Chapter Text
‘How can an entire tree just appear in the middle of a car park without anybody noticing?’
This will be the burning question on everybody’s lips by sunrise. The muggle police who arrive on the scene will be confounded by the impossible scenario, with no footprints, no trace of DNA to work with. If only they could close their eyes and dismiss it as a curious art piece by the illusive likes of Banksy or Above… but the dead man sewn into the branches will demand an answer. When none are forthcoming, the public will invent their own. There will be cries of ‘conspiracy’, talk of a government psyop, blame laid at the feet of capricious billionaires with nothing better to do than tormenting the 99%. Most will find solace in some variation of these.
And then, there will be those who dare to whisper ‘magic’.
They will be sneered at and silenced, placed in the same category of crackpots who say that aliens built the pyramids. What delicious irony—almost as delicious as the meal Hannibal Lecter will make of the warm heart nestled in his bloody hands. He saves it for later, taking out his charmed thermos flask which can hold any number of dismembered limbs without ever becoming full. He shrinks down the organ until it’s no bigger than a penny, sliding it inside.
Thanks to a choice enchantment, his heartless ‘victim’ is still alive. Hannibal watches with satisfaction as he struggles. The vines binding his wrists and ankles to the branches are the Devil’s Snare, their grip tightening with every thrash and flail. With a lazy flick of his wand, Hannibal opens his chest cavity wider. The curse draws a precise red line down the man’s abdomen like a scalpel, followed by the sickening crunch of bone as he splits him wide open. Hannibal reaches in with his bare fingers and pulls. Liver, spleen, and kidneys are safely retrieved in short order—his only parts that have any worth. A little blood splashes Hannibal in the process, but his dapper red-checked suit escapes unscathed. He’s wearing a transparent covering that loosely resembles a plastic poncho. This too is enchanted, burning away any gore or stray hairs that might link him to his crimes.
The moon is beautiful tonight, and the blood coagulating on the forest floor shines obsidian under its pale light. The thestral that Hannibal brought with him sniffs the ground with interest, attracted by the iron scent. Apparition is prohibited within the Hogwarts grounds, so Hannibal had to opt for more… unconventional means of transport. Thestrals, in Hannibal’s estimation, are lovely creatures. Black skin ripples over its skeletal equine form like shrink wrap, leathery wings folded tightly against its body. The not-quite-horse begins lapping up the fresh blood, uncaring of the man’s groans. Hannibal closes his eyes with a pleasurable shiver, lost in the moment. He is not a man easily surprised—usually he can smell people coming a mile off— but the immediate tang of blood overwhelms his keen nose.
A branch snaps behind him.
Most people’s hearts would leap into their throat at the sound, but not Hannibal. He collects himself and turns around. Standing on the opposite side of the clearing is a striking young man. His curly hair is attractively dishevelled, strong jaw set in a grimace, with purpose in his eyes. He’s dressed in muggle attire appropriate for the forest: shabby jeans, beaten sneakers, and an oversized jacket, complemented by the broken glasses perched on the bridge of his nose. It looks like they’ve been clumsily repaired with spellotape. At his side is a hunting dog shining silver in the gloom, as if formed from liquid mercury and starlight... a patronus.
The hairs on Hannibal’s arms stand up—not because of the incredible magical potential he senses in this man—but because of how familiar he is. He feels as though he has stepped back in time; like he’s seen this man’s portrait hanging in the Italian gallerias of his youth. Hannibal is about to open his mouth and begin the interrogation, but the ‘stranger’ pre-empts him:
“Who are you?”
Hannibal raises an eyebrow at the strange emphasis in the question which implies they’ve crossed paths before. There is also something peculiar about the man’s expression—guarded, but not fearful, or even shocked by the macabre scene. His focus is wholly on Hannibal, not the disembowelled man strung up in the tree. With that in mind, Hannibal decides not to hex him just yet.
“That’s a rather interesting choice of opening. Have we met?” Hannibal enquires politely. The curly-haired man pauses. His patronus whines in sympathy.
“… I don’t know.” Another interesting response.
“May I have your name?”
“I asked first,” the interloper points out. How prickly. Hannibal eyes the patronus in amusement. A mongoose would have suited him better than a common dog. He grants the stranger a smile, gesturing to his bloody palms.
“My apologies. I am Hannibal Lecter— please excuse me if I don’t shake your hand. And you are?”
“Will. Graham.”
The vague squirming in Hannibal’s gut warning that he knows this man grows teeth, latching on and gnawing. He decides it’s time to address the elephant in the room.
“I can’t help but notice that you haven’t asked yet, Will.” Hannibal gestures to his whimpering captive. “In fact, you don’t seem the least bit surprised. Did you perhaps expect to find me here under these circumstances?”
“Yes,” Will confirms, voice tight. Hannibal tilts his head.
“But you’re not an Auror, clearly, or else you would have already tried to apprehend me. You didn’t track me here with righteous intentions.”
“No.” Will seems to be struggling to explain. A flash of discomfort passes over his face. “I… saw you here.” Hannibal’s interest is piqued further.
“Ah, so you’re a Seer. A rare and uncomfortable gift.”
“Yeah well, don’t get too excited. My ‘gift’ is kind of niche,” Will bites out. He gives no further detail. Hannibal raises an eyebrow.
“A pity. And here I was hoping you would spare ten minutes to read my tea leaves.” He points his wand at a nearby tree stump. The trunk is sheared off and sanded down in seconds, transfigured into a wooden table and two chairs. It’s an elaborate setup, with engraved edges and carved feet. With another quick spell he conjures a porcelain tea set, the print on the teacups curiously childlike in their design, along with a plate of fresh pastries. Hannibal subtly turns over his thermos flask, sensing its inner dimensions realign accordingly, and unscrews the cap. Out pours a stream of hot tea in lieu of organs, filling both their cups. His eyes twinkle with mischief at Will’s ignorance, indicating for him to take a seat and indulge. The latter remains where he is. Hannibal raises an eyebrow at his rudeness, courtesy turning crisp: “Is there a problem?”
“I don’t drink tea with dark wizards.” Will’s objection lacks conviction. Hannibal smiles thinly. With a flourish of his wand, both his plastic overcoat and the crusting blood on his hands evaporate, transforming Hannibal into the picture-perfect gentleman. He settles in the chair and plates himself a croissant.
“‘Dark’ is a matter of perspective. As is ‘wizard’.”
“Then what are you?” Will’s gaze falls to the man’s wand resting on the table. Hannibal surveys Will over the tips of his fingers.
“What do you think I am?”
Will looks him up and down, considering. Electricity sparks in Hannibal’s gut as Will’s gaze wanders across the angles of his face and down the sheer plains of his body.
“You might have Fae blood. They specialise in luring the unwary. Fairies flaunt their beauty to extract favour from wizards; Erklings entice children to their deaths through music.” Will eyes the tea and pastries in mistrust. “An untreated Doxy bite can kill a witch or wizard in a couple of hours.” Hannibal’s lips twitch, quietly impressed by his knowledge of magical creatures.
“I have no intention of poisoning you Will; I wouldn’t do that to the food.”
“You don’t deny the entrapment, then.”
“Is this entrapment, or innocent curiosity?” Hannibal’s smile widens. The steaming teacup and empty plate slide an inch in Will’s direction, cajoling him to sit. Will pulls a face, reluctant, but he cannot resist temptation. He slides into the seat opposite Hannibal, fidgeting every couple of seconds. The other nods in approval and takes a refined sip from his teacup, painted with classic teddy bears. Will watches and waits for him to swallow; only then does he follow suit, taking a tentative bite into a flaking pain au chocolat. His eyes widen in pleasure.
“It’s delicious, thank you.”
“Thank you for entertaining me,” Hannibal purrs, buoyed by Will’s reaction. “To answer your question, I do indeed come from a wizarding lineage, but I choose to live apart from the wizarding world.”
“What—in the Forbidden Forest?” Will’s disbelief is scathing, blue eyes raking Hannibal from head to toe. The older man is dressed impeccably, with his tailored suit and Oxford brogues, not a single hair on his head out of place. He certainly doesn’t look like the type to enjoy living rough. His mannerisms and grooming resemble a pampered house cat, not an alley cat.
“Goodness, no.” Hannibal sniffs at the thought. “But I did attend school here, for a time. I am quite fond of these woods; it was my preferred haunt when I needed privacy.”
Nostalgia clouds Hannibal’s eyes. It was in here in the Forbidden Forest that he became a man—in every sense. He is caught up in the memory of old teenage follies: a handsome Slytherin boy (whose name Hannibal no longer remembers) pressed up against a tree beneath his bloody hands, the slain unicorn at their feet ignored in the pursuit of young lust. They rutted before its sightless eyes; a macabre voyeur. Unfortunately, Hannibal’s trip down memory lane is short lived. He is interrupted by a strangled gurgling coming from the man in the tree. Hannibal silences him with an irritated stab of his wand. He’s not concerned about being caught. Hogwarts castle and the surrounding grounds are cloaked in centuries-old defensive spells, making it a low priority for Aurors. The Forbidden Forest is called as such for a reason; short of an attack on the castle itself, the Ministry will turn a blind eye. No help is coming for their involuntary guest.
“I was here too. For a time,” Will volunteers. He frowns straight after, as if wishing he hadn’t said anything. Hannibal picks up on his reticence.
“May I ask what happened to cut your stay short?” he probes. Will chuckles mirthlessly into his teacup of pastel ducklings.
“Actually, I was expelled.”
His words hang heavy in the air. Hannibal stares him down as Will fiddles with his cutlery to keep his jittery fingers busy.
Curious, Hannibal muses. It seems they have more than a few things in common.
“As a matter of fact, so was I.” Unlike Will's guilt-ridden confession, Hannibal makes it sound like a proclamation. Will’s eyes snap up in surprise, but his counterpart isn’t looking at him. Hannibal is focussed on Will’s wand on the table. Will is half-covering it with his right hand, taking care not to point it in Hannibal’s direction. “And yet, like me, you dare to still carry a wand—a flagrant breach of wizarding law. It seems I am not the only one with a penchant for bending the rules.”
Now that he’s close up, Hannibal can see the wand’s body is stubby and twisted. It almost looks homemade. He presumes that Will must have crafted it himself after the Ministry obliterated his original— the standard punishment for any expelled wizarding student. Hannibal eyes the man’s creation with intrigue. A wand is a wizard’s defining asset, and Wandlore a complex and mysterious magical art; foregoing the expertise of a wandmaker is a risky business. A wand like Will’s is bound to have side effects… unpredictable magic.
Hannibal considers his own by comparison: a sleek thing made of yew, 12 ¼ inch. Yew as a base material is power-hungry and demanding. It resonates with those who have lofty designs of death and immortality… although its former master decidedly failed to live up to said values. Hannibal’s lips curl in cruel satisfaction, feeling the responding hum of the stolen wand beneath his fingers coming from the heartstring core. It answers to him now. As for the exact type of heartstring, Hannibal masterfully avoids that question whenever people ask.
“Is that what we’re calling this?” Will prompts with a jab of his thumb, finally acknowledging the dying man in the tree. “Bending the rules?”
It’s an absurd scene: the two of them pretending to be gentleman, enjoying tea and scones in the presence of their gutless guest. A mad tea party if there ever was one.
“I would term it an act of cosmic justice,” Hannibal bats back with ease. He chooses to deflect before Will can press the issue further, cocking his head flirtatiously. “I notice your accent is American. Indulge me, if you will: how did you find yourself enrolled at Hogwarts?”
Will bites his lip to hide his smile, but Hannibal catches it; just as he catches the glances Will keeps sending him from underneath his lashes. It seems the attraction between them is mutual. The observation sends hope soaring in Hannibal’s chest—hope which logically has no right to be there.
“I’m muggle born; couldn’t find a place to study in the States. Fees were too high,” Will explains, scratching his cheek in shyness.
“The challenges of the American education system, whether muggle or wizard.”
“What about you? That’s not a British accent either.”
The temporary bubble of levity bursts. Hannibal smooths down his suit trousers, answering with practiced coolness:
“I was born in Lithuania. The Lecter family name holds great sway in wizarding circles there; we are descended from the eldest pureblood line in eastern Europe. Unfortunately, due to… unforeseen family circumstances, I was forced to relocate. My uncle thought that a fresh start in new country would be good for me. Hogwarts came well recommended.” Hannibal notices how Will has suddenly become tense at the topic of blood purity. Hannibal frowns at him, sympathetic. “You don’t need to worry about the old prejudices from me, Will. My uncle held such beliefs, but I never shared them. Magic, or the lack thereof, does not separate people from pigs.”
Will looks across to Hannibal’s victim. Understanding shines within his eyes, followed quickly by disgust. Hannibal observes his changing expressions with intrigue. Can Will appreciate his motives? Can he tell that he took away this man’s organs because he doesn’t deserve to keep them? Hannibal wets his lips in response to a sudden pang of hunger. Will sets down his teacup, still half-full.
“What did this particular pig do to offend you?” he asks.
“What makes you think he did something? If I am a dark wizard as you claim, perhaps this is simply for my amusement.” Hannibal’s attempt at minimisation draws a sinister laugh from Will.
“Oh, I know you take pleasure in it—that much is obvious from the amount of effort you’ve put in. But there’s a theatrical artistry to your work that speaks to a level of personal investment beyond simple sadism.” Hannibal remains silent. Will leans forward an inch across the table. His blue eyes are suddenly wide and sympathetic. “You also mentioned cosmic justice before,” he says softly. “Hannibal, tell me, what did he do?”
On hearing his name spoken out loud, a foggy sensation descends. Alarm bells ring in the vague recesses of Hannibal’s mind, but he can’t bring himself to care; nor can he prevent the confession forcing its way up his throat, sweet and passable like honey.
“He’s part of a criminal ring of dark wizards facilitating the torture and harvesting of pureblood children,” Hannibal answers, almost dreamlike. “Some parts of the world still believe the myth that purebloods carry magical strength that exceeds half-bloods and muggle-borns. Our blood, organs, and bones, are fashioned into amulets which are said to bestow protection upon the bearer. It is believed that the younger a child is harvested, the stronger the magical potential extracted.”
“W-what?” Will’s horrified expression makes something in the air snap, and the miasma clouding Hannibal’s mind clears as quickly as it came. He is left with the chilling realisation of what just transpired. Hannibal looks down at Will’s hands, seeing that his wand is no longer sitting horizontal, but pointed directly at him.
In that moment, Hannibal Lecter feels something he hasn’t experienced since he was a child: fear.
“I lacked conscious control over my words just now.” He casually adjusts his arm so that their wand tips are pointed at each other across the table. Hannibal’s tone has reverted to one of cool detachment. “That was the Imperius Curse, wasn’t it?”
To Hannibal’s surprise, Will startles. His eyes widen, fumbling the teacup.
“Fuck,” he hisses, jumping up from the chair as hot tea splashes into his lap. “Really? Shit, sorry I didn’t—I didn’t mean to.”
The reaction is so bizarre, so erratic, that Hannibal concedes it can’t be an act. Will did not intend to curse him. Hannibal fixes his companion with a penetrating stare.
“Am I to believe that you can unconsciously cast Unforgiveable Curses?”
Will nods, miserable. He reaches for the table in search of balance, unable to meet Hannibal’s eyes.
“It started when I was just a kid. I realised I could make people do what I wanted. People would tell me secrets— things I didn’t even want to know. I’d just be thinking of a question, and they would volunteer an answer.”
Hannibal absorbs this, considering the twisted advantages and crippling horrors of such a gift. He imagines Will as a tender lad in elementary school, burdened by the knowledge of a classmate’s unsavoury home life, his neighbours’ salacious extra-marital affairs, his parents’ darkest secrets.
In the present, Will still cannot look at him. His face is turned away in shame, fearing judgement. Hannibal has the peculiar urge to reach for his hand; to perform some tender gesture and proclaim with all the fierceness in his heart that Will has nothing to be ashamed of… but why? Reason says that Hannibal doesn’t know Will Graham from Adam. Yet, there is a soft, fractured part of him that whispers he is wrong—that he knows this man so well. The faint growl of hunger in Hannibal’s soul bares its teeth. Seer, maker of wands, scholar of magical creatures, and now caster of Unforgiveable Curses; Will Graham’s vast potential is clear. He is beautiful—and Hannibal wants him.
In the name of common courtesy, Hannibal does not reach for Will’s hand uninvited. Instead, he rises from the chair and makes his guest an offer:
“Would you care to assist me?”
Will is startled by the invitation.
“What?”
“He’s not finished yet. I intend to make an example of him,” Hannibal explains, turning back to survey his work. A malicious smile has once more found its place on his lips. The man in the tree is still moaning softly, but weaker now. Hannibal is concerned by this. It’s too soon for him to die. He points his wand directly at the man’s gaping chest, reinforcing the curse that keeps him twitching in a diabolical imitation of breathing, absent of lungs. Will is watching with morbid intrigue, but propriety keeps his lips sealed. Hannibal decides to indulge him, whether or not he wants to be indulged: “With practice, I have crafted a unique curse which puts the body in a state of suspended animation and allows for the live removal of organs whilst the subject remains conscious… and feeling.”
Will’s jaw works, either nauseated or savouring the prospect.
“Human trafficking, you said… exactly how many kids are we talking about?”
Hannibal turns to look at him, trying to decipher his intent. Will’s face is half-covered in shadow, tone equally ambiguous.
“My sources tell me a few thousand,” Hannibal answers, eliciting a violent twitch.
“… And you were one of them.”
Hannibal grants Will a curt nod, but he refrains from elaborating. Revenge in the name of self-interest is a perfectly believable motive. He grips his stolen wand tighter, the heartstring core calling to him. A memory stirs of a little girl with sharp cheekbones, chestnut hair, and big brown eyes that carry a rust red tint, much like his own. When it comes to himself, Hannibal has always had a high pain threshold; pain inflicted on his loved ones is an entirely different matter. But Will does not need to know the precise shape and depth of his wounds.
Hannibal is startled when the disembowelled wizard suddenly regains new life. He begins to writhe in his bonds, emaciated body contorting. Oh, and the screams. The peals ring out, high pitched and soul shattering, a performance worthy of God’s ears. Hannibal thankfully already cast a silencing charm around the clearing to avoid drawing necessary attention. The last thing they need is a herd of territorial centaurs paying them a visit. Hannibal observes the man’s suffering with contentment, recognising the torture curse at work. Beautiful. He gives Will a knowing look. Sure enough, his companion is standing with feet planted and wand raised, wearing a face that is not quite his own. It takes a few moments for reality to set in. Will’s icy eyes turn to liquid fear, catching his wand-arm and lowering it by force. He almost trips on a stray tree root in his haste to back away. The tortured man sags in his bindings and finally stops screaming.
“You knew that would happen,” Will grits out. Hannibal notices his wand-arm trembling. He wonders if it’s a nervous response, or if Will is still tempted by a deep-seated impulse to pass judgement upon a deserved sinner. “Why do you always—“ Will breaks off mid-sentence, confusion passing over his face. Hannibal responds with an equally quizzical frown.
Always, what? They’ve only just met. There shouldn’t be any ‘always’ between them.
“I only sought to test my hypothesis. It seems I was correct: you can instinctively cast both the Imperius and Cruciatus curse.” Pride and hunger gleam in Hannibal’s eyes. He twirls his wand in his fingers in contemplation. “I have also tried my hand at the Unforgiveable Curses, but I could not direct them properly. Persuasion is an artform, and I enjoy the challenge; the use of Imperio removes that challenge. As for the other two, I find them far too cold for my liking. Wands are rather like those steel projectile launchers used by muggles… ‘guns’, I believe they’re called. A frightfully impersonal method. Ending a life deserves intimacy... and for that, only the use of one’s hands will do.” Will shudders where he stands, but Hannibal cannot resist poking him further: “Have you ever performed the killing curse—unconsciously, or otherwise?”
“No, thank God,” Will whispers, but his words come out weak once again. Performative. Hannibal takes a step closer. Will’s eyes snap to him, but he does not recoil. Being in proximity like this does not concern either of them like it should. Hannibal feels compelled by a higher power to reach out, cupping Will’s cheek with his jaw. Will, surprisingly, does not resist. His eyes flutter in the dark.
“Or perhaps you prefer using your hands too,” Hannibal croons. Will shivers under his touch but does not deny the allegation. The other licks his lips, suddenly ravenous. “As much as I’m enjoying this wonderfully strange conversation Will, I must say I’m confused. You should be a stranger to me. Yet…”
“It feels as though we’ve spoken before. Like you’ve seen my face before,” Will finishes. He sounds like a man who hasn’t slept for forty days and forty nights. Hannibal stares at him. The air between them feels thick, like the oppressive heaviness of a thunderstorm before lightning strikes.
“These visions of yours, Will, I’d like to hear more about them.”
Will runs his tongue slowly across his lips, grip tightening on his wand for security.
“We don’t have all night. I need to be back home by sunrise.” He sounds gruffer than Hannibal suspects he truly means. Will dares a side-glance at the man in the tree. “We need to do something about him.”
Hannibal is secretly pleased by Will’s choice of pronoun. ‘We’ suggests they are a unit; that this forbidden act in which they are accomplices has bound them in unholy matrimony. Why does that make him feel so happy?
“I’m open to suggestions,” he offers. Will closes his eyes, reciting from memory:
“The tree you’ve chosen is magnolia which symbolises purity, and you’ve tied him up with the Devil’s Snare, implying trickery and damnation. Appropriate. He coveted purity in the children he killed; now he’s bound to suffer for his cause. You took away his organs so that he could experience the destiny that he created for so many.” Will pauses, opening his eyes. He turns to Hannibal in question. “Were you planning to fill the chest cavity with anything?”
“As I said, I am open to suggestions,” Hannibal practically purrs. Will nods, apparently coming to a decision.
“Wait here, then.”
Will quickly reconjures his patronus before heading off. Considering the notorious difficulty of the Patronus Charm, Hannibal is impressed by how easy he makes it look. Perhaps Will was a budding Auror before he was expelled. Hannibal observes the liquid-silver canine gliding over the forest floor, and how Will rests one hand on its ghostly body as if it were the real thing, certain he conjured it out of a desire for company, rather than protection.
Lonely, Hannibal concludes, silencing the traitorous voice of self-pity that whispers: ‘like me’.
Still, Will must at least have one happy memory lurking inside him; he wouldn’t be able to cast the charm otherwise… Hannibal has never mastered it. Irrational jealousy coils in his guts like a serpent. The idea that Will might have such precious experiences locked away in the bone arena of his skull disturbs him. Instinct howls that he should own the skeleton key to every locked room and hidden corridor of Will Graham’s psyche. It’s his right. Hannibal considers his potion stores back in his office. There are more ways than one to break into a locked room. He should still have a little Veritaserum left…
Will is gone for a long time, to the point that Hannibal starts to wonder if he’s been stood up. Thankfully, he’s wrong. Will returns almost a full hour later, his pockets now bulging with a variety of plants. Will kneels at his feet and begins laying out his findings for Hannibal’s inspection: wolfsbane, oleander, belladonna; ragwort, and asphodel. The blooms are bright in colour and enticing, which Hannibal knows belies their true nature. Will glowers at the wizard hanging in his bonds.
“Men like him are a poison,” he mutters, stroking the nearest flower petals; bright crimson, like fresh blood. “They take root in the dark, away from prying eyes, infecting all that’s bright and good in the world. I thought toxic plants might be appropriate. Give people something beautiful to look at—which is more than he ever gave anyone.” When Hannibal remains silent, Will looks up at him in quiet anxiety, like a schoolboy awaiting the results of an exam. “I’m a herbologist,” he explains hurriedly. “It’s one of the few magical professions that the Ministry doesn’t strictly regulate. I source all my own stock. Business isn't spectacular, but I do alright.”
Hannibal’s chest swells with admiration. This also explains his knowledge of magical creatures and defensive spells like the Patronus Charm. Will is accustomed to delving into dark places in search of treasure. Sometimes that requires fending off the shadows that try to follow him home.
“I see—that is why you cannot stay longer. Business calls,” Hannibal sighs. He doesn’t bother trying to hide his disappointment.
“We all have to make a living.” Will scratches the back of his neck, gesturing to the flowers to change the subject. “I take it you approve, then?”
“Oh yes, Will,” Hannibal assures softly, his expression nothing short of reverent. “They’re perfect.”
”… Good. I’m glad.”
Will ducks his head, focussing on gathering the blooms to hide his flushed cheeks. He doesn’t spare a glance at the dying man either, arranging the flowers inside the chest cavity with surprising efficiency, his hands steady as a rock. It’s almost like he’s done this before. Once the job is complete, Will steps away with a shaky breath and comes back to himself again. He runs a hand through his hair without thinking, smearing a line of blood across his forehead. It looks like somebody tried to take a bone saw to his brain. Hannibal feels something catch in his throat.
“If I confessed the urge to kiss you right now, Will, how would that make you feel?” he asks, husky. Will’s shoulders stiffen at the proposal, but he does not shy away.
“Maybe a little overwhelmed, but… not surprised.” His eyes flick to Hannibal’s face and then away. Once again, it’s a curious answer—one that could easily draw accusations of vanity. Shame on Will for presuming Hannibal would desire him in that way.
It doesn’t feel like vanity, though.
In Hannibal’s profession he needs to be good at reading people, and the only emotion Will is giving off right now is hesitance. Encouraged, he takes a step closer.
“Would you be inclined to indulge me?” Hannibal presses. Will fixes him now with a steady gaze. Behind his eyes, Hannibal finds cautious interest, coupled with tired resignation.
“I would,” he confirms.
Once more, Hannibal reaches for him. Will does not lean in to meet him halfway, but his eyes close in acceptance, allowing Hannibal to press a chaste, lingering kiss to his mouth. When they part, Will runs his tongue across his lips. His eyes are clouded in thought, mouth downturned in the aftermath. There is none of the typical giddiness that follows a first kiss. He has the look of a man who has been paid a long-overdue debt, any meagre satisfaction overshadowed by the trial of pursuance.
“How are you getting home tonight?” Hannibal asks at last, needing to say something to break the awkward silence. Will’s eyes regain some of their focus. His mouth quirks, eying Hannibal’s thestral standing on the edge of the clearing.
“Same way as you, apparently.”
Will motions to the treeline with his wand. On cue, a second thestral emerges from the trees, shaking out its wings in preparation for flight. Herd animals by nature, the two greet each other in recognition, nuzzling at each other’s necks. Hannibal and Will give them a minute, watching the affectionate display.
“Thestrals are badly misunderstood creatures,” Will says. “Everyone is quick to write them off as bad omens because of their connotations with death. If they only took the time to observe them in their natural environment like this, they’d understand.”
“Thestrals can only be observed by those who are deserving,” Hannibal points out. “It may be a lonely existence, but perhaps a more rewarding one; to be seen only by those you truly connect with.” Will hums in thought. Hannibal steals a look at him, taking note of his expression. Will’s eyes are perfectly focussed on the tender pair, a faint smile on his lips. Hannibal prods him as gently as possible: “You can see them, can’t you Will?”
“I’ve always been able to,” he replies in a strained voice. Again, Hannibal sees an opportunity for common ground—he also cannot recall a time in his life when he couldn’t see these magnificent beasts.
“You lost somebody when you were young?” he queries. Will hunches his shoulders, hands shoved in his pockets. His voice turns painfully quiet.
“No… I wasn’t young.”
Hannibal’s gentleness dissipates, jaw twitching in irritation. It is maddening how many of Will’s words do not make sense; how many layers there are still to be uncovered. He looks over forlornly to the carved table and chairs, their half-drunk tea now stone cold, pastries fast growing stale. Hannibal sighs and waves his wand, their place settings reverting to the plain old tree stump.
“I would’ve very much liked to talk further with you, Will… unfortunately, it seems we’ve all run out of time.”
In his distraction, Hannibal forgot to maintain the suspension curse. His quarry in the tree is now deceased, limbs turning stiff in the crisp forest air. With a decisive wave of Hannibal’s wand, the dead wizard vanishes, tree roots and all. Will startles.
“What did you do with him?”
“I’ve sent him to a car park in the picturesque seaside town of Hythe,” Hannibal replies airily, delighting in the disapproving look on Will’s face. “Art is made to be seen, is it not? I only wish I could see the looks on the muggles’ faces come morning.”
“You risk being caught,” Will frowns. Hannibal smiles deviously.
“What’s life without a little risk?” With a flourish of his wrist that is more suited to a common magician than a wizard, Hannibal conjures a business card between his fingers and hands it to Will. “If you ever feel like continuing our conversation, this is where you can find me. I will happily clear my diary for you, Will.”
“So, you’re a psychiatrist.” Will turns over the card in his hand with a dry smile. “That explains the fancy office. I’ve never seen one with a private library before, let alone a whole second floor. You'll have to show me your book collection sometime.”
It takes a moment for Hannibal to catch up. Will Graham has never been inside his office in his life—he should be in no position to make snide comments about the décor.
“Another vision,” he concludes, to which Will nods. Hannibal’s eyes dart across him, pulling the common threads together. “Earlier, you described your gift as ‘niche’… Does your Inner Eye often focus on me specifically, Will?”
The man in question takes a shuddering breath.
“Too often.”
A loud chuffing from one of the thestrals breaks the tension. A relieved Will clears his throat, busying himself with pre-flight preparations to escape Hannibal’s scrutiny. With a swish and flick, his patronus vanishes. Will approaches his steed, running a hand over the horse’s shiny leather skin and jutting bones in greeting before attempting to mount. He struggles on the way up; threstrals are a couple of hands taller than mundane horses, and whilst Will is not short, he’s certainly not the towering spectre of Hannibal Lecter. Thankfully, Hannibal doesn’t hesitate to give him a leg-up, even if it means kneeling in the dirt.
“… Thanks.” Will eventually finds his seat, placing his legs just behind the wing joint. He looks down at Hannibal, caught between discomfort and fondness. His murmured farewell is almost swallowed: “Goodbye… Hannibal.”
Before Hannibal can say another word, Will nudges the threstral’s sides with his heels, cantering down the centre of the clearing. Leathery winds thump and gather speed, kicking up twigs and dirt. Bloody hoofs clear the forest floor in a rush of wind.
The last Hannibal sees of Will Graham is his silhouette against the backdrop of the full moon before he soars off into the night.
Notes:
Hi everyone! This brainworm bit me at 2am the other night and before I knew it I had an entire plot mapped. I'm a little rusty on HP lore, but hopefully I did OK here! Please let me know if you spot any glaring errors haha. The title 'Reparo' comes from a spell in HP- 'occulus reparo' which mends Harry's broken glasses, and 'reparo' specifically means to repair or revive. The meaning should tie in nicely by the end.
Chapter Text
Hannibal sits at his office desk, staring vacantly at a painting of a majestic stag framed on the far wall. His quill tip lingers over the lined pages of a notebook, a blot of ink landing on his patient’s observations. He blinks, pulled out of his reverie, and casts a quick tergeo to fix it. With a displeased sigh he closes the file, eyes flicking to the bouquet of flowers and jewellery box next to him; a constant reminder of the task he’s been putting off all morning. The clock on the wall tells Hannibal that he still has a couple of hours before he really must go… if only a worthy distraction would materialise. He side-eyes the adjacent sketchbook, still open where he left it; imperfect figures and rough landscapes abandoned halfway, his distracted fingers refusing to cooperate. Absorbing himself in work or the creative is proving impossible today.
Luckily for him, the intercom rings.
Hannibal is caught off guard by the obnoxious buzzing that cuts through the equally deafening silence. He’d instructed his muggle secretary Nancy to take the day off and leave his diary clear today. He’s not expecting any appointments. Hannibal lets it ring off in case it’s simply a sales enquiry—but when the buzzer on his desk sounds for the second time, he realises this is not somebody who can be ignored. He presses the answer button, considerably brusquer than how he would usually greet a patient:
“I’m afraid we’re closed.”
“It’s me.”
Hannibal stills, recognising the quiet intensity of Will Graham’s voice. Just like in their first meeting, the herbologist has an inconvenient knack for surprising him. After a moment’s deliberation, Hannibal presses another button and unlocks the main door downstairs. His office is a well-to-do establishment located in Richmond, one of London’s affluent inner districts. He shares this historic building with four other muggle businesses, his own located at the very top for security reasons. The entire block is cloaked in defensive spells, including anti-apparition charms; should some bureaucratic busybody from the Ministry of Magic start poking around, Hannibal doesn’t want to make it too easy for them. Will Graham has a total of four steep flights of stairs to climb to reach him. Now the race is on.
Hannibal stands and draws his wand, pointing to his impressive oak-carved desk. A clicking noise follows as the inner locks undo, and the solid wood separates in two, the bottom half sliding out to reveal his secret potion stash. The drawer holds dozens of multi-coloured vials, all labelled meticulously and arranged in alphabetical order: Amorentia, Draught of the Living Death, Liquid Luck. Hannibal quickly routes through to the letter ‘V’ and retrieves the tiny bottle of Veritaserum hiding at the back. It’s still full. Hannibal would normally eschew such crass methods of extracting information, but he senses that Will Graham is going to be a tougher nut to crack than his muggle patients. With another wave of his wand, the desk reverts to normal. Hannibal has just enough time to conjure two empty wine glasses, dispensing a few drops of the truth potion into one, when Will knocks on the door.
“I’ll be with you in a moment,” Hannibal calls, checking himself in the full-length mirror on the wall to make sure he looks presentable.
“Sure, take your time,” Will answers, sounding apologetic.
When Hannibal is satisfied with both his general appearance and the state of his office, he finally opens the door. He finds Will waiting with his back turned, wearing a flattering pink salmon shirt, ironed chinos, and dress shoes. He’s even combed his hair. Will is not looking Hannibal’s way, busy admiring the painting on the wall outside. It’s a replica of the classic Greco-Roman sculpture Boy With Thorn that Hannibal painted many years ago, attracted by the beauty and complexity of the human body captured in an ordinary moment… but it’s not the artwork that draws his eye now. Will turns around at the sound of the door opening, and Hannibal is not quite quick enough to look up. Will’s raised eyebrow says it all:
Were you checking me out?
Rather than feign embarrassment, Hannibal dips his head and smiles.
“Will, what a pleasant surprise. Please, come in.” He steps aside, allowing the younger man over the threshold. Will peers owlishly at the lavish surroundings, whilst Hannibal applies to him the same scrutiny. He homes in on Will’s sallow skin and the dark circles under his eyes. They weren’t obvious in their last meeting, hidden behind his glasses and softened by the shadows of the Forbidden Forest, but now his exhaustion is plain to see. Hannibal muses what tasteless thoughts are keeping him awake at night.
“I haven’t come at a bad time, have I?” Will interjects, hovering just inside the doorway. “You said you were closed.” The answer to Will’s question is actually ‘yes’—but Hannibal is not going to squander this opportunity.
“I was merely taking a personal day to run some errands. I promise, you’re quite welcome.”
Will nods, concerned frown clearing.
“Good… that’s good.”
Hannibal gives Will a wide berth to allow him to acclimatise, observing with beady dark eyes. Will paces the length of the polished wooden floor, jacket slung casually over his arm, other hand stashed in his pocket. He cranes his neck, blue eyes sweeping across the stylish archways and alcoves.
“This place is really something,” he says after a minute, pausing by the imposing stone fireplace behind Hannibal’s desk. It looks fit for summoning the demons of the underworld.
“A true likeness to your visions?” Hannibal prompts.
“With eerie clarity,” Will confirms, running his finger almost lovingly over a miniature stag statue on the mantlepiece. He soon spots the certificates framed on the adjacent wall, bearing the seal of numerous prestigious medical associations. Will gives Hannibal a half-smile. “I read up on you after our last meeting. I understand you’re very accomplished in psychiatric circles. Word on the street is that you have a gift for handling ‘problem patients’. You’re the man people turn to when the world has written them off as ‘unfixable’.”
To that, Hannibal inclines his head in demure agreement.
“I have a respectable success rate with my patients, yes, although one does not like to boast.”
“And you achieve this all through conventional therapy?” Will presses, eying the shiny awards with scepticism. In this professional setting, with his suit and tie and slick-backed hair, Hannibal might appear to be a man of science—but it couldn’t be further from the truth. Muggle minds are frightfully easy to unravel and reshape. A quick Obliviate, some choice potions…
“Every patient is unique,” Hannibal answers. Will opens his mouth, no doubt to ask more questions, when he stalls. Hannibal follows his gaze, landing on the ribbon-wrapped bouquet and present box on his desk. His stomach drops, realising how this looks.
“Oh, I see… it’s that kind of ‘personal day’, huh?” The smile that Will flashes him is pained.
“Not in that sense,” Hannibal is quick to assure, but the doubt in Will’s eyes remains. Hannibal crosses over to the desk, fiddling with the scalpel and set of razor-sharp pencils laid out next to his half-baked sketches of Palermo and the Duomo. He sighs in irritation, realising he’s going to have to explain himself. Humble pie is not a dish he cares for. “… I know I said that I would clear my diary for you, Will, and I fully intended to keep that promise,” he begins slowly. “But unfortunately, you’ve picked a rather awkward day for it. I’m scheduled to visit my sister today. These gifts are for her.”
“You have a sister?” Will asks with intrigue, taking a careful step forward. He’s clearly not completely sold on Hannibal’s story, thinking it could be a clever lie to hide his sexual escapades.
“Had a sister,” Hannibal corrects after only the smallest delay. Will’s face falls, now close enough to glimpse the delicate blooms inside the wrapping paper: a collection of white lilies and pink carnations. Mourning flowers. Hannibal reaches for the jewellery box to keep his hands busy. The lid springs open, revealing a jade necklace displayed on a cushion of white silk. Hannibal’s nose twitches, stomach turning at the scent of his sister’s blood embedded in the metal. He envies Will, blissful in his ignorance. Hannibal forces a polite smile in front of his guest and finally drags his eyes up, confirming Will’s suspicions: “She would have been thirty-two today. I’ve been putting off my visit to the cemetery all morning.”
“Oh, God. I’m sorry—look, I can come back another day.” Will is already backing up towards the door, looking as though he wishes the ground would swallow him. Hannibal frowns at him, necklace case snapping shut. He holds up a hand in deterrence.
“You don’t need to leave, Will. I meant what I said when I invited you in. Your visit is a bright spot on an otherwise bleak day.” Hannibal glances again to the clock on the wall. It’s just past one o’clock in the afternoon. “I can easily spare another hour before they shut the gates... I imagine you must be hungry, seeing as it’s lunchtime.”
With a wave of Hannibal’s wand, a bottle of red wine and a platter of salami and artisan cheeses appear, floating next to Will’s elbow. Hannibal sees the relief wash over his face.
“Well… if you’re sure.”
“Quite sure.”
Hannibal retrieves the two ‘identical’ glasses he prepared earlier, keeping a close eye on the one in his left hand. The bottle pours of its own accord, red wine mixing with the tasteless, colourless potion sitting at the bottom of the glass. Will gratefully accepts the drink without thinking twice, nibbling on a salami slice.
“Interesting flavour,” he comments, distracted by the ladder sitting in the corner which leads to the library on the second floor. Hannibal smiles in amusement, noticing where Will is looking.
“I recall you commenting on my literary collection during our last meeting. By all means, quench your curiosity.”
Will doesn’t need telling twice. He ascends the ladder and begins perusing the bookshelves. Hannibal’s earlier spell continually tops up his wineglass and replenishes the food platter, as if accompanied by an invisible waiter. From a cursory glance, Hannibal’s collection is as expected for a professional in his field. Will finds several volumes on biology and anatomy, a copy of the DSM 5; advanced mathematics, quantum physics and relativity. Will runs a hand along the wooden shelf, frowning. All is not what it seems. He reaches into his jacket pocket and pulls out his stubby wand, muttering a quick charm:
“Revelio.”
With a worrying groan, the antique bookshelf begins to buckle and bend. Hannibal winces at the heavy-handed spell, making a mental note to check for damage later. A new section slides out from the stone wall, pushing the mundane books to the left. Magical tomes take their place, spines glimmering in golden and silver print. Some are standard-issue, with titles such such as: ‘Moste Potente Potions’, ‘One Thousand Magical Herbs and Fungi’ and ‘The Dark Forces: A Guide to Self-Protection’… but there are more than a few unsavoury volumes too, the likes of which could only have come from the dusty bookshops of Knockturn Alley. Blood magic, rare curses. Even time magic.
Will steps back, comparing the mundane and magical books with amusement.
“You have a peculiar mix of interests,” he notes, speaking to Hannibal down below. “A lot of wizards wouldn’t see any value in studying muggle medicine when you can brew a perfectly good Restorative Draught.”
“I see the disciplines as complementary. Muggle accomplishments can contextualise and advance our knowledge in the wizarding world and vice versa,” Hannibal counters, eyeing his sister’s bouquet with a sour face. “For example, the mathematical probability of you choosing to come here on this day out of an entire year is only 0.27%. That tells me your Inner Eye is rather unreliable.”
Or a little too reliable, depending on one's perspective. Hannibal didn't plan on broaching the painful topic of his sister's death with Will Graham so soon. By his reckoning, this intrusion demands reciprocity. Ignorant of his dark intentions, Will laughs and turns around, leaning over the wooden guard rail. He shoots Hannibal a sarcastic smile.
“How perceptive. You have no idea how many nights I wasted hanging around the Forbidden Forest, hoping you’d show up. I didn’t have much to go on from my visions: only the position of the celestial bodies. I must have mapped more than a hundred astronomy charts trying to work out when you’d be there.” Warmth flickers in Hannibal's chest, hearing that Will went to such lengths to find him. A wry smile curves his lips, mirth dancing in his eyes.
“Well, they do say that Divination is an art, not a science.”
“More like fraud and delusion wrapped up in a pretty package for the gullible.” Will wrinkles his nose in distaste. “The Sight isn’t something that can be taught. The ‘techniques’ they make you learn in school are useless. I barely scraped a pass in my O.W.L.s.”
“Ironically, I did rather well in it,” Hannibal purrs, perching on his desk like an overgrown cat. Will gives him a withering look, nodding to the artisan platter and expensive wine.
“That isn’t surprising. You have a talent for theatrics. Somehow, I can’t imagine you did so well in Care of Magical Creatures.”
“Or Herbology,” Hannibal’s smile widens to a grin, sharp teeth glinting. “I had a nasty encounter with a Venomous Tentacular in my O.W.L. exam. Terribly rude plant. After a brief stay in the hospital wing, I appropriated its roots for my potions stock. Suffice to say the examiners were rather bemused the next day.”
Hannibal’s story has the two wizards chuckling. He is surprised by just how easy Will is to talk to; sharing such foolish memories doesn’t feel debasing, like it would with anyone else. Mirth gives way to bemusement as their laughter fades; but Will’s eyes are still bright and curious, compelled to ask the inevitable:
“Which house were you in anyway?”
Hannibal purses his lips in displeasure. It’s a trite question that could have been lifted from a Ministry of Magic interview– a convenient method of categorisation to put people in boxes. Worthy versus unfit. Incompatible versus suitable. Good versus evil. Will seems to realise he’s mis-stepped, grin sliding off his face when he sees Hannibal’s expression.
“Ravenclaw.” Hannibal does not give Will the opportunity to analyse his answer, quickly flipping the question back on him: “And yourself?”
“… Gryffindor,” Will answers. Hannibal fixes him with a knowing look.
“And was that what the Sorting Hat whispered in your ear, cunning boy?” Will flinches at the challenge. Their gazes lock, both recounting the Sorting Hat’s ditty in their heads:
‘Or perhaps in Slytherin, you’ll make your real friends. Those cunning folk use any means to achieve their ends.’
“No,” Will admits with a sigh, holding onto the guard rail to steady himself. Hannibal wonders if he’s starting to suspect the Veritaserum yet.
“But Gryffindor was the 'morally correct' choice,” he infers. Will gives him a stiff nod. Hannibal smiles faintly at being proven correct. “For those seeking to become Aurors, it is also the best house to put on a resume.” The astute comment catches Will off guard. He squints in mistrust, a flush creeping up his neck.
“How do you know about that?”
“An educated guess, based on your behaviour,” Hannibal replies simply. Will’s grip on the wooden ledge tightens.
“Don’t psychoanalyze me,” he warns through gritted teeth. “You won’t like me when I’m psychoanalyzed.”
“I’m sorry Will; observing is what we do. I can’t shut mine off anymore than you can shut yours off.” Hannibal shrugs in apology, but he’s not off the hook. Sharp blue eyes scrutinise him from on-high.
“Alright then—why did you choose Ravenclaw?” Will’s demand garners a sly smile.
“Those sorted into Slytherin house have always drawn greater scrutiny from the Ministry than their peers, whereas Ravenclaws are perceived as bookish and law abiding. My academic traits were strong enough to make it a believable match.” Hannibal's smirk turns to a sneer, eyes glinting with devilry. “That, and I sincerely despise being labelled.” An awkward silence follows. Will searches his face, a question on the tip of his tongue that he is too polite to ask. Hannibal can already guess what it is. “You wish to learn the reason for my expulsion,” he presumes. At Will's shy nod, Hannibal flashes him an easy smile and gestures towards his desk. “I suspect a verbal explanation would be inadequate. Come down, Will. There’s something I would like to show you.”
Will does as instructed and climbs back down the ladder. With a swish and flick from Hannibal’s wand, the oak desk creaks and clunks, like its non-existent nuts and bolts are coming undone. It slides aside, peeling back the floor beneath in the process, revealing a set of stone steps leading down into darkness. Hannibal turns to Will with a sweeping gesture.
“After you," he invites. Will shoots him a withering look, grip tightening on his wand.
“Do you think I was born yesterday? After you.”
Hannibal considers Will’s demand. Going in front would be the equivalent of allowing a gun to be pointed at his back... but it would also gain Will's trust. They teeter together on the edge, the atmosphere fraught with tension, until Hannibal breaks the deadlock and steps in front. Thankfully, Will only mutters only an innocuous 'Lumos' to light the way. Hierarchy established, they venture slowly down the steps.
They emerge in a circular stone chamber. Muggle logic says that this room shouldn’t exist; Hannibal’s office sits directly above three other floors—there simply isn’t space for it. Magic is handy like that. The chamber is dominated by a large stone basin sitting on a raised platform, filled with a shimmering silver liquid. Will’s eyes grow wide in recognition.
“Is that a pensieve?”
“It is,” Hannibal hums.
Will approaches the magical object in wonder. Hannibal’s mercurial thoughts are swirling within the bowl, their texture somewhere between liquid and gas. Will grips the edge, leaning dangerously close to the surface. He looks like a man dying of thirst, about to plunge his head under and gulp down every last drop. Will straightens up with a shaky laugh, the threads of restraint barely holding together.
“You know, I could really do with one of these at home.”
“I thought you might,” Hannibal agrees, studying his counterpart. The pensieve’s pale light makes Will look even more sickly, highlighting his hollow cheeks and the bags under his eyes. “I imagine your visions must take quite a toll. It must be difficult to rest when your mind is too full of other people. Too many questions. Too many feelings.” Will twitches, throwing Hannibal a sharp glare. The other inclines his head towards the pensieve. “If you wish, you may unburden yourself. I am not averse to sharing, under the right circumstances.” Will swallows thickly, staring at the basin in naked want. The lure of a pensieve is in the promise of peace: a place to store painful memories and ease the burden on an overcrowded mind. Hannibal lays a coaxing hand on Will’s shoulder, crooning in his ear: “A dreamless sleep, Will. Wouldn’t you like that?”
“I would,” he admits, voice dangerously close to a groan… until reason digs its heels into his psyche. Will fixes him with a chilly stare. “But you know, I’m not giving you this for free, Hannibal.” The corner of Hannibal’s lips twitch. Will understands in the marrow of his bones that this is not a benevolent offer of refuge, but a naked bid for power; Hannibal wants to own his very thoughts, so that he may invade them at his leisure... Curious how this brilliant, bizarre man seems to know him so very well.
“I’m sure. As I said, I’m not averse to sharing,” he repeats, smooth as silk. “We both seem equally eager to breach the forts guarding the palaces of our minds. If I proposed a joint venture, would you be amenable?” There is a brief standoff. The two wizards stand opposite the stone basin, the flickering light casting sinister shadows across their faces. Will’s gaze lowers, as if drawn by a magnetic force to Hannibal’s thoughts, shining so brilliant and tempting. He licks his lips, tongue catching between his teeth.
“Within limits,” he concedes. Hannibal hides his smirk of victory and pulls out his wand.
“In that case, may I?” he requests. In answer, Will closes his eyes and leans forward in submission, permitting Hannibal to press the tip of his wand to his temple. "Reveal your thoughts to me, Will," Hannibal commands, low and lustful. Will braces himself against the basin rim, squinting in pain as Hannibal hooks a long, silver thread from the oceans of his mind, casting it into the glimmering abyss.
“There’s more,” Will rasps, cracking his eyes open. “Lots more.”
Hannibal repeats the process, drawing strand after strand of Will’s intrusive visions. By the time he’s done, the basin is almost overflowing, glowing twice as bright as before. Will is breathing heavily, looking ready keel over at any moment, were it not for the block of stone supporting his weight. Hannibal reaches out and squeezes his hand.
“Are you ready?” he asks softly. Will raises his head and manages a nod.
Facing each other, both men lean forward in unison, their faces reflected in molten silver. Their thoughts seem to reach for them, tendrils latching on and pulling them in.
Together, they fall.
Notes:
Office date! Hope you all enjoyed~ I've written most of the pensieve diving, but it was becoming an unmanageable length, so I decided to split it. In case you were wondering, Will is going to realise he's been spiked with Veritaserum next chapter.
Venomous Tentacular = the Matthew Brown of magical plants~ Also, something tells me Hannibal would be a superb bullshitter at Divination.
Kudos/comments are always welcomed, thank you for the positive response on chapter 1!
Chapter 3: Unforgiveable
Notes:
FYI, I’ve added the ‘graphic violence’ tag just in case… I don’t think it’s too violent considering the source material, but ymmv. Also this chapter contains physical violence against kids.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
As they sink into the pensieve, the two wizards are caught in a whirlwind of colour and sound, accompanied by the stomach-churning sensation of falling from a great height. They land hard on unforgiving stone. Will staggers sideways, Hannibal catching him before he falls.
The setting they find themselves in is achingly familiar: high ceilings, arched windows, and ancient castle walls decorated in livery of blues, reds, yellows, and greens—the four signature house colours. Hogwarts students are bustling about on their way to classes. Hannibal takes a moment to inhale, catching wind of the old scents of his youth: freshly cut grass from the Quidditch pitch, hot school lunches; parchment, candlewax, and leather-bound books. He watches with amusement as a gang of preteen Hufflepuff witches walk straight through Will, chattering away without a care in the world. Their giggles turn to shrieks as Peeves the Poltergeist whirls overhead, dousing the unlucky students beneath with water balloons. Despite being directly in the line of fire, Will escapes unscathed. Grim-faced, he flexes his fingers as if testing their solidity, disturbed to realise that he is less than a ghost. Hannibal remembers that this is his first time using a pensieve. He takes pity and taps Will on the shoulder, making him jump.
“Well, at least someone around here can still see me,” Will mutters, scratching the back of his neck. Hannibal is startled by his choice of words. An insistent itch niggles at the back of his mind; a broken whisper from a nightmare:
‘I let you know me. See me.’
“… Of course, I see you, Will.”
Hannibal ignores Will’s quizzical look, unable to explain the lump in his throat that has turned his voice to sandpaper, nodding in the opposite direction. Will follows his gaze. Heading towards them from the far end of the corridor is a sophisticated looking young man, no older than sixteen. He’s dressed in Ravenclaw garb, with sharp cheekbones and fair brown hair, a Prefect badge pinned to his lapel.
“That’s you?” Will guesses. His companion makes a sound of confirmation.
They watch as young-Hannibal makes a sharp diversion from the student body, darting down one of the lesser-used fickle staircases that is particularly fond of changing destination. Nobody notices him go; his wand is concealed up his sleeve, muttering Obliviate under his breath. Anyone who happens to glance his way will forget he was ever there. Current Hannibal smirks in self-congratulation; he's always been good with memory charms. His younger-self makes his way unchallenged to Professor McGonagall’s office, speaking the password to the door: ‘thistle thorn’. The practicality of Hannibal's choice of house is now obvious. Professor McGonagall would have undoubtedly thought twice about letting an ambitious Slytherin into her inner circle. A studious Ravenclaw on the other hand…
The two men follow the teenager inside. They witness him strolling around the Professor’s meticulously organised office as if he owns the place, running his fingers across McGonagall’s books stacked on her desk, feather quill and ink set. The stern Transfiguration teacher herself is nowhere to be seen. Present-day Hannibal smirks, remembering how he’d spent weeks meticulously mapping out her routine in readiness for this exact moment. In the corner lies his prize: a sealed glass cabinet containing a single gold time-turner. It was entrusted to McGonagall specifically by the Ministry because, aside from being a fearsomely skilled witch, she is a stickler for security; and—usually—an impeccable judge of character. Still, nobody is perfect.
Hannibal’s younger-self stops in front of the cabinet. He runs the tip of his wand down the wood, chanting advanced lockpicking spells that far exceed the Alohamora Charm.
“That’s a different wand,” Will observes. Hannibal makes a noise of agreement, mouth downturned in melancholy.
“I’ve had many over the years, but this was my original:13-inch willow, with a dragon heartstring core. It was destroyed by the Ministry the day I was expelled. As was yours, I’d wager.”
Will grimaces at the uncomfortable reminder. His eyes flick to the sleek monstrosity in Hannibal’s hand.
“Where did you get your current one?”
“I acquired it.” The vague answer makes Will frown, but he is distracted from asking further questions.
Young-Hannibal’s efforts have finally paid off. In a flash of white, the glass cabinet springs open. He withdraws the time-turner with an expression of reverence and hooks the delicate chain around his neck—but does not turn it immediately. He places his wand to the metal, green sparks exploding from the tip, temporarily blinding his ghostly onlookers.
“Did you just…” Will trails off, looking to his counterpart in uncertainty and awe.
“I removed the limitation charm.”
Will’s sharp intake of breath makes Hannibal’s soul sing with twisted satisfaction. All Ministry-issue time-turners are subject to a five-hour restriction; a sensible safety feature to prevent the traveller from unravelling events in the distant past and erasing the current reality—or themselves—by accident. Hannibal Lecter, however, has never appreciated being limited.
“I’ve dedicated my whole life to the study of temporal magic,” he reveals, voice turning quiet. “The events I wanted to change happened many years ago.”
“Why?” Will breathes, looking to the teenager who is holding the keys to reality between his fingertips. Young-Hannibal is mesmerised. His lips are pressed together, brow furrowed in concentration. Light reflects off the metal time-turner, catching his eyes just right, brown irises glinting with red fire. Will’s hands twitch, as if tempted to shake the answers out of him. “What did you want to change so badly?”
Hannibal does not answer. His younger self turns the device once, five, ten times. Will soon loses count of the rotations, hours bleeding into days, weeks, months… but as soon as the magic begins to take effect, the memory abruptly cuts to black.
Will startles, looking around. It’s as though God reached down with His divine hand and turned out all the lights. The two wizards are stood together in stretching darkness.
“What happened?” He turns to Hannibal in demand. “Why can’t we see anything?”
“In truth, I don’t know,” Hannibal sighs. “With regret, I cannot show you the events of my travels because I have no memory of them myself. Evidently, there was some kind of malfunction.”
“Evidently,” Will echoes, deadpan. Hannibal raises his wand in readiness, his expression darkening.
“What I can show you is what happened after.”
With a swish and flick, the curtain rolls back, and light returns to their surroundings. What follows is the aftermath. Teenage Hannibal awakens on the floor of Professor McGonagall’s office, surrounded by a throng of concerned and enraged faculty members. From his position, it looks as though he must have passed out. Unfortunately for the sly boy, the proof of his guilt is still strung around his neck. He makes the wise decision not to resist as the teachers snatch his wand away and frogmarch him in the direction of Dumbledore’s office.
“Well. I guess that solves the mystery of why you were expelled,” Will says stiffly. Hannibal nods, licking his lips in anticipation.
This is it.
“Indeed. But tell me, what of your expulsion, Will?” The intrusive question makes Will bristle.
“I thought you only wanted to see my visions.”
Hannibal smiles, reaching out and gliding a thumb across his stubble-covered cheek.
“Oh no, Will,” he croons. “I want to see everything.”
Will’s expression creases in protest, but he cannot hold off the swirling white fog that is suddenly rolling in, as Professor McGonagall’s office melts away before their eyes.
The pair rematerialise in a gloomy room of cold stone. Sunbeams filter through the cracks in the roof, accompanied by the quiet hooting of birds. Amber eyes blink out at them from the shadows. They are in the Owlery at the very top of Hogwarts castle. There are two male students facing off in the centre of the room: a scrawny looking Hufflepuff with a noticeable scar on his temple, and slick Slytherin with a very punchable face. The Hufflepuff is sobbing on his knees, cradling a lifeless hippogriff in his lap. The magnificent beast dwarfs him in size. Its talons and equine hindquarters are sprawled out across the floor, the boy’s skinny arms looped around its feathery neck. Hannibal immediately spots that the hippogriff’s underbelly has been torn open. Blood is seeping across the floor, turning the boy’s robes damp and the air thick with the scent of copper. Hannibal’s lashes flutter in macabre delight—but his revelling is short lived.
“We shouldn’t be here.” Hannibal turns in the direction of the gravelly voice. Will has retreated as far as he can, backing up against the wall with haunted eyes. “I didn’t give you permission to extract this. This is private, Hannibal.”
Heart hardened, Hannibal observes Will's changing expressions as he struggles to wrestle back control over his own mind. In normal circumstances, Will would be able to limit Hannibal’s access to his memories—but these are not normal circumstances. Under the influence of Veritaserum, the mind is rendered superbly malleable. Will unwittingly agreed to offer up his innermost thoughts at Hannibal’s behest. Closing a dam once the flood has arrived is nigh impossible.
“As we agreed, the forts that divide our minds will come down—one way or another,” Hannibal declares. Will’s expression turns from fearful to glacial.
“You did something, didn't you?”
Hannibal does not flinch at the accusation spoken through clenched teeth, nor attempt to deny it. He gives Will a pointed look.
“Whilst I may not have your talent for the Unforgiveable Curses, I am very adept at potions.” The statement makes Will pale. His voice shakes.
"What have you given me?"
"Only a few drops of Veritaserum. The effect will wear off in a day or so. Plenty of time for us to become friendly." A bitter laugh bursts from Will's chest, teeth bared in spite.
"So much for 'I wouldn't do that to the food.' You crazy son of a bitch.”
Hannibal is not intimidated by Will's foul mouth, but a withered part of his soul protests the pain in Will's voice. He quashes the strange feeling like a scurrying bundimun underfoot. Hannibal did not earn all those medical awards for nought; when the sick patient protests the prescribed cure, the doctor’s duty is to act in their best interests. This is a painful but necessary treatment. Who knows? In the end, Will may even thank him.
"Technically it was the wine," Hannibal points out with maddening calm. "And after our curious little tea party in the woods, I'd say you're in no position to be pointing fingers, Will."
Will winces at the reminder of his unconscious use of the Imperius Curse during their previous encounter. His mouth works, but no sound comes out. With no counter forthcoming, Hannibal turns his back, privately glad to escape Will’s conflicted expression. He returns his attention to the two arguing students. It quickly becomes apparent that this was no tragic accident. This was murder.
“What have you done, Peter?” the Slytherin accuses. His expression of shock is painted on, dark eyes vacant of feeling. The scrawny boy—Peter— sniffles, voice as broken as the creature in his arms.
“I didn’t—didn’t do anything.”
“I’m worried about you. You’ve been expressing a lot of rage lately,” the other croons in false concern, eying the dead hippogriff. “You’re prone to extremes of emotion. The way you think is compromised. This is the same hippogriff that kicked you in the head, isn’t it?” The slimy boy gestures at the scar on Peter’s forehead, in the distinctive shape of talons. The Hufflepuff shakes his head wildly, holding the creature tighter.
“No… you killed him. You killed him!” Just as the boy seems to be on the verge of a breakdown, a third voice interjects:
“It’s alright, Peter.”
Hannibal’s eyes flick to the side. From out of the shadows steps a much younger Will Graham, sporting a red and gold tie, the signature Gryffindor apparel. Hannibal is quietly shocked by Will’s youthful appearance. Absent his masculine stubble and faint frown lines that speak to adult hardships and accrued wisdom, this Will looks downright pretty. Long lashes, big blue eyes that catch the sunbeams, full cheeks. Hannibal is sure that had they crossed paths at this age, he would’ve eaten him up.
“Clarke Ingram, isn’t it?” the newcomer asks quietly. His voice is slightly higher pitched than his present-day counterpart, but it’s still undeniably Will. The Slytherin boy is taken aback.
“How long have you been there?” he asks, sounding more inconvenienced than afraid.
“Long enough.” Young-Will bends down next to the weeping Peter and loops an arm around his shoulders, helping him to stand.
“Are you a Prefect?” Ingram demands, scanning Will’s clothes for the usual badge; looking for any indication that he holds a position of authority that should be respected. Will doesn’t answer, preoccupied with steadying the shaking boy. The Slytherin frowns and dares to take a step forward. “Look, let me be clear, this is all a tragic misunderstanding.”
Before Clarke Ingram can manage a basic counter-curse, Will’s wand is pointed at his throat.
“I’m not a Prefect,” Will tells him, words biting and cold as ice. “I’m Peter’s friend.”
The Gryffindor teen begins his advance, driving Ingram at wand-point towards the Owlery window. Just then, a gasp to his left draws Hannibal’s attention. Adult-Will is struggling, his face screwed up with effort, gripping his hair so tightly that he risks ripping out great chunks. The guilt that Hannibal thought he’d exorcised returns tenfold.
“There’s no sense in fighting it,” he warns, sternness tempered by worry. Hannibal reaches out to try and stop Will from hurting himself, but he pulls out of Hannibal’s grip with an animalistic hiss.
“Don’t touch me.”
Just then, a scream rips through the air.
Ingram is pressed up against the wall as if a stake has been driven through his sternum, Will’s wand pointed directly at his chest. He writhes like a man possessed, fingernails splintering as he claws the stone walls, leaving a trail of blood. Just like in the Forbidden Forest, young-Will seems not to be fully awake— or rather, it’s as though another personality has taken over. Righteous anger steadies his wand-arm, observing his handiwork without remorse; an executioner passing a just sentence. Ingram’s cries travel the length and breadth of the tower, the owls’ shrieks of alarm only adding to the din. It seems that the torture might go on forever, until Peter dares to step forward and catch his arm.
“Will? Will! Y-you need to stop!”
At the gentle boy’s request, Will finally lowers his wand, but the cold expression on his face hasn’t changed. Peter sighs in relief, and Hannibal also makes the mistake of thinking it’s over—until Clarke Ingram picks himself up from his crumpled heap and begins shuffling towards the Owlery window.
“I-Ingram?” Peter tries.
The Slytherin boy doesn’t say a word. Doesn’t falter. He simply hoists himself up onto the ledge with a dreamlike smile on his lips, and then steps off.
In the seconds that follow, it’s as though time has stopped. The echo of Ingram’s screams from the Cruciatus Curse have faded, and an eerie pall has fallen. Will remains frozen opposite the window with a glazed-over expression. Hannibal regards him in wonder, chest swelling with pride. Will Graham may never have cast the third Unforgiveable Curse in his life… but that doesn’t mean he’s never killed anyone. Peter is still latched onto Will’s arm, eyes wide as saucers, staring at the spot where his tormentor was just standing. Even the owls have stopped their shrieking, like the entire world is holding its breath.
Then comes the dull thud from down below.
The sound brings the young Gryffindor to his senses. A whimper escapes Will’s lips as he backs away from the window, stammering and stuttering. His protests overlap with his present-day counterpart:
“N-no, no, no— no!”
Adult-Will has buried his face in his hands, shoulders shaking. Hannibal isn’t sure if he’s crying or enraged. Either way, he feels compelled to step in. Will Graham in distress is not a sight that he can abide—Lord knows why. Hannibal steps forward and gathers the disturbed man into his arms, just as Peter Bernadone does for Will’s younger-self, coaxing the guilty wand from his hand that he will never use again.
“You did nothing wrong, Will,” Hannibal assures, cupping the back of his head in a firm grip, wrapping his other arm around his waist. Will succumbs to the embrace, propping his chin on Hannibal’s shoulder and sliding his arms up his back.
As the past continues to play out, Peter leads his younger-self away down the tower steps, to be shortly taken to the Headmaster’s office—and thereafter, to the Ministry of Magic to stand trial.
“Well, now you know what happened to my dreams of becoming an Auror. I was lucky they didn’t throw me into Azkaban,” Will mutters with no small amount of sourness. He draws closer, grip tightening just below Hannibal’s shoulder blades, scrunching his expensive suit jacket. Strangely, Hannibal finds that he doesn’t mind. “Almost makes me wish I’d given him a more personal send off.”
Hannibal’s lips curl in delight at the predatory growl. He can read the regret expressed in Will’s clenched fingers; his longing to turn back the clock, pull Clarke Ingram back from the ledge, and squeeze the life out of him with his bare hands. Hannibal turns his face into the crook of Will’s neck, nosing at the soft skin. He smells of fresh pine, animal fur, and cheap sea-salt aftershave. Hannibal is surprised that the scent evokes a feeling of home.
“Doing bad things to bad people makes you feel good,” he mouths against his neck. Will presses up against him, pawing at Hannibal’s jacket in need.
“Yes,” he whispers. Hannibal’s lips graze along his throat, murmuring sweetly like a lover would.
“Then it is the Ministry’s loss. Clarke Ingram displayed all the hallmarks of one day becoming a dark wizard. If I were Headmaster, I would have put in a good word for you with the Auror Office.”
“I’m sure you would.” At last, Will finds it in himself to pull away. He wipes his damp eyes with his shirt sleeve and gives Hannibal a twisted grin, looking twice as exhausted as before. “Guess I should’ve known you hadn’t forgiven me for the Imperius incident. I’d say this makes us even, wouldn’t you?”
“Even steven,” Hannibal agrees. Will shivers at a sudden chill that has nothing to do with the cold breeze coming through the Owlery window. He rubs his arms through his shirt, trying to erase the goosebumps that have erupted on his skin.
“You felt that too just now, right? Almost like déjà vu?” he queries, throat scratchy. Hannibal runs a musing thumb across his bottom lip.
“Indeed. Many aspects of our conversations feel familiar. I wonder, why is that?”
“Search me.” Will shoves his hands in his pockets. Hannibal’s eyes flash with hunger at the ‘offer’, placing a smooth palm on Will’s cheek before he can escape.
“Yes, I rather think I shall.” Will trembles charmingly under his touch, unable to break free of his dark gaze. Hannibal’s satin words bind his spirit tighter than rope, honeyed tongue extracting bitter truths. “Time to show me what you See, Will.”
Will screws his eyes shut as the solid bricks and mortar surrounding them collapse into wisps of smoke, still affected by the Veritaserum. Even if he wanted to, he can’t refuse. Hannibal takes hold of Will’s twitching arm to ground him, as figures of mist coalesce and disperse in quick succession. As Hannibal suspected, these ‘visions’ Will spoke of are in fact memories… Specifically, memories of him.
Snapshots of Hannibal’s early years play out before his eyes. He sees himself at twelve years old receiving his first wand—an expensive import bearing the wandmaker Olivander’s mark, gifted from his father. In the next, Hannibal is perched on a wooden stool in Professor Dumbledore’s office wearing the Sorting Hat, a third-year transfer student fresh-off-the-boat from Lithuania. The hat eventually gives its verdict of ‘Ravenclaw’, sounding unusually displeased.
There are more painful memories too. Hannibal’s stomach drops when the mist consolidates into the bars of a steel cage. He and Will are standing in a bare, windowless room lit by flaming torches. ‘Dungeon’ would be the most apt term. Inside the cage are two children, both heartbreakingly thin, with matted brown hair and sunken cheeks: a boy no older than eight, and a girl a couple of years younger. Neither can speak, their lips sealed by a silencing charm. Magical rope binds their wrists and ankles, glowing a sickly green. Hannibal knows this memory well… in fact, it is the reason why he chose to invest in a pensieve in the first place. Will Graham is not the first to suffer from sleepless nights.
“What do you know of this vision, Will?” Hannibal queries, voice as neutral as he can make it.
“Nothing,” Will answers, shaking his head. His fists are clenched, fingernails biting into his palm at the sight of the wretched babes curled up at the bottom of the cage. “I’ve been dreaming about them since I was a kid myself… but I don’t know who they are.”
“Are you certain?” Hannibal presses softly. Will bites his lip but does not answer. Hannibal suspects they are both remembering the same thing: a magnolia tree bearing sinful fruit, delicious screams that fail to satisfy; poisonous blooms with bloodstained petals, cut stems drinking from split capillaries. Will had been so very eager to participate back then, hadn’t he?
Just then, the door to the dungeon opens, and a trio of wizards clad in hooded cloaks sweep into room. The ringleader of the group draws his wand. Hannibal recognises it immediately: yew, 12 ¼ inch, with a cheap and nasty core of kneazle whisker that is in desperate need of replacement. With a lazy flick, the cage door is released, and one of the men reaches inside. The little girl is dragged out by the hair, her screams straining for release against invisible stitches. The young boy tries to get to her, but their jailer simply laughs and kicks him in the chest, sending him sprawling on his back. They are two children facing a cult of dark wizards. They don’t stand a chance.
With another jab of the ringleader’s wand, the young boy is made to sit up in the cage, limbs jolting and joints cracking at the sudden force. The back of his head is pushed forward by an invisible hand, cheeks forced up against the iron bars, his eyelids peeled open. Present-day Hannibal watches on with a face of stone, long-healed bruises resonating with a dull ache. Just beyond the cage, the hooded lackeys tower over the little girl, holding her still by the arms. The boy frets and writhes against his invisible bonds, but he can’t reach her. They are only a few feet apart, but fate and circumstance conspire to separate them forever. The ringleader steps up from behind, his face hidden beneath the hood of his cloak.
“Cowards,” Will seethes in the present, echoing Hannibal’s own sentiment. In his right hand, the criminal wields a gleaming dagger. It appears ritualistic, with runes engraved into the white hilt. Hannibal identifies the colour and texture as human bone.
It all happens so quickly. So undramatically.
The ringleader yanks the little girl’s hair and pulls her head back, granting him easy access to her neck. Rather than draw a line across her throat, he stabs the blade with cool precision into her trachea. Surprisingly, no blood is spilled: the knife appears to be absorbing it, turning the hilt from white to crimson, runes flaring with dark power. The little girl spasms on the floor, her skin shrivelling and turning black like a dried prune. Once every last drop of blood is extracted, the dark wizard pulls out the blade, examining it with satisfaction. With a casual swish and flick, her body vanishes. Where they’ve sent her is anyone’s guess.
The men leave their remaining captive with a promised threat of return. As soon as the door closes, the boy sags against the cage bars, shaking like a leaf. Will takes several, stilted steps towards him. Present-day Hannibal maintains his distance, observing with typical reserve as Will bends down and reaches out— only for his hand to pass straight through the shaking child. He’s more than three decades too late.
“Help will come,” Hannibal assures quietly. Word has spread of the children’s abduction, with a hefty reward promised for their safe return. Wizards from noble houses across Europe and beyond will soon join in the search. The Murasakis of Okinawa will be the ones to find him. Hannibal knows this for a fact. Will’s ghostly hand falls away from the bars, hanging limply by his side.
“He’s you, isn’t he?” The whisper is barely audible. Hannibal draws a deep breath before approaching. Will can sense him in his periphery; his mouth spasms, unable to look at Hannibal for fear of breaking down. Despite how immediate it feels, this is not his pain to indulge in. Hannibal reaches out for Will’s closed fist with the gentlest touch, encouraging his fingers to uncurl.
“Yes,” comes the simple answer.
“Then, the girl who was with you…”
“Was my sister. That’s right.” Hannibal looks down at his wand, hesitating to speak her name aloud. The syllables feel foreign on his lips from years of disuse. “Her name was… Mischa.” Will closes his eyes, shaking his head in disgust. Hannibal is rendered speechless as the tears spill over.
Crying—for me?
If the sight of Will’s pain disturbed him before, this is on another level. Hannibal hates it, knowing that he is—in some way— the cause of these tears. Stranger still, he feels like he’s seen Will cry for him before, because of him before. In the most terrible, ugliest of circumstances.
“The time-turner you stole… the thing you wanted to fix… it’s this, isn’t it?” Will rasps. Hannibal feels his own eyes stinging, blinking a few too many times in the dark. He takes refuge in the academic to hide the tightness in his voice.
“Yes—but as you saw, the magic didn't take. In truth, I always knew failure was the most likely outcome. Time magic is a fickle, nebulous beast... Scholars cannot seem to agree on its limits; particularly where temporal paradoxes are involved." Hannibal stops short, looking anywhere but at the little boy in the cage. Helpless. Weak.
"I understand. You studied time magic to undo your sister’s death—but if you'd succeeded in saving her, you would never have stolen that time-turner in the first place. It's a contradiction.” The quiet damnation in Will's voice cuts deeper than a karambit. Hannibal dips his head in agreement. He’d arrived at the same conclusion years ago.
"Yes... but I owed it to Mischa to at least try.”
Quiet falls, punctuated by fretful gasps. The little boy in the cage is weeping, bound and mute, sobs contained behind his sewn mouth. Even animals are permitted to grieve; Hannibal’s captors have denied him even that small dignity. A minute passes. And then:
“I would’ve killed them.” Tear-filled eyes have turned to ice, calloused fingers twitching with the desire to wrap around a sinner's throat. "If I'd been here, Hannibal, I swear..." Hannibal is taken aback by Will's sudden change in tone. No longer is he a broken bird, but a steel-backed soldier. In him, Hannibal sees the product of accumulated pain; a blunted sword thrown into the furnace to be melted down and reforged, struck by the blacksmith’s hammer until it forms the perfect point. A lifetime’s work… perhaps more than a lifetime. He takes a step closer, catching hold of Will's fingertips. They are perfectly steady.
“Tell me, how would you have done it?” he intimates softly as the white mist begins to descend, engulfing the imprisoned child, sobs swallowed by silence. Will takes a deep breath and looks Hannibal dead in the eye.
“With my hands.”
The stale, claustrophobic air of the dungeon is swept away by a fresh breeze as a new vision emerges. This time, Hannibal sees himself as a young man in his mid-twenties, facing off against an elderly wizard in a hooded robe. They are alone in a wheat field in the sprawling farmlands of Lithuania, not far from the castle where Hannibal grew up—where he and Mischa were taken from. The full moon looms overhead, tendrils of fog clinging to their ankles as if the spirits are trying to trip them. Hannibal remembers this encounter well.
“Avada Kedavra!”
Green flashes split the night, summoned by the blood-curling cry. The hooded man is firing killing curses left and right, but his opponent is nowhere to be seen, disguised by a disillusionment charm. His Achilles heel is suddenly slashed from behind by an invisible blade. The elderly wizard falls back with a yell, wand rolling away into the grass. It is an inelegant way to disarm someone—but Hannibal is a practical soul when he needs to be. Theatrics can wait until the post-mortem.
The young man rematerialises, standing over his old enemy with wand raised:
“Petrificus Totalus.”
The frail man goes rigid at Hannibal’s behest, every muscle in his body contracting as if hooked up to an electric current. His fingers curl into claws, jaw clamping shut with such force his aging teeth threaten to crack. Only his eyes still move, watching in terror as Hannibal reaches into his suit jacket and pulls out a dagger. The blade is sharp and wicked, its hilt engraved in the same style as the one used on his sister years earlier. A deliberate choice.
Watching from the sidelines, present-day Hannibal steals a glance at Will. His mouth is set in a thin line, but he doesn’t avert his gaze from the bloody proceedings. Hannibal is surprised at first, until he remembers that Will has been seeing these visions for years. He thinks back to their meeting in their Forbidden Forest, and Will’s bland reaction to his morbid artistry. It’s all starting to make sense.
The pair watch as young-Hannibal extracts the man’s heart from his chest with elegant precision. His defeated opponent twitches on the ground, forced to watch as the victor takes a great bite of the spoils. Blood slides down Hannibal's chin, dripping red onto golden wheat. His older counterpart grimaces at the memory of copper, saliva flooding his mouth. Hannibal enjoys certain meats raw, but heart is not one of them; still, the pleasure in this particular meal is not in the taste. His younger-self presses on valiantly, teeth sinking into gristle and fat, swallowing past the bile rising in his throat. Soon the entire thing is gone.
“You—you ate his heart,” Will states. His voice is strained, but the emotion beneath is indecipherable. Hannibal turns to him with a sneer.
“He wasn’t using it anyway. This is the same man you saw in the previous vision.”
“The one who killed Mischa?”
“Yes.” A tense pause. “Are you disgusted by me?” Hannibal is unsettled by the deafening insecurity in his own voice. Why should he care what Will Graham thinks of him?
“No.” The vehement denial brings a rush of relief that almost makes Hannibal groan. Will is staring at him with parted lips, dark triumph gleaming in his eyes. “I think it’s poetic.” Electricity sparks and crackles between them. Hannibal can’t resist drawing closer, the two of them magnets with opposing poles.
“Beautiful, even?” He speaks in hushed tones; the delicious taboo of blasphemy uttered in church. Will’s half-lidded eyes fall to his lips, and Hannibal is just about to bend, when a soft glow illuminates their surroundings.
“Lumos,” comes the command. Will glances to his left to look. Hannibal draws back, annoyed by the interruption. His younger-self has picked up the dead man’s wand and is now casting a tester spell. His face is set in concentration as he measures the response, pleased by its slightly heavier weight, the smooth grip of the handle. For a second, he almost looks as though he’s about to cry… but with a decisive motion, the moment passes. Young-Hannibal slides his current wand out of his pocket and holds it aloft. “Incendio.” The wood bursts into orange flame, proof of the crimes committed by its hand reduced to ashes. His expression doesn’t so much as flicker; a wand too-easily won does not inspire much loyalty from either side—but Hannibal is confident that his latest prize will prove a better match.
“I guess taking his heart wasn’t enough for you,” Will remarks dryly.
“When I realised my efforts to save Mischa with the time-turner had failed, I made her a promise.” Hannibal’s voice drops, watching his younger-self conjure a shower of silver and gold sparks with his new wand, the night sky transformed into a canvas. “I swore that if I couldn’t save her, I would at least find her. Every last piece… however long it takes.” Will’s eyes are turned towards the heavens, where the familiar face of a little girl now smiles down upon them. A nudge against his elbow makes him tear his gaze away; he finds Hannibal offering his wand for inspection. Intrigued, Will runs his index finger tentatively along the sprig of yew, shuddering as the core’s energy passes into him. There’s something almost human about it. Hannibal soon reveals why. “As I said before, these ‘men’ are in the business of harvesting pureblood children, turning our organic matter into amulets. That includes wands.” Will looks up at him, appalled. Hannibal does his best to school his face, but he isn’t sure he quite succeeds. “This wand’s core, it’s her. It’s Mischa’s heartstring.” Will takes a moment to absorb this. He looks unsteady, like a mariner who has spent too long at sea in bad weather.
“That necklace on your desk, back in your office," Will begins, battling against his closing throat. "You said it was a 'gift'.”
“And a sense, it was," Hannibal confirms. "I was returning to her what they stole."
The grave of Mischa Lecter that sits on the edge of Richmond Cemetery is unlike any other: a glittering vault of gemstones steeped in blood, and precious metals that belie fragments of teeth and bone.
“Have you found all of her yet?” Will ventures.
“Around 20%."
His counterpart sucks in a breath, closing his eyes in pain. Will’s question, when it finally comes, is not at all what Hannibal expects:
“If I confessed the urge to kiss you right now, how would that make you feel?” A deadly-delightful spark shoots through Hannibal’s limbs, hearing his words echoed back to him. When Will’s eyelashes flutter open, Hannibal’s mouth turns dry. He realises that he doesn’t have a clue how to answer.
“I’m… not entirely sure,” he admits.
Will frowns, stepping in and taking Hannibal’s waist with both hands. Their roles from earlier have suddenly reversed. Now it is Will whose grip is solid and grounding; an anchor in heavy weather, whilst Hannibal fights the impulse to cling. Will’s salmon shirt reveals the contour of his biceps, filled with the promise of hidden strength. A part of Hannibal wonders what it would be like to sink into those reliable arms and allow himself to weep—but he doesn't. He is a big brother, his sister’s keeper, now a full-grown man, stuck in an overpopulated world of wallowing pigs begging to be culled. He is the hunter now.
Yet, the second Will lays a hand on his cheek, all of Hannibal’s deadly instincts vanish. A comforting thumb passes just below his eye as if wiping away unshed tears, tracing his jawline down towards cupid's-bow lips. Hannibal’s mouth twitches reflexively. Will’s hands are so unlike his own: smaller, rougher, raised callouses accrued from years of manual labour. Not soft. But... safe. Will's touch lingers on his jaw, thumb resting against his bottom lip. Hannibal presses a kiss to the lone digit, trying to read his intent. The desire in Will’s eyes has flamed out, leaving glowing embers of something gentler. Kinder. Deeper. Hannibal is simultaneously intrigued and unnerved.
Hannibal welcomes the tickle of warm breath against his mouth, blood pounding in his ears in anticipation before the kiss lands. The first touch is a bare brush, followed by a gentle press. Will’s lips are chapped, bitten from nervous habit, the slight scratch of his beard leaving tingles on Hannibal’s skin. His tongue is equally attentive as his hands, making a polite lick of enquiry before he slips into Hannibal’s mouth, almost shy. As Will’s fingers thread through his salt-and-pepper hair, Hannibal feels himself sinking. Compassion floods into him through every point of connection, like Will is trying to drown him with every shared breath. He’s never kissed anyone like this. Never lost himself like this.
The twitch of his ever-keen nose finally pulls Hannibal back to the present. Too late, he realises their surroundings have changed. It is still night, but there is now a distinctive smell of salt on the breeze, accompanied by the distant crash of waves coming from somewhere far below.
“Are we by the sea?” Hannibal murmurs inquisitively against Will’s mouth, moving to pull away. Will’s blissed-out expression bleeds into fear.
“Wait.” His hands have found Hannibal’s forearms, tightening like a vice. Will implores him with whispered words and frantic eyes. “Please… don’t.”
“I asked to see all your visions, Will,” Hannibal reminds him, formerly indulgent tongue regaining some of its sharpness.
There are other noises now: pained grunts and protesting cries, heavy thumps and scraping metal on stone. The sounds of war. From the distinct cadence, it sounds to Hannibal like there are three combatants, all males. Will shoots him a glare.
“You didn’t ‘ask’ me for anything.”
That gives Hannibal pause. Perhaps it is the influx of hormones from the kiss affecting his neurotransmitters, or the memory of Will's expression of betrayal in the Owlery tower; whatever the reason, Hannibal suddenly feels guilty for putting Will in this position. Like this is a mistake he’s made before.
In that moment, Hannibal decides to try something new. He decides to try listening.
“… There is a vial in my breast pocket. It contains the antidote to the Veritaserum.” Will blinks at the revelation. Suspicious, he dips a hand quickly into Hannibal's jacket pocket and fishes out a glass vial. It contains a distinct lilac liquid with a silver sheen. Will examines the contents, teeth worrying his lip; he may be a man of many talents, but he is no potions master. "I already poisoned you," Hannibal helpfully reminds him. "What do you have to lose?"
"Oh, just a few things: my sanity, my life, probably more. You can be quite inventive," Will grimaces. But it's not like he has any other options. Misgiving etched into his brow, Will uncorks the stopper and—pausing just long enough to say a silent prayer—downs it in one.
As soon as the potion passes his lips, the forts of Will’s mind raise themselves afresh. The men’s cries are cut off mid-shout and the smell of sea spray dissipates, concealed by a curtain of darkness. Frustration stabs at Hannibal’s gut, accompanied by a yearning ache, like his insides have been pulled out. He regards his companion in silent demand.
Who are you to me, truly?
Something tells Hannibal he was so close to understanding, if he could only see this final event—but it's not to be.
Another rushing sensation ambushes them. This time, the pair are thrust sharply upwards like they are strapped to a rocket launcher, reaching for each other amongst the cacophony of colour and sound.
Time's up.
With a great gasp, Hannibal and Will break through the pensieve’s surface, free from their tumultuous thoughts. They are back in reality. Hannibal staggers away as Will falls forward, catching hold of the stone basin for support. Out of the two of them, the latter seems to have come off worse. Hannibal prises Will’s fingers free and takes hold of his elbow, leading him back up the stone steps towards the office.
Once above-ground, Hannibal’s desk slides seamlessly back into place, covering the entrance to the secret chamber. He guides Will into one of the comfortable leather armchairs. Will is grey-faced, hands trembling on the armrests as his fingers dig into the padding. With a quick flick of his wand, Hannibal conjures a glass of whisky and waves it under his nose; Will jumps, pulled out of his daze by the heady scent of liquor.
“Do I look like a whisky guy or something?” he queries, accepting the glass.
“A hunch,” Hannibal answers, settling down in the opposite chair, cross-legged. “Am I correct?”
“Yeah.” Will nurses the glass with a frown of contemplation. “Thanks. For letting me leave,” he says at last. Hannibal drums his fingers on the chair in agitation, speaking to the stag painting behind Will’s head.
“I found the prospect of forcing you to disclose intimate details you were not ready to give… distasteful.”
“That’s a pretty rapid rate of personal growth. Congratulations,” Will snarks, looking off to the side.
After a few seconds, he seems to come to a decision. Will sets down the glass and pulls out his wand. Hannibal is transfixed as he presses the tip to his temple and withdraws a delicate silver thread. Will transfers it carefully to the empty antidote vial and stoppers it. With a quick Winguardium Leviosa the vial levitates, floating over towards Hannibal.
“Take it,” he orders. Hannibal accepts, but does not fully trust Will’s gift, searching his counterpart for any whiff of deceit. Will gives him a tired smile. “I was planning to tell you anyway at some point; I just didn’t count on showing you… and definitely not with me present.”
“What is it about this particular vision that inspires such fear in you?” Hannibal queries, turning the shimmering bottle over in his hand. Will frowns, struggling to find the right words.
“It’s... different to the others.” He hunches forward in the chair, taking a sudden interest in the Arabic-style rug on the floor. “I know it can’t be a memory—at least, I don’t think it is. It doesn’t make any sense. Maybe it’s my sleep deprived mind playing tricks on me.” A weak laugh follows, unnatural and forced, poorly covering Will's lack of conviction. His grip tightens on the empty glass. “I’m in it.”
That captures Hannibal’s attention. So far, all of Will’s visions were memories of his life.
“Not me this time?” Hannibal presses, just to be sure. He is further intrigued when Will avoids the question.
“I did something terrible," he confesses. "Something unforgiveable.” Hannibal tracks Will’s tongue as it darts out, moistening his chapped lips. Some would interpret it as a sign of guilt, but beneath Will’s lowered lashes, Hannibal glimpses the aching hunger within. Slowly, Will drags his gaze up to meet Hannibal's red-eyed stare. “It’s what I think of when I cast my patronus, and it’s also why I can see thestrals.”
“A vision of death.” Hannibal fiddles with the stopper of the vial, longing to jump straight back into the pensieve. Will grimaces at his obvious glee.
“You can watch it to your heart’s content once I’m gone. Oh, and that reminds me.” Will stands up on liquor-strengthened legs and pulls out small pouch from his trouser pocket. He opens it and shows the contents to Hannibal—a fine cobalt blue residue. “Floo powder. My own brand,” he elaborates, gesturing to the ornate fireplace that dominates the wall space behind Hannibal’s desk. “You’ll need it to get to my place.” Hannibal tries to ignore the strange flip-flop in his stomach at the thought of Will inviting him into his home. He examines the strange substance with intrigue. Floo powder is usually silver.
“Is it wise for an unregulated herbologist to be using the Floo Network?” he queries, pleased that he manages to keep his voice level. Will rubs the back of his neck.
“Actually, I’m on a private channel. Strictly invite only. A good friend of mine, Beverly, she helped me set it up.”
Well, that explains the odd colour, Hannibal thinks with a smirk, rubbing the sandy grains between his fingers.
“In other words, you’re giving me unfettered access to your living quarters. You’re not concerned that you might find me standing over your bed in the middle of the night?”
“Sorry, the channel’s only open during business hours—9am to 5pm. You’ll have to try harder than that,” Will rebuffs with a grin. The harmless flirting instead has a chilling effect. Hannibal’s gaze is drawn back to the sombre flowers and cursed necklace sitting on the desk, and the clock on the wall which tells him Will’s hour is almost up. The cemetery gates will be closing soon. There won’t be further opportunity for them to reconvene today.
“That’s unfortunate,” he remarks, not quite as cool as he’d hoped. “Then, it seems we must part ways. At least, for now.”
“Yeah,” Will agrees softly. “Strange how timing seems to be a recurring issue for us.”
The two men study each other with mournful expressions. Will reluctantly helps himself to a handful of blue powder and steps into the fireplace. Hannibal’s feet move without conscious intention, desperate to be near him for just a little longer. Will looks faintly amused to see Hannibal following him like a lost puppy. He beckons him forward and leans in close, lips grazing Hannibal's cheek.
“I’ll see you again soon,” Will promises, with an immediate caveat: “If you still want to, that is.”
Why wouldn’t I want to? Hannibal puzzles, but doesn't voice the question aloud. He suspects he's already holding the answer. The glass vial containing Will’s final vision thrums in the palm of his hand.
“I’m sure I shall,” he answers instead, dipping his head. “Safe travels, my dear Will.”
The fondness of the address visibly startles Will. He clears his throat, examining his ash-covered shoes in a futile effort to hide the colour blooming in his cheeks. A distraction is in order. Without further ceremony, Will tosses the powder at his feet. Blue flames erupt, tendrils of cold fire curling around his limbs. Hannibal is so busy admiring the colour—a striking shade reminiscent of Will’s eyes—that he almost misses the address:
“Evergreen Galley!” At Will’s command, the cobalt flames whisk him away to an unknown destination. Hannibal sighs, sliding the vial into his pocket for later, and picks up the bouquet on his desk.
As much as he longs to dive back into the tempestuous seas of Will Graham’s mind, he has a duty to fulfil first—and Hannibal Lecter always keeps his promises.
Notes:
Okaaaay now we’re getting into the good stuff! ;) I hope you all enjoyed.
Some terms:
Azkaban- wizarding world prison
Bundimun- a common magical pestThe Owlery scene was inspired by that moment in the fourth HP book/movie where ‘Professor Moody’ demonstrates the Unforgiveable Curses on that poor spider: ‘Talented isn’t she… what shall I have her do next? Jump out the window?’ Honestly, Imperio to me is the scariest Unforgiveable. Seriously, who needs the killing curse? I chose the Owlery specifically because I imagine that would be Peter’s sanctuary, similar to his menagerie of animals in the show. Ingram dragging the dead hippogriff there was done to spoil that place for him.
Some info on Hannibal’s original wand: dragon heartstring wand cores are the most powerful type, and most easily turned towards the Dark Arts. They are also more temperamental than the other cores. Willow trees are symbols of grief and withstanding hardship. In English folklore they were also said to uproot themselves and stalk people... and we know how persistent our happy little cannibal is.
Kudos/comments are very welcome, thank you to everyone who has left feedback and subscribed, couldn't do this without you! <3
Chapter Text
Pop—the satisfying sound of a stopper being uncorked, followed by the trickle of pouring liquid.
Hannibal stands over the pensieve in the secret room beneath his practice, alone with Will Graham’s thoughts. He finishes emptying the vial into the basin and takes a deep breath. His visit to Mischa’s grave is still raw and smarting. Perhaps it would have been wiser to wait a couple of days before wading back into Will’s mind— but Hannibal is, at heart, a hedonist. He can only delay gratification for so long. Hannibal braces himself against the sides of the basin, peering into the mercurial silver mixture, getting closer inch by inch. Cold touches the tip of his nose, spreading out across his face… and then the world turns upside down.
When the room stops spinning and the mist clears, Hannibal finds his footing on solid rock. As he deduced previously, they are indeed by the sea, perched atop a desolate bluff. The hour is late, and the wind is high. Three combatants take centre stage, positioned dangerously near the cliff-edge. As expected, Will Graham is one of them. He looks roughly the same age as he does in the present, although it takes Hannibal a second to be sure; Will’s face is covered in blood, oozing from a deep puncture in his cheek. As for the other two figures, Hannibal has no idea who they are. Aside from Will, there is a terrifying man dressed all in black. He looks incredibly strong, with a muscular torso and broad shoulders, sporting a distinct scar on his lip. He appears to be the aggressor, bearing down upon Will with murderous intent—something closer to a monster than man. Hannibal does not know his face.
And as for the last… he has no face.
Will’s other associate is blurry to Hannibal’s eyes, as though obscured by a watermark. His features are entirely masked, so that the wizard cannot even tell his age, although he looks roughly the same build as himself.
This scene has been tampered with, Hannibal muses. It looks like the result of an imprecise Obliviate spell, not unlike those he reserves for particularly difficult patients. Hannibal only uses the memory charm in special circumstances; for those with pasts so painful, they are better off remembering nothing at all. The question is, who is responsible? Who benefits? Hannibal’s first thought is none other than Will himself. If this vision is as traumatic as he made it sound, a memory wipe would seem the obvious solution.
Am I correct? Did you do this to yourself? he wonders.
Watching the scene unfold, it becomes clear to Hannibal that the mystery man and Will are working together to take down the man in black. They circle their larger prey, harrying like a pair of hunting wolves. Knives and axes inflict shallow cuts, the man-monster’s movements becoming sloppier as the balance of power shifts in the duo’s favour. Hannibal wonders if this is what Will was so afraid to show him. This dance of death… this naked bloodlust. Far from being off-putting, Hannibal is excited. After their previous encounters, Will should know that… so, it must be something else.
Will’s breathing is laboured now, the stab wounds to his shoulder and side pouring with blood. His faceless partner is limping too, although his injuries are less obvious. Looking at him, Hannibal feels a phantom pain shoot through the small of his back, as if struck by a sharp object. He hisses between his teeth and reaches behind, feeling gingerly for any sign of a wound—but his fingers come away clean. He spots a vaguely familiar steel item discarded on the paving stones nearby. It’s one of those ‘guns’ the muggles love to hide behind.
Come to think of it, guns shoot projectiles, don’t they?
Bullets, Hannibal recalls, sifting through the vast halls of his memory palace for the right word. Once more, his back twinges. Hannibal rubs the spot again with a grimace, refocussing on Will. Unbelievably, he’s still bleeding.
What is he waiting for? Hannibal wonders. If Will doesn’t fix himself soon, he’ll be in serious trouble. All he needs to do is whip out his wand and cast a quick Vulnera Sanentur to close the wounds.
Hannibal waits, expectant. Every passing second, his worry increases. Will is still embroiled in the battle, lunging again for the towering man in the black leather jacket. At the same time, his companion leaps onto their enemy’s back, exposing his stomach for gutting.
Reckless, Hannibal fumes. Both men are gravely injured. Normally he would endorse this hands-on approach—it’s a great deal more satisfying than relying on cheap spells—but at some point, survival must take priority over pleasure. Unless… A frown creases Hannibal’s brow, faced with a novel and terrifying possibility.
What if Will isn’t using his wand because he doesn’t have one?
Scratch that—what if none of them do?
Hannibal is mesmerised as Will’s mundane knife gouges deep into vulnerable flesh, drawing a horizontal line that gushes red. His counterpart joins in, pulling back their prey’s neck. Voracious teeth sink in, tearing out vocal cords and tendons. They both spring backwards, landing in perfect unison—dance partners on a blood-soaked ballroom floor. Their felled enemy falls to his knees before his betters. He stays like that for what feels like an age, posed in a mockery of prayer. Which god would listen is anyone’s guess. There is not a healing charm in sight. Finally, the man’s incredible strength leaves him, and he collapses backwards. Obsidian blood seeps into the paving stones, leaving imprints in the shape of dragon wings. Hannibal witnesses it all, stunned by the conclusion he draws.
They’re muggles. All of them.
The wizard takes a step back, peculiarly lightheaded. He understands now why Will finds this vision so disturbing; why he cannot distinguish if it is fact or fiction, why it doesn’t fit with his current reality.
It is a memory… of a world in which magic does not exist.
Will’s partner leans down and helps him to his feet, the two clinging to each other for balance on the edge of the cliff. Will is shaking with adrenaline; the other calm and steady but breathing hard. Hannibal is reminded of how they’d held each other in the pensieve just the night before.
The mystery man says something to Will, but Hannibal cannot hear it. Just like his face, his voice is distorted and muffled, like he’s speaking underwater. What Hannibal does hear, though, is the shaky answer that slips from Will’s lips:
“It’s beautiful.”
Hannibal’s soul aches in agreement. An exhausted Will finally succumbs; he sinks into his companion’s arms and lays his head down, directly over his heart. The other tips his head back in bliss, clenching Will’s bloodstained shirt and pulling him as close as he dares with their respective injuries. When he turns his head in towards Will, leaning against him in exquisite tenderness, Hannibal has to avert his eyes. He feels as though he’s intruding on something private—something sacred. This scene would be a suitable choice for the patronus charm. In fact, Hannibal feels as though he could cast it himself right now.
And then, it all falls apart.
Will reaches up and wraps his arms fully around his companion’s neck. The other doesn’t fight it, limbs hanging loose, content to be held at Will’s mercy. He must have no clue what is about to happen. Will doesn’t hesitate. He closes his eyes, leans fractionally to the left… and pulls them both over.
What?
Hannibal stares, numb, at the spot where the pair were just embracing. Vicarious bliss turns to nausea and betrayal. He remembers the question he’d put to Will in the Forbidden Forest, accompanied by their winged steeds of leathery skin and bone:
‘Did you lose somebody when you were young?’
‘No… I wasn’t young.’
Wand drawn, Hannibal marches towards the crumbling cliff-edge, stomach plunging with dread as he peers over. He ignores the voice of logic telling him that no muggle could survive a fall from this height; that this is just a memory from days long dead—that he’s too late. Hannibal Lecter is a wizard, for pity’s sake. There must be something he can do. But below, all Hannibal sees are roiling black waves stretching out to the horizon. Curiously, there is no sign of an impact; no disturbance in the current, or bodies floating on the water. It’s like the pair have simply vanished.
Almost as if by magic.
The coastal gale howls in Hannibal’s ears, whipping his face red raw, but it pales in comparison to the sting of betrayal in his breast. It almost feels like he was the one sent diving onto the rocks below.
Why does he feel this way?
Hannibal’s fingers travel to his collar and tie, remembering the weight of a much thinner chain around his neck; a miniature hourglass encased in a golden circle, begging to be turned. Now he understands. There is one other person aside from Will Graham who would want to forget this scenario... one other person who would benefit from a fresh start. The betrayer, and the betrayed.
Stepping back from the ledge, a taunting voice from another life is carried on the wind, posing Hannibal a question that will haunt his dreams:
‘Which are you?'
Notes:
*Channels Garrett Jacob-Hobbs and points to timey-wimey tag* See? <3
I’ve included a graphic here which may help:
Click Me
Chapter title comes from Bedelia's quote in the show:"Forgiveness is too great and too difficult for one person. It takes two: the betrayer, and the betrayed. Which are you?"
Quick reminder on Patronus charm- it's a defensive spell that produces a protective guardian animal that is basically made of happiness (Will has it in chapter 1). It can only be conjured by a powerful, happy memory. Here, the slaying of the Dragon 'it's beautiful' is Will's. This memory is also why he can see thestrals (the winged black horses in chapter 1); thestrals can only be seen by those who have witnessed a death. Wizard Will has been dreaming of the cliff vision since he was a child, hence he's always been able to see them.
Final chapter will be the resolution at Will's place/happy ending <3
Chapter Text
Three months pass before Hannibal steps into the fireplace in his practice with blue powder in hand, ready to confront Will Graham in his home. Calm, determined, he gives the order: “Evergreen Galley”, and the crackling cobalt flames carry him away.
Before he even opens his eyes, Hannibal is hit by the sound of crashing waves, violent wind, and the scent of sea salt. For a second, he’s convinced he’s back in the pensieve, about to be confronted by a vision of consummation and betrayal. When his eyes are no longer stinging with ash and smoke, Hannibal opens them, and realises with no small relief that he is wrong. He appears to have materialised inside a firepit on the top deck of a small, one-man boat.
Well, Will did call it a ‘galley’, Hannibal reasons, stepping carefully out of the coals and making a sweeping assessment of his surroundings. The vessel itself has seen better days. The paint is peeling, safety railings rusted through. Hannibal sincerely hopes there aren’t holes in the keel beneath. As for the man himself, Hannibal is disappointed that Will Graham is nowhere to be found. Only the overcast grey sky and the biting wind of the North Sea is present to greet him. The lack of security is surprising, but then again, Will doesn’t need to worry about intruders; living on a boat outside territorial waters, Will is beyond Ministry jurisdiction. Even if the powers-that-be did take an interest in him, his private Floo Network is the perfect defence. Will has made sure that nobody can drop in on him unannounced. Hannibal is privately impressed by his cunning. Now, if only he could express his admiration personally.
Fastened to the railing with twine is a hand-painted sign, directing customers to head below deck for service. Scouring the floor, Hannibal spies a nearby hatch. With a simple Alohamora to pick the lock, the hatch pops open, revealing a metal ladder. Peering over the edge, Hannibal cannot easily determine its height; the rungs disappear into a leafy green canopy, making it impossible to see the bottom. Hannibal decides to cast Epoximise to make his fingers sticky with adhesive before attempting the climb. Slowly, carefully, he descends.
When he breaks through the canopy, Hannibal understands where the 'Evergreen' in the address came from. He momentarily questions if he's on a boat, or in a jungle. The vast atrium below deck is teeming with life, tangy sea salt replaced by the fragrant aroma of sweet flowers and leafy green plants. Will must have cast an impressive Extension Charm to fit it all in.
The artificial roof has the appearance of glass, with a retractable screen to allow for as much or little light as desired. The floor is carpeted with moss, and climbing plants cover the walls: honeysuckle, clematis, and lobelia. As he descends through the foliage, Hannibal spots a shy bowtruckle camouflaged amongst the leaves, similar in appearance to an overgrown muggle stick-insect; an ideal natural method of pest-control. Busy bees and brightly coloured butterflies flit between the flowerheads. Hannibal is glad for the Epoximise when a monstrously large dragonfly zips past his face, translucent wings glittering like stained glass.
If there are dragonflies here, there must be a water source nearby. Sure enough, he spies a pond off to the side, the water's surface disguised by lily pads. Most intriguingly, a dirt path cuts through the centre of the room, leading to a thicket of hardy evergreens at the back. Thick tree trunks stand in solidarity, branches tickling the ceiling, partially blocking out the light. It is impossible to tell just how deep they go.
It's all very beautiful—save for the rickety workbench bearing Will's tools, covered in scratches and scorch marks. The table legs are taped together with reams of spellotape, looking like it might fall over at any moment. Hannibal wrinkles his nose at the eyesore. He has a mind to repair it properly, wondering why Will hasn't done so.
Hannibal finally reaches the bottom of the ladder. He’s itching to explore, but doesn’t even make it one step before a warning growl sounds at his feet.
Hannibal turns around, and finds a small dog eerily similar in appearance to a Jack Russel Terrier, with small ears, a pointed face, and a cute white spot on its chest. The only thing that gives it away as magical is its forked tail. Hannibal recognises it as a crup—a wizard-bred dog, known for its preference for purebloods—but this one doesn’t look exactly welcoming. Its hackles are raised, canines bared. Hannibal pulls out his wand in readiness, wishing it had occurred to him to come armed with a few slices of ‘salami’. If this animal belongs to Will, he would prefer to avoid injuring it.
Unfortunately, Hannibal soon discovers that Will Graham is quite the dog lover. Agitated barking fills the air, all slightly different cadences. Hannibal braces himself as another six crups burst onto the scene, claws sliding on the mossy ground in haste. Emboldened by its pack mates, the white-spotted dog lunges for Hannibal's ankle, just as the wizard raises his wand in defence.
Just in the nick of time, a wide-eyed Will rounds the corner. He’s looking decidedly worse for wear compared to their last encounter, back to his oversized jackets, patched jeans, and scuffed boots. The gardening gloves are a new addition, as are the protective earmuffs around his neck. Will places a finger to his lips and lets out a sharp whistle. At their master’s call, the pack stops attacking. All seven dogs bound over to Will and sit obediently at his feet, tails thumping in excitement. Will kneels beside them, offering soothing strokes.
“Hey, calm down you guys. He’s a friend,” Will scolds.
A ‘friend’, is it? Hannibal raises an eyebrow, wondering how Will greets his enemies.
Will is turned away from him, busy quieting his pets, but Hannibal spots him keeping one eye on him at all times. Most of the dogs have quietened down, but the one with the white spot can’t resist snarling. Will’s tone sharpens.
“No, Buster.” The little dog whines and sits back on its haunches. Hannibal notices that Will is wearing his broken glasses again, seemingly unable to meet his eyes. There is a familiar tension in the air too. It feels like their first meeting in the Forbidden Forest all over again—like they’ve taken one step forward and two steps back. “Sorry about that," Will offers. "I don’t know what’s got into them. They’ve never attacked a customer before.”
“Crups are fiercely loyal guard dogs. They will instinctively attack any perceived threat to their master’s wellbeing. Perhaps they can tell I am not merely a customer,” Hannibal suggests.
Will tenses, finally looking properly in Hannibal’s direction. His fellow wizard hasn’t moved, but his wand is still drawn. The seconds drag on, both men remembering the circumstances of their last parting: the innocuous silver vial containing a vision of betrayal. An unspoken question flickers in Will’s eyes:
Are you a threat?
After a moment’s consideration, Hannibal kneels upon the mossy floor and sets down his wand. His head is bowed in an uncharacteristic display of deference. Seizing the opportunity, one of the crups bounds forward and snatches up Hannibal's wand between its teeth, delivering it into Will’s lap. Hannibal dies a little inside, seeing his precious wand being treated like a stick in a game of fetch.
“Good boy Winston,” Will praises, patting the dog’s head. With Hannibal disarmed, the other dogs relax, jumping over one another for Will’s attention. The herbologist chuckles, trying to pet them all at once.
“May I come in now?” Hannibal prompts with the merest trace of irritation. Will peers at the kneeling wizard over the top of his glasses, holding Hannibal’s wand as gently as a newborn babe. They both know whose heartstring it contains. Hannibal waits with his head bowed, hoping this gesture of trust will convince Will he means no harm. It works.
“… You may.” Permission granted, Hannibal rises to his feet with as much dignity as he can muster. There is an awkward moment where neither speaks. Will half-opens his mouth, on the verge of addressing the elephant in the pensieve... but changes his mind at the last second. He turns away abruptly, nodding for Hannibal to follow him. “Come on. I’ll give you the grand tour.”
The herbologist leads Hannibal through the atrium, pointing out the various plants and their usages. With his guest being an accomplished potions master, Will draws Hannibal’s attention to the newly replanted mandrakes sprouting from a nearby vegetable bed.
That explains the earmuffs, Hannibal thinks with a wry smile. The plants look deceptively innocent just from looking at the leaves, their wailing roots that can strike a man dead at twenty paces silenced by the earth. Will is in his element, lecturing with intensity on his area of expertise. Hannibal suspects his loquaciousness is partly because of nerves, but it’s still nice to see him in such an animated state. They fall into step with ease, despite the parade of Leaping Toadstools that try to trip them underfoot. The little crups quickly take care of them, scattering the fungi with their chomping maws and excitable barks, forked tails wagging. Their very illegal forked tails.
“I can’t help but notice the standard severing charm hasn’t been applied to your dogs,” Hannibal interjects as Will pauses for breath midway through a spiel on wolfsbane and its many uses. The herbologist stalls mid-step, thrown by the observation. Hannibal smiles that faint, enigmatic smile of his. “Are they perhaps unregistered like their owner?”
All crups are required by wizarding law to undergo the painless amputation procedure, to avoid attracting muggle attention. For Will’s dogs to still have their tails can only mean one thing: the Ministry doesn’t know they exist. Will swallows, hands clenching at his side.
“They were going to be destroyed.”Hannibal detects the rumble of anger in Will’s voice that promises an oncoming storm. “They were bred for an underground fighting ring for magical beasts. When the Ministry got wind, they swooped in and shut the place down. It was thought they couldn’t be rehabilitated. Thankfully, I know a guy in the Department for the Regulation and Control of Magical Creatures. He’s a regular of mine—managed to smuggle them out.”
“How admirable.” Hannibal’s praise is sincere. “I imagine it took a significant amount of work.” Will’s eyes slide up to meet his, a spark of determination igniting within.
“I’m not afraid of a little hard work.”
Case in point, the Venomous Tentacular in the corner needs no introduction. Will catches Hannibal’s wary expression and grins, remembering their previous conversation.
“The seeds are one of my best sellers. Worth every second of pain.”
“Yes, I expect your prices are extremely attractive,” Hannibal concurs dryly. Venomous Tentacular seeds are a controlled substance. On the open market they cost a pretty penny; being unlicensed, Will doesn’t need to bother with pesky little details like paying taxes. His competitors must be thrilled.
“I’ll give you a free sample if you help me extract them,” Will proposes, a mischievous twinkle in his eye. Hannibal shoots him a withering look.
“As tempting as the offer is, I’m afraid I must decline.”
“That’s a shame,” Will sighs, as they reach the edge of the pond. He bends down, gesturing for Hannibal to follow suit. “Then, how about a swim instead?” Will gestures to an underwater plant with ugly tendrils floating on the surface that look an awful lot like rats’ tails.
“Gillyweed? I didn’t think it grew in cold climates.” Hannibal peers closer, dipping his fingers into the pond water and fondling the rubbery texture.
“It’s usually endemic to the Mediterranean; I’ve been breeding a hardier sub-type. You could grow this in your garden back home in Lithuania.” Will cocks his head in curiosity. “Ever tried it?”
“The prospect of sprouting gills and flippers never appealed to me,” Hannibal smiles wanly. “Should I ever feel the burning desire to breathe underwater, I shall cast a simple Bubble-Head Charm.”
“Simple, is it?” Will rolls his eyes. “The Bubble-Head Charm is a N.E.W.T level spell. Not many witches and wizards can be trusted to cast it. Do you know how many decapitations there are each year?”
They are so caught up in their banter, they don’t notice the surface of the pond ripple, until something shoots out of the water and latches onto Will’s ankle. Hannibal isn’t quick enough as the rug is pulled from under him. Will falls flat on his face, yanked backwards into the water. He tries to fight, scrabbling fingers ripping up chunks of moss from the floor, exposing the dull shine of the metal hull beneath. It’s not enough. Will hits the water with a loud splash, their wands flying out of the inner pocket of his jacket and sinking to the bottom of the pond.
So much for the Bubble-Head Charm.
Hannibal doesn’t think twice. He shucks his suit jacket and kicks off his shoes, tearing off a small sprig of gillyweed and shoving the rubbery tubers into his mouth. Then he dives straight in after Will.
Once he’s underwater, it takes a few seconds for Hannibal to adjust. Breathing water doesn’t exactly feel natural. Hannibal gingerly touches the gill flaps on his neck, catching sight of his webbed hands in the process. His feet are even worse; it looks as though he’s wearing flippers. He dreads to think what people would say if they saw him like this; there would be more than a few tasteless jokes about pureblood inbreeding. Will would have a field day.
Speaking of Will…
Hannibal detects a disturbance in the water; a false current caused by gasping breaths and thrashing limbs. He turns to find Will some feet away, struggling to dislodge the creature glued like a limpet to his leg. It looks like a deformed octopus with a humanoid upper half, cursed with a leering mouth that stretches from ear to ear, filled with razor sharp teeth. Hannibal recognises it as a grindylow—a common water demon prevalent to the British Isles. He looks down, but sees no sign of their wands. By now, they must be half-buried in the bed of silt below… which means he’ll have to do this the old-fashioned way.
Break its grip, Hannibal thinks, zeroing in on the squid-like arms wrapped around Will’s legs, binding him tighter than Devil’s Snare. Hannibal closes the distance in three powerful strokes. Saliva fills his mouth, lips peeling back to reveal glinting teeth. Without a wand, Hannibal is reliant on the element of surprise.
He dodges the grindylow’s tentacle that tries to snag his wrist, catching hold of it in his hands. Grindylows are renowned for their strength, but Hannibal is no slouch in that department either. He lunges forward and bites down, hard. The sensation feels eerily familiar: incisors sinking into a man’s neck, vocal cords snapping like violin strings, collecting his pound of flesh. The grindylow’s arm rends free, purple blood expelled around Hannibal in a dark cloud, its iron grip broken. Just like that, Will Graham is free.
Will kicks up for the surface, his lungs screaming for air. Enraged to see its prey escaping, the grindylow tries to make chase, but Hannibal is having none of it. He grabs it by the head and pulls back its neck, the satisfying snap of bones and tendons reverberating through his fingers. The grindylow goes limp.
Now he just needs to retrieve their wands.
Scanning the pond bed, Hannibal spots more grindylows hidden amongst the weeds. He dives down to meet them, red eyes daring them to try it twice. They gnash their teeth but keep their distance, scenting their brother’s blood on him. After a bit of digging, Hannibal finds their wands nestled in a rocky crevice. He carefully wipes off the layer of silt; this is his first time seeing Will’s wand up close. At an educated guess, the wood appears to be hawthorn... as for the core, Hannibal has no idea. He tests the grip, struck by how warm it feels in his hand. The wand seems to be radiating heat, staving off the chill of the water seeping into his bones.
What are you? Hannibal wonders, turning it over in his hand. Unfortunately, now is not the time for academic musings. Having swallowed a deliberately small mouthful, the gillyweed is due to wear off any minute. Hannibal can already feel his gills twinging in warning.
When he resurfaces, Hannibal finds Will lying flat on his back on the mossy bank, shivering and gasping. His pants and shirt are both ripped from the grindylow’s assault, and his cracked glasses are nowhere to be seen, likely at the bottom of the pond. Buster, Winston and the other crups are gathered around, tails wagging in concern. Hannibal hauls himself out of the pool and collapses beside Will, looking quite literally like a fish out of water with his webbed hands and feet. Just when he thinks the situation can’t possibly get any more undignified, one of the crups decides to lick his face off. Will splutters with laughter as Hannibal fends off the energetic Winston.
“Your home is proving rather more hazardous than I was expecting, Will,” Hannibal bites out, holding Winston at arm’s length. It’s a small mercy that his gills and flippers are shrinking on schedule, but the wet clothes clinging to his skin are doing little to improve his mood. It must be even worse for Will: the soaked rags he’s wearing can barely be considered ‘clothes’ at all. "Aren’t you going to fix that?” Hannibal prompts, gesturing to his tattered shirt and pants. Will flushes in embarrassment.
”I would, but I—er—can’t.”
”Meaning?”
“Meaning, I have a certain… talent for breaking things. Wish I could say the same about mending them.” Will shivers, pulling the frayed remnants around his shoulders with a scowl. Hannibal looks towards the pond, where Will's shoddy spectacles are lost to the depths. He pictures the splintered bookshelf in his office following Will's visit, the questionable seaworthiness of their current vessel, and the rickety workbench that has seen better days. The crunch of Clark Ingram’s bones echoes from years past.
“May I request a demonstration?” Hannibal cocks his head, never one to deny his curiosity. Will sighs and points his wand at his torn jeans.
“Reparo.” There is a weak sizzle from the wand, like rain droplets landing on embers. Nothing happens. He fixes Hannibal with a dull stare.
”There. Satisfied?” Will’s negativity garners a frown; his attitude at odds with the flourishing fauna and fantastic beasts that surround them.
“You claim a talent for destruction, but in your work, you dedicate yourself to the preservation of life." Hannibal nods to the rescued crups, keeping his tone deliberately light. “Making up for past errors, perhaps?” Will stares at him, not knowing what to say. Hannibal doesn’t push for an answer. He picks up his elm wand and gestures to Will's clothes in request. “Allow me?” Realising he's lost the advantage of being the only armed man in the room, Will hesitates. The Veritaserum incident is still fresh in his mind. Hannibal frowns, reproachful. “Do you really think I would go to such lengths to save your life, only to curse you?”
“Yes,” Will mutters. Hannibal’s lips quirk; it is impossible to tell whether from amusement or displeasure.
“That sort of doubt between friends can lead to unfortunate accidents.”
Before Will can say ‘no’, Hannibal has already conjured him a fresh button-down shirt and jeans, and drained the excess water from their clothes. Ignoring Will’s glare, Hannibal turns his attention to the lifeless grindylow oozing blood on the mossy bank.
“Well, it looks like dinner plans for tonight are set,” he declares, sealing the creature inside a see-through container filled with pondwater to keep it fresh. Will gives him a deadpan look.
“You’re not serious.”
“Whyever not?” Hannibal queries, rapping the tank with the tip of his wand. “Grindylow meat is considered a rare delicacy in some parts of the world.”
“Presumably you’re aware the Ministry has marked them as unfit for human consumption?”
“Because they sometimes consume humans themselves, yes.” Hannibal shoots him a wicked smile with purple-stained teeth. “Lesson learned: never give one’s food the opportunity to bite back.”
“You should have that printed on a t-shirt,” Will snarks. Hannibal throws him a sharp look.
“Forgive me for being blunt, Will, but you’re in no position to be pointing fingers. Your dogs aside, Grindylows are classified as dark creatures by the Ministry. The fact you’re keeping them at all is a breach of regulation.”
“They’re good for the PH balance,” Will defends. Hannibal raises a placating hand.
“I wasn’t making an accusation. I was merely highlighting that neither of us are the type to be held back by a little red tape.”
It’s an uncomfortable truth. Will lowers his gaze and shoves his hands in his jacket pockets. Hannibal picks up the grindylow container by the handle, the two of them continuing down the winding path. Hannibal senses Will’s swirling thoughts, trusting that silence is often more effective than speech. He is soon proven correct.
“I tried playing by the rules, you know. Once upon a time,” Will says suddenly. The admission is clearly difficult, words sticking in his throat. “But I’ve come to accept I’m too malleable to stick to any defined sense of right and wrong. Too curious for any ideals.”
“God Himself doesn’t seem to place much stock in ideals,” Hannibal notes with a half-smile, looking to the dead grindylow in the tank. “Typhoid and swans; grindylows and fairies—it all comes from the same place.” Will follows his gaze to the tank and sighs.
“I should’ve fed them last night. It wouldn’t have attacked us if it wasn’t hungry.”
“Feeling guilty?” Hannibal asks mildly.
“Let me think: do I feel guilty for not letting a grindylow drown and eat me? No, Hannibal.” Will rolls his eyes. “I’m just saying it could have been avoided.”
“Forgiveness comes easily to you,” Hannibal notes, recalling how Will had cried for him so readily in the pensieve. His voice drops a note. “You assess motive absent any pre-existing notions of morality. You look, and you understand… It’s a quality I admire in you.”
They soon pass over the mossy threshold, swallowed by evergreen trees. The crups hang back on the forest edge when Will tells them to wait. He promises he’ll be back soon, but the dogs still whine in protest as their master disappears further into shadow and dappled light. Hannibal breathes deep, the scent of pine filling his lungs. In the quiet of the forest, every sound is amplified to his ears; the snapping of twigs beneath his polished shoes, Will crunching through the detritus in muddy boots with glued soles. Hannibal is struck then by just how different they are… different, and yet, adaptable. Hannibal seldom visits the forest when there isn’t bloodletting involved, but he finds himself enjoying the calm atmosphere; idly observing the changing light as it hits the leaves, soothed by the distant sound of running water. There must be a stream somewhere nearby. It isn’t quite the same as being serenaded by the genius of Bach or Mozart, but it’s still pleasing on the ear. Hannibal could get used to this, just as he is certain Will could adapt to him. He imagines how beautiful Will would look on his arm at the Royal Opera House: tuxedo freshly pressed, beard trimmed and brown curls shining, a dab of vanilla fragrance just behind the ear where Hannibal could subtly breathe him in. They would canvas the crowd, making polite conversation both magical and mundane, knowing their hands will be stained red by the dawn.
“How about you, then?” Will prompts, cutting through the quiet. “What’s your position on forgiveness?”
“Where the sin is against me, the appropriate restitution depends on the gravity,” Hannibal answers. Naturally, he tailors the answer to himself. Hannibal isn’t interested in abstract moral philosophising on the problem of suffering and the failings of the human condition. He is only concerned with purging the ugliness that dares to affront his own eyes. A dagger in the back. A fall from a cliff. A lovers’ suicide with an unwary participant. Will looks to the dead grindylow in the container and sees himself reflected in the glass.
“An eye for an eye is your moral imperative, then?” he grinds out.
“Short of undoing what has been done, it is the only effective palate cleanser.”
“Undoing what has been done… turn back time, you mean?” The words are spoken in jest, but there is a tense note beneath the tease.
“If only it were possible,” Hannibal muses with convincing longing. “Life would be much simpler if we were all born with a personal time-turner. In such a world, there would be no need for forgiveness.” His words must taste offensive because Will is suddenly grimacing like he’s bitten straight into a lemon.
“But without consequences, we’d never grow. Our personalities, our beliefs, would be the same from the cradle to the grave. We’d keep making the same mistakes; failing to communicate. Inflicting the same wounds over and over.” The melancholy murmur is accompanied by a subtle movement through the trees. Hannibal spots a trio of thestrals watching them with moonstone eyes. Death is stalking them yet again.
“Then perhaps the ideal solution would be to start afresh, but to remember something of the lessons that came before,” Hannibal suggests carefully. Will runs his tongue across his bottom lip, apparently finding this proposal far more palatable.
“That would be the ideal.”
As Hannibal predicted, they turn the corner and come to a bubbling brook. The pair walk along the bank, enjoying the tranquil sight and sound of water trickling over rock. On the other side of the stream, Hannibal spies a makeshift camp. There is a hammock erected next to a firepit, with a primitive rotisserie rack fashioned out of wood. His keen nose detects the faint trace of smoke hanging in the air—most likely from Will’s breakfast that morning. A set of handmade fishing rods are propped against a nearby tree trunk, washing line strung between the branches. Hannibal knows it is a washing line because of the garments pegged to the twine that can only belong to Will: several plaid flannel shirts, faded jeans at different stages of wear and tear, and several pairs of boxer shorts. Realising he’s yet to see a single normal room in this place, Hannibal has the sinking feeling he’s looking at Will’s bedroom and kitchen. On his part, Will doesn’t seem remotely embarrassed by his crude living arrangements, or the fact his underwear is on proud display in front of a guest. Hannibal is far too polite to comment on it. Instead, he opts for the diplomatic approach.
“Will, may I ask, why a forest?” The wizard in question chuckles, gesturing back the way they came.
“The nursery back there is for the needier plants and creatures. Some species prefer solitude.” Will points to the trees above. Hannibal follows his gaze, eyes widening when he spots a distinctive flash of red amongst the greenery. Will places his fingers to his lips and lets out a low, enticing whistle, trying to coax the bird out of hiding. It works… sort of.
Hannibal’s breath stalls as the magical creature emerges from the cover of the trees, scarlet and gold plumage glowing like embers. Unfortunately, it doesn’t look best pleased to see them. The bird’s feathers are puffed up in an obvious threat display. It makes an odd clicking noise in its throat; the avian equivalent of a growl.
“Hey, Vesta,” Will ventures. His soft tone fails to placate as intended. As Vesta’s wings unfurl, it feels like all the moisture has been sucked from the cool forest air, her feathers radiating searing heat. Will sighs and draws his wand. It seems he’s done this many times before.
“Protego.” The shield materialises around them just in time before they are showered in flaming sparks. By the time the onslaught is over, the legendary creature is nowhere to be seen. The only proof she was ever there are the scorch marks on the ground, and the single, scarlet feather resting on the forest floor. It takes Hannibal a few moments to find his voice.
“That was a phoenix.” The awe in his voice is matched by the wonder in his eyes. Will dips his head, scratching the back of his neck.
“Yes, it was. Like I said, her name’s Vesta.” Will is smiling, but there is a pained edge to it. “Not that she remembers it anymore. Or me.” Seeing Hannibal’s enquiring look, Will elaborates. “I rescued her, years ago. Shortly after I was expelled, I needed some time to think, so I ended up doing a tour of the States. I took odd jobs that paid cash-in-hand; wound up as an assistant in a magical menagerie. That’s where I found Vesta.” Will stops short, mouth twisting into a grimace. Hannibal can only guess the living conditions in such a place. “She has a neurological disorder, similar to Alzheimer’s in humans. It causes loss of memory and poor impulse control. She was becoming too much for her previous owners to handle; started attacking paying customers. They decided to cut their losses and sell her to the highest bidder. Nobody claimed her… so I claimed her.” Hannibal’s already thin eyebrows threaten to disappear into his hairline. He’s never heard of a phoenix suffering from such an affliction. Their lifecycle is one of decay and renewal, their aging bodies devoured by flame at the point of death, only to be reborn from the ashes.
“She doesn’t rejuvenate on Burning Day?” he queries.
“The body yes... but not the mind.” Will looks to the scorch marks on the forest floor, swallowing thickly. “Most days, she doesn’t even acknowledge me. She looks straight through me, past me like I’m—like I’m just a stranger.”
“Our memories are our identity. It’s a terrible thing, to have your identity taken from you, whether by the cruel hand of Mother Nature or Man.” Hannibal bends to pick up the fallen feather, examining it with a pensive expression. “Tell me Will, were you compelled to rescue Vesta because you felt you had something in common with her?”
“Perhaps,” Will snarks, turning to self-deprecation to hide his discomfort. “Two broken minds struggling to navigate the shifting sands of reality. Guess we were made for each other.”
“Broken things can be repaired,” Hannibal says quietly, running his fingers along the precious feather. He can sense the limitless lifeforce sparking through the vanes and barbs, unpredictable and overflowing with potential. He’ll be adding this to his potions stock when he returns.
“I wouldn’t if I were you.” Confused by the interjection, Hannibal turns to Will. The other is holding up his imperfect, handcrafted wand, wearing a lopsided smile. “I know what you’re thinking Hannibal, but take it from me, you won’t get the results you expect.” Hannibal’s stares. At last, the puzzle pieces click.
9-inch hawthorn with a phoenix feather core.
In professional wandmaking, wand cores are harvested from magical creatures in the peak of health. As far as Hannibal knows, there is no precedent for this: an amateur wizard crafting a handmade wand with a core donated from a sickly phoenix.
No wonder he struggles with basic repair charms, Hannibal muses. The beast who gave Will's wand a heart can’t even repair herself. Still, he slides the feather into his suit pocket when Will isn’t looking. Broken things can be uniquely beautiful when viewed from the right perspective, and Hannibal is loathe to let something beautiful be wasted.
Just then, a sudden proclamation from Will cuts through his thoughts:
“We're nearly there. It’s just a little further upstream."
“Oh? I wasn’t aware you had a destination in mind," Hannibal remarks coolly, content to follow Will along the winding path, despite the lack of answers. By now, Hannibal has learned that as inscrutable as Will’s actions might seem, everything he does has a point. Hannibal steals a glance at the other's profile: strong jawline cut by shadows, untamed curls, blue eyes-come-quicksilver. For months now, this impossible, wild thing has been taking conscious, determined steps towards him, lowering the forts of his vulnerable mind, baring the ugliest parts of his soul. Hannibal shivers in anticipation.
What terrible beauty are you about to reveal to me now?
He notices a gradual change in the lighting as they walk. The sunlight filtering through the glass ceiling has now been completely overshadowed by thick fir trees and towering redwoods. In its place, soft lights flicker amongst the branches, mimicking the golden glow of fireflies. Drawing closer, Hannibal sees that they are not insects, but miniature winged figures perched amongst the leaves.
“Fairies?” he quirks an eyebrow at Will, but the younger wizard offers no explanation. Fairies are vain creatures, happy to be used by wizards as decorations for pretentious social events. Playing to his audience, Hannibal presses the tip of his wand to his throat and casts a Sonorous Charm, praise echoing through the trees: “What a beautiful display. I doubt my eyes have ever been blessed with a lovelier sight.” Will rolls his eyes, but the insincere words have the desired effect. A high-pitched tittering ripples through the forest like a flock of sparrows as the fairies giggle and preen, their little bodies glowing even brighter.
The treeline soon opens into a clearing. Hannibal stops in his tracks, breath momentarily stolen from his lungs. It appears they have arrived at the ‘event’ after all. The fairies have congregated here in greater numbers, arranged deliberately to produce the desired lighting effect. Forget-Me-Nots carpet the clearing along with several flower beds, protected by an enchantment to preserve the blooms all-year round. Hannibal spies frozen lilies encased in ice and translucent roses made of glass. The flowerbeds encircle a mound of freshly turned over earth bearing a wooden cross. Will gently coaxes the grindylow tank from Hannibal’s hand and sets it aside without a word. Hannibal approaches slowly, his face arranged into a mask of neutrality, confirming the name carved into the grave marker.
Mischa Lecter
“This is for you,” Will murmurs from his left. He pulls out a small ring box from the pocket of his jacket and offers it to him. Hannibal tenses the second he lifts the lid, hit by the familiar scent of blood; but the satin interior is empty. His eyes slide across to the freshly dug grave in understanding. “Crups don’t just make good guard dogs, you know. They’re good at tracking too," Will tells him quietly. “Your genetic makeup is almost the same as Mischa’s, so I used a few strands of your hair to teach them her scent.”
Hannibal thinks back to their embrace in the pensieve. He pictures Will caressing his hair, a few stray strands disappearing unnoticed into the herbologist's pockets. He pictures canny Buster and loyal Winston following the scent of prey through the twisting labyrinth of Knockturn Alley; sees Will making hushed conversation with unsavoury figures in the back of secondhand bookstores and dimly-lit taverns, luring them with the promise of rare potions ingredients at cut-throat prices. Luring them back to his territory. In the middle of the North Sea. Where nobody will hear them scream.
What a cunning boy he is.
Will is watching Hannibal’s face for a reaction, hope giving way to doubt as the seconds drag on.
“I—er, hope you don’t mind that I already buried her… I didn’t know if you were coming back.” Will's voice falls to a near-whisper at the end, looking down at his feet. He flinches as Hannibal closes the case with a snap.
“You never cease to surprise me, my dear Will.”
Will startles, eyes darting up to meet Hannibal’s. Instead of anger, he’s met with a look so intense, he might melt beneath its heat. Of course, Hannibal isn’t angry—how could he be? He recognises the gesture for what it is: not a thoughtless imposition of boundaries, but a precious gift… a tribute. When Will looks away for the second time, it is for an entirely different reason. He regards Hannibal from underneath his lashes, cerulean eyes reflecting cold, clear purpose… but hungry. So very hungry. Both hear the proposition loud and clear:
Do you see? The wondrous, terrible things we could do—everything we could be.
Hannibal turns to the enchanted rosebush next to them. He caresses the smooth, see-through petals, and presses his thumb against one of the glass thorns. A ruby droplet trickles down the stem.
“Truly lovely," he sighs. "I’m reminded of the manor gardens from my childhood. We had fairies too. Mischa would often ask me to have tea parties with her there.”
Picking up on the suggestion, Will goes to draw his wand, but Hannibal is already one step ahead. With a swish-and-flick, he conjures up a table, chairs, and a steaming teapot with twin teacups. Will laughs, abashed by his lack of hospitality. It seems they have come full circle; albeit there are no eviscerated victims looking down on them from the trees tonight. Thank God for small mercies.
“I should’ve done that. Sorry, I don’t usually have guests,” Will admits, sliding into his seat.
“You are a creature who typically prefers solitude,” Hannibal replies sagely, taking a sip. The teacups are the same as before, each printed with pastel ducklings and teddy bears. Only now does Will realise their significance. This must be the same tea set from Hannibal's childhood; a relic from happier times filled with fairies, life, and laughter, unspoiled by horrid adult notions of dark wizardry and death. Will's stomach twists at the realisation he's probably drinking from Mischa’s cup right now.
They lapse into silence, punctuated by the creaking branches and chirruping fairies in the trees. The quiet is simultaneously peaceful and oppressive, too aware of the glowing pairs of eyes watching them, and the illusion of Mischa’s ghost sitting with them at the table. Both sense they can no longer dance around the inevitable. After a few false starts, opening and closing his mouth with no sound forthcoming, Will finally lets the sword of Damocles fall:
“Did you watch my vision, in the pensieve?”
“I did,” Hannibal confirms. His tone is steady, red wine eyes betraying nothing. Will’s grip tightens on the delicate handle of the teacup.
“And? Do you think I’m insane?”
Hannibal squints at him, choosing his words carefully.
“Before I share my thoughts, perhaps you should tell me what you think it means, Will.”
“I don’t know.” Will takes a deep breath, forcing out the words he knows he must: “But I know he looks exactly like me.” It is obvious who Will means by ‘he’— the doppelganger in his vision, armed with steel and soaked in blood under a moonlit sky. Betrayer. Hannibal nods in solemn agreement, waiting patiently for Will to stop fiddling with his napkin and continue. “... I want to write it off as some kind of lucid dream. A theatrical production of my subconscious.”
“Perfectly valid theories,” Hannibal acknowledges. “And yet, you cannot do so.”
“Because it feels too real,” Will confesses. “It feels… like a memory. Even though that’s impossible.”
“Are you certain of that?” Hannibal’s question is posed in a neutral fashion, but Will immediately turns defensive.
“I remember my past all the way back to my early years; I know that never happened.”
“Then logically, it cannot be you,” Hannibal answers smoothly, taking another swig of tea. Will’s jaw works as he struggles to respond.
“It feels like I’m watching another ‘me’,” he declares, achingly soft. “A mirror image reflected from another place—far away and long ago.” Desperate eyes flick up to Hannibal in search of understanding.
“A ‘you’ who condemns the wicked without the aid of a wand.” The silken words provoke a tremble of delight and fear in Will. “Curious that you would refer to this man in your vision as a ‘reflection’,” Hannibal continues, unblinking in his scrutiny. “In many myths, mirrors are depicted as gateways to other worlds.” Now it is Will’s turn to squint. He can’t quite perceive the path Hannibal is coaxing him down; a blind man feeling for the crevices in the walls to guide his stumbling feet. Hannibal decides a firmer grip is required. “What about the man you were attacking? When you relive the scene, how does it make you feel?” Will reclines in the chair and tips back his head, eyes flickering rapidly behind closed eyelids.
“It feels… deserved." When he looks at Hannibal again, the desperation and doubt has disappeared. Will’s eyes glint now in muted delight. “The same as it did with Clarke Ingram.” Hannibal’s lips twitch. He’d predicted such an answer.
“And the third man?” he prompts. At this, Will turns quiet. Hannibal leans forward a fraction across the table. Will’s hand is within arm’s reach; his middle finger twitches as a tremor passes through him, reflecting his mental stress. Hannibal’s eyes drill into Will’s soul in search of gold. “His face was obscured to me, as was his voice. Tell me Will, do you have any idea who he might be?”
“I know it has all the hallmarks of an Obliviate Charm. It's like someone got inside my head and moved all the furniture around.” Will’s eyes narrow at Hannibal—but his accusatory tone is an obvious distraction. Will is avoiding the meat of the matter, choosing to answer the ‘how’, and not the ‘who’.
“A disconcerting thought," says Hannibal, tilting his head. "Then again, have you considered that forgetting may have been in your best interests? Such a memory would be difficult to live with."
A choked laugh answers.
“Yeah well—I’m pretty sure ‘living with it’ wasn’t part of the plan.”
The temperature in the clearing seems to plunge to sub-zero. Hannibal remains statuesque, holding Will's gaze.
“No,” he agrees softly. “It would seem not.” The unexpected warmth thaws Will’s defences. He endures the residual sting, like salt burning through snow. Will sinks into the chair, chin dropping to his chest, curls falling forward into his eyes.
“Hannibal," he begins. "... I think I killed us.”
The silence is suddenly deafening.
Hannibal finally reaches across the table to bridge the gap, thumb stroking the back of Will’s hand. Will twitches violently, as though bracing for the ragged kiss of a linoleum knife instead. Hannibal has certainly considered it. He’s spent many nights these past months turning the empty vial of Will’s memories over in his hands, and the problem over in his mind. Self-destructive thoughts posing as solutions tempted him, veiled in questionable logic, corrupted by emotion. 1 + 1= 2. An eye for an eye.
‘You and I are stuck in a zero-sum game.’
Will’s hand turns over unprompted in his grasp, offering up his vulnerable inner wrist. Hannibal’s fingertips land above his quickening pulse. The dark blue vein is exposed and stark, pulsing beneath his touch. Looking into Will’s eyes, he can still taste the grindylow’s blood at the back of his throat. Hannibal swallows. He presses down on the vein as if trying to keep it closed, deadly-soft hands that once promised exsanguination repurposed as a tourniquet. One cannot solve an equation with a missing constant.
“Do you remember who this man was to you?” Hannibal intones. Will raises his eyes. They shine in a way that Hannibal cannot quite explain; some glimmer of certainty discovered amongst the murky depths.
“I know he loved me.” A pause. “I loved him too.” As their gazes lock, a vision flashes through Hannibal’s mind: two blood-soaked wolves dressed in human skin embracing catastrophe, falling off the edge of the world.
We never belonged there anyway.
Hannibal shifts his grip, fingers threading loosely through Will’s.
“Love is one of the oldest forms of magic there is." The intimate words do not have the desired effect. Will cringes at the sickly-sweet expression, snatching back his hand and folding his arms.
“Please,” he scorns, looking away.
“There you go again, doubting my sincerity,” Hannibal scolds. “If this vision is a memory that somebody wanted you to forget, something gave you the power to resist. The love you feel for this man may be the answer; it may be the source of your other visions too.”
“My other visions are all of you,” Will counters, strangled. His grip on the teacup is trembling precariously, searching Hannibal’s face for a confirmation he doesn’t truly need—because deep down they both know. Why else be so afraid to show Hannibal the truth? Why the fear of retaliation?
It was you who I killed, wasn’t it?
Hannibal opens his mouth to answer, when suddenly a shadow moves in their peripheral vision, accompanied by rustling feathers and a spark of fire. They both look over.
Vesta is perched on Mischa’s grave.
Will’s jaw goes slack. The teacup slips from his grip, smashing to the ground. Cursing his clumsiness, he bends to pick up the pieces, flinching when a porcelain shard cuts his palm. Will freezes when Hannibal places a hand on his shoulder.
“It’s alright, Will." The quiet promise is accompanied by a gentle squeeze. Hannibal kneels beside Will in the dirt with napkin in hand. They work together to gather up the shards under Vesta’s watchful eye. Will’s muscles are tense, glancing at the phoenix out of the corner of his eye.
“She seems to have taken a liking to you,” he mutters. “First a feather, now this.” Hannibal looks up for a moment. The bird does seem to be staring at him.
“Phoenixes are intelligent, curious creatures. I’ve read several magizoologist texts on the topic,” Hannibal murmurs as they work. “They are described as symbols of life itself; as bright and enduring as the sun. After Mischa’s death, I spent some time looking into their regenerative properties for potion-making. I considered experimenting with her tissue samples.”
“You mean like… regrow her?” Will looks up in alarm, brows knitted together. “Would she still be your sister if you did that?”
“A wise question,” Hannibal agrees. “I asked myself the very same and found I could not answer in good conscience. That’s why I settled on the time-turner.”
“Is that any better?” Will wonders aloud, eyes downcast. “Changing history... creating new versions of events... new versions of people. You’re still playing god.” Their fingers brush as they both reach for the same shard, making Will flinch.
“What else is magic for, Will, if not to attempt the work of the divine?”
To that, Will has no answer.
Together, they manage to gather up every last piece. The shards are laid out on the table in front of them. Hannibal spots his counterpart’s guilt-stricken look.
“I told you, it’s alright,” he repeats. Will grimaces.
“But wasn’t that Mischa’s cup? I didn’t mean any disrespect.” Hannibal holds up a hand to hush him. He draws his wand and points it at the broken fragments with calm determination.
“Reparo.”
With a quiet crackling noise, the cup reforms; jagged shards slot back into place like pieces of a puzzle, fault lines resealing and vanishing. Will watches with an inexplicable lump in his throat as a teddy bear’s shorn face is made whole. Hannibal, on the other hand, is watching with a nostalgic smile.
‘Sometimes I drop a teacup to shatter on the floor. On purpose. I’m not satisfied when it doesn’t gather itself up again.’
“What?” Will rasps, seeing Hannibal’s peculiar expression.
“I was admiring how easily the cup comes together,” he answers simply, giving Will a long, searching look. “Magic is a true miracle, wouldn’t you agree Will? We just use it so often, we forget how fortunate we are. You and I could easily have been born into a crueller, far less forgiving world. One where the teacup stays shattered.”
“… A universe without magic, you mean.”
Hannibal looks across to Vesta who still hasn’t moved. Emboldened, he takes hold of Will’s hand, slotting their fingers together. They turn together to face the phoenix. Hannibal can feel the trepidation in Will’s touch, afraid of scaring Vesta off. Afraid of making a mistake. Afraid of losing something precious all over again.
“I have a thought experiment for you, Will: what do you think would happen if a wizard were to interfere in such a world—such as to save a life?” he poses, tugging Will forward lightly.
“Like, if you came across two men falling off a cliff, you mean?” A shaky laugh escapes Will’s twisted lips. They take another step towards Vesta. “Well, assuming said wizard somehow found a way to cross entire universes, I’d guess nothing good. The use of magic would create an anomaly. Hell, everyone involved could die.”
“That’s one possibility,” Hannibal acknowledges. He changes his grip, letting go of Will’s hand and taking his waist from behind instead. The pressure at Will’s back is light but resolute, steering him forward. He shivers as Hannibal’s breath tickles the shell of his ear. “Or, like the phoenix, perhaps they would rise again from the ashes, perfect and shining. The chance for a brand-new life in a brand-new world.” The pair stop just short of the grave marker. Vesta is very nearly within arm’s reach, showing no signs of flight.
“You’re quite the optimist,” Will says at last. The scale of such a paradox would be absurd: be doomed to die in one world, in order to live happily-ever-after in another.
“I’d say you’re too much of a pessimist,” Hannibal counters lightly. He drops his chin onto Will’s shoulder; feels him shudder under his touch and lean back, allowing Hannibal to lift his arm and guide his actions like a marionette. The whisper in Will’s ear sounds like a prayer: “I stole that time-turner with the aim of saving Mischa’s life… maybe my efforts were not entirely in vain. I said before that nobody truly understands the limitations of time magic, didn’t I?”
Finally, Will’s rough fingers connect with Vesta’s gleaming feathers. The warmth rends a sob from his chest. They stay like that a while, in no hurry to ruin the moment. Vesta's chest rumbles, pleased, as the herbologist’s rough fingers pass over her plumage with reverence. Hannibal joins in, letting the minutes pass. His watch tells him it’s long past business hours, but he has no intention of leaving. Not this time.
Vesta is eventually bold enough to hop onto Will’s offered arm, allowing him to stroke the sensitive, downy feathers on her head. He thinks nothing of it when Hannibal takes his free hand, but startles when he feels water droplets falling onto his cut palm. Vesta’s head is tilted, tears leaking from the corner of her eyes. Rather than irritating, the salty droplets cleanse and close the wound, broken skin knitting together. Will’s shoulders sag with relief. With the right tools, forgiveness doesn’t have to be hard.
“Before you, and after you.” The words are so quiet, Hannibal almost misses them. He frowns in puzzlement. Will twists his head, not quite looking him in the eye. “Where the difference between the past and future comes from… Remember?”
And just like that, Hannibal does:
The sacred stillness of an empty gallery. A place beyond the touch of time, where beautiful things are immortalised, and the hours slip by like grains of falling sand. The quiet scratching of pencil on parchment stalling at the approach of hesitant footsteps. Faces marred by twin wounds like two halves of a butterfly’s wings. Hushed words and longing glances. No witnesses save for the painted faces on the wall. An unspoken prayer:
‘Please don’t leave again.’
In the here and now, surrounded by flowers of glass and all manner of impossible things, Hannibal brushes a thumb across Will’s unblemished cheek. He doesn’t need a sacrifice—not when he’s already been granted a miracle. Their lips touch. A taste of absolution.
You found me, once again.
“Stay with me.” Will breathes the words into Hannibal’s lungs, stolen from some other once-upon-a-time. Hannibal smiles against his mouth, unshed tears clinging to his lashes. He locks eyes with Vesta over Will’s shoulder, who has found her place again on his sister's grave. For a moment, he is certain Mischa is looking back at him from within.
Time didn’t quite reverse. A different cup came together than the one he’d originally intended—but maybe that’s just fine. Hannibal buries his face against Will’s neck, the feather in his breast pocket thrumming with warmth against their beating hearts. He didn’t know it back then, but this is all he’s ever wanted. For both of them.
“Always.”
The End
Notes:
Yay, second multi-chapter work completed~ Thank you so much to everyone who subscribed/kudosed/commented, I hope you enjoyed it! <3 If you were waiting until the end to leave your thoughts, it would be lovely to hear them!
I’ve commissioned some artwork for this fic, which I’ll be including in the near future. If you’re subscribed, I recommend staying subbed for the update!
Reminder, there is a graph here explaining the timey-wimey: Click Me
Per the circular graph, Will and Han being reborn is a paradox/contradiction in the natural order; it shouldn't be possible for them to die in one universe (which is needed to inspire teenage Han to save them with the time-turner) and also be living happily in another. AND YET, MAGIC.A huge thank you to Aomimi for helping me out with the HP herbology knowledge here, she writes for the Hannibal fandom too, please check out her works!
Some terminology/mildly interesting notes:
Magizoologist: wizard equivalent of zoologist/vet, specialising in magical creatures.
Burning Day: the day a phoenix becomes too old and has to regenerate its aging body by bursting into flames. Some myths say their lifespan is directly linked to the life of the sun.
Phoenixes in HP are really interesting, not only can they regenerate as described but they are also capable of carrying heavy loads, and their tears have healing powers.
Will’s wand is made of hawthorn with phoenix feather core, hawthorn being symbolic of spring and new beginnings. Phoenix feather cores are known for producing the greatest range of magic but can be unpredictable/have a mind of their own.
The ending line is a callback to Snape from HP (*cries*)
I was inspired to write this fic by the song ‘Everything Goes On’ by Porter Robinson: “Will you meet me in the daylight like we did before? Then I felt you on my shoulder, and you weren’t suffering anymore. You said ‘I’m sorry that you worried’ but don’t apologise. I told you to forget me, but you stayed by my side.”
Thanks again for your support!
Chapter 6: Fanart
Notes:
Hi guys! As promised, artwork by the wonderfully talented Ani, @Sahti_Waari on Twitter/X, AKA: @louhetar on Tumblr. Follow the link to their profile here: LINK
Thank you so much for your hard work on this piece, it's gorgeous <3 Please take a couple of minutes to check out their works and show them some love, you won't be disappointed!
Chapter Text
