Actions

Work Header

White Shark Café

Chapter 4: Games

Summary:

Abigail serves TEA

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“Will, I don’t want to shock you,” Abigail said, “but Mr. Achilles has the hots for you.”

Will spluttered, trying not to choke on his coffee.

It was after hours, and they were just cleaning up and preparing pastries for the next day, so Will didn’t have to worry about any customers overhearing, but that didn’t stop him from looking around to be sure they were alone.

“What the hell , Abs?” Will demanded, scowling at her as she measured out some butter.

“It’s just the truth,” she said with a shrug, “you think he comes here for the coffee? He only orders half the time. He compared you to Patrocles after you named him Achilles. The Ancient gays ? For someone so smart most of the time, you can be really dumb sometimes.”

Will knew he was red and he tried to hide it behind his cup as he took another drink of his coffee.

“I could fire you, you know,” Will said half-heartedly.

Abigail laughed, dumping some flour into the mixing bowl.

“Only if you want to have a hoard of serial killers after you,” she said, “they like me more than you.”

Will laughed at the tease, shaking his head.

“Sorry to break it to you, but they were all coming here long before I hired you. They wouldn’t touch me,” he shot back.

Abigail shrugged.

“But they sure wouldn’t be happy with you,” she pointed out, “so I guess you could take that chance and see.”

Will huffed a laugh and shook his head.

He wouldn’t fire her. They both knew that. He also didn’t really want to test the loyalty of his customers. As much as they valued his services, they were a group not notorious for forgiveness.

“Also, if you don’t like the idea of Mr. Achilles, I’d stop flirting with him if I were you,” Abigail said with a grin.

“I’m not !” Will said, scoffing at her.

Abigail shook her head.

“You give him free food and bat your eyelashes at him,” she said, leaning on the counter as if to mimic him, “ No charge other than pleasant conversation, big strong ancient gay man. ”

“That is not what I sound like, and I do not bat my eyelashes,” Will objected, swatting her with a hand towel, “and it’s not wrong to have friends. You should try it sometime.”

Abigail stuck her tongue out at him as she tasted the dough she was mixing, checking to see if it had been made correctly.

“I have friends,” she said casually, “and most of them aren’t even serial killers. Can you say the same?”

Will humphed at her, but didn’t otherwise answer. They both knew he didn’t have friends outside the café other than Beverly. His one normal friend, and she was a computer tech for a big security company. They didn’t talk much, and Beverly didn’t know the reality of what the café had turned in to.

“What makes you think Achilles would be interested in me, anyway?” Will asked, curious despite himself.

Abigail smirked.

“Ever heard of mirroring?” she asked.

Will’s expression must have communicated just how silly of a question that was, because Abigail just shrugged and continued talking.

“When someone likes someone else, they tend to mirror their movements, either consciously or not. You lean on the counter, Achilles leans forward to match you. You smile, he smiles. He tries not to get caught doing it, so he’ll turn away sometimes and look somewhere else, but he always turns back quick. He can’t help but stare at you too. He has eyes for nothing else in the world but you, Will. God , you can be so dense.”

Will was actually considering this now. He hadn’t noticed the mirroring, but thinking back he realized they did often end up with the same position or posture. He almost always felt Achilles’ eyes on him too.

Damnit. Did Achilles actually like him?

“Not to mention, he doesn’t exactly make friends with the other regulars,” Abigail continued, rolling out dough as she spoke, “he rarely even sits down in the café anymore. He just stands by the counter to talk to you. When he does sit, he sits alone and just stares at you the entire time. That’s textbook infatuation right there.”

“Alright, I get it,” Will said, stopping her from going any further and making him have a crisis, “I’ll try to be a little more aware from now on. God. You’re like a child sometimes.”

Abigail pouted.

“I’m an adult ,” she complained.

Will huffed a laugh.

“Still a teenager, though,” he reminded her.

“For one month!” she objected, putting her hands on her hips and getting flour all over her clothes, “you’re worse than Norman!”

  Will grinned.

“Who’s Norman ?” he asked sweetly.

“Ugh. You’re more of a child than I ever was,” Abigail said, throwing a handful of flour at him and getting it all over his clothes as well, “I want to start dating him, but I just need to convince him he wants that too.”

Will laughed.

“Well, he’d better watch out. You’ve got a thing for psychology.”

Abigail stuck her tongue out at him.

---

“Good morning, Will.”

Will smiled, though he felt a pang of panic at hearing the voice again after Abigail literally spelling it all out for him.

“‘Morning, Achilles. What can I get for you today?” he said.

The other regulars had taken to leaving Achilles alone after Will had started referring to him by the name. It was like a rite of passage, where having an alias meant you were allowed to visit the café in peace. Will hadn’t noticed that before this man.

Achilles hummed pleasantly, his eyes drawing over Will’s face fondly.

“I would like to have what you first gave me, if you can recall what it was,” he said.

A clear challenge, and one Will was well equipped for. He had a fabulously good memory.

“One Artist’s Blood, and one Cannibal Crown coming up,” he said with a wink, turning to get them for the man.

Oh god. Had he just flirted with Achilles? He hadn’t thought about it first. He had just acted how they usually acted with each other. Were they usually flirting with each other? Was that what this was?

Will turned back around, knowing his face was a complete blushing mess, and put the cup and the pastry down on the counter for Achilles. The man smiled warmly, as he always did, and Will felt a flutter in his chest.

“Thank you, Will,” Achilles said, taking some cash from his pocket and holding it out.

When Will took the money, Achilles grabbed his hand. He didn’t pull sharply, yanking Will towards him, as Will expected. Instead, he just held on, waiting for Will to look up at him.

Will finally looked up, meeting his eyes, and the man tipped his head curiously.

“Is there something wrong, Will?” Achilles asked, his thumb tracing over Will’s knuckles absently, he actually looked concerned.

Will swallowed and shook his head.

“No, sir ,” Will said, tensing a bit and feeling his face heat up even more, “Be careful out there.”

Achilles blinked, then looked down at where their hands were joined. He traced his thumb over Will’s knuckles again, more slowly and deliberately, then lifted it and pressed a kiss where his thumb had gone.

“Will Graham,” Achilles whispered, “I hope you do not fear me, but know this: you will be mine .”

And with that, he was gone. Will was left, holding the cash in his hand, his face blank and flushed. Achilles was gone so fast Will didn’t have time to process what had happened.

Notes:

I'm going to be updating a bit more sporadically for a while. I'm hoping to get a new job, and then I'm moving, so I'm going to be pretty busy. I'll update as often as I'm able, and I'm posting the first chapter of a few fics I've been working on.
<3