Actions

Work Header

Reparo

Chapter 5: Reparo

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Three months pass before Hannibal steps into the fireplace in his practice with blue powder in hand, ready to confront Will Graham in his home. Calm, determined, he gives the order: “Evergreen Galley”, and the crackling cobalt flames carry him away.  

Before he even opens his eyes, Hannibal is hit by the sound of crashing waves, violent wind, and the scent of sea salt. For a second, he’s convinced he’s back in the pensieve, about to be confronted by a vision of consummation and betrayal. When his eyes are no longer stinging with ash and smoke, Hannibal opens them, and realises with no small relief that he is wrong. He appears to have materialised inside a firepit on the top deck of a small, one-man boat.

Well, Will did call it a ‘galley’, Hannibal reasons, stepping carefully out of the coals and making a sweeping assessment of his surroundings. The vessel itself has seen better days. The paint is peeling, safety railings rusted through. Hannibal sincerely hopes there aren’t holes in the keel beneath. As for the man himself, Hannibal is disappointed that Will Graham is nowhere to be found. Only the overcast grey sky and the biting wind of the North Sea is present to greet him. The lack of security is surprising, but then again, Will doesn’t need to worry about intruders; living on a boat outside territorial waters, Will is beyond Ministry jurisdiction. Even if the powers-that-be did take an interest in him, his private Floo Network is the perfect defence. Will has made sure that nobody can drop in on him unannounced. Hannibal is privately impressed by his cunning. Now, if only he could express his admiration personally.

Fastened to the railing with twine is a hand-painted sign, directing customers to head below deck for service. Scouring the floor, Hannibal spies a nearby hatch. With a simple Alohamora to pick the lock, the hatch pops open, revealing a metal ladder. Peering over the edge, Hannibal cannot easily determine its height; the rungs disappear into a leafy green canopy, making it impossible to see the bottom. Hannibal decides to cast Epoximise to make his fingers sticky with adhesive before attempting the climb. Slowly, carefully, he descends.

When he breaks through the canopy, Hannibal understands where the 'Evergreen' in the address came from. He momentarily questions if he's on a boat, or in a jungle. The vast atrium below deck is teeming with life, tangy sea salt replaced by the fragrant aroma of sweet flowers and leafy green plants. Will must have cast an impressive Extension Charm to fit it all in.

The artificial roof has the appearance of glass, with a retractable screen to allow for as much or little light as desired. The floor is carpeted with moss, and climbing plants cover the walls: honeysuckle, clematis, and lobelia. As he descends through the foliage, Hannibal spots a shy bowtruckle camouflaged amongst the leaves, similar in appearance to an overgrown muggle stick-insect; an ideal natural method of pest-control. Busy bees and brightly coloured butterflies flit between the flowerheads. Hannibal is glad for the Epoximise when a monstrously large dragonfly zips past his face, translucent wings glittering like stained glass.

If there are dragonflies here, there must be a water source nearby. Sure enough, he spies a pond off to the side, the water's surface disguised by lily pads. Most intriguingly, a dirt path cuts through the centre of the room, leading to a thicket of hardy evergreens at the back. Thick tree trunks stand in solidarity, branches tickling the ceiling, partially blocking out the light. It is impossible to tell just how deep they go.

It's all very beautiful—save for the rickety workbench bearing Will's tools, covered in scratches and scorch marks. The table legs are taped together with reams of spellotape, looking like it might fall over at any moment. Hannibal wrinkles his nose at the eyesore. He has a mind to repair it properly, wondering why Will hasn't done so.  

Hannibal finally reaches the bottom of the ladder. He’s itching to explore, but doesn’t even make it one step before a warning growl sounds at his feet.

Hannibal turns around, and finds a small dog eerily similar in appearance to a Jack Russel Terrier, with small ears, a pointed face, and a cute white spot on its chest. The only thing that gives it away as magical is its forked tail. Hannibal recognises it as a crup—a wizard-bred dog, known for its preference for purebloods—but this one doesn’t look exactly welcoming. Its hackles are raised, canines bared. Hannibal pulls out his wand in readiness, wishing it had occurred to him to come armed with a few slices of ‘salami’. If this animal belongs to Will, he would prefer to avoid injuring it. 

Unfortunately, Hannibal soon discovers that Will Graham is quite the dog lover. Agitated barking fills the air, all slightly different cadences. Hannibal braces himself as another six crups burst onto the scene, claws sliding on the mossy ground in haste. Emboldened by its pack mates, the white-spotted dog lunges for Hannibal's ankle, just as the wizard raises his wand in defence.

Just in the nick of time, a wide-eyed Will rounds the corner. He’s looking decidedly worse for wear compared to their last encounter, back to his oversized jackets, patched jeans, and scuffed boots. The gardening gloves are a new addition, as are the protective earmuffs around his neck. Will places a finger to his lips and lets out a sharp whistle. At their master’s call, the pack stops attacking. All seven dogs bound over to Will and sit obediently at his feet, tails thumping in excitement. Will kneels beside them, offering soothing strokes.

“Hey, calm down you guys. He’s a friend,” Will scolds.

A ‘friend’, is it? Hannibal raises an eyebrow, wondering how Will greets his enemies.

Will is turned away from him, busy quieting his pets, but Hannibal spots him keeping one eye on him at all times. Most of the dogs have quietened down, but the one with the white spot can’t resist snarling. Will’s tone sharpens.

“No, Buster.” The little dog whines and sits back on its haunches. Hannibal notices that Will is wearing his broken glasses again, seemingly unable to meet his eyes. There is a familiar tension in the air too. It feels like their first meeting in the Forbidden Forest all over again—like they’ve taken one step forward and two steps back. “Sorry about that," Will offers. "I don’t know what’s got into them. They’ve never attacked a customer before.”

“Crups are fiercely loyal guard dogs. They will instinctively attack any perceived threat to their master’s wellbeing. Perhaps they can tell I am not merely a customer,” Hannibal suggests.

Will tenses, finally looking properly in Hannibal’s direction. His fellow wizard hasn’t moved, but his wand is still drawn. The seconds drag on, both men remembering the circumstances of their last parting: the innocuous silver vial containing a vision of betrayal. An unspoken question flickers in Will’s eyes:

Are you a threat?

After a moment’s consideration, Hannibal kneels upon the mossy floor and sets down his wand. His head is bowed in an uncharacteristic display of deference. Seizing the opportunity, one of the crups bounds forward and snatches up Hannibal's wand between its teeth, delivering it into Will’s lap. Hannibal dies a little inside, seeing his precious wand being treated like a stick in a game of fetch.

“Good boy Winston,” Will praises, patting the dog’s head. With Hannibal disarmed, the other dogs relax, jumping over one another for Will’s attention. The herbologist chuckles, trying to pet them all at once.

“May I come in now?” Hannibal prompts with the merest trace of irritation. Will peers at the kneeling wizard over the top of his glasses, holding Hannibal’s wand as gently as a newborn babe. They both know whose heartstring it contains. Hannibal waits with his head bowed, hoping this gesture of trust will convince Will he means no harm. It works.

“… You may.” Permission granted, Hannibal rises to his feet with as much dignity as he can muster. There is an awkward moment where neither speaks. Will half-opens his mouth, on the verge of addressing the elephant in the pensieve... but changes his mind at the last second. He turns away abruptly, nodding for Hannibal to follow him. “Come on. I’ll give you the grand tour.”

The herbologist leads Hannibal through the atrium, pointing out the various plants and their usages. With his guest being an accomplished potions master, Will draws Hannibal’s attention to the newly replanted mandrakes sprouting from a nearby vegetable bed.

That explains the earmuffs, Hannibal thinks with a wry smile. The plants look deceptively innocent just from looking at the leaves, their wailing roots that can strike a man dead at twenty paces silenced by the earth. Will is in his element, lecturing with intensity on his area of expertise. Hannibal suspects his loquaciousness is partly because of nerves, but it’s still nice to see him in such an animated state. They fall into step with ease, despite the parade of Leaping Toadstools that try to trip them underfoot. The little crups quickly take care of them, scattering the fungi with their chomping maws and excitable barks, forked tails wagging. Their very illegal forked tails.

“I can’t help but notice the standard severing charm hasn’t been applied to your dogs,” Hannibal interjects as Will pauses for breath midway through a spiel on wolfsbane and its many uses. The herbologist stalls mid-step, thrown by the observation. Hannibal smiles that faint, enigmatic smile of his.  “Are they perhaps unregistered like their owner?”

All crups are required by wizarding law to undergo the painless amputation procedure, to avoid attracting muggle attention. For Will’s dogs to still have their tails can only mean one thing: the Ministry doesn’t know they exist. Will swallows, hands clenching at his side. 

“They were going to be destroyed.”Hannibal detects the rumble of anger in Will’s voice that promises an oncoming storm. “They were bred for an underground fighting ring for magical beasts. When the Ministry got wind, they swooped in and shut the place down. It was thought they couldn’t be rehabilitated. Thankfully, I know a guy in the Department for the Regulation and Control of Magical Creatures. He’s a regular of mine—managed to smuggle them out.”

“How admirable.” Hannibal’s praise is sincere. “I imagine it took a significant amount of work.” Will’s eyes slide up to meet his, a spark of determination igniting within.

“I’m not afraid of a little hard work.”

Case in point, the Venomous Tentacular in the corner needs no introduction. Will catches Hannibal’s wary expression and grins, remembering their previous conversation.

“The seeds are one of my best sellers. Worth every second of pain.”

“Yes, I expect your prices are extremely attractive,” Hannibal concurs dryly. Venomous Tentacular seeds are a controlled substance. On the open market they cost a pretty penny; being unlicensed, Will doesn’t need to bother with pesky little details like paying taxes. His competitors must be thrilled.

“I’ll give you a free sample if you help me extract them,” Will proposes, a mischievous twinkle in his eye. Hannibal shoots him a withering look.

“As tempting as the offer is, I’m afraid I must decline.”

“That’s a shame,” Will sighs, as they reach the edge of the pond. He bends down, gesturing for Hannibal to follow suit. “Then, how about a swim instead?” Will gestures to an underwater plant with ugly tendrils floating on the surface that look an awful lot like rats’ tails.

“Gillyweed? I didn’t think it grew in cold climates.” Hannibal peers closer, dipping his fingers into the pond water and fondling the rubbery texture.

“It’s usually endemic to the Mediterranean; I’ve been breeding a hardier sub-type. You could grow this in your garden back home in Lithuania.” Will cocks his head in curiosity. “Ever tried it?”

 “The prospect of sprouting gills and flippers never appealed to me,” Hannibal smiles wanly. “Should I ever feel the burning desire to breathe underwater, I shall cast a simple Bubble-Head Charm.”

“Simple, is it?” Will rolls his eyes. “The Bubble-Head Charm is a N.E.W.T level spell. Not many witches and wizards can be trusted to cast it. Do you know how many decapitations there are each year?”

They are so caught up in their banter, they don’t notice the surface of the pond ripple, until something shoots out of the water and latches onto Will’s ankle. Hannibal isn’t quick enough as the rug is pulled from under him. Will falls flat on his face, yanked backwards into the water. He tries to fight, scrabbling fingers ripping up chunks of moss from the floor, exposing the dull shine of the metal hull beneath. It’s not enough. Will hits the water with a loud splash, their wands flying out of the inner pocket of his jacket and sinking to the bottom of the pond.

So much for the Bubble-Head Charm.

Hannibal doesn’t think twice. He shucks his suit jacket and kicks off his shoes, tearing off a small sprig of gillyweed and shoving the rubbery tubers into his mouth. Then he dives straight in after Will.  

Once he’s underwater, it takes a few seconds for Hannibal to adjust. Breathing water doesn’t exactly feel natural. Hannibal gingerly touches the gill flaps on his neck, catching sight of his webbed hands in the process. His feet are even worse; it looks as though he’s wearing flippers. He dreads to think what people would say if they saw him like this; there would be more than a few tasteless jokes about pureblood inbreeding. Will would have a field day.

Speaking of Will…

Hannibal detects a disturbance in the water; a false current caused by gasping breaths and thrashing limbs. He turns to find Will some feet away, struggling to dislodge the creature glued like a limpet to his leg. It looks like a deformed octopus with a humanoid upper half, cursed with a leering mouth that stretches from ear to ear, filled with razor sharp teeth. Hannibal recognises it as a grindylow—a common water demon prevalent to the British Isles. He looks down, but sees no sign of their wands. By now, they must be half-buried in the bed of silt below… which means he’ll have to do this the old-fashioned way.

Break its grip, Hannibal thinks, zeroing in on the squid-like arms wrapped around Will’s legs, binding him tighter than Devil’s Snare. Hannibal closes the distance in three powerful strokes. Saliva fills his mouth, lips peeling back to reveal glinting teeth. Without a wand, Hannibal is reliant on the element of surprise.

He dodges the grindylow’s tentacle that tries to snag his wrist, catching hold of it in his hands. Grindylows are renowned for their strength, but Hannibal is no slouch in that department either. He lunges forward and bites down, hard.  The sensation feels eerily familiar: incisors sinking into a man’s neck, vocal cords snapping like violin strings, collecting his pound of flesh. The grindylow’s arm rends free, purple blood expelled around Hannibal in a dark cloud,  its iron grip broken. Just like that, Will Graham is free.

Will kicks up for the surface, his lungs screaming for air. Enraged to see its prey escaping, the grindylow tries to make chase, but Hannibal is having none of it. He grabs it by the head and pulls back its neck, the satisfying snap of bones and tendons reverberating through his fingers. The grindylow goes limp.

Now he just needs to retrieve their wands.

Scanning the pond bed, Hannibal spots more grindylows hidden amongst the weeds. He dives down to meet them, red eyes daring them to try it twice. They gnash their teeth but keep their distance, scenting their brother’s blood on him. After a bit of digging, Hannibal finds their wands nestled in a rocky crevice. He carefully wipes off the layer of silt; this is his first time seeing Will’s wand up close. At an educated guess, the wood appears to be hawthorn... as for the core, Hannibal has no idea. He tests the grip, struck by how warm it feels in his hand. The wand seems to be radiating heat, staving off the chill of the water seeping into his bones.

What are you? Hannibal wonders, turning it over in his hand. Unfortunately, now is not the time for academic musings. Having swallowed a deliberately small mouthful, the gillyweed is due to wear off any minute. Hannibal can already feel his gills twinging in warning.  

When he resurfaces, Hannibal finds Will lying flat on his back on the mossy bank, shivering and gasping. His pants and shirt are both ripped from the grindylow’s assault, and his cracked glasses are nowhere to be seen, likely at the bottom of the pond. Buster, Winston and the other crups are gathered around, tails wagging in concern. Hannibal hauls himself out of the pool and collapses beside Will, looking quite literally like a fish out of water with his webbed hands and feet. Just when he thinks the situation can’t possibly get any more undignified, one of the crups decides to lick his face off. Will splutters with laughter as Hannibal fends off the energetic Winston.

“Your home is proving rather more hazardous than I was expecting, Will,” Hannibal bites out, holding Winston at arm’s length. It’s a small mercy that his gills and flippers are shrinking on schedule, but the wet clothes clinging to his skin are doing little to improve his mood. It must be even worse for Will: the soaked rags he’s wearing can barely be considered ‘clothes’ at all. "Aren’t you going to fix that?” Hannibal prompts, gesturing to his tattered shirt and pants. Will flushes in embarrassment.

”I would, but I—er—can’t.”

”Meaning?”

“Meaning, I have a certain… talent for breaking things. Wish I could say the same about mending them.” Will shivers, pulling the frayed remnants around his shoulders with a scowl. Hannibal looks towards the pond, where Will's shoddy spectacles are lost to the depths. He pictures the splintered bookshelf in his office following Will's visit, the questionable seaworthiness of their current vessel, and the rickety workbench that has seen better days. The crunch of Clark Ingram’s bones echoes from years past.

“May I request a demonstration?” Hannibal cocks his head, never one to deny his curiosity. Will sighs and points his wand at his torn jeans.

“Reparo.” There is a weak sizzle from the wand, like rain droplets landing on embers. Nothing happens. He fixes Hannibal with a dull stare.  

”There. Satisfied?” Will’s negativity garners a frown; his attitude at odds with the flourishing fauna and fantastic beasts that surround them.

“You claim a talent for destruction, but in your work, you dedicate yourself to the preservation of life." Hannibal nods to the rescued crups, keeping his tone deliberately light. “Making up for past errors, perhaps?” Will stares at him, not knowing what to say. Hannibal doesn’t push for an answer. He picks up his elm wand and gestures to Will's clothes in request. “Allow me?” Realising he's lost the advantage of being the only armed man in the room, Will hesitates. The Veritaserum incident is still fresh in his mind. Hannibal frowns, reproachful. “Do you really think I would go to such lengths to save your life, only to curse you?”

“Yes,” Will mutters. Hannibal’s lips quirk; it is impossible to tell whether from amusement or displeasure.

“That sort of doubt between friends can lead to unfortunate accidents.”

Before Will can say ‘no’, Hannibal has already conjured him a fresh button-down shirt and jeans, and drained the excess water from their clothes. Ignoring Will’s glare, Hannibal turns his attention to the lifeless grindylow oozing blood on the mossy bank.

“Well, it looks like dinner plans for tonight are set,” he declares, sealing the creature inside a see-through container filled with pondwater to keep it fresh. Will gives him a deadpan look.

“You’re not serious.”

“Whyever not?” Hannibal queries, rapping the tank with the tip of his wand. “Grindylow meat is considered a rare delicacy in some parts of the world.”

“Presumably you’re aware the Ministry has marked them as unfit for human consumption?” 

“Because they sometimes consume humans themselves, yes.” Hannibal shoots him a wicked smile with purple-stained teeth. “Lesson learned: never give one’s food the opportunity to bite back.”

“You should have that printed on a t-shirt,” Will snarks. Hannibal throws him a sharp look.

“Forgive me for being blunt, Will, but you’re in no position to be pointing fingers. Your dogs aside, Grindylows are classified as dark creatures by the Ministry. The fact you’re keeping them at all is a breach of regulation.”

“They’re good for the PH balance,” Will defends. Hannibal raises a placating hand.

“I wasn’t making an accusation. I was merely highlighting that neither of us are the type to be held back by a little red tape.”

It’s an uncomfortable truth. Will lowers his gaze and shoves his hands in his jacket pockets. Hannibal picks up the grindylow container by the handle, the two of them continuing down the winding path. Hannibal senses Will’s swirling thoughts, trusting that silence is often more effective than speech. He is soon proven correct.

“I tried playing by the rules, you know. Once upon a time,” Will says suddenly. The admission is clearly difficult, words sticking in his throat. “But I’ve come to accept I’m too malleable to stick to any defined sense of right and wrong. Too curious for any ideals.”

“God Himself doesn’t seem to place much stock in ideals,” Hannibal notes with a half-smile, looking to the dead grindylow in the tank. “Typhoid and swans; grindylows and fairies—it all comes from the same place.”  Will follows his gaze to the tank and sighs.

“I should’ve fed them last night. It wouldn’t have attacked us if it wasn’t hungry.”

“Feeling guilty?” Hannibal asks mildly. 

“Let me think: do I feel guilty for not letting a grindylow drown and eat me? No, Hannibal.” Will rolls his eyes. “I’m just saying it could have been avoided.”

“Forgiveness comes easily to you,” Hannibal notes, recalling how Will had cried for him so readily in the pensieve. His voice drops a note. “You assess motive absent any pre-existing notions of morality. You look, and you understand… It’s a quality I admire in you.”

They soon pass over the mossy threshold, swallowed by evergreen trees. The crups hang back on the forest edge when Will tells them to wait. He promises he’ll be back soon, but the dogs still whine in protest as their master disappears further into shadow and dappled light. Hannibal breathes deep, the scent of pine filling his lungs. In the quiet of the forest, every sound is amplified to his ears; the snapping of twigs beneath his polished shoes, Will crunching through the detritus in muddy boots with glued soles. Hannibal is struck then by just how different they are… different, and yet, adaptable. Hannibal seldom visits the forest when there isn’t bloodletting involved, but he finds himself enjoying the calm atmosphere; idly observing the changing light as it hits the leaves, soothed by the distant sound of running water. There must be a stream somewhere nearby. It isn’t quite the same as being serenaded by the genius of Bach or Mozart, but it’s still pleasing on the ear. Hannibal could get used to this, just as he is certain Will could adapt to him. He imagines how beautiful Will would look on his arm at the Royal Opera House: tuxedo freshly pressed, beard trimmed and brown curls shining, a dab of vanilla fragrance just behind the ear where Hannibal could subtly breathe him in. They would canvas the crowd, making polite conversation both magical and mundane, knowing their hands will be stained red by the dawn.

“How about you, then?” Will prompts, cutting through the quiet. “What’s your position on forgiveness?”

“Where the sin is against me, the appropriate restitution depends on the gravity,” Hannibal answers. Naturally, he tailors the answer to himself. Hannibal isn’t interested in abstract moral philosophising on the problem of suffering and the failings of the human condition. He is only concerned with purging the ugliness that dares to affront his own eyes. A dagger in the back. A fall from a cliff. A lovers’ suicide with an unwary participant. Will looks to the dead grindylow in the container and sees himself reflected in the glass. 

“An eye for an eye is your moral imperative, then?” he grinds out.

“Short of undoing what has been done, it is the only effective palate cleanser.”  

“Undoing what has been done… turn back time, you mean?” The words are spoken in jest, but there is a tense note beneath the tease.

“If only it were possible,” Hannibal muses with convincing longing. “Life would be much simpler if we were all born with a personal time-turner. In such a world, there would be no need for forgiveness.” His words must taste offensive because Will is suddenly grimacing like he’s bitten straight into a lemon.

 “But without consequences, we’d never grow. Our personalities, our beliefs, would be the same from the cradle to the grave. We’d keep making the same mistakes; failing to communicate. Inflicting the same wounds over and over.” The melancholy murmur is accompanied by a subtle movement through the trees. Hannibal spots a trio of thestrals watching them with moonstone eyes. Death is stalking them yet again.

“Then perhaps the ideal solution would be to start afresh, but to remember something of the lessons that came before,” Hannibal suggests carefully. Will runs his tongue across his bottom lip, apparently finding this proposal far more palatable.

“That would be the ideal.”

As Hannibal predicted, they turn the corner and come to a bubbling brook. The pair walk along the bank, enjoying the tranquil sight and sound of water trickling over rock. On the other side of the stream, Hannibal spies a makeshift camp. There is a hammock erected next to a firepit, with a primitive rotisserie rack fashioned out of wood. His keen nose detects the faint trace of smoke hanging in the air—most likely from Will’s breakfast that morning. A set of handmade fishing rods are propped against a nearby tree trunk, washing line strung between the branches. Hannibal knows it is a washing line because of the garments pegged to the twine that can only belong to Will: several plaid flannel shirts, faded jeans at different stages of wear and tear, and several pairs of boxer shorts. Realising he’s yet to see a single normal room in this place, Hannibal has the sinking feeling he’s looking at Will’s bedroom and kitchen. On his part, Will doesn’t seem remotely embarrassed by his crude living arrangements, or the fact his underwear is on proud display in front of a guest. Hannibal is far too polite to comment on it. Instead, he opts for the diplomatic approach.

“Will, may I ask, why a forest?” The wizard in question chuckles, gesturing back the way they came.  

“The nursery back there is for the needier plants and creatures. Some species prefer solitude.” Will points to the trees above. Hannibal follows his gaze, eyes widening when he spots a distinctive flash of red amongst the greenery. Will places his fingers to his lips and lets out a low, enticing whistle, trying to coax the bird out of hiding. It works… sort of.

Hannibal’s breath stalls as the magical creature emerges from the cover of the trees, scarlet and gold plumage glowing like embers. Unfortunately, it doesn’t look best pleased to see them. The bird’s feathers are puffed up in an obvious threat display. It makes an odd clicking noise in its throat; the avian equivalent of a growl.  

“Hey, Vesta,” Will ventures. His soft tone fails to placate as intended. As Vesta’s wings unfurl, it feels like all the moisture has been sucked from the cool forest air, her feathers radiating searing heat. Will sighs and draws his wand. It seems he’s done this many times before.

“Protego.” The shield materialises around them just in time before they are showered in flaming sparks. By the time the onslaught is over, the legendary creature is nowhere to be seen. The only proof she was ever there are the scorch marks on the ground, and the single, scarlet feather resting on the forest floor. It takes Hannibal a few moments to find his voice.

“That was a phoenix.” The awe in his voice is matched by the wonder in his eyes. Will dips his head, scratching the back of his neck.

“Yes, it was. Like I said, her name’s Vesta.” Will is smiling, but there is a pained edge to it. “Not that she remembers it anymore. Or me.” Seeing Hannibal’s enquiring look, Will elaborates. “I rescued her, years ago. Shortly after I was expelled, I needed some time to think, so I ended up doing a tour of the States. I took odd jobs that paid cash-in-hand; wound up as an assistant in a magical menagerie. That’s where I found Vesta.” Will stops short, mouth twisting into a grimace. Hannibal can only guess the living conditions in such a place. “She has a neurological disorder, similar to Alzheimer’s in humans. It causes loss of memory and poor impulse control. She was becoming too much for her previous owners to handle; started attacking paying customers. They decided to cut their losses and sell her to the highest bidder. Nobody claimed her… so I claimed her.”  Hannibal’s already thin eyebrows threaten to disappear into his hairline. He’s never heard of a phoenix suffering from such an affliction. Their lifecycle is one of decay and renewal, their aging bodies devoured by flame at the point of death, only to be reborn from the ashes.

“She doesn’t rejuvenate on Burning Day?” he queries.

“The body yes... but not the mind.” Will looks to the scorch marks on the forest floor, swallowing thickly. “Most days, she doesn’t even acknowledge me. She looks straight through me, past me like I’m—like I’m just a stranger.”

“Our memories are our identity. It’s a terrible thing, to have your identity taken from you, whether by the cruel hand of Mother Nature or Man.” Hannibal bends to pick up the fallen feather, examining it with a pensive expression. “Tell me Will, were you compelled to rescue Vesta because you felt you had something in common with her?”

“Perhaps,” Will snarks, turning to self-deprecation to hide his discomfort. “Two broken minds struggling to navigate the shifting sands of reality. Guess we were made for each other.”

“Broken things can be repaired,” Hannibal says quietly, running his fingers along the precious feather. He can sense the limitless lifeforce sparking through the vanes and barbs, unpredictable and overflowing with potential. He’ll be adding this to his potions stock when he returns.

“I wouldn’t if I were you.” Confused by the interjection, Hannibal turns to Will. The other is holding up his imperfect, handcrafted wand, wearing a lopsided smile. “I know what you’re thinking Hannibal, but take it from me, you won’t get the results you expect.” Hannibal’s stares. At last, the puzzle pieces click.

9-inch hawthorn with a phoenix feather core.

In professional wandmaking, wand cores are harvested from magical creatures in the peak of health. As far as Hannibal knows, there is no precedent for this: an amateur wizard crafting a handmade wand with a core donated from a sickly phoenix.

No wonder he struggles with basic repair charms, Hannibal muses. The beast who gave Will's wand a heart can’t even repair herself. Still, he slides the feather into his suit pocket when Will isn’t looking. Broken things can be uniquely beautiful when viewed from the right perspective, and Hannibal is loathe to let something beautiful be wasted.

Just then, a sudden proclamation from Will cuts through his thoughts:

“We're nearly there. It’s just a little further upstream."

“Oh? I wasn’t aware you had a destination in mind," Hannibal remarks coolly, content to follow Will along the winding path, despite the lack of answers. By now, Hannibal has learned that as inscrutable as Will’s actions might seem, everything he does has a point. Hannibal steals a glance at the other's profile: strong jawline cut by shadows, untamed curls, blue eyes-come-quicksilver. For months now, this impossible, wild thing has been taking conscious, determined steps towards him, lowering the forts of his vulnerable mind, baring the ugliest parts of his soul. Hannibal shivers in anticipation. 

What terrible beauty are you about to reveal to me now?

He notices a gradual change in the lighting as they walk. The sunlight filtering through the glass ceiling has now been completely overshadowed by thick fir trees and towering redwoods. In its place, soft lights flicker amongst the branches, mimicking the golden glow of fireflies. Drawing closer, Hannibal sees that they are not insects, but miniature winged figures perched amongst the leaves.

“Fairies?” he quirks an eyebrow at Will, but the younger wizard offers no explanation. Fairies are vain creatures, happy to be used by wizards as decorations for pretentious social events. Playing to his audience, Hannibal presses the tip of his wand to his throat and casts a Sonorous Charm, praise echoing through the trees: “What a beautiful display. I doubt my eyes have ever been blessed with a lovelier sight.” Will rolls his eyes, but the insincere words have the desired effect. A high-pitched tittering ripples through the forest like a flock of sparrows as the fairies giggle and preen, their little bodies glowing even brighter. 

The treeline soon opens into a clearing. Hannibal stops in his tracks, breath momentarily stolen from his lungs. It appears they have arrived at the ‘event’ after all. The fairies have congregated here in greater numbers, arranged deliberately to produce the desired lighting effect. Forget-Me-Nots carpet the clearing along with several flower beds, protected by an enchantment to preserve the blooms all-year round. Hannibal spies frozen lilies encased in ice and translucent roses made of glass. The flowerbeds encircle a mound of freshly turned over earth bearing a wooden cross. Will gently coaxes the grindylow tank from Hannibal’s hand and sets it aside without a word. Hannibal approaches slowly, his face arranged into a mask of neutrality, confirming the name carved into the grave marker.

Mischa Lecter

“This is for you,” Will murmurs from his left. He pulls out a small ring box from the pocket of his jacket and offers it to him. Hannibal tenses the second he lifts the lid, hit by the familiar scent of blood; but the satin interior is empty. His eyes slide across to the freshly dug grave in understanding. “Crups don’t just make good guard dogs, you know. They’re good at tracking too," Will tells him quietly. “Your genetic makeup is almost the same as Mischa’s, so I used a few strands of your hair to teach them her scent.”

Hannibal thinks back to their embrace in the pensieve. He pictures Will caressing his hair, a few stray strands disappearing unnoticed into the herbologist's pockets. He pictures canny Buster and loyal Winston following the scent of prey through the twisting labyrinth of Knockturn Alley; sees Will making hushed conversation with unsavoury figures in the back of secondhand bookstores and dimly-lit taverns, luring them with the promise of rare potions ingredients at cut-throat prices. Luring them back to his territory. In the middle of the North Sea. Where nobody will hear them scream.

What a cunning boy he is.

Will is watching Hannibal’s face for a reaction, hope giving way to doubt as the seconds drag on.

“I—er, hope you don’t mind that I already buried her… I didn’t know if you were coming back.” Will's voice falls to a near-whisper at the end, looking down at his feet. He flinches as Hannibal closes the case with a snap.  

“You never cease to surprise me, my dear Will.”

Will startles, eyes darting up to meet Hannibal’s. Instead of anger, he’s met with a look so intense, he might melt beneath its heat. Of course, Hannibal isn’t angry—how could he be? He recognises the gesture for what it is: not a thoughtless imposition of boundaries, but a precious gift…  a tribute. When Will looks away for the second time, it is for an entirely different reason. He regards Hannibal from underneath his lashes, cerulean eyes reflecting cold, clear purpose… but hungry. So very hungry. Both hear the proposition loud and clear:

Do you see? The wondrous, terrible things we could do—everything we could be.

Hannibal turns to the enchanted rosebush next to them. He caresses the smooth, see-through petals, and presses his thumb against one of the glass thorns. A ruby droplet trickles down the stem.

“Truly lovely," he sighs. "I’m reminded of the manor gardens from my childhood. We had fairies too. Mischa would often ask me to have tea parties with her there.”

Picking up on the suggestion, Will goes to draw his wand, but Hannibal is already one step ahead. With a swish-and-flick, he conjures up a table, chairs, and a steaming teapot with twin teacups. Will laughs, abashed by his lack of hospitality. It seems they have come full circle; albeit there are no eviscerated victims looking down on them from the trees tonight. Thank God for small mercies.

“I should’ve done that. Sorry, I don’t usually have guests,” Will admits, sliding into his seat.

“You are a creature who typically prefers solitude,” Hannibal replies sagely, taking a sip. The teacups are the same as before, each printed with pastel ducklings and teddy bears. Only now does Will realise their significance. This must be the same tea set from Hannibal's childhood; a relic from happier times filled with fairies, life, and laughter, unspoiled by horrid adult notions of dark wizardry and death. Will's stomach twists at the realisation he's probably drinking from Mischa’s cup right now.

They lapse into silence, punctuated by the creaking branches and chirruping fairies in the trees. The quiet is simultaneously peaceful and oppressive, too aware of the glowing pairs of eyes watching them, and the illusion of Mischa’s ghost sitting with them at the table. Both sense they can no longer dance around the inevitable. After a few false starts, opening and closing his mouth with no sound forthcoming, Will finally lets the sword of Damocles fall:

“Did you watch my vision, in the pensieve?”

“I did,” Hannibal confirms. His tone is steady, red wine eyes betraying nothing. Will’s grip tightens on the delicate handle of the teacup.

“And? Do you think I’m insane?”

Hannibal squints at him, choosing his words carefully.

“Before I share my thoughts, perhaps you should tell me what you think it means, Will.”

“I don’t know.” Will takes a deep breath, forcing out the words he knows he must: “But I know he looks exactly like me.” It is obvious who Will means by ‘he’— the doppelganger in his vision, armed with steel and soaked in blood under a moonlit sky. Betrayer. Hannibal nods in solemn agreement, waiting patiently for Will to stop fiddling with his napkin and continue. “... I want to write it off as some kind of lucid dream. A theatrical production of my subconscious.”

“Perfectly valid theories,” Hannibal acknowledges. “And yet, you cannot do so.”

“Because it feels too real,” Will confesses. “It feels… like a memory. Even though that’s impossible.”

“Are you certain of that?” Hannibal’s question is posed in a neutral fashion, but Will immediately turns defensive.

“I remember my past all the way back to my early years; I know that never happened.”

“Then logically, it cannot be you,” Hannibal answers smoothly, taking another swig of tea. Will’s jaw works as he struggles to respond.

“It feels like I’m watching another ‘me’,” he declares, achingly soft. “A mirror image reflected from another place—far away and long ago.” Desperate eyes flick up to Hannibal in search of understanding.

“A ‘you’ who condemns the wicked without the aid of a wand.” The silken words provoke a tremble of delight and fear in Will. “Curious that you would refer to this man in your vision as a ‘reflection’,” Hannibal continues, unblinking in his scrutiny. “In many myths, mirrors are depicted as gateways to other worlds.” Now it is Will’s turn to squint. He can’t quite perceive the path Hannibal is coaxing him down; a blind man feeling for the crevices in the walls to guide his stumbling feet. Hannibal decides a firmer grip is required. “What about the man you were attacking? When you relive the scene, how does it make you feel?” Will reclines in the chair and tips back his head, eyes flickering rapidly behind closed eyelids.

“It feels… deserved." When he looks at Hannibal again, the desperation and doubt has disappeared. Will’s eyes glint now in muted delight. “The same as it did with Clarke Ingram.” Hannibal’s lips twitch. He’d predicted such an answer.

“And the third man?” he prompts. At this, Will turns quiet. Hannibal leans forward a fraction across the table. Will’s hand is within arm’s reach; his middle finger twitches as a tremor passes through him, reflecting his mental stress. Hannibal’s eyes drill into Will’s soul in search of gold. “His face was obscured to me, as was his voice. Tell me Will, do you have any idea who he might be?”

“I know it has all the hallmarks of an Obliviate Charm. It's like someone got inside my head and moved all the furniture around.” Will’s eyes narrow at Hannibal—but his accusatory tone is an obvious distraction. Will is avoiding the meat of the matter, choosing to answer the ‘how’, and not the ‘who’.

“A disconcerting thought," says Hannibal, tilting his head. "Then again, have you considered that forgetting may have been in your best interests? Such a memory would be difficult to live with."

A choked laugh answers.

“Yeah well—I’m pretty sure ‘living with it’ wasn’t part of the plan.”

The temperature in the clearing seems to plunge to sub-zero. Hannibal remains statuesque, holding Will's gaze. 

“No,” he agrees softly. “It would seem not.” The unexpected warmth thaws Will’s defences. He endures the residual sting, like salt burning through snow. Will sinks into the chair, chin dropping to his chest, curls falling forward into his eyes.

“Hannibal," he begins. "... I think I killed us.”

The silence is suddenly deafening.

Hannibal finally reaches across the table to bridge the gap, thumb stroking the back of Will’s hand. Will twitches violently, as though bracing for the ragged kiss of a linoleum knife instead. Hannibal has certainly considered it. He’s spent many nights these past months turning the empty vial of Will’s memories over in his hands, and the problem over in his mind. Self-destructive thoughts posing as solutions tempted him, veiled in questionable logic, corrupted by emotion. 1 + 1= 2. An eye for an eye.

‘You and I are stuck in a zero-sum game.’

Will’s hand turns over unprompted in his grasp, offering up his vulnerable inner wrist. Hannibal’s fingertips land above his quickening pulse. The dark blue vein is exposed and stark, pulsing beneath his touch. Looking into Will’s eyes, he can still taste the grindylow’s blood at the back of his throat. Hannibal swallows. He presses down on the vein as if trying to keep it closed, deadly-soft hands that once promised exsanguination repurposed as a tourniquet. One cannot solve an equation with a missing constant.

“Do you remember who this man was to you?” Hannibal intones. Will raises his eyes. They shine in a way that Hannibal cannot quite explain; some glimmer of certainty discovered amongst the murky depths.

“I know he loved me.” A pause. “I loved him too.” As their gazes lock, a vision flashes through Hannibal’s mind: two blood-soaked wolves dressed in human skin embracing catastrophe, falling off the edge of the world.

We never belonged there anyway.

Hannibal shifts his grip, fingers threading loosely through Will’s.

“Love is one of the oldest forms of magic there is." The intimate words do not have the desired effect. Will cringes at the sickly-sweet expression, snatching back his hand and folding his arms.

“Please,” he scorns, looking away.

“There you go again, doubting my sincerity,” Hannibal scolds. “If this vision is a memory that somebody wanted you to forget, something gave you the power to resist. The love you feel for this man may be the answer; it may be the source of your other visions too.”

“My other visions are all of you,” Will counters, strangled. His grip on the teacup is trembling precariously, searching Hannibal’s face for a confirmation he doesn’t truly need—because deep down they both know. Why else be so afraid to show Hannibal the truth? Why the fear of retaliation?

It was you who I killed, wasn’t it?

Hannibal opens his mouth to answer, when suddenly a shadow moves in their peripheral vision, accompanied by rustling feathers and a spark of fire. They both look over.

Vesta is perched on Mischa’s grave.

Will’s jaw goes slack. The teacup slips from his grip, smashing to the ground. Cursing his clumsiness, he bends to pick up the pieces, flinching when a porcelain shard cuts his palm. Will freezes when Hannibal places a hand on his shoulder.

“It’s alright, Will." The quiet promise is accompanied by a gentle squeeze. Hannibal kneels beside Will in the dirt with napkin in hand. They work together to gather up the shards under Vesta’s watchful eye. Will’s muscles are tense, glancing at the phoenix out of the corner of his eye.

“She seems to have taken a liking to you,” he mutters. “First a feather, now this.” Hannibal looks up for a moment. The bird does seem to be staring at him.

“Phoenixes are intelligent, curious creatures. I’ve read several magizoologist texts on the topic,” Hannibal murmurs as they work. “They are described as symbols of life itself; as bright and enduring as the sun. After Mischa’s death, I spent some time looking into their regenerative properties for potion-making. I considered experimenting with her tissue samples.”

“You mean like… regrow her?” Will looks up in alarm, brows knitted together. “Would she still be your sister if you did that?”

“A wise question,” Hannibal agrees. “I asked myself the very same and found I could not answer in good conscience. That’s why I settled on the time-turner.”

“Is that any better?” Will wonders aloud, eyes downcast. “Changing history... creating new versions of events... new versions of people. You’re still playing god.” Their fingers brush as they both reach for the same shard, making Will flinch.

“What else is magic for, Will, if not to attempt the work of the divine?”

To that, Will has no answer.

Together, they manage to gather up every last piece. The shards are laid out on the table in front of them. Hannibal spots his counterpart’s guilt-stricken look.

“I told you, it’s alright,” he repeats. Will grimaces.

“But wasn’t that Mischa’s cup? I didn’t mean any disrespect.” Hannibal holds up a hand to hush him. He draws his wand and points it at the broken fragments with calm determination.  

“Reparo.”

With a quiet crackling noise, the cup reforms; jagged shards slot back into place like pieces of a puzzle, fault lines resealing and vanishing. Will watches with an inexplicable lump in his throat as a teddy bear’s shorn face is made whole. Hannibal, on the other hand, is watching with a nostalgic smile.

‘Sometimes I drop a teacup to shatter on the floor. On purpose. I’m not satisfied when it doesn’t gather itself up again.’

“What?” Will rasps, seeing Hannibal’s peculiar expression.

“I was admiring how easily the cup comes together,” he answers simply, giving Will a long, searching look. “Magic is a true miracle, wouldn’t you agree Will? We just use it so often, we forget how fortunate we are. You and I could easily have been born into a crueller, far less forgiving world. One where the teacup stays shattered.”

“… A universe without magic, you mean.”

Hannibal looks across to Vesta who still hasn’t moved. Emboldened, he takes hold of Will’s hand, slotting their fingers together. They turn together to face the phoenix. Hannibal can feel the trepidation in Will’s touch, afraid of scaring Vesta off. Afraid of making a mistake. Afraid of losing something precious all over again.

“I have a thought experiment for you, Will: what do you think would happen if a wizard were to interfere in such a world—such as to save a life?” he poses, tugging Will forward lightly.

“Like, if you came across two men falling off a cliff, you mean?” A shaky laugh escapes Will’s twisted lips. They take another step towards Vesta. “Well, assuming said wizard somehow found a way to cross entire universes, I’d guess nothing good. The use of magic would create an anomaly. Hell, everyone involved could die.”

“That’s one possibility,” Hannibal acknowledges. He changes his grip, letting go of Will’s hand and taking his waist from behind instead. The pressure at Will’s back is light but resolute, steering him forward. He shivers as Hannibal’s breath tickles the shell of his ear. “Or, like the phoenix, perhaps they would rise again from the ashes, perfect and shining. The chance for a brand-new life in a brand-new world.” The pair stop just short of the grave marker. Vesta is very nearly within arm’s reach, showing no signs of flight.

“You’re quite the optimist,” Will says at last. The scale of such a paradox would be absurd: be doomed to die in one world, in order to live happily-ever-after in another. 

“I’d say you’re too much of a pessimist,” Hannibal counters lightly. He drops his chin onto Will’s shoulder; feels him shudder under his touch and lean back, allowing Hannibal to lift his arm and guide his actions like a marionette. The whisper in Will’s ear sounds like a prayer: “I stole that time-turner with the aim of saving Mischa’s life… maybe my efforts were not entirely in vain. I said before that nobody truly understands the limitations of time magic, didn’t I?”

Finally, Will’s rough fingers connect with Vesta’s gleaming feathers. The warmth rends a sob from his chest. They stay like that a while, in no hurry to ruin the moment. Vesta's chest rumbles, pleased, as the herbologist’s rough fingers pass over her plumage with reverence. Hannibal joins in, letting the minutes pass. His watch tells him it’s long past business hours, but he has no intention of leaving. Not this time.

Vesta is eventually bold enough to hop onto Will’s offered arm, allowing him to stroke the sensitive, downy feathers on her head. He thinks nothing of it when Hannibal takes his free hand, but startles when he feels water droplets falling onto his cut palm. Vesta’s head is tilted, tears leaking from the corner of her eyes. Rather than irritating, the salty droplets cleanse and close the wound, broken skin knitting together. Will’s shoulders sag with relief. With the right tools, forgiveness doesn’t have to be hard. 

“Before you, and after you.” The words are so quiet, Hannibal almost misses them. He frowns in puzzlement. Will twists his head, not quite looking him in the eye. “Where the difference between the past and future comes from… Remember?”

And just like that, Hannibal does:

The sacred stillness of an empty gallery. A place beyond the touch of time, where beautiful things are immortalised, and the hours slip by like grains of falling sand. The quiet scratching of pencil on parchment stalling at the approach of hesitant footsteps. Faces marred by twin wounds like two halves of a butterfly’s wings. Hushed words and longing glances. No witnesses save for the painted faces on the wall. An unspoken prayer:

‘Please don’t leave again.’

In the here and now, surrounded by flowers of glass and all manner of impossible things, Hannibal brushes a thumb across Will’s unblemished cheek. He doesn’t need a sacrifice—not when he’s already been granted a miracle. Their lips touch. A taste of absolution.

You found me, once again.

“Stay with me.” Will breathes the words into Hannibal’s lungs, stolen from some other once-upon-a-time. Hannibal smiles against his mouth, unshed tears clinging to his lashes. He locks eyes with Vesta over Will’s shoulder, who has found her place again on his sister's grave. For a moment, he is certain Mischa is looking back at him from within.

Time didn’t quite reverse. A different cup came together than the one he’d originally intended—but maybe that’s just fine. Hannibal buries his face against Will’s neck, the feather in his breast pocket thrumming with warmth against their beating hearts. He didn’t know it back then, but this is all he’s ever wanted. For both of them.

“Always.”

 

The End

Notes:

Yay, second multi-chapter work completed~ Thank you so much to everyone who subscribed/kudosed/commented, I hope you enjoyed it! <3 If you were waiting until the end to leave your thoughts, it would be lovely to hear them!

I’ve commissioned some artwork for this fic, which I’ll be including in the near future. If you’re subscribed, I recommend staying subbed for the update!

Reminder, there is a graph here explaining the timey-wimey: Click Me
Per the circular graph, Will and Han being reborn is a paradox/contradiction in the natural order; it shouldn't be possible for them to die in one universe (which is needed to inspire teenage Han to save them with the time-turner) and also be living happily in another. AND YET, MAGIC.

A huge thank you to Aomimi for helping me out with the HP herbology knowledge here, she writes for the Hannibal fandom too, please check out her works!

Some terminology/mildly interesting notes:

Magizoologist: wizard equivalent of zoologist/vet, specialising in magical creatures.

Burning Day: the day a phoenix becomes too old and has to regenerate its aging body by bursting into flames. Some myths say their lifespan is directly linked to the life of the sun.

Phoenixes in HP are really interesting, not only can they regenerate as described but they are also capable of carrying heavy loads, and their tears have healing powers.

Will’s wand is made of hawthorn with phoenix feather core, hawthorn being symbolic of spring and new beginnings. Phoenix feather cores are known for producing the greatest range of magic but can be unpredictable/have a mind of their own.

The ending line is a callback to Snape from HP (*cries*)

I was inspired to write this fic by the song ‘Everything Goes On’ by Porter Robinson: “Will you meet me in the daylight like we did before? Then I felt you on my shoulder, and you weren’t suffering anymore. You said ‘I’m sorry that you worried’ but don’t apologise. I told you to forget me, but you stayed by my side.”

Thanks again for your support!