Actions

Work Header

A Promise in Reverse

Chapter 5: Chapter 4

Chapter Text

It perhaps said something about Ardelia’s state of mind that once the idea occurred to her, she didn’t try to talk herself out of it.

She was desperate, she knew that—but the longer she considered it, the more absurdly brilliant it seemed. Lecter had given the necklace to Clarice as a token of thanks after she had stopped Will Graham from being killed in Minnesota. Clarice had told her all about that night and the conversations that had passed between them, including the suddenly not insignificant fact that Lecter had offered to do for her what she had done for Graham.

Ardelia grabbed the card that had come with the necklace again, scanning it to confirm what she already knew.

Her heart sped up as she re-read the last line, and if anything at all in her had been wavering, it was decided in that moment. If Lecter was still looking for the opportunity to repay Clarice for saving Graham’s life, Ardelia was going to give it to him.

After all, she thought darkly, he wasn’t going to get another chance.

-----

Two hours later, Ardelia was back from her trip to buy a prepaid burner phone. Paranoia had made her drive out of town, too afraid she would see someone she knew. Of course, she hadn’t, but the drive had done her good anyway, as it had given her time to consider what she intended to do and how she intended to do it.

The best way to attempt contact with Lecter was through Tattle Crime. Ardelia vaguely remembered that the FBI had used the site to get Lecter’s attention before, but more than that, Clarice had said they’d briefly discussed the site while in Minnesota, so Lecter had at least still been a reader at that time. She had to hope he still was.

Several times, Ardelia questioned what she realistically expected to happen, even if she did manage to contact Lecter. Lecter and Graham were undoubtedly out of the country. The logical part of her mind said there was no way Lecter could be of any use, even if he wanted to be.

But the frantic part of her mind clung to the idea that she could speak to them and something would change. The more she thought about it, the more she realized that the one she wanted wasn’t Lecter, but Graham. Graham was the one who looked at a case file and divined the impossible, the one who saw everything. If Lecter’s interest in Clarice led to him involving himself, Graham would become aware of the case as well. Ardelia didn’t have access to the file anymore, but she had been swimming in it all day, and had been the first to witness the scene at Clarice’s house. She could tell them everything; Graham could tell her what obscure detail she had missed, and then she could do something about it.

If she could contact them at all.

Once she configured the phone to maximum privacy settings, connected to a proxy server, and set up an anonymous email account, she opened the browser and went to the Tattle Crime website. After scrolling through the menu, she entered the forum and opened a tab to post a new topic.

Then Ardelia sat staring at the empty text box for a literal five minutes, mentally rejecting any words she thought of before she even typed them.

She had to get Lecter’s attention, but she couldn’t write anything that would be understood by any other reader. The words had to be vague yet exact, and nothing that anyone could trace to herself, Clarice, or Lecter. Making any sort of reference to Lecter was the last thing she wanted to do, as that would only attract attention on the site.

Ardelia read the card again. She knew she had to work the word ‘favor’ in somehow, but everything she thought of sounded wrong. It didn’t sound like something Clarice would write, and no matter what Ardelia started to type, she found herself trying to explain something using words that meant nothing.

Frustrated, Ardelia deleted the sentences she had just worked out; they had looked like a goddamn riddle.

She tried to imagine what Clarice would write, if Clarice were contacting Lecter. Clarice understood Lecter. Clarice wouldn’t have explained anything; she would have trusted that Lecter would catch her meaning, and she would have written something Lecter couldn’t mistake.

Again, Ardelia read the card that had come with the necklace. It was well composed but short, only five sentences in total. It also didn’t spell anything out, she noticed. The true substance of the note was dependent upon context from prior conversations. Perhaps the best way to get Lecter’s attention was to make her message dependent upon the words of the card and nothing more.

And the necklace, she thought with a burst of inspiration. The pendant was generic, meaningless to anyone else, and Lecter alone would know what it was.

Finally, Ardelia settled on a subject line of two sentences, mirroring Lecter’s own language but written in the passive voice: A service was done. A favor is requested. For the body of the post, she simply took a photo of the necklace, and then wrote, Please, followed by the number of the burner phone.

The words were simple yet indirect, which satisfied her. They were also misleading, as she was effectively masquerading as Clarice. Lecter would assume that Clarice had written the message, because of the necklace if nothing else. But Ardelia didn’t know how else to get his attention. Truthfully, the last thing she wanted was his attention, but if there was a chance that it could keep Clarice from dying, she would deal with it.

She still stared at the screen for another two minutes, not actually debating on whether or not to go through with it, but knowing that once she submitted the post, it was done. Her thumb hovered over the screen as she read her words over and over, as if proofreading was going to change something.

Gathering her resolve, Ardelia tapped the screen, and the post went live.

-----

Ardelia carried the phone with her for the rest of the evening. The maddening tension of waiting for a call—even one that was unlikely to come—had her taking the phone to the bathroom with her every time she needed to go, afraid that it would ring in the seconds she was out of earshot. It didn’t, of course.

Nor did it ring when she heated a frozen dinner for herself, or when she uncharacteristically took a bath instead of a shower because she was afraid she wouldn’t hear the phone over the sound of the water.

Throughout the evening, she had also checked her new email account what felt like hundreds of times, constantly refreshing it to see if there were any replies to her post. There weren’t.

Not having anything else to do and not feeling like doing anything, Ardelia stayed in the tub for nearly two hours, simply adding more hot water as the bath began to cool. She felt numb; the events of the day had left her overwhelmed and anxious. She thought about Clarice, who, wherever she was, was certainly not taking an unenjoyable bath.

When Ardelia finally got out, she went straight to bed, even though she did nothing but lie in the dark for what seemed like hours. She did eventually sleep, however, because she was awakened by the sound of a phone ringing.

It took a bleary second for her to confirm that it was the burner phone ringing and not her own, and then she was instantly awake.

In the split second before she answered, several thoughts flashed through her mind in one chaotic jumble as her heart sped up. The post had been a desperate gambit, and while she had written it knowing full well that she was opening a line of communication, receiving that contact was another thing entirely. There was also the possibility that the person on the other end was someone who had simply seen the number and called it for kicks. She feared disappointment even as she worried about success.

“Hello?” Ardelia said, answering.

“May I speak to Clarice Starling, please?”

Ardelia’s breath caught. There were only two people besides Clarice who could infer her full name from what Ardelia had written, and only one of them had that accent. Lecter, she was actually talking to Lecter.

“She’s missing,” Ardelia blurted, realizing that as much as she had imagined what might happen in this conversation, she wasn’t at all prepared for it to actually occur.

There was a pause on the other end. “Then to whom do I have the pleasure of speaking?”

Once, long ago, Ardelia had asked Clarice what piece of advice she would give to anyone dealing with Lecter, besides the obvious of being polite. It had been hypothetical, a conversation of maybes and nevers. Clarice had thought for a moment, then said, “Don’t try to manipulate him; you can’t. Don’t lie to him; he’ll know it.”

With those words ringing in her mind, Ardelia found herself blurting, “Her friend, Ardelia.” She quickly continued with, “I’m the one that wrote the message on Tattle Crime. I apologize if it was misleading, but Clarice isn’t in a position to ask for herself. So I’m asking on her behalf.”

There was another pause. “Asking for a favor that was not yours to receive? One might comment on the presumption of such an act.”

Lecter didn’t sound entirely pleased, not with her or that it hadn’t been Clarice who had answered the phone.

“If the favor was to save her life, she is still the recipient,” Ardelia said with a calm that she didn’t feel, hoping that the fact that he had called at all meant he was inclined to be obliging to whatever he assumed Clarice might ask. “Clarice was abducted from her house this morning, and the FBI isn’t going to be able to find her.”

“Distressing news, to be sure, but I find it hard to believe the department grinds to a halt at the loss of one agent.”

“No, it doesn’t,” Ardelia said. “They’re doing everything they can, but it will all be for nothing because they’re wrong about their suspect.” She paused, gathering herself before continuing. “The FBI thinks you took her.”

The darkness of the room around her seemed almost tangible in the silence that followed.

“Do they indeed?” Lecter said, a note of amusement creeping into his voice. “And why is that?”

“The card from you was in her mail, and you have a history with her. The planning behind the abduction was impressive. It’s a reasonable assumption, and there wasn’t enough found to contradict it.”

“Yet you think otherwise?”

“I know that there’s a difference between what Clarice has spoken about publicly and what actually happened. I’m the only one she told about that night in Minnesota, the only one she ever showed the necklace to.” After a moment, Ardelia said, “Clarice needs help, and I can’t help her.”

Lecter was silent a long moment, but then he spoke. “So you thought of me. A strange impulse for an FBI agent.”

Ardelia was thrown; she hadn’t identified herself as such. “How—how did you know I’m an FBI agent?”

“I recognize your name. It’s in my interest to keep apprised of the agency’s doings.”

He knew who she was. Wasn’t that a lovely thought.

“You are going rather impressively off the rails for an agent,” he continued. “Or has contacting wanted killers become standard protocol when the FBI is adrift?”

Ardelia swallowed. “I don’t care if this costs me my career. You’re the only other one who knows that you didn’t take her.”

“Are you certain I didn’t?” Lecter asked mildly. “I’ve done worse to better friends.”

The easy way he said it was unsettling. But it was a question she had already asked herself that day, and answered long before she had written the message. But she only said, “If you had taken her, you wouldn’t have called and asked to speak with her.”

Again, Lecter didn’t immediately reply. “And what do you imagine I could do?”

“You can see things I can’t,” Ardelia said. “I know there has to be something that we’ve missed, some clue that will tell me how to find her. I was the first on the scene. I can tell you everything that’s known so far.”

“And you yourself have nothing but the purest of intentions, of course.”

“What do you mean?”

He actually chuckled, and Ardelia knew he was laughing at her. “Your eloquence leaves no doubt that this conversation is a means to an end. I only wonder if it will be the end you intended.” Before she could ask what that meant, he said, “Perhaps we will speak again. Goodbye, Ardelia.”

Lecter ended the call.

Well, that wasn’t ominous at all.

After another moment, Ardelia brought the phone away from her ear, double checking to make sure he had actually hung up. She pressed the button to lock the screen and then let the phone fall to the bed.

She could still feel her heart racing, still taste the panic of trying to say the exact right thing, and she wasn’t sure she’d succeeded. She might have even failed. Ardelia was somewhat shocked her plan had worked, that he had called. Part of her thought he’d been intrigued, but the other part was stuck on the slightly vindictive tone of his every word.

She had no idea how Clarice had actually been in the same house with that man and remained calm.

-----

Ardelia understandably did not go back to sleep.

First, she deleted the post on Tattle Crime. Lecter had her number—which wasn’t worrisome at all, of course—and wouldn’t need the site to call it again.

Second, she got up and made breakfast, despite the fact that it was barely after three in the morning. Then she started cleaning her kitchen—unable to sit and do nothing, and very much needing to do something to take her mind off the fact that she was waiting for she didn’t know what.

Lecter practically said they would speak again, and she wasn’t entirely sure that was a good thing.

Ardelia could only hope he was enticed enough by the idea of repaying a favor to Clarice that he would help in some way. He had to be interested, she told herself. It was about Clarice; he had to be interested.

In that, she wasn’t disappointed. Just over an hour later, the burner phone rang again. Ardelia quickly stopped what she was doing and answered it.

“Hello?”

“Hello, Ardelia. I’ve decided I should like to see where the abduction took place,” Lecter said without preamble. “A remote tour of the scene, if you will.”

“But it’s a crime scene,” Ardelia said.

“Precisely. A viewing unfiltered by another’s observations is necessary if anything useful is to be learned.”

“I mean they’ll be there again this morning, processing things and combing for any trace evidence.”

“Then you should hurry,” Lecter said, “so that we can be done before dawn comes and the FBI descends.”

Ardelia rapidly calculated—she still had Clarice’s spare key, its place in her pocket forgotten during the whirlwind of the day until she had come home that night.

She would be fired if she was caught. But Clarice was going to die if she couldn’t do something. And Ardelia was convinced that if Lecter could only point her in the right direction, she could find Clarice. If he needed to see Clarice’s house to do that, then so be it.

“I can be across town in twenty minutes,” she said, deciding. As if there had been any other decision.

“Then we shall call you in half an hour.”

The line went dead.

Ardelia literally ran to her bedroom, throwing on a pair of jeans and a sweater, then pulling on her shoes in the hallway. She put on a coat and grabbed her keys, Clarice’s key, the phone, and her wallet.

One minute later, she was pulling out of her driveway.

Ardelia made good time. There was no traffic to speak of this early, and soon she was in Clarice’s neighborhood.

Parking at Clarice’s house was out of the question, dead end street or not. If anything was likely to get neighbors’ attention, it would be the noises of a car in the driveway. Instead, Ardelia circled nearby streets. Two blocks away, she found several houses that had extra cars parked in the road. She parked neatly between two of them, hoping that if anyone heard or noticed the extra car, they would suppose it belonged to the house next door.

The night was pitch black, and even if anyone was awake, they were still settled firmly indoors. Ardelia quickly walked the distance to Clarice’s house, arriving exactly twenty-six minutes after she had left her own house. The front door had a temporary FBI lock box on it, but the back door was simply locked from the inside.

Both, of course, had yellow crime scene tape across them. Ardelia pulled on a pair of latex gloves she’d had in the car, used the key to open the back door, and ducked under the tape.

She hesitated before turning the lights on, but the lights would be more than necessary. After a short debate with herself, she turned every light in the house on. At least if someone noticed, they wouldn’t see lights going on and off as she moved between rooms, and might simply assume the lights had been left on.

Clarice’s house was no less messy than it had been when Ardelia had eaten dinner there a day and a half ago. Ardelia had the mad impulse to straighten things up. She didn’t, as it would be the absolute least helpful thing she could do, but she knew that Clarice would hate anyone seeing the current chaos of her personal space, let alone Lecter, who had an uncommon interest.

The phone rang.

It was a request ringing for a video call. Ardelia braced herself even as she answered it, her pulse suddenly racing.

She didn’t know what she had expected to see, but a black screen wasn’t it.

“Hello, Ardelia,” a new voice said, the diction crisp and intense. “This is Will Graham. Flip your camera, please.”

“Right,” she said, her nerves making her fumble as she hit the screen to change the input from the front camera to the back one.

Of course he had obscured his own camera. And of course he wasn’t interested in seeing her. Though that didn’t mean she liked the fact that two serial killers knew exactly who she was.

“How do you want to do this?” she asked him, forcing herself to get a grip. She had expected Graham to become involved if Lecter was, but she hadn’t expected to talk to him so abruptly.

“Show me the scene first. You can tell me what you know afterward.”

“All right.”

Ardelia went to the front entryway.

Graham gave her directions. At his prompting, she alternately panned the area with the camera and stepped forward or back, showing him everything from every angle. He bit out commands in a brisk manner; the last time he had said please had been the first time he’d spoken to her. But there was also something detached about his orders, like he was so focused on what he was looking at that she wasn’t even an afterthought.

Ardelia learned very quickly never to zoom in, but to always get physically closer to whatever he wanted to look at. And to always, always go slower. Ardelia had thought she was moving slowly, but if there was so much as a blur of motion in the video, Graham would simply say, “Slower.”

The entryway was just as it had been yesterday when she’d found it—coat rack and table tipped over, decorative items fallen to the floor. Then there was the box that was a random package from the stolen UPS truck, and the message in marker, of course, stark on the wall. Yellow crime scene markers indicated each item, but so far, nothing had been removed.

After a thorough survey, Graham started asking questions.

“When were you here yesterday, and why?”

“It was nearly noon and Clarice hadn’t even called in. It wasn’t like her. I used the spare key and came in the back door, around the corner, there,” she said, turning around in her position to point the way through the living room. “I checked the garage for her car, but it was empty. I thought she had left, until I saw her phone and her watch discarded together on the floor. That’s when I came inside and found this.” She turned toward the entryway again.

“Tell me what the FBI knows so far.”

Ardelia did, giving him the details of what the warrants had discovered: the hijacking of the UPS truck, the location of Clarice’s abandoned vehicle, and the security footage of Clarice answering the front door in the morning. She tried to keep her voice level and even, as if she were just repeating the basic facts of any other abduction. She wasn’t sure she succeeded.

Ardelia told him how the Christmas card had been discovered, and how the investigation had focused on Lecter from there. She did not mention that she had taken the stationary box full of cards, or read its entire contents. Lecter hadn’t spoken once, but she knew he was on the call, watching from behind the blackness of the screen. She had told him that Clarice had shared things with her, but the idea of admitting that she had read years of private correspondence made a cold feeling settle in the pit of her stomach.

“Obviously there were no fingerprints found,” Graham commented, “or there wouldn’t be a question of Hannibal.”

“No prints,” Ardelia said. “Though he wasn’t wearing gloves in the video. A cloth glove might interfere with his dexterity and his grip on the syringe, and latex ones would look out of place. I suppose he had some in his pocket.”

“It wouldn’t be hard,” Graham said in placid agreement. “Have the syringe in his hand, ring the bell with his knuckle. Kick the door closed afterward and put his gloves on at his leisure. I doubt he even fought with her. He knows the dosage. He knows she’s not going anywhere. He knows he already has exactly what he wants.”

A shiver went down Ardelia’s spine. If she had been troubled by reciting the events of the camera feed, it was nothing to how she felt about Graham’s dispassionate reconstruction of the crime. It was more than the simple facts; it was the why of the facts. He was seeing things as the man who’d taken Clarice had seen them.

It was exactly what she’d wanted, but it was chilling to hear. The tone and timbre of his voice changed, slipping into something distant, darker.

“You don’t think there was a struggle?” Ardelia asked, gathering herself.

“This was a struggle of one person, not two,” Graham said, his voice still flat. “She seizes the lamp to hit him, but she’s already faltering. She misses and knocks over the table in the process. She grabs the coat rack to drag herself up, but it goes down under her weight.” Graham continued, “He watches. He likes seeing her helpless. He didn’t come here for brutality and violence. He came with efficiency and purpose.”

Ardelia didn’t know what to say to that. Perhaps she could have found words, if this hadn’t been about Clarice. Hearing Graham’s narration was worse than watching the video.

Graham saved her the trouble of a reply, saying, “Show me the writing again.”

Ardelia did, moving to face it and framing it with the camera.

“I would guess he wrote that directly over where she finally fell,” Graham said.

The words were above and just to one side of the fallen coat rack. Ardelia stared at them, as if they weren’t already burned into her memory. “I knew these were wrong,” she said absently. “Hannibal Lecter wouldn’t have written this. It’s too impulsive.”

“Hannibal is as impulsive as anyone,” Graham said.

Ardelia was surprised, but she didn’t argue with him. Graham’s knowledge of Lecter was hardly a theory at this point.

She started again. “Regardless, all of Hannibal Lecter’s crime scenes say something. There may be writing here, but the rest of this doesn’t say anything. It’s just aftermath.”

“Everything says something, even when it’s not designed to. All of this says that he only cares about achieving his goal. And this…” He fell silent for a moment. “…was written once it was done. It was… an afterthought to his success.” Graham was silent again, then said, “A message from Hannibal would have been different. He also would have righted the furniture, and left everything just as it was.”

He would have, Ardelia realized. It seemed obvious once it was pointed out to her. Clarice undoubtedly would have noticed it, in addition to noticing what Ardelia had. Ardelia had known that the scene wasn’t staged elaborately enough to be Lecter, but only now did she see that the chaos left behind would have been cleaned up entirely, unless it had fit with whatever message Lecter would compose.

“Do they think I did it, too?” Graham asked.

“Your name has come up. But only because of your connection to Lecter.”

There was a noise that might have been a chuckle. Then Graham said, “Show me the rest of the house.”

Ardelia had known this was probably coming, but she still recoiled at the idea. “There’s nothing in the rest of the house.”

“Nothing that you saw.”

She hated the matter-of-factness of his tone, as well as the truth of the words. This was exactly what she’d wanted—for Will Graham to tell her what she couldn’t see—but she hated that she had to show him—show them—everything in Clarice’s house.

Ardelia didn’t reply, but simply did as he asked, going down the hallway off the living room. Graham directed her as before, though there were fewer instructions. There really was nothing to see in the guest bathroom and bedroom, certainly nothing that required consideration as things in the entryway had.

Then she followed the hall to the master bed and bath. There were shoes and clothes strewn about, and random items littering the floor near the bed. Cords to charge devices, a triangular pillow to prop up a tablet, house shoes and a robe. There were three glasses of water on the nightstand, all partly full to varying degrees. The bed was unmade, the sheets still rumpled from when Clarice had crawled out of it yesterday. The bathroom counter was messy, littered with everyday items used and not put back to place—toothpaste, hand lotion, a powder compact, Chapstick, a hair brush, and more.

All of it Ardelia saw through the camera screen, as she let it linger on each personal detail. She felt sick.

It felt like a betrayal. Like she was offering up Clarice’s privacy to Lecter in some terrible exchange.

Yet Ardelia knew that Graham seeing everything was the best chance Clarice had. For a while, Graham said nothing besides simple directions. Then he asked, “What does the FBI think about the bedroom?”

“We don’t think he came this far into the house. But so much is out of place that I suppose he could have moved something or taken something without it being obvious.”

“Is it typical that this much is out of place?”

“Generally, no. Clarice isn’t a neat freak, but she keeps things more or less in order because she’s efficient. But work has been non-stop lately. She’s barely had time to sleep.”

“Because of Jack’s retirement,” he said mildly.

Ardelia wasn’t sure why she was surprised that he knew. “Yes.”

He then directed her to go into the living room. There wasn’t as much mess here, only a few blazers thrown over the back of the couch and some dishes from a meal eaten in the recliner. Another pair of shoes, a winter coat, and two piled up afghans. A few books left out from who knows how long ago—Ardelia couldn’t imagine the last time Clarice had been able to read for leisure.

The office was in much the same state as the living room, with the expected papers and bills left unfiled on the desk, and books and folders that had been untouched on the bookshelf opposite.

The kitchen, however, was another room of commotion and disarray. Everything that had been here when she’d eaten dinner with Clarice was still here—the dirty dishes, food from the pantry on the countertops, the stack of things on the kitchen table, and piles of clothes visible from the laundry room.

Ardelia began to slowly show Graham the kitchen, panning to let him see the layout of it. Then she waited for him to instruct her which side of the room to start on in detail.

He surprised her, by instead saying, “Why didn’t you mention the flowers earlier?”

Ardelia turned toward the vase of white lilies that sat on Clarice’s countertop, a yellow evidence marker next to it. She walked closer, keeping them in frame.

She frowned to herself. “Because you sent those.”

There was a beat of silence, followed by the indistinct murmur of Lecter’s accent, the first confirmation that he was indeed on the call.

Then Graham spoke, his tone decisive yet intrigued. “Those weren’t from us.”

-----

Ardelia had shown Graham the rest of the kitchen as well as the laundry room and garage, but there was nothing else he found out of the ordinary. To her, the rest of the call had been overshadowed by the revelation about the flowers. Graham had asked her about any messages with the arrangement, but Ardelia could only say that the FBI had found no card, and that Clarice had offhandedly told her it was from Lecter.

Everything had changed and yet nothing had changed. The FBI had already investigated the floral delivery, and hadn’t been able to identify the sender. Ardelia had the ridiculous thought that the FBI should know the arrangement wasn’t from Lecter, even if just to point out that there was indeed another party involved, but she could hardly tell them her source of information.

Ardelia left Clarice’s house when it was still fully dark. She walked back to her car and drove home as the beginnings of morning traffic were starting.

Once at her house, she numbly plugged in the burner phone to charge.

She didn’t know what to do, what she could do, or even what Graham and Lecter could possibly do. Graham had found something she hadn’t seen, but it was still a dead end.

At the end of the call, she’d asked, “What happens now?”

“That remains to be seen,” Graham had said, maddeningly cryptic. Then he’d hung up.

Surely he would find something, think of something that could lead her to Clarice. Some detail would occur to him and the whole thing would fall into place.

Ardelia waited, and waited, and waited. No matter what else she was doing as hour after hour dragged by, her whole being was waiting for the phone to ring.

After a day, she called their number again in desperation. An alert tone and a robotic message told her that the number was no longer in service.

She never heard from them again.