Actions

Work Header

To Fix What Was Broken

Chapter 20: A Small Blade is Better Than None

Summary:

The Company is on their way out of Mirkwood when they're attacked once again, but at least they're not in barrels.

Notes:

This chapter didn't get a lot of editing. I hope it doesn't feel too choppy. Let me know if you notice any mistakes! :)

 

Edit: Thanks to Swirl_O_Whirl for pointing out that I had the timeline a little wrong concerning how long Bilbo had the Ring!

Chapter Text

The dungeon echoed with angry shouting and loud clangs as the cell doors slammed shut. Bilbo didn’t particularly care for being manhandled by an elf, so he slipped into his cell without complaint and was soon followed by Gloin who had to be half thrown in. He reached out to help the dwarf get his balance before he fell, but Gloin was too busy grumbling something about ‘goblin mutants’ to acknowledge him.

Sighing, Bilbo stepped around him to take a look outside.

On the other side of the narrow chasm, he watched the red-haired guard captain as she led Kili to a cell where Fili was already sitting on the floor and glaring at the wall across from him—they’d managed to find all of his daggers and knives, then.

The younger prince didn’t need to be forced into the cell, but he paused on the threshold and turned to the elf. Bilbo couldn’t hear what was said, but the elf’s lips twitched into something of a smile before pointing at the cell again. She closed the door behind Kili and there was a goofy grin on his face as he watched her walk away.

Bilbo snorted and shook his head. He hadn’t ever interacted with the elf on the first journey, but he remembered Bofur telling him about their time in Lake-town when Smaug attacked. Apparently, she showed up to heal Kili’s wound from the orc arrow he’d taken in the knee during their trip down the river and afterwards Kili was none too subtle about his adoration for her. He also remembered that she witnessed the youngest Durin’s death and was found crying over his body when the battle was over. After that, no one knew where she had gone. She just disappeared.

He often wished that he’d had the chance to speak with her at least once before she left. They both lost someone they loved on that dreadful day, after all, and he felt that she might have understood his pain better than anyone else.

Bilbo’s chest tightened and he immediately pushed the thought away. What did it matter? They were all alive and well, yet, and he had every intention of keeping it that way. There was no point in dwelling on a past that no longer existed.

So he turned his attention back to the present.

He could only see a fraction of the Company from where he stood, but he knew they were all there. He counted them during their long walk through the elvish kingdom and made sure that none of them looked to be seriously injured. To his relief, everyone seemed to be alright, save some scrapes and bruises.

As soon as all the cell doors were closed, the elves disappeared and the Company was left alone. The noise didn’t subside at all, though.

Several dwarves were shouting, their voices bouncing off the stone walls of the dungeon.

In the cell directly above the two princes, Dwalin was trying to use his body as a battering ram against the steel bars holding him prisoner and was spitting out a string of curses in khuzdul of which Bilbo understood just enough to recognize that they were particularly nasty ones.

It went on for a minute or so before Balin’s voice rose above the din. “Enough! There is no way out! No one leaves here but by the King’s consent.”

That was enough to silence them all. Even Gloin stopped his grumbling.

With that, Bilbo lowered himself to the floor and leaned back against the hard wall, stretching his sore legs out in front of him.

They were quiet for a long while. Then, eventually, Bofur’s voice spoke up rather hesitantly.

“Where d’you suppose they’ve taken him?”

Balin’s face appeared before the bars of the cell he shared with his brother and his gaze was fixed on the next level up above where Bilbo was.

“To meet with King Thranduil, I expect,” the old dwarf said, sounding more than a little put out at the thought.

Bilbo couldn’t blame him. He wasn’t too thrilled at the idea of Thorin speaking with that conceited ponce of a King all on his own, either. The dwarf was liable to lose his temper at any moment in the elf’s presence, and then where would they be?

Stuck there in that dungeon forever, probably.

Or until Gandalf eventually reappeared and convinced Thranduil to release them.

Either way, if Thorin couldn’t keep his anger in check, their chances weren’t looking good.

This was exactly what he had been afraid of.

Bilbo felt a flash of guilt and his hand slipped into his pocket of its own accord, wrapping his fingers around the little pouch that resided there. Then he pursed his lips. Maybe it was selfish of him to refuse to put on the Ring to help the Company. If he had, he could already be well on his way to helping them escape. Instead, there he was, just as trapped as the rest of them. But there was nothing for it. He couldn’t stand the thought of wearing that accursed Ring again. Actually, the idea terrified him. He couldn’t help but fear that he would once again be caught under its influence, and if that happened…

Bilbo couldn’t shake the feeling that the Ring was stronger now. It didn’t make the slightest bit of sense—and for the life of him, he couldn’t figure out how or why—but the Ring knew more than it should. It spoke more than it should. And it recognized him. And if he put it on and allowed it into his head, he shuddered to think what would happen.

The truth was, he didn’t know if he would be able to resist it.

Even after sixty years of carrying it with him wherever he went, using it to avoid relatives and for cheap party tricks, somehow this time was different.

He could not—would not—put it on ever again.

Even if that meant he had to find a different way to get through this quest.

 

***

 

It couldn’t have been more than an hour when the elvish guards reappeared with Thorin in tow. And Bilbo felt a spark of hope. If they were bringing Thorin to be with the rest of the Company rather than isolating him in a lonely cell far below, surely that was a good sign.

The moment they came into sight at the top of the stairs, someone let out a whoop and then everyone was crowding up to their cell doors to call out a greeting to their leader and jeer at the elves leading him. Bilbo scrambled to his feet and wrapped his hands around two of the bars, and when the group of four passed his cell, Thorin paused and met his gaze despite the elves urging him onward.

“How did it go?” he asked quietly.

There was a stormy look in Thorin’s eyes and he grimaced at the question, but he nodded in response.

Bilbo felt himself deflate a bit in relief.

Once Thorin was out of sight—it sounded like he was put in a cell two or three down from his own—he turned away from the door, intent on returning to his spot on the ground, but he paused when he found Gloin standing directly behind him.

The dwarf had an odd look on his face and he looked at Bilbo scrutinizingly. He stared back for a few moments, then shifted on his feet uncomfortably.

“What?”

Gloin’s eyes narrowed, but he shrugged and turned away. “It’s nothing.”

That was odd, but Bilbo didn’t have the energy to try and get an answer, so he shrugged too and sat down again.

 

***

 

Bilbo jolted awake in a cold sweat, heart hammering wildly and echoing in his ears. His eyes opened to find Gloin leaning over him, looking worried. Blinking, Bilbo looked around. It took several moments for him to recognize his surroundings and when he did, he let his head fall back against the wall with a dull thud and closed his eyes. The hand on his shoulder that had shaken him awake fell away and he heard the dwarf shuffle back to sit against the opposite wall.

The lights in the dungeon were dimmed, and he guessed it must be the middle of the night. He didn’t remember falling asleep. Given that he was still half sitting up with his back against the wall and a crick in his neck, sleep had likely come over him before he could take the time to at least try and find a more comfortable position. Not that it would have been easy, given that he was surrounded by nothing but stone walls and floors.

“Are you alright, lad?”

He opened his eyes again to look at Gloin, who was watching him closely. “I'm fine.”

The dwarf hummed, and for a moment, Bilbo thought he wouldn’t say anything more. Then he let out a long breath and spoke again, his voice a bit softer. “There’s no shame in it.”

“Sorry?”

“Bad dreams,” the dwarf said. “We all get them from time to time. Especially after everything we’ve been through over the past few months. None of us would think any less of you for it.”

Bilbo blinked, then sat up a little straighter, stifling a groan as his stiff muscles pulled and a twinge went through his neck. He couldn’t help the small bit of surprise at the admission.

If he noticed, the sincerity on Gloin's face didn’t waver. “If you ever need to talk about it, my ears are open. And I’ve no doubt the same goes for the rest of the Company. Well...except Oin, of course.” He chuckled a bit at that.

Gloin had always been kind to him, even if he hadn’t been as close to the dwarf as some of the others. At least, not until several decades after the quest was over and they met again in Rivendell. They became good friends there in the valley of elves, catching each other up on their lives since they’d last seen one another at the gates of Erebor. Then, after the Ring was destroyed and the Fellowship returned, Bilbo helped the dwarf work through the emotional turmoil of finding out that his son was going to marry an elf—an elf who was the “spawn” of Thranduil, no less.

He smiled slightly at the memory. “Thank you, Gloin. Truly.”

“Bah! Don’t thank me.” Gloin waved away the thanks, though he did give Bilbo a half smile in return and his voice softened again. “It’s no less than I’d do for any of the others.”

 

***

 

As glad as Bilbo was to be leaving the halls of Mirkwood behind them—and as relieved as he was that Thorin actually managed to keep his head and work out a deal with Thranduil—he wasn’t particularly pleased that it came at the price of Sting. He told himself that it was a necessary sacrifice and that, really, it wasn’t forever, as long as Thranduil deigned to keep his word and return the elvish blades once the White Gems were returned to him. Still, it didn’t change the fact that without the familiar weight of his sword on his hip, Bilbo felt rather exposed. He supposed he should at least be grateful that his mother’s dagger was returned to him, along with the rest of the Company’s weapons. Given the circumstances, they had gotten off fairly well.

Quickening his pace a little, he said as much to Thorin.

The dwarf had been in an incredibly stormy mood ever since they were released from the dungeons nearly two hours ago. In part because of Orcrist, but also because Thranduil insisted on sending them with an escort out of the woods.

Thorin snorted, but didn’t give a reply, and Bilbo followed his gaze to the front of the line where the Guard Captain was. Walking beside her was Kili, and the young dwarf prince was perfectly happy to jabber on in conversation with the red-haired elf.

Rolling his eyes, Bilbo elbowed Thorin in the ribs. “Don’t get your knickers in a bunch. This isn’t so bad.”

“I fail to see anything good about the situation,” Thorin grumbled, moving out of Bilbo’s reach.

“Well, maybe not. But it could certainly be worse.” When the dwarf didn’t say anything, Bilbo tugged on his sleeve and shot a pointed glance towards the river. “At least it’s not barrels.”

To his satisfaction, the corner of Thorin’s mouth twitched slightly. “I seem to remember that the barrels were your idea.”

“True. But personally, I find walking to be much more to my liking.”

“Leave it to you to plan a prison-break involving white water rapids when you cannot swim. When we finally made it to the bank, there were a few minutes where I was sure you had drowned.”

Bilbo made an indignant sound at that, but there was nothing he could say in argument, so he opted for elbowing him in the ribs again. “At least I had a plan. You were going to sit there in the dark forever out of spite. Besides, I had to get you bumbling lot out somehow.”

Finally, Thorin tore his gaze away from the odd pair at the front of the group and looked at him. He gave Bilbo a slight smile. “This is true. I am not sure we ever would have gotten out if not for you.” Thorin paused, then something in his eyes darkened and his smile fell. When he spoke again, his voice was much quieter. “Speaking of which, I have been meaning to ask you how you knew you would not be able to evade the elves this time.”

Bilbo drew in a sharp breath and his chest tightened. On instinct, his hand drifted to his pocket. “Er, well, you see…”

He had yet to come up with a suitable answer to the question, though he had anticipated it would come sooner or later.

Luckily, they were interrupted and he was given the excuse he needed not to answer.

Unluckily, they were being attacked by orcs.

The moment the first orc showed its ugly face, Thorin drew his sword—the dwarven made one he’d been carrying before the trolls—and shoved Bilbo behind him. He cried out in protest, though he had to admit that his little dagger really didn’t give him a very good advantage against the grotesque creatures appearing from every direction. Still, it was better than nothing.

Moreso, it was very good that the elves had returned the dwarves’ weapons because given the numbers of orcs coming out of the trees, their small troop of elvish escorts wouldn’t be enough to fight them all off on their own.

Thorin wasn’t able to shield him for long, and it was hardly a minute before they were surrounded and Bilbo turned so that they could fight back to back. Small as it may be, his dagger was certainly a help.

A particularly nasty looking orc lunged at him and Bilbo ducked, avoiding the jagged blade by mere inches. Missing him threw the orc off balance and Bilbo took his chance. He grabbed the orcs arm and pulled, making it stumble towards him, then sank his dagger hilt deep into its chest. For half a moment, the orc stared at him with hate filled eyes before it let out a gurgling noise and slumped dead to the ground. He pulled the dagger out and swung around just in time to make a deep slice across another orc’s abdomen as it hurtled past and a moment later a swing of Thorin’s sword sent its head flying.

It went on like that for what felt like forever, and Bilbo found himself beginning to slip. He hardly noticed that he and Thorin were steadily drifting apart from one another—it was all he could do to continue dodging attacks and wielding the dagger. He was breathing hard and his arm was beginning to ache terribly, but he kept going. Until he heard a scream that most definitely did not belong to any orc. He faltered and whipped his head around, trying to see who it was. The distraction cost him.

He saw the orc from the corner of his eye. Saw it raise a heavy club in the air, ready to deal a killing blow. For a moment, he was sent back to the Misty Mountains on that damned cliff where he’d gotten beat over the head. He’d escaped with a concussion last time, but he didn’t think he would be so lucky again. He wasn’t fast enough to try and block the blow.

Flinching, Bilbo stumbled back a few steps, fully expecting to feel his skull shatter in on itself.

But something odd happened.

Just as it was about to bring its arm down in a blow that would surely kill him, the orc went sprawling to the ground and slammed face first into a rock. It didn’t get up again.

Wide eyed, Bilbo stared in amazement.

Dwalin, who had appeared from the fray and seemed to have been readying himself to bury his axe into the orc’s back stood frozen for a moment as well, looking just as surprised as Bilbo felt.

But Bilbo wasn’t looking at him.

He was staring at the ground near the unfortunate orc’s feet, where he was nearly certain he had seen a tree root move just enough to trip his would-be killer.

Dwalin recovered much quicker than he himself did and sprang forward to slam his axe into another orc’s gut as it went for Bilbo, and when it doubled over, he split the creature’s head open down the middle for good measure. Bilbo didn’t get the chance to give the dwarf any sort of thanks before he felt himself being swept off his feet.

“Time to go, hobbit!”

He let out a rather undignified yelp as the world spun around him for a moment, then he found himself hanging over Dwalin’s shoulder like a sack of potatoes. He got his breath back after a moment then yelled, “pardon me! Put me down!”

The dwarf didn’t respond. Dwalin was holding onto him with one arm, and with the other he wielded his axe, mowing down orcs left and right as he ran through the fray. All the while, Bilbo was bouncing against his shoulder, and he was sure his ribs would be bruised by the time it was all over.

One advantage of being treated like luggage was that his position gave him a better view point of what was going on, though it was difficult to really focus on anything given how much he was being jolted around. From what he could tell, though, the orcs were beginning to find themselves outnumbered as more and more of them fell or fled. Then they hurtled past a cluster of boulders, and atop them stood two archers, taking advantage of the higher ground.

It was a sight that was almost poetic, worthy of songs and great stories—an elf and a dwarf, fighting as One despite centuries of hostility between their two peoples. Kili and Tauriel fired arrow after arrow, working together to clear the river banks of orcs. When one started to pursue Dwalin, she took it out with an arrow straight through the left eye. At the same time, when an orc set its sights on Legolas, the young dwarven prince didn’t hesitate a second before he brought it down.

There was no room for petty feuds between them. Not in that moment.

For some reason, Bilbo felt a burst of pride at the sight. But the feeling was short lived as he realized where the scream had come from.

Bilbo hadn’t noticed just how far he had been separated from everyone. The majority of the Company, including Thorin, had placed themselves into a protective circle and were fighting off whatever orcs were left. In the middle of them all, Dori laid on the ground motionless, with Oin hovering over him. He couldn’t tell where the injury was, but he could see blood. A lot of blood.

Fear gripped him so tightly that by the time Dwalin finally put him down, he didn’t even try to kick the dwarf in the shins. Rather, he immediately ran towards Thorin and landed a foot on the back of an orc’s knee, causing it to fall. Thorin stuck his sword through the orc's middle then yanked out the blade and shoved the body out of the way. He panted out a thanks to Bilbo, but he ignored it.

“What happened?” he yelled as he and Thorin both spun towards the same orc. Bilbo caught it in the ribs and Thorin its neck.

“I do not know,” he said, jaw clenched tightly. “I did not see.”

Bilbo hazarded a glance back at the white haired dwarf, who he hoped was only unconscious. Then he tripped back a few steps when Thorin grabbed his arm and tugged him out of the way of the swing of an orc’s sword—the blade would have gone straight through his middle. As it was, only the tip of it caught at his jacket.

“Focus, Bilbo!”

He forced himself to look away from his injured friend and nodded, and Thorin let go of him.

Over the next couple of minutes, the orc attack finally started to slow. Whether they were running out of forces or had made the decision to retreat, Bilbo didn’t know. Either way, he was grateful for it. He wasn’t sure how much longer he could keep it up.

Then, from the corner of his eye, he saw one of the few remaining orcs manage to knock Bofur to the ground and placed its foot on his chest to keep him down. It raised its jagged sword, a slash of a smile on its face.

A split second later, an arrow head protruded from its garish mouth. It froze, then its eyes rolled back into its head and it fell dead to the ground, barely missing landing directly on top of Bofur. The dwarf sat up, hat askew and looking a bit pale and looked around for the archer that saved him.

Bilbo did the same, immediately looking to where Tauriel and Kili were a few minutes before, but the two were gone.

Then he spotted movement about a dozen yards down the river and sighed in relief.

It was Bard.

Once it was all over, Bilbo found himself sitting beside Dwalin, watching from afar as Oin tended to Dori. There was a rather deep slice running from his right shoulder and halfway down his chest. At first, the entire Company crowded around their fallen friend, afraid that he was dead. Oin quickly put a stop to that, shouting at them that while Dori was still alive, he might not stay that way for long if they didn’t give him room to work. The only ones allowed to stay were Dori's brothers.

There were dwarves scattered along the riverbank, tending to their wounds, washing dirt and blood from their skin, or just resting. Quickly after Oin shooed them all away, Thorin and Balin went to speak with Bard—presumably to procure safe passage to Lake-town. They were far enough away that Bilbo couldn’t hear their conversation, but the man had a sour look on his face that suggested he wasn’t too happy about whatever the dwarves were saying.

He himself was unharmed, despite a few close calls. Which reminded him…

He shot a glare at Dwalin, who was currently cleaning his axes with a bloodied rag. “What was that for?”

The dwarf just raised a brow and didn’t look at him. “What was what for?”

Bilbo snorted. “You know perfectly well what I’m talking about. I was doing just fine, thank you very much!”

For several moments, the dwarf didn’t respond, then he set his axe down so it was resting across his lap and turned to Bilbo. He studied him for a moment, then nodded.

“Aye, you were doing beautifully. You remembered your lessons well.”

Bilbo blinked, caught off guard by the compliment, but it didn’t deter him from wanting an answer to his question. He gave Dwalin a pointed look and the dwarf rolled his eyes.

“Look, your safety and Thorin’s safety is my top priority. And you were in the middle of it all on your own. I won’t apologize for getting you out.”

“I don’t see you throwing Thorin over your shoulder like a sack of potatoes,” Bilbo grumbled irritably. Dwalin had a point, of course, but he still didn’t appreciate being treated like some damsel in distress.

Dwalin huffed out what may have been a laugh if not for the exhaustion that was in it. “One, trying to carry Thorin like that would be like carrying a boulder. I’d break my back. Two, Thorin would strangle me if I so much as tried. And three,” he paused and looked Bilbo straight in the eye, his voice taking on an odd tone. “If anything happens to you, Bilbo, it will destroy him. I can’t afford to rely on your unusual good luck to ensure that doesn’t happen.”

The dwarf shot a glance over to where the Company’s leader was still dealing with the bargeman—for some reason, Legolas had joined in on their conversation. Odd, but Bilbo didn’t have enough attention to spare to wonder why. For a moment, Bilbo was confused, then he noticed the look in Dwalin’s eye and immediately felt his face get hot.

“I-I’m not sure I quite know what you’re talking about.”

Dwalin didn’t respond. He just gave Bilbo a look that suggested he wasn’t at all convinced, then he stood and walked away—headed towards Ori, it seemed. The young dwarf was sitting several feet away from Dori, with visible tear tracks running down his dirty face. He was staring at the ground blankly, like the world around him didn’t exist. It was his scream that Bilbo heard earlier. Poor Ori saw his brother be cut down by the orc.

He watched Dwalin go, then sniffed and looked away, pointedly making the effort not to look in a certain dwarf king’s general direction. The tips of his ears still felt hot thanks to Dwalin’s unspoken suggestion that Thorin actually had some sort of feelings for their Company’s resident burglar.

It was an absurd idea, really. Thorin was a king—or at least, he would be, if Bilbo had any say in the matter. What possible reason could he have to hold any kind of affection for a simple hobbit? They were close, certainly. Even more so, now that they knew they weren’t alone in their mission to save the Line of Durin, but that didn’t mean there was anything more between them than friendship.

Absurd, indeed.

He decided to ignore whatever part of him that was saying otherwise.

He didn’t have time to entertain his silly infatuation. There were more important things to worry about—like figuring out how they could get rid of Smaug without sacrificing the poor people of Lake-town, and how to ensure that the entire Company stayed alive so Thorin could be crowned King. And after that, well…

Unconsciously, Bilbo let his hand drift to his pocket to touch the little pouch that resided within. Or, he would have, if the pouch was there.

He looked down at the tattered scrap of his coat, remembering the orc that tried to cut him in half earlier.

There was a giant, gaping hole in Bilbo’s pocket.

Panic seized him immediately and he jumped to his feet, searching the ground around him for the little pouch that he’d been carrying since Beorn’s, but he didn’t see it anywhere.

The Ring was gone.

Bilbo whirled around and scanned the river bank, trying to pinpoint where he was standing when the orc cut his jacket. But everything happened so quickly, and it wasn’t as though he was really focused on his location. He had been rather busy avoiding any fatal stab wounds. So he started walking in that general direction, frantically looking at the ground as he went. It didn’t help that the pouch was brown. It would blend in pretty much everywhere!

His chest tightened and his breathing grew quicker as he felt more and more that he wasn’t getting enough air.

This was very, very bad.

The Company would be leaving soon—once they convinced Bard to give them transport and Oin decided they could safely move Dori. But Bilbo couldn’t leave without the Ring. It was too important for the future survival of Middle Earth. If it fell into the wrong hands…

Bilbo knew this would happen. He expected the Ring to try and make its way to another after he made his intention of its destruction perfectly clear. Why hadn’t he done more to ensure that it wouldn’t get away? Surely he could have put it somewhere safer than his jacket pocket.

The full panic had nearly set in when Bilbo’s gaze landed on a particular dwarf, half a dozen yards away from where he stood.

He watched as Kili bent and picked something up from the ground, inspecting it curiously in the palm of his hand. There was no reason for Bilbo to think it was the pouch. No reason but the faraway look in Kili’s eyes. It reminded him of how Thorin looked when he picked the Ring up in the Goblin Tunnels.

Bilbo practically sprinted over to Kili and snatched the pouch from the young dwarf’s hands just as he was about to open it. “Oh, good, you found it! I’ve been looking for it everywhere!”

His voice was a little too high pitched for it to sound convincing, but Kili didn’t seem to notice. He scowled at Bilbo for a short second, then blinked and the expression disappeared, replaced by confusion.

“What is it?” Kili asked, his eyes still fixed on the pouch.

Bilbo slipped the pouch into the pocket of his trousers—he would find a better way to carry it soon—and gave the dwarf a tight smile. “A good luck charm from the Shire. I know it’s a rather silly thing to be carrying around, but it’s comforting to me.”

“Good luck charm.” Kili repeated, his eyes locked on Bilbo’s pocket. His voice sounded distant. “But it feels—”

At that moment, Thorin’s voice echoed over the area, calling for everyone to gather so they could leave.

Bilbo thanked Yavanna for the timing and hurried to rejoin the rest of the Company.