Chapter Text
Hannibal sits at his office desk, staring vacantly at a painting of a majestic stag framed on the far wall. His quill tip lingers over the lined pages of a notebook, a blot of ink landing on his patient’s observations. He blinks, pulled out of his reverie, and casts a quick tergeo to fix it. With a displeased sigh he closes the file, eyes flicking to the bouquet of flowers and jewellery box next to him; a constant reminder of the task he’s been putting off all morning. The clock on the wall tells Hannibal that he still has a couple of hours before he really must go… if only a worthy distraction would materialise. He side-eyes the adjacent sketchbook, still open where he left it; imperfect figures and rough landscapes abandoned halfway, his distracted fingers refusing to cooperate. Absorbing himself in work or the creative is proving impossible today.
Luckily for him, the intercom rings.
Hannibal is caught off guard by the obnoxious buzzing that cuts through the equally deafening silence. He’d instructed his muggle secretary Nancy to take the day off and leave his diary clear today. He’s not expecting any appointments. Hannibal lets it ring off in case it’s simply a sales enquiry—but when the buzzer on his desk sounds for the second time, he realises this is not somebody who can be ignored. He presses the answer button, considerably brusquer than how he would usually greet a patient:
“I’m afraid we’re closed.”
“It’s me.”
Hannibal stills, recognising the quiet intensity of Will Graham’s voice. Just like in their first meeting, the herbologist has an inconvenient knack for surprising him. After a moment’s deliberation, Hannibal presses another button and unlocks the main door downstairs. His office is a well-to-do establishment located in Richmond, one of London’s affluent inner districts. He shares this historic building with four other muggle businesses, his own located at the very top for security reasons. The entire block is cloaked in defensive spells, including anti-apparition charms; should some bureaucratic busybody from the Ministry of Magic start poking around, Hannibal doesn’t want to make it too easy for them. Will Graham has a total of four steep flights of stairs to climb to reach him. Now the race is on.
Hannibal stands and draws his wand, pointing to his impressive oak-carved desk. A clicking noise follows as the inner locks undo, and the solid wood separates in two, the bottom half sliding out to reveal his secret potion stash. The drawer holds dozens of multi-coloured vials, all labelled meticulously and arranged in alphabetical order: Amorentia, Draught of the Living Death, Liquid Luck. Hannibal quickly routes through to the letter ‘V’ and retrieves the tiny bottle of Veritaserum hiding at the back. It’s still full. Hannibal would normally eschew such crass methods of extracting information, but he senses that Will Graham is going to be a tougher nut to crack than his muggle patients. With another wave of his wand, the desk reverts to normal. Hannibal has just enough time to conjure two empty wine glasses, dispensing a few drops of the truth potion into one, when Will knocks on the door.
“I’ll be with you in a moment,” Hannibal calls, checking himself in the full-length mirror on the wall to make sure he looks presentable.
“Sure, take your time,” Will answers, sounding apologetic.
When Hannibal is satisfied with both his general appearance and the state of his office, he finally opens the door. He finds Will waiting with his back turned, wearing a flattering pink salmon shirt, ironed chinos, and dress shoes. He’s even combed his hair. Will is not looking Hannibal’s way, busy admiring the painting on the wall outside. It’s a replica of the classic Greco-Roman sculpture Boy With Thorn that Hannibal painted many years ago, attracted by the beauty and complexity of the human body captured in an ordinary moment… but it’s not the artwork that draws his eye now. Will turns around at the sound of the door opening, and Hannibal is not quite quick enough to look up. Will’s raised eyebrow says it all:
Were you checking me out?
Rather than feign embarrassment, Hannibal dips his head and smiles.
“Will, what a pleasant surprise. Please, come in.” He steps aside, allowing the younger man over the threshold. Will peers owlishly at the lavish surroundings, whilst Hannibal applies to him the same scrutiny. He homes in on Will’s sallow skin and the dark circles under his eyes. They weren’t obvious in their last meeting, hidden behind his glasses and softened by the shadows of the Forbidden Forest, but now his exhaustion is plain to see. Hannibal muses what tasteless thoughts are keeping him awake at night.
“I haven’t come at a bad time, have I?” Will interjects, hovering just inside the doorway. “You said you were closed.” The answer to Will’s question is actually ‘yes’—but Hannibal is not going to squander this opportunity.
“I was merely taking a personal day to run some errands. I promise, you’re quite welcome.”
Will nods, concerned frown clearing.
“Good… that’s good.”
Hannibal gives Will a wide berth to allow him to acclimatise, observing with beady dark eyes. Will paces the length of the polished wooden floor, jacket slung casually over his arm, other hand stashed in his pocket. He cranes his neck, blue eyes sweeping across the stylish archways and alcoves.
“This place is really something,” he says after a minute, pausing by the imposing stone fireplace behind Hannibal’s desk. It looks fit for summoning the demons of the underworld.
“A true likeness to your visions?” Hannibal prompts.
“With eerie clarity,” Will confirms, running his finger almost lovingly over a miniature stag statue on the mantlepiece. He soon spots the certificates framed on the adjacent wall, bearing the seal of numerous prestigious medical associations. Will gives Hannibal a half-smile. “I read up on you after our last meeting. I understand you’re very accomplished in psychiatric circles. Word on the street is that you have a gift for handling ‘problem patients’. You’re the man people turn to when the world has written them off as ‘unfixable’.”
To that, Hannibal inclines his head in demure agreement.
“I have a respectable success rate with my patients, yes, although one does not like to boast.”
“And you achieve this all through conventional therapy?” Will presses, eying the shiny awards with scepticism. In this professional setting, with his suit and tie and slick-backed hair, Hannibal might appear to be a man of science—but it couldn’t be further from the truth. Muggle minds are frightfully easy to unravel and reshape. A quick Obliviate, some choice potions…
“Every patient is unique,” Hannibal answers. Will opens his mouth, no doubt to ask more questions, when he stalls. Hannibal follows his gaze, landing on the ribbon-wrapped bouquet and present box on his desk. His stomach drops, realising how this looks.
“Oh, I see… it’s that kind of ‘personal day’, huh?” The smile that Will flashes him is pained.
“Not in that sense,” Hannibal is quick to assure, but the doubt in Will’s eyes remains. Hannibal crosses over to the desk, fiddling with the scalpel and set of razor-sharp pencils laid out next to his half-baked sketches of Palermo and the Duomo. He sighs in irritation, realising he’s going to have to explain himself. Humble pie is not a dish he cares for. “… I know I said that I would clear my diary for you, Will, and I fully intended to keep that promise,” he begins slowly. “But unfortunately, you’ve picked a rather awkward day for it. I’m scheduled to visit my sister today. These gifts are for her.”
“You have a sister?” Will asks with intrigue, taking a careful step forward. He’s clearly not completely sold on Hannibal’s story, thinking it could be a clever lie to hide his sexual escapades.
“Had a sister,” Hannibal corrects after only the smallest delay. Will’s face falls, now close enough to glimpse the delicate blooms inside the wrapping paper: a collection of white lilies and pink carnations. Mourning flowers. Hannibal reaches for the jewellery box to keep his hands busy. The lid springs open, revealing a jade necklace displayed on a cushion of white silk. Hannibal’s nose twitches, stomach turning at the scent of his sister’s blood embedded in the metal. He envies Will, blissful in his ignorance. Hannibal forces a polite smile in front of his guest and finally drags his eyes up, confirming Will’s suspicions: “She would have been thirty-two today. I’ve been putting off my visit to the cemetery all morning.”
“Oh, God. I’m sorry—look, I can come back another day.” Will is already backing up towards the door, looking as though he wishes the ground would swallow him. Hannibal frowns at him, necklace case snapping shut. He holds up a hand in deterrence.
“You don’t need to leave, Will. I meant what I said when I invited you in. Your visit is a bright spot on an otherwise bleak day.” Hannibal glances again to the clock on the wall. It’s just past one o’clock in the afternoon. “I can easily spare another hour before they shut the gates... I imagine you must be hungry, seeing as it’s lunchtime.”
With a wave of Hannibal’s wand, a bottle of red wine and a platter of salami and artisan cheeses appear, floating next to Will’s elbow. Hannibal sees the relief wash over his face.
“Well… if you’re sure.”
“Quite sure.”
Hannibal retrieves the two ‘identical’ glasses he prepared earlier, keeping a close eye on the one in his left hand. The bottle pours of its own accord, red wine mixing with the tasteless, colourless potion sitting at the bottom of the glass. Will gratefully accepts the drink without thinking twice, nibbling on a salami slice.
“Interesting flavour,” he comments, distracted by the ladder sitting in the corner which leads to the library on the second floor. Hannibal smiles in amusement, noticing where Will is looking.
“I recall you commenting on my literary collection during our last meeting. By all means, quench your curiosity.”
Will doesn’t need telling twice. He ascends the ladder and begins perusing the bookshelves. Hannibal’s earlier spell continually tops up his wineglass and replenishes the food platter, as if accompanied by an invisible waiter. From a cursory glance, Hannibal’s collection is as expected for a professional in his field. Will finds several volumes on biology and anatomy, a copy of the DSM 5; advanced mathematics, quantum physics and relativity. Will runs a hand along the wooden shelf, frowning. All is not what it seems. He reaches into his jacket pocket and pulls out his stubby wand, muttering a quick charm:
“Revelio.”
With a worrying groan, the antique bookshelf begins to buckle and bend. Hannibal winces at the heavy-handed spell, making a mental note to check for damage later. A new section slides out from the stone wall, pushing the mundane books to the left. Magical tomes take their place, spines glimmering in golden and silver print. Some are standard-issue, with titles such such as: ‘Moste Potente Potions’, ‘One Thousand Magical Herbs and Fungi’ and ‘The Dark Forces: A Guide to Self-Protection’… but there are more than a few unsavoury volumes too, the likes of which could only have come from the dusty bookshops of Knockturn Alley. Blood magic, rare curses. Even time magic.
Will steps back, comparing the mundane and magical books with amusement.
“You have a peculiar mix of interests,” he notes, speaking to Hannibal down below. “A lot of wizards wouldn’t see any value in studying muggle medicine when you can brew a perfectly good Restorative Draught.”
“I see the disciplines as complementary. Muggle accomplishments can contextualise and advance our knowledge in the wizarding world and vice versa,” Hannibal counters, eyeing his sister’s bouquet with a sour face. “For example, the mathematical probability of you choosing to come here on this day out of an entire year is only 0.27%. That tells me your Inner Eye is rather unreliable.”
Or a little too reliable, depending on one's perspective. Hannibal didn't plan on broaching the painful topic of his sister's death with Will Graham so soon. By his reckoning, this intrusion demands reciprocity. Ignorant of his dark intentions, Will laughs and turns around, leaning over the wooden guard rail. He shoots Hannibal a sarcastic smile.
“How perceptive. You have no idea how many nights I wasted hanging around the Forbidden Forest, hoping you’d show up. I didn’t have much to go on from my visions: only the position of the celestial bodies. I must have mapped more than a hundred astronomy charts trying to work out when you’d be there.” Warmth flickers in Hannibal's chest, hearing that Will went to such lengths to find him. A wry smile curves his lips, mirth dancing in his eyes.
“Well, they do say that Divination is an art, not a science.”
“More like fraud and delusion wrapped up in a pretty package for the gullible.” Will wrinkles his nose in distaste. “The Sight isn’t something that can be taught. The ‘techniques’ they make you learn in school are useless. I barely scraped a pass in my O.W.L.s.”
“Ironically, I did rather well in it,” Hannibal purrs, perching on his desk like an overgrown cat. Will gives him a withering look, nodding to the artisan platter and expensive wine.
“That isn’t surprising. You have a talent for theatrics. Somehow, I can’t imagine you did so well in Care of Magical Creatures.”
“Or Herbology,” Hannibal’s smile widens to a grin, sharp teeth glinting. “I had a nasty encounter with a Venomous Tentacular in my O.W.L. exam. Terribly rude plant. After a brief stay in the hospital wing, I appropriated its roots for my potions stock. Suffice to say the examiners were rather bemused the next day.”
Hannibal’s story has the two wizards chuckling. He is surprised by just how easy Will is to talk to; sharing such foolish memories doesn’t feel debasing, like it would with anyone else. Mirth gives way to bemusement as their laughter fades; but Will’s eyes are still bright and curious, compelled to ask the inevitable:
“Which house were you in anyway?”
Hannibal purses his lips in displeasure. It’s a trite question that could have been lifted from a Ministry of Magic interview– a convenient method of categorisation to put people in boxes. Worthy versus unfit. Incompatible versus suitable. Good versus evil. Will seems to realise he’s mis-stepped, grin sliding off his face when he sees Hannibal’s expression.
“Ravenclaw.” Hannibal does not give Will the opportunity to analyse his answer, quickly flipping the question back on him: “And yourself?”
“… Gryffindor,” Will answers. Hannibal fixes him with a knowing look.
“And was that what the Sorting Hat whispered in your ear, cunning boy?” Will flinches at the challenge. Their gazes lock, both recounting the Sorting Hat’s ditty in their heads:
‘Or perhaps in Slytherin, you’ll make your real friends. Those cunning folk use any means to achieve their ends.’
“No,” Will admits with a sigh, holding onto the guard rail to steady himself. Hannibal wonders if he’s starting to suspect the Veritaserum yet.
“But Gryffindor was the 'morally correct' choice,” he infers. Will gives him a stiff nod. Hannibal smiles faintly at being proven correct. “For those seeking to become Aurors, it is also the best house to put on a resume.” The astute comment catches Will off guard. He squints in mistrust, a flush creeping up his neck.
“How do you know about that?”
“An educated guess, based on your behaviour,” Hannibal replies simply. Will’s grip on the wooden ledge tightens.
“Don’t psychoanalyze me,” he warns through gritted teeth. “You won’t like me when I’m psychoanalyzed.”
“I’m sorry Will; observing is what we do. I can’t shut mine off anymore than you can shut yours off.” Hannibal shrugs in apology, but he’s not off the hook. Sharp blue eyes scrutinise him from on-high.
“Alright then—why did you choose Ravenclaw?” Will’s demand garners a sly smile.
“Those sorted into Slytherin house have always drawn greater scrutiny from the Ministry than their peers, whereas Ravenclaws are perceived as bookish and law abiding. My academic traits were strong enough to make it a believable match.” Hannibal's smirk turns to a sneer, eyes glinting with devilry. “That, and I sincerely despise being labelled.” An awkward silence follows. Will searches his face, a question on the tip of his tongue that he is too polite to ask. Hannibal can already guess what it is. “You wish to learn the reason for my expulsion,” he presumes. At Will's shy nod, Hannibal flashes him an easy smile and gestures towards his desk. “I suspect a verbal explanation would be inadequate. Come down, Will. There’s something I would like to show you.”
Will does as instructed and climbs back down the ladder. With a swish and flick from Hannibal’s wand, the oak desk creaks and clunks, like its non-existent nuts and bolts are coming undone. It slides aside, peeling back the floor beneath in the process, revealing a set of stone steps leading down into darkness. Hannibal turns to Will with a sweeping gesture.
“After you," he invites. Will shoots him a withering look, grip tightening on his wand.
“Do you think I was born yesterday? After you.”
Hannibal considers Will’s demand. Going in front would be the equivalent of allowing a gun to be pointed at his back... but it would also gain Will's trust. They teeter together on the edge, the atmosphere fraught with tension, until Hannibal breaks the deadlock and steps in front. Thankfully, Will only mutters only an innocuous 'Lumos' to light the way. Hierarchy established, they venture slowly down the steps.
They emerge in a circular stone chamber. Muggle logic says that this room shouldn’t exist; Hannibal’s office sits directly above three other floors—there simply isn’t space for it. Magic is handy like that. The chamber is dominated by a large stone basin sitting on a raised platform, filled with a shimmering silver liquid. Will’s eyes grow wide in recognition.
“Is that a pensieve?”
“It is,” Hannibal hums.
Will approaches the magical object in wonder. Hannibal’s mercurial thoughts are swirling within the bowl, their texture somewhere between liquid and gas. Will grips the edge, leaning dangerously close to the surface. He looks like a man dying of thirst, about to plunge his head under and gulp down every last drop. Will straightens up with a shaky laugh, the threads of restraint barely holding together.
“You know, I could really do with one of these at home.”
“I thought you might,” Hannibal agrees, studying his counterpart. The pensieve’s pale light makes Will look even more sickly, highlighting his hollow cheeks and the bags under his eyes. “I imagine your visions must take quite a toll. It must be difficult to rest when your mind is too full of other people. Too many questions. Too many feelings.” Will twitches, throwing Hannibal a sharp glare. The other inclines his head towards the pensieve. “If you wish, you may unburden yourself. I am not averse to sharing, under the right circumstances.” Will swallows thickly, staring at the basin in naked want. The lure of a pensieve is in the promise of peace: a place to store painful memories and ease the burden on an overcrowded mind. Hannibal lays a coaxing hand on Will’s shoulder, crooning in his ear: “A dreamless sleep, Will. Wouldn’t you like that?”
“I would,” he admits, voice dangerously close to a groan… until reason digs its heels into his psyche. Will fixes him with a chilly stare. “But you know, I’m not giving you this for free, Hannibal.” The corner of Hannibal’s lips twitch. Will understands in the marrow of his bones that this is not a benevolent offer of refuge, but a naked bid for power; Hannibal wants to own his very thoughts, so that he may invade them at his leisure... Curious how this brilliant, bizarre man seems to know him so very well.
“I’m sure. As I said, I’m not averse to sharing,” he repeats, smooth as silk. “We both seem equally eager to breach the forts guarding the palaces of our minds. If I proposed a joint venture, would you be amenable?” There is a brief standoff. The two wizards stand opposite the stone basin, the flickering light casting sinister shadows across their faces. Will’s gaze lowers, as if drawn by a magnetic force to Hannibal’s thoughts, shining so brilliant and tempting. He licks his lips, tongue catching between his teeth.
“Within limits,” he concedes. Hannibal hides his smirk of victory and pulls out his wand.
“In that case, may I?” he requests. In answer, Will closes his eyes and leans forward in submission, permitting Hannibal to press the tip of his wand to his temple. "Reveal your thoughts to me, Will," Hannibal commands, low and lustful. Will braces himself against the basin rim, squinting in pain as Hannibal hooks a long, silver thread from the oceans of his mind, casting it into the glimmering abyss.
“There’s more,” Will rasps, cracking his eyes open. “Lots more.”
Hannibal repeats the process, drawing strand after strand of Will’s intrusive visions. By the time he’s done, the basin is almost overflowing, glowing twice as bright as before. Will is breathing heavily, looking ready keel over at any moment, were it not for the block of stone supporting his weight. Hannibal reaches out and squeezes his hand.
“Are you ready?” he asks softly. Will raises his head and manages a nod.
Facing each other, both men lean forward in unison, their faces reflected in molten silver. Their thoughts seem to reach for them, tendrils latching on and pulling them in.
Together, they fall.
