Actions

Work Header

To Fix What Was Broken

Chapter 19: The Price of Freedom

Summary:

Thorin's hopes of making it out of Mirkwood without any run-ins with spiders or elves are dashed. And with Bilbo being captured alongside the rest of the Company, he has to face the challenge of negotiating for their freedom without letting his anger ruin their chances of being released.

Notes:

So, I've got good news and bad news. The good news is, I used NaNoWriMo to work on this fic and I've nearly gotten all of it written--save for a few major scenes that I'm still hashing out. The bad news is, it's finals season, meaning I have two big papers to write and a Spanish exam to study for so I can't actually get around to finishing those scenes. My hope is that once the semester ends, I'll be able to start posting a new chapter once a week until it's done. Fingers crossed. No promises.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

When Thorin awoke, he felt worse than he did the day before. His entire body was stiff and aching and he could practically feel the weight of hunger pressing down on him. They’d run out of water two days ago, now, and their food a day before that. They wouldn’t make it much farther if they didn’t find some way to replenish their supplies, but they hadn’t come across so much as a stream since crossing the enchanted river and there was no food to be seen save for the occasional scrawny squirrel that crossed their path, and those were no good to eat. Kili shot one several days ago and they’d tried cooking it over a fire that released putrid smoke and drew biting insects to them. He’d taken one bite and spat it out—the meat tasted like it was rotted, as if the squirrel had been decomposing even as it was scurrying around the miserable forest.

Mirkwood was proving to be just as bad as he remembered it.

His only consolation was that they had yet to lose the path. That, and the warm creature that slept beside him.

Opening his eyes, Thorin had to blink away the bleariness then allow his vision to adjust to the dim light. Dawn was nearing, but the sun had not yet risen and the long shadows of the forest were still so thick as to seem nearly tangible. Avoiding looking at any of those shadows too closely, Thorin cast his gaze around the area, taking a mental count of his companions, and was relieved to see that they were all still there. Everyone else was still asleep, besides Bofur and Bifur who were on the last watch of the night.

Normally, the watch would only require one dwarf to be awake at a time, but shortly after entering the woods the Company collectively agreed that they’d all feel safer if they took watch in pairs. So that was the way they’d been doing it for nearly three weeks, now.

Satisfied that no one was missing, Thorin finally looked to Bilbo.

The hobbit was curled up against his side, breathing softly in sleep, one arm draped over Thorin’s torso and his face pressed into his shirt. Thorin’s fur overcoat was laying over him like a blanket, as he’d woken in the middle of the night to find Bilbo shivering with cold.

What the Company thought when they woke up each morning to find their King and their burglar wrapped around each other, he didn’t know. No one had so much as mentioned it—not even his nosy sister-sons who normally wouldn’t miss a chance to tease him. If they’d been anywhere but where they were, they certainly would have teased him. But this was Mirkwood, where the air was heavy and the nights were cold, and they had all taken to huddling together for warmth as they slept.

He hated it there. But at least, he thought as he looked down at the hobbit beside him, he wasn’t alone.

When the dawn came, it took less than half an hour for everyone to wake up and start walking again. Despite the fatigue and hunger and exhaustion, they were all eager to get out of the forest and that was motivation enough to start moving. That, and they were all afraid of staying in one place for too long. They stopped at night out of necessity—it was so dark, they could barely see their own hands in front of their faces and if they tried to continue on, they would lose the path for sure. Not to mention each other. It was always a relief when dawn came, if only so that they could actually see their surroundings and be sure none of their friends had gone missing during the night.

So they walked, and though there was no such thing as a “good day” underneath those dreaded trees, it was slightly less miserable than the others. Though the air was still thick and hard to breathe, it wasn’t causing hallucinations or disorientation. At least, not as much as usual. They were clear minded enough, in fact, that they didn’t have to tie themselves together to ensure that no one wandered off. Thanks to the lack of rope tugging at their waists, the Company was in a considerably better mood. So much so that Thorin even heard the occasional joke that was met with a short bout of scattered laughter.

It gave him hope that maybe they were reaching the other side of the forest and that they would soon find themselves leaving the trees behind. After all, they managed to stay with the path much longer and further than they did the first time they went through the woods. They had to be coming close to the end of it.

He should have known better.

It was around mid-afternoon when he felt someone tug insistently at his sleeve and he glanced back to see Bilbo’s anxious face.

“What is it?” he asked, automatically looking back on the line of dwarves behind him and counting heads until he got up to twelve.

“I think we’re getting close to a spider nest,” Bilbo said.

Furrowing his brows, Thorin looked at their surroundings then stopped walking and blinked a few times.

Sure enough, there were webs littered throughout the trees around them. And as he looked ahead, he saw they grew thicker and thicker farther up the path. How had he not noticed them before?

“Why did we stop?”

Dwalin’s distant voice calling from the back of the line snapped him out of his daze and he turned back to look at the Company, then back down to Bilbo. “Do you think they will be on the path?”

“I don’t know, but we can’t leave it.” Bilbo peeked around him to look ahead then drew back and shook his head. “I think the best we can do is avoid touching the webs and stay quiet. Hopefully they won’t even notice we’re here.”

Pursing his lips, Thorin decided against pointing out that it would be hard not to notice thirteen dwarves and a hobbit. Bilbo was right, of course. Leaving the path proved to be disastrous the first time and he wasn’t inclined to do it again. Though, he also wasn’t inclined to face a hoard of giant spiders again, either. Still, between possibility of disaster and certainty of one, he’d prefer to go with the former. They would just have to keep quiet.

After a few moments of thought, he relayed the orders to the Company and they moved on.

For their part, the dwarves did well at keeping the noise they made to a minimum, though Thorin found himself wincing at every boot that crunched on fallen leaves or twigs. He wished they all had the light step of hobbits like Bilbo, who was walking beside him on silent feet.

They only made it like that for ten minutes.

Just as Thorin was thinking maybe they could sneak through without being caught, somebody let out a yell and he whirled around in time to watch Kili careen off the path and fall directly into one of the webs.

For a moment, there was complete silence, as if the world held its breath. Then there was a low rumbling noise and the entire forest started to shake.

The Company leapt into action. Fili and Ori both lunged forward to help pull Kili out of the web as everyone else drew their weapons and fell into a defensive circle so they had eyes in every direction. Thorin glanced over at Bilbo as the hobbit drew Sting from its sheath, a resigned look on his face. He caught Thorin’s gaze and grimaced.

“I hate spiders,” the hobbit said.

Thorin had just enough time to grumble an agreement before several massive creatures appeared from the treetops above and dropped down onto them. In his peripheral vision, Thorin saw some of his friends take a hesitant step back in the face of the massive spiders.

He took a steadying breath, raised Orcrist, and shouted. “Du-bekâr!”

The rest of the Company echoed him, Bilbo’s voice among them, and they plunged into the fight.

The spiders seemed endless. One fell and two more took its place, and that wasn’t even mentioning all the normal sized spiders that covered parts of the forest floor like a moving carpet. It took all the focus Thorin had to defend himself from the onslaught and keep an eye on the others at the same time—all while he concentrated on fighting his way to his sister-sons.

Fili and Kili were holding their own, but he still would feel better if he were fighting at their side. Just to be safe.

Thorin hacked the leg off a spider that lurched towards him, then plunged his sword through its eyes as it screamed. He leapt over its fallen carcass and kept going.

He wasn’t worried about Bilbo. The hobbit was fairing just as well as the rest of them, and he had fallen to fighting side by side with Dwalin. He knew his best friend would protect the smallest member of their Company to the death if need be, so he continued past them without hesitation. Though, he did pause momentarily to help pull the legs off a spider that managed to knock Dori to the ground and was snapping its sharp pincers at the dwarf’s face. As soon as the spider was dead, he and Gloin each grabbed one of the disheveled dwarf’s hands and pulled him to his feet. Dori gave a breathless word of thanks before he turned and lunged for a spider that had Ori cornered against a tree.

Thorin only managed to take about half a dozen more steps towards his sister-sons when a high, piercing sound rose above the noise of the fight and he swore.

It was the Horn of the Mirkwood.

Meaning the elves had just joined the party.

Sure enough, within moments a scouting party fell upon them, appearing from the tree canopy high above, weapons ready before they even hit the ground. Among them, Thorin spotted a familiar pale-haired prince who went as far as using a tendril of spider web like a rope to slide down, firing arrows as he went.

Perfect.

He swore again.

It was over within a minute, the majority of the spiders dead and the few who still lived fled into the trees, closely pursued by several of the elves.

The ones who remained immediately turned their focus to stealing the Company’s weapons and herding them into a close circle. Thorin snarled at the elf who took Orcrist, but did nothing to stop him. What was the point? They were outnumbered and clearly outmatched, as much as he was loath to admit it. If the Company wasn’t exhausted and half starved to death, it would be a much different story. As it was, they followed Thorin’s lead and surrendered without much resistance.

At least they were all alive, he thought. All of his dwarves were there, and Bilbo…

Thorin cast his gaze around and whatever hope he had that the hobbit had gotten away was dashed as soon as he spotted a head of honey-golden curls beside Balin. A burst of anxiety coursed through him at the sight, but he didn’t get the chance to question how they would escape the dungeons. Before he could think much of anything at all, Legolas Thranduilion was standing before him, Orcrist in hand. And behind him stood a red-headed she-elf holding Sting.

“Where did you get these?”

Thorin didn’t deign to answer, knowing he’d be called a thief and a liar no matter his response. Rather, he just glowered at the elf in silence.

He never cared for the elf prince, even before Thrór fell to the gold-sickness and relations between the dwarves of Erebor and the elves of Mirkwood were strained, and then subsequently irrevocably shattered when Thranduil refused to send aid after the dragon attacked. He met Legolas a total of three times before that fateful day, and each time Thorin had gotten the distinct impression that he was just as stuck up as the rest of his kin. More so, even, thanks to his parentage. The prince always looked down his nose at Thorin and was just as patronizing and condescending as his kakhuf inbarathrag father.

In fact, Legolas was sneering down at him now.

When it became clear that Thorin wasn’t going to give him an answer, the elf turned away and shouted out a command in Sindarin to his guards. Thorin took the chance to shoot a glance back to his hobbit. Bilbo met his gaze and he shook his head slightly, looking apologetic. He didn’t have the time to think on it much, since the elves started pushing them into a line and led them into the forest—and away from the path.

 

***

 

As he found himself being led into the depths of the caves of Mirkwood once again, Thorin felt a heavy pit of dread start to build in his gut. He had not readily forgotten all those weeks spent in a deep, dark cell far from the rest of the Company. He was not ready to go back there again. Back to the constant fretting over the safety of his kin, and the anger at being held captive by one of the people he hated most, and the humiliation that came with knowing there was nothing he could do about it. And yet, despite being one of his lowest points in the whole quest, it had also become one of his most treasured.

Because as miserable as it had been, there were several light moments to interrupt the unending darkness.

He could still remember the feeling of relief he’d had when a familiar head of curly hair appeared at the door of his cell in one of the deepest levels of the dungeon. It took Bilbo nearly a week to finally find him there, and seeing that the hobbit had somehow evaded capture gave him a spark of hope. At that point, he was more than used to Bilbo saving them from difficult situations and tight spots, so he’d had no doubt that the hobbit would do it again. Still, it took time to solidify their escape plan, and in that time was when he finally had the chance to get to know his Company’s burglar more. It was also when he finally started to admit to himself that the hobbit truly was his One. Up until then, he had been doing everything he could to deny it. But after spending so much time alone together, their conversations becoming more and more personal as the days went by, he didn’t have much of a chance to continue that denial.

He ended up telling Bilbo things that he had never voiced out loud, even to Dwalin.

He gained a confidant down in those dungeons. More than that, he gained a true friend.

And just as Thorin knew he would, Bilbo got them out.

But now…

The Mirkwood guards continued to shepherd them deeper into the elvish kingdom until they eventually reached a divergence in the path. One path continued forward. The other sloped downward.

Three of the guards pulled Thorin out of the line as the rest of the Company was led onto that sinking path. A path that would take them to the dungeons far below.

With a lump in his throat, Thorin watched as they trooped past him, sending him apprehensive looks as they went. Bilbo was near the end of the line, and as he neared Thorin, his pace slowed despite the urging of the guard at the rear for him to keep moving.

The hobbit had not managed to evade capture this time. He had been taken prisoner along with the rest of the Company. That subtle disappearance in times of danger that Thorin had gotten so used to—had come to depend on, even—had not happened. And that meant they were going to have to find another way to get out of there. No, it meant that he was going to have to find another way out. He was their leader and this responsibility fell to him. It was unfair of him to have let himself place that expectation on Bilbo alone. He would have to apologize for that later.

Bilbo looked at him worriedly, and as he passed by, he spoke softly under his breath. “Stay steady, Thorin.”

He couldn’t find the words to respond, so he let out a shuddering breath and watched as his friends disappeared one by one. He had no idea how long it would be before he got to see them again. And with Bilbo captured, too… Thorin would be well and truly alone down in that dark cell in the deepest part of the dungeon if he didn’t succeed in negotiating their way out.

As soon as the Company was out of sight, their footsteps still echoing through the caverns, the guards who remained with Thorin surrounded him and they started walking again.

He recognized the path well enough to know where it would take them.

Their arrival to the throne room was much the same as it had been the first time around. Thranduil sat languidly upon that ridiculous throne of his that stood at least ten feet above the floor and required a staircase to get to, a glass of deep red wine in one hand, his clothes and jewelry shimmering in the bright lamplight of the room.

The elf king watched them file into the room through half-lidded pale eyes, looking for all the world entirely disinterested in them.

The guards stopped at the entrance, effectively blocking his only exit, but Thorin continued on until he reached the middle of the room. He stood tall with his head held high and met the King’s gaze challengingly.

Thranduil blinked at him slowly then turned his head away and drank from his glass.

Bristling, Thorin had to bite his tongue to stop himself from spitting out any words he would probably come to regret. He waited there in silence, watching as Thranduil slowly drained the wine. It wasn’t until the drink was gone and a servant stepped forward from behind the throne to take the empty glass that Thranduil finally turned his attention back to the dwarf standing before him. They stared at each other for several moments and Thorin refused to look away.

“Some may imagine that a noble quest is at hand. A quest to reclaim a homeland and slay a dragon. I myself suspect a more prosaic motive. Attempted burglary, or something of that ilk.”

Thorin glowered at the elf. He had heard this little speech before, of course, but he still didn’t appreciate the suggestion that he and his Company were nothing but thieves. Still, he forced himself to keep his silence.

Thranduil leaned forward, looking down on him as if he were a speck of dirt of the polished floor. “You have found a way in. You seek that which would bestow upon you the right to rule. A King’s jewel. The Arkensto—”

At the mention of the stone, Thorin felt his thin thread of control begin to fray. “We seek a home that is rightfully ours. I do not need a sparkling stone to tell me I am the true King. I have earned that right over a hundred and seventy years of leading my people through peril and poverty.”

He ignored the small voice in the back of his mind that said he was a liar—that he would never be king without the stone in his possession—and kept his focus on Thranduil.

The elf’s expression was unreadable, though one of his eyebrows raised ever so slightly. His voice, however, held a thinly veiled tone of condescension. “And yet, there is no army at your back. Tell me, Thorin son of Thrain, son of Thror, if you truly do not need the stone to be King, then why have your people not answered the call to take back their home?"

“We have lost enough to dragon-fire,” Thorin said lowly.

“And what makes you think they will not be soon losing their King as well, when he insists on walking straight into a dragon’s hoard with nothing more than twelve dwarves and a halfling?”

“Hobbit.”

“What?”

“He is a hobbit. He is not half of anything.”

Thranduil studied him closely for a moment, something like curiosity flitting across his face for a brief moment. Then the look was gone, replaced once again by cool indifference. “Tell me, why should I release you and risk the awakening of the dragon?”

“I would think you would be perfectly content to watch us be killed by Smaug. You were happy enough to do it once before.” Thorin couldn’t help but let the accusation slip, a vicious bite in his voice.

Thranduil’s eyes flashed dangerously and he sat back in his throne abruptly. Thorin didn’t miss the way the elf’s slender hands gripped the armrests tighter, his knuckles going white. He wasn’t quite sure what it was about the words that elicited the change, but he felt a spark of satisfaction that he had obviously hit a nerve.

A minute or two passed by in silence before either of them spoke again.

“Perhaps we can come to an agreement.”

He braced himself, knowing what was going to come next.

“Within that mountain lies something that I, too, desire. A chest of White Gems of pure starlight. Swear to return them to me, and I will let you go.” The elf king’s voice was casual enough, but he saw the greed lying just under the surface.

Thorin bit down on his tongue to stop himself from letting his initial reply escape.

Stay steady, Thorin, a familiar voice said in the back of his mind.

Bilbo. The hobbit knew it would come to this, somehow. As they were leaving Beorn’s, he even tried to warn Thorin. Why he hadn’t just said it outright, Thorin didn’t know, but it wasn’t important right now. What was important was that Bilbo knew how easily he might lose his temper and condemn them all. And he knew that he didn’t want to let Bilbo down. He didn’t want to let any of them down.

The Company was counting on him, and they were worth more than his own pride. It was a small price to pay.

Drawing in a steadying breath, Thorin forced himself to speak, albeit begrudgingly. “A box of Gems is well worth our freedom.”

Thranduil’s gaze was heavy on him. “Do you swear it?”

Thorin held the elf’s stare, considering.

Careful. He had to be careful here.

Steady, Thorin.

“If I swear to return your Gems, you will swear to release all fourteen members of my Company, return our weapons to us, and allow us to leave your kingdom unhindered.”

The ghost of a smirk pulled up at the corner of Thranduil’s mouth, as if the specific wording of Thorin’s demand amused him. “I will release all thirteen dwarves and the hobbit and will allow you to leave, yes.”

Thorin’s eyes narrowed. “And our weapons?”

“I will return them all.” Thranduil paused for half a moment, then spoke again. “All but two. The elvish blades you carried when my scouts caught you will remain with me until the White Gems are returned, as insurance to compel you to keep your word.”

His stomach tightened, as if he had swallowed a rock, and he had to slam back the wave of fury that rose in him at the words.

Orcrist and Sting.

He had no desire to part with his sword, and had no doubt Bilbo would feel the same. After all, the hobbit had gone through the effort to reclaim the two blades when they were passing through the Trollshaws. But would Bilbo be willing to give up Sting if it meant the Company’s freedom?

As much as he hated it, Thorin knew the answer to that question would be a firm yes.

Steadying himself, Thorin looked up at the elf king sitting high above him and grit his teeth. “It is a deal.”

“Very well.” Thranduil relaxed back in his throne, looking satisfied, and motioned for the elves that still stood a silent guard at the entrance. “In one week hence, you will be released from my dungeons.”

It took a moment for the words to sink in, then Thorin lunged forward in outrage just as the guards reached him and held him back. “You gave your word!”

Thranduil looked thoroughly unimpressed at Thorin’s anger as he took a sip of his newly filled glass of wine that had just been placed in his hand. “And I will keep it. However, you come in a time of celebration and I have not the guards to spare to escort you and your Company to the borders of the Greenwood.”

“We need no escort! Bring us to the path and we will leave ourselves!”

“And allow a bunch of dwarves to wander freely through my kingdom? I think not.”

Thorin swore at him, but the King gave no reaction.

“You have one week, Thorin Oakenshield. I suggest you rest while you have the chance.”

Notes:

Du-bekâr -- to arms

kakhuf inbarathrag -- goat turd

 

As always, the khuzdul came from the Dwarrow Scholar