Actions

Work Header

Reparo

Chapter 3: Unforgiveable

Notes:

FYI, I’ve added the ‘graphic violence’ tag just in case… I don’t think it’s too violent considering the source material, but ymmv. Also this chapter contains physical violence against kids.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

As they sink into the pensieve, the two wizards are caught in a whirlwind of colour and sound, accompanied by the stomach-churning sensation of falling from a great height. They land hard on unforgiving stone. Will staggers sideways, Hannibal catching him before he falls.

The setting they find themselves in is achingly familiar: high ceilings, arched windows, and ancient castle walls decorated in livery of blues, reds, yellows, and greens—the four signature house colours. Hogwarts students are bustling about on their way to classes. Hannibal takes a moment to inhale, catching wind of the old scents of his youth: freshly cut grass from the Quidditch pitch, hot school lunches; parchment, candlewax, and leather-bound books. He watches with amusement as a gang of preteen Hufflepuff witches walk straight through Will, chattering away without a care in the world. Their giggles turn to shrieks as Peeves the Poltergeist whirls overhead, dousing the unlucky students beneath with water balloons. Despite being directly in the line of fire, Will escapes unscathed. Grim-faced, he flexes his fingers as if testing their solidity, disturbed to realise that he is less than a ghost. Hannibal remembers that this is his first time using a pensieve. He takes pity and taps Will on the shoulder, making him jump.

“Well, at least someone around here can still see me,” Will mutters, scratching the back of his neck. Hannibal is startled by his choice of words. An insistent itch niggles at the back of his mind; a broken whisper from a nightmare:

‘I let you know me. See me.’

“… Of course, I see you, Will.”

Hannibal ignores Will’s quizzical look, unable to explain the lump in his throat that has turned his voice to sandpaper, nodding in the opposite direction. Will follows his gaze. Heading towards them from the far end of the corridor is a sophisticated looking young man, no older than sixteen. He’s dressed in Ravenclaw garb, with sharp cheekbones and fair brown hair, a Prefect badge pinned to his lapel.

“That’s you?” Will guesses. His companion makes a sound of confirmation.  

They watch as young-Hannibal makes a sharp diversion from the student body, darting down one of the lesser-used fickle staircases that is particularly fond of changing destination. Nobody notices him go; his wand is concealed up his sleeve, muttering Obliviate under his breath. Anyone who happens to glance his way will forget he was ever there. Current Hannibal smirks in self-congratulation; he's always been good with memory charms. His younger-self makes his way unchallenged to Professor McGonagall’s office, speaking the password to the door: ‘thistle thorn’. The practicality of Hannibal's choice of house is now obvious. Professor McGonagall would have undoubtedly thought twice about letting an ambitious Slytherin into her inner circle. A studious Ravenclaw on the other hand…

The two men follow the teenager inside. They witness him strolling around the Professor’s meticulously organised office as if he owns the place, running his fingers across McGonagall’s books stacked on her desk, feather quill and ink set. The stern Transfiguration teacher herself is nowhere to be seen. Present-day Hannibal smirks, remembering how he’d spent weeks meticulously mapping out her routine in readiness for this exact moment. In the corner lies his prize: a sealed glass cabinet containing a single gold time-turner. It was entrusted to McGonagall specifically by the Ministry because, aside from being a fearsomely skilled witch, she is a stickler for security; and—usually—an impeccable judge of character. Still, nobody is perfect.

Hannibal’s younger-self stops in front of the cabinet. He runs the tip of his wand down the wood, chanting advanced lockpicking spells that far exceed the Alohamora Charm. 

“That’s a different wand,” Will observes. Hannibal makes a noise of agreement, mouth downturned in melancholy. 

“I’ve had many over the years, but this was my original:13-inch willow, with a dragon heartstring core. It was destroyed by the Ministry the day I was expelled. As was yours, I’d wager.”

Will grimaces at the uncomfortable reminder. His eyes flick to the sleek monstrosity in Hannibal’s hand.

“Where did you get your current one?” 

“I acquired it.” The vague answer makes Will frown, but he is distracted from asking further questions.

Young-Hannibal’s efforts have finally paid off. In a flash of white, the glass cabinet springs open. He withdraws the time-turner with an expression of reverence and hooks the delicate chain around his neck—but does not turn it immediately. He places his wand to the metal, green sparks exploding from the tip, temporarily blinding his ghostly onlookers.

“Did you just…” Will trails off, looking to his counterpart in uncertainty and awe.

“I removed the limitation charm.”

Will’s sharp intake of breath makes Hannibal’s soul sing with twisted satisfaction. All Ministry-issue time-turners are subject to a five-hour restriction; a sensible safety feature to prevent the traveller from unravelling events in the distant past and erasing the current reality—or themselves—by accident. Hannibal Lecter, however, has never appreciated being limited.

“I’ve dedicated my whole life to the study of temporal magic,” he reveals, voice turning quiet. “The events I wanted to change happened many years ago.”

“Why?” Will breathes, looking to the teenager who is holding the keys to reality between his fingertips. Young-Hannibal is mesmerised. His lips are pressed together, brow furrowed in concentration. Light reflects off the metal time-turner, catching his eyes just right, brown irises glinting with red fire. Will’s hands twitch, as if tempted to shake the answers out of him. “What did you want to change so badly?”

Hannibal does not answer. His younger self turns the device once, five, ten times. Will soon loses count of the rotations, hours bleeding into days, weeks, months… but as soon as the magic begins to take effect, the memory abruptly cuts to black.

Will startles, looking around. It’s as though God reached down with His divine hand and turned out all the lights. The two wizards are stood together in stretching darkness.

“What happened?” He turns to Hannibal in demand. “Why can’t we see anything?” 

“In truth, I don’t know,” Hannibal sighs. “With regret, I cannot show you the events of my travels because I have no memory of them myself. Evidently, there was some kind of malfunction.”

“Evidently,” Will echoes, deadpan. Hannibal raises his wand in readiness, his expression darkening. 

“What I can show you is what happened after.”

With a swish and flick, the curtain rolls back, and light returns to their surroundings. What follows is the aftermath. Teenage Hannibal awakens on the floor of Professor McGonagall’s office, surrounded by a throng of concerned and enraged faculty members. From his position, it looks as though he must have passed out. Unfortunately for the sly boy, the proof of his guilt is still strung around his neck. He makes the wise decision not to resist as the teachers snatch his wand away and frogmarch him in the direction of Dumbledore’s office.

“Well. I guess that solves the mystery of why you were expelled,” Will says stiffly. Hannibal nods, licking his lips in anticipation.

This is it.

“Indeed. But tell me, what of your expulsion, Will?” The intrusive question makes Will bristle.

“I thought you only wanted to see my visions.”

Hannibal smiles, reaching out and gliding a thumb across his stubble-covered cheek.

“Oh no, Will,” he croons. “I want to see everything.” 

Will’s expression creases in protest, but he cannot hold off the swirling white fog that is suddenly rolling in, as Professor McGonagall’s office melts away before their eyes.

The pair rematerialise in a gloomy room of cold stone. Sunbeams filter through the cracks in the roof, accompanied by the quiet hooting of birds. Amber eyes blink out at them from the shadows. They are in the Owlery at the very top of Hogwarts castle. There are two male students facing off in the centre of the room: a scrawny looking Hufflepuff with a noticeable scar on his temple, and slick Slytherin with a very punchable face.  The Hufflepuff is sobbing on his knees, cradling a lifeless hippogriff in his lap. The magnificent beast dwarfs him in size. Its talons and equine hindquarters are sprawled out across the floor, the boy’s skinny arms looped around its feathery neck. Hannibal immediately spots that the hippogriff’s underbelly has been torn open. Blood is seeping across the floor, turning the boy’s robes damp and the air thick with the scent of copper. Hannibal’s lashes flutter in macabre delight—but his revelling is short lived.

“We shouldn’t be here.” Hannibal turns in the direction of the gravelly voice. Will has retreated as far as he can, backing up against the wall with haunted eyes. “I didn’t give you permission to extract this. This is private, Hannibal.”

Heart hardened, Hannibal observes Will's changing expressions as he struggles to wrestle back control over his own mind. In normal circumstances, Will would be able to limit Hannibal’s access to his memories—but these are not normal circumstances. Under the influence of Veritaserum, the mind is rendered superbly malleable. Will unwittingly agreed to offer up his innermost thoughts at Hannibal’s behest. Closing a dam once the flood has arrived is nigh impossible.  

“As we agreed, the forts that divide our minds will come down—one way or another,” Hannibal declares. Will’s expression turns from fearful to glacial.

“You did something, didn't you?”

Hannibal does not flinch at the accusation spoken through clenched teeth, nor attempt to deny it. He gives Will a pointed look.

“Whilst I may not have your talent for the Unforgiveable Curses, I am very adept at potions.” The statement makes Will pale. His voice shakes. 

"What have you given me?" 

"Only a few drops of Veritaserum. The effect will wear off in a day or so. Plenty of time for us to become friendly." A bitter laugh bursts from Will's chest, teeth bared in spite. 

"So much for 'I wouldn't do that to the food.' You crazy son of a bitch.” 

Hannibal is not intimidated by Will's foul mouth, but a withered part of his soul protests the pain in Will's voice. He quashes the strange feeling like a scurrying bundimun underfoot. Hannibal did not earn all those medical awards for nought; when the sick patient protests the prescribed cure, the doctor’s duty is to act in their best interests. This is a painful but necessary treatment. Who knows? In the end, Will may even thank him.

"Technically it was the wine," Hannibal points out with maddening calm. "And after our curious little tea party in the woods, I'd say you're in no position to be pointing fingers, Will."

Will winces at the reminder of his unconscious use of the Imperius Curse during their previous encounter. His mouth works, but no sound comes out. With no counter forthcoming, Hannibal turns his back, privately glad to escape Will’s conflicted expression. He returns his attention to the two arguing students. It quickly becomes apparent that this was no tragic accident. This was murder.

“What have you done, Peter?” the Slytherin accuses. His expression of shock is painted on, dark eyes vacant of feeling. The scrawny boy—Peter— sniffles, voice as broken as the creature in his arms.

“I didn’t—didn’t do anything.”

“I’m worried about you. You’ve been expressing a lot of rage lately,” the other croons in false concern, eying the dead hippogriff. “You’re prone to extremes of emotion. The way you think is compromised. This is the same hippogriff that kicked you in the head, isn’t it?” The slimy boy gestures at the scar on Peter’s forehead, in the distinctive shape of talons. The Hufflepuff shakes his head wildly, holding the creature tighter.

“No… you killed him. You killed him!” Just as the boy seems to be on the verge of a breakdown, a third voice interjects:

“It’s alright, Peter.”

Hannibal’s eyes flick to the side. From out of the shadows steps a much younger Will Graham, sporting a red and gold tie, the signature Gryffindor apparel. Hannibal is quietly shocked by Will’s youthful appearance. Absent his masculine stubble and faint frown lines  that speak to adult hardships and accrued wisdom, this Will looks downright pretty. Long lashes, big blue eyes that catch the sunbeams, full cheeks. Hannibal is sure that had they crossed paths at this age, he would’ve eaten him up.

“Clarke Ingram, isn’t it?” the newcomer asks quietly. His voice is slightly higher pitched than his present-day counterpart, but it’s still undeniably Will. The Slytherin boy is taken aback.

“How long have you been there?” he asks, sounding more inconvenienced than afraid.

“Long enough.” Young-Will bends down next to the weeping Peter and loops an arm around his shoulders, helping him to stand.

“Are you a Prefect?” Ingram demands, scanning Will’s clothes for the usual badge; looking for any indication that he holds a position of authority that should be respected. Will doesn’t answer, preoccupied with steadying the shaking boy. The Slytherin frowns and dares to take a step forward. “Look, let me be clear, this is all a tragic misunderstanding.”

Before Clarke Ingram can manage a basic counter-curse, Will’s wand is pointed at his throat.

“I’m not a Prefect,” Will tells him, words biting and cold as ice. “I’m Peter’s friend.”

The Gryffindor teen begins his advance, driving Ingram at wand-point towards the Owlery window. Just then, a gasp to his left draws Hannibal’s attention. Adult-Will is struggling, his face screwed up with effort, gripping his hair so tightly that he risks ripping out great chunks. The guilt that Hannibal thought he’d exorcised returns tenfold.

“There’s no sense in fighting it,” he warns, sternness tempered by worry. Hannibal reaches out to try and stop Will from hurting himself, but he pulls out of Hannibal’s grip with an animalistic hiss.

“Don’t touch me.”  

Just then, a scream rips through the air.

Ingram is pressed up against the wall as if a stake has been driven through his sternum, Will’s wand pointed directly at his chest. He writhes like a man possessed, fingernails splintering as he claws the stone walls, leaving a trail of blood. Just like in the Forbidden Forest, young-Will seems not to be fully awake— or rather, it’s as though another personality has taken over. Righteous anger steadies his wand-arm, observing his handiwork without remorse; an executioner passing a just sentence. Ingram’s cries travel the length and breadth of the tower, the owls’ shrieks of alarm only adding to the din. It seems that the torture might go on forever, until Peter dares to step forward and catch his arm.

“Will? Will! Y-you need to stop!”

At the gentle boy’s request, Will finally lowers his wand, but the cold expression on his face hasn’t changed. Peter sighs in relief, and Hannibal also makes the mistake of thinking it’s over—until Clarke Ingram picks himself up from his crumpled heap and begins shuffling towards the Owlery window.

“I-Ingram?” Peter tries.

The Slytherin boy doesn’t say a word. Doesn’t falter. He simply hoists himself up onto the ledge with a dreamlike smile on his lips, and then steps off.

In the seconds that follow, it’s as though time has stopped. The echo of Ingram’s screams from the Cruciatus Curse have faded, and an eerie pall has fallen. Will remains frozen opposite the window with a glazed-over expression. Hannibal regards him in wonder, chest swelling with pride. Will Graham may never have cast the third Unforgiveable Curse in his life… but that doesn’t mean he’s never killed anyone. Peter is still latched onto Will’s arm, eyes wide as saucers, staring at the spot where his tormentor was just standing. Even the owls have stopped their shrieking, like the entire world is holding its breath.

Then comes the dull thud from down below.

The sound brings the young Gryffindor to his senses. A whimper escapes Will’s lips as he backs away from the window, stammering and stuttering. His protests overlap with his present-day counterpart:

“N-no, no, no— no!”

Adult-Will has buried his face in his hands, shoulders shaking. Hannibal isn’t sure if he’s crying or enraged. Either way, he feels compelled to step in. Will Graham in distress is not a sight that he can abide—Lord knows why. Hannibal steps forward and gathers the disturbed man into his arms, just as Peter Bernadone does for Will’s younger-self, coaxing the guilty wand from his hand that he will never use again. 

“You did nothing wrong, Will,” Hannibal assures, cupping the back of his head in a firm grip, wrapping his other arm around his waist. Will succumbs to the embrace, propping his chin on Hannibal’s shoulder and sliding his arms up his back.

As the past continues to play out, Peter leads his younger-self away down the tower steps, to be shortly taken to the Headmaster’s office—and thereafter, to the Ministry of Magic to stand trial.

“Well, now you know what happened to my dreams of becoming an Auror. I was lucky they didn’t throw me into Azkaban,” Will mutters with no small amount of sourness. He draws closer, grip tightening just below Hannibal’s shoulder blades, scrunching his expensive suit jacket. Strangely, Hannibal finds that he doesn’t mind. “Almost makes me wish I’d given him a more personal send off.”

Hannibal’s lips curl in delight at the predatory growl. He can read the regret expressed in Will’s clenched fingers; his longing to turn back the clock, pull Clarke Ingram back from the ledge, and squeeze the life out of him with his bare hands. Hannibal turns his face into the crook of Will’s neck, nosing at the soft skin. He smells of fresh pine, animal fur, and cheap sea-salt aftershave. Hannibal is surprised that the scent evokes a feeling of home.

“Doing bad things to bad people makes you feel good,” he mouths against his neck. Will presses up against him, pawing at Hannibal’s jacket in need.

“Yes,” he whispers. Hannibal’s lips graze along his throat, murmuring sweetly like a lover would.

“Then it is the Ministry’s loss. Clarke Ingram displayed all the hallmarks of one day becoming a dark wizard. If I were Headmaster, I would have put in a good word for you with the Auror Office.”

“I’m sure you would.” At last, Will finds it in himself to pull away. He wipes his damp eyes with his shirt sleeve and gives Hannibal a twisted grin, looking twice as exhausted as before. “Guess I should’ve known you hadn’t forgiven me for the Imperius incident. I’d say this makes us even, wouldn’t you?”

“Even steven,” Hannibal agrees. Will shivers at a sudden chill that has nothing to do with the cold breeze coming through the Owlery window. He rubs his arms through his shirt, trying to erase the goosebumps that have erupted on his skin.

“You felt that too just now, right? Almost like déjà vu?” he queries, throat scratchy. Hannibal runs a musing thumb across his bottom lip.

“Indeed. Many aspects of our conversations feel familiar. I wonder, why is that?”

“Search me.” Will shoves his hands in his pockets. Hannibal’s eyes flash with hunger at the ‘offer’, placing a smooth palm on Will’s cheek before he can escape.

“Yes, I rather think I shall.” Will trembles charmingly under his touch, unable to break free of his dark gaze. Hannibal’s satin words bind his spirit tighter than rope, honeyed tongue extracting bitter truths. “Time to show me what you See, Will.”

Will screws his eyes shut as the solid bricks and mortar surrounding them collapse into wisps of smoke, still affected by the Veritaserum. Even if he wanted to, he can’t refuse. Hannibal takes hold of Will’s twitching arm to ground him, as figures of mist coalesce and disperse in quick succession. As Hannibal suspected, these ‘visions’ Will spoke of are in fact memories… Specifically, memories of him.

Snapshots of Hannibal’s early years play out before his eyes. He sees himself at twelve years old receiving his first wand—an expensive import bearing the wandmaker Olivander’s mark, gifted from his father. In the next, Hannibal is perched on a wooden stool in Professor Dumbledore’s office wearing the Sorting Hat, a third-year transfer student fresh-off-the-boat from Lithuania. The hat eventually gives its verdict of ‘Ravenclaw’, sounding unusually displeased.

There are more painful memories too. Hannibal’s stomach drops when the mist consolidates into the bars of a steel cage. He and Will are standing in a bare, windowless room lit by flaming torches. ‘Dungeon’ would be the most apt term. Inside the cage are two children, both heartbreakingly thin, with matted brown hair and sunken cheeks: a boy no older than eight, and a girl a couple of years younger. Neither can speak, their lips sealed by a silencing charm. Magical rope binds their wrists and ankles, glowing a sickly green. Hannibal knows this memory well… in fact, it is the reason why he chose to invest in a pensieve in the first place. Will Graham is not the first to suffer from sleepless nights. 

“What do you know of this vision, Will?” Hannibal queries, voice as neutral as he can make it.

“Nothing,” Will answers, shaking his head. His fists are clenched, fingernails biting into his palm at the sight of the wretched babes curled up at the bottom of the cage. “I’ve been dreaming about them since I was a kid myself… but I don’t know who they are.”

“Are you certain?” Hannibal presses softly. Will bites his lip but does not answer. Hannibal suspects they are both remembering the same thing: a magnolia tree bearing sinful fruit, delicious screams that fail to satisfy; poisonous blooms with bloodstained petals, cut stems drinking from split capillaries. Will had been so very eager to participate back then, hadn’t he?

Just then, the door to the dungeon opens, and a trio of wizards clad in hooded cloaks sweep into room. The ringleader of the group draws his wand. Hannibal recognises it immediately: yew, 12 ¼ inch, with a cheap and nasty core of kneazle whisker that is in desperate need of replacement. With a lazy flick, the cage door is released, and one of the men reaches inside. The little girl is dragged out by the hair, her screams straining for release against invisible stitches. The young boy tries to get to her, but their jailer simply laughs and kicks him in the chest, sending him sprawling on his back. They are two children facing a cult of dark wizards. They don’t stand a chance.

With another jab of the ringleader’s wand, the young boy is made to sit up in the cage, limbs jolting and joints cracking at the sudden force. The back of his head is pushed forward by an invisible hand, cheeks forced up against the iron bars, his eyelids peeled open. Present-day Hannibal watches on with a face of stone, long-healed bruises resonating with a dull ache. Just beyond the cage, the hooded lackeys tower over the little girl, holding her still by the arms. The boy frets and writhes against his invisible bonds, but he can’t reach her. They are only a few feet apart, but fate and circumstance conspire to separate them forever. The ringleader steps up from behind, his face hidden beneath the hood of his cloak.

“Cowards,” Will seethes in the present, echoing Hannibal’s own sentiment. In his right hand, the criminal wields a gleaming dagger. It appears ritualistic, with runes engraved into the white hilt. Hannibal identifies the colour and texture as human bone.  

It all happens so quickly. So undramatically.

The ringleader yanks the little girl’s hair and pulls her head back, granting him easy access to her neck. Rather than draw a line across her throat, he stabs the blade with cool precision into her trachea. Surprisingly, no blood is spilled: the knife appears to be absorbing it, turning the hilt from white to crimson, runes flaring with dark power. The little girl spasms on the floor, her skin shrivelling and turning black like a dried prune. Once every last drop of blood is extracted, the dark wizard pulls out the blade, examining it with satisfaction. With a casual swish and flick, her body vanishes. Where they’ve sent her is anyone’s guess.

The men leave their remaining captive with a promised threat of return. As soon as the door closes, the boy sags against the cage bars, shaking like a leaf. Will takes several, stilted steps towards him. Present-day Hannibal maintains his distance, observing with typical reserve as Will bends down and reaches out— only for his hand to pass straight through the shaking child. He’s more than three decades too late.

“Help will come,” Hannibal assures quietly. Word has spread of the children’s abduction, with a hefty reward promised for their safe return. Wizards from noble houses across Europe and beyond will soon join in the search. The Murasakis of Okinawa will be the ones to find him. Hannibal knows this for a fact. Will’s ghostly hand falls away from the bars, hanging limply by his side.

“He’s you, isn’t he?” The whisper is barely audible. Hannibal draws a deep breath before approaching. Will can sense him in his periphery; his mouth spasms, unable to look at Hannibal for fear of breaking down. Despite how immediate it feels, this is not his pain to indulge in. Hannibal reaches out for Will’s closed fist with the gentlest touch, encouraging his fingers to uncurl.

“Yes,” comes the simple answer.

“Then, the girl who was with you…”

“Was my sister. That’s right.” Hannibal looks down at his wand, hesitating to speak her name aloud. The syllables feel foreign on his lips from years of disuse. “Her name was… Mischa.” Will closes his eyes, shaking his head in disgust. Hannibal is rendered speechless as the tears spill over.

Crying—for me?

If the sight of Will’s pain disturbed him before, this is on another level. Hannibal hates it, knowing that he is—in some way— the cause of these tears. Stranger still, he feels like he’s seen Will cry for him before, because of him before. In the most terrible, ugliest of circumstances.

“The time-turner you stole… the thing you wanted to fix… it’s this, isn’t it?” Will rasps. Hannibal feels his own eyes stinging, blinking a few too many times in the dark. He takes refuge in the academic to hide the tightness in his voice.

“Yes—but as you saw, the magic didn't take. In truth, I always knew failure was the most likely outcome. Time magic is a fickle, nebulous beast... Scholars cannot seem to agree on its limits; particularly where temporal paradoxes are involved." Hannibal stops short, looking anywhere but at the little boy in the cage. Helpless. Weak. 

 "I understand. You studied time magic to undo your sister’s death—but if you'd succeeded in saving her, you would never have stolen that time-turner in the first place. It's a contradiction.” The quiet damnation in Will's voice cuts deeper than a karambit. Hannibal dips his head in agreement. He’d arrived at the same conclusion years ago.

"Yes... but I owed it to Mischa to at least try.”

Quiet falls, punctuated by fretful gasps. The little boy in the cage is weeping, bound and mute, sobs contained behind his sewn mouth. Even animals are permitted to grieve; Hannibal’s captors have denied him even that small dignity. A minute passes. And then:

“I would’ve killed them.” Tear-filled eyes have turned to ice, calloused fingers twitching with the desire to wrap around a sinner's throat. "If I'd been here, Hannibal, I swear..." Hannibal is taken aback by Will's sudden change in tone. No longer is he a broken bird, but a steel-backed soldier. In him, Hannibal sees the product of accumulated pain; a blunted sword thrown into the furnace to be melted down and reforged, struck by the blacksmith’s hammer until it forms the perfect point. A lifetime’s work… perhaps more than a lifetime. He takes a step closer, catching hold of Will's fingertips. They are perfectly steady. 

“Tell me, how would you have done it?” he intimates softly as the white mist begins to descend, engulfing the imprisoned child, sobs swallowed by silence. Will takes a deep breath and looks Hannibal dead in the eye.

“With my hands.”

The stale, claustrophobic air of the dungeon is swept away by a fresh breeze as a new vision emerges. This time, Hannibal sees himself as a young man in his mid-twenties, facing off against an elderly wizard in a hooded robe. They are alone in a wheat field in the sprawling farmlands of Lithuania, not far from the castle where Hannibal grew up—where he and Mischa were taken from. The full moon looms overhead, tendrils of fog clinging to their ankles as if the spirits are trying to trip them. Hannibal remembers this encounter well.

“Avada Kedavra!”

Green flashes split the night, summoned by the blood-curling cry. The hooded man is firing killing curses left and right, but his opponent is nowhere to be seen, disguised by a disillusionment charm. His Achilles heel is suddenly slashed from behind by an invisible blade. The elderly wizard falls back with a yell, wand rolling away into the grass. It is an inelegant way to disarm someone—but Hannibal is a practical soul when he needs to be. Theatrics can wait until the post-mortem. 

The young man rematerialises, standing over his old enemy with wand raised:

“Petrificus Totalus.”

The frail man goes rigid at Hannibal’s behest, every muscle in his body contracting as if hooked up to an electric current. His fingers curl into claws, jaw clamping shut with such force his aging teeth threaten to crack. Only his eyes still move, watching in terror as Hannibal reaches into his suit jacket and pulls out a dagger. The blade is sharp and wicked, its hilt engraved in the same style as the one used on his sister years earlier. A deliberate choice. 

Watching from the sidelines, present-day Hannibal steals a glance at Will. His mouth is set in a thin line, but he doesn’t avert his gaze from the bloody proceedings. Hannibal is surprised at first, until he remembers that Will has been seeing these visions for years. He thinks back to their meeting in their Forbidden Forest, and Will’s bland reaction to his morbid artistry. It’s all starting to make sense.

The pair watch as young-Hannibal extracts the man’s heart from his chest with elegant precision. His defeated opponent twitches on the ground, forced to watch as the victor takes a great bite of the spoils. Blood slides down Hannibal's chin, dripping red onto golden wheat. His older counterpart grimaces at the memory of copper, saliva flooding his mouth. Hannibal enjoys certain meats raw, but heart is not one of them; still, the pleasure in this particular meal is not in the taste. His younger-self presses on valiantly, teeth sinking into gristle and fat, swallowing past the bile rising in his throat. Soon the entire thing is gone.  

“You—you ate his heart,” Will states. His voice is strained, but the emotion beneath is indecipherable. Hannibal turns to him with a sneer.  

“He wasn’t using it anyway. This is the same man you saw in the previous vision.”

“The one who killed Mischa?”

“Yes.” A tense pause. “Are you disgusted by me?” Hannibal is unsettled by the deafening insecurity in his own voice. Why should he care what Will Graham thinks of him?

“No.” The vehement denial brings a rush of relief that almost makes Hannibal groan. Will is staring at him with parted lips, dark triumph gleaming in his eyes. “I think it’s poetic.” Electricity sparks and crackles between them. Hannibal can’t resist drawing closer, the two of them magnets with opposing poles.

“Beautiful, even?” He speaks in hushed tones; the delicious taboo of blasphemy uttered in church. Will’s half-lidded eyes fall to his lips, and Hannibal is just about to bend, when a soft glow illuminates their surroundings.

“Lumos,” comes the command. Will glances to his left to look. Hannibal draws back, annoyed by the interruption. His younger-self has picked up the dead man’s wand and is now casting a tester spell. His face is set in concentration as he measures the response, pleased by its slightly heavier weight, the smooth grip of the handle. For a second, he almost looks as though he’s about to cry… but with a decisive motion, the moment passes. Young-Hannibal slides his current wand out of his pocket and holds it aloft. “Incendio.” The wood bursts into orange flame, proof of the crimes committed by its hand reduced to ashes. His expression doesn’t so much as flicker; a wand too-easily won does not inspire much loyalty from either side—but Hannibal is confident that his latest prize will prove a better match.   

“I guess taking his heart wasn’t enough for you,” Will remarks dryly.

“When I realised my efforts to save Mischa with the time-turner had failed, I made her a promise.” Hannibal’s voice drops, watching his younger-self conjure a shower of silver and gold sparks with his new wand, the night sky transformed into a canvas. “I swore that if I couldn’t save her, I would at least find her. Every last piece… however long it takes.” Will’s eyes are turned towards the heavens, where the familiar face of a little girl now smiles down upon them. A nudge against his elbow makes him tear his gaze away; he finds Hannibal offering his wand for inspection. Intrigued, Will runs his index finger tentatively along the sprig of yew, shuddering as the core’s energy passes into him. There’s something almost human about it. Hannibal soon reveals why. “As I said before, these ‘men’ are in the business of harvesting pureblood children, turning our organic matter into amulets. That includes wands.” Will looks up at him, appalled. Hannibal does his best to school his face, but he isn’t sure he quite succeeds. “This wand’s core, it’s her. It’s Mischa’s heartstring.” Will takes a moment to absorb this. He looks unsteady, like a mariner who has spent too long at sea in bad weather.

“That necklace on your desk, back in your office," Will begins, battling against his closing throat. "You said it was a 'gift'.” 

“And a sense, it was," Hannibal confirms. "I was returning to her what they stole."

The grave of Mischa Lecter that sits on the edge of Richmond Cemetery is unlike any other: a glittering vault of gemstones steeped in blood, and precious metals that belie fragments of teeth and bone. 

“Have you found all of her yet?” Will ventures.

“Around 20%."

His counterpart sucks in a breath, closing his eyes in pain. Will’s question, when it finally comes, is not at all what Hannibal expects:

“If I confessed the urge to kiss you right now, how would that make you feel?” A deadly-delightful spark shoots through Hannibal’s limbs, hearing his words echoed back to him. When Will’s eyelashes flutter open, Hannibal’s mouth turns dry. He realises that he doesn’t have a clue how to answer.

“I’m… not entirely sure,” he admits.

Will frowns, stepping in and taking Hannibal’s waist with both hands. Their roles from earlier have suddenly reversed. Now it is Will whose grip is solid and grounding; an anchor in heavy weather, whilst Hannibal fights the impulse to cling. Will’s salmon shirt reveals the contour of his biceps, filled with the promise of hidden strength. A part of Hannibal wonders what it would be like to sink into those reliable arms and allow himself to weep—but he doesn't. He is a big brother, his sister’s keeper, now a full-grown man, stuck in an overpopulated world of wallowing pigs begging to be culled. He is the hunter now.

Yet, the second Will lays a hand on his cheek, all of Hannibal’s deadly instincts vanish. A comforting thumb passes just below his eye as if wiping away unshed tears, tracing his jawline down towards cupid's-bow lips. Hannibal’s mouth twitches reflexively. Will’s hands are so unlike his own: smaller, rougher, raised callouses accrued from years of manual labour. Not soft. But... safe. Will's touch lingers on his jaw, thumb resting against his bottom lip. Hannibal presses a kiss to the lone digit, trying to read his intent. The desire in Will’s eyes has flamed out, leaving glowing embers of something gentler. Kinder. Deeper. Hannibal is simultaneously intrigued and unnerved.

Hannibal welcomes the tickle of warm breath against his mouth, blood pounding in his ears in anticipation before the kiss lands. The first touch is a bare brush, followed by a gentle press. Will’s lips are chapped, bitten from nervous habit, the slight scratch of his beard leaving tingles on Hannibal’s skin. His tongue is equally attentive as his hands, making a polite lick of enquiry before he slips into Hannibal’s mouth, almost shy. As Will’s fingers thread through his salt-and-pepper hair, Hannibal feels himself sinking. Compassion floods into him through every point of connection, like Will is trying to drown him with every shared breath. He’s never kissed anyone like this. Never lost himself like this.

The twitch of his ever-keen nose finally pulls Hannibal back to the present. Too late, he realises their surroundings have changed. It is still night, but there is now a distinctive smell of salt on the breeze, accompanied by the distant crash of waves coming from somewhere far below.

“Are we by the sea?” Hannibal murmurs inquisitively against Will’s mouth, moving to pull away. Will’s blissed-out expression bleeds into fear.

“Wait.” His hands have found Hannibal’s forearms, tightening like a vice. Will implores him with whispered words and frantic eyes. “Please… don’t.”

“I asked to see all your visions, Will,” Hannibal reminds him, formerly indulgent tongue regaining some of its sharpness.

There are other noises now: pained grunts and protesting cries, heavy thumps and scraping metal on stone. The sounds of war. From the distinct cadence, it sounds to Hannibal like there are three combatants, all males. Will shoots him a glare. 

“You didn’t ‘ask’ me for anything.”

That gives Hannibal pause. Perhaps it is the influx of hormones from the kiss affecting his neurotransmitters, or the memory of Will's expression of betrayal in the Owlery tower; whatever the reason, Hannibal suddenly feels guilty for putting Will in this position. Like this is a mistake he’s made before.

In that moment, Hannibal decides to try something new. He decides to try listening.

“… There is a vial in my breast pocket. It contains the antidote to the Veritaserum.” Will blinks at the revelation. Suspicious, he dips a hand quickly into Hannibal's jacket pocket and fishes out a glass vial. It contains a distinct lilac liquid with a silver sheen. Will examines the contents, teeth worrying his lip; he may be a man of many talents, but he is no potions master. "I already poisoned you," Hannibal helpfully reminds him. "What do you have to lose?" 

"Oh, just a few things: my sanity, my life, probably more. You can be quite inventive," Will grimaces. But it's not like he has any other options. Misgiving etched into his brow, Will uncorks the stopper and—pausing just long enough to say a silent prayer—downs it in one.

As soon as the potion passes his lips, the forts of Will’s mind raise themselves afresh. The men’s cries are cut off mid-shout and the smell of sea spray dissipates, concealed by a curtain of darkness. Frustration stabs at Hannibal’s gut, accompanied by a yearning ache, like his insides have been pulled out. He regards his companion in silent demand.

Who are you to me, truly?  

Something tells Hannibal he was so close to understanding, if he could only see this final event—but it's not to be.

Another rushing sensation ambushes them. This time, the pair are thrust sharply upwards like they are strapped to a rocket launcher, reaching for each other amongst the cacophony of colour and sound. 

Time's up. 


With a great gasp, Hannibal and Will break through the pensieve’s surface, free from their tumultuous thoughts. They are back in reality. Hannibal staggers away as Will falls forward, catching hold of the stone basin for support. Out of the two of them, the latter seems to have come off worse. Hannibal prises Will’s fingers free and takes hold of his elbow, leading him back up the stone steps towards the office.

Once above-ground, Hannibal’s desk slides seamlessly back into place, covering the entrance to the secret chamber. He guides Will into one of the comfortable leather armchairs. Will is grey-faced, hands trembling on the armrests as his fingers dig into the padding. With a quick flick of his wand, Hannibal conjures a glass of whisky and waves it under his nose; Will jumps, pulled out of his daze by the heady scent of liquor.

“Do I look like a whisky guy or something?” he queries, accepting the glass.

“A hunch,” Hannibal answers, settling down in the opposite chair, cross-legged. “Am I correct?”

“Yeah.” Will nurses the glass with a frown of contemplation. “Thanks. For letting me leave,” he says at last. Hannibal drums his fingers on the chair in agitation, speaking to the stag painting behind Will’s head.

“I found the prospect of forcing you to disclose intimate details you were not ready to give… distasteful.”

“That’s a pretty rapid rate of personal growth. Congratulations,” Will snarks, looking off to the side.

After a few seconds, he seems to come to a decision. Will sets down the glass and pulls out his wand. Hannibal is transfixed as he presses the tip to his temple and withdraws a delicate silver thread. Will transfers it carefully to the empty antidote vial and stoppers it. With a quick Winguardium Leviosa the vial levitates, floating over towards Hannibal.

“Take it,” he orders. Hannibal accepts, but does not fully trust Will’s gift, searching his counterpart for any whiff of deceit. Will gives him a tired smile. “I was planning to tell you anyway at some point; I just didn’t count on showing you… and definitely not with me present.”

“What is it about this particular vision that inspires such fear in you?” Hannibal queries, turning the shimmering bottle over in his hand. Will frowns, struggling to find the right words.

 “It’s... different to the others.” He hunches forward in the chair, taking a sudden interest in the Arabic-style rug on the floor. “I know it can’t be a memory—at least, I don’t think it is. It doesn’t make any sense. Maybe it’s my sleep deprived mind playing tricks on me.” A weak laugh follows, unnatural and forced, poorly covering Will's lack of conviction. His grip tightens on the empty glass. “I’m in it.”

That captures Hannibal’s attention. So far, all of Will’s visions were memories of his life. 

“Not me this time?” Hannibal presses, just to be sure. He is further intrigued when Will avoids the question.

“I did something terrible," he confesses. "Something unforgiveable.” Hannibal tracks Will’s tongue as it darts out, moistening his chapped lips. Some would interpret it as a sign of guilt, but beneath Will’s lowered lashes, Hannibal glimpses the aching hunger within. Slowly, Will drags his gaze up to meet Hannibal's red-eyed stare. “It’s what I think of when I cast my patronus, and it’s also why I can see thestrals.” 

“A vision of death.” Hannibal fiddles with the stopper of the vial, longing to jump straight back into the pensieve. Will grimaces at his obvious glee. 

“You can watch it to your heart’s content once I’m gone. Oh, and that reminds me.” Will stands up on liquor-strengthened legs and pulls out small pouch from his trouser pocket. He opens it and shows the contents to Hannibal—a fine cobalt blue residue. “Floo powder. My own brand,” he elaborates, gesturing to the ornate fireplace that dominates the wall space behind Hannibal’s desk. “You’ll need it to get to my place.” Hannibal tries to ignore the strange flip-flop in his stomach at the thought of Will inviting him into his home. He examines the strange substance with intrigue. Floo powder is usually silver.

“Is it wise for an unregulated herbologist to be using the Floo Network?” he queries, pleased that he manages to keep his voice level. Will rubs the back of his neck. 

“Actually, I’m on a private channel. Strictly invite only. A good friend of mine, Beverly, she helped me set it up.”

Well, that explains the odd colour, Hannibal thinks with a smirk, rubbing the sandy grains between his fingers. 

“In other words, you’re giving me unfettered access to your living quarters. You’re not concerned that you might find me standing over your bed in the middle of the night?”

“Sorry, the channel’s only open during business hours—9am to 5pm. You’ll have to try harder than that,” Will rebuffs with a grin. The harmless flirting instead has a chilling effect. Hannibal’s gaze is drawn back to the sombre flowers and cursed necklace sitting on the desk, and the clock on the wall which tells him Will’s hour is almost up. The cemetery gates will be closing soon. There won’t be further opportunity for them to reconvene today.

“That’s unfortunate,” he remarks, not quite as cool as he’d hoped. “Then, it seems we must part ways. At least, for now.”

“Yeah,” Will agrees softly. “Strange how timing seems to be a recurring issue for us.”

The two men study each other with mournful expressions. Will reluctantly helps himself to a handful of blue powder and steps into the fireplace. Hannibal’s feet move without conscious intention, desperate to be near him for just a little longer. Will looks faintly amused to see Hannibal following him like a lost puppy. He beckons him forward and leans in close, lips grazing Hannibal's cheek.

“I’ll see you again soon,” Will promises, with an immediate caveat: “If you still want to, that is.”

Why wouldn’t I want to? Hannibal puzzles, but doesn't voice the question aloud. He suspects he's already holding the answer. The glass vial containing Will’s final vision thrums in the palm of his hand.

“I’m sure I shall,” he answers instead, dipping his head. “Safe travels, my dear Will.”

The fondness of the address visibly startles Will. He clears his throat, examining his ash-covered shoes in a futile effort to hide the colour blooming in his cheeks. A distraction is in order. Without further ceremony, Will tosses the powder at his feet. Blue flames erupt, tendrils of cold fire curling around his limbs. Hannibal is so busy admiring the colour—a striking shade reminiscent of Will’s eyes—that he almost misses the address:

“Evergreen Galley!” At Will’s command, the cobalt flames whisk him away to an unknown destination. Hannibal sighs, sliding the vial into his pocket for later, and picks up the bouquet on his desk.

As much as he longs to dive back into the tempestuous seas of Will Graham’s mind, he has a duty to fulfil first—and Hannibal Lecter always keeps his promises.

Notes:

Okaaaay now we’re getting into the good stuff! ;) I hope you all enjoyed.

Some terms:

Azkaban- wizarding world prison
Bundimun- a common magical pest

The Owlery scene was inspired by that moment in the fourth HP book/movie where ‘Professor Moody’ demonstrates the Unforgiveable Curses on that poor spider: ‘Talented isn’t she… what shall I have her do next? Jump out the window?’ Honestly, Imperio to me is the scariest Unforgiveable. Seriously, who needs the killing curse? I chose the Owlery specifically because I imagine that would be Peter’s sanctuary, similar to his menagerie of animals in the show. Ingram dragging the dead hippogriff there was done to spoil that place for him.

Some info on Hannibal’s original wand: dragon heartstring wand cores are the most powerful type, and most easily turned towards the Dark Arts. They are also more temperamental than the other cores. Willow trees are symbols of grief and withstanding hardship. In English folklore they were also said to uproot themselves and stalk people... and we know how persistent our happy little cannibal is.

Kudos/comments are very welcome, thank you to everyone who has left feedback and subscribed, couldn't do this without you! <3