Actions

Work Header

To Fix What Was Broken

Chapter 21: Secrets Yet Unspoken

Summary:

After a few relatively calm days in Laketown, the quiet will soon come to an end when certain truths are finally spoken aloud.

Notes:

Spring semester starts on monday, so I'll be back to classes and work, but I'm hoping I can at least get the next chapter up before then. No promises.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

To say that Thorin was annoyed was an understatement.

True, his and Balin’s negotiations with Bard hadn’t been going very smoothly. Somehow, the man was even more distrustful now than he had been on the first journey—despite the fact that they weren’t even fugitives from the elves this time around. He wasn’t too agreeable to the idea of transporting a group of dwarves who had just been attacked by orcs. What difference it made was beyond Thorin, but the man was adamant that he would not carry them to Lake-town. And true, Bard was being so stubborn, he hadn’t even been sure if they could sway him or not.

But that did not mean he in any way appreciated elves sticking their noses into his business.

After they had been arguing with the man for a good ten minutes, Legolas appeared from wherever he and the rest of his guards had run off to, looking for all the world that he hadn’t just been involved in a fight with orcs—there wasn’t even a strand of hair out of place—and interrupted their conversation. Apparently, the elvish princeling and Bard knew each other to some extent and it only took a short, terse exchange between the two before Bard finally agreed to allow the dwarves onto his barge.

Eventually, Thorin might acknowledge the fact that if Thranduil’s spawn had gone so far as to procure them passage to Lake-town, then the White Gems might be a much more valuable bargaining chip than he originally imagined. But for now, he was rather set on being angry about it.

The fact that they had just sustained their first major injury of the journey did nothing to help his sour mood.

Oin said that Dori would survive, though the dwarf’s wound would take some time to fully heal, and he would be left with a significant scar. Dori, thank Mahal, was awake and present enough to be annoyed with the Company’s fussing, though he didn’t have the strength to stop them when they piled him with every blanket and cloak they could to protect him from the bitter cold of the lake. Presently, he was sitting near the back of the barge with his brothers on either side of him, looking incredibly pale and incredibly grouchy.

Though Thorin was in no way happy that one of his Company was hurt, he was silently grateful that it wasn’t Kili. On the last journey, the younger of his sister-sons had been shot in the leg by an orc arrow during their escape down the river and by the time they made it back to solid land, Thorin was already too caught up in the growing gold-sickness to take the time to allow the wound to be properly tended to. He was so focused on reaching Erebor as soon as possible that he went as far as leaving members of the Company behind in his haste, including Fili and Kili. They joined them in Erebor later, after the death of the dragon, but Thorin never actually bothered to ask how Kili’s leg healed so quickly.

It was just another of his many failings on the quest, and a mistake that he refused to make again, no matter who was injured and what the circumstances were—he would not leave anyone behind.

Thorin stood at the front of the barge, staring into the mists ahead and only half listening as the others went about gathering the funds they needed to pay their unwilling transport for his services. It seemed Gloin was arguing again, though he knew that it wouldn’t last for long.

Soon enough, the fog parted. He didn’t have to turn around to know that the ensuing silence meant that the Company had seen what he was watching for.

The Lonely Mountain stood tall in the distance.

He knew from experience that the others’ silence was caused by reverence, but the sight only made his stomach tighten painfully with a sense of foreboding.

Thorin didn’t even notice Bilbo’s presence until a warm hand took his and he tore his gaze away from the mountain to look down at him. The look on his face was hard to read, so full of conflicting emotions that Thorin wasn’t sure if it was longing, grief, or dread in the hobbit’s eyes—maybe it was all three. He remembered that Bilbo never once returned to Erebor after it was reclaimed.

With a lump in his throat, he held Bilbo’s hand tighter and prayed they would soon have the chance to look upon Erebor with hope for the future rather than fear of the past.

That this time, things would be different.

 

***

 

They had been in Lake-town for three days. Three days of sleeping in actual beds—threadbare and thin as they may be—and of having a roof over their heads, and Thorin was grateful for it. At least, he much preferred this to hiding out in Bard’s house and sneaking around town like fugitives.

Upon reaching Lake-town, they were allowed through the checkpoint without issue—apparently, a letter from King Thranduil of Mirkwood was enough to get them into Lake-town and taken straight to the Master, no smuggling inside barrels of fish required. He resented being grateful for it, but Thorin wasn’t sure they would have been able to pull off sneaking in given the shape that Dori was in. When Legolas had even given the letter to Bard, he had no idea. He hadn’t seen it during their “negotiations” and he certainly had no idea what was written in it.

As it turned out, the sight of thirteen dwarves and a hobbit trooping through town led by four of the Master’s guards and his deputy—that greasy little weasel of a man—was a strange enough occurrence that by the time they made it to the town hall, crowds were already gathered to see what was going on.

That served Thorin’s purpose well enough, seeing as the Master was more likely to be generous if he had a crowd to cheer him on.

His assumption was correct.

The speech he gave about sharing in the wealth of Erebor did its job in getting the people excited about the Company’s presence. Paired with the elf’s letter, no one even bothered questioning his identity or his honor. Even without it, he still silently vowed to himself that this time, he would fulfill his oath. The people of Lake-town deserved better lives just as much as his own people did—they had all suffered great losses thanks to the dragon—and he intended to do everything he could to ensure that they would all thrive once again.

All in all, their negotiations with the Master went over well, though the man wasn't too thrilled when Thorin declined the offer of a feast in his honor and asked instead to be provided shelter for a week as they made their preparations to move on to the mountain. Despite his dismay, the Master was unable to refuse the request with the entire town as his audience, so he set the Company up in a two-story house near the edge of town. The house was furnished, yet apparently unoccupied, and Thorin had the distinct impression that whoever lived there previously had been evicted—though there was enough dust about that he assumed the house had been standing empty for some time.

The thought made him feel guilty, especially considering how many people were left homeless and living outside, unprotected from the harsh weather. His only comfort was that with the dragon gone and Erebor reinhabited by the dwarves, this town would soon be rebuilt and made prosperous once again.

Still, he was glad that for this last leg of their journey before facing the dragon, the Company would have the chance to get some proper rest—there was no question they needed it.

Thorin, however, was struggling to take advantage of the rare instance of down-time they had been given. He was just as tired as everyone else, but there was far too much on his mind for him to get any kind of peace. There they were on the brink of finishing their journey—after facing trolls, and elves, and orcs, and spiders, and a myriad of other nasty things—yet the true danger of the quest hadn’t even begun. No, they had merely just begun to toe at the edge of a cliff so steep that if they fell, there would be no climbing back up again.

He wondered how long it would take for the ledge to crumble beneath their boots and send them plummeting. Somehow, the fall had been less terrifying the first time, before he knew what they would face as soon as they reached the bottom. They would have to hit the ground running if they wanted any chance of survival.

The mere thought of it was exhausting.

Wandering through the house on his way to the kitchen, Thorin was confused at how quiet it was until he remembered that a large chunk of the Company planned on going out into town that afternoon. They invited him to go along, but the thought of pushing his way through a marketplace crowded full of men and stinking of dead fish was anything but appealing, so he declined. Plus, with the house mostly empty, it would give him a good opportunity to speak with a certain hobbit alone and without interruption.

If Thorin had been restless over the past few days, then Bilbo was full of pure nervous energy. The hobbit seemed to be incapable of staying still for more than a few minutes at a time. Sure enough, when he peeked into the kitchen, it was to see Bilbo standing in the middle of the room, bouncing on his toes and staring at a large pot hanging over the fireplace.

Thorin watched him for a second or two, then took a few steps into the room. “Bilbo, do you have a moment to—”

The moment he spoke, Bilbo jumped slightly, as if he hadn’t noticed him come in, then interrupted him before he could finish.

“Oh, Thorin! I’m glad you’re here!” The hobbit scooped a large mug off the counter and shoved it into Thorin’s hands. “Could you do me a favor and take this up to Dori?”

He blinked down at the steaming mug, then looked back to Bilbo. “Actually, I was hoping to—”

“I came down here to get it for him, but then Bombur had to run to the market and asked me to keep an eye on his pot so it doesn’t boil over. By the time I get the chance to bring it up, the tea will be cold.” As he spoke, Bilbo turned back to the pot and stirred it a few times.

“But—”

“It will only take a minute.”

Giving up, Thorin stifled a heavy sigh and nodded. He had been meaning to check in on their injured friend at some point, anyways, and he had a sneaking suspicion that Bilbo was a bit too distracted to have a conversation. “Is there anything else he needed?”

“No, that’s it. Thank you.”

Thorin hesitated at the threshold of the room and glanced back over his shoulder. “Bilbo?”

“Hm?”

“I would like to speak with you, when you have the time.”

“Sure, alright.”

The response was less than reassuring, and he wasn’t even sure Bilbo actually heard him, but Thorin let it go and headed for the stairs. He had waited this long to talk to Bilbo about what was on his mind. What difference could a little more time make?

At the top on the stairs, Thorin turned left into the hallway and stopped at the second door on the right. It was cracked open, but he tapped on the door anyway and waited for an invitation to go inside. The room was small, barely big enough to have two beds pushed against either wall and still have walking space in between.

Dori was in the bed on the left, beneath the one tiny window, with several layers of blankets piled on top of him. As soon as Thorin entered, the dwarf opened his eyes and blinked at him several times before noticing what he carried.

“I brought you some tea.”

Immediately, he began struggling to sit up and Thorin hurried forward, setting the mug down on the bedside table so he could help. Once Dori was propped up against his pillow, Thorin handed him the tea then sat on the edge of the other bed.

Grumbling his thanks, Dori took a sip of his drink then relaxed a little, slumping back against the pillow with a groan.

“How are you feeling?”

“Stiff and sore, but better than I was.” His voice was a little hoarse when he spoke.

“I am glad to hear it.”

The two dwarves fell quiet while Dori drank his tea, and Thorin took the moment to study him closely. He hadn’t yet gotten the chance to speak with Dori since the fight at the river—mainly due to Oin’s insistence that nobody was allowed in the room except for himself and the two younger Ri brothers—and he was glad to see that the rest was doing him some good. Dori was still a little paler than usual, but his eyes were as sharp and focused as always and his hands didn’t shake as he held the mug to drink. His hair had been re-braided at some point, though the braids which were normally immaculate looked slightly sloppy. Ori had likely been the one to fix his brother’s hair, Thorin supposed, seeing as Dori’s shoulder was in no shape to be put under any kind of strain. The young scribe had been practically glued to Dori’s bedside—much to Oin’s ire, no doubt—and hardly left him over the past few days other than to fetch food and water. Thorin was honestly a little surprised that the others managed to coax Ori out of the room, let alone out of the house entirely.

Thorin continued his musing until Dori finished the tea, and he took the empty mug and set it aside.

After a few moments of thought, he asked, “will you be healed enough to make the trip to Erebor come the end of this week?”

Dori tensed up immediately and there was a defensive tone in his voice when he responded. “I’m fine! Don’t you dare get any ideas about leaving me here.”

“Relax. I have no intention of leaving you behind, my friend.” He shook his head to rid himself of the image of Kili’s betrayed eyes looking up at him, then smiled and leaned forward to brace his arms on his knees. “I simply want to be sure you feel confident you can make it. We will have to keep a fast pace if we want to reach the mountain by Durin’s Day, and there will be the dragon to deal with after that. It is your choice, and I will respect whatever decision you make. As will the rest of the Company. No one will think any less of you for needing more time to heal.”

“I can do it.” Dori’s face was determined, leaving no room for argument.

Thorin nodded. The last time he’d done this, he was so focused on getting his hands on the Arkenstone, he forgot that everyone else had a personal stake in the quest as well. They all joined him on this journey for a reason, and he disregarded all of that the moment he saw the Lonely Mountain looming over the Long Lake.

Not this time.

He would gladly keep them all by his side as long as they wanted to stay.

Dragging himself out of his thoughts, he sat a little straighter. “I want you to focus on getting as much rest as you can in the meantime, then. And do whatever Oin tells you to.”

Dori grimaced and looked ready to protest, but Thorin held up a hand to stop him. “I know, but the more you listen to him now, the less time we will have to spend convincing him you are well enough to continue the journey when it comes time to leave.”

He had been at the old healer’s mercy enough times by now, he understood Dori’s dismay. Oin was positively ruthless when it came to bedrest and he wasn’t one to negotiate. Tough love was likely the most accurate way to describe it—but more often than not, it was just tough.

Still a little sour-faced, Dori looked ready to argue, but before he could say anything, the door swung open. Ori walked into the room, holding a large skein of grey-green yarn in his arms.

“Dori! Look what—” the young dwarf paused as soon as he noticed Thorin and his face went a little red. “Oh. Sorry, I didn’t mean to interrupt.”

“No need to apologize, I was just leaving.” Thorin shook his head and stood, then shot a glance at Dori. “Let us know if there are any supplies you need to get before we leave and we will try to find it for you.”

As Thorin stepped past Ori on his way to the door, he patted his shoulder and paused for a short moment. Smiling slightly, he nodded toward Dori. “Keep an eye on your brother and make sure he is listening to Oin, hm?”

Ori grinned at him and Thorin left the room, followed by Dori’s protests that he didn’t need anyone to keep an eye on him.

Thorin made it to the stairs the moment Dwalin reached the top step. All it took was one look at the smug smile on his best friend’s face for him to change direction and walk with him down the hall.

Keeping his voice casual, he asked, “and how many coins did you spend on that?”

“Does it matter?” Dwalin responded, then rolled his eyes when Thorin shot him a pointed look. “I couldn’t help it. He said it matched my eyes then got all sad when Nori said it was time to go. Besides, the woman at the stall gave me a discount.”

“I cannot imagine why. Certainly not for your good looks and charm,” Thorin said with a snort, jabbing his elbow into his ribs.

Dwalin shoved him back just hard enough to make him stumble before replying. “Ori spent a good ten minutes talking knitting patterns and complimenting her craft. Went straight over my head, but it buttered her up.”

“Softie.”

They stopped walking and stared at each other for a moment, then Dwalin said, “maybe I am, but you’ve got no room to talk. You take one look at the hobbit and get all doe-eyed. You don’t even try to hide it anymore.”

Thorin blinked. Then, before he could get another word in, Dwalin shot him a small smirk and walked into his room.

Scowling, Thorin continued to the next door and slipped through it, shutting it firmly behind him.

 

***

 

About an hour later, Thorin was in his room, peering out the little window that gave him an underwhelming view of a small alleyway below that was entirely deserted save for some barrels and litter strewn about the ground. If he pressed close to the glass and craned his head a little, though, it was possible to get a slight glimpse of the mountain standing in the distance. And that was exactly what he was doing—his breath fogging up the window pane and obscuring what little view he had of Erebor—when there was a quiet and unmistakable knock on his door.

He sighed and wiped the glass before turning his back on the window.

“Come in!”

Bilbo slipped into the room, his bare feet hardly making a sound against the hardwood floor.

Not for the first time, Thorin found himself wondering how the hobbit could stand walking around in such cold temperatures without boots to keep his feet warm—and he may have asked if it wasn’t for the anxious look on his friend’s face. Immediately, he felt a spike of worry and stood a little straighter.

“What is it? Are you alright?”

“Yes.” Bilbo stopped then shook his head. “Well, no. But yes. Can we talk?”

Thorin studied him for a moment, then crossed the room to stoke the fire, motioning to one of the two chairs in front of it. “Of course. Come sit down.”

The hobbit hesitated by the door for a moment before he moved closer and sat on the edge of the seat, looking entirely uncomfortable. If anything, he was acting rather restless, like whatever was on his mind was making it impossible for him to sit still. It wasn’t much different from his behavior over the past few days, actually. Since their arrival there in Lake-town, Bilbo had been acting odd. Distracted. Jumpy, even. Though, whatever it was that was on his mind, Thorin hadn’t the chance to find out. Bilbo hardly stayed still long enough for him to get more than a few words in before making some excuse and scurrying away.

Now, though...

Once the flames were burning higher again, Thorin sat in the chair facing Bilbo and asked again. “What is wrong?”

Bilbo made a funny little noise in the back of his throat that was half nervous laugh and half whine. Then he launched into speaking so fast that Thorin could hardly keep up. “See, I’m not entirely sure where to start. There’s just so much and up to this point I haven’t told you because I know how stressed you are already with the dragon and the battle and all that and I really don’t want to make things harder on you. But I’m also worried that this could have an impact on our success in the coming weeks and I can’t keep it to myself anymore. Not to mention the fact that if something happens to me—”

Not liking where his rambling was going, Thorin interrupted. “Bilbo.”

“Right, sorry. Where to start… Er… I suppose the Misty Mountains, since that’s where you first enter the picture in relation to this particular issue.”

“Issue? What—”

“Do you remember when we fell off that cliff?” Bilbo asked suddenly.

Bemused, Thorin nodded. “I do not think I could easily forget it.”

“And you remember how I made us go into the Goblin Tunnels even though you really didn’t want to?”

“Yes. If I remember correctly, you challenged me with the fact that a hobbit would go underground even as a dwarf refused.”

“Right. And do you remember—” Bilbo paused again and his face twisted into a grimace. “Do you remember that Ring you picked up from the ground? The one that I took?”

At that, Thorin couldn’t help but wince. That particular moment of their escapade through the Misty Mountains was one he remembered a little too well. He could never quite forget the fear in Bilbo’s eyes as he snatched the golden trinket from his hand and hid it away. Nor could he forget the split second vision of himself standing in the treasury of Erebor, half-mad and surrounded by a sea of wealth. “If this is about the sickness, I—”

“Sickness?” Bilbo’s brows furrowed in confusion for a moment, then there was a spark of understanding and he was shaking his head quickly. “No! That’s not what this is at all, Thorin. It’s...it’s about the Ring in particular.” Bilbo bit his lip, then plowed on. “I’m going to start talking about a lot of really random things all at once and I know it’s not going to make any sense, but I promise I have a point.”

Confused, Thorin just nodded and sat back. “Take your time, Bilbo, I am listening.”

“Right. Alright. Okay.”

The hobbit fell quiet for several long moments where he seemed to be trying to relax. Thorin found Bilbo’s difficulty speaking to be more concerning than anything he’d actually said so far. His friend had always seemed to be gifted with a silver tongue, able to say the right things at the right times to make a situation turn in his favor. The only times Thorin ever noticed that to not be true was when Bilbo was either caught off guard or incredibly nervous. And given that he was capable of keeping his head in the face of things as dangerous as trolls and dragons, whatever was bothering him at that moment had to be huge. Thorin forced himself to be patient and wait, despite his ever growing concern and curiosity.

Eventually, Bilbo drew in a deep breath and nodded once, as if coming to some kind of resolve. Then he spoke.

“Back in the Goblin Tunnels, the creature we met, Gollum, accused me of stealing from him. Which I did, sort of, though the thing I took doesn’t actually belong to him seeing as he originally stole it himself. But that’s beside the point. The point is that on the first journey, the Ring is largely the reason I was so successful as the Company’s burglar. It’s what allowed me to stay hidden in Thranduil’s dungeons and avoid capture, and how I survived Smaug, and how I managed to make it to Ravenhill during the battle.”

“How?”

Bilbo winced slightly, but answered the question nevertheless. “It’s magic. Anyone who puts on the Ring is rendered invisible.”

Thorin blinked. He had no idea where he thought this conversation had been going, but this was not it. Worry over how to kill the dragon, or how they would go about surviving the battle looming on the horizon, or how they would face winter inside the mountain with minimal supplies—those were all things he could reasonably see them talking about. Magical rings, however, were not a part of that list.

Of course, by now, he should have been used to dealing with unexpected twists in their story. It seemed to become a theme over the past several months.

So he let himself process for a few moments, reign in the whirlwind of questions that was flying through his head, then slowly asked, “so...if the Ring is what allowed you to stay free of the elves before, why did that change this time? Is it...not working?”

“Oh, no, it’s working just fine. At least, I assume it is. I haven’t put it on to test it, you see.”

“Why not?”

Bilbo let out another nervous laugh and was immediately on his feet, pacing back and forth in front of the fire and wringing his hands anxiously. “Because it…it caused so much pain and suffering. And you must understand, I had no idea what it was. No idea. Not until I was old. And by then, it was too late—”

He was babbling again. Thorin wouldn’t have interrupted if it weren’t for the actual words that Bilbo was saying. He did not like where they were going.

“I do not understand what you are talking about.”

“I know, I’m sorry. This is such a difficult subject for me. I’m afraid that the damned thing still has a hold of me, even now. I can hardly bear to look at it, much less speak of it.”

For nearly a minute, Bilbo continued his pacing in silence, and his constant movement was getting to the point where Thorin felt that he himself was beginning to become restless. But he forced himself to wait—to stay still and give the hobbit as much time as he needed to work out whatever it was that he was building up to. Even if the dread that was slowly rising in him like the tide was beginning to feel a little suffocating.

After what felt like forever, Bilbo came to a stop almost abruptly and stood in front of the fire with his back to Thorin. His voice was much quieter than it had been before.

“Back in Beorn’s garden, when I was telling you of my life after the quest, I can honestly say that I told you the truth. But I didn’t tell you all of it.”

Letting out a slow breath, Thorin reached out and caught hold of Bilbo’s hand, which was clenching and unclenching at his side. Gently, he pulled Bilbo closer until he was facing him, then grabbed his other hand so they were both cradled in his own. He hated how distressed he was. Looking up into Bilbo’s nervous eyes, he spoke softly.

“Bilbo. Bâheluh. Please, just tell me. Whatever it is, we will deal with it together.”

To his surprise, the hobbit immediately burst into tears.

 

***

 

Thorin stared at Bilbo. Stared and stared and felt as though he had gone deaf, other than a high pitched ringing in his ears. It seemed so impossible. Impossible, yet so painfully in line with all the other insane things that were happening lately.

The One Ring.

And Bilbo carried it for sixty years. He was carrying it now, in his pocket.

Somehow, it seemed only right. He came back to save the line of Durin and retake Erebor—he should have known that wouldn’t be the end of it. Three dwarves alone were not important enough for the Valar to alter the very passage of time. Of course there was more. Of course.

He may have laughed at the pure ridiculousness of it all if Bilbo didn’t look like he was going to be sick. Because the implications of what having that Ring meant… He knew Bilbo too well to so much as think for a second that he would leave it for Frodo to destroy again. He could see it in the fear and determination in the hobbit’s eyes—knew that Bilbo had already come to the same conclusion.

Letting out a long, shaking breath, Thorin stood up and pulled Bilbo into his arms. The hobbit relaxed against him almost immediately and hugged him back. He was trembling.

“We will figure it out. I promise.” Thorin whispered, and it was reassurance for himself as much as it was for Bilbo. “I promise.”

They sat in silence for nearly an hour, and at some point moved to the bed—it was no more comfortable than the chairs, but at least they could sit beside each other there.

After such a monumental confession from Bilbo, anything else they could speak of seemed inconsequential. But Thorin had been formulating an idea in the back of his mind for the past few days, ever since seeing Erebor through the fog as they crossed the Long Lake, and now he was more sure than ever of what needed to be done.

It felt wrong to break the quiet, but he couldn’t wait any longer. “Bilbo.”

“Hm?” The hobbit had his head leaned back against the wall with his eyes closed. He looked as exhausted as Thorin felt.

“I would like your opinion on something.”

“Alright.”

He hesitated, then decided there was no point in beating around the bush. “I think we should tell the others what we know.”

That got Bilbo’s attention.

The hobbit sat up straight and looked at Thorin closely. When he responded, he spoke slowly and carefully. “What, exactly, do you want to tell them?”

“Nothing about the Ring. Not yet. But,” Thorin pursed his lips and thought for a moment, searching for the right words. “I do not feel comfortable moving forward without telling them of the danger we will face. The dragon they are aware of, but the battle...it is not something they came here expecting to do. It does not feel right to let them face what is coming entirely unprepared when we have the opportunity to warn them. To give them a choice.”

For several long moments, Bilbo said nothing. He just stared at Thorin with an entirely unreadable look on his face. Then he nodded and let out a shaky breath. “I think you’re right.”

“And...I would like to tell them tonight.”

That, at least, seemed to catch Bilbo by surprise.

“Tonight?”

“Yes. It would mean we have the next few days for everyone to come up with a plan to take out Smaug together. Their input could be invaluable, and we will need as much help as we can get.”

“Well…” Bilbo almost looked like he was going to be ill, but he cracked a small smile anyways. “There’s no time like the present, I suppose.”

 

***

 

Thorin had made up his mind that telling the Company the truth was the right thing to do, and his resolve had not changed in that decision. But sitting there before his friends and family, he found himself at a loss for words. He now understood why it was so difficult for Bilbo to tell him about the Ring earlier that evening—he didn’t even know where to start. It was such a big confession to make.

It was too late to change his mind, though, even if he wanted to. After his conversation with Bilbo nearly an hour before, he caught Balin in the hall on his way downstairs and asked him to spread the word that he was calling a meeting and they were all to gather in the dining room as soon as supper was done. It took a while for everyone to get there, but now they were all accounted for.

From the head of the table, Thorin could practically feel the growing impatience around him at his prolonged silence. Pursing his lips, he shot a glance at Bilbo. The hobbit gave him a sympathetic look, but didn’t make any effort to get the conversation started. They had already agreed it would be best for Thorin to be the one to begin—not because the Company would be more likely to doubt Bilbo’s word, but because it was Thorin who recruited them for this quest and Thorin who led them across Middle Earth to get where they were now. It seemed only right that he be the one to tell them the truth of things.

But how to start?

There was just so much to be said and the majority of it would likely sound mad. And, if he was being honest with himself, it was an intimidating thought to finally share a secret he’d been keeping for so long.

Still, if Bilbo could do it, he could as well.

Before he could change his mind, Thorin finally managed to speak, keeping his gaze fixed on a spot in the middle of the table.

“We—Bilbo and I—have something we must tell—”

He didn’t even have the chance to finish before a certain young dwarf piped in cheerfully. “You’re finally courting!”

Immediately, several people started murmuring all at once as they passed coins around between themselves. Thorin opened his mouth to tell them off, but two others beat him to it.

“What?” Bilbo’s voice was a little higher than usual and it cracked oddly.

At the same time, Fili cuffed his brother over the back of his head. “No they’re not, boulder-brain. No bead.”

Everyone’s attention turned to Bilbo, as if to confirm that he did not, in fact, have a bead in his hair. With no small amount of grumbling, the coins were passed back around again. Thorin glared at them all, waiting until they quieted again before speaking.

“May I go on, or would you all rather continue settling your silly wagers?” After several seconds of silence, he shot a glance over at Bilbo. The hobbit's eyes were locked resolutely on his hands, seeming to make every effort not to meet Thorin’s gaze. His cheeks and the tips of his ears were slightly red. Stifling a heavy sigh, he turned his attention back to the Company. “I feel I must ask your forgiveness. There are things that I have neglected to tell you about this quest and, in some ways, I have lied to you.”

All at once, the energy in the room shifted into something more serious and Thorin stood slowly, leaning forward to brace his hands on the table. He wanted nothing more than to avoid looking at the friends and family around him directly, but he forced himself to meet each of their gazes one by one as he continued.

“I cannot keep the truth from you any longer. If we are to have any hope of reclaiming our home and keeping it, you must know what I know. More importantly, you must know because for me to lead you any further than this without warning of what we will face would be inexcusable. You have a right to know, and a right to decide for yourselves if you wish to continue onward.”

Thorin’s eyes met Fili’s and he paused for a short moment. The golden-haired dwarf’s expression was confused and his shoulders were tense.

“What are you talking about, Uncle?”

The memory of seeing the light fade from those clever green eyes and watching as his sister-son’s broken body fell from the top of the tower on Ravenhill made Thorin’s heart clench and he swallowed thickly. He held Fili’s gaze as he spoke. “After we reclaim Erebor, an army of orcs led by the Defiler will march on the mountain and attempt to take it from us. The battle will be bloody, and if we are not careful, we may not all make it out alive.”

“You can’t possibly know that, lad.” Balin’s voice was tight and Thorin tore his focus away from his sister-son to see that his old friend’s face was pale.

“One year ago, I set out from the Shire with twelve dwarves, a hobbit, and a wizard to reclaim a lost mountain from a dragon. Five months ago, I faced Azog in battle atop Ravenhill and killed him, but lost my own life in turn.” From the corner of his eye, Thorin thought he saw Bilbo flinch, but he faltered for only a moment before pressing on. “After my death, I awoke in the Halls and met the Maker. I was given a choice—join my lost loved ones in Waiting, or return to Middle Earth at the start of this quest to fix my mistakes and ensure that the Line of Durin would not fall. So I returned. In April, I awoke at the inn in Bree with a letter from Gandalf telling me how to get to the home of our prospective burglar in the Shire.”

Pausing to take a breath, Thorin glanced around the table at his Company. They were all staring at him with varying degrees of shock and disbelief. He could not blame them for it. He would likely feel the same about the story he had just told, if not for the fact that he was the one living it.

Thorin lowered his tone and spoke quietly, willing his voice to stay steady. “I know how impossible this all sounds. Believe me, I do. But it is the truth.”

They all remained deathly still for nearly a full minute and Thorin matched the stares of the dwarves, standing tall and unyielding before them. In the corner of his vision, he could see Bilbo clenching his handkerchief so tightly in his hands that his knuckles were turning white. It felt as if the universe itself was holding its breath, waiting to see what would happen next.

Then, all at once, the spell of silence hanging over them seemed to lift.

And the room erupted.

Notes:

Bâheluh - friend of all friends

 

Once again, the khuzdul came from The Dwarrow Scholar