Chapter Text
Achilles met Will’s eyes, and must have seen the sincerity there, because he nodded solemnly.
“I have no intention to cause her any harm,” Achilles assured him, “If I am quite honest, she reminds me of my own sister.”
Will didn’t allow himself to react to the news that Achilles had a sister. He just watched the man for another moment before he spoke.
“She’s dead, isn’t she?” he asked carefully.
The look on Achilles’ face was one of long held mourning. He didn’t frown, but the crinkle and light were gone from his eyes.
“Yes. She died when we were both still quite young.”
Will didn’t ask for the man to elaborate. He didn’t need to know anything more, and he had no intention of making Achilles upset. It was clear he had loved his sister, and had not been the one to kill her. He genuinely mourned her, and if she had been killed at the hand of any agent, he had avenged her.
“So,” Will said, changing the subject and lightening the atmosphere, “what first brought you to the café?”
It was something he had wondered before. He didn’t exactly know how any of the regulars first heard of it, especially including the unique type of people that worked there. They all just showed up. None of them would ever admit to talking about it outside the walls of their oasis, but someone had to be blabbing if word was getting around.
“A patient of mine,” Achilles revealed, “they are not a regular, and I doubt they are aware of the slip, but they frequently recalled your cafe, and the way you had seemingly peered into their soul when they visited. I was intrigued, especially considering their unique personality and the way they described your insight.”
Will hummed thoughtfully.
That was fair enough.
“You’re a psychiatrist,” he mused, “I should have guessed. I probably could have. It fits.”
Achilles smiled, seeming pleased.
“Care to elaborate?” He asked slyly.
Will huffed a laugh.
“No.”
He wasn’t about to inflate the mans ego any more than necessary for Will to survive. Achilles didn’t need to hear that he was smart and insightful. He already knew. He just wanted to hear Will compliment him.
“But I will tell you this,” Will offered placatingly, “I don’t think most of the regs would be glad to hear it. Most of them have had unpleasant experiences with psychiatrists.”
Will had never been told as much, but it was a fairly safe thing to guess. He knew they wouldn’t have argued if they heard him.
Achilles nodded.
“I understand that is not uncommon for a demographic such as you have collected,” he agreed, “how did that begin?”
Will huffed another laugh, feeling the muscles in his shoulders slowly relax as he grew more comfortable, but never letting his guard down.
“That there’s a story for the ages,” Will said with a grin, “and it all started with a conversation about nominative determinism.”
At that, Achilles tipped his head curiously, silently bidding Will to keep going.
“The White Shark Café,” he continued, “is an area in the middle of the ocean where great white sharks gather yearly. My friend suggested an actual café by that name would mysteriously attract predators as well. I guess I didn’t expect her to be right.”
Will told Achilles about the first and second visitors that he had known were killers, and how the rest had shown up and slowly accumulated. He talked about Hobbs, and how he had worried the café would be dragged into the investigation after his death.
And then, he met Achilles’ eyes, and nearly jumped out of his skin from what he saw.
Achilles was listening intently, his expression soft and pleasant. He looked as if he were enjoying himself immensely. But that wasn’t what gave Will pause. There was some secret, caged hunger in those burgundy eyes. Something more frightening than all the polite indifference and quiet judgment. This was more dangerous than being seen as inconsequential or unimportant by the Chesapeake Ripper.
Will had once said he didn’t want Achilles to fixate on him, and now he knew it was too late. Achilles had locked on, and was prepared to raze everything in his path to get what he wanted.
And he wanted Will.
Will must have stuttered to a stop as he spoke, because Achilles tipped his head again and looked at him with curious concern.
“Is everything alright, Will?” He asked kindly.
Will shook himself back to reality, trying to smile and cover up the sudden strike of fear.
“Yeah,” he said weakly, “I guess I just drifted for a moment. What was I saying?”
Achilles smiled indulgently, as if allowing Will this one lapse.
“I believe the tale was over,” he said, picking up the plates of overly beautiful food that he had carefully created as Will had talked, “and now is a perfect time for me to show you to the dining room as well, if you would just follow me.”
Will did, thinking over the implications of what he had seen.
Will still could not tell if Achilles had a desire to kill him. The hunger he had seen could easily have been the kind sated by the death and devouring of the subject, and it was equally as likely as it being the kind to motivate a new outlook on life. Will simply had no way to tell as of yet.
This night was going to be a terror on his nerves.
Will was seated, and Achilles placed a plate of food in front of him.
“That’s just so damn unfair,” Will mumbled as he looked at it.
Achilles paused in his movements and tipped his head at Will. Will didn’t notice for a moment, but then he laughed nervously and shrugged for his host.
“I mean, it’s just that cannibalism is so taboo. It’s basically drilled into people from a young age that it’s an act of evil. I just think it’s not fair that your cooking is so… pleasing.”
Will felt a pang of worry once he finished, not sure how Achilles would respond to something like that. He hadn’t planned to say anything like that, but it was the best explanation he could come up with, at least and not outright insult the serial killer providing him with food.
After a terrible moment of silence, Achilles smiled and hummed pleasantly.
“I’m so pleased you think so, Will,” he said, and Will wasn’t sure what part of the statement he was so glad about, “one must toss aside many societal standards in order to truly enjoy oneself, in my opinion. We cannot possibly please everyone, so the only thing left is to please ourselves.”
Achilles took his own seat, taking up his silverware and looking at Will with casually pleased expectation.
Will glanced down at the food once more, mentally apologizing to whomever it was he was about to eat, and lifted his own set. He carefully cut a piece of meat and lifted it to his lips, feeling Achilles’ eyes on him the entire time. Once the food touched his tongue, Will had to suppress a sound of pleasant surprise at the taste.
As beautiful as the display was, it was infinitely more delicious.
And Will stood by his earlier statement. It was damn unfair.
“It’s delicious,” Will managed, trying to keep his tone even to avoid letting Achilles know what he was thinking.
Achilles’ eyes sparkled and he finally looked down at his own plate to cut a bite for himself. Will almost audibly sighed in relief to no longer be pinned in place by his intense gaze.
“Thank you, Will,” Achilles said, “I have always had the opinion that we should not allow ourselves to become complacent when it comes to the quality of what we make up our lives with. We must eat to survive, and so we should enjoy eating to the fullest.”
Will nodded, considering that as he tried not to stare at the man across the table from him. He wasn’t privy to all the nuances of high class table etiquette, but Achilles had set them across from each other rather than sitting at the head with Will at his side. Will felt like that was significant, but he had no idea why. He didn’t know what it meant.
“You keep saying my name,” Will accused, knowing he was being rude, but also aware that he was all the time being tested, “That’s a manipulation tactic. It makes a person like and trust you more, without them understanding why. Are you trying to manipulate me?”
