his luck if the doors opened and he fell backwards into the elevator. And it was strange, because he had never had a fear of small places, had always been inordinately fond of climbing into wardrobes and the like, but right now his heart was racing and he thought he might collapse if he didn’t get some space.
“You’ve betrayed me,” Thorin said, and sounded so ridiculously old-fashioned that it broke the moment and Bilbo actually let out a startled laugh. Thorin wasn’t amused. He glared at Bilbo full-on, a look with real heat behind it, and then—finally—took a step back. Bilbo choked on his own laughter. “After everything I told you, you still—”
“Anyone else,” Bilbo interrupted, his voice unsteady but his resolve strong, getting stronger by the second, “anyone else would just have a normal conversation. About this. Whatever ‘this’ is. Not go around tossing their only friends into elevators.” Stupid, he told himself, you are being very stupid, but he couldn’t stop.
“Oh, so now you’re pretending nothing’s happened?”
“Nothing has happened.”
“I don’t believe you,” Thorin said, his hands clenching and unclenching into fists like he wanted to hurt someone, hurt Bilbo, who was the only someone nearby. “This is absolutely— You have no fucking clue what you’re doing and you’re standing here and lying about it to my face.”
“I don’t lie.”
“I saw you!”
“Well, congratulations on not being blind,” Bilbo snapped. “No, look, you know what? We’re done here. Done. I have a French exam to study for. I don’t have time for this—this nonsense. I can’t, I won’t, I refuse.” And, in what was possibly one of the bravest things he’d ever done, he walked away. Went back into the library to collect his things—even paused to apologise to the librarian—and then, without so much as a backward glance, passed Thorin and headed down the stairs, all the while expecting to be hauled back by the neck of his sweater. Thrown around some more. But Thorin didn’t move. Did nothing except loom and glare, and Bilbo could feel it without even looking at the man, and then he let out a low angry noise, incoherent, and then Bilbo was out of the building.
What Bilbo doesn’t know, hiding in the darkness of Sage, knees brushing the hymnals and head against dry, cool stone, is that Thorin had come looking for him and had found him, studying yes but not alone. Bilbo doesn’t know—and would never guess but probably should, given the specific level of Thorin’s anger—that Azog had been standing just behind him, pale fingers hovering over his shoulders, looking for all the world equal parts a predator and a close conversation partner, each just as damning as the other in Thorin’s eyes.
Yesterday, Bilbo was meant to have delivered a map from the university archives into Azog’s hands. He didn’t. Of course he didn’t, not after Thorin’s plea—he purged his e-mail account of all their conversations and steered clear from dark alleyways and generally felt like a paranoid idiot but there had been fear, real fear, behind the anger in Thorin’s eyes. So Bilbo was true to his word, and if he can be faulted at all it’s for being too naïve. Azog was not so easily dissuaded.
When Bilbo didn’t show up for their rendezvous yesterday, the would-be map thief must have been furious. Being Azog, he would be furious in a quiet, cold way, and then quickly turn to thoughts of revenge. If the rushing in Bilbo’s ears would stop, if he could calm down enough not to feel like Thorin was going to come knock the chapel’s doors off their hinges, Bilbo would put two and two together and make four: their fight, though avoidable with the help of communication—but when hasn’t communication been an issue for the them?—wasn’t unfounded at all.
Because Thorin is always like that: strong foundations. And the carpenter’s son in Bilbo, the same one who appreciates the detail work of the chapel ceilings, should recognise that. Should admire that. But too often it comes out as stubbornness, as implacability, and there was a time when Bilbo would have had the patience to deal with that, to coax out whatever was lurking underneath it all. Since he has had to grow up and get used to people leaving him, though, patience is a virtue he cannot afford. If you wait for anyone long enough, they will—eventually—leave. So you can’t stick around to find out. You have to be the one to leave first.
For a while—six months, more or less—Thorin has made Bilbo forget that. But tonight, now, he is remembering so hard it hurts.
What do you do, when you find yourself someplace you’ve just started to feel you belong, with someone you think will be different, and then it turns out that you’re wrong? Entirely wrong? What do you even do next? Bilbo doesn’t have answers. He’s cold and damp; he suspects he’s going to catch cold, or worse. So he buttons up his sweater and shoulders his bag and walks home, breath caught in his throat. Only when he’s climbed up to his attic and locked the door does he properly exhale, long and slow, and collapse back against the wall.
“You’re late.” The voice comes out of the darkness, somewhere over by the stove. Bilbo’s breath hitches. He is panicked, absolutely. He is cold all over and shaking, even worse than before. None of this can be real. “I even put the kettle on. Long cold now, of course. And when I say late, I mean two days late, Baggins. We had a deal.”
Azog steps out into the room, straightening up under the peaked roof. Light from the street outside filters in and catches on his white-blond hair. He crosses the room in three strides easily, long legs in tight black denim, and Bilbo can smell the leather of his jacket, the cigarette slowly smouldering between his fingers. It probably says something about him that his first proper reaction is to worry about how he’s going to get the smell of cigarette smoke out of his apartment; meanwhile, Azog’s free hand has found its way to Bilbo’s elbow, is hauling him upward.
“No one walks away from me. Or didn’t your boyfriend tell you?”
“Wha— He’s not— What?”
“Oh, he really didn’t? Hmm. Oakenshield, keeping secrets. Who’s surprised? Lying bastard doesn’t have a truthful bone in him. Unless you were . . . Well. I suspect it’s the other way round.” Azog smiles, unevenly, the scar through his cheek twisting his lips. He leans in close, presses Bilbo bodily up against the wall and breathes down his neck. “I don’t really need that visual, though, thank you. What I do need is my map.”
“I’m not stealing anything for you,” Bilbo manages, turning his face away. His arms won’t cooperate for some reason. Azog’s fingers work their way up from elbow to neck and he smiles when Bilbo winces. “How did you even— Get out of my apartment. I don’t want you here.”
“I don’t give a damn what you want.”
“I’m not a thief!”
“I think you’ll change your mind. Once you realise . . . the alternatives.” Azog takes a drag of his cigarette and breathes a line of smoke into Bilbo’s eyes. Then, while Bilbo is blind and coughing, Azog twists an arm behind his back, flips him over entirely so his face is up against the wall. Bilbo’s lost his footing and his shoulder is burning. The ringing in his ears has returned. Azog’s fingers are cold and hard around his wrist. “The alternatives being, none,” Azog says, and brings the glowing end of his cigarette down on Bilbo’s left palm. It is the sort of thing that should be done swiftly, with vengeance; he does it slow as you please, still smiling.
Bilbo shouts and twists, tries to jerk his arm away. Azog’s hips are against his from behind, pinning him to the wall. Out of the corner of his eye he can just make out the man’s profile, bent over his burning hand. “Please—” Bilbo gasps, but then stops himself, because what’s the point in pleading at a time like this? His evening is repeating itself, only worse this time. Much worse. He didn’t cry in front of Thorin but he is crying again now, which is no help at all. But he is powerless in every sense of the word and his skin burns and his shoulder aches and all he wants to do is bury himself in blankets and never emerge. He wants to be anywhere but here.
“My father would have cut off your hand,” Azog is saying, when Bilbo shakes himself back into the present moment enough to listen. “But, changing times being what they are, I thought I’d be a bit more gentle. Besides, you’d make a poor thief with only one hand.” He runs his fingers up Bilbo’s spine and Bilbo shudders, biting back a moan. Azog puts the cigarette back between his lips, as if it hadn’t just been searing a hole in someone’s skin. “I’ll give you a day,” he says. “Generous, don’t you think? And then you’re going to do exactly as I tell you.”
Azog presses his jaw to the top of Bilbo’s head, runs his nose down along Bilbo’s neck, breath hot and damp. Bilbo squeezes his eyes shut. Every useful function of his brain has shut off. It’s as though he’s watching it all from across the room. Across the room, where his blankets are—a safe space. He aches to be there.
“And you’re not going to say a word to Oakenshield,” Azog whispers into Bilbo’s ear. He flicks ash casually onto Bilbo’s wrist, his sleeve, his wooden floor. Contamination: that’s what Azog is. Like a stain, or a disease. A spot—out, out. “One day. No need to worry about finding me. I’ll be watching you.”
Just as suddenly as he appeared Azog is gone, out the door and down the rickety stairs of the house. Released from his grip Bilbo crumples to the floor. He folds in on himself, trembling, cradling his left arm to his chest. There is ash beneath his cheek.
He has had bad days before but they have never left him feeling like this.
A minute passes, maybe more. Maybe an entire succession of minutes, because what is time, really? There are too many thoughts in his head to count. Everything and nothing is happening at once. He should stand up, re-lock his doors—for all the good that’ll do—run his hand under cold water. He should figure out what happens next. Clumsily, he digs his phone out of his satchel. He should call someone. Gandalf. Campus safety. The police.
After four rings there’s an answer, short, weary: “What?”
“Hello,” Bilbo means to say, but it comes out as “Help” and then “Oh, hell,” because he’s dialed Thorin. The only one he ever calls, and very close to the last person he wants to see right now. He has just enough presence of mind to hang up before dropping the phone.
Thorin calls back immediately and Bilbo stares at his phone, the screen lit, vibrating on the floor. He doesn’t answer, can’t answer. Thorin doesn’t leave a message, just calls back, and then again, and the fourth time Bilbo makes himself pick up, if only to lie.
“Where are you?” Thorin asks, before Bilbo can even speak. “I’m on my way, just tell me where?”
“I’m home, but—”
“I’ll be there in five minutes. Three. Are you— What happened?”
“Nothing,” Bilbo says. Lie better, he tells himself, and tries to sit up. “Just a misunderstanding. You don’t need to come. I didn’t mean to call you. I was trying to . . . Just nevermind.”
“Bilbo I said, ‘What?’ and you said, ‘Help.’ What the hell’s going on?”
“Really, it’s nothing.”
“Is this about earlier?”
“No.”
Thorin is quiet a moment. Bilbo sniffs, tries to wipe his nose on his shoulder because his good hand is holding the phone. “What do you need me to do?” Thorin asks, his voice gruff. “I know we . . . things went wrong earlier but if you need something now I—”
“I don’t,” Bilbo says. What he needs is not something Thorin can give, not something he himself can even put a name to. “I just . . .” His voice fails him.
“Fuck this, I’m coming over. Stay on the phone.”
“No, please don’t. I don’t want—”
“Already in the car,” Thorin says. Bilbo feels his eyes burning and blinks fiercely. The seared skin of his left palm is taut and shiny and when he tries to push himself to his feet while still holding the phone he nearly blacks out. Or maybe he does black out, because it’s definitely not three minutes later that Thorin’s footsteps are pounding up the stairs.
Bilbo’s door bangs open and he hears Thorin call his name, close and too-loud, and then Thorin’s hands are on his shoulders, turning him over, and it is the same thing again, a third time now. It is too much. Bilbo jerks himself back, his breath coming fast. Instead of pushing forward like he expected, though, he watches as Thorin backs off, hands raised.
Thorin drops to a crouch on the floor next to Bilbo, a foot or two away. “You hung up the phone,” he says after a moment.
“I told you not to come.” It still seems important, somehow, that Bilbo cling to his original story. That way, perhaps, he might get out of all of this with a shred of dignity. He can be stubborn, too. “You don’t have to—”
“I’m sorry,” Thorin stammers, interrupting. “This evening . . . I don’t know what came over me.”
“You threw me into the elevator.”
“I—I did.” He at least has the decency to look ashamed of it. His mouth twists, like there’s a bad smell on the air. Bilbo holds his breath. Thorin’s eyebrows draw together and he tilts his head, leans in closer. “Something happened. Something more than me. To you, I mean.”
Bilbo says nothing.
“You don’t smoke,” Thorin says, slowly, because there really is a bad smell on the air, and then his face goes still. He stares at Bilbo’s wall, unblinking, for a good minute, and then lets out a low-voiced “Shit.”
“Thorin,” Bilbo starts, trying to head it off.
“Shit, Bilbo, where is he? What did he do? I’m going to fucking kill him, I swear, just— What did he do to you?”
“Why didn’t you tell me?” Bilbo asks. “You saw him earlier, didn’t you? That’s what you were mad about?”
“Of course! What the fuck did you think I was mad about? He was right there! And you—”
“Thorin, I didn’t know! And you didn’t tell me! And then he— Why didn’t you warn me?”
“What?” Thorin says, and then, “Oh. Oh, fuck.” He’s quiet, clearly thinking, but all of Bilbo’s spare energy has gone into trying not to think about pain and also trying to breathe evenly, so he has nothing left to use on translating Thorin’s silences. “He was here. Before you called me.”
“Yes,” Bilbo says. There doesn’t seem to be a point in lying now.
“Then he can’t have gotten far.” Thorin stands, reaches into his back waistband and pulls out a switchblade. He tosses it to Bilbo, who doesn’t catch it. “Take this. Stay here. Put a chair against your door. I’ll call you when I’m done. Do not pick up the phone unless it’s me.”
“No, wait, what are you doing?”
“I told you, I’m going to kill him. This is the last time, the last time he hurts anyone I care about. He already got to the rest of my family. He will not get to you.”
“Thorin—”
“I will come back for you,” Thorin says, already halfway out the door.
“I don’t want you to go!” Bilbo yells, surprising himself. Where did that come from?
Thorin stops and tenses, then turns and looks Bilbo over. Really looks him over, not just the redness around his eyes and his mussed hair, not just the way his left shoulder is hanging low, but the paleness of his face and the whiteness of the knuckles of his right hand as he grips his left wrist. “Show me your hand,” Thorin orders, stepping back inside, and Bilbo, knowing that this can only end badly but hoping it won’t get any worse, does.
Thorin hisses in a breath through clenched teeth. His fingers are light on the back of Bilbo’s hand, warm and dry. He tries to say several things at once and fails, settling for picking Bilbo up and hauling him over to the sink.
The cold water is better relief than Bilbo could have dreamt of. He leans forward, rests his elbows on the smooth porcelain, closes his eyes. Thorin’s holding his wrist, loosely, keeping it under the faucet. The anger seems to have gone out of him. Bilbo knows better than to think that it really has, but it is secondary now, buried beneath the more immediate emotions that are playing out, illegible, across Thorin’s face.
“If I step away, are you going to fall over?” Thorin asks.
“Probably not?” Bilbo ventures. Thorin takes a step, hesitant, and then another. When it looks like Bilbo will remain upright, Thorin walks over to the tiny bathroom. Bilbo can hear him rummaging around.
“For fuck’s sake, don’t you even have a first-aid kit?”
“I don’t know,” Bilbo says. The water feels so good he wants to climb into the sink. Judging by how much he is shivering, though, that is probably not a good idea. He has enough of a sense of self preservation left to recognise that, at least. Thorin bangs around in the bathroom a bit more before coming back, grumbling.
“I have to run down to my car. I will be right back. Do not move. Do not fall over. Do not pass Go.”
“Mmmm,” Bilbo says, eyes still closed. Thorin’s hand presses briefly to the back of his neck and then is gone. He comes back breathing like he’s taken the stairs at a run.
It takes some convincing to get Bilbo away from the sink, but Thorin has the first-aid kit of an Eagle Scout and there is anything anyone could want, including antibacterial wash and burn gel and prescription-strength painkillers for someone with a name Bilbo does not recognise. So, not exactly an honest Scout, but a well-prepared one. Thorin sits Bilbo down on the floor, facing him, and with hands far steadier than Bilbo’s own he cleans the dark-edged hole in Bilbo’s palm, winds a careful bandage around it. He opens up Bilbo’s freezer and, not finding any ice packs, takes out a bag of frozen broccoli and sets Bilbo’s hand atop it, wraps it all in a towel.
“I’m still going to kill him,” Thorin says as he sits back down, next to Bilbo this time.
“No,” Bilbo says. Gravity has increased somehow, or he’s lopsided; he leans over and comes up against Thorin’s shoulder. The sharp bite of Old Spice clears the sour cling of cigarette smoke from his nose.
“Bilbo, you don’t know what he’s done!” Thorin protests, but he shifts so that Bilbo is more firmly against his chest. Solid. Tangible.
“I know what he did to me, and I’m telling you I don’t want you to kill him.” If Thorin were to ask him why, Bilbo couldn’t say, but this is Thorin, and Thorin is so rarely concerned with the whys and hows, only the whens and whats. There was something said back there, something about family, but Bilbo can’t quite get the words back to ask Thorin what he meant.
“Then,” Thorin says, floundering—it is an unusual look on him, and Bilbo would savour it if he weren’t so suddenly exhausted—“at least let me call the police. This is assault. Battery. Did he— He didn’t—” Thorin cannot get the words out, but the glance he casts over Bilbo’s body again completes the question well enough.
“No. And I don’t want— Let’s just . . . not. Today.”
“What?”
“I want a do-over on today. Didn’t happen. No.”
“He can’t get away with this!”
“I have a plan,” Bilbo says, and it is mostly a lie, mostly just to get Thorin to sit still, but there is a thought, in the back of his mind, that may be the start of something. “Right now, though, I just feel . . . deflated. Sort of . . . washed up. Washed out? One of those.”
Thorin sighs. He brings his hands up to his temples, runs his fingers through his hair while swearing under his breath. “Fine,” he says, suddenly, startling Bilbo back to full wakefulness. “But you and I are going to talk about this.”
“That’ll be the day,” Bilbo mutters, speaking into Thorin’s chest.
“Look, you—” Thorin starts. He bites his lip and drops his hands. “I know, okay? I know I’m awful at this. It’s been a damn sight since I had anyone around to point it out but I know the looks you are giving me.”
“What looks?”
“The you’re-awful-at-this looks. Yes, that one. Fuck, you even do it well sideways. My sister used to give them exactly the same way. If she were here now . . . You don’t even want to know. She’d have a hell of a lot to say.”
“Good.”
“Hey, I’m not the only one awful at things here. You don’t get to talk.”
“Hmm. Thought you wanted to talk,” Bilbo reminds him. His mind has already turned to thoughts of pajamas.
“I do. And we are going to. But Bilbo, you have a problem."
“Just one?”
“I’m really not in the mood, and I don’t think you are, either.”
“Sorry.”
“No, don’t— What I mean is you need to learn to stand up for yourself!”
“I do.”
“Verbally. Half-heartedly. With a lot of questions.”
“So?”
Thorin makes a noise of aggravation and shifts position again. Before Bilbo can say anything, Thorin has twisted around and gripped Bilbo’s upper arms, is forcing him down to the floor. He gets one knee on either side of Bilbo’s hips and waits, glaring.
“What are you doing?” Bilbo asks. He actually cannot process things anymore. There’s scientific reasoning behind that, isn’t there, about the point when your mind is simply overloaded? There must be.
“Proving a point,” Thorin says. He waits, and glares, and Bilbo waits, and the broccoli is cold beneath his fingers.
“Can your point wait until morning?” Bilbo asks.
“This is the point. You’re not resisting. I’m overpowering you and you haven’t even told me to stop. Damn it, Bilbo, don’t you know anything?”
“Lots of things.”
“Useless things. You don’t know anything practical. I’m amazed you’ve made it this far.”
“Hmmm.” To form proper words has become difficult. Bilbo wants to protest, but more than that, he wants to sleep. This has always been a coping mechanism of his, ever since he was little; any ordinary night will see him awake until three or four o’clock, anxious, worrying over something, but give him a bad day and he can fall asleep anywhere, straight away. This is probably one of those “useless” things Thorin was talking about. This is probably impractical, and unwise, and a whole host of other things, but it is how he is. He cannot change that.
Thorin gets Bilbo over to his bed and helps him take off his shoes, removes his jacket and sweater. Thorin pulls the quilt up and Bilbo’s half-asleep already so he can’t really tell, but thinks he hears a sort of apology again. If he does, it is a record for the two of them. If he doesn’t, it’s just as he expected.
When he falls asleep he dreams about being a space cadet, burnt by a rocket, wakes thinking he’s falling to Earth and thrashes upright to see Thorin’s head resting on the edge of his bed, his body slumped over in one of the kitchen chairs, looking profoundly uncomfortable. But still there.
I don’t want you to go, Bilbo had said, and Thorin listened.
That has to count for something, right?
Bilbo can’t fall back asleep that night.
