Chapter Text
Achilles led Will to a sitting room after dinner was finished, pouring more wine for both of them. Will hoped he wasn’t planning to get Will drunk for any reason. Will had a high alcohol tolerance, but he didn’t feel safe refusing wine offered by the Chesapeake Ripper.
Achilles was quiet for a long time, standing near the active fireplace, and Will started to feel as if Achilles might not have any intention of bringing him back. Will didn’t have his car, so he was basically a prisoner if Achilles decided he didn’t want him to leave.
“Did I upset you?” Will asked nervously when the silence became too much.
Achilles jumped slightly, apparently startled out of his thoughts. He looked over at Will, and his expression grew fond, despite the slight look of fright that lingered in his features.
“No, of course not, Patrocles,” he said immediately, almost unthinkingly, “You have simply given me much to think about. I confess I am somewhat absorbed in my own thoughts at the moment.”
Will nodded, relaxing a bit now that he knew Achilles wasn’t angry.
“Well, feel free to share,” Will said, almost sounding mocking, though that hadn’t been his intention, “It’s killing me not knowing what’s going on.”
Achilles smiled, and that was a relief as well. If he was smiling in this way, a harmless smile with no malicious intent behind it, Will felt assured that he had not made a very big mistake. At least not yet.
“If you must know, Patrocles, I have been wondering how I can rectify this blunder of mine. This night has taken a turn I did not expect or prepare for.”
Will smiled, but hid it behind his glass as he took a sip of wine. He had made the Chesapeake Ripper second guess himself. That was a rare privilege, he was sure.
“Tell me what you’re thinking, and I’ll tell you where you can improve,” he offered.
Achilles frowned in confusion, studying Will like he might be trying to play a trick.
“Why would you help me?” he said suspiciously.
Will shrugged. He had nothing to gain by lying here. Achilles was not someone who could be easily messed with, and Will was aware that he was already getting away with more than almost anyone else would have been able to.
“Believe it or not, Achilles,” he said, “I do actually like you. If you started going about this properly, I might even fall for you. I want to see you succeed, probably against my better judgement, so I’ll help where I can.”
A spark of hope flashed in Achilles’ gaze, and Will hoped he hadn’t just made a mistake. He knew this could all go very wrong, but the way Achilles looked at him just then made him feel like it was worth the risk. God, he was such a temptation to Will. It was not good.
“Very well, Patrocles, tell me what I can do to improve,” Achilles said, somehow making it sound like a request and not an order.
Will shifted in his seat to get more comfortable on the couch. He took another drink of his wine and thought about what to say first.
“You should start by getting over being scary,” Will said bluntly, earning another slight jump from Achilles, “You’re not going to get anywhere with me by being threatening, and I think I’d like it if you at least try to be friendly with the regulars. You don’t have to like them, sure, but I want them to at least stop hating you. They’re like a family to me, in some ways, so you should try to get along.”
Achilles walked over and sat on the other end of the couch, his expression contemplative. Will knew the man had no real desire to socialize with anyone at the café other than him, but the fact that he was considering it gave Will hope that something could potentially work for them. He had started the night almost sure he would end up dead, but now he thought he might actually come out better than he had gone in.
“Very well,” Achilles said after a moment, sounding mildly unhappy, “I will do my best. I assume that is not the only advice you would offer me, though.”
Will smiled and nodded, trying to show Achilles he wasn’t doing this all just to be difficult. His next suggestion was bound to put more strain on this delicate situation.
“You should also start treating me like I’m a regular person,” Will said, holding a hand up to stop Achilles when he saw the man wanted to argue, “I don’t mean you can’t try to ask me out and things like that, but try some more normal things. Maybe I’m frightened that you have been trying to move too fast, or that you’ve been so serious about it. I want you to treat this like we’re both just regular people who might just get to the point where a relationship would work. Casual.”
Achilles frowned, and it was clear he was actually unhappy about this bit of advice. Will hoped he hadn’t made a mistake in how he had said it, but he knew he had to hold his ground on this. He couldn’t back down, or Achilles might decide he wasn’t serious about it. Will had to be serious about it now, or he never would be.
“I cannot promise I will be able to do that,” Achilles said at length, a tone of regret in his voice, “but I will try.”
Will nodded reassuringly. He had to tread carefully, to be sure Achilles didn’t snap and decide to just lock Will up in the basement. That would probably be easier for him than what Will was asking him to do, as unlikely as that sounded.
“That’s all I ask,” he said with a smile, “and as long as I see that you are trying, I’ll give you a chance. I’ll let you know about anything else as it comes up.” Then, without letting himself think better of it, “I really hope we can work this out.”
Will felt his face heat up slightly at the confession, but Achilles’ face lit up with renewed hope, and Will knew he was going to fall into the trap that this man seemed to be. The Chesapeake Ripper was far too tempting for Will, even though he knew every reason to stay away.
“I believe I have imposed on you for too long,” Achilles said with a note of finality, “Please allow me to drive you back to your shop.”
Will nodded and Achilles stood up from the couch. Achilles took Will’s wine glass, and Will stood to join him.
They walked into the kitchen and Achilles set both the wine glasses by the sink before he led Will back to the foyer. Achilles helped Will into his windbreaker, and they made their way out to the Bentley.
The drive back was largely uneventful, both of them silent and the only sounds being the classical music from the radio, and rain pouring over the exterior of the car.
Will glanced at his companion a few times, and saw a smattering of raindrops clinging to Achilles’ copper hair. They glistened in the reflected street lights, reminding Will of fairy handkerchiefs in early morning grass. He wanted to run his fingers through that hair and collect the tiny droplets on his fingers.
Will knew this was an extremely dangerous game he was playing, especially since he was dangerously close to letting himself actually fall for Achilles. Fall for the Chesapeake Ripper.
Achilles insisted on opening the car door for Will when they were parked at the café. Will thanked him, but could tell there was something Achilles wanted to say still, as they stood between their respective cars. They were each getting slightly soaked from the rain, but neither of them moved to leave yet, sensing the unfinished quality in the atmosphere.
“Just spit it out,” Will said eventually, surprised he had managed to not sound irritated, “I can tell there’s something you want to say, so say it.”
Achilles pressed his lips together, and he actually looked a bit nervous. He wasn’t meeting Will’s eyes, and Will thought he might actually be blushing, but it could be on account of the rain. There was another moment of silence between them before Achilles finally plucked up the courage to say what was on his mind.
“May I kiss you?” he asked.
Will blinked in surprise. Of all things, he supposed that wasn’t the last thing he had expected to hear the man say, but it still caught him off guard.
And Will knew he should say no. He had just laid down rules for their continued interactions, and kissing had not been included at all. He hadn’t said anything about this kind of thing, and hadn’t even set boundaries for them. He supposed he should be glad Achilles was asking instead of just going for it.
And Achilles’ hair was starting to flop into his face, making him look so harmless and charming.
Will sighed, raking his own hair away from his face and thinking about what he should do about this. He knew whatever he did, he could be taking a risk. He just had to decide what kind of risk he was willing or wanted to make.
Achilles was watching Will intensely as Will considered it. His dark eyes were a source of warmth among the cold rain making his clothes stick to his skin.
Will reached out and took the lapels of Achilles’ suit between his fingers. He smiled softly and pulled Achilles into a soft kiss.
It was just a quick, chaste, press of their lips, and it was exactly what Will had wanted. It was nice, and soft, and warm. Will allowed himself to enjoy it while it lasted, telling himself he would not let this happen again until he was sure Achilles was improving on his approach to their potential.
Achilles leaned forward, attempting to deepen the kiss, but Will used his strategically placed hands to push him away.
“Stop,” Will said, and Achilles froze in spot, “just that. It’s a gesture of good faith. I believe you can do this, so do it.”
Will managed to pull away and get into his car, Achilles standing in stunned silence as Will drove away.
That was probably a huge mistake. Will knew it, and he worried over it the entire drive home. He just hadn’t been able to help it. He had been trying to be reasonable the entire time. For months, he had forced himself to act with reason as much as possible. He had just wanted to let himself be delusionally selfish for a moment. Just a second.
