Actions

Work Header

White Shark Café

Chapter 11: Hunger

Chapter Text

After one beat of silence, Achilles laughed. It was a subdued sound, as if he were too polite to laugh from his belly, but Will thought it was probably the most genuine laugh he would ever hear from the man.

“My apologies,-” Achilles said, clearly having to extract Will’s name from that sentence with purpose, “I had no intention of causing you discomfort in that way. Would you prefer I call you by the name I gave you in the café?”

Will didn’t know what he had been expecting, but the sparkle in Achilles’ eyes told him he was doing well on the test, whatever that meant for his future. 

Did Will want Achilles to start calling him Patrocles , though? That hadn’t been his intention when he asked about the verbal habit, but it seemed he had backed himself into a corner. Achilles intended to continue structuring his sentences the same way, so Will just needed to decide if he wanted the man to call him by his real name or the alias. 

There was no right answer, and that was likely by design.

“It almost seems fair, doesn’t it?” Will asked, masking his internal debate and consequential nerves, “I can’t very well call you by your real name, as I don’t know it, Achilles.”

Throwing the trick back at him to illustrate his point made Achilles smile wider. It was almost as if Will couldn’t do anything to make Achilles actually upset with him. Will was starting to wonder if he should test the boundaries a bit and see if he could make Achilles angry. 

The larger part of himself screamed that he was not the only one in danger if he made this man angry. He could be putting all the regulars and Abigail in his line of fire. And that was just the people he knew immediately about. He might also go after innocent civilians and people in the FBI or local police. No one would be safe from the Chesapeake Ripper if Will managed to actually make him angry.

But the temptation was there all the same.

“Very well,” Achilles said, looking back down to his food and smiling all the while, “Then Patrocles it is. Then tell me, Patrocles, why might I want you to like and trust me? Surely you have an idea, as you were prepared to make that accusation.”

Will wanted to roll his eyes at the man. He sounded so pretentious.

“The most logical reason I can think of is that you are trying to lull me into a false sense of security. Calming the lamb before the slaughter,” he said smartly.

Achilles tipped his head curiously.

“And what does the less logical voice in your head tell you of my motivations?” he asked.

Will’s thoughts flashed back to that look of odd, intense hunger that he had seen, and what he felt it meant. He didn’t feel that he should reveal this knowledge, at least not yet. It was his last card to play, and he wanted to hold onto it until the time came.

“You are desperate for understanding. While you could accept that understanding from someone who dislikes or even hates you, you would prefer to be understood and still held in some kind of high regard. You see that I can understand you, and maybe I’m the only person you’ve ever met who can do that, so you are desperate for me to see you in a positive light, even though I know the worst about you,” Will said calmly, but firmly, “did I get that about right, Achilles?”

A fire lit in Achilles’ eyes, and they almost seemed to flash red for a moment. That hunger was back in full force, a desire so strong Will almost felt as if it were his own for a moment as it overshadowed almost everything else.

And then it was gone. Achilles was back under control, his emotions kept in careful check. 

“Very near perfection, dear Patrocles,” Achilles said conversationally, “and I cannot help but wonder what you think I stand to gain by changing our relationship from the somewhat comfortable one we had when I was nothing more than a patron of your café.”

Will considered that for a moment. 

“Perhaps you are worried you will lose my interest if you do not do something to capture my attention in a more permanent way,” he mused, “or maybe you’re just so possessive that you can’t stand the thought of any of the other regulars getting close to me. You needed to stake your claim so they wouldn’t try it. So which is it, Achilles? Are you insecure, or possessive?”

And if Will was taunting the Chesapeake Ripper, he almost didn’t regret it. He had planned to be careful, but the man’s self-assured attitude was contagious, and he was getting to the point where he almost didn’t care about the consequences of his actions. Achilles had been warned of what would happen if he hurt Abigail or Will, so he either would or wouldn’t follow that advice.

Achilles smiled, almost benignly, giving Will the impression that he was a tiger slowly stalking his prey and nearing the ambush. It was a dangerous expression, but Will refused to back down.

“There is an alternate answer that you have not stated,” Achilles said smoothly, “I believe you are quite aware of it, yet you did not offer it as an option. Is that not overtly manipulative of you, Patrocles?”

Will felt his face grow warm, but he held Achilles’ gaze. 

The other option. The other option was actually a mixture of both the others, in a way. This final option was that Achilles actually felt some form of attraction and even affection for Will, and thus was simply courting him, in the way he knew how.

The reason Will had not offered it as an option was because, of all potential options, he considered it to be the most dangerous.

With the others, Will had hope that the feeling would wane or Achilles would grow bored of the game. With this, Will could clearly see that the most likely, if not only, escape from the man would be death. Will would end up hurting the man, and because he was someone entirely unused to being capable of being hurt, the only way to alleviate that pain would be to eradicate the cause. Will would have to die.

And now, Achilles was trying very hard to make it seem like this was the reality of where they stood with each other.

Achilles was becoming vulnerable, but could turn the moment he thought Will betrayed him. Will didn’t know if he could stand much more of this.

“Are you saying the other, unspoken option is the answer you would want to give me?” Will asked, taking a drink of wine and trying to hide the slight tremor in his hand.

Achilles examined Will carefully, probably seeing the shaking despite Will’s best efforts. He seemed to be considering whether or not he could allow this to be the truth. It made Will even more nervous, seeing that Achilles had his own reservations, because it added weight to whatever the man might say next. It meant this wasn’t a game at all.

“How would it make you feel, if that is what I am saying?” Achilles asked eventually, apparently refusing to be the first to outright say what it was they both knew.

That meant it was on Will’s shoulders to finally bring an end to the macabre dance they had been doing all night, perhaps since the moment they had met.

Recognizing the obligation didn’t make it any easier for Will.

“Just the thing a psychiatrist would say,” he said dryly, drinking more wine in the hopes to gain some liquid courage, “it makes me damn nervous, honestly. I don’t know how to handle it.”

Achilles watched Will drain his glass with something akin to fascination before he rose and filled it again. The action put Achilles right over Will’s shoulder, and the man all but draped himself over the back of the chair so his presence loomed over Will.

Will could smell the man’s expensive cologne, and the wine and meat on his breath. Despite everything Will knew and believed, his heart beat faster and he felt his entire body growing warmer in such close proximity to the man.

Had Will flirted with the man? Yes. He had come to the decision that he had, and it had been intentional. But had he actually meant it to go anywhere? That was where things got a little more blurry.

There had been times, he would admit to himself, when he had actually allowed himself to consider encouraging some kind of warm attraction to grow between them. Achilles was handsome, that much was easy to admit, and Will had imagined what it might be like to run his fingers through his spun-gold hair, or kiss his elegantly Romanesque lips.

But Will feared the kind of love Achilles offered. It would burn, and bite. A killer like the Chesapeake Ripper would have love like a wild fire. Love like the hunger Will had glimpsed earlier. Will couldn’t convince himself that he would be held and loved by Achilles. He was sure he would be consumed and devoured.

Achilles pulled away and returned to his seat after what felt like an eternity, leaving Will feeling mildly sunburned, as if he had just come inside from a hot day of working outside.

“Perhaps if you voice your specific concerns, we can address them properly,” Achilles said calmly, “rather than leave it all to guesswork.”

Will took a deep breath, steadying his nerves as well as he could under the circumstances. He placed his fingers along the stem of his wine glass, not picking it up to take another drink just yet. He only watched the way the light refracted through the glass and liquid, casting stars of wavering light onto the table and his hand.

“Alright,” Will relinquished at last, “first things first. I think we should settle exactly what this is you’re doing. If we leave it all just implied and assumed, things could get messy.”

Achilles nodded, his eyes sparkling just like the wine.

“I would prefer to avoid messes,” he agreed readily, “so please, enlighten me to what you believe I am doing, so I may clear up any confusion.”

Will almost rolled his eyes. Of course Achilles was putting it back onto Will to actually say it out loud. A psychiatrist thing.

“Fine,” he said, a bit more roughly than he had intended, “I think, at least I’m mostly convinced, that you are trying to… court me… in a way you are not used to. For most people, you don’t see them as permanent, but for me you think I could be. You’ve strayed into unfamiliar territory, and you find that exciting. You’re doing your best to not scare me away, but keeping me just scared enough that I won’t lash out at you. You’re afraid of losing the game you’ve decided this is, because you realized you can get hurt.”

Will hadn’t exactly meant to say all of that, having set out just to say the bit about courting, and now he felt as if he’d slipped and shown his hand to the other man. He watched, nervously, as Achilles considered what he had said.

“Your perception has yet to do anything other than amaze me,” the man said, sounding honest, “and I confess I have not put such articulation to my motivations. Despite my negligence to do so, I would say your observations are nearly, if not perfectly accurate.”

Against what Will expected, he felt relieved to hear that he had been right. He hadn’t been worrying over nothing. He felt relieved, validated, and justified. Even though the confirmation that he was being courted by a prolific serial killer should have only frightened him more.

A memory surfaced. One Will couldn’t believe he had forgotten while he worried over his situation.

“So, when you said I’ll be yours…” he said slowly, almost not believing he was saying it.

Achilles nodded, almost reverently.

“Mind, body, and soul, I fully intend to possess you,” he said.

That did nothing to assuage Will’s feelings that this wouldn’t be the kind of relationship he wanted.

“So you are the possessive type,” Will pointed out, trying to keep himself from having a nervous breakdown, “That doesn’t sound like a healthy way to go about this, Doctor.”

Maybe that had been pushing it too far. Will saw the hunger reignite in Achilles’ eyes, and it looked like he wanted to eat Will alive, which was still probably on the table. Will felt his face warm with a blush as he realized he had sounded flirtatious. He had intended to merely remind the man that he’s a psychiatrist, hopefully making him rethink the entire situation. He had utterly failed to sound stern.

“I mean, think about all of this,” Will said, trying to reclaim his original point, “If you had a patient describe their feelings for someone the way you do for me, you’d either tell them to quit it, or you’d pity the subject of their affections. Tell me I’m wrong.”

Achilles’ expression turned pensive, losing the nearly flippant amusement he had always worn since their first meeting.

Will felt as if he had hit a nerve, or at least struck a chord within the man. Perhaps he did have a patient who had spoken that way about another person, and he was now comparing himself to them. If the slowly shifting expression on his face was anything to go by, he found the patient distasteful. Will thought he might just be getting through to the man.