Chapter Text
For six days and nights the winds howled unrelentingly. Snow piled against the ramparts, growing deeper and deeper until opening even windows became next to impossible (not that you’d want to: even just a moment in front of an open window was apt to leave you coated in a layer of snow). By the end of the first week, the dwarves (and hobbit) of Erebor had resigned themselves to a long, cold winter and finding ways to manage the heavy cloak of snow and ice that Erebor now wore around its shoulders. Each dawn brought only more clouds, an endless shroud obscuring everything beyond the mountain.
Inside Erebor the air grew thin, and morale fell despite itself. The light-and-mirror tunnels, another of Erebor’s ancient marvels of engineering, remained partially clogged with snow despite the best efforts of the labouring dwarves. Some corridors were now so dim that you needed old oil lamps to find your way along them: others were only partially clogged, which left the halls in a grey and unpleasant twilight, cold and unwelcoming. The air was chill enough that breath fogged in front of the face all hours of the day, gathering in cold, damp droplets on any fabric held too close to the skin, making things all the worse. Clothing layers were shared out, but no matter how well wrapped you were there was always the sensation of never quite being warm enough.
The dwarves of the young re-settlement – barely two hundred strong, besides the original company – learned swiftly the measure of their rations and the cost of this strange confinement. During the first week, the disruption was most obvious in the forges. Several had been closed down as per Bilbo’s planning, but key ones remained for heating the pipes, and they needed constant feeding. The air-shafts that kept the furnaces breathing were narrowed by ice, and they found themselves forced to keep clearing it as best they could, in the meantime keeping the fires low to avoid smoke backing up, gathering in rooms and staining stone dark and oily. The glow of the furnaces was dimmed and the rooms darker than normal, and although no dwarf would have dreamed of complaining, you could feel the restless energy, like static in the air. The dwarves in the first caravans were hard workers, those used to physical toil and complex activity. Most found themselves unable to complete their normal activities and wandered aimlessly unless they were needed to clear snow, idle for the first time in decades. It was at first mildly amusing, and then increasingly alarming to Bilbo as he watched tempers fray. In the end, he sought out who he knew could be best trusted to lift spirits.
Bofur's hat flaps were now tied under his chin in his efforts to keep warm, but in all other regards seemed to be handling the low temperatures well. Bilbo wasn't sure if that was because he didn't feel the cold much, or if it was because of some secret layering of clothes he wasn't privy to. Either way, Bofur took to the task that Bilbo had brought to him with good cheer. He seemed to know every dwarf by name and spent the days finding those who looked in need of some company, either to vent or just for some reassurance and kindness. He diffused tensions in groups with his songs – some old and steeped in tradition, some improvised in the moment. They filled the halls in the evening, easing tempers and relaxing those in the worst of moods. He encouraged some of the others too: at his request, Balin told long tales when the evenings were stretching long—old histories of Durin’s line, tales of Moria before its fall, stories seeped in the warmth of history and shared belonging that never failed to make something ache deep in Bilbo’s chest.
“You’re very good with people,” Bilbo told him, quite sincerely. “You know how to talk to everyone, and make them feel better. It’s really quite impressive. I could have done with you in some difficult family situations, you know. I’ll have to make sure you have invitations to all the Shire functions when I return.”
Bofur grinned, though there was an edge of tension to it. “Well, don’t rush off home then. No doubt I’ll be needed here a time.”
Bilbo didn't have an answer to that: he could feel the real request to stay buried underneath, and he didn't know how to respond to it.
Bofur made sure to stop by wherever Bilbo was at least once a day, to share a cup of tea and a chat, and it took Bilbo an embarrassing amount of time to realise that Bofur was checking in on him as well.
The snow finally eased at the end of the first week: one morning, they awoke to a strange quiet, almost unnatural compared to the winds that had been their constant companion for the last seven nights. Looking out of some of the few windows that remained unblocked showed them a landscape transformed in shades of grey and white and blue: a vast, pale sky above them, and a world around them carpeted in snow so deep that in some places entire familiar trees had been covered. Distant smoke was the only marker of Dale, hidden by this deep blanket: Bilbo worried for them, but at the end of the day, they might have been in another world for all the help he could give them right now. For a brief moment, the dwarves celebrated their freedom, until they realised that the great gates of Erebor were absolutely impassable. All other known exits were equally sealed by ice or buried, and though some windows could be forced open, to what end? The land outside was impassable, and it would be impossible to bring back any substantial supplies. Even worse was the temperature. The dwarves dug out old thermometers and assumed at first they must be broken, as the temperature they showed was bitterly low. It was only when the ravens confirmed that one of their own had perished, freezing instantly to death when risking leaving their new home in the dovecote, that they realised they read true. The risk to any one person was significant enough that Thorin refused to allow any dwarf to leave the mountain (though no one was particularly keen to do so in the first pla).
A team of dwarves was dispatched to explore whether any external doors could be opened, but the main gates were quickly abandoned. Instead, they focused on the smaller doors (and Bilbo had been surprised to realise that there had been other doors into the Mountain, after all the faff with the secret door (although in hindsight, what kind of a city would only have one exit?), but it had emerged that most of the other entrances had either been destroyed in the dragon attack or in subsequent rockslides caused by the movements of the dragon, so would have been impossible for the Company to use. This had been what had caused such a huge number of deaths, as dwarves in large sections of the city had no route to evacuate. Clearing those entrances had been one of the earliest priorities of the Ereborians. Miners, builders and engineers examined routes, some of them only recently cleared, to ascertain what their options were. No one was saying it, but all were concerned about what would happen if there were a fire. It might seem unlikely with the cold, but on the off-chance that something caught, they needed to know that there was a way to escape the Mountain.
The dwarves of Erebor were cautious about fire.
Two routes were cleared by the end of the second week, both slightly awkward and narrow, but enough to reassure the dwarves that they would be able to get out should they need it in the event of an emergency. Some of the younger dwarves tried to venture outside, just to see what it was like, only to sink into snow banks taller than they were. It seemed fun and games for a brief moment until the snow collapsed onto one of them, and a panicked ten minutes was spent digging them out, thankfully none the worse for wear.
Thorin had not been impressed.
The cold did not shift the next day, nor the next. Frost gathered on the edges of stone pillars. The youngest dwarves wrapped woollen scarves around their beards as they shuffled through the corridors, breath steaming. The stores of food, carefully laid but not meant for a siege from the very elements, dwindled slowly despite the careful eye kept on them. Salted meats were carved thin. The cave mushrooms, coaxed from trays in a side-hall under deliberately dim lamps, grew slower in the cold. Stews and porridges were made thin, and bowls small. That, coupled with the cold which made sleeping a struggle for many dwarves, were also impacting the health of the dwarves.
One day Bilbo and Oin, exploring the old medical buildings, found several crates of dried pine needles, stored for burning, Oin explained: the resin in the pine kept illnesses at bay and purified the air.
“Is that something we should be worried about?” Bilbo asked, seeing the considering look in Oin’s eyes. The old dwarf looked tired: he had been pressed into caring for a huge number of the dwarves, whose bones were struck by the cold. Muscles seized in the night, cold water made teeth and heads ache, and frostbite was a legitimate concern. He was particularly gruff about the cold, muttering loudly about how no dwarf ought to be able to see his breath inside his own home. Still, he had a knack for concocting warming salves, and though dwarves were hardy, they understood well enough that their bodies were their most essential tool, and they reported to Oin for advice and care.
“Cold weather keeps a lot away,” Oin replied thoughtfully. “But large numbers of bodies close together, and air that doesn’t move much, is always a risk.”
They started burning them in the evening, when the dwarves were gathered together. The smell of it made him think of home, of those pine wreaths in his hair and branches burning on the fire, of old yuletide hobbit traditions, of warm drinks and hot food and the press of familiar bodies on either side of him as he walked, hand-in-hand with his parents, through an array of hobbit festivals and events. When he closed his eyes and breathed deep he was that same hobbit again, now so unfamiliar it might have been a dream, fussy and easily tired, alone and content. Sometimes, when he opened his eyes again, he didn’t know who he was, or where in time. Disconsolate and alone he would sneak away early, sometimes using his ring to avoid his friends, and hide under the covers in the bed he now awkwardly shared with Thorin.
As for Thorin, the King held council each morning beneath on the surviving statues of Durin, in an old council room. He spoke in low, calm tones with different dwarves, those who brought him updates. Balin was a great help, with a keen mind for strategy and a good understanding of how best to manage the overall situation, and Thorin looked to him often for advice. Gloin had taken overall responsibility for resource management and had an excellent head for numbers. He managed the tracking of fuel, and daily checked in with every team managing the furnaces. His reports were long and frustrated and surprisingly hilarious, each one with sections written in the style of ancient poems detailing the ongoing battle against the nefarious enemy, insufficient fuel. When the mood grew too serious, he would often launch into these – quite poorly written – poems, dramatic enough to make even Thorin laugh.
“Has he always been like this?” Bilbo asked Balin, as Gloin laughed with Thorin. “He seemed much more serious during the journey – though I suppose there wasn’t as much to laugh at.”
Balin stroked his beard, smiling to himself. “It’s been odd, those of us related to Thorin and Dis. We’re part of the line of Durin, enough to have responsibility but distant enough that the brunt of the burden never fell on us. When we were younger, it was always Gloin that would make my younger cousins sneak out and have some fun – I had to cover for them more than once. He had less of a chance to do that, of late. Perhaps he’s taking the opportunity to do that again, now Thorin has reclaimed our home.”
Ledgers littered the great table that served as the command centre, numerous eyes reviewing the numbers of the fuel, the food, the levels of the water tanks, the updates from the guards and ravens and the dwarves made responsible for ensuring that the furnaces didn’t fail. Fili stayed carefully by his shoulder, watching everything through his one good eye, always just a touch too close to his uncle as if he were afraid that one of them would falter and need propping up. Bilbo wondered, sometimes, which one of them Fili was afraid for. They were all of them transforming, each dwarf he knew so well growing and changing to fit the world around them, but despite the changes, they still felt like the dwarves he knew and loved, only somehow more so.
In the evenings, Bilbo saw a different version of the king than the one presented to the rest of the dwarves.
Sharing a room was awkward at first. Bilbo would often come in to find Thorin standing stiffly, arms crossed, as if he were guarding the room from intruders or simply didn’t know what to do with himself. Bilbo found himself fussing more in response, despite himself, as if trying to prove that he was not unsettled by Thorin’s presence. He found himself worrying over the straightness of the blankets, the cleanliness of the floor, muttering aloud about the lack of hobbit amenities and good quality tea, speaking aloud his inane concerns to fill the strange silence between them. He didn’t even care about these things, not really: they belonged to a past life, to a version of himself that had died somewhere between mountain road and darkened wood, but pulling the coat of a past-self on again felt like an easy disguise for his own disquiet. Silence stretched and ached between them when they could not think of what to say, and for the first few nights sometimes they went to bed without exchanging words, though often Bilbo found himself waking wrapped in Thorin’s arms.
But eventually they fell into a comfortable rhythm. Bilbo had been sent a chest of dried leaves from Bard shortly before the storm hit, a wide range of herbs exchanged with different travellers or harvested from the local lands. It was a gift in silent thanks for Bilbo’s support and the Arkenstone, though they didn’t speak of it. None of them were really fit for the kitchens or he would have given them over, but the cooks had declined when they were offered.
Bilbo was trying different combinations to find ideal tea blends, and to his surprise, Thorin was happy to assist him with the task. After the long days spent meeting with dwarves, working through complex logistics, supporting other dwarves and trying to maintain morale, there was a comfort in retreating to the small, warm-ish room. Bilbo would heat water on the closest furnace, and then run the old iron kettle back, wrapped in blankets to try and conserve the heat. They would steep whatever leaves Bilbo had mixed for the occasion, and as their silences became more comfortable, their conversations came more easily.
They spoke mostly of small things at first—of Dale’s latest trade methods, of the food cellars Bilbo insisted needed better labelling, of the stories Balin had told the night before. But as the snow lay thicker and the days blurred together, the conversations deepened. Thorin told him of his childhood, a prince of a plentiful kingdom, of adventures sought with brother and sister through the echoing halls of the palace. He told Bilbo about his brother, who had Fili's hair and Dis' smile, and who Thorin missed every day. He spoke of his sister, his fear of seeing her once again warring with how desperately he longed to embrace her, and how he didn't know how he would face her after nearly killing her sons. He spoke of his mother, and the silver chains of her beard, and the great pearl she had worn from the tip of it that glowed a thousand colours in different lights. He talked of his apprenticeships and learning, hours spent with old masters who did not tolerate poor behaviour just because he wore an heir’s coronet, and how much he had appreciated that. He did not speak much of his father or grandfather, but sometimes things slipped through, and Bilbo could hear the old ache in his voice.
It was easy to listen to Thorin: something in the tone of his voice made some deep pain in his chest settle. It had been Thorin’s voice, all that time ago, that had made a fussy old hobbit believe he could be someone else, someone who went on adventures and saw the world.
In return Bilbo told him tales of the Shire, of his own youth spent running through gentle landscapes, dipping his feet into the quiet, slow waters of the Brandywine. He told him about his mother’s herb lore, imparted to him as he peered over the top of the kitchen counter, and his father’s vegetable patch, and numerous relatives that pinched his cheeks and showed him how to braid flowers into his hair. He told him how he had longed for siblings but had learned to enjoy his own company instead, and the way as a child he had once walked through Bag End trying to find every bit of wood that his father had carved two entwined B's onto, for Bungo and Belladonna. He told him of the high days and traditions of the Shire, and what the earth there felt like underfoot when the root vegetables were ready for digging up. He told him of harvest festivals, corn dolls, and the crop burnings, and watching the fleet-footed wild hares speed across the fields like the shadows of birds to escape the smoke.
When they spoke to each other like this, in the quiet late nights, Bilbo was reminded of the soft intimacy his parents had shared. He remembered seeing them, sat in their armchairs in front of the fire, his mother’s feet curled up underneath her and his father’s pipe smouldering in his hands, and the way the firelight caught the planes of their faces, painting them in coppers and golds, in a world of their own. But there wasn’t anything between him and Thorin, Bilbo knew. Sure, he sometimes dreamed of the way Thorin’s arms had felt around him that moment on the Carrock. And that soft, distant memory of Thorin’s voice haunted his quiet moments, when he was lost in his own mind and thinking of his home and who had been.
And yes, perhaps he had thought that there might be something between them, before the Arkenstone and the battle, when Thorin had handed him that mithril shirt and looked at him like he was the only person in the world. But then Bilbo had betrayed him and Thorin had slipped into that strange madness, and though they had settled everything between them since, things had changed. Water passes under the bridge, but that means that the water is no longer the same.
They had what they had, and that would be enough. Besides, he was planning on leaving soon, and returning to the Shire, and all of this would turn into a distant memory. Better to leave things sweet and unspoken, and be glad that they had slowly regained being comfortable together, than dwell on what else they might have once become, in a different time.
One evening, Thorin brought with him a bundle wrapped in dark cloth and sat on the floor despite the chill coming through the stone. Inside was a set of small, delicate tools, and a selection of jewellery, tarnished now and damaged.
“I went to find my mother’s rooms today,” he said quietly. “I hadn’t thought much of them until recently, and they were in quite a poor state. But I found some of her jewels, among the debris. I couldn’t find her pearl – I suppose she must have been wearing it. But there were other things I recognised, even if they are damaged now.”
He didn’t say anything more as he laid out the tools, and then, with a precision that seemed almost like magic to Bilbo, began to repair things, and Bilbo remembered what Thorin had told him, that he had been apprenticed to the jeweller’s guild, as his father had been before him. His movements were sure and steady, and there was something almost automatic in them, as if he had done this so many times that he was able to slip into that quiet, ground space in your mind, where your thoughts simmer down to a background rumble and everything feels calm and peaceful.
“Do you find it calming?” Bilbo asked, immediately regretting disturbing the moment, but Thorin only paused to glance up at him, his expression softening.
“Aye,” was his answer. “Grounding, perhaps. I’d forgotten that. When we were in the Blue Mountains, I would do blacksmithing work for coin - men never require the great skills of masters, and even a poor dwarven blacksmith is better than a good one of theirs. But the work did not speak to me, in my heart, and I did not find the joy in it that I did with this kind of fine work, or music. That's when it is the best, when there is skill in the work that rests your soul. It is good for the hands to have something to do so that the mind can rest. Sometimes ruling goes too far in the other direction.”
Bilbo smiled into his mug. “I suppose it’s a bit like growing plants and herbs then. Except my rosemary doesn’t glitter.”
“Perhaps you just haven’t found the right variety then,” was the response, a joke that would have felt unfathomable just a few days before.
A strangely festive mood started the third week. Rimli had found an old stash of honey from before Smaug, and with the miracle that honey was, it was still sweet and pure, albeit cloudy and crystalline now in the cold. The decision was made to use a chunk of it to create something to make everyone feel a bit better, and Bilbo had assisted in baking a number of honey cakes, a sweetness that seemed to lift everyone’s spirits. The younger dwarves had found an old corridor where the ice had formed so thickly on the stone slabs that a dwarf could slide across if given enough momentum, and Kili had started a competition to see which dwarf could propel themselves the furthest, a record that was currently held by Gloin.
The guards on post duty started swapping out shifts more frequently, for the cold that crept through the outer stone was sharper than any blade, and none envied the dwarves stationed near the frost-bound upper tunnels: this seemed to improve their moods, and the changing rotation of dwarves through the halls kept things feeling lively. Several dwarves had dug out musical instruments and were trying to find ways to tune them despite the deep cold, practising together to both perfect old songs and compose new. Kili took to this too with some pleasure, trying to act as composer and conductor at the same time, to varied success. It didn’t take long for him to be ousted by Dori, who Bilbo learned was what the dwarves called a songsmith by trade: a composer of songs for the royal court.
“I haven’t had much chance to use those skills in decades,” Dori confided to Bilbo, staring into a mirror as he neatened his braids the morning before his first performance. “In the Blue Mountains there wasn’t much call for new songs, and besides which the royal family could hardly afford to keep songsmiths on staff as they did in Erebor. I made my living in the fabric trade instead – that was my father’s trade and I’ve always had a good eye for quality. But it is good to find that part of myself again: it makes me feel younger, like the dwarf I thought I might be.”
Dori’s song was in Khuzdul, and Bilbo couldn’t understand the words, but it was beautiful. He could feel the slow, deep-voiced melodies in his bones, sounding like the heartbeat of the mountain, the roar of winter, the joy of living. Even the gruffest dwarf could be seen to shed a tear when it was first performed for the settlement. There was something in the melody that spoke of fear and waiting and wanting, of raw emotions and the real living essence of things, and it did not matter that he did not understand the words, because he felt them, deep inside his old and tired bones.
It made him think of Laketown, of the night before they were due to leave to undertake the last stretch of their long and perilous journey, from lake to mountain proper. The Company had been subdued, thinking of the mountain and the task ahead of them and that great and unspoken sleeping dragon they knew they had to wake. Kili had been injured of course, and all of them still nursing bruises from their unappealing barrel ride. They had food in their bellies and warm beds to sleep in, but Laketown had come with its own challenges, and all of them were ill at ease there and ready to leave at first light.
He had found Thorin standing on one of the small balconies, overlooking the water. A pipe was in Thorin’s hand, burning low, the bitter smell of acrid leaf hot in Bilbo’s nostrils as he approached. All day he had felt Thorin’s eyes on him, bright and hot, but every time he had looked in the dwarf’s direction he had glanced away again.
He stood next to Thorin, and took the pipe from him without saying a word, inhaling a mouthful of smoke.
“You don’t have to come with us,” Thorin said, quietly. “You have already done so much for us, and risked your life more times than I can count. If not for you, I fear I would be dead already, or trapped in some elven prison for the rest of my miserable days.”
Bilbo stared at him, at the hard lines of his profile lit by weak moonlight and the low warmth of a lantern strung overhead. Thorin’s face was a map of places Bilbo felt he would never know, but wanted to. When he had first met Thorin, the dwarf had been unknowable, terrifying in a way Bilbo didn’t know how to explain. Hearing his voice, that low song echoing through his smial, had woken something in him that he didn’t know how to put to sleep again. Over the course of the journey, he had thought Thorin rude, and impulsive, and reckless, and undeserving, and beautiful and noble and heartbreakingly good. His father's voice, reading aloud, echoed through his mind: home is where one starts from. As we grow older, the world becomes stranger, the pattern more complicated.
“I’m coming with you,” he replied, chewing on the end of the pipe, quite forgetting it was not his. Thorin looked at him, his eyes impossible to read.
“You have already met the terms of your contract,” was his reply. “You have successfully stolen – me and my Company, from the elves. No one would think less of you if you chose to leave now.”
“I’m not leaving you,” was his answer, and Thorin’s gaze was full of old forgotten songs, ancient and aching. There was hope and fear and a strange, lingering joy in that expression, as if the dwarf had been walking a thousand years in search of water, and had finally found a lake. A lifetime burning in every moment, he thought to himself. And not the lifetime of one man only, but of old stones that cannot be deciphered. Thorin was a riddle, and a mystery, and Bilbo could hardly dare to dream of solving it.
The corner of Thorin's mouth had tilted upwards, as if he was trying not to smile, and the way he looked at Bilbo in the coold night air made him think of his father, and Bag End, and acts of devotion that lasted for generations to come.
“Very well,” Thorin said, and his hand touched Bilbo’s, a heavy weight on his own on the wooden balustrade. It was a gentle touch, full of promise. “Perhaps when this is over – well, we will see.”
Bilbo had known, then, what Thorin chose not to say – or perhaps he had merely been hoping. It was always too hard to know for certain. And now, a year on, he sat and watched Thorin from across a hall of dwarves, settled into his home once more, alive and hale and still with them. They had never had that conversation, probably never would now – but he was content enough to see Thorin here.
He had to be content enough with that, he thought as he breathed deep the smell of burning pine needles. If he wasn’t, he didn’t know what else to be.
