Chapter Text
“Marry you? Your own brother?”
Margot was glad that Alana, at least, was having the appropriate reaction to learning this news.
“There’s some legal loopholes that allow him to do it, but it won’t do any good to explain to him that we’re still biologically related,” she said. They were sitting on Alana’s bed, surrounded by her notes and books on psychology and medicine, as well as Alana’s own touches of plush pillows and flowered curtains that made her home that much more comfortable. Margot usually felt safer here than she ever did at home, but now she was wondering if there was anywhere she would ever be safe.
“I know the amount of control he has over you,” said Alana. “He sounds like the type of person who won’t let anything or anyone go if he feels it’s his right to have them. Is there anywhere you can go…?” She trailed off at the end, as if she knew it was a futile question; if there was anywhere Margot could go, she wouldn’t be in such despair.
“Short of fleeing the country, no. I’d have to leave so much behind, too. I’ve lived my whole life on that estate, and our father did a good job ensuring we wouldn’t easily adjust to anything different. There’s the whole farm, and my horses…”
“Oh, Margot.” Alana put her arms around her, and Margot, who did not often cry in front of other people, felt the tears welling up again.
“I’ll help you,” Alana whispered in her ear. “You can stay here for now. Hide in my room if you have to. If he comes by, I’ll say I haven’t seen you. Then, we can work on getting you away from him.”
“Are you planning to have him arrested? I’ll warn you, that would be hard to do.”
“I’ve heard. He had a friend of mine sent away almost solely through his own influences.”
Margot pulled back to look her in the face. “Do you mean…you know Will Graham?”
Alana nodded. “I met him on the ship back from Australia. He was being released. I know what you might be thinking, but – I helped get him finally acquitted of the false charges against him. I think I can be more careful than he was, now that I have the knowledge I do.”
“He helped me,” said Margot, “back then. Or at least he tried, and I appreciated it. Perhaps he can help me again.”
“I’ll talk to him,” said Alana. “But I do worry that he is nursing a personal grudge against your brother that could cloud his judgment.”
“Well, I’m nursing an even more personal grudge against him, and I don’t feel that my judgment is at all clouded.”
“True, but Will…he’s spent a long time in an environment that does one’s state of mind no favors. Many men have come out of prison more disposed towards violence and murder than they ever were when they went in.”
“I know, we talked about your study. You said people would do well to remember there are means of influence other than violence, like your colleague Chiyoh said. But she also said that violence is the only thing some men understand.” Margot sighed and laid down on her back. “I think my brother is one of those men.”
“I’m not saying anything against violence,” said Alana, and laid down beside her. Margot glanced over at her with slight surprise, but remained in her position. “I think we’ll have to see what method of solution will work best for this situation. We just can’t be too reckless and lose sight of a practical goal in the pursuit of catharsis.”
Margot smiled. “You’re very intelligent. Combine that with your kind heart and you’ll be the person the field of psychological medicine has always needed.”
Alana’s returned smile was shy, hesitant. “I don’t know if I’ll be as good as that. But I can try.”
Margot turned onto her side. “I think the only way I’d be able to get out of this marriage is if I were already married. Of course, my brother knows I’d never do that on my own or I’d have found a husband years ago. And it’s awful what happened to Will’s wife, but since he is – no longer married, perhaps he and I could…”
“If I were a man, I’d marry you as soon as possible,” said Alana.
Margot felt her heart skip a beat, as they said. “I would gladly marry you, too. If only…” She stopped, not sure if she should say it.
“If only women could marry each other? I’ve often wished that. We don’t have to be married to go away together, though. When did he say he wanted to have the marriage performed?”
Her heartbeat quickening by the second, Margot whispered, “Monday.”
“We can leave Sunday, then. Or Saturday, or tomorrow, or even tonight.”
“Alana…”
“Yes?”
“Kiss me.”
She did.
Hannibal was at the front counter of the shop the next day when Mason Verger entered alone.
“Mr. Verger,” he said, greeting him as soon as the bell rang. Verger, he gathered, was the kind of man who expected prompt and immediate service. “I haven’t seen you around lately. Is everything going well?”
“Oh, just fine, Dr. Lecter – do they still call you Dr. Lecter? I hear you’re no longer practicing.” He aimed a probing eye from atop the small pair of spectacles he wore. Hannibal wondered idly if the glasses were purely decorative, like the reading glasses Will only wore when he wished to put further barriers between himself and the gaze of his current company.
“Most do,” said Hannibal. “Even those who did not know me in my former profession. I don’t blame them – it’s hard to adjust, sometimes, to a new form of address, and in this case especially people fear being accidentally rude by not respecting my doctorate. And to be fair, giving up the practice didn’t mean giving up the degrees I’d earned.”
“I suppose,” said Verger. He glanced around the shop. “Interesting setup you have here. Meats, pastries, and wine, all in the same place?”
“My customers find it convenient. It helps that I already had the freedom to be somewhat eclectic with my choice of wares, since I came here with a good accumulation of resources.”
“I hear business isn’t as good as it once was, though,” Verger remarked, never losing his supercilious smile. “Meat’s lower-quality these days. Doesn’t taste very good at all, people say, which is a shame, because I hear you’re quite a good chef when you have better ingredients.”
“Yes, it is, but we work through it.” Hannibal smiled back.
“I will say, the Verger company has been offering affordable and high-quality meat for generations now, and I would always welcome a new client – oh, hello there, Miss Hobbs.” Abigail had stepped out of the back kitchen and stopped short when she saw Mason Verger.
“How are you doing?” he asked, his tone taking on a veneer of sympathy. Hannibal imagined it was similar to how he spoke to the orphans who visited Muskrat Farms for their sponsored tours and riding lessons.
“Just fine,” said Abigail, giving him a hard stare.
“You’re working here now?”
“Yes, I am,” she said. “Are you here to buy anything, or just dropping by?”
“Oh, I am here to purchase, but not on this floor. Is your business partner in, by any chance?” Verger glanced upwards.
“He is,” said Hannibal. “Are you looking to buy fresh fish, or fishing gear?”
“Fish for me today. I felt like seafood for dinner tonight, and normally I would have sent my sister out to buy it, but…we had an unfortunate incident the other night, and I’m afraid I can no longer entrust her with the privilege of shopping for dinner ingredients right now. We really do need to hire more staff once business is better. Times are hard for all of us, Dr. Lecter…”
“I’m aware,” said Hannibal.
Abigail watched Verger head upstairs. When he was out of sight, she muttered, “God, I hated him.”
“Saw enough of him during Will’s trial, I imagine,” said Hannibal.
Abigail nodded. “I didn’t see him much in person, but I read about what he said in the papers, and…I couldn’t stand how he kept talking about me when he’d never even met me, acting like he cared about me and as if he was advocating entirely on my behalf, when it was clear all he really cared about was whatever grudge he held against Mr. Graham. And you can probably imagine how frustrating it was to be the only other person who knew what happened and not even be able to speak.” She sighed heavily, leaning against the counter and looking up.
“Well, you won’t have to worry about him for much longer,” Hannibal said. “Our friend Will, if all goes right, will soon take care of that for us.”
Abigail looked back at him, surprised. “He’s…going to kill him?”
“He might. He seemed very set on it when he returned. I wouldn’t be concerned, though. I assure you this will be the most expedient way of preventing that man from causing any more harm than he already has.”
Abigail didn’t need to ask what else he’d done – she had been reporting on it alongside Freddie Lounds and her staff for the last seven years. The only real loss that would result from Mason Verger’s death would be the reliable fountain of scandals and corruption that the Tattler always managed to know about no matter how carefully the Vergers covered it up.
And it wasn’t as if Miss Lounds needed to worry about her career at the moment, either, but Abigail didn’t need to know that just yet.
“Mr. Graham said that killing someone, even if you have to do it, is—”
“The ugliest thing in the world?”
“Yes, that’s what he said. Were you listening in?”
“One cannot help but overhear things when living in close quarters. But yes, he has confessed that he doesn’t enjoy the act of killing. However, I believe he sees it as a necessary evil, in certain circumstances.”
“Freddie said he could develop a taste for it.”
“She said a lot of things, didn’t she?”
Abigail kept looking up. “I just don’t know how to feel about a man being killed right over our heads. Even if it’s a necessary evil.”
“It’s certainly a preferable situation to having innocent girls killed by a member of your household while you were unawares, no?”
Abigail looked at him sidelong. “I’m going to step outside for a bit, if that’s alright.”
“Do what you need to do.”
“You’ve fixed this place up nicely, Graham.”
“What do you want?” asked Will, who was in the middle of cleaning off a fishing knife.
Mason Verger held up both hands. “I know you’re probably not thrilled to see me after our last confrontation all those years ago, but I think we can try making amends at this stage. What kind of fish would you recommend for a family dinner?”
Will turned slowly to face him, keeping the knife wrapped in the handkerchief he held. “What’s the occasion?”
“Celebrating an engagement.”
Will walked casually over to the glass-fronted case displaying fresh catches. He did not look at the sealed ice chest. “Whose?”
“Mine.”
“Oh.” Will set down the handkerchief that held his knife, newly cleaned and sharpened just that morning. “Who’s the, ah…lucky woman?”
“You haven’t gotten much better at hiding when you have a clear disdain for the subject of your address, Graham…” Verger leaned against the glass, just inches away from Will. He slipped a hand into his front pocket. Will knew very well that he likely concealed a knife there, too.
“Forgive me,” Will said. “I haven’t had much chance to improve my conversational skills while in prison.”
“And we can agree that I’ve apologized. I know now I had the wrong man, of course, but I’m sure you understand that I just wanted to do right by those poor girls. As a man of the law, you’d been in situations before where you had to work with what you believed to be the case even if it didn’t turn out to be true, hadn’t you?”
“You were talking about your upcoming engagement.”
“Yes, right. You see, I recently discovered something interesting about my family history – well, I needn’t get into all the details here, but suffice it to say, I learned that Margot and I are not actually siblings. Which means that, in the eyes of the law, we can solve the problems of my bearing an heir and her need to secure a marriage in one simple move. It’s a shame we didn’t find this out earlier, could have saved a lot of trouble for us…” He bent down to study the dead, staring eyes of the fish behind glass.
Will’s hand clenched around his concealed blade. He took a step towards Verger, prepared to make a sudden move at any second, knowing the other man might be equally prepared to do the same thing.
He might be trying to lure you into a false sense of security…and he knows exactly where to stick you whether you’re a human or a pig…but you know, too.
“Tell me, Graham,” Verger said without looking up, “what kind of fish do you think Margot would like best?”
Alana passed the Hobbs girl in the street on her way to Dr. Lecter’s shop. The young woman seemed to be taking a walk, not going anywhere in particular but lost in thought. She nearly walked right into Alana.
“Sorry, miss,” Abigail said hastily.
“It’s alright. Were you just coming from the pie shop?” She pointed towards it.
Abigail nodded. “I’m working there now. I was taking a short break.”
“Oh, that’s nice…” Alana needed to think straight. “Will Graham lives on the top floor, doesn’t he?”
“Yes, he has his own part of the business up there. He sells fish.”
“Perfect. Thank you.” She hurried past Abigail and pushed open the door, the tinkle of a bell announcing her arrival.
“Are you Dr. Lecter?” she asked the man at the counter.
“That I am. What have you come for?”
“I’m Alana Bloom. I’m a friend of Will Graham’s. I apologize for not buying anything, but I just need to talk to him for a minute.”
“You’re Dr. Bloom?” Dr. Lecter’s eyes shone with interest. “I’ve heard about you. Will is right upstairs.” He gestured towards the stairwell, set back in the wall and heading up seemingly into pure darkness.
Alana started towards it, then stopped. “He’s not with any customers at the moment, is he?”
“No, he should be quite alone. If anyone else comes in while you’re having your conversation, I can hold them off down here for however long you need until you’re finished.”
“Thank you, sir.” Alana wasted no time in getting up the stairs.
There was no door at the top of the stairs, which was a design flaw Will should have drawn more attention to when he first moved in. Unfortunately, it wasn’t something he thought of very often, and at the moment he was more focused on getting the immediate task done while he had the perfect opportunity to do it.
“Will!” Alana exclaimed as she reached the landing.
Mason Verger straightened up at the sound of her voice. Will swiftly drew his knife behind his back and re-wrapped it.
“Alana,” he said. “Could you wait just a minute?”
“Miss Bloom,” said Verger. Alana had frozen in shock at the sight of him. “I know you. My sister’s always going over to your house. I’ll bet that’s where she was last night.” He turned around to face Will, smirking. “And I heard you helped get Mr. Graham here off in Australia. What was it you wanted to talk to him about?”
“Later,” she said, taking a step down.
“No, no, don’t mind me. We were just making small talk, catching up on our lives. Did you know I’m engaged to be married, Miss Bloom?”
“It’s Dr. Bloom,” said Will.
“Yes,” said Alana, “I heard.”
“Did my sister tell you? What else did she say? Because when I first proposed, she showed a certain…reluctance. That’s why I’m hoping to reconcile with her by buying her dinner tonight. I know she has a taste for the flesh of creatures from the deep.” His smile grew wider and, if possible, more sinister.
“Alana,” said Will, trying to keep his voice steady, “why don’t you leave, and we can meet up later and talk?”
“No need,” said Verger. “I’ll actually be leaving now. I’ve decided not to buy anything – in fact, I’m terribly sorry, Mr. Graham, but I don’t think I’ll be able to patronize this establishment anymore. I need to get home straightaway and have a serious talk with Margot. By the way, Miss Bloom, don’t expect to see her around much after this. I think she’s going to visit her mother very soon.” He stormed off down the stairs, shoving past Alana on the way.
Once he was gone, Alana came back up, her face pale and drawn. “I’m so sorry, Will. I came here to tell you – it seems you already know, but – Margot was going to come here, and we thought you might be able to help her hide before we…left…”
“I’m sorry, too,” said Will. “I almost had him. I should have been faster.”
“With what?”
“Nothing. I think you should go.”
Alana hesitated. “Margot’s mother is dead, isn’t she?”
“Yes, I think. But before that…she was in an insane asylum.”
“Oh, god, that’s right. She told me.” Alana clutched the railing. “I’ll go now. I really am sorry.” With that she turned and fled downstairs.
Will stared after her for a few minutes, then unwrapped the fish knife and put it away in the drawer it belonged.
“I had him. I was so close, it would have been the perfect time. He might not even have suspected anything. And then Alana burst in – not her fault, she couldn’t have known, but – now he knows we know, and he’s probably going to send Margot off to some asylum, exactly the kind of place Alana’s been saying we need to reform, and she’ll be even worse off and it’ll all be my fault, when you think about it—” Will collapsed on his bed and buried his face in his hands.
Hannibal, who had been watching calmly from the desk chair as Will paced frantically around the room, spoke up. “I understand your frustration, Will, but all hope is not lost.”
“It might as well be!” Will stood up again. “He’s never coming back here, and when am I ever going to get another good opportunity to get to him?” He laughed, mirthlessly but with a degree of honest reaction to absurdity. “I can’t believe I ever thought I’d be able to do anything about a man with that kind of wealth and influence. What was the point of coming back here? What’s the point of anything, really?”
Hannibal was now standing up, coming over to him. “Questioning the ‘point’ of anything can lead to dangerous places. Let’s look at what you have done.”
“Like what?”
“You found a place to live at no cost to yourself and started a business, doing something you enjoy and are good at, and which is doing fairly well for the short time it has existed. You met two people who have helped you – one who lives near you and was instrumental in your release, and who considers you a friend and would be willing to offer you whatever you need. And one who gave you a residence and space to work out of, who lives with you and who, if I am not mistaken, you enjoy the company of. Correct?”
“Correct,” said Will.
“You also reunited with a young woman whose life you saved – living proof of your ability to make a positive difference in the world – and who now also lives and works with you.”
“Yes,” said Will, becoming heated again, “and despite that, she doesn’t seem to like or trust me very much, considering I also orphaned her when I killed her father, and she associates me with a significant traumatic change in her life. And she also only works here because I killed her previous employer. I came here planning to kill one person, one terrible person who’s responsible for so much misfortune and suffering in others’ lives, and I ended up only killing someone else who has done nothing but write some mildly inflammatory news articles. And my wife is dead, Margot is going to be locked away in an awful place by her devil of a brother who’s also planning to legally marry her with all that entails…”
“Will,” said Hannibal, and suddenly was wrapping his arms around Will in an embrace, and pulling him close, resting his head on Will’s shoulder.
“Breathe,” Hannibal whispered.
Will, even while being held tight, managed to draw in a deep breath. He let it out slowly and shakily.
Hannibal held him for a moment longer. Will had the sense he should be embracing him back, but before he lifted his own arms to attempt it, Hannibal was stepping back and looking him in the eyes again.
“Do you feel better?” he asked.
“Yes,” said Will.
“Good. Now, think. How did you feel when you killed Mr. Hobbs?”
“This again?”
“Yes. Think. Remember that feeling. In the moment. Not the shock or the horror or the guilt you felt afterward, but how you felt in the action of it.”
“I felt…” Will swallowed hard. “Good.”
“And when you killed Miss Lounds?”
“I felt…similarly. But – that might have been the same action, but a different situation. The guilt set in quicker then.”
“But in addition to the guilt, did you not feel anything else?”
Will thought. “I felt…relief. That it was over. That I didn’t have to worry about her and what she might say or do anymore, concerning me.”
Hannibal nodded. “Exactly. When you talked to Mr. Hobbs, or Miss Lounds, before you killed them, did you get the sense that they were bad people? Even before you knew what they did, or could do?”
“Hobbs I only spoke to once, but I didn’t like it. He seemed shady. I could tell he was hiding something. Not just the murders, but – nervousness that he might be caught, and a touch of guilt over what he’d done. Conflict within himself, trying to rationalize it. Protectiveness over his daughter – worry for her, and worry about himself, whether how he felt about her was appropriate. Deep down he knew he wasn’t a good man, and I knew it too.”
“Good. Your empathy sees a lot. And Lounds, what was she like?”
“I didn’t like her either, the first time I talked to her, but for different reasons. She was upfront about everything. She had few morals and was mostly self-serving. She said she just wanted to tell my side of the story, but I could sense the calculation underneath, that she was hoping to get something interesting out of me and didn’t care if it made me look good or not. I knew she could very easily be a threat to me, and I was right.”
“What about Mason Verger?”
Will smiled bitterly. “You don’t need a lot of empathy to tell what he really is. Or maybe you just need to be someone he isn’t paying off.”
“So some people are easy for you to read, and some require a bit more probing. But you can always tell a person’s true nature, when you interact with them and allow yourself to connect with their emotions, their way of speaking, the inner thoughts they reveal in their face and body language. In other words, you can tell if someone deserves to die.”
“I wouldn’t go that far.”
“But you have already, twice. Three times if you count your plans for Mr. Verger. Tell me, Will, did it get easier or harder after you’d already done it once?”
“I thought it would be harder, but…” Will looked at the chest where Freddie Lounds’ body lay. “It was easier. And that was frightening, to me.”
“You could do it again, then. If someone walked into this shop, and came upstairs and was alone with you, and you looked into their eyes and saw the soul of a cruel, selfish, unrepentant person who could cause great harm to others, who has done so already…”
Will knew what he was implying. “When I was working with the police, we arrested one man who had been killing people and making their bodies into – angels, of sorts. He said that sometimes when he looked at someone he would see their head wreathed in flames, and it would always turn out that person had committed some violent crime. So he began killing people he saw like that, to rid the world of dangerous sinners. When we were alone I asked him what he saw when he looked at me.” Will looked down. “He wouldn’t tell me. He killed himself later. The autopsy showed he had a tumor in his brain.”
“You saw yourself in him. Except you don’t have a tumor in your brain.”
“Not that I know of.”
“You can see the truth of a person just from how your mind naturally operates.”
“So you’re saying I could be a better vigilante than him? I’m not sure I should. If you go by my mind’s logic, you could start finding reasons that everybody deserves to die.”
“Everybody will die, someday.”
“You’ve always been hard for me to read, Hannibal.” Will was looking directly into his eyes, something he didn’t do often when talking to anyone. Hannibal’s eyes were deep brown pools, with an almost maroon tint he noticed now. Mesmerizing eyes, the kind that were almost impossible to look away from once you got this close.
“I would think that makes me more interesting to you.”
“I think it does.” He was aware of Hannibal’s hand coming up behind him, their heads bowing towards one another, foreheads nearly touching.
“You’ll be alright, Will,” Hannibal whispered, his breath on Will’s face. The smell of him in the air, not unpleasant, smelling like the downstairs area of his shop. Meats and pastries and wine all mixing together.
A thought flickered into Will’s mind – one that had come to him before, but which he had dismissed as irrational, not to be seriously entertained. Now seemed the time to grab it and hold on to it like a circling fish and yes, it seemed much more reasonable now.
“Hannibal?”
“Yes?” He’s thinking it, too.
“Kiss me.”
He did.
