Chapter Text
Eru the One, Ilúvatar, allowed the offspring of his thought – the Ainur – to behold the Great Music they were making for him. From those visions the World was born: Eä, into which some of the Ainur entered of their own will and came to be known as the Valar. Yet the World that stood before them in the mind of the Creator was still an illusion – a future that had yet to be given Being.
Before the making of the World, there were not only the Valar. The people of the Valar, their helpers and servants – the Maiar – were less mighty than the Ainur who entered Eä, yet greater than all others. The wisest of the Maiar known to the peoples of Middle-earth was Olórin, who in visible form became a friend to all the Children of Ilúvatar and was known among them as Mithrandir, or Gandalf. From him sprang worthy impulses and fair visions, and by his words hearts were lifted from despair and sorrow.
When the shadow of Sauron’s return fell once more upon the world, the Istari – the Wizards – appeared in the west of Middle-earth, and among them was Gandalf the Grey. At the Great Council, convened to decide what should be done, Gandalf spoke words that would one day lead him to the Shire, to one remarkable hobbit. Bilbo.
“Many are the strange chances of the world,” Mithrandir said to his good friend Elrond, “and help oft shall come from the hands of the weak when the Wise falter.”[30]
Gandalf would at times foresee what was to come – whether through sudden insight or through his own keen foresight – and at times could even bend the course of events by his own efforts. Yet there were matters that even the Valar, who knew much, could not know; and if so, what could be said of him? The visions of the Great Music were not a precise prophecy. Ilúvatar revealed all his designs to none, and in every Age new and unforeseen things appeared. Hobbits, for instance.
Mithrandir knew that true insight, not founded on obvious causes or sober logic, could also descend upon the Children of Eru. Their own minds were shaped by lived experience and held no knowledge of the future in themselves, though they could at times make astonishingly accurate predictions, drawing on judgment, learning, and a keen sense of cause and effect. But such “prophecies” did not always come to pass, nor could they account for what could not be seen without knowledge of the Design.
Of the future, such a mind could learn only from another mind – one that beheld the Design of Eru. Such a guide might, in the end, be Ilúvatar himself, or the Valar, who saw a greater part of His purpose.
True insight took many forms: troubling dreams or waking visions, shapes of things to come upon the surface of water, a call of the heart, verses veiled in riddles, or clear and precise messages. They might be vague or exact; they might be unconditional – events that would come to pass exactly as foretold, regardless of any circumstance – or conditional, allowing for two or more outcomes, shaped by the choices and actions of particular individuals.
So when a shaken, breathless Bilbo appeared before Gandalf by night in the camp of the Elves and the Men of Lake-town, pitched beneath the walls of Erebor among the ruins of Dale, clutching the Arkenstone and stumbling through a tale of having seen something three times already in the fire, Gandalf was not surprised. Yet the more measured conversation that followed – after two mugs of tea and a bowl of fish stew had finally calmed the hobbit – stirred a genuine curiosity in the Wizard.
Bilbo’s first “vision” Olórin, not without some satisfaction, privately credited to his own efforts. He had sought to awaken the Took within Baggins, and by all appearances he had succeeded. Given Bilbo’s lively imagination – about which Belladonna Took-Baggins had once spoken to Gandalf – such fiery illusions were hardly unexpected. Mixed with the vivid impressions of his first meeting with the dwarves and Gandalf’s own gift of persuasion, Bilbo’s subconscious seemed simply to have conjured in the hearth an image he had already painted in his mind.
At first, the Istar could get no clear account from the exhausted Baggins of the other two visions and hastily dismissed them as well as products of an overexcited imagination, stirred by emotion. And while the second illusion could indeed be explained in much the same way, the most recent vision – seen in Erebor itself – caught his attention more than any other. It held details Bilbo could not possibly have known, nor heard, nor seen.
The inflamed mind of an impressionable Baggins – especially after all he had endured over the past month in Erebor – might well have foreseen Thorin Oakenshield’s death. Of all his kin, Thorin seemed to Gandalf the most sensible, yet he was a creature of extremes: great secrecy and suspicion, prudence and caution, standing side by side with reckless, “heroic” plunges taken without thought. Fili and Kili followed their uncle everywhere; fear for their deaths, too, was not unfounded. By the same token, drawing on grim experience and his own conclusions, Bilbo might have foreseen that Azog – or any other orc – could kill them all.
But he could not possibly have known where it would happen, nor that the orc host would be split in two. Gandalf had expected that Azog’s legion would soon march from Dol Guldur – the fortress in the southwest of Mirkwood – against Erebor, but he had not foreseen reinforcements from the northern stronghold of Gundabad, led by Bolg, spawn of the Defiler. From Bilbo’s account, Azog was to draw the forces of elves, men, and dwarves into battle until Bolg arrived from Ravenhill, where the orcs would slay Thorin and his nephews.
“Bilbo, true insight is rare,” Gandalf said gently. “Those it finds are not always ready for what it brings. To an unprepared mind it can cause great pain and confusion, especially when it foretells death. But I beg you – do not despair. Your vision is a gift. It gives us an advantage our enemies know nothing of.”
Gandalf smiled at Bilbo, lifted his hand from the hobbit’s shoulder, and leaned on Radagast’s staff. Despite the biting December wind and the snow on the ground, they had stepped out of Thranduil’s warm tent at Bilbo’s request; he wished to speak in private. The hobbit stood beside him, head bowed, clenching and unclenching his fists without thought. Gandalf knew what weighed on him, yet he could no more promise that all would be well than he could have at the journey’s beginning. He did not know whether Bilbo’s vision was conditional or not – but he knew that if they did nothing, there would be only one outcome, and it would be a bitter one.
“We will do all we can to save Thorin and his nephews. Of that you may be sure. Thanks to you, we may yet have a chance to shape what is to come.”
Baggins thawed a little and looked up at him with hope. Gandalf answered with an encouraging nod and glanced back toward the tent. There was still much to be settled: the matter of the Arkenstone, for one, and the far greater problem of uniting the scattered and embittered forces – dwarves on one side, elves and men on the other. The Istar sighed heavily. It would not be easy.
To his relief, matters went better than he had expected. Bilbo made a remarkable move, handing the gem over to Thranduil and Bard. The hobbit believed it might be used to pressure the King under the Mountain and avert open conflict, but Gandalf had known from the start that this plan would fail. The true value of showing the Arkenstone to Oakenshield lay elsewhere: it might yet draw him back from madness, restore his reason, and force him to see the situation clearly.
Olórin believed Thorin was capable of that. Dwarves were stubborn, but they were no cowards, and they did not shirk battle when the matter touched them directly. As it did now. If Thorin refused to come to their aid, he would lose Erebor once more – and his entire goup with it, for they could not withstand an orc assault alone if elves and men were defeated. The mad King under the Mountain had shut himself within his halls and would hear no one. All that remained was hope that Thorin would hear them.
Beyond the Arkenstone, Gandalf faced another problem: how to dissuade Thranduil and Bard from rash action after the King under the Mountain’s first response to their “generous bargain.” Once again, his dear hobbit came to his aid – more precisely, Bilbo’s vision. Bard had been inclined from the start to seek a peaceful settlement, especially with danger drawing near. The Lord of Mirkwood, however, flatly refused to heed Gandalf’s warnings about the orcs. Dwarves are stubborn by nature, elves by choice – and which is worse is hard to say, Mithrandir grumbled inwardly, nettled by Thranduil’s lofty manner.
The vision shook Thranduil’s distrust. The minds of the elves, unclouded by the influence of Melkor, were more open than those of others to the great minds beyond them, and among the peoples of Eä they possessed an unmatched capacity for true insight. They also knew its nature and its power well.
Thranduil listened closely as the hobbit recounted the heart of the prophecy, following Gandalf’s advice and omitting only the deaths of Thorin, Fili, and Kili. The Elvenking already suspected that the Wizard’s warnings were driven merely by his wish to save “his dear dwarves”; there was no need to press the point.
At last, after some thought, the King made his decision. He lifted his pale, unreadable eyes to Gandalf and gave a barely perceptible nod. Olórin let out a breath he had not realized he was holding and broke into a smile: they had just secured the support of Mirkwood’s army in the coming battle. Now it was time to shape a general plan. After exchanging a few words with Bard and Thranduil, Gandalf left them to work out their strategy and stepped out of the tent, taking Bilbo with him. Two important matters remained.
The Istar knew he would be placing the hobbit in grave danger if he asked him to return to Erebor and warn the dwarves of Oakenshield’s company, who had not yet lost the last shreds of their modest reason. Yet only Bilbo could slip in unseen – and persuade them to act. Over the course of the journey they had grown close, and they would not ignore the words of their dear Burglar.
“I’m not afraid of Thorin, Gandalf,” Bilbo said. “I wanted to go back anyway.”
Gandalf frowned. The hobbit’s resolve troubled him no less than the battle to come.
“You should be afraid. Never underestimate the power of gold. Dragon-sickness takes hold of the hearts of all who come too close to what the serpent once possessed. Almost all,” he added, seeing Bilbo’s stubborn determination and realizing his warning had not made the hobbit more cautious. “Do not let Thorin see you, Bilbo. He is not himself and capable of anything. You must keep your wits about you.”
There was no time for long farewells. Gandalf let Baggins go, hoping to see him again – safe and whole. He watched him for a long moment, thoughtful, and then turned back into the camp, where he had left his horse.
One last task remained. The strength of the elves and the men – exhausted by the sudden burdens of the past month – was clearly not enough to turn the tide of the coming battle. They needed help. And Gandalf knew where to seek it. No one hated orcs more than Beorn, whose family Azog had nearly wiped out, enslaving those who survived. All that remained was to get word to him in time.
