Chapter Text
Thorin woke at dawn to someone shaking him. It was unusually difficult to drag himself to consciousness that morning, likely due to the softer sleeping arrangements. Still, after a few moments, he opened his eyes to see Bilbo hovering over him.
He jolted and sat up quickly, already reaching for his sword. “What is it? Is something wrong?”
“Oh, calm down, you silly dwarf.” Bilbo sat back on his haunches, looking exasperated. “Nothing’s wrong. It’s only that Beorn is outside, and I think the sooner that we introduce ourselves, the better.”
Relaxing a bit, he nodded. “You are right.”
“Of course I am. Now come on and help me wake the others.”
Amused, Thorin watched the hobbit move away and head towards where Bofur and Nori were sleeping, the former of the two snoring loudly and sprawled out so he was half on top of his partner. Then he stood and kicked Dwalin’s outstretched boot on his way to wake Kili and Fili, snickering when his friend snapped awake and hit Gloin in his struggle to get to his feet.
It wasn’t long before the whole Company was up and awake, yawning and grumbling irritably at being woken up so early on a day they weren’t actually running for their lives.
Granted, if their host wasn’t feeling very charitable, that might change soon enough.
Just like he said he would a few days ago at the Carrock, Bilbo was taking it upon himself to lead the introductions to Beorn, which was likely a good idea. If anyone could talk an angry skin-changer out of ripping them all to pieces, it was Bilbo. So Thorin had no issue with letting the hobbit—who was standing in front of them all with his hands on his hips, looking for all the world like a mother lecturing a group of unruly dwarflings—take charge for a while.
“Gandalf and I will go out first and talk to him, then I’ll wave for Thorin to join us. After that, you’ll come out in small groups at a time when, and only when, I wave for the next group. Balin will keep watch and send you out when I give the signal. Dori, Ori, and Nori will come out first. Then Oin and Gloin. Then Fili and Kili. Bofur, Bifur, and Bombur. Balin and Dwalin will be last. Any questions?”
Clearing his throat, Dori took a small step forward and spoke. “I have one. This is nothing against you of course, Master Baggins, but if he’s really so dangerous, would it not be better to let the wizard speak with this skin-changer first?”
“I was wondering the same thing, actually,” Gandalf piped up from where he stood at the back of the group.
Bilbo simply raised a brow. “If we were expecting a fight, we wouldn’t be going out there to speak with our host at all. As it is, this interaction is about making a good first impression, meaning we need a certain amount of tact and good manners.”
The old wizard actually looked offended at that and Thorin coughed, trying to mask his laugh, but Bilbo must have heard it because he spoke again.
“That’s also why we’re not sending Thorin out first.”
Several members of the Company didn’t even try to hide their laughter at that comment, a certain pair of princes being the loudest of the bunch, and Thorin scowled.
“Anyone else? No? Good.” Bilbo took a step towards the door, then paused and gave them all a stern look. “Remember what Gandalf said. Master Beorn isn’t overly fond of dwarves. Wait for my signal, and when you come out, introduce yourselves then keep quiet. Don’t crowd him. And definitely don’t draw your weapons.”
The hobbit let his gaze settle on a certain bald headed warrior.
“What’re you looking at me for?” Dwalin spluttered.
Bilbo didn’t respond and just headed for the door, catching Thorin’s eye as he passed and sending him a small wink.
Thorin couldn’t help but smile as he watched the hobbit disappear outside with Gandalf close behind.
***
The introductions to Beorn went fairly well in comparison to the first journey, and Beorn seemed to take a liking to Bilbo rather quickly, which likely helped keep him amiable even as thirteen dwarves began coming out of his house.
A few hours later, after recounting the tale of their journey so far to their host and eating their fill of the food that he provided, the Company had dispersed and were enjoying the rare instance of peace and safety. Many were snoring in the hay piles, catching up on lost sleep. Those who weren’t napping had found their own ways to entertain themselves, either sitting quietly inside or enjoying the nice weather.
And with the Company distracted, that meant Thorin finally had the chance to have a long awaited conversation with his burglar.
He found Bilbo sitting on a bench at the huge dining table, his feet kicking back and forth from where they dangled almost comically high above the floor. He was humming cheerfully to himself, all of his attention focused on the pile of honey cakes in front of him.
A warm feeling bloomed in Thorin’s chest at the sight, and for a moment he just stood there and watched. He shook himself out of it soon enough, though, and took another step closer. “Bilbo.”
The hobbit jumped slightly then turned, a smile lighting up his face a moment later. “Thorin.”
“I was hoping to speak with you for a while. That is, if you’re not busy.”
“Oh, not at all,” Bilbo said quickly. He turned and grabbed several of the honey cakes then hopped down from the bench and walked over to Thorin.
He led the way to the door, and they passed Fili and Kili on their way out. The moment his sister-sons saw them, they grinned and Kili leaned over to whisper something in his brother’s ear, making Fili snort out a laugh.
Thorin rolled his eyes and kept walking, then sighed after the two disappeared inside the house. “Those two.”
“They don’t mean any harm,” Bilbo pointed out. His voice held an affectionate tone, but there was something wistful to it as well. “I’m just happy to hear them laugh.”
Thorin just nodded in silent agreement, and neither of them said anything more as they turned towards the garden. They kept walking until the house was hidden by a row of trees and they found a secluded spot behind some rose bushes. Stopping at a patch of grass, Thorin sat down and patted the spot beside him, motioning for Bilbo to join him. The hobbit did so, dropping to sit crisscross on the ground, leaving a small space between the two of them.
Bilbo took a honey cake off the top of his pile and held it out to him. “What do you want to talk about?”
Pausing for a moment to gather his thoughts, Thorin took the offered cake, but didn’t take a bite out of it yet. Eventually, he said, “everything, but first, I want to apologize.”
“What for?”
“For the awful way I treated you when we finally reached Erebor.”
“Oh.” Bilbo’s smile fell and he stopped eating. “Thorin, that really isn’t necessary—”
He interrupted the hobbit before he could finish. “Please, Bilbo, let me get it off my chest. It has weighed heavily on me for the past few months.”
Bilbo sighed, then nodded. “Alright, then. Go on.”
Despite his eagerness to finally speak honestly, Thorin hesitated. One of his biggest regrets of the first journey was that he never had the chance to properly apologize to Bilbo—or any other members of the Company—for his actions after they retook the mountain. There was nothing he could ever do to make up for what he put them all through. All he could do now was make sure that it never happened again. That goal was what kept him from spiraling into his guilt. After all, any apology he tried to make now would only create more questions that he had no way of answering. At least, that was what he had thought up until that moment in Rivendell all those weeks ago, when he realized that there may be one person who would understand. But now that he had his chance, what could he possibly say to make it right? No apology could erase past hurts. Still, he had to try.
“In my madness, I could think of nothing but the Arkenstone. I let it cloud my judgement. Let it taint my trust in the people I love most. My own family. Somehow, I believed that you were all conspiring to keep it from me. And then that day at the gate...it was like my worst fears had come true. I said such hateful things to you. I can hardly bear to think about it now.” He paused, grimacing. None of it was coming out the way he wanted it to.
Bilbo had listened to him ramble patiently, but spoke up before Thorin could make another attempt at saying what was on his mind. “You were sick, Thorin. And you were hardly the only one at fault for what happened that day. I did betray you. I gave the Arkenstone to Thranduil of all people. Your anger wasn’t entirely undeserved.”
“You did not deserve any part of what I did to you.” It came out sharper than he meant them to, and he winced, then softened his tone. “You were only doing what you thought was best. And gold sickness or no, I still did it. I know I hurt you, and for that I am deeply sorry.”
For several long moments, Bilbo didn’t say anything, and the look on his face was unreadable, though there was an undeniable sadness in his hazel eyes. Thorin held the hobbit’s gaze for as long as he could, then looked down to his lap and stared at the honey cake still in his hands.
“I forgive you. I have forgiven you, Thorin.” Bilbo said it with no amount of uncertainty.
It was as though the words lifted a weight from his chest, and Thorin drew in a deep breath. Still, he couldn’t stop himself from questioning the response. “After everything, you forgive me just like that? That easily?”
“Believe me, it was anything but easy.” Bilbo sighed tiredly. “I may not look it, but I am old, Thorin. For me, these things happened a very long time ago. And I’ve had a very long time to make peace with it.”
“How long?”
“Around eighty years, give or take a few. I started to lose count near the end.” Something in the hobbit’s tone changed and he chuckled a bit.
Thorin didn’t laugh. Instead, it felt like the breath was knocked out of him and he looked up again so quickly it almost hurt his neck. “Eighty years.”
Bilbo shot him a smile and puffed up slightly, something like pride crossing his face. “You are looking at the longest lived hobbit in history. I suppose I cheated, though. I never would have lasted as long as I did if not for…”
He trailed off slowly, a far away look appearing in his eyes, and one of his hands moved to hover over his jacket pocket.
“Bilbo?”
He snapped back to the present and immediately took his hand away from his jacket, instead grabbing one of his honey cakes and jamming half of it into his mouth. He chewed for several seconds then swallowed and cleared his throat before speaking again, not quite meeting Thorin’s gaze. “Anyways, the point is, I forgave you a long time ago, so there’s no point in you holding onto all that guilt. It’s all in the past.”
Before he could reply, Bilbo started eating again, and Thorin sighed before taking a bite of his own cake.
They sat in silence for several minutes and Thorin took the time to sort through his thoughts. It was a relief to have finally apologized, though he knew he wouldn’t be able to completely let go of the guilt for a long time to come, no matter what Bilbo said. Even more relieving was the fact that Bilbo had apparently lived a very long life. Over the past few days, he found a part of himself beginning to worry that something terrible may have happened to the hobbit in order for him to be sent back in time as well, seeing as Thorin’s second journey was a result of his own untimely death. He wasn’t sure he could bear it if it turned out that Bilbo had died soon after him and didn’t end up surviving the quest after all.
Granted, that raised the question of what did happen after he died there on Ravenhill. If eighty years had truly gone by, then that meant Bilbo was starting over a much larger part of his life than this quest alone.
As if the hobbit could read his thoughts, he finally spoke again. “What else were you wanting to talk about, then?”
“I would like to know what happened after my death.”
He didn’t miss the way that Bilbo flinched at the words, but his reply came out jokingly, if not a bit tense. “You really are going straight for the fun topics, aren’t you?”
Thorin did say anything, just giving him an expectant look.
Bilbo sighed and finished off his honey cake, then looked up at the sky.
“Very well. After you…” his voice shook and he paused for a moment before going on. “A couple days after the battle, we had the funeral and then Dain was crowned king.”
Thorin nodded, having already known about Dain becoming king. “And the rest of the Company? I know about Fili and Kili,” he swallowed thickly before finishing his question. “But did the others make it?”
“Yes. There were some injuries, but everyone else lived.”
He felt himself relax at the news and found himself silently thanking Mahal for it. After a moment, he returned his attention back to Bilbo. “And you?”
“Gandalf and I left the next morning, and we reached the Shire by late spring.”
It was comforting, really, to know that despite all the danger that he dragged the hobbit into, he still went on to live a long life. He made it back to his home, with his armchair and his books and his garden, and had hopefully never been dragged onto any more dangerous adventures.
“I am glad,” he said quietly. He could have left it at that. Should have, really. But a small thought in the back of his mind sparked his curiosity and he spoke again before he could stop himself. “And what of your life after you made it home? Were you happy? Did you...ever marry?”
He regretted the words the moment they came out of his mouth and he winced, silently cursing himself. Why would ask such a stupid question?
Bilbo stilled, and gave him an odd look. Then, after several seconds, he shook his head. “No, I never married. I couldn’t bring myself to consider it after… Well, at any rate, it didn’t matter at all. No hobbit would have wanted to marry old Mad Baggins anyways.” The statement left them in an uncomfortable silence as Thorin pondered what that could have meant, but Bilbo perked up after a moment. “I wasn’t alone the whole time, of course. Eventually I had Frodo to keep me company.”
“Frodo?” Thorin asked, glad for the change of subject.
“Yes, my nephew. Well, I say nephew, but really he’s my cousin. The boy always insisted on calling me his uncle though, and I gave up on correcting him after a while.” Bilbo grinned, shaking his head a bit. “I adopted him after his parents drowned in a boating accident. Sad business, that was, but I have to say I was ever so grateful to have him. Bag End was beginning to get a bit too quiet for me to handle, and he brought a bit of life into the place. I often found myself thinking he and his friends would get on with Kili and Fili quite well.”
And just like that, whatever discomfort lingering between them melted away. Bilbo started rambling about his life, and Thorin found that he was quite content to sit back and listen.
Hearing that the hobbit returned home at the end of his journey to find his belongings all being auctioned off irritated Thorin immensely, but Bilbo just shook his head when he recalled the memory, seeming mildly amused. The more he talked, the more Thorin found himself disliking the other inhabitants of the Shire. From what he could understand, the hobbits all treated Bilbo as an outcast upon his return from his adventure, calling him mad and whispering about him behind his back. Apparently, he lost all respectability in the eyes of his kin, and he never really managed to regain it all.
At one point, Thorin interrupted to point out that Bilbo had saved all of the Company’s lives multiple times and should have been regarded as a hero. Bilbo just laughed in response and shook his head, saying that his so-called “heroics” were only more reason for his family and neighbors to look down on him.
“They didn’t quite like hearing that I’d gone up against trolls and orcs and dragons. A lot of people were convinced that I simply wandered off and gotten myself lost somewhere for a year and ended up eating too many hallucinogenic mushrooms.” Bilbo chuckled, somehow amused by the idea, then went on. “The children all seemed to enjoy my tales, though. When we had parties I’d end up surrounded by nearly every fauntling in Hobbiton, all begging for me to tell them another story.”
He brightened at whatever new memory that brought up and grinned. “Speaking of parties, the best was by far my hundred and eleventieth birthday. It was like a festival. Half the Shire showed up, and Gandalf brought fireworks, and there was music and dancing. And I gave a speech long enough to rival one of yours, Thorin!”
At that, Thorin jolted and half sat up from where he had lain back on the grass, letting out a sound of protest and ready to argue that his speeches weren’t that long, but Bilbo just laughed and kept talking.
“Though, I think my speech was far more entertaining than any of yours. I insulted all of my relatives. You should have seen their faces! Then I snuck away and left the party in chaos and by the time I made it back to Bag End, Bofur, Nori, and Bifur were all there waiting for me. They were traveling back to Erebor from Ered Luin, you see, and I intended to go with them. I was getting so bored in the Shire, and I wanted to go on another adventure.” Bilbo’s voice turned a bit sad, then, but there was still a soft smile on his face as he spoke. “I only made it as far as Rivendell before I realized my legs were too old to carry me through the Misty Mountains. I was so disappointed. I never did get to see Erebor again.”
Frowning, Thorin rolled onto his side and propped his head up to look at the hobbit. “Did you turn back, then?”
“No. I ended up staying with the elves for a fair amount of time. It gave me the chance to finish writing my— Oh don’t make that face, Thorin Oakenshield, I quite enjoyed my time in Rivendell and Elrond was a good friend of mine by then.”
Thorin hadn’t even realized he’d grimaced at the mention of Bilbo living with the elves. Huffing, he muttered out an apology, and couldn’t help but return the hobbit’s smile a moment later. He opened his mouth to speak, but didn’t get the chance.
Bilbo’s gaze slid up to the sky and he blinked. “Why did you let me go on for so long?”
Glancing to where Bilbo was looking, Thorin saw that the sun was just beginning to set behind the Misty Mountains. He blinked, too, not having noticed just how long they’d been sitting there together.
He sat up and stretched, getting a satisfying crack from his spine, then got to his feet. “I liked listening,” he said, then held out a hand to help Bilbo up. “Besides, we had nothing more important to be doing.”
Bilbo smiled at him. “I suppose you’re right. Shall we head back to the house? I believe we should be having supper soon.”
Thorin nearly agreed with the suggestion, but stopped when he caught movement from the corner of his eye. It was barely noticeable, and could have easily just been a squirrel scampering up the side of a tree or maybe a bird, but something told him that it wasn’t. Forcing himself to return Bilbo’s smile, he shook his head. “You go ahead. I will be there in a few minutes.”
The hobbit stared up at him curiously for a moment, then just shrugged. “Alright.” He turned to go, but stopped and reached out, touching Thorin’s arm. His next words were hushed, and that odd look from earlier returned to his eyes. “I really did miss you, you know.”
If it weren’t for the fact that he suspected that they had an audience, Thorin may have done something more. As it was, he just nodded and put his hand over Bilbo’s, squeezing in what he hoped was a reassuring gesture. After a few moments, Bilbo smiled up at him then pulled away and started towards the house. Thorin watched him go, then once the hobbit was out of sight he turned and started going in the opposite direction, heading towards a small clump of trees not far off from where they had been sitting. He reached the tree that he had seen the movement by, and walking around it, sure enough, he found a certain red-headed thief.
“How much of that did you hear?” he growled angrily.
Nori looked up at him, spinning a knife he had been using to pick at his fingernails. “How much did I hear of what?”
Glowering, Thorin drew himself up taller and folded his arms over his chest, not at all amused by the feigned ignorance.
“Alright, fine,” Nori said, putting the knife away and standing up straighter. “I heard all of it, but don’t go blaming me. Believe it or not, I wasn’t eavesdropping intentionally. It’s not my fault you two decided to talk so close to where I was napping and woke me up.”
Cursing, Thorin turned away and started to pace, dragging a hand through his tangled hair. He walked back and forth a few times, then stopped and grabbed onto Nori’s arm tightly, staring down at him. “Not a word of this to anyone,” he hissed. “Understand?”
The dwarf raised a braided eyebrow, seemingly unconcerned by the furious glare Thorin was giving him. “Just to be clear, you don’t want me to tell anyone that our king and our burglar have both been sent back from the future to redo this quest that apparently ended in disaster the first time around?”
“Nori.”
“Yeah, fine.” Nori shook his head, looking exasperated. He looked Thorin up and down for a moment, then said, “I won’t tell anyone. Not that they’d believe me if I did. I’m not even sure that I believe it.”
Thorin finally let go of Nori’s arm and took a few steps back, sighing. He’d forgotten about his exhaustion and stress for a while—the talk with Bilbo served as a good distraction—but it was beginning to weigh on him again like he had the entire Lonely Mountain sitting atop his shoulders. He could only hope that Nori would keep his word and not tell anyone about what he heard. He had considered telling the Company about it, but until he made his decision he didn’t want them finding out from someone else. No, if they learned of what he and Bilbo had experienced, they would hear it from their king.
“Cheer up, Thorin. I’m sure everything will work out alright in the end. There’s no need to tie yourself up in knots over it.” Nori clapped him on the shoulder, his large grin visible even from beneath his beard, then he turned and walked away, headed for the house.
Watching him go, Thorin couldn’t help but think that he wouldn’t be saying such a thing if he knew what lay in wait ahead of them.
