Chapter Text
When Abigail walked into the kitchen and saw Will with his back against the counter, a bottle of whiskey in his hand, she knew something was up. She came over and sat opposite him, watching him expectantly until he finally spoke.
“You know, you were right,” Will said, taking another swig from the bottle, “Achilles has it out for me. I just don’t know if it’s in the way we thought.”
Abigail raised her eyebrows and reached for the bottle, but Will pulled it away.
“Nope. Not gonna happen,” he said, “you’re not even almost there. You’ve still got a year to go before that’s legal. This is mine.”
Abigail pouted, but she let it go.
“Okay, so are you saying he might be thinking of taking you out in the not dinner-and-kissing way?” she asked.
Will shrugged.
“Hey, maybe they're the same thing for him,” he said, then stopped, “No. Forget I said that. They aren’t. Not for him. He’s not that kind of killer.”
Abigail watched him for another moment.
“So, you can figure out what kind of killer this guy is just by talking a few times, but you can’t figure out if he’s flirting or threatening?” she asked.
Will huffed.
“I don’t think he’s used to being in a situation where he can be himself with someone,” he said, “so he’s not acting the same around me as he would with someone he’s planning on dating or killing. I have no reference point or contrast.”
Abigail hummed at that, tipping her head back so it tapped the wall.
“Well, you’re in a real jam, aren’t you?” she asked, “at least you have all our regs behind you if he tries anything.”
Will shook his head.
“That won’t do any good,” he said, “if he kills me, not only will there be no evidence it was him, he would easily take out anyone who went after him. Jeff, Carrie, Jason, Freddy. None of them would stand a chance against him. Even if they all went at him together, I don’t know who would come out the other side. If he decides to kill me, there’s no stopping him.”
Abigail looked down at her hands, fidgeting nervously. Will could tell she was worried for him, and that she was afraid. He hadn’t meant to frighten her, but he wanted her to be aware of the situation.
“So let’s just hope he’s going for the dinner and kissing way,” Will said, earning a laugh from Abigail.
“Will, please be safe,” Abigail said quietly, hugging her knees to her chest, “I don’t have a home to come back to anymore. Once I go to college, I don’t have parents to visit on the weekends or for holidays. I don’t have a place to come when I have a hard day. You’re that for me now. You and the café, and all those stupid killers that hang out here. This is my family, and my home. I couldn’t stand to lose all of this too.”
Will put down the whiskey and moved over to hug Abigail. She had never confessed all that to him before, though he had figured it out. Abigail had lost everything when her father had been caught. He had killed her mom right in front of her, and had almost killed her too. She didn’t have a family aside from this.
“I know, Abs,” he said, pulling her close and setting his chin on top of her hair, “I know. I’ll do my best. I just want you to be safe and happy. If anything happens to me, you get the shop, and I bet all the regs will make sure nothing threatens it. I want you to be sure that you’re going to be okay. Even if I’m not around someday, because we both know I’ll die sooner or later, I’m going to make sure you are taken care of.”
Will hadn’t told her before that he had made sure to make her his sole beneficiary if he died. He hadn’t expected it to come up, but he felt like he had to give her some reassurance in this moment. Let her know she wouldn’t be left with nothing. Not again. She would have somewhere to start this time, and people to help her.
He wasn’t her father, but he was going to do better than he had. Her father had left her with nothing but a tainted name and a tabloid journalist after her scent. Will wanted to give her something.
“Don’t leave me, Will,” she sobbed into his shoulder, “I won’t ever forgive you if you leave. Everyone always leaves.”
Will shushed her gently, stroking her hair to soothe her. He wanted to cry right along with her, because it all felt that way at times. His own parents had left him at a young age, and he hadn’t been able to make anything of himself until he started this café. She and him were the same. They were alone without each other, and adrift at sea without the café.
“Abigail, I can’t promise to be around forever, you know that,” Will said, fighting back the urge to promise the impossible, “but I’ll be strong for you, and I’ll fight for you, as long as you do the same for me. Be strong, and fight. Don’t ever let the world tell you what you should be, because you’re the only one who gets to decide that.”
Abigail continued to sob and sniff into his shoulder, and Will just held her.
It was cathartic to experience this with her, even though Will didn’t cry himself. Feeling her work through the pain and fear as he helped was as good as going through it all in his own heart.
Will did all the baking after Abigail went home that night.
---
“Hello, Will.”
Will looked up with a smile, meeting the dark brown eyes of someone who looked too young to be one of his usual kind of customers, but he saw the same hunger in the boy’s eyes.
“White shark has something for everyone’s unique tastes, be they predator or prey,” Will chirped back, “what can I do for you today?”
The boy tipped his head, reminding Will of a curious dog the way he did.
“What do you think?” the boy asked.
Will almost rolled his eyes, realizing this kid had come because he wanted Will to read him. Will looked him over before pointing to the menu.
“Two birds with one stone and a bear claw,” he said, “unless you’re more fresh than you look, in which case I would suggest a short blonde.”
The boy grinned, apparently giddy about being understood. Will almost wanted to step farther away from him, having grown used to the others being casually friendly.
“I don’t think I’m all that fresh,” the boy said with a smile, “so the first one sounds good to me. I don’t suppose you’re hiring, are you?”
Will paused in his work for a moment.
He did need more help, and he would need even more once Abigail left for college. He had actually been thinking about hiring someone, though he had been hesitant due to what the job was like. He couldn’t exactly advertise that he needed someone who could bake, make coffee, and sympathize with serial killers since that was the majority of their business.
But this kid was one of them . That might work out.
Will turned and set the order down on the counter.
“I just might be, but why do you ask?” Will said, smiling politely.
The kid handed over a card to pay unlike the usual cash the regs used to keep their anonymity.
“A friend of mine told me to ask, but they said to keep their name out of it, which I hear is sorta a theme in the café,” he said with a shrug, taking a sip of the coffee.
Will nodded, not sure who would have thought he needed fresh help, but knowing it could rightly be any of the regs.
“Alright. What do you know about coffee?” Will asked.
“I’m a connoisseur,” the boy shot back just as quickly, grinning widely, “and this is excellent, by the way.”
Will nodded, waving him down. The enthusiasm was a bit over the top for him.
“How about baking?” he shot back.
The boy shrugged.
“Give me a recipe and I’ll get it close the first time, if not perfect,” he replied casually.
Will nodded.
“And what exactly do you know about how this café is run? What did your friend tell you?”
This part was important, because Will refused to hire someone who was unaware who they would be dealing with on a daily basis.
The boy smiled and leaned in close, lowering his voice.
“Most of the customers are killers, and you keep that pretty lowkey so they keep coming back,” he said, “you don’t ask questions, and they don’t string you up over the café awning. Is that what you wanted to hear?”
Will rolled his eyes.
“Bit dramatic, but essentially yes. You can start tomorrow if that works, and I’ll run you through the motions at noon. That’s when we’re pretty slow, but still get customers. Perfect time for training. You in?”
The boy grinned even wider and stuck his hand out for a shake.
“That sounds good, sir. My name’s Billy, and I can’t wait to get started.”
Will shook his hand with a smile, hoping this was a sign that things were going to go well for a while at least. He didn’t want all this drama in his life. He just wanted to run a little café, and see Abigail go to college, and live his boring but peaceful life.
Life had other plans.
