Chapter Text
Achilles had insisted on driving Will to dinner, casting more suspicion and worry into Will’s mind. No one would be able to see and later identify his car in the area. If Achilles was going to kill him, that would make it much easier for him.
But Will tried not to think about that. He wanted to have faith that Achilles truly meant him no harm. If he played his cards right, he could get out of this alive.
The moment the man’s Bentley pulled up outside what could only be the house where he lived, Will sent the address and the license plate number to Abigail in case something were to happen to him.
Achilles eyed Will as he did it, but made no comment, only smiling some secret smile.
“I don’t expect that to stop you,” Will explained as he put his phone back into his pocket, “but if you do kill me, I’ll at least have caused you an inconvenience. I also don’t expect that you’ll get caught because I did that. I think you’re too smart for that. But you’ll have more than just the police after you if I don’t make it back to work tomorrow.”
Achilles’ smile never faltered, never wavered. If Will had to explain that smile, he would almost say that Achilles was thrilled . Thrilled that Will was still concerned about being killed, or thrilled that Will was being so petulant about it, Will wouldn’t have been able to say. He just knew there was some twisted glee in Achilles’ expression, and Will still didn’t know how much danger he was in.
The house where Achilles lived was grand, if not grandiose , and Will felt a dark sense of admiration for it. The interior was impeccably well kept, and the décor was just to this side of gothic horror. The man would be considered eccentric by most of his guests. Will thought he might be the first guest to know that the design was less out of morbid fascination, and more a dark, internal humor. It was as if all of it was an elaborate joke, which only Achilles was privy to.
And now Will.
“Please, allow me to take your coat,” Achilles said in the foyer, all chivalry and consideration.
Will shucked off his windbreaker, that he had only been wearing because of the slight drizzle outside. He wouldn’t deny that he also considered that it would be more evidence left behind if he were killed. He thought idly of the old movie, Rope, in which the final clue for identifying that the murder had occurred was the hat of the victim being left in the coat closet by the door.
Will had no delusions about Achilles being that foolish if he chose to kill Will. He was much smarter than the boys of that story.
But, much like the old movie, Achilles would be sure to throw a dinner party after Will’s death, though the guests would not simply be unknowingly eating over his soulless corpse.
Something about comparing Achilles to the movie lightened Will’s mood a bit, as if he could now be killed and just laugh about it. He smiled secretly to himself, and it seemed to catch Achilles’ eye.
“I hope you will enjoy yourself tonight,” Achilles said pleasantly, shutting the coat closet and leading the way through the house to the kitchen, “I have been told it is something of a show to watch me cook, so please, take a seat.”
Achilles gestured to a few bar stools at the island, and turned to begin his preparations.
Will again felt that this could be a ploy to make the eventual murder go more smoothly. A way to ensure Will did not leave Achilles’ sight, at the same time as having him already be in the kitchen. It would certainly be more convenient.
Will took a seat, knowing the events of the evening were mostly in the hands of Achilles, and all he could do was be ready for whatever may come.
Achilles had taken his jacket and vest off, and rolled his crisp, white sleeves up to begin cooking. It was a bit strange for Will to see him that way, as he had only ever seen him impeccably dressed in three-piece suits to this point.
Achilles’ forearms were tan and strong, which again surprised Will. He tried to picture the man wearing clothes with shorter sleeves while out in the sun, in order to have gotten a tan, but he couldn’t conjure the image.
“Tell me about yourself, Will,” Achilles said pleasantly, moving with a peculiar, practiced grace around the kitchen as he worked.
Will tipped his head and frowned.
“What?” he asked.
Achilles looked up at him frankly and pleased.
“Conversation,” he said, as if it were obvious, “you are not required to speak with me, of course, but I imagine it will be more enjoyable for both of us if we are not trapped in silence for the entire evening. You may ask me questions as well, if you like. Conversation goes both ways.”
Will considered that. It was somewhat reassuring that Achilles had asked to get to know him, as Will could tell he wasn’t the type of killer that would enjoy killing the person more the more he knew about them. He wouldn’t bother asking if he planned to kill Will.
But, of course, it was still on the table.
“Alright. Well, you know my real name, care to even the playing field a bit?” he asked, unsure if he would get an honest answer or not. It didn’t hurt to ask. Unless it did.
Achilles smiled, the corners of his eyes crinkling with amusement.
“That is a dangerous bit of information, Mr. Graham,” he said smoothly, “for the both of us. You must know I do not intend to be caught in this life. If I tell you, it would bind you to me. Do you truly wish for that?”
Will considered it. It did seem a bit intimate, now, to learn the man’s name. If he spoke his true name, he wondered if it would feel right, or if it would feel like a curse.
“Maybe not. Fine,” Will conceded, “where are you from?”
Achilles nodded, accepting the change of course. He seemed pleased that Will felt the same way, and Will would have even guessed he was glad Will was being cautious.
“Lithuania, though only in my very early years. I travelled around Europe for many years as I learned, before I found myself in the states and settled.”
Will nodded, the pieces fitting well into the puzzle the man had made of himself. Will thought he probably could have guessed most of that himself, if not all of it. He had a way of guessing things.
“I’m originally from Louisiana,” he told Achilles, offering information about himself in return for what he was given, “but I’ve moved around quite a bit too. Settled here with the café for good after meeting Abigail. She needed a bit of stability after her father died, and I just happened to have a café.”
Achilles nodded again, looking as if he had his own puzzle of Will that he was piecing together in his mind. Will wondered if they might not be doing reflections of what the other was, dancing and circling around each other for the time. He didn’t know quite what would happen when the dance ended.
“I had originally thought you might be her father,” Achilles confessed, “there is some resemblance, and you certainly treat each other as family. I quickly realized, though, that your bond was of a different nature.”
Will smiled sadly, humming in agreement.
“Yeah. Her dad was the Minnesota Shrike,” he said.
Achilles halted his movements for a moment, glancing up at Will in surprise.
“Garrett Jacob Hobbes?” he asked.
Will nodded.
“The same. He killed all those girls because Abs was growing up. She was going to leave him. He got caught, and Abigail was left with nothing to show for everything she had gone through. We ran into each other at the café one day, funnily enough, and I knew she was desperate for someone she could hold onto. Maybe it wasn’t the best thing for her mental health, necessarily, but I couldn’t do anything but try to be her someone.”
Achilles was listening intently, as if this story was a valuable insight into Will’s life, and it was. This was something Will felt as if his entire reality had been built around for the past few years. It was the cornerstone of who he was. Nothing would be the same if they had not met.
“When Abigail basically begged for me to hire her, I had just decided I was going to need some help, and I couldn’t have asked for anyone better suited for it. I think we kind of needed each other,” Will finished, feeling like he had started rambling, but smiling regardless. He had always had a hard time keeping from talking about Abigail. He was just so proud of her, and she was doing so well for herself now.
Achilles continued cooking, his motions a tad slower and more deliberate as he seemed to consider what he had learned.
“And the regulars of the café have grown fond of her as well,” he noted after a time.
Will huffed a laugh.
“Yeah. We’ve never told any of them about her dad, but I bet a few of them recognize her from the news, and they feel a kinship with her regardless. She’s more likely to understand them than a random person off the street, even if she’s not like them. In a way, they see her as unblemished innocence, and they want to protect that.”
Will paused, after saying that, studying Achilles for a moment. The man showed no clear reaction to the words, but Will knew he was probably remembering his first visit to the café.
“The regs wouldn’t go after you if you ended up killing one of them ,” he said slowly, “but they’d not stop until you were dead if you ever hurt her.”
