Actions

Work Header

variations

Chapter 3: quartet 3

Chapter Text

Their brief joy passed as quickly as the sweetness of honey on the tongue: it had been a brittle thing, forged more from the mortal desire for brightness than from anything real or substantive.

The end of the third week also brought dangerous news: the erratic winds blowing down the ventilation shafts had caused fuel to burn more quickly than anticipated, and their stores of fuel were growing lower than planned. There seemed to be no break in the cold, and so eyes turned inwards to see where further fuel might be found. Ori had needed and received immediate reassurance that there was no intention to look to the surviving manuscripts in the old libraries (not in the least because parchment really doesn’t have a long enough burn time to be worth it).

Dwalin had been surprisingly calm throughout the whole situation. If you’d asked Bilbo in advance, he would have thought that Dwalin would have been one of the dwarves who would struggle the most with the lack of action, but instead, the tall dwarf had been remarkably composed and circumspect. Perhaps it was something innate to a good guardsman: the willingness to sit and watch and wait, not letting tension and emotion take over, remaining centred and focused while waiting for something to happen that would require action. So it was with Dwalin, and when the emergency came he sprang to action like a well-oiled machine, and rallied groups to begin scouring the still unexcavated parts of the city for further timber or coal to burn.

And there was one place that it made the most sense to look. Colloquially, it had become known as Old Erebor. These were the ancient levels of the city, buried deep below surface level, where the first dwarves had settled. Over time, the city had expanded upwards through the mountain proper, exploiting veins of minerals and ore and opening up new parts of the city as they went. There were deep mines too, feeding off the city, but down in Old Erebor the line between domestic and industrial was blurred, houses built into abandoned mine shafts and old rock repurposed to create taverns and shops between different mine entrances. This was a long way from the fine palaces and royal buildings in the middle of the mountain, or the merchants' buildings and guildhalls closest to the entrances.

When they had returned, they had made a conscious decision not to try and clear Old Erebor immediately. It had suffered badly under the dragon, and there were still concerns about the structural security of these lower tunnels after decades of bearing the weight of both the dragon and the decaying structures above it. It would need securing and renovating, but for now could wait until more dwarves arrived and the space was required. Thorin had confessed to Bilbo that he wasn't sure it ever would be, not for housing at least, but that they would need to access the old mines again eventually.

However, it did mean that there was potentially a large amount of fuel still to be found, wood and coal, perhaps even preserved peat stocks cut from the heather outside, always a popular source of fuel for the working class of the city in previous times. 

Bilbo had not planned to join the expedition: it wasn’t exactly his skill set, after all. But as the dwarves were gathering, he realised that Ori was among them, which prompted him to ask why.

Ori had been busy these last weeks, recording the activities and events of the storm. He was still officially the scribe of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield, responsible for chronicling the retaking of Erebor: the battle had been won, but you would be hard pressed to say that the city had been fully resettled, so Ori continued with his work. Before the storm, he had spent most of his time tucked up in warm corners of the old archives, organising old records no one had touched since before Smaug’s reign. Surrounded by scrolls and dusty ledgers, he had seemed very content. Since then, it was more common to see him roaming the halls, writing notes in his quick script about frozen doorways, collapsing passages, and the strange groans of the mountain at night, complete with sketches of snowdrifts, diagrams of blocked tunnels, and the occasional small portrait of dwarves when he thought no one would notice.

Now, Ori had his notebook gripped tightly to his chest, and despite the cold, wore fingerless gloves to give him enough flexibility to write. He was glaring across the room at his brother Nori, who was doing a very good job of pretending not to notice.

“I need to chronicle what we find down there,” Ori told Bilbo. “Not just for the story, but so that we can tell people when we need to resettle it. And-” he broke off, looking a bit unhappy. “No one wants to admit it, but the losses were the worst down there. Very few dwarves could get out – the dragon was literally on top of them. The dwarves we find deserve to have their beads marked, even if they have no living relatives, even if we can't retrieve their bones yet.”

He was referring to the tradition of personal bead marks: every dwarf had their own personal markings that indicated their identity, which they wore on one bead in their beard. Bilbo had heard the dwarves talking in the lead up to the battle: he knew that tradition dictated that beads should be returned to the family if bodies could not be retrieved, and the Company had all left theirs in the Mountain for survivors to pass on, in case they did not make it. They had been speaking of it since Laketown: Thorin had quietly offered to carve one for Bilbo, before the gold and the strangeness distracted him. 

“And I keep telling him that the dead can wait, because it is going to be damned dangerous down there, and Dori would skin him alive if he knew our little brother was planning on going along.”

The only reason Bilbo didn’t jump at the sound of Nori’s voice was because he had already trained himself not to.

Nori was, to Bilbo’s mind, probably the oddest member of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield. He hadn’t noticed this much during the journey: he’d been too focused on trying not to get eaten or die to pay too much attention to the quiet dwarf with a gaze as sharp as a blade. But after the battle, when he’d started to learn about all the dwarves’ normal lives and day-to-day personalities when they weren't at immediate risk of dying, Nori had remained an enigma. He did not talk about his past, and what Bilbo knew he had learned only through vague comments and offhand remarks from other people. He, Dori and Ori all had different fathers (not hugely uncommon among dwarves, where monogamous marriage was viewed more as an option than an obligation, as it was in the Shire) and had all spent time away from each other at different times, learning their trades. Nori had spent a lot of time travelling, and was the only member of the Company other than Thorin who had ever been to the Iron Mountains. He had been to the far Southron lands as well, and had seen the frozen seas of the far north. Quite what he did was unclear, and certainly, he did not give the impression of a trader or merchant.

Dori had been raised in Erebor: Ori had been born in the Blue Mountains. Somewhere between them came Nori, whose eyes were cunning and whose wrists bore manacle scars.

Once, Gloin had made a joke about Nori being a thief, but the reaction from the group (except for Bifur, Bombur and Bofur, who were as in the dark as Bilbo) made him suspect that there was more to the story than that.

“Dori can go sharpen a hammer,” Ori said, with surprising alacrity. “And so can you. I’m a grown dwarf who's earned my mastery, and I can go where I please.”

Nori seemed quite as taken aback by this as Bilbo, and watched Ori storm off with an irritated twist of his mouth.

“I can’t keep an eye on him,” he told Bilbo. “I’ve got to – well, it doesn’t matter, but I need to be doing something else. And you know what he’s like when he’s writing – head buried in the paper, not paying a bit of attention to where he’s going or reading the rock. He’s as likely to fall through a mineshaft as he is anything else.”

Nori wasn’t wrong, Bilbo admitted to himself. “Alright,” he acquiesced. “I’ll come along, and stick with him. Can’t say I’ll be much use for anything else, so I might as well try to stop him walking into any holes.”

To his surprise, Nori wrapped a brief arm around Bilbo’s shoulders, sideways-on, and squeezed. It was over as soon as it happened, but Bilbo rather thought it was as close to a hug as anyone was likely to receive from Nori.

The gathered group stood in the half-lit passage outside a sealed stairwell, fifty dwarves (and one hobbit) wrapped in cloaks stiff with frost, breath rising like ghosts in front of their faces. Down here, far from the freezing walls of the mountain, the temperature felt strange. Still cold, unimaginably so, but with some barely definable warmth rising from the deep rock. The air was still, and heavy, too long unstirred, and tasted almost metallic, the slow thickness of blood on the tongue. Old Erebor seemed to keep its own atmosphere, as if it were a whole other world.

A crowbar was used to open a door that had been sealed months before to stop anyone from wandering into unsafe areas. It groaned like something waking, and Bilbo felt a chill run down his spine. The draft that rolled out brought the smell of dry earth, burned wood, and lost things. The light of the lanterns pooled around them, lighting up the old tunnels and casting long shadows before them.

“Keep close,” Thorin said, from the front of the group, as Nori slipped away from Bilbo into the darkness ahead.

They began the descent, and Bilbo found Ori again quickly in the group, sticking close. It was not particularly precarious at first: the hallway sloped downwards at a gentle camber, and the sound of their breathing was a welcome respite from the old, stale quiet. The walls, once carved with reliefs, were furred over with a thick layer of old soot and ash, the residue of the dragon not yet cleaned away. Bilbo dragged one finger through it, revealing beneath a startling pair of eyes cut into the rock.

“Old spirits,” Ori told him, quietly. “The deep dwarves believed that there were spirits in the rock that would keep their eyes on the mines, and look after the dwarves that worked them.”

“Do you not keep the same faith?” Bilbo asked, glancing at Ori out of the corner of his eyes.

“I’m a historian,” was Ori’s reply. “It is my job to document, not to believe.”

They reached the end of the corridor relatively quickly, and the passageway widened out into the edge of Old Erebor, a twisting network of ancient stone-front dwellings, small rooms cut directly into the rock, doors now hanging at all angles or missing altogether. Rubble had poured across the roadways like frozen waves, and above them, low roofs stood intact but in places bowed and cracked, as if weighed down. Huge sheets of ice frosted the walls, as thick as the width of a palm in places, shimmering and distorting the lamplight. Formed by the meltwater, one dwarf explained quietly, and with some concern in his voice. Meltwater caused by their own, slightly warmer floors of the mountain: there was enough ventilation for them to breathe, but the old air pumps were not enough to move the warm air they exhaled. It sank, and once the temperature dropped, it froze again. The results down here were obvious.

Ori drifted between different groups, scribbling as he went. Nori had been right to be concerned: several times Bilbo had to take his arm and steer him around debris and potholes. It was a strange and perilous place: doorframes crumbled away beneath incautious hands, and often the stonework was duplicitous, fragile when it appeared otherwise. The ice had done no end of damage, worming its way into cracks and expanding them. Even the old mining supports, thick beams of seasoned pine, felt as though they might disintegrate if pulled too sharply.

Ori paused to sketch something, and Bilbo was distracted by another group of dwarves approaching. Their movements were slow and careful, and they already carried large amounts of wood on their backs and piled onto the sledges they were pulling, fashioned from old shields.

“Bilbo?”

It was Thorin, leading another group and looking concerned. Bilbo raised a hand in an awkward wave, as the dwarf came close, belatedly realising that Thorin had not known that Bilbo was down here with them. Thorin raised his own hand, a half-aborted motion as if he had been reaching to cup Bilbo’s face, gentle, reverently.

But he didn’t do that. Instead, he tried to disguise the movement by running his hand through his own hair. There was a look in his eyes that made Bilbo think that he wanted to say something, but was stopping himself. 

“I told Nori I’d keep an eye on Ori,” he said, pre-empting the inevitable question.

“Quiet,” growled Dwalin suddenly, and Bilbo flinched for a moment before realising that Dwalin wasn’t speaking to him but to the group as a whole. All lanterns stopped moving. Every dwarf held his breath.

Something was shifting in the dark: nothing tangible, nothing clear. Not footsteps or bodies, more like the granular sigh of a cave in, but far away – but the shifting of the air felt close, and strange. The sound ebbed and flowed around them for a moment, then an almost alarming creak, and then everything fell silent once again. Even Ori stopped writing, his notebook disappearing back into his layers as he looked around, disquieted.

“Stone settling,” muttered Dwalin into that silence, though his voice betrayed his unease.

A section of wall not far from them cracked, shedding a mist of powdered rock. The dwarves did not flinch at it (though Bilbo did): these were hardy dwarves, used to the dangers of the deep earth. The Blue Mountains had not sent dwarves faint of heart on the first caravan to resettle Erebor: these dwarves were all experienced, but also calm in the face of emergencies and used to dealing with problems. Despite that, none of them looked completely confident in these surroundings, Bilbo couldn’t help but note.

“We should not stay down here much longer,” Thorin said quietly. His voice carried differently than other people’s, as if the stone were breathing in to listen to him. “We misjudged the ice. Old Erebor is not ready for us.”

Working faster now, Bilbo watched as they pried loose several beams from a collapsed workshop near an abandoned tavern. Bilbo did not offer to help – he knew well enough that he was more likely to hinder progress than he was to aid it. The dwarves bundled the wood, careful not to make sudden movements, not speaking much at all.

Their sledges were full now, and they moved back to the rendezvous point. Bilbo kept close to Ori, even though the dwarf seemed much less keen on writing now. Thorin stuck close to Bilbo, close enough that the lines of their arms brushed against each other now and again, barely felt through the many layers they were wearing. On their way back, they passed a side tunnel, barely of interest: Dwalin flicked the light of his lantern towards it half-heartedly, revealing a floor thick with dust, and another pair of carved eyes.

For a moment, they seemed to flicker with movement. Despite himself, Bilbo hesitated, staring at them as the rest of the group moved forward.

“What is it?” Thorin asked, his voice quiet.

“The eyes,” was Bilbo’s response, uncertain what he was planning to say.

“Leave them,” said Thorin softly. “Shadows are but a thought and a moment in time, but best to leave them as they are.”

From nowhere came once again that strange and terrible sound, surrounding them, vibrating through the soles of his feet. A wind, so light it was barely a caress against their faces, brought a deep chill, and Bilbo turned, despite himself, his lantern light glittering in a wall rimed with a thick sheet of ice that had grown cloudy and veined like marble, and something that seemed to glitter in the air: it took him a moment to realise that it was dust, tiny fragments of ground stone, and that the ceiling above them was cracking.

“Thorin!”

He spun on his heels, using the momentum to propel himself forward, into Thorin’s body and knocking them both to the side of the corridor, where they hit the wall hard enough to ricochet off and collapse to the floor. The dwarves further down the corridor shouted, but the sound was swallowed by the crashing noise around them, huge and echoing in the narrow corridor. Chunks of ice and stone slammed around them, and a terrible pain radiated from his shoulder, appearing so suddenly he wasn’t even sure when it had happened. Beneath him was the pale warmth of Thorin’s body, arms reaching up to wrap around him, and he screamed as those safe arms pressed against his shoulder, his face buried in Thorin’s chest.

It could have lasted a moment; it could have lasted hours.

Eventually, the noise subsided, and Bilbo raised his head. Where they had been standing was now heavy rock and huge shards of ice. Had Bilbo been a moment slower, both he and Thorin would now be crushed under the weight of it. 

“Bilbo? Bilbo!”

Thorin’s voice was faint, and Bilbo realised that his ears were ringing.

“I’m alright,” he said, as beneath him, Thorin shifted, trying to get them both to their feet. He winced at the movement and tried to roll off him, only to jar his shoulder in the process. He was forced to bite back another scream as he stumbled to his feet. They had been hit by the tail end of the rockslide, and around them lay rubble that had fortuitously avoided them, and he found himself staring at it in an absent sort of horror.

“Bilbo!” Thorin’s voice was rough, and Bilbo realised that he still hadn’t answered Thorin, who was already on his feet. “Are you hurt? Let me see.”

Bilbo tried to wave him off with his uninjured arm. “It’s fine-”

“It’s not fine!”

He could feel the argument they were about to have, and even the thought of having to talk about the amount of pain he was in made him want to cry. This was not a place he could show that part of himself. 

“Thorin. It is not the time. We need to get out of here, not stand around. You can fret about it once you've led your dwarves out of this damned place.”

Thorin stared at him. They were both breathing heavily, and the sound of settling stone seemed suddenly very loud in the quiet. Thorin nodded stiffly, once, before turning back to the other dwarves and picking his way across the rubble to join them. Bilbo lagged after them, one hand on his injured shoulder. It didn’t feel wet, but then there were many layers between his hands and his skin, so if there was blood, perhaps he would not know. For now, he tried to ignore the way the flesh and bone ached, deep and brutal and angry beneath his skin.

“You look pale,” was Nori’s greeting when they rejoined the other dwarves. “And Ori told me you not only stopped him from falling down a hole into the depths of the mountain, you also threw yourself between our king and certain death-by-stone, which I have to tell you, would have been a really bad morale-wise.”

Bilbo glanced at him, frowning.

“Of course I’m pale,” he snapped back. “It’s the middle of winter, and I’m freezing cold.”

Nori rolled his eyes. “No need to be tetchy. I’m not going to ask you why you were so willing to risk your own life to save Thorin’s.”

“I’d save any of your lives!” was Bilbo’s response, through gritted teeth. “I’d jump in front of a warg for any member of the Company. I don’t know what you are implying.”

Nori grinned, and Bilbo remembered that the dwarf always loved the bite of conversations like this, of push and pull, always leaning on the edge of a knife blade.

“Not implying anything you don’t already know,” Nori told him, all bared teeth and razor expression. But his arm slipped around Bilbo’s waist, propping him up as Bilbo put his uninjured arm around Nori’s shoulders, enough to keep him upright as they followed the rest of the dwarves.

“No one’s going to say anything,” Nori said, and his voice was quiet now. “About what there is between the two of you-”

“There’s nothing like that,” Bilbo hissed between his teeth.

Nori rolled his eyes. “Sure, nothing at all.”

“Just like there’s nothing between you and Dwalin, right?”

Nori glanced at him from the corner of his eye, and said nothing, though it looked a little like he was trying not to grin, just a little bit.

 


 

The door to their room had a weight to it beyond that of the wood itself. As it closed, Bilbo felt his shoulders slumping, and he exhaled heavily; the rest of the world blocked out. The pain had sunk into that deep, throbbing ache that it suggestive of damage much worse than you want to acknowledge, and he had a horrible feeling that it was going to get feel worse before it got better.

He had almost been glad, once they had returned to the warmer halls of the mountain, when Thorin had scowled at him and nodded in the direction of their room. The pain was the kind that made it hard for him to focus on anything else, and it brought with it a tiredness that seemed to sink into his bones.

Trying to get his layers off was more of a challenge than he was up for at this exact moment. Thorin stripped him of the outer layers with an efficiency that might have been brutal but for the warmth in his eyes, and the careful way that he pulled each layer of fabric away from his shoulder. Bilbo grew colder as Thorin went, and he realised that he wasn’t breathing only when he had to take a sudden, sharp inhale.

Thorin glanced at him, lips parting as if to speak, before looking away again. It was strangely awkward, as if he wasn’t sure of his welcome.

Bilbo blinked, realising.

“Sorry for snapping before,” he said to the quiet. “I just – I couldn’t stop and fuss about it, not when we needed to get out of there. Not in front of everyone. Not when I’m already not sure what people think of me being here half the time. I don’t – I don’t want to be a burden. That’s all it was.”

Thorin sighed, and then his hands were on Bilbo’s face, thumbs tucked into the hollow of his cheekbones, palms cupping the curve of his jaw.

“I have a terrible suspicion that you saved my life down there today,” Thorin told him. “And I have no idea why you feel like you should apologise for doing so once again. The only thing that concerns me is that I now owe you multiple life-debts, and I have no way of repaying you for that.”

Bilbo felt the corner of his mouth twitch upwards, and he dared to meet Thorin’s eyes. They were warm, and a little sad.

“No debts between us, I think,” was his reply. “Or if there must be, I will take repayment in honey cakes and tea once we manage to open the gates of this blasted rock again. But nothing more than that.”

Thorin held his face a moment longer before returning to his task. As he eased a layer over Bilbo’s head, he spoke again, contemplative.

“I’ve heard no dwarf utter a negative word against you being here, you know. Often the opposite. The Company sing only your praises, and my sister writes that your reports were the only ones she was interested in reading – apparently, you’re the only person she trusts to be honest with her about what I am doing, and she hasn’t even met you. The chief engineer called you invaluable last week-”

“The chief engineer is Bombur’s wife, and is hardly impartial.”

“Lir may be married to Bombur, but if she didn’t like you, she would have no problem telling you that to your face. Dorinbar trusts you with the care of the ravens, and more dwarves than I can name have remarked on how essential you have been these last months. And I know that while I slept, it was only thanks to you that peace was forged and settled with so little incident.”

The last layer was pulled from Bilbo’s back, and he hissed at the tacky, pulling sting of it.

“It’s just a scrape,” Thorin said, sounding relieved. "Deep bruising already, and we should have Oin look at it to see how long you should rest it, but it doesn’t look too bad. I think it will ache, though, for a long time, particularly with the cold. Can I bind it for you? I have some compresses.”

Bilbo nodded, silently. A salve of some kind was gently applied with warm, careful fingers, and he inhaled the deep herbal scent, like pine leaves and rosemary and something else he could not name.

“We haven’t really talked about the fact that you want to leave,” Thorin said, into the silence. “Once the snow clears, I mean. I just - I need you to know that you can do what you like, what your heart is telling you do. You are the most important thing, Bilbo. I know it is dangerous here – and hardly a fit home for a hobbit. There will be little in the way of comfort for some time. Priorities will remain on essentials – and I don’t blame you for wanting to go back to your own home, where you can be safe and warm, and the ceiling doesn’t collapse on you.”

“It’s not- that’s not why I have to go back to the Shire,” Bilbo replied, eyes at half-mast, already tired. “It’s not because I need things, or anything like that. It’s just-”

“Just what?”

But Bilbo did not have the words. How could he express the deep longing for home, the feeling of his mother’s travelling cloak, still hanging by the front door, between his fingers? The smell of burning hay, and the dried herbs in the pantry, and the familiar creak of wooden floorboards beneath his feet? What words could shape the resounding knowledge that his longing for home was due to the terrible sensation that he needed to reclaim the person that he had once been, and nothing at all to do with wanting to leave here, this strange mountain that had welcomed him? The fear, deep inside, that if he went home, he might learn that he didn’t fit there either anymore, which was why he kept agreeing to stay for longer – because if he didn’t fit the mould of the Shire, then what would he do, and where would he go? Who was he, if he did not fit there? Who was he, now that he had travelled so far, and seen so many things? What shadow would he need to force himself to become in order to make his life work again?

The fear that what he was missing was a home that wouldn’t fit him anymore?

The knowledge that if he left, when he left, he would be tearing a part of himself out in the process.

“You could stay,” Thorin said, and his voice was so quiet, quiet enough that Bilbo could pretend not to hear it if he wanted. “I know – I thought that, maybe once, you might care for me as I do for you. And I know that I – I changed. And it changed everything that was between us, what we might have become. But the one thing that didn’t change is how I feel. I just wanted you to know that.”

And what could Bilbo say? That yes, Thorin was right, that there was a ghost that stood between them of a potential future that they had lost, of a home that they might have found together but had both burned down with poor decisions? That if they had trusted each other a little more they would not have broken what was once between them? That Bilbo loved Thorin, loved him so much that sometimes he thought that if you carved him open you would see the chords of Thorin’s voice carved into his ribs, but that it is impossible to give yourself when you don’t know who you are, when you feel so lost, when you may need to leave and travel a world away just to find the skin you had shed and return to something that felt safe, and normal?

So, he closed his eyes, and didn’t say anything, and let Thorin wrap his shoulder and lead him to bed, hating himself a little.

Thorin vanished, and he half-fell asleep despite the early hour and the pain in his shoulder. He drifted in and out until the sound of Oin’s voice woke him, cool, gentle hands pressing and pulling.

“Hurts,” he said, and Oin laughed quietly.

“Aye, that it would,” came the reply. “But I’ve a draught for that, and there’s no real damage, though I hear there might have been if you’d have been slower.”

“Felt slow enough,” Bilbo mumbled. “Like trying to throw a sack of potatoes across the room.”

“Am I the potatoes in this analogy, or you?” asked Thorin, and Bilbo realised he was sitting on the bed beside him, a warm hand in his hair and another on the ball of his shoulder, holding him gently in place while Oin looked at his injury. He had become so used to the warmth of Thorin’s skin that he hadn’t even noticed. Thorin’s voice was kind, and in it Bilbo could hear the unspoken words: let’s forget I said anything, don’t let me have burned that fragile peace we were rebuilding again.

So Bilbo smiled, and made a joke in response, and tried not to wonder at the strange masks they both seemed so happy to wear.

Eventually, he was sat up enough to be given a bitter herbal drink that warmed him through and left him feeling lethargic but just too awake to sleep, the pain dulled to something faint enough to ignore. Without him needing to ask, Thorin returned to bed beside him. He had with him a book, old and dusty, clearly something that had been brought in one of the caravans (the texts that had survived Smaug were understandably fragile, and Ori wouldn’t have let them out of the library for love nor money, not even for a King. He had grand plans for having them all transcribed and restored, but understood well enough that there was not yet the manpower to devote to such a task.

Thorin read aloud from it as Bilbo drifted in and out of sleep, some sections in Westron and others not, the sound of his voice melodic and low. He didn’t really follow what it was about – something to do with lost halls, and ancient kings, and dark winters endured against the odds, and finding a home where you thought you might not.

Fare forward, travellers! Not escaping from the past into different lives, or into any future; you are not the same people who left that station or who will arrive at any terminus came a voice, and to his tired mind he didn't know who it belonged to, whether it was his mother or his father or Gandalf or Thorin or even his own, echoing through his mind. What was real and what wasn't bled together, a haze of soft sound and warmth and aching loneliness in his chest.

He wasn’t sure if he dreamed the feeling on Thorin’s hands in his hair, or his soft voice calling his name, over and over again.