Actions

Work Header

I see (you in) fire

Chapter 3: A Lull After the Storm. Part 1. A Foolish Heart

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Merciful Eru, Bilbo Baggins was by no means like the heroes of old songs and lays, and he never thought of himself as one.

With a shudder, the hobbit watched the dreadful scene unfolding before him. A scene taken straight out of his vision. Unlike the first, this one stayed with Bilbo – alas, all too clearly. Thorin was drained of all strength and could neither rise nor reach Orcrist. A pale Orc sat astride a warg, baring his teeth in something like a smile. He was drawing out the Dwarf’s death, savouring the nearness of victory. At his command another Orc lifted his sword high over Thorin.

Bilbo was full of faults: a little vain and inclined to boast, suitably grumbly, selfish and timid, not given to desperate self-sacrifice – yet now and again prone to sudden, unconsidered acts.

For a few painfully long seconds he hesitated at a distance, nervously turning Sting in his hand. He was weak and worn to the bone; in such a state he could do very little. Baggins knew exactly what ought to be done, though that did not mean he could bring himself to do it. The choice lay with him, and he made it – without having truly thought it through at all.

He worried a great deal, wavered, and of course made foolish mistakes. Bilbo was an ordinary, somewhat plump hobbit of middle years, with an unremarkable kindly face, warm brown eyes, and coppery curls, deeply attached to his home and his own quiet corner of the world.

With a sudden rush he charged headlong, bowled the Orc clean over, and drove his small sword with all his strength into the creature’s chest. He might have noticed the flash of genuine horror that crossed Thorin’s eyes at that moment, had the hobbit’s attention not been fixed on the Orcs closing in around them both – and had Thorin not soon after lost consciousness altogether.

Bilbo did not think of himself as a hero or a warrior; yet he possessed a small measure of selflessness. He was kind, pure of heart, honest, and free from greed (and, now and then, inclined to a kind gesture). In truth, he did believe in Gandalf – believed in the whole mad business of the journey, felt a fondness for Thorin and the Dwarves, and was drawn to them. He simply did what he thought was right and needful.

And also what his foolish, tender heart urged him to do.

☜ ☞

Thorin’s eyes flew open, and he pushed himself up onto his elbows. His whole body ached with pain, and sleep would not come, weariness notwithstanding. He glanced about, searching for a way out of the house. The direct path was blocked by Fili, Kili, Óin, and Glóin, snoring with great enthusiasm and almost in unison as they lay sprawled on the warm oak floor, their cloaks spread beneath them.

Oakenshield rose to his feet with some effort and picked his way around the bodies scattered here and there. Twice he stumbled over someone and muttered a hearty curse. The wooden floorboards, too, betrayed him with their creaking beneath his weight; but the members of the company, at last enjoying a long-awaited rest, did not so much as stir at such trifles.

Thorin pushed open a large dark door and stepped out onto what was something like a veranda, overlooking a garden spread with a carpet of flowers. Limping slightly, he walked without haste to a wooden bench and sank heavily onto it.

It was the twenty-first of July. The weather had turned hot and almost windless, and the nights were warm and sultry. On the horizon dawn was slowly kindling, the milky light of the moon giving way to a widening band of orange. Only the chirring of crickets and the unrestrained snoring from the house disturbed the stillness.

Thorin drew a deep breath; his nose filled with a pleasant honey-sweet, floral scent. He surveyed the grounds carefully, and, seeing nothing amiss, leaned back against the rough bench and closed his eyes. That near-maniacal watchfulness had long since become habit. His mind filled with the events and images of recent days, blending into one another: stone-giants, trolls, goblins, orcs, eagles. One captivity after another, one escape after the next, clash following clash – each of them, as Thorin stubbornly believed, drawing them closer to their final goal, to their home, Erebor.

To the Arkenstone…

To think of home was a pleasure, for Thorin had spent his happy childhood there. He liked to lose himself again in those carefree days with his younger brother Frerin, in the nursery where the rudiments of many crafts were taught through play; or to wander once more, in memory, through the wide halls of the Mountain-kingdom, richly adorned with skilful carvings and reliefs in stone, their harmonious architecture giving voice to the very soul of rock. There were often held great, boisterous feasts, with music, dancing, and singing until dawn (and sometimes for days on end), in which he, despite his tender years, took part with keen delight – playing the harp and bellowing merry songs, often quite bawdy. If nothing else, Dwarves knew how to make merry.

The mighty kingdom flourished then. Folk of many peoples came to his grandfather, King Thrór, seeking aid, and Thrór gave it freely. Yet when he himself needed help most, none came to his side.

To return home in thought was sweet – and yet so painful. Beloved memories lay buried beneath the splintered shards of a grim past; to sink into them always cost Thorin a heart cut to ribbons. The piercing cries of his kin burning alive in the dragon’s fire. A wandering family, forced to beg, to endure disdainful looks, to take on the blackest labour merely to live. The Pyrrhic victory at the Battle of Azanulbizar, and the frozen mask of terror on his brother’s death-pale face. A new exile in the Ered Luin, and the disappearance of his father. Thorin came to be proudly named the King of Durin’s Folk – but within he was only an orphan, embittered against the whole world, bearing wounds of the spirit from which he had never recovered. Nor did he wish to. They reminded him of what he fought and avenged so fiercely, and of what he must live for. Upon Thorin lay the crushing burden of responsibility for an entire people, and for a family reduced to a sister and her sons. He had forgotten nothing – neither the good nor the ill.

All who met the King under the Mountain thought him overly stern and cruel, even merciless: a calculating, greedy Dwarf without a spark of compassion. They did not consider that the open, cheerful, and level-headed Thorin – who would not spare his last shirt, nor even his one life, for his people, his friends, his family – had never chosen to become otherwise. But now he chose to remain so.

From the mire into which his thoughts were dangerously sinking, Thorin was pulled by the creak of the door leading out onto the terrace. Bilbo’s head appeared in the doorway. He took a couple of careful, soundless steps across the wooden floor toward the bench he had taken a liking to earlier that day upon arriving at Beorn’s house, but froze halfway when he noticed Oakenshield already seated there. The Dwarf, who had tensed at the sound, turned toward it – and relaxed at once on seeing the hobbit, giving him a slight nod of invitation.

Bilbo sat down at the far end of the bench and, after a little fidgeting, settled into a comfortable position and fell silent. Thorin cast another brief glance at the unexpected visitor and turned away. Along the garden fence stood rows of beehives with flat straw-thatched roofs. As dawn took hold, the garden began to fill with the hum of great bees, still lazily drifting from flower to flower.

Bilbo, meanwhile, drew from his rather crumpled waistcoat a long, curved wooden pipe and lit it. Thorin caught the sweet scent of Old Toby.[14] He himself scarcely touched pipe-weed, yet now he breathed in the soothing aroma of the fragrant galenas with pleasure.

“There will be heavy rain,” the halfling said softly, releasing another puff of smoke.

Thorin looked up at the cloudless sky of early dawn and glanced at the hobbit inquiringly.

“If the bees are lively before the sun is fully up, there’ll be a strong rain by day. It’s a saying where I come from.”

“Interesting,” Thorin murmured. He had little faith in omens – save, perhaps, those bound to the sacred Dwarvish number seven (he recalled how Dís had rejoiced at the sight of seven ravens together – good fortune), and the old superstition concerning their forefather Durin the Deathless.[15] Yet for some reason he found himself curious about other folk’s beliefs. All the more so because he had heard very little of the traditions, culture, and daily life of the halflings: a quiet, inconspicuous people, seldom seen beyond their own lands. He himself had visited them but once – and that briefly – when he sought out Baggins’ home.

“Thorin?” Bilbo called softly, drawing Oakenshield back to the present. He realised that he had been staring at the hobbit all this while. Watching the intricate column of smoke rising from the pipe-bowl, he recalled a question that had troubled him since before they had blundered into the trolls.

“Mr. Baggins,” he said, “tell me – what happened in that cave in the mountains? What frightened you so?”

Bilbo’s shoulders tightened visibly. He chewed nervously on the stem of his pipe and then took it from his mouth.

“I think I was a little… shocked,” he said at last, choosing each word with care, “by the fact that I very nearly fell off a stone-giant.” He turned the wooden bowl in his hands for a moment. “Yes. Quite so.” He bit down on the stem again and fell silent.

It seemed to Thorin that the hobbit was trying to convince himself of something more than stating it as certain; but he did not wish to press the matter. With only a slight nod in reply, Oakenshield returned to his contemplation of the garden.

A few minutes passed before the hobbit spoke again.

“Thorin, thank you – for saving me then… and before that as well.”

Bilbo looked a little embarrassed, yet his gaze met the King’s with steady, boundless gratitude. Thorin shook his head. It was not Baggins who ought now to be offering thanks, but Thorin himself.

“You have done far more for me, though you had little reason to do so. I am in your debt, Mr. Burglar.”

Seeing Bilbo falter slightly, Thorin wished to say more – but could not. He promised himself that he would prove his deep gratitude by deeds, since words had failed him.

When the sun had fully risen above the horizon, the rolling thunder of snores from the house gave way to the sounds of stirring and the voices of dwarves, soon joined by the Wizard’s. Thorin heard his own name mentioned more than once and rose reluctantly from his seat. Bilbo had long since finished his Toby and dozed off unnoticed. At the sight of the halfling’s comically nodding head, the corners of Thorin’s mouth twitched in the faintest hint of a smile. As quietly as he could (though that was properly their Burglar’s domain, not a dwarf’s), he made for the door and slipped inside, joining the general bustle.

Far away in the sky, lightning flashed, and thunder rolled.

Notes:

[14]For more on pipe-weed (often called “tobacco”) in Middle-earth, see: https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Pipe-weed [return to text]

[15]On the reincarnations of Durin the Deathless, see:https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Durin_I [return to text]