Chapter Text
Bilbo knew perfectly well that Thorin, in his current state, was a danger. Not only to Baggins himself, but to the other dwarves of their company as well – those whose loyalty he had begun to question, convinced that one of them had stolen his beloved Arkenstone (the sheer thought of it – he even suspected his own nephews). Bilbo did not know how far Oakenshield’s madness might carry him, but he feared that if nothing were done, Thorin would destroy both himself and those around him.
His heart hammered wildly in his chest. By the time Bilbo reached Erebor and climbed up the makeshift rope lowered from the wall of the Great Gate, dawn was already breaking. There was scarcely any time left to warn the dwarves of the danger closing in, and do it without running into the mad king himself. He slipped past the half-asleep Bombur on watch without difficulty and vanished into the Mountain. He meant to find Balin.
The hobbit hurried through the cunning tangle of stairways and, first of all, cautiously peered into the armoury. The last time he had seen the dwarves, they had been there, fast asleep, and Bilbo had seized the chance to steal quietly out of Erebor to do what he should have done long ago – to be rid of the cursed stone at last. Now the armoury stood empty.
What drove Baggins to this desperate step was the vision he had seen. In the camp, Gandalf had remarked in passing that Bilbo had been “fortunate” enough to receive true foresight. By Bilbo’s reckoning, the wizard had a rather odd idea of good fortune, for what he had seen filled him with sheer horror. Hordes of orcs. Mountains of corpses. Fili and Kili dead. Thorin mortally wounded. Whoever had sent this “gift” from on high had spared no effort this time, laying it on thick and forcing Bilbo to live through a waking nightmare. Dori and Nori had barely managed to drag him away from the fire when he tried to throw himself into it, hoping to smother the flames with his own body.
A masterstroke, really. Madness must be catching. Whoever had stirred up this whole business with visions must have nearly dropped dead when all his careful work almost went straight to the wargs. The thought made the hobbit give a hysterical little laugh. He had already searched a third familiar hall, but Balin was nowhere to be found. Bilbo began to shiver, panic rising in his gut. He stopped behind one of the pillars along the road leading to the Throne Room, trying to catch his breath and gather his thoughts. Balin could be anywhere – but so far, he was nowhere. As if the ground had swallowed him whole.
Bilbo was weighing his next move when the echo of heavy footsteps rang beneath the vaulted ceiling. He froze. The Throne Room was the king’s second favourite place after the treasure hoard, so there was a very good chance that whoever was coming out now was Thorin himself. For a moment Bilbo dearly wished he could simply melt into the pillar, but he forced himself to lean out from cover. In the torchlight, a bald head gleamed above a stocky frame.
Dwalin!
Not at all who he had been hoping to see – but beggars could not be choosers.
Balin’s younger brother was not known for his gentle nature even on his best days, and now he radiated such pure, undiluted fury that Bilbo regretted his decision to whisper his name a thousand times over. His relationship with Fundin’s son had never been especially warm, but after Bilbo had proved his loyalty to the dwarves’ cause, Dwalin had thawed and even begun to show him a fair measure of respect. Besides, Bilbo thought it highly unlikely that the Dragon-sickness had taken hold of him so deeply. He would never squander the wealth of his people – but if forced to choose between gold and the defence of his homeland and kin, he would choose the latter without hesitation.
At first, Dwalin could not tell where the mouse-like squeak was coming from. Then he spotted the hobbit, for some reason lurking behind a pillar and beckoning him closer.
“Bilbo, I don’t know what you’re up to, but you shouldn’t be here. Thorin has completely lost his mind.”
Oh, really? And here he was, completely unaware.
“Dwalin, we need to find the others – now. You have no idea what’s about to break loose outside the walls of Erebor.”
At Bilbo’s request, Dwalin led him first to what passed for the group’s brain trust – his elder brother. Baggins’s account of the vision was no simple thing, and its meaning needed to be explained to the sharpest mind among the dwarves who still had their senses about them. Besides, Balin was the one dwarf – though not without misgivings – to whom Bilbo would first entrust the crucial detail of where the Arkenstone was.
“I wish that stone had never been found.” Bilbo was not entirely in agreement with the grey-bearded dwarf’s words, spoken during one of their recent conversations. Without the Arkenstone, they had no chance of saving Thorin from himself. He had lived for so long with the dream of reclaiming Erebor and the throne of the King under the Mountain – whose symbol of power was that ill-fated gem – that it had consumed him utterly when he drew dangerously close to the object of his desire. Bilbo did not object to returning the diamond to Thorin; it was his by right, and no one – least of all some hobbit – had any standing to deny that. What he opposed was Thorin receiving it now, in the heat of the moment, when he could no longer clearly judge what he truly wanted: to be a king, or a pitiful shadow of one.
Balin, together with Ori, was found in the last place Bilbo would have thought to look – the library. He drew the bewildered dwarf aside and told him everything that had happened in the camp. Balin knit his brows and searched Bilbo’s face, as though seeking proof of his words.
“Balin, I know you can’t leave Erebor to fight and abandon Thorin in this state, and I’m not asking you to do that. Nor am I asking you to forgive me. I’m only asking you to remind Thorin who he is, and what he has been fighting for all this time. And to help save him.”
Balin shook his head heavily.
“Bilbo, there is nothing we can do right now. Neither I nor any of us doubt the truth of what you say, or… the goodness of your intentions. But tell me – why are you so sure Thorin can overcome the sickness?”
That was when Bilbo finally decided to tell the dwarf what he had left unsaid in the camp. One detail from the vision had little bearing on how the future might unfold, but that was not the only reason he had kept it from Gandalf.
“Because I know what he said to me before he died.”
But because remembering it hurt more than he could bear.
Balin and Bilbo agreed not to share the details of Thorin’s death – or Fili’s and Kili’s – with the entire company. Only the least impressionable dwarves and the most seasoned warriors were told, those who could keep an eye on the trio and prevent them from turning into a suicide squad. Everything else, including the matter of the Arkenstone (at Balin’s insistence), he volunteered to explain to the others himself. Signalling to Ori and Dwalin, they left the library together and made their way toward one of the chambers near the main entrance, where, according to Dwalin, the rest of the Company was gathered.
After everyone involved had been told the details of the vision, Bilbo wanted to remain with the dwarves in Erebor. Balin dissuaded him – though not without effort. He feared that if Thorin learned the hobbit had taken the Arkenstone, he might, in a fit of rage, try to kill him. Attempts on Bilbo’s life had somehow become far more frequent of late. He really ought to have taken Balin’s warning seriously, but Bilbo answered it with a mischievous chuckle. The dwarf’s words deserved belief; still, the adrenaline that had kept him going for months now had dulled his instinct for self-preservation to a dangerous degree.
Bifur was due to relieve Bombur shortly and offered to escort Bilbo to the Great Bastion. As they climbed over the stones with which the dwarves had barricaded the main gate, elven horns sounded from outside. Thranduil had arrived at Erebor with part of his host – and with Bard.
“So soon… They’ve come with the Arkenstone so soon…” Bilbo whispered.
He and Bifur exchanged a glance and broke into a run, but they were already too late to do anything. Bombur, unaware of the dwarves’ conversation with the hobbit, sounded his horn to summon his brothers to the wall. They answered the call.
And with them came the king.
☜ ☞
Paraphrasing a well-known saying in Middle-earth: love and hate are just one Arkenstone apart.
Bilbo could tell himself a thousand times over that Thorin, even in his madness, would not truly do him harm, and beat his chest swearing he was not afraid of the king’s insanity. He could imagine Oakenshield hurling insults at him once he learned what had been done. He could picture him grabbing Bilbo by the front of his coat, shaking him hard like a kitchen towel, and hissing that he never wanted to see him again. He could even entertain the unlikeliest thought of all – that perhaps the sickness would lift at that very moment. Deep down, he had never fully believed either Gandalf or Balin, who spoke with one voice of Thorin’s deadly danger, and he thought himself ready for whatever might come.
But he was not.
He was not ready to see raw pain on Thorin’s face, shining through the haze. He had never once seen even the faintest hint of tears in Oakenshield’s eyes, believing that if Thorin had ever been capable of them, they had long since been spent on the suffering that had befallen his family and his people. All the more startling it was to glimpse their trace now. Why now, of all times?
For reasons Bilbo himself could not quite explain, he had remained the last of their group whom Thorin trusted almost blindly, even through the darkness of madness. Most likely because Thorin naively assumed that a hobbit would not steal his gold precisely because he was a hobbit – someone who cared nothing for the treasures of Erebor. Imagine that: he trusted a burglar, whom he himself had hired for that honourable post, more than his own kin and brothers-in-arms. Bilbo would have given anything not to lose the trust of a dwarf dear to him – but instead he betrayed him, and gave everything up in order to save him. And yet even betrayal should not have cut Oakenshield so deeply, not even in the grip of the sickness. After all, Bilbo was only a common burglar, hardly so vital a part of Thorin’s life. The whole thing made no sense. What kind of madness was this?
He was not ready, either, for the helpless anger that surged in him when he realised that the Thorin he had known had dissolved completely into greed and bitterness. Bilbo could not believe that the famed King under the Mountain was so weak that his own vows and principles meant nothing to him – no more than the loyalty of his brothers, which he had cast aside the moment they helped him reclaim Erebor. And that his own heart, which Bilbo had dared to place on Thorin’s scales against the “Heart of the Mountain,” proved lighter and less valuable than some stone.
And though Baggins had been warned that Oakenshield might well wish him dead, he still reeled when the king ordered him thrown from the battlement. No one was about to carry out the command, but Thorin was nothing if not decisive – and meant to finish it himself. He did not succeed. By some miracle, Gandalf arrived in time to stop him, and the dwarves helped Bilbo escape.
Events on the bastion unfolded so quickly that Bilbo scarcely had time to grasp what was happening. Only later, once he had put a safe distance between himself and Erebor, did he realise with surprise that the only things he had felt while Thorin dangled him halfway over the edge were a meagre flicker of fear and an overwhelming indifference. It did not hurt. He simply did not care. Toward the king who had tried to kill him, Bilbo felt nothing but pity and distaste; he did not know this Thorin, did not trust him, and so his actions could not truly wound him. Except by killing him, perhaps – but thankfully, it had not come to that.
All that remained was to hope that none of it had been in vain. And that they would yet manage to keep Thorin from dying – and from dragging Fili and Kili with him into the Halls of Mahal.
