Actions

Work Header

he served a dark and a hungry god

Chapter 4: What a Sweet Child It Is

Notes:

this week's chapter is a bit shorter than the others. I keep finding myself splitting up my original plans for chapters and I'm now bumping the total count up to 8. consider this an interlude of sorts since it doesn't map directly onto any scenes from the musical. this fic is turning out to be a slower burn than originally expected.
this week: Margot hits a low point, Will and Hannibal have portentous conversations, and Abigail kind of sort of joins the family.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

As a peace offering, Margot had volunteered to prepare and serve dinner the following night, after so rudely rejecting her brother’s generous proposal. She spent the morning buying ingredients, promising something truly special to make up for their earlier disagreement.

She stopped at Eldon Stammets’ counter to inquire about which types of mushrooms were edible and which were poisonous. He was happy to expound on this subject at great length, and provided her with a helpful visual guide to the types of fungi that could be commonly found on the east coast. Some of the toxic ones, she noted, looked very similar to some of the species that were safe to eat. She pointed this out and he only nodded gravely, and wished her luck on her foraging.

She offered him some extra cash to show her what he kept under the table. She made her selection alongside a purchase of some expensive imported truffles, and went home to spend the rest of the day riding.

Cordell watched her like a hawk going in and out of the kitchen, but said nothing.

Dinner was a quiet affair, although Mason did compliment her cooking midway through. “See, Margot, I knew you’d make a good wife someday.” She forced herself to smile, but it felt more like a grimace and probably looked more like one too.

She talked up the final course, describing the rarity and high value of the truffles and how they were considered a great delicacy in France and Italy, and she thought she may have truly pulled it off when he stopped with the fork halfway to his mouth and said, “Just one minute.”

“What?” she said.

“I’ve never had these before. How do I know I won’t have some kind of reaction?” His tone was calm, even pleasant, but she knew that was when he could be at his most dangerous.

“They’re perfectly safe. Mr. Stammets said—”

“Eldon Stammets sold you these, did he?” Mason set the fork down. “You know, in the past kings and wealthy nobles would have servants hired for the sole purpose of tasting their food before they ate it, to make sure it wasn’t poisoned. It was a dangerous job, of course, but plenty of people volunteered for it because they knew the importance of preventing a potential assassination. Plus they got free food out of it.”

“I’ve already tasted it myself,” said Margot, perhaps too quickly.

“That’s good of you, but I’d never ask you to be my taster. I wouldn’t put you at risk like that.” He stood up. “In some cases, the taster was an animal.”

Margot had set up her new pet bird’s cage in the dining room. It was a good wide-open space for even a blind bird to fly in, she thought, and she left the door of the cage open when no one was eating in the room, but the bird had never dared try flying. Not that she’d seen.

“Mason, no,” she said, trying to keep her own voice calm. “How do you know birds can eat truffles? If he gets sick, or dies, even, that won’t mean anything as to whether we can eat it. Like how dogs can’t eat chocolate.”

“I’m sure birds eat mushrooms all the time,” he said. “They eat worms out of the dirt, don’t they?”

Margot was at a loss for what to do or say, short of knocking the mushroom out of his hand. “Don’t feed my bird anything without my permission.”

“Would you rather I feed it to one of your horses?” he asked, softly and dangerously.

“No,” said Margot, softly and angrily.

She watched the bird, unseeing but trusting anything offered as food, peck at the bit of mushroom.

When nothing happened, Mason said they might as well wait to eat the mushrooms anyway, and had the table cleared.

The next morning, Margot found her bird unmoving at the bottom of his cage. She took him out, stroked his tiny soft-feathered body, and allowed herself to cry. She buried him behind the stables, marking the spot with a stone, not knowing how else to commemorate the short, confused, unnatural life of an innocent little creature that never did anything but sing.

She tried the door to the kitchen and found it locked. Cordell informed her that, for security reasons, only he and Mason now held the key.

 

All things considered, Hannibal had handled the situation rather well, Will thought.

He himself had been practically catatonic after killing Miss Lounds, but Hannibal had been almost completely unfazed on seeing it. If anything, he seemed to see the incident as an inconvenience for him, but one that could be dealt with. He had swiftly sent Abigail away on her own, saying that he, Will, and her employer were having a discussion that could take a while but that she need not worry about. Then he had set about cleaning up the blood and, with Will’s help, heaving the body into the ice chest and covering it with ice and, yes, fish.

Will felt as if he were in a dream.

“Shouldn’t we bury her?” he asked after the chest was securely closed.

“Not yet,” said Hannibal. “You may want to consider putting a lock on this chest, though.”

Will’s dreams were troubled again that night, which didn’t surprise him. He found himself locked in a chest of ice, dying fish weakly twitching all around him, and woke up soaked in sweat despite how cold he’d been in the dream.

After looking around and assuring himself he was now awake and in the real world, he got another shock when he saw a figure standing in the doorway. But it was only Hannibal.

“I heard you upstairs, making noises as if you were thrashing about in the midst of a nightmare,” he said. “I wanted to see that you were alright.”

“I am,” said Will.

“I’ll be right here if you need anything,” said Hannibal. Will fell asleep easily after that, but when he awoke in the morning, realized he did not remember Hannibal ever returning downstairs. He did not know if he really felt safer knowing Hannibal was watching over him or not, or if he even should feel safe with that man in the room.

At breakfast, Will thought Hannibal might not bring up anything that had happened the previous day, but instead he asked Will how he felt about it right away.

“Nervous, mostly. Scared that I’ll get caught for it and sent right back to prison. This time for an actually justified reason.” He took a sip of the coffee Hannibal had prepared. Will had gotten used to drinking black coffee during his time working with the police, but Hannibal preferred to make his with all sorts of spices and sugars added to give it more flavor. It took some adjusting to, but Will did admit it tasted better that way.

“Understandable. I can only assure you that if you let me handle it, there will be nothing for you to worry about. But how did you feel while doing it? And directly after?”

“You mean, how did it compare to killing Hobbs?” He did have to think. It was like trying to remember a dream – in fact, he felt like it was easier to remember his dream of the previous night than the reality of the previous day. “It was – impulsive. I lashed out, out of…panic?” No, panic was what he had felt when he saw Hobbs cutting his daughter’s throat. He had not had any time to think or act rationally in that situation. “Out of fear. She was threatening me. Not with a weapon, but with – slandering me.” It sounded especially foolish when he put it like that. “I knew she could ruin things for me, when I’d finally come back home, started putting my life back together. Before I even had the chance to do what I needed to do.” He met Hannibal’s eyes. “But that doesn’t justify killing her, does it.”

“Perhaps not in the eyes of the law,” Hannibal said, “but it can be justified if your own moral code allows for it. I believe you did what seemed reasonable from your position. Especially now that you have been hardened by many years spent incarcerated, and returned already planning to kill again for the purposes of serving your own idea of justice. After you had already killed a man, for entirely justified reasons, but still you felt righteous, as you said.”

“That was a very different situation,” said Will. “And if I am going to kill Verger, that will also be different. These are people who pose an immediate threat to others. Taking them out could save lives. With Lounds I was just trying to save my own reputation.”

“You saw a strong potential threat to yourself and eliminated it in the quickest and most effective way available. And you likely saved many more reputations by doing so, which could lead to saving more lives. Didn’t you think that she was at least partly to blame for putting you in prison?”

“Are you trying to convince me that this murder was in fact justified?”

“I am trying to help you balance your thoughts on the matter. Playing the devil’s advocate, as it were.”

“I still feel guilty.” Do you? a voice whispered in his head, and he tried to push away thoughts of the benefits Freddie Lounds’ death could have. One less thing to worry about, now.

“Dwelling on guilt can be unhealthy. It’s usually best to accept whatever responsibility you bear and then move on to more productive modes of thought.”

Will ate the last bite of his breakfast sausage. “That’s true. I should get out on the water as early as possible. There are other people’s boats that need fixing, and the earlier I get to work on that, the sooner they can return to their livelihoods and keep feeding their families.”

“Good. Focus on the positive effects of your actions, not whatever negative emotions you associate with the actions themselves.”

“Mm-hmm.” Will barely heard him, but must have absorbed something, because he barely thought about Freddie Lounds’ body in the ice chest for the rest of the day. Not even when he opened the chest to place what he’d caught that day on top of the ice.

He slept well that night. Once he woke up in the middle of the night to see a shadowy figure in the doorway again, but reminded himself it was just Hannibal keeping an eye on him, and returned to sleep. He remembered no dreams – except, upon waking, briefly thought he recalled seeing the shadowy figure with deerlike antlers sprouting from its head.

The mind played strange tricks on itself at night.

 

It was Hannibal who was there to receive Abigail Hobbs the next day when she made her second visit to the shop.

He was alone at the counter, rolling out dough for the next batch of meat pies, when the soft ring of a bell above the front door announced a customer. He greeted her as one despite knowing what she was most likely really there for.

“Ah, Miss Hobbs. Come for a pie? Or perhaps another luncheon?”

“Sorry, but I’m not looking to buy anything today. Have you seen Miss Lounds recently?”

“She hasn’t come by here since she left the last time you were here.” Hannibal was good at speaking casually so as not to betray any further knowledge.

“Well, I haven’t seen her since either. She didn’t come home that day.”

“Hmm. That is strange.” Hannibal stepped back from the counter, thinking. “Did she say anything about leaving before? Is it like her, do you think, to make off without telling you for long stretches of time?”

“She’s left me alone before, but usually she tells me where she’s going first. I was going to ask you if she said anything about leaving town.”

“Now that I think about it,” said Hannibal, pretending to think about it, “she may have mentioned that she was considering moving the newspaper headquarters to a different part of town. Will and I tried to convince her there was not very much here that was newsworthy these days, and we may have succeeded.”

Abigail nodded slowly. “Where is Will, anyway?”

“Out fishing. He usually works on boats in the harbor on alternating days.” Abigail was walking around the shop, taking in the small seating areas and the meats and wines on display, then stopped at the foot of the stairs leading to the upper level.

“What’s up here?”

“Will’s part of the business, and his living arrangements. He sells fish, and he may be planning to expand his trade to fishing supplies. He makes his own lures. I used to rent the room out for a bit of extra money, but now that we are becoming a dual-income household, I do not need to charge him as a tenant.”

“Too bad it’s already occupied, then. I was thinking I might need a place to stay if Freddie – Miss Lounds is gone any longer.”

“We do have a spare room on this floor,” Hannibal said, nodding in its direction, “that we could make up as a bedroom if you need it. We would be happy to offer any help we can to those who need it. You wouldn’t need to pay.”

“I could help out here, though,” Abigail offered, “whatever you’d like. I’ll sweep the floors, arrange the tables, serve the customers…I could even learn to cook some more.”

“You don’t plan to keep working at the newspaper, now that there might be an opening in the staff?”

Abigail glanced out the window. “I’d still like to be a journalist, but…I don’t really think I’ll get very far in that field if I stay at the National Tattler. At least not in the field of serious journalism.”

“You’re glad to get out from being under her custody, I take it. No longer indebted to her for work and housing.”

“Maybe so.”

“If you’d like to learn more about cooking,” he said with a small smile, “you can start by helping me knead the dough for these pies.” She’d now wandered back over to the counter where he prepared the food, and was watching with interest as he rolled out another lump of dough. “What’s your experience with it?”

“Not much. I can feed myself well enough, but the most I did at home was when I helped my father prepare the meat after…” She trailed off. “Um – we’d go hunting together, before…you know.”

Hannibal nodded sympathetically. “Your memories of working with meat, and more broadly of spending time with your father, may now be tainted by your experiences and what you know now of his true nature. Fortunately, I believe you can still alleviate the pain associated with those memories by supplementing them with new experiences. Shall we try?”

Abigail stepped behind the counter. “I think so.”

 

Will returned with a bucket of fish to see Hannibal making pies with Abigail Hobbs.

“Hello, Will,” Hannibal said cheerfully as he stepped through the door. “Abigail will be staying with us for the time being, in the spare room down here. I’m showing her how to bake so she can help with our business. Freddie Lounds has been missing since the day we last saw her, did you know that?”

“No,” said Will.

Abigail acknowledged him only slightly, concentrating on her pie crust. “Hello, Mr. Graham.”

“You may call us by our first names, if we are to be housemates and potential business partners,” said Hannibal. “Perhaps Will could teach you to fish.”

“Some people find fishing boring,” said Will.

“I wouldn’t mind,” said Abigail, finally looking at him. “It might be good for me to spend more time with you. Dr. Lecter told me about supplementing my painful memories with more pleasant experiences. This could be just similar enough to hunting with my father to work for that.”

“Right,” said Will. Strange, he thought, that Hannibal had seemingly adopted Abigail while he was out, but he supposed that if he was responsible for killing both her father and the woman who had been her guardian after her parents’ deaths, he had a sort of responsibility to her now. “I’m more of a fisherman than a hunter, but the two methods of gathering meat have their similarities alongside their differences. One you stalk, the other you lure.”

“I saw some of the lures you made upstairs,” said Abigail. “They’re very nice.”

“Thank you.”

Will headed upstairs to put the fish in the icebox right over top of the frozen body of Abigail’s “missing” employer. As he passed Hannibal, he shot him a look that he could only hope properly communicated – we’ll talk later.

Notes:

I have a few...issues with how Margot and her storyline are written in the show and one of them is that we know she tried to kill her brother but we never get to see or hear about the details of how. fortunately we have an infinite variety of possibilities to explore in fic. poison seemed an appropriate choice for the setting.
as always, if you liked this story/chapter, consider leaving a comment! everyone loves comments on here