Chapter Text
Pop—the satisfying sound of a stopper being uncorked, followed by the trickle of pouring liquid.
Hannibal stands over the pensieve in the secret room beneath his practice, alone with Will Graham’s thoughts. He finishes emptying the vial into the basin and takes a deep breath. His visit to Mischa’s grave is still raw and smarting. Perhaps it would have been wiser to wait a couple of days before wading back into Will’s mind— but Hannibal is, at heart, a hedonist. He can only delay gratification for so long. Hannibal braces himself against the sides of the basin, peering into the mercurial silver mixture, getting closer inch by inch. Cold touches the tip of his nose, spreading out across his face… and then the world turns upside down.
When the room stops spinning and the mist clears, Hannibal finds his footing on solid rock. As he deduced previously, they are indeed by the sea, perched atop a desolate bluff. The hour is late, and the wind is high. Three combatants take centre stage, positioned dangerously near the cliff-edge. As expected, Will Graham is one of them. He looks roughly the same age as he does in the present, although it takes Hannibal a second to be sure; Will’s face is covered in blood, oozing from a deep puncture in his cheek. As for the other two figures, Hannibal has no idea who they are. Aside from Will, there is a terrifying man dressed all in black. He looks incredibly strong, with a muscular torso and broad shoulders, sporting a distinct scar on his lip. He appears to be the aggressor, bearing down upon Will with murderous intent—something closer to a monster than man. Hannibal does not know his face.
And as for the last… he has no face.
Will’s other associate is blurry to Hannibal’s eyes, as though obscured by a watermark. His features are entirely masked, so that the wizard cannot even tell his age, although he looks roughly the same build as himself.
This scene has been tampered with, Hannibal muses. It looks like the result of an imprecise Obliviate spell, not unlike those he reserves for particularly difficult patients. Hannibal only uses the memory charm in special circumstances; for those with pasts so painful, they are better off remembering nothing at all. The question is, who is responsible? Who benefits? Hannibal’s first thought is none other than Will himself. If this vision is as traumatic as he made it sound, a memory wipe would seem the obvious solution.
Am I correct? Did you do this to yourself? he wonders.
Watching the scene unfold, it becomes clear to Hannibal that the mystery man and Will are working together to take down the man in black. They circle their larger prey, harrying like a pair of hunting wolves. Knives and axes inflict shallow cuts, the man-monster’s movements becoming sloppier as the balance of power shifts in the duo’s favour. Hannibal wonders if this is what Will was so afraid to show him. This dance of death… this naked bloodlust. Far from being off-putting, Hannibal is excited. After their previous encounters, Will should know that… so, it must be something else.
Will’s breathing is laboured now, the stab wounds to his shoulder and side pouring with blood. His faceless partner is limping too, although his injuries are less obvious. Looking at him, Hannibal feels a phantom pain shoot through the small of his back, as if struck by a sharp object. He hisses between his teeth and reaches behind, feeling gingerly for any sign of a wound—but his fingers come away clean. He spots a vaguely familiar steel item discarded on the paving stones nearby. It’s one of those ‘guns’ the muggles love to hide behind.
Come to think of it, guns shoot projectiles, don’t they?
Bullets, Hannibal recalls, sifting through the vast halls of his memory palace for the right word. Once more, his back twinges. Hannibal rubs the spot again with a grimace, refocussing on Will. Unbelievably, he’s still bleeding.
What is he waiting for? Hannibal wonders. If Will doesn’t fix himself soon, he’ll be in serious trouble. All he needs to do is whip out his wand and cast a quick Vulnera Sanentur to close the wounds.
Hannibal waits, expectant. Every passing second, his worry increases. Will is still embroiled in the battle, lunging again for the towering man in the black leather jacket. At the same time, his companion leaps onto their enemy’s back, exposing his stomach for gutting.
Reckless, Hannibal fumes. Both men are gravely injured. Normally he would endorse this hands-on approach—it’s a great deal more satisfying than relying on cheap spells—but at some point, survival must take priority over pleasure. Unless… A frown creases Hannibal’s brow, faced with a novel and terrifying possibility.
What if Will isn’t using his wand because he doesn’t have one?
Scratch that—what if none of them do?
Hannibal is mesmerised as Will’s mundane knife gouges deep into vulnerable flesh, drawing a horizontal line that gushes red. His counterpart joins in, pulling back their prey’s neck. Voracious teeth sink in, tearing out vocal cords and tendons. They both spring backwards, landing in perfect unison—dance partners on a blood-soaked ballroom floor. Their felled enemy falls to his knees before his betters. He stays like that for what feels like an age, posed in a mockery of prayer. Which god would listen is anyone’s guess. There is not a healing charm in sight. Finally, the man’s incredible strength leaves him, and he collapses backwards. Obsidian blood seeps into the paving stones, leaving imprints in the shape of dragon wings. Hannibal witnesses it all, stunned by the conclusion he draws.
They’re muggles. All of them.
The wizard takes a step back, peculiarly lightheaded. He understands now why Will finds this vision so disturbing; why he cannot distinguish if it is fact or fiction, why it doesn’t fit with his current reality.
It is a memory… of a world in which magic does not exist.
Will’s partner leans down and helps him to his feet, the two clinging to each other for balance on the edge of the cliff. Will is shaking with adrenaline; the other calm and steady but breathing hard. Hannibal is reminded of how they’d held each other in the pensieve just the night before.
The mystery man says something to Will, but Hannibal cannot hear it. Just like his face, his voice is distorted and muffled, like he’s speaking underwater. What Hannibal does hear, though, is the shaky answer that slips from Will’s lips:
“It’s beautiful.”
Hannibal’s soul aches in agreement. An exhausted Will finally succumbs; he sinks into his companion’s arms and lays his head down, directly over his heart. The other tips his head back in bliss, clenching Will’s bloodstained shirt and pulling him as close as he dares with their respective injuries. When he turns his head in towards Will, leaning against him in exquisite tenderness, Hannibal has to avert his eyes. He feels as though he’s intruding on something private—something sacred. This scene would be a suitable choice for the patronus charm. In fact, Hannibal feels as though he could cast it himself right now.
And then, it all falls apart.
Will reaches up and wraps his arms fully around his companion’s neck. The other doesn’t fight it, limbs hanging loose, content to be held at Will’s mercy. He must have no clue what is about to happen. Will doesn’t hesitate. He closes his eyes, leans fractionally to the left… and pulls them both over.
What?
Hannibal stares, numb, at the spot where the pair were just embracing. Vicarious bliss turns to nausea and betrayal. He remembers the question he’d put to Will in the Forbidden Forest, accompanied by their winged steeds of leathery skin and bone:
‘Did you lose somebody when you were young?’
‘No… I wasn’t young.’
Wand drawn, Hannibal marches towards the crumbling cliff-edge, stomach plunging with dread as he peers over. He ignores the voice of logic telling him that no muggle could survive a fall from this height; that this is just a memory from days long dead—that he’s too late. Hannibal Lecter is a wizard, for pity’s sake. There must be something he can do. But below, all Hannibal sees are roiling black waves stretching out to the horizon. Curiously, there is no sign of an impact; no disturbance in the current, or bodies floating on the water. It’s like the pair have simply vanished.
Almost as if by magic.
The coastal gale howls in Hannibal’s ears, whipping his face red raw, but it pales in comparison to the sting of betrayal in his breast. It almost feels like he was the one sent diving onto the rocks below.
Why does he feel this way?
Hannibal’s fingers travel to his collar and tie, remembering the weight of a much thinner chain around his neck; a miniature hourglass encased in a golden circle, begging to be turned. Now he understands. There is one other person aside from Will Graham who would want to forget this scenario... one other person who would benefit from a fresh start. The betrayer, and the betrayed.
Stepping back from the ledge, a taunting voice from another life is carried on the wind, posing Hannibal a question that will haunt his dreams:
‘Which are you?'
