Chapter Text
Clarice threw herself against the cellar doors after they closed in her face.
It achieved nothing. She didn’t have the strength to move them. She had to stand on the steps to reach them, and there was simply no way to apply enough force with her hands braced over her head, even as she ascended higher to really put her back into it. That didn’t stop her from furiously rattling the doors for several minutes after her captor left.
When she had momentarily tired herself out, Clarice slumped to the concrete floor and mentally and physically regrouped. She realized she still had the tape on her mouth, and she carefully pulled it off. The flashlight he had dropped was still on, laying on the floor a few feet away from her. Clarice stared at it for a minute before she shifted to reach for it.
That was when she became aware of the pain in her right ankle. She knew abstractly that it had twisted when he’d thrown her, but only now after her adrenaline rush was gone, did she register the pain of it.
Clarice winced and grabbed the flashlight. It was a cheap plastic one that was only as long as her hand was wide, the kind of thing that would be in a bin at Walmart for a dollar. But it was more than enough to illuminate the space.
First, Clarice examined her ankle, and after moving experimentally, determined that it was sprained but probably not broken. It hurt to turn it and put weight on it, but it felt nearly exactly the same as when she had twisted her other ankle several years ago. Either way, right now her ankle was the least of her problems.
She turned her attention to the rest of her surroundings.
It was a cellar, obviously. Concrete all around, maybe seven by ten feet. The steps leading out of it were like a cross between a ladder and stairs. They more closely resembled a ladder because of the steep angle, but all the rungs were made of boards wider than would have been used in a ladder’s construction. The cellar floor was filthy and looked like it hadn’t been swept in years; there were already streaks of dirt on her clothing from it. On one long wall was the cot he’d dropped her on, a thing that was stained, sagging, and looked like it had been purchased at an Army surplus store fifty years ago. On the wall opposite there was a busted plastic cooler. Behind her and underneath the ladder were two broken lawn chairs.
Clarice clicked off the flashlight, and gave her eyes a minute to adjust. When she opened them, she could see a small amount of gray light coming in through the ventilation pipe, and she could make out the outline of the cellar doors where a hint of light crept in around the cracks. Neither was enough to see by, but it would be a gauge of the passing of day and night.
She turned the flashlight back on.
Clarice gingerly got to her feet, dusted her clothing off as best she could, and sat down on the cot again. She stared blankly at the opposite wall.
She wondered what time it was and looked at her wrist without thinking. Of course her watch was missing—it had GPS on it, after all, and some part of her had known that it wouldn’t be there just as her phone wasn’t in her pocket. But she looked at her watch a hundred times a day and doing so had been automatic. She took several deep breaths and closed her eyes, before opening them to look at the wall again.
The blinding terror that she’d felt earlier had dissipated, leaving in its place a looming dread. The man had left her here, and she was not currently in immediate danger of being hurt or killed. She was alone, and while nothing about that was good in the bigger picture, it meant that she had time to think without the life-or-death calculus she’d been consumed by since he had opened the trunk.
She again tried to calculate where she might be. The brief glimpses of light that she’d seen when she’d cracked her eyes open as he carried her had seemed consistent with midday. If he had been driving the entire time since he’d abducted her that morning, he couldn’t have made it more than four hours away from Quantico. Though that was still a disturbingly large radius when mapped out. Of course, she could also be much closer; she had no way of knowing what had happened when she’d been unconscious. And as much as she wanted to figure it out, where she had been taken was irrelevant if she couldn’t get out of the cellar.
Clarice tried to take control of the situation as much as she could. She was going to try the doors again, but she hadn’t heard the car start, which made it likely that he was still nearby. Though whether he was near the cellar or doing something else, she had no way of knowing. Until she thought it was safe to attempt opening the doors, she did the only thing she could, which was take what she knew and try to extrapolate a profile.
She did it every day. She had never done it from this perspective before, but it wasn’t the first time she had done a profile backwards.
Clarice could only assume that he had gone to considerable effort to abduct her. While she still didn’t remember the abduction itself, he had successfully pulled off abducting an FBI agent, which said something about his skills. She had already noted that he had tied her up in the trunk in a way that was almost impossible to get out of, and that he’d made sure the trunk couldn’t be opened from the inside. He hadn’t made any real mistakes that she could see besides believing that she’d been unconscious when he’d carried her down to the cellar. And if she hadn’t had all her training and experience, she doubted that she would have managed to pull that off.
She also assumed that she was a chosen target, not a random one. She would never be a target for monetary ransom, but he could have hoped to use her as leverage against the FBI somehow. It remained a possibility, since he had confined her but had yet to harm her. However, her gut said that this was something else, and she had made a career out of following her gut instincts. And so far, her circumstances had too much in common with cases where abduction victims ended up dead. She had to operate on the assumption that he intended to kill her.
If she was a chosen target that he intended to kill, she needed to figure out why. Killers who had ‘types’ that they went after might stalk a victim for weeks, might even abduct them from outside their home, but they also tended to opportunistic and impulsive about when to pounce, and this seemed too well planned to be impulsive. And as far as she could remember, there were no open cases in this part of the country with abductions in any demographic that she fit, beyond the general category of ‘woman.’ Two open cases that she could bring to mind involved the disappearances of college aged women, one case particularly around the time of spring break, and then an additional third case that involved hitchhiking young men going missing. And were no known killers who were targeting law enforcement in general.
She could be wrong, but it seemed likely that her captor had wanted her specifically. She could be a target simply because of who she was and what she did—it was a risk of such a public FBI job. Or she could have done him some perceived slight, as some killers were egotistical about what they did. Dr. Lecter had made a spectacle more than once because incorrect things were speculated or reported about him.
Clarice cut that thought off abruptly. This wasn’t one of Dr. Lecter’s crime scenes—she wasn’t anyone’s crime scene. She was alive and she intended to keep it that way.
If she was working under the assumption that her captor knew exactly who she was and wanted her for some particular reason, then she needed to figure out what he wanted. Which was admittedly hard to do when she had nothing to work with.
Clarice began going through a mental file of all her current cases, reviewing what she knew about the victims and what she had surmised about the killers. It took a considerable amount of time, but she had near encyclopedic knowledge about everything that was currently assigned to her, and when she closed her eyes she could almost see the case files.
Unfortunately, there was nothing that jumped out at her as definitive or even promising. She knew he could still be related to something there, as many of the cases were just beginning to take shape, but as it was, she had nothing to go on.
She had thought of everything she could, and she still had nothing to go on. But processing this like any other crime scene was how she was keeping herself from going crazy.
She still hadn’t heard the car start, even after all this time.
Clarice stood up. Her ankle pained her more now, but it hardly mattered. She made her way to the ladder, and took two steps up. Then she turned the flashlight off and put it in her pocket. She let her eyes completely adjust until she could clearly discern faint light from of the doors. She wanted to be able to see if a shadow passed over either of them. She also wanted her voice to carry.
“Hello?” she called in a neutral, professional tone. “Hello?”
There was no response, but she hadn’t expected one. She continued nonetheless. “My name is Clarice Starling. I’d like to speak to you. However you’re planning for this to end, it’s not going to lead to a good outcome for you. I can help you with that. You can change your mind at any time, and I’ll speak to the FBI on your behalf.”
He didn’t reply, but she would have been surprised if he had done so immediately. She paused, waiting a solid minute before speaking again.
“Or maybe there’s something you want?” she continued. “I can help you with that too. We can talk about this.”
There was no indication that he had even heard her. But her gut instincts told her that he was still nearby. Clarice kept talking in intervals, using all the skills she had built over the years. She talked about herself only enough to perhaps humanize her, but she never directly alluded to his obvious plans to kill her. She tried to identify with him, and gave him chances to share his point of view, all the while offering any assistance she could. She pretended that they were sitting across from each other in an interview room, and that this was only a casual information gathering chat, not a hostile situation.
He never responded.
After a time, Clarice stopped. She had made a good start, but she knew she had to let her words settle in his mind before she tried again. Clarice turned the flashlight back on and made her way to the cot. Her ankle was hurting more now, and she stretched her leg out as she pondered her next move.
Around half an hour later, she heard the car come to life and drive away.
Her heart jumped in anticipation at the idea of being truly alone. If she could manage to get the doors open, she could get away.
She heard nothing else from above, but she stayed where she was on the cot and counted out sixty seconds ten times in her head. When she heard nothing, she set the flashlight upright on the floor and climbed the ladder again. She pressed on the doors, ratting them ineffectually. She again tried throwing all of her weight, such as it was, at the middle of the doors where they opened, but she still didn’t have the leverage.
At the thought of leverage, Clarice climbed down the ladder and surveyed the cellar again. She examined the broken lawn chairs with interest. The woven plastic fibers were brittle and shredding, and she thought she might be able to separate them from the frame. She dragged one of them over to the cot, re-positioned the flashlight, and began to work.
It took her probably an hour, but eventually she picked enough of the plastic loose to free the metal frame. The frame itself, she managed to partially disassemble, which gave her one long L-shaped piece that she intended to try on the door. It even had an end that was flat, from where it had been shaped to screw into another part of the frame.
Clarice balanced on the ladder and applied her makeshift pry bar along the edges of the doors. She tried not to be discouraged, and even tried the least likely places for pressure to work after she had applied leverage at the obvious places. She bashed and pried at the hinges, but they were solid and immovable. She worked for long after she knew she’d failed, but if she simply sat and gave up, that was giving up.
She wondered if he had slid something like a broom handle through the doors after he’d locked them. It’s what she would have done, if she were designing an escape-proof room. A bar was a simple, yet incredibly effective way of blocking an exit.
Eventually, she had to accept that she wasn’t going to be able to get the doors open. She threw her piece of metal to the floor. Then she screamed for help as loud as she could.
Clarice knew the chances of someone being nearby, let alone nearby when she happened to yell, were close to zero. But she had to try. She knew that screaming her head off was going to do nothing but make her lose her voice and dry her mouth out. But she determined that she would make an attempt at regular intervals. However, she couldn’t climb up the ladder every time to do it.
Getting down, Clarice dragged the cot close to the ladder so that she could sit at one end of it and have the ventilation pipe directly overhead. She moved the remains of the lawn chair back under the steps so he wouldn’t immediately see it when he came back. The longest piece of frame, she leaned against the wall next to the cot. If nothing else, it could be a makeshift weapon. It was aluminum and lightweight, but it would take him by surprise if nothing else. A surprise blow to the head, even without much weight behind it, could be very effective. A smaller L-shaped piece of the lawn chair frame, she balanced on the second step from the top. He would see it if he looked, as it stuck out at an angle, but if he simply started down without looking, it might trip him and give her the advantage she needed.
The afternoon passed slowly.
She examined the cellar again with the flashlight, looking for anything she had missed. She also looked for any hidden cameras that might be monitoring her. But she found nothing. Cameras were of course small enough to be nearly invisible, but there were no electrical outlets, no smoke alarms, no picture frames to hide them in here. And everything was covered with a layer of grime. It truly looked like nothing in the cellar had been touched in years.
Clarice never heard the car return, and she shouted for help whenever she could. Twice, she heard a car pass on the distant gravel road, but they never slowed or stopped. Her thirst and her hunger began to make themselves known, but she tried to ignore them. She designated the broken cooler as her toilet, which was disgusting on many levels, but at least it was better than going in a corner.
Her ankle remained sore, a persistent pain from the multiple times she balanced on the ladder, but it only swelled minimally and hadn’t gotten worse. She had initially tried to stay off of it, but had quickly given up on that. If she hurt her ankle further getting out of here, that was a price she was willing to pay. Occasionally she had to get up and move just to stay warm. The temperature outside had been cool since this morning, but as the day wore on and her adrenaline wore off, she was plagued by a persistent chill.
She only realized that night had fallen when she turned off the flashlight to check, and no longer saw the faint daylight through the ventilation pipe.
It was still early in the evening, but the stress of the day, plus the fact that she’d been sleep deprived for at least a week, had finally caught up to her. She disliked the idea of going to sleep, of being unaware and vulnerable, but she also knew that it was going to be impossible to remain awake the entire time she was here, however long that might be.
Clarice was a light sleeper while napping, and she told herself that she would hear the noises of the metal doors opening if he came back before she woke, and she would definitely hear him if he tripped and fell. However, despite her exhaustion and her usual ability to find sleep easily, sleep was elusive. The metal supports of the cot dug in uncomfortably, but more distracting than that was the cold.
It wasn’t life threatening—the forecast for the entire region had been milder than usual, and temperatures were not going to be nearly cold enough for frostbite or hypothermia. But it was more than cold enough to be profoundly uncomfortable for someone who was dressed to go into an office. She had on wool socks and practical leather ankle boots, but her polyester slacks, while perfectly serviceable for walking briskly around a crime scene, seemed painfully thin. Her blazer gave her another layer on top, but it was far from enough to make her comfortable.
She had the dry thought that she could thank climate change for the fact that she wasn’t freezing to death in December.
Clarice slept in fits and starts throughout the night, curled in a fetal position with her hands tucked into her armpits for warmth. Sometimes it seemed like she had only just gotten to sleep before the cold or the discomfort woke her.
When she finally woke up for good, it was light outside, but she’d slept so badly that she had no other gauge for how early it might be. It could have been eight in the morning or it could have been noon. She also had no way of knowing if her captor had returned or if he was still gone. She was confident she would have heard the cellar door opening while she was asleep, but she was less certain that she would have heard the car.
Clarice briefly debated, but decided that she had to operate on the assumption that he both was there and that he wasn’t. She tried talking to him again, all the same essentials that she’d said yesterday but with different words. When that produced nothing, she screamed for help, fully aware that such a thing might bring him down into the cellar to silence her.
But there was nothing.
The day passed slowly, agonizingly slowly.
She kept up her routine of calling for help, but she had to wet her mouth before each time, and it was increasingly hard to do so. She was thirsty, and she was hungry, but her thirst was a thing that was impossible to ignore. It was also going to start affecting her physically soon, in more ways that just her mouth being dry.
Sometime into what had to be the afternoon, she heard the car again. It was the sound of a rumbling engine that left the road as the car pulled onto the property. The engine cut, and a single door opened and closed.
Clarice waited, her heart in her throat. She gripped the end of the lawn chair bar.
Minutes passed, but he didn’t open the door.
There was a slight possibility it wasn’t him, but she had to assume that it was. Therefore, it would be better to try talking again than to try yelling for help. She stood on the ladder and again worked her way through all that she had said that morning. There was no reply.
But since she knew he was there, she kept talking, trying different tactics than she had before. She tried to get him to identify and empathize with her. She mentioned her situation directly, but still with the assumption that it could be worked out between them. Knowing that some killers liked to hear it, she even tried begging. It was humiliating, and no part of what she said was put on, which made it all the more awful on a personal level. Everything she said was true—she wanted to live and she didn’t want to die here.
She had felt a creeping sense of desperation and uncertainty at the continued utter silence from above, and finally, her voice worn out, she stopped talking and sat down on the cot.
It had to be over a day since he’d thrown her down here, and that had been the sole interaction she’d had with him.
He hadn’t returned to torture her physically, assault her sexually, or terrorize her psychologically. Which was an abduction best-case scenario in nearly all ways, while being deeply worrying in one other, incredibly specific way. If he wasn’t coming in the cellar, that meant she had not even the smallest chance to trick him or overpower him and escape.
If he never opened the doors, the doors would never open.
It was a stark, bleak realization. Any hope she had of getting out had been entirely pinned on the assumption that he would return for some reason of his own.
Yesterday, she had been frightened but proactive—realistic about how bad this was, but hopeful that she would be able to maneuver something to her advantage. Now that hope had disappeared.
It was clear he was going to leave her here to die.
She could be wrong—there could be something she wasn’t seeing, or even some larger part of his plan that hadn’t gone as anticipated. But she knew she was imprisoned here and he was visiting the scene of his crime, which killers often did for personal enjoyment, even after their deeds were done.
He didn’t even seem to want to be part of it, to do anything to hasten her death. She guessed he simply wanted to know that it was happening. His intention had been to leave her here in the dark—dropping the flashlight had been an accident, but not enough of one that he felt the need to rectify it. He wanted her to know that there was no way out no matter what she tried. Perhaps he wanted her to know that he was there right now, to know that there was a person on the other side of the doors who could easily open them, but wouldn’t.
To know that she was going to die.
The blunt reality of it was overwhelming. She thought she’d been prepared for the idea; she’d known it was a possibility all along, but it wasn’t until this moment that she realized how much she truly thought she would get out of this somehow.
She needed to deal with the fact that that wasn’t going to happen.
Clarice shut her eyes.
Only a minute later, she opened them.
Actually, she decided with a grim practicality, she didn’t have to deal with it. She was going to die here whether she tried to make peace with it or whether she refused to think about it.
The end result would be the same.
