Actions

Work Header

To Fix What Was Broken

Chapter 16: Old Friends

Summary:

Bilbo learns that he isn't as alone as he's believed himself to be, and the Company heads for the house of Beorn.

Notes:

Greetings, friends! I pounded out the majority of this chapter today in an attempt to escape the harrowing darkness of depression. It didn't work. However, you get an update, so at least something good came out of this shitty day.

There is no proofreading here, we die like dwarves with far too much pride and a reckless amount of hubris.

Buckle up because things are HAPPENING and our dear Bilbo is truly getting into the thick of it now.

Chapter Text

“Did you plant your trees, Bilbo?”

He gaped at the dwarf, thoughts spinning through his head like a windstorm. The question was an echo of words that were spoken to him once, a very long time ago. Still, it was a memory so vivid, he could almost feel the hard ice under his knees and the warm blood on his hands. He’d never been able to forget the feeling of it. Nor had he forgotten the final words his best friend ever said to him, no matter how much it hurt to remember.

This wasn’t possible.

Then again, nothing that happened over the past several months should have been possible. He was supposed to be in Valinor with Frodo, not here, reliving this adventure. The dwarf in front of him was supposed to be dead, for Yavanna’s sake! Yet here they both were, alive and well. Those blue eyes Bilbo had long yearned to see again were staring down at him, and they were far more knowing than they should be.

You are not alone.

Was this what Lady Galadriel had meant that day in Rivendell?

Bilbo buried his face in his hands.

Wizards, elves, whatever that Bombadil creature in the Old Forest was—why did immortals always have to be so gods-damned cryptic? Would it kill them to speak plainly for once in their incredibly too long lives? He enjoyed a good riddle, but there was a time and place for those things. And that time was certainly not several decades into his past, in the middle of a dangerous quest, when the leader of his Company was apparently...

He took a few steadying breaths that really didn’t do much to calm his pounding heart, then slowly lowered his hands and looked at the dwarf sitting before him.

“Thorin?”

Any small bit of uncertainty in the dwarf’s expression up until that point melted away and Thorin gave him one of those bright smiles that made his whole face light up, and his voice was soft when he spoke. “Hello, Bilbo.”

He stared. He hadn't seen that smile since…

Well, since…

Really it didn’t matter how long it had been. A very long time, to say the least. Long enough that Bilbo had told himself he was over that smile and all the complicated feelings that came with it—and by the time he was old, he almost believed it.

The past was in the past, after all, and it was far too late to do anything with those feelings in any case.

Of course, that was until he woke up one fateful morning to find that the past was once again his present and there were dwarves on his doorstep.

Ever since then, he'd been telling himself that it didn’t matter if his heart skipped a beat every time he looked at a certain dwarf king because while the dwarf certainly was Thorin, it wasn’t his Thorin.

Not to say that Thorin had ever actually been his, of course, but—

Well, that was beside the point. The simple fact of the matter was that the dwarf Bilbo had fallen for all those years ago was dead. This Thorin didn’t have any memory of their friendship or the dangers they went through together, and that was the end of it. So, Bilbo had taken all those lingering feelings and shoved them down deep and decided that his focus had to be on keeping this Thorin alive. Anything he might have felt for the dwarf in the past didn’t matter.

But now…

Throughout his life, Bilbo came up with countless scenarios, imagining what he might do if he ever came face to face with Thorin Oakenshield again. He imagined yelling at the dwarf for his recklessness. Sometimes he thought he would pull the dwarf into a hug and never let him go again. There were a few times, when he was particularly upset, he pictured himself slapping Thorin across his stupid, beautiful face. But out of all the hundreds of daydreams Bilbo came up with over the years, he never once thought he would laugh.

It started out as a small giggle—a high pitched, nervous sound. It quickly grew into a chuckle, then an all out laughing fit that had him gasping for breath, his whole body shaking.

“What is so funny?” The look of complete bafflement on Thorin’s face only made him laugh harder.

He couldn’t help himself.

Clutching at his stomach, Bilbo wheezed and shook his head. There were tears streaming down his face.

Maybe all the pent up frustration and anxiety from the past few months were finally rising to the surface, or maybe it was just the sheer absurdity of the situation.

“I am far too old for this nonsense.” The words came out in heavy gasps, and Bilbo couldn’t say anything else after.

Thorin looked even more confused than before and he shook his head, but that smile was coming back—and wasn’t that a lovely sight?

Bilbo stopped and blinked a few times, caught off guard by the thought. Then he started laughing again.

Oh. He was in so much trouble.

 

***

 

The entire Company probably would have benefitted from another day of rest there at the base of the Carrock, but by dawn the next morning everyone was awake and packing up whatever meager supplies they had left, getting ready to move on. It hadn’t been outright decided that they would be setting out soon, but they all seemed to be in silent agreement. Azog was tracking them, and though their flight on the eagles would have done much to hide their trail, it was only a matter of time before the orcs caught their scent once again. Nobody wanted to stick around to find out exactly how long it would take for that to happen.

Wrapped in a thin blanket to fight off the early morning chill, Bilbo headed across camp to where Thorin, Bombur, and Balin were quietly speaking. He stood a few feet back, not wanting to interrupt their conversation—Bombur had decided they only had enough food for three days if they rationed it right. Not ideal, but Bilbo knew their supplies would be refilled soon enough, as long as they managed to get on Beorn’s good side again, so he wasn’t too concerned.

There was something more pressing on his mind, in any case.

The moment the three dwarves were finished, Bilbo hurried over to Thorin and caught his sleeve just as he took his first step towards his two nephews.

Thorin paused and turned, his eyes lighting up the moment they settled on Bilbo. Then the light was gone, replaced by worry. “What is it? Are you alright?” he asked, looking him up and down as if expecting him to be injured.

Ignoring the urge to roll his eyes at the unnecessary concern, Bilbo shook his head. “I’m fine. But before we leave, we should talk to Gandalf.”

“The wizard?” Thorin’s gaze flickered over to the spot where the old man was perched on a rock, pipe in hand. “Why?”

“Because apparently I’m not the only person reliving this journey, and I think the wizard needs to be made aware of the most recent development in the situation.”

The dwarf scowled. “I do not like the idea of others being aware of the situation, as you say. The less people who know, the better.”

This time, Bilbo did roll his eyes. “Well, like it or not, Gandalf has known about me since the beginning. And, after our stop at Rivendell, so does the rest of the White Council. I’m not going to suddenly leave him in the dark just because of your silly trust issues.”

Thorin’s wince was almost imperceptible, but Bilbo noticed. Before he could say anything about it, though, Thorin gave a terse nod.

“Fine, if this is what you think is best. But make it quick. I am anxious to leave this place.”

With that, Thorin started off towards Gandalf, not waiting for a response. Surprised, Bilbo just stared after him for a moment. He had honestly expected a bit more argument over the matter. Shaking his head, Bilbo hurried to follow.

When they reached the wizard, Bilbo almost wondered if he hadn’t noticed they were there, as his focus remained locked on his pipe. After a moment, though, he blew out a smoke ring then looked up at them. His gaze went over Thorin once before he turned to Bilbo, studying him.

“How is your head?”

“Fine, thank you.” Bilbo waved off the question and went on. “There’s something more important we need to speak with you about.”

Gandalf raised a bushy brow. “Oh?”

Turning to Thorin, Bilbo gave him a look, but the dwarf looked thoroughly unmoved by it and didn’t seem at all inclined to be the one to start this conversation. So, stifling an exasperated sigh, he looked back to Gandalf.

“Our esteemed Master Oakenshield has brought it to my attention that I am not, in fact, the only person present who has more knowledge than I should about future events.” He said the last few words a bit more quietly than the rest, not wanting to risk anyone else from the Company hearing him and asking questions.

To anyone who didn’t know Gandalf well, it would seem like the wizard was entirely unfazed by what he had just been told. Bilbo, however, noticed the way his old friend paused in the middle of puffing on his pipe and how his eyes widened ever so slightly.

Gandalf studied Thorin for a moment, as if expecting the dwarf to somehow deny what Bilbo had just said. Thorin only scowled back at him in response.

“Interesting,” Gandalf said eventually.

“Interesting? Is that all you have to say about this?” Thorin growled, then immediately went quiet again when he caught a well aimed jab of an elbow to his ribs.

Ignoring the dwarf’s small sound of indignance, Bilbo kept his attention on Gandalf. “Please tell me you’ve got some idea what’s going on here. I know the Council wasn’t able to come to any kind of conclusions, but I need something to go on.”

Gandalf was already shaking his head before Bilbo even finished. “I have no more idea of why this is happening than you do, my friend. I do not understand how you were sent back or for what purpose. And I am not sure—”

“Actually, I may be able to help with that.”

Blinking, Bilbo turned to Thorin, who looked as if he had just bitten into something sour. “What do you mean?”

“I mean, while I cannot say how you ended up here, Bilbo, I—” Thorin paused and glanced around for a moment before stepping closer to them both and lowering his voice. “I am here by choice. After my death, I was granted the opportunity by the Maker to return and fix my mistakes.”

Bilbo choked at the words, and even Gandalf’s surprise was plain.

“You spoke to Aulë?” the wizard asked.

Thorin glared. “I spoke to Mahal, and he gave me a choice. Accept my death and join my loved ones in the Halls, or come back and ensure that the line of Durin does not fail.”

His mind racing, Bilbo suddenly felt a spark of hope. Ever since that day all those months ago when he woke up in Bag End to find himself in the past, he had no idea why he was here, but he had made the decision and given himself one purpose—relive the quest, retake Erebor, and make sure that this time, all of his friends lived to see their home thrive once again. That was his promise, to himself and all of them.

They would live.

Of course, there was always that nagging thought in the back of his mind that he might fail. That it might be impossible to save Fili and Kili and Thorin from their fates, and he would be forced to relive the pain of losing them once again.

But if what Thorin was saying now was true…

Maybe there was a chance that he could succeed. Maybe he truly could fix things before they ever got the chance to break.

And if one of the Valar believed it could be done, surely that had to count for something.

Bilbo couldn’t help the grin that slowly began to form on his face.

When he came back out of his own thoughts, it was to find that both his friends were staring at him—Thorin, with a strange look in his eyes.

He didn’t care how silly he probably seemed in that moment. Bouncing on his toes, Bilbo nodded once. “Right, then. Let’s get this show on the road, shall we?”

At the words, Gandalf stood up from his place on the rock and tucked his pipe away. “I think that would be wise, but we should return to this conversation later. We have much to discuss.”

“Agreed. But for now, we head for the home of Master Beorn.” Bilbo paused and glanced at Thorin, but the dwarf just nodded in agreement, so he looked back to Gandalf. “I assume you can lead us there?”

“Beorn? You mean the skin-changer?”

Thorin snorted at the response, but they both ignored it.

“Yes, yes. Who else would I mean? Can you get us there or not?” Bilbo asked.

“I can,” Gandalf said, putting on his hat and grabbing his staff. “But I should warn you, he is not overly fond of dwarves.”

Standing at his full height, Bilbo looked the wizard directly in the eye. “Leave that to me.”

 

***

 

It took four days to reach their destination. The first three went peacefully, with a surprising absence of the orcs that were sure to be tracking them. The Company was in good cheer and Bilbo had begun to think that maybe they could avoid an altercation altogether.

Of course, his hope had come a bit too soon.

It was mid-morning of the fourth day, when they made a brief stop at a stream to refill their water, that they heard the first warg howl. With everyone much more alert now than they’d been before, they picked up the pace.

Bilbo, Gandalf, and Thorin were the only ones who knew they were headed straight for the lands of a creature just as dangerous as the ones that lay behind—more so, maybe, since even Azog wouldn’t dare cross the borders of Beorn’s territory. Still, when the Company began to murmur among themselves with the worry that there was no shelter to hide them now since leaving the mountains behind them for open fields, Gandalf mentioned that there was a house ahead where they might take refuge. It helped their spirits somewhat, but it didn’t last long.

Astride their snarling warg mounts, the orcs seemingly appeared from nowhere, and were far too close for the Company to attempt outrunning them.

Cursing, Bilbo drew his sword alongside the dwarves, and turned to face the oncoming attack.

The first warg was taken out by Kili’s arrow and crushed its rider beneath it when it fell. The second was shot through the chest and stumbled, but the orc riding it managed to escape unharmed and it reached them on foot, brandishing its crude blade and screeching.

It was immediately dispatched by a swing of Dwalin’s axe, but then the rest of the orc pack crashed over them and they were fighting for their lives.

Bofur, Bombur, and Bifur all seemed to take it upon themselves to protect him and surrounded him the moment the first orc fell, and Bilbo didn’t have time to complain that they were coddling him. Not that it mattered much. The onslaught was too heavy to keep him entirely shielded from the fight, despite their best efforts, and Bilbo found himself protecting his dwarves just as much as they were protecting him.

An orc that lunged for Bombur was knocked away by a great swing of Bofur’s mattock, just as Bombur killed one with its eyes set on Bifur, who was holding his own with his boar spear, impaling adversaries left and right and leaving them dead on the ground at his feet. When an orc lifted a curved blade aiming for Bofur’s back, Bilbo didn’t hesitate to step in before its stroke fell, using Sting to slash at its legs and ending it with a quick stab to the chest when it fell to its knees.

It went on for several minutes, the four of them fighting in tandem and watching each other’s backs. There was too much chaos for Bilbo to really take stock of what was happening, but the voices of the Company rang out over the sounds of the battle, and he had to take that as reassurance that they were okay.

The noise was nearly deafening—metal crashing against metal, howls and shrieks, and battle cries that echoed from orc and dwarf alike.

Then, a roar like thunder rose over the field, and as if time itself had come to a standstill, everything stopped.

Silence lasted for about three seconds and suddenly the orcs were screaming out in that horrible language of theirs and pulling back, their fight with the dwarves suddenly forgotten. They practically scrambled to retreat, racing for wargs to ride, pushing and shoving each other out of the way in their haste.

Then the crowd parted enough for Bilbo to see through the mass of bodies, and he understood why.

Some huge beast was barreling across the field, heading straight for the fight, its roars so loud the ground shook beneath his feet.

Beorn.

In the distraction, Thorin called the Company to him and they all hurried to fall back. When they reached him, Bilbo allowed himself a short moment of relief to see that Thorin seemed to be unharmed, as did Fili and Kili.

Gandalf appeared, disheveled and panting, his hat sitting lopsided on his head. “Don’t just stand here, you fools! This way! Quickly!”

And then they were running, trampling their way through a field of purple and white wildflowers, headed for a stand of trees off in the distance.

To their luck, the bear had its sights set on the orcs that were attempting to retreat, and either he hadn’t spotted the dwarves or he was too preoccupied at the moment to concern himself with them. Either way, it gave them the chance they needed to get away.

As Beorn fought off the wargs and orcs, the Company only moved faster when they caught sight of the large house sitting in the shade of a stand of huge oak trees. Sprinting past beehives and grazing sheep, they burst into the yard at full speed and didn’t stop until they were inside with the door shut and barred behind them.

For a minute, they all just stood there and tried to regain their breath and listened to the distant roars of the bear.

Ori was the first to speak. “What is that?!”

At the question, everyone turned to look at Gandalf. The wizard met their gazes, unwavering. “That is our host. His name is Beorn. He’s a skin-changer.”

He didn’t say anything more, probably still too breathless to really launch into an explanation. The dwarves stared at him for about three seconds before they erupted all at once, shouting over each other so much that their words were practically indiscernible.

Bilbo and Thorin stood at the edge of the group, the only two not joining the argument. Bilbo kept his eye on Gandalf, watching as the wizard slowly got more and more annoyed, the air around him beginning to darken.

It was Thorin, however, who put a stop to it.

“Enough!” The Company fell silent, turning to look at him. “There is no point in arguing. We stay here for the night and hope that our host is in a more agreeable mood in the morning. We cannot go back out there now, and that is the end of it.”

After that, there were no more complaints greater than some disgruntled mumbles, and the Company dispersed to settle down and take stock of their wounds.

“Are you hurt?”

Bilbo turned to Thorin and shook his head. “I think the running was worse than the actual fight. I’m sure I’ll be stiff and sore in the morning. You?”

The corner of Thorin’s mouth quirked up at the comment. “I am well.” As he said it, he glanced over to where his nephews were standing across the room.

“You should check on them,” Bilbo said, nodding at the two young dwarves. “We’ll talk more later.”

Thorin seemed to hesitate for a moment, but then he patted Bilbo’s shoulder and stepped away.

Bilbo watched him go, then went to find an empty corner where he could sit in a pile of comfy hay and get off his aching feet.

 

***

 

Late that night, when the Company finally settled in and the house was filled with the sound of snoring dwarves, Bilbo couldn’t sleep.

He laid in his pile of hay, wide awake and staring at the ceiling above him, tracing the rafters with his eyes and desperately trying to think of something—anything—to distract himself from the weight of the object currently sitting in his pocket. Such a small thing, yet he could still feel it there. Could feel it caressing the back of his mind, like a cat rubbing up against a person’s legs, begging for attention.

Up until now, it wasn't too much of a struggle to ignore it. Over the past four days, they had always been on the move, and he was focused on watching for signs of Azog’s hunting party catching up with them. He’d had plenty to occupy his mind, what with his newfound discovery concerning Thorin.

But they weren’t moving now.

Now, they were safe (relatively speaking, anyways) and he was finally getting the chance to think about other things. But he really didn’t want to.

Because this thing in his pocket was evil. He wanted nothing more than to throw it away in some deep, dark hole and never look at it again.

Before their confrontation with Gollum in the goblin tunnels, Bilbo hadn’t considered how difficult it might be to carry the Ring with the knowledge he now possessed. After many long years, he forgot how it felt to bear the weight of it. Now, with it back in his pocket, as if it had never left, he wondered how he could have ever forgotten. How he could have forgotten its whispers.

Eventually, it became too much for him to bear.

With a shaking hand, Bilbo carefully pulled the Ring from his pocket.

It sat in his palm, just a golden trinket, glinting in the dim light of the few candles lit around the house. Yet, for a trinket, it felt heavy as a mountain.

He stared at it, imagining he could see the glowing inscription around the band.

‘Hello, thief.’

Bilbo jolted and nearly dropped the Ring on the ground. Heart hammering, he looked around the room, looking for any sign that someone else had heard the soft whisper, like a hiss.

Nobody stirred.

Had he imagined it?

He looked back to the Ring, the hair at the nape of his neck standing on end.

‘I never thought to meet you again, Bilbo Baggins.’

“What?” Bilbo winced at the sound of his own voice in the quiet of the house, high pitched and shaking.

‘You are different than when I last saw you. Smarter. Younger.’

Bilbo closed his eyes and shook his head, like he might be able to banish the voice from his mind. Or it would somehow wake him up from a bad dream.

When he opened his eyes again, the Ring gleamed, and he had the horrible sensation that it knew he was afraid.

‘Have you missed me, old friend?’