Actions

Work Header

thunder and the riversong

Chapter 4: shrike

Notes:

thank you once again moonyism for helping me edit this chapter (which is the longest so far!)

title comes from the song "shrike" by hozier and is the most bilbo song in all the world ever

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Every step became harder once they reached the mountain range. Bilbo had not expected it. 

They were well on their way to the High Pass, the broad shoulders of the mountains looming ever nearer, their crests tipped with snow that dripped downward on all sides and made the air chill even in the middle of June. 

But the lightness in his chest and his mind had slowly dwindled since they’d left Rivendell, and now it was all but gone as they came closer and closer to the cliff-drops and tunnels, and to the eerie underground lake in the cavern that had haunted Bilbo’s dreams for so many years.

Bilbo knew he was becoming jumpy, and that it was starting to worry some of his companions as they walked on. He would startle at small noises in the mountains and along the rock, and his blossoming habit of turning to check behind them for danger was becoming irksome to everybody, especially those who had walked this track before. He could not seem to keep up his usual cheer any longer, and he began to talk less and less, all the while treading crookedly on to perils he could see no escape from and had to bear anyway.

It was a hard thing, that he and his dwarves had to beat and suffer through so much danger before they could finally close their eyes and rest their heads. There were stone giants to flee from and goblins to skirt around and great evils to steal from under the nose of creatures that crept in the dark.

Perhaps it was his penance for what he had done to Frodo.

Bilbo had tried with all his might to keep pushing the thought from his mind, to wait until they were out of danger, until he could have a moment’s rest, but the walls of the river had burst, and it was all he could do to keep them at bay.

It was like an ache in his side, the awareness of what he had truly put Frodo through in the finding of the Ring. It had not left his mind since they departed from Rivendell; since they’d set out from Bag End, even. It tore at every step he took along the ragged mountainside, and often he would be left quietly gasping back sobs, thinking of his little boy in Bag End with his wide eyes and mop of tangled hair, and thinking of how it was entirely because of him Frodo had had to learn words like fear and starvation and pain. 

And then Fili or Kili would spot him at the back of the line, and playfully call out, “Allergies again, Master Baggins?” And Bilbo would have to crush down his guilt and wipe his nose and smile, and silently carry the ache again, until the next time he looked up to the mountain peaks and pictured instead a ring of scalding fire at the top.

(If he had just left it alone. If he had just kept his hands to himself. If. If. If.)

It hadn’t mattered what he’d said to Elrond, in the small room in Rivendell. He could not push his guilt aside when it hung so heavily like a black cloud over the mountains. He had become so accustomed to missing all of his loved ones since before he was even grown that he did not know how to set it aside as though it were simply a book he could pick up again later.

What on Earth would Elrond know, anyhow? Bilbo prided himself on knowing quite a bit about Elves for someone who wasn’t one himself, and he knew enough to understand that Elven emotions did not brush the heartstrings in quite the same way as they did the emotions of mortals. That was the way Elvish legend told that the Second Children had been shaped in the Music. Their lives were shorter, and all the more potent for it; they laughed louder and mourned more. Their hearts broke more messily in two. They felt their losses sharply, and were taken from the world because of it where the First Children were not. 

So it was far too rich for Elrond to stroll around in his Homely House and tell Bilbo that he should simply stop mourning.

(Bilbo wasn’t being fair. He’d heard whispers of the things Elrond Halfelven had given up over the course of his limitless life. He knew the toll it could take when immortal beings lost a mortal love and had to go on without them. Mourning was all the same wherever you went and whoever you were, he guessed, and it was just as unbearable on all sides. 

But he’d let himself be unfair and cross for a little while longer.)

They crept higher. Bilbo spoke little, listening to the whistling wind and looking only at his feet moving underneath him. They had to stop and camp in sharp clefts huddled against the rock, and the days were bleak and shrouded in fog so high up. Soon, even the sunniest of their bunch were finding it hard to carry on with the same cheerfulness.

(It was true that the Company of Thorin Oakenshield should have given themselves some leniency in the whole situation. The High Pass through the Misty Mountains was one of the few paths that remained from ancient days, and hardly anyone still attempted it at all, much less with such vigour as they had. But Bilbo was not quite up to thinking of this in his sorry state, so think of it he did not.)

On the third evening, after they’d stopped trekking for the day and he’d settled himself just far enough from the camp that he could be alone with his thoughts but still keep an eye on all of them, Bilbo decided that for once, the wind would have to listen to his whispers instead.

“I often wonder if you are there yet, Frodo, wherever there may be,” he said softly into the night air. “I’m sure it’s been an awfully long journey, out there on the ship among the Sea. I hope you pestered Gandalf as much as you were able.”

He looked down, at the black nothing far below, the ground a haze of silvermist from how high in the mountain ranges they were. 

“I hope you will think of me kindly, and won’t be too upset that I left you so soon. But don’t - don’t think of me too often, my dear boy. I don’t want you to be sad.” 

Bilbo did not know if he talked to Frodo because he thought that somehow Frodo would hear him, or would know somewhere in his heart, or because he simply had a lot to say, and there was no one else to listen. Not even Gandalf, who’d known Frodo better than almost anyone in Middle-Earth and who had seen him through all the adventures Bilbo had not been there for. Gandalf the Grey of this time was not Gandalf the Grey of the last years of the Third Age, and he was not yet Gandalf the White, formidable in his grace and valour.

The wind blew then through all of Bilbo’s clothes and hair and then onward to the West, and he wondered if it was carrying all of his thoughts with it. 

(If only he had gotten to say goodbye in a proper state of mind. The thought was almost insurmountable.)

“Perhaps it is better that you forget me," he whispered, "and when we see each other a long time from now, you can remember me all over again.” His voice cracked, and he bent his head. “I am so sorry, Frodo, my lad.”

“Who do you talk to?” a gruff voice said behind him.

It was so sudden that Bilbo startled quite badly and almost slipped off the face of the rock, but caught himself in time. He turned his head to see Thorin leaning against the cliff-face behind them with his arms folded, watching Bilbo with an unreadable expression. A few of the other dwarves scattered nearby had looked up at the noise, and Balin’s eyes were resting on him with what looked strangely like pity. 

“Nobody,” Bilbo said, and was not quite able to keep his weakened voice steady. “Just myself.”

Looking up at Thorin after being so lost in guilt over Frodo made Bilbo feel as though he was untethered to the earth, floating in the mists that covered every inch of the rock they stood on. It had not been his brightest idea.

“You must focus, Master Baggins,” Thorin said. “This is the High Pass. It is no gentle Shire-track.”

There was nothing accusing in his voice, nothing cruel or unkind, but nor was there anything much to be found of comfort. There wasn’t anything at all. There was only his unmoving eyes lingering on Bilbo.

Bilbo realised with blunt embarrassment that Thorin had been watching him for much longer than he’d been aware of.

“Yes, well, I will be much better for it when we are over this pass and out of these mountains,” he got out, clambering up and wiping his damp hands on his trousers.

“There is no danger up here,” Thorin said, eyes trained heavily on Bilbo’s squinting ones. “Someone will be sure to catch you if you fall.”

It was strange, the slow indifference he spoke with and how it clashed with the intensity of those eyes. He seemed almost impatient, like he was trying to shake Bilbo out of whatever stupor he’d fallen into so they could keep on going, but for all his outward roughness he still did not poke or pry. Once or twice his line of sight fell to the ground beneath Bilbo’s feet as he hauled himself back up the rock, and Bilbo realised with a bright twinge of embarrassment that he was watching to ensure Bilbo was not going to slip.

“Get some sleep,” Thorin ground out, gaze on Bilbo for a moment longer before he turned to look around at the other dwarves. “We’re leaving here at first light.”

That night Bilbo watched Thorin lay with his back against the stone floor, face angled up at the moon. His eyes were wide open for hours; he seemed barely to want to close them. The vastness of the night sky was like a smother over them all, and to be so high up in the ridges felt as though they were merely pinpricks amongst endless blackness.

Bilbo woke sometime on the cusp of dawn, earlier than he’d meant to, and looked over once more to see Thorin in the same still position, though his eyes were closed now in sleep, and his nose struck his face like a knife-edge. A ghosting unease fell over Bilbo at the sight and he rolled over, pulling his blanket up around his shoulders and staring wide-eyed out at the far-off grey hills.

The stillness reminded him far too much of the funerals.

Bilbo had been watching, since they’d left Rivendell, spending long hours at night looking through the firelight at Thorin Oakenshield. He moved always with his head bent, almost like he was bowing to forefathers long passed, or praying to them. He seemed a wanderer never at rest, and was every bit the hardened king Bilbo had always remembered.

Thorin seemed to not ever look at Bilbo if he could help it, and Bilbo had started to wonder if maybe it was deliberate, if the memory of shamefully unwanted fingers on his face in the dead of night caused him discomfort. Maybe Bilbo’s fretful, forlorn nature was grating at him. Maybe he thought Bilbo a weight holding them down in the mountains, or a nuisance to be babysat. Maybe he would try to send him home yet.

Bilbo would not ever let him.


It was the next night that the storm came. The rock was slick and wet, and the rain lashed at their faces, and the collision of the rock-giants was like nothing any of them had ever heard. It was as if they'd crashed head-on into a hurricane and it was doing its best to batter them off the side of the mountain, down into the depths below.

There was a suddenly-located open crevice in the rock-face, and a cheer, and then they were clambering, all of them, into a cave that was dry and sandy on the bottom but safe from the rain and the almighty thunder. Fili and Kili were already at the back, scouting, and Gloin had collapsed down onto the floor in complete exhaustion.

A deadly prickle crept across the back of Bilbo’s neck. This cave was familiar.

His heart skipped in his chest.

“We cannot stop here.”

A few of them turned back to face him standing still out in the cold, blinking in the downpour. Some of them had already started unravelling their bedrolls inside. Bilbo charged forward, wiping the rain from his eyes. 

“We have to keep going, find shelter further down the path. It isn’t safe here.”

Heavy footfalls made their way slowly out from the cave until Thorin was standing at the entrance once more, his sopping hair thrown back and one foot propped up on the outcrop beside him. There must have been gallons of water weighing down his coat, and he looked worn down, Bilbo noticed, with a lopsided sort of jolt.

Thorin's voice was dark. “You do not think we should stop for shelter when we have not been able to find any before now?”

Bilbo scowled, water getting into his eyes and ears and sticking his eyelashes together until they were thick and glassy. Hail was starting to come down all around them, and the clashing echo of the boulders in the near distance rang in their ears as if they were the very source of all the thunder and lightning.

“There are things that live in these mountains, and we are right at the centre of them if we stop," Bilbo pressed. "We have to make more headway along the pass.” All of his waterlogged clothes squelched as he moved, and he felt himself beginning to shiver terribly.

Thorin’s face was closing off the more he spoke, his eyes narrowing and his fingers beginning to harden into fists against the edge of the cave mouth.

“We are half-drowned and hungry, Master Baggins. We need rest and warmth. We cannot push on because you are scared of what sort of creatures might be hiding in the shadows.”

Bilbo grit his teeth stubbornly and pushed on, not budging one inch. “Gandalf is not with us, so we are without protection, and you are not invincible, Thorin.”

Far over their heads, rocks boomed and broke, shaking the mountain. They were going to be killed if they did not move. It was only a matter of whether it would happen one way or the other.

Thorin snarled. “I am the leader of this Company -”

“And I am telling you, we are not safe here!”

Thorin’s eyes rested on him for a very long while, and there was real animosity and warning there, now, and still Bilbo stood his ground.

Bilbo had absolutely no way of knowing if Gandalf would make it to them in time again, or if their luck in the foul caverns of Goblintown would hold once more, so he would not risk it. They could be angry at him all they wanted. He didn’t care one bit.

“Fine,” Thorin snarled, his eyes like daggers turned right onto Bilbo. “We will do it your way.” 

A chorus of groans echoed all around. Bilbo ignored them. 

Thorin turned again so his back was to Bilbo and the wailing winds beyond, the fur atop his coat matted and discolouring in the storm. He half-glanced back at Bilbo, looking down his nose at where Bilbo was standing barefoot on the slippery black rock-face.

“I trust you will have no problems with walking ahead and leading the rest of us, since you are so eager to carry on. You have been so eager to lead our Company thus far, after all,” he said, and oh, Bilbo could smack him. 

Stubborn, arrogant, bone-headed dwarves!

If only you were mine, and then I could kiss that argumentative frown off your face, you thick idiot, he thought tiredly, turning without a word to the path ahead and squinting uselessly through the rain. 

Hate me all you want, my dear. You are still alive and in front of me, and it is only a bit of rain.  

(A bit of rain that Bilbo was sure was going to give him pneumonia in the very near future, but beggars could not very well be choosers.)

Soon enough, there were thirteen grumbling voices trailing out of the cave after him, drenched to the bone and shooting him their fair share of scowls, though most of the dwarves looked simply too weary to even think about pointing accusing fingers at anybody.

Bilbo did not know what had tripped the mechanism of the goblin gate last time, and he did not know how quickly they would be alerted to intruders on their doorstep, but even the fact that bedrolls had been laid out had him already feeling uneasy, and he was chill all over with icy water and wind and a sense of deep foreboding.

He could sit idle no longer. They were moving on borrowed time.

Despite how high they were in the mountain pass, it was not terribly long before they came out into a grove of trees, and the ground gradually faded from rock to dirt and tree-roots. There was an especially thick canopy of pine and fir overhead in one of the smaller clearings, and after a few quick glances between them the Company all but collapsed into heaps on top of each other.

“I don’t know if lighting a fire is the best idea,” Bilbo began tentatively, “there may still be watchers in the woods -”

But he could see that he’d pushed his limits, and that no one would listen to him any further tonight. 

Thorin gazed over at him stonily from across the camp, his arms folded.

“We have fighters amongst us, Master Baggins, and we will all die of cold, otherwise. I am sure they will be able to protect us from anything,” and here he paused, clenching his jaw to fully exact his disdain, “lurking in the woods.”

Bilbo rolled his eyes and turned to wring the water from his coat. He didn’t mind if they did not believe him, as they hadn’t seen hide nor hair of the goblins and didn’t know what would be waiting for them up ahead, but they could at least be a little more polite about it.

“Don’t mind him, laddie," Balin said kindly, coming up next to him. "We’re still just getting used to the skittishness of hobbits, I suppose.”

Bilbo’s eyebrows furrowed, and he squinted at Balin through the thick drops of rain still falling through the gaps in the canopy above. “You've known me for nearly three months, Balin. You know I'm not skittish.”

Balin’s eyes rested on him, and Bilbo could see how tired he was, and abjectly refused to feel guilty about it.

“We’re quite safe here, Bilbo. There's nothing to worry about. The wizard will be with us again soon.”

Bilbo looked out into the darkness that lay the way they’d come and did not reply.

He could hardly be cross with them, since they had no way of knowing the dangers all around, and he knew that if he was in their place, he’d probably find his constant worry just as tiresome. But he’d hoped they’d realise that his fear was very real, and not simply hobbitish fright or cowardice due to his apparent lack of experience in the Wild. He could feel eyes on them from afar. He knew there were things hiding out, sizing them up.

He would have to go sooner rather than later, if he wanted to find the Ring, and he could find out how much time they had before the goblins were upon them.


“Bofur,” Bilbo whispered a few hours later. “Bofur, get up. Oh, honestly,” he said, and he pulled Bofur’s hat right off and smacked him across the shoulder with it so Bofur jerked awake, blearily blinking sleep out of his eyes. 

Bilbo eyed him. “You dwarves sleep like the dead."

“Hmm?”

“Are you any decent with hunting game?" Bilbo asked quickly. "I spotted a rabbit earlier, just down the grove from here, but I can’t kill it myself.”

“Sure you can, Bilbo!” Bofur said encouragingly, that signature wide grin stretched across his face as he nestled his beloved hat back on his head. “You’ve got a weapon now!”

“I’m not going to cut down a helpless little rabbit with this mighty thing, am I?” he countered, exasperated, gesturing to Sting.

Bofur’s smirk widened, and he tilted his head to the side, the flaps of his hat bouncing merrily. “Aye, but would you call that mighty?”

Bilbo rolled his eyes and wondered if they might fall out of his head at some point. Confusticate dwarves who were too snarky for their own good.

“All right, lad. I’m no good with a bow and arrow, but I’m not a bad aim with a slingshot. We can nick Ori’s and slip it back before anyone’s noticed.”

It was no time at all before the rabbit Bilbo had spotted hiding under a nearby shrub was out cold and Bofur was ambling up to it, gently breaking its neck to put it out of its misery.

“What d’you need game for, anyhow, Bilbo?” The dwarf was still as friendly as ever, but his smile had faded slightly, and he was watching Bilbo with a careful sort of look in his eye. Bilbo swallowed.

“I’m going back to scout the area, and I can’t take any of the Company’s food or they’ll try and stop me. I should only be gone for the night at most. I’m not leaving, so don’t worry about that, but we’re not safe here, and the only person who seems to believe so is me.”

He looked back at Bofur, whose smile had fallen to a feeble sort of grimace, weary and resigned, like he was getting ready to say goodbye.

“I’m not leaving you, Bofur," Bilbo said firmly. "I promise. Wait here for Gandalf in the meantime. All of you need to rest.”

Bofur clapped a sturdy hand to Bilbo’s shoulder, and seemed to linger like he wanted to lean forward and touch his head to Bilbo’s before talking himself out of it.

“Good luck, our burglar.”

The journey back up the rock was treacherous, and horribly bitter, and Bilbo wished uselessly that he could just leave the damned Ring where it was, and the goblins would miraculously leave them alone, and everyone could be quite done with it already. But he knew by now that that was not the way things were, and so he scurried on, shoulders hunched against the whistling wind and rain-soaked shirt sticking uncomfortably to his skin.

He slowed almost to a total stop once he reached the mouth of the cave, hoping that his hobbitish ways would not fail him now, and he’d stay silent and hidden from whatever horrors lurked within. Bilbo pulled the rabbit carcass tighter against his back and prayed that the goblins could not smell the blood.

When he poked the tiniest sliver of his face around the side of the cave, Bilbo saw immediately that he’d been right, and a pit of anxiety opened up in his stomach. There was a crack in the floor like a great gash, and beyond the opening he could see movement, and hear voices, and the sound was like slick choking coming up from the dangerous depths below. Bilbo shuddered, and then closed his eyes briefly and pushed his forehead against the wall of the cave in a silent prayer.

No goblins had come through the Front Gate and into the cave yet, thankfully, and Bilbo crept like he was made of smoke and mist, not daring to disturb a single rock or pebble. When he reached the farthest edge of the opening in the floor, he dropped the rabbit from his back and tied it to his belt with some spare rope so it hung there alongside Sting like a ridiculous ornamental decoration. He resisted the mad urge to laugh, and then cocked his head, wrinkled his nose, and went on, gripping the edge of the rock gently with both hands and swinging as quietly as he could manage, down into the upper arches of Goblintown.

He dropped right into the shadows, keeping his breathing as still as he could manage. There were goblins clambering back and forth along their bridges like a swarm of ants, carrying hideous weapons along the rafters. Not a single one of them noticed the little shape that had appeared in the dark. 

Bilbo really was lucky. Not even the pack of them closest to him had moved an inch, instead standing around to argue with each other in Orcish and making crude gestures in the direction Bilbo had come from.

They know we’re near, he realised, and the frantic fear inside him grew, though he swallowed it down and began to walk soundlessly backwards, one step at a time along the bridge. He did not dare draw his sword.

I shall have to be quick, then, shan’t I?  

He’d nearly made it all the way off the rope-bridge and onto solid ground when there was a dull crack, and the slats of the bridge began to shudder in a perfect ricochet. The rabbit had slipped off its rope and crashed onto the floor.

The goblins all fixed their eyes on him.

Bilbo quickly reattached the rope, then turned and ran like hell itself was after him, eyes wide and panicked as the walls of rock blew past him and searching with urgency for the sight of anything remotely familiar at all in this wretched, stinking place. He didn’t know exactly where he’d fallen last time, and he did not know which of the underground tunnels led where, or whether any of them led to the right cave at all.

There were feet, clawing, closing in behind him. They were all far bigger than he; they would easily outpace him even if he ran until his legs collapsed out from under him. Shouting flew over his head to who-knows-where, and answering roars of glee echoed in the red abyss below him. He could hear the chuckles of the Goblin-King as if they were taunting him alone. Whitening panic slid swiftly down into Bilbo’s heaving chest as he ran and ran and ran.

But then, all of a sudden, he felt a dip in the floor below his feet, and he wrenched his eyes open, and there it was. The plunging drop into darkness, the little cliff-face jutting down, down, into winding tunnels deep within the belly of the mountains. He hurtled over the side without a second thought and disappeared from view.


Bilbo hit the ground hard, so hard his ears began to ring, and he had to raise himself woozily on all fours until his head felt like it had settled.

He felt for his belt. Sting, and the rabbit fastened to his rope; both still there. The sickness of blind panic and quite plausible concussion faded slightly, and reluctantly Bilbo began to drag his way through the shards of rock on hands and knees, feeling around, hoping against hope that he’d see the horrid thing before he touched it. The thought of having to come into contact with that cursed little ring again made Bilbo’s skin crawl.

All of a sudden, on the rocky path just ahead, a few paces from him, there appeared in his vision a dull band of gold. 

Bilbo had to turn away.

He’d known he would be able to find it with relative ease. It made no sense in Bilbo’s mind that whichever powers in the Blessed Realm that had given him another chance would let something as ridiculous as finding the Ring in a cave be a setback on his quest.

He wondered if it could sense him, if it could feel the traces of blackness once coiled around his body and mind even though they had not yet done so in this life.

Bilbo carefully took out his handkerchief from the pocket of his trousers and pinched the Ring between his fingers, not even brave enough to pick up the band with bare skin. He could feel his own thudding pulse in his teeth and in his fingertips, and wondered whether he was imagining the distant thrum beneath the handkerchief too.

He did not want to touch it. He barely wanted to look at it, a glowing-red beam in his mind’s eye like the entrance to a darkness below where all the worst monsters slept. He wished he could simply tuck it away in a rock somewhere and come back for it later, that he did not have to be so near to something that had turned so many to evil, that had wound around his mind like steel wire and tightened every day.

He slipped the Ring into his front-pocket and looked up, gritting his teeth to repress a shiver. The whole subterranean cavern was utterly quiet, only the slow drip, drip of water from high stone stalactites echoing in the gloom. There was no sign of another living creature anywhere. 

Perhaps Bilbo wouldn’t even need the rabbit, after all. The thought made him sigh loudly, and he trudged back up the rock to where he’d fallen from.

He had almost made it to the tunnel opening when, very quietly, Bilbo began to hear something slinking, snaking up from the black edge of the water, and noises like wet fingerprints touching at the bones scattered all around, and the faintest tap-tapping like a tiny boat was lapping at the shore of the lake, kissing up against the rock. Dread crept up and settled in his throat.

Bilbo turned as slowly as he could, and saw the pale gleam of eyes like orbs, the sickly pallor of an elongated body, fish-like in the darkness. He dared not draw his sword. He could not move at all.

“Sméagol,” Bilbo whispered.

The creature stopped. 

There was no sound in the cave, no wind, no crunch of bone or rock. No breath, for Bilbo was holding his, scared out of his wits. He felt blindly at the hilt of Sting beneath his coat and closed his eyes for one terrible moment.

“It knows us, precious,” the thing whispered. “How does it knows us, we wonders?”

The sound of the creature had spent so long drifting through Bilbo’s nightmares that hearing it aloud again was almost a relief, for it was worse and yet not quite as terrible as he remembered. This Gollum was not a ghost, and though he crept and haunted the cave and the lake below the goblin tunnels, he could not creep or haunt anywhere else.

But even so, he hated to be in this dank, dreary cavern again, the very air stale and wet and suffocating to breathe, and for just a moment, he wished again that he had never taken the Ring and doomed himself to crawling around in here with a thing like Gollum.

Then Bilbo shook himself and set his jaw, and thought that it did not really matter whether he wished it or not; he had taken it, and although the guilt of it pulled at him even still, he knew that the fate of the world had been better for it, in the very end, and so he would have to take it once more.

No use complaining, you silly old thing. You are here now, and the journey must go on.

“My name is Bilbo Baggins,” he said to Gollum. “I’ve brought you a gift. So you won’t have to eat any goblins or nasty fish from the lake for a little while.”

“Bagginses? We’ve never met any Bagginses before, precious. Does it bring us birthday presents?”

“Yes, I do,” Bilbo said, untying the rope from his belt and holding it up with one hand. “See? A nice, fat rabbit, fresh from the woods.”

The white-green eyes lit up gleefully, and Gollum reached out with spindly, bony fingers to tear at the flesh of the rabbit, hacking up dreadful noises that Bilbo thought might have been laughter. He averted his eyes. 

“I brought it for you so I could come and talk to you, Sméagol. I’ve come to talk about your… your other birthday present.”

The creature’s eyes sharpened immediately, his bulbous lids falling and his teeth bared. Bilbo hurried to amend the situation in a panic.

“I don’t want to take it, I promise!” he called, holding up both hands in pathetic surrender and taking a single step backward. There was a suspicious crack of something that might have once been a skeleton underneath his foot. “It is yours, Sméagol. Not mine.” 

The words were bitter on his tongue, and he swallowed back bile. 

Mine. Mine. My precious. 

“I am only curious about how special it is,” he said, knowing he could well be sealing his own death sentence by even speaking the words. “You must love it a lot.”

Gollum slowly settled back, though his limbs were still tense, and he peeled at the carcass of the rabbit much more warily. Bilbo knew he was making a huge gamble by willingly drawing Gollum’s attention to the Ring; he may as well have been playing with lit matches around a firecracker. And yet, it was Gollum who had destroyed it, in the end, and it was Gollum who he had shown mercy to, in the ghostly darkness beneath the beds of the mountains, and it was Gollum who had taken it into the fire. Not Frodo.

Bilbo’s feelings towards Gollum were so complex as to not be put into words. Anger, such anger towards him for Frodo and Sam, and even Frodo’s poor finger, and guilt, for being the one who had caused Gollum to creep his way back into the light, and a miserable, sick sort of recognition, like Gollum was an omen of what was in store, like he was the demon that clung to Bilbo’s shoulder and whispered in his ear. Bilbo felt as though he was looking down into the lake at a horrifying sort of reflection. 

The sight was awful. The way the teeth were ground down to brown nubs, nothing but dark, bloody holes in the gums where the rest had once been. The limp few strings of black hair that hung from the crown of his head, scabbing at the roots and torn at the ends.

He pushed forward. 

“Sméagol, do you know who the Precious belongs to?”

Gollum hissed at him, creeping closer across the floor. “It’s ours, precious, and nobody else’s!”

“Yes, of course. It was your birthday present,” Bilbo agreed calmly. “But do you know who gave it to you? Do you know where they got the Precious from?”

Gollum peered dubiously at him, but Bilbo could see the slightest intrigue begin to spark in his hideous face, and knew the smallest part of him that loved riddles and games was curious about such a mystery. He tilted his head, perching like a great frog on the tip of a rock.

“We finds it ourselves, precious,” he hissed. “Nobody gives it to us.”

Bilbo pressed forwards earnestly. “Yes, you found it yourself, and it is your treasure. But it was put there by the Enemy. By Him.”

This approach was not working. Bilbo could see Gollum’s face darkening, the limbs stretching out insidiously. The creature had his teeth bared again. Bilbo tried a new tactic.

“Do you remember your grandmother, Sméagol?” he asked, and Gollum’s demeanour changed at once.

“Yes, yes, we does!” he howled excitedly, eyes growing wide. “She taught us to suck eggses!”

“Do you remember what she looked like?” Bilbo held his breath.

“Sméagol doesn’t… doesn’t remember.” Gollum's bony shoulders seemed to slump in on themselves, and he was so very pitiful that Bilbo wondered again if running him through with a sword wouldn’t be the more humane option after all. “I don’t remember.”

I don’t remember. I. Not we. Not Sméagol.

“The Ring took her from you, Sméagol,” Bilbo said carefully, keeping his tone as even as he could. He did not look away once from Gollum’s eyes. “It made her scared of you.”

But the bumps of Gollum’s spine seemed suddenly to jut out, and he turned his head slowly, terribly, baring his yellowing teeth in the eerie green darkness. 

Bilbo’s blood ran cold. His time was up.

“Baggins is trying to steal it,” Gollum hissed, and he leapt on Bilbo with a scream.

There were slippery, slimy arms all around him, and rotting breath in his ears, on the back of his neck, hot against his skin and making it crawl. Bilbo madly threw his arm backwards with as much force as he could muster, letting his elbow connect with hard bone, and the creature let out a sickening shriek. He could feel the filthy nails scrabbling at his clothes, his skin, digging in, trying to rip and tear at him. He grasped wildly at where the arms were touching him and kicked with his legs, wriggling like an eel to get away from Gollum.

His hand came up, connected with Gollum’s skull, forced him off of Bilbo with a painfully clenched fist. The creature howled, and the walls of the cave threw the noise against each other so it rang dreadfully in their ears and curdled Bilbo’s blood. He threw himself at the nearest upward climb, clawing at the rock with desperate, grubby fingers, and dashed away from the horror of the lake as though both of his lives depended on it. 

It was like one of Bilbo’s nightmares come to life, the way the creature howled out Baggins from further and further away, the screaming of the rock underneath his feet as he raced out of the tunnel and back towards the goblins.

There was movement all around, and shouts in unfamiliar, drawling speech as he whipped past the goblins once more, the ones lurking in the depths and guarding each of the gates hidden within the rock. The sound was like oil slick dripping from their mouths. He did not stop.

Bilbo ducked and weaved and hurtled out of the tunnels, out through the little gap in the gate and all the way down the side of the mountain, hoping with all he had that the Company had waited for him, that he had not forgotten the way. The balls of his feet were pounding against the packed dirt, stones and twigs and little tufts of grass flying in all directions as the ground kicked up behind him.

He had no way of knowing if he’d delayed Gollum’s capture by the armies of Mordor or only spurred it on faster. He knew, too, that running in broad daylight with no way of hiding himself would likely lead the goblins right towards them if they saw him, but he was a hobbit, after all, and he could be quiet and hidden of his own accord.

He would not put the Ring on. Not ever again.


Bilbo was sucking in air and still thumping his flat feet on the ground when he began to hear voices nearby, and he stumbled to a stop, leaning against a tree with his hands and bowing his head as he tried to catch his breath. Trickles of the deep rumbling of dwarves filtered through the trees, and he closed his eyes in relief. They were still here.

He concentrated, still a little ways away from the clearing but just able to catch glimpses of them through the trees, and realised that they were in the midst of what seemed to be a heated argument. Predictably, Thorin’s voice was clearest over the din.

“It does not matter what Master Baggins said to you, Bofur. It’s clear he has no plan on returning.” There was the sound of grit crunching under boots, and Bilbo could see the set of Thorin’s shoulders between a gap in the branches. 

“We cannot stay here any longer. We are losing time by sitting here and awaiting someone who has abandoned us.”

Even from this distance, Bilbo could see the way Bofur’s face tightened into a troubled frown. A tall figure turned to the side to fix their eyes on the assorted members of the Company, and Bilbo realised with another immense spark of relief that it was Gandalf, reunited with them from Rivendell.

“What exactly happened, Bofur?” Gandalf asked, patiently but imploringly, and a few of the others murmured in agreement. There was a distinctly morose feeling between them all, settling across the Company and clouding the sullen air. Bilbo had not realised that they had grown so fond of him.

Bofur rolled his shoulders and fixed them all with a look as if to test them, and Bilbo’s heart grew light as air.

“He woke me and asked for help with catching some game for food, and when I asked him what he needed it for, he said he was going to scout behind us, like I told you. He seemed awfully convinced that there was something lurking in the mountains, waiting for us, and he told me not to leave until Gandalf arrived.”

“Yet Gandalf is here,” Thorin murmured, “and our burglar is not.”

“It does seem odd that he needed a whole rabbit for a journey that takes only a couple of hours,” Bombur added unsurely, looking around at them all.

“Well - aye, that is true, but we all know hobbits eat a lot," Bofur said. “I’ve no idea what he expected to do with it, but I wasn’t going to question him in the middle of the night.” He took off his hat and began to fiddle with it in his fingers. Bilbo had never in his life seen Bofur without it before the previous night, and the sight was still completely bizarre. “Something’s spooked him, Thorin. He seemed so worried.”

“The mountains haven’t been sitting well with him,” chipped in Dori. “He’s been acting twitchier than usual.”

“Well, who can blame him?” Nori shot back, throwing an arm vaguely towards the towering treeline. “We here all knew we might be walking toward our deaths, but are we so sure he was ever told as much?” 

“That is quite enough,” boomed a voice like thundering iron. Bilbo watched as Gandalf rose to his full height, his expression like a great statue hanging over the rest of them and his pointed hat trembling on his head.

“If you all still believe our hobbit is to be spooked by such simple things as walking and climbing after all he has done for you,” he said fiercely, “then you are much blinder than I imagined, and I am ashamed to be amongst you. He has been a friend to every one of you, and now, you would forsake him to the Wild like he is expendable weight!”

“If he is our friend, Gandalf,” said Thorin quietly, “then where is he?”

Gandalf’s narrowed eyes pierced him at once, and Bilbo could feel the tension that settled over the ring they stood in. A brief, strange burst of sympathy ran through him as he watched Thorin very deliberately lift his chin to meet the wizard’s glare.

Oh, your stubbornness is admirable, my heart, but you are never in all your days going to win against Mithrandir.

“He could be in danger!” Gandalf cried. “The Misty Mountains are treacherous. There is every chance he could have been taken captive or gravely hurt by now, no doubt trying to keep all of you safe!”

This seemed to incense Thorin even further, and Bilbo had no way of knowing if it was because he thought Gandalf was wrong, or because he thought he was right.

“Do none of you recall what he said at the Trollshaws?” Thorin said, turning to face the others. His voice had become almost a growl. “Master Baggins informed us he can protect himself just fine, but he could not brave the mountains, so he cut his losses and slipped away. We will not be seeing our burglar again.”

Bilbo knew it had come time for him to step out and end this unpleasant haggling, but he first spared a moment to admire how Thorin could command attention even when he was being thick as a blunt axe, and how it really wasn’t quite fair the way his brows sat when he was mad. Ridiculous.

“I wouldn’t be quite so sure of that, Master Oakenshield.”

Fourteen heads spun as one, and their faces broke open with relief. Bilbo felt stupidly warm with affection for all of them.

“Bilbo!” several of them cried, staggering towards him and smacking him affectionately on the back or the shoulders. Kili’s grin was especially huge, and Bilbo winked at him.

“Bilbo Baggins,” Gandalf said, and Bilbo could see the warm relief in his twinkling smile. “You are indeed a sight for sore eyes.”

“Yes, yes, it’s all a miracle and I’m very grateful you’re all so relieved, but we need to get out of here,” Bilbo said, smiling quickly but trying to handle their most pressing matters with all the haste he could muster. “They are coming. We need to get into the trees, or they will catch us.”

“Who?”

Bilbo huffed exasperatedly. “The goblins. I was scouting the area, I told you. There are goblins on our trail.”

At the suddenly-sheepish looks on their faces, Bilbo’s eyes narrowed.

“You really didn’t believe me, did you?”

“Well,” Gloin said, a note of apology in his voice, “it’s just that we wouldn’t have blamed you, Bilbo, if you’d decided to turn around after all. You don’t have any personal stake in this quest.”

That sent Bilbo into even more of a huff, and he strode forward before he could give it a second thought, jabbing Gloin hard in the chest with a pointed finger.

“Now, look here, I may be small, and easily hidden, but I rather thought I’d shown you all by now that I’m made of stronger stuff than I seem. Do you honestly think I would have come along on this quest at all if I hadn’t had at least an inkling of what I was getting into?”

He petered out quite suddenly, and decided to frown for good measure. Gloin looked positively abashed, and not one of the others was holding eye contact with him any longer, except for Bofur and Balin.

Bilbo saw Thorin glance at him, and directed the next part of his speech straight to him. If Thorin did not want to look at him, well, he was going to have to just grit his teeth and bear it.

“There is no one else in the world who is willing to stop and help you, so it is me who must do what I can. You may not feel the same way, but you are all my friends,” he said, breathing out slowly, gazing around at these faces he’d so loved, “and I would not be a friend at all if I did not carry on with you when things got difficult. I am not going to leave you.”

Thorin was watching him, the look in his eyes unreadable, unrelenting. There'd always been something in those eyes that Bilbo could never place.

And for once, Bilbo let his gaze wander, over the speckled streaks of grey that swept back through the darkness of his hair, the ample slope of his nose, the twin braids hanging down by his shoulders and the gold clasps threaded through them. His forearms, shot with scars; the marks of a blacksmith who excelled at his work. The meshed material across his chest and his close-cropped beard, almost too neat and tidy to seem like it belonged to Thorin. Bilbo had imagined the feel of it under his fingers more times than he could count.

After a long silence, where Bilbo held his ground, Thorin bent his head downwards and then looked back up to Bilbo, his eyebrows no longer as tense, his eyes no longer so harsh, almost like he was yielding. Like he had wanted to be proven wrong, and Bilbo had succeeded. Bilbo knew it for the silent acquiescence it was, and a little smile twitched onto his face without him quite meaning it to.

Bofur clapped him on the shoulder and squeezed gently. Ori and Dori smiled at him, and so did Oin and Gloin, and Fili and Kili, and Bifur and Bombur, and Balin inclined his head, and Dwalin rolled his eyes mightily and turned to watch Thorin instead. Bilbo met Gandalf’s eyes over the fabric of Bofur’s hat, and they were glowing with something otherworldly that looked rather satisfied with the whole turn of events. They watched each other, and Gandalf tipped his hat so slightly that Bilbo wasn’t sure if he was just imagining things. For just a second, all of them breathed in a single moment of quiet.

It was then, in the distance, that the drums began. 

Bilbo’s heart stopped. His eyes frantically snapped back to Thorin's, still heavy on him. 

“We have to get to the trees,” he said.

Thorin didn’t hesitate, whipping around roughly and calling out, “Into the trees! Now!”

All fifteen of them, dwarves and a hobbit and Gandalf the Grey, raced towards the trees, the thud of their leather-soled boots thunderous amongst the rustle of leaves and the steady boom, boom, boom of danger coming closer.

Bilbo couldn't hear how close they were; couldn't hear anything over the sudden hammering in his ears, and he reached a tree and gripped at the branches like he was trying to tear them down with his own hands, his head swivelling side to side as he counted each of his dwarves.

Bifur up. Bombur up. Fili, Kili, Ori, Nori, where is Dori, where is - Dori, Oin, Gloin; Dwalin, you fool, you cannot take them all yourself, get into a tree!

Thorin up, in a tree far away from Bilbo’s, and Bilbo could see the faint luminous blue of his sword glowing beneath his hands like a pinprick in the sky. He was closest to Gandalf, Balin and Bofur, and distantly Bilbo felt himself clutch at his chest through the loose fabric of his shirt, as though he was making sure it was still there.

The tips of pine-needles were like blades against their throats as they waited, nobody daring to breathe in or out, the entire world utterly still and the drums drawing closer. Cackles started to ring in the distance, and the goblins poured in.

There was a vile way the taunts dripped from their lips, their mouths like torn gashes in their faces. They had creeping, curling tongues and wicked grins that stung at your skin with fear. Bilbo clung to the trunk of the tree and wished he was higher up, scrabbling with one hand in the twigs above for pinecones to use if it came to it once again. Wargs snapped and howled at the base of each tree, great hulking masses like creatures from the depths of hell itself, ghostly-white and bred by shadow. Their jagged claws gouged into the bark and shook the trees terrifyingly.

The goblins were mocking them, dancing around in rings below them, jeering and laughing, sadistically stringing songs together about their bones shrivelling and cracking and the skin peeling from their faces. Bilbo felt utterly ill with fear and revulsion, and weakly pressed his forehead against the trunk of the tree. And still the goblins growled, their sickly grins menacing and creeping closer and closer in their awful dancing to where each of the trees was full of dwarves. 

Then, suddenly, one of them yelped out in pain and clutched the back of its head, aghast. A compact little stone had struck from somewhere behind and to the left of it.

Ori’s slingshot, Bilbo realised. They were distracting the goblins, trying to lead them astray, confuse them. He reached upwards and plucked a pinecone from the branch above him. His leaning caused the branch to creak, just slightly, and the air in his lungs turned into empty, hollow space in his chest.

When in doubt due to mortal peril, one must turn to what one knows.

All thirteen of the dwarves started to shout back at them, calling down to the goblins from the treetops and throwing all sorts of things to enrage them even further; more pinecones, lit with Gandalf’s white-blue flame, and sticks, and rocks, and someone’s fur-lined boot soaring through the air to crack against one of the goblin’s noses.

Then, the air became quite still, and the world seemed to slow down, as one of the goblins’ mouths fell open and it crumpled to the ground, thick blood gushing from a slash in the side of its head. Bilbo’s head whipped around.

It was Nori, hanging from the tree with only his legs wrapped around the trunk and his arm still outstretched from where the knife had left his hand.

The moment snapped. Any merriment was utterly gone from every one of the goblins’ faces, and they swarmed as one on the pine trees, hacking at them with axes and hammers and their bare fingers tearing into the gouges left by the wargs. The laughter was dark and foreboding and rang in Bilbo’s ears, and he prayed with all his might for the eagles to hurry, hurry, hurry already!

But the goblins weren’t spread evenly against each tree. More and more were surrounding the base of Nori’s, climbing on top of each other’s bodies in a horrid writhing heap and clawing at the tree to reach the culprit. Bilbo could see Nori scurrying higher in the branches, but he couldn’t reach the top, and Bifur and Ori were clambering desperately after him, and Dori was crying out to them across the glade, and the pale bodies of the goblins began to reach their arms out towards the dwarves up in the branches.

There was a sudden deep and gut-wrenching roar, the sort of noise that tore from you and bruised the walls of your throat with the sheer violence of it. Bilbo wanted nothing more than to squeeze his eyes shut, but forced himself to keep them open.

There Thorin stood, out of the tree and alone in the clearing against thirty goblins, his sword a piercing blue across the front of his body. His entire frame was heaving; Bilbo could see it even from this distance. His mouth was pulled back in anger, and his eyes were clear and focused. He was trying to draw their attention. Bilbo watched him bellow at them again, and couldn’t bear the sound of it.

The blade of Orcrist swept upwards in a perfect, deadly arc, and Thorin cleaved the closest goblin in two. 

Bilbo immediately dropped like a stone out of the tree, taking no notice of the wild yell Kili let out after him or the pain that ricocheted through his knees when he hit the forest floor, and he ran like mad.

He'd done it so suddenly that the goblins nearest to him had no chance to close in before he was gone, dashing madly through the underbrush and weaving around the thick roots of trees as tall as mountains. Vines and low-hanging branches split at his face, and the sound of his feet against the hard-packed earth rang like a gong through the eerie battle-quiet in his head.

To their credit, the dwarves had taken out quite a few of the goblins, Gandalf's fire circling in a ring around them so a number of them could not pass through. Several had fallen to the ground in howling pain, clutching at their knees or heads or the base of their necks, and Bilbo knew Ori must be aiming as hard as he could. Dwalin was on the lowermost rung of the tree, hacking at their hands and faces wildly and swinging his axes with a roar.

But goblins were still rushing at Thorin like a wave, and he was whipping Orcrist through the air like a wildstorm, the Elven gleam mirroring the blue of the fire around them until the very air was glowing. He was cutting them down, and yet it was not fast enough, and time seemed to trickle on like water as the tallest one approached with its weapon raised. Thorin’s head was turned the other way.

There was a hammer, and a sickening crack. Thorin dropped to his knees. Bilbo’s vision went white.

Almost out of his body, he could see the goblin still looming over Thorin mockingly, the mallet-like hammer swinging by its side and its body wracked with laughter as Thorin slumped to the ground, his eyes huge. 

Huge, but still open, and focusing, with some effort, on Bilbo.

Bilbo urged his frantic feet to move faster, and dashed into the path of the goblin so he was standing between its body and Thorin’s, Sting slipping faithfully in his hand. He could hear Thorin’s gasping breaths behind him, and tried to remind himself that the dwarf was all right, possibly, probably, though he could barely think over the thundering in his ears and the wild pounding of his heart. He set his footing and gripped the hilt of his sword in both hands.

“You can cut me down,” he spat, “but you will not touch him.”

The goblin threw its head back and laughed, and then began to stalk towards them both, moving in for the kill.

Bilbo bit down on his lip, hard, and closed his eyes for just a second, feeling the cold night air rustling the ends of his hair and washing over him like a stream. He could feel nothing but the wind, and the smooth curve of his little sword in his fingers, and the churned-up earth beneath his feet. He opened his eyes and ran forwards with Sting clasped in both hands and only the thud of his beating heart echoing in his ears, and let the blade sink deep into the goblin’s foul stomach. It screamed.

He pulled the sword out, drove it in again, hard, at its throat this time. Blood the colour of ichor began to spurt from its mouth and run down the sides, and its eyes rolled back until only the bloodshot whites were visible. Bilbo bared his teeth as he climbed off the body, staggering back and throwing his sword out to the side, his whole body heaving with wild adrenaline. He waited for the next danger to approach, willing them to even try. Sting slashed at the air in front of him.

From very, very far away, almost as if underwater, he could hear other voices calling out, and he began to breathe, slowly falling back into himself. Bilbo. Bilbo.

“Bilbo!” he heard someone - Ori, maybe - cry, and he whipped around to see the rest of them climbing up, up, further through the trees, and beyond them, a soar of great black shadows descending from the sky. 

The eagles had come.

Bilbo dropped Sting at his feet and knelt to look over Thorin, his chest lurching. Thorin was awake, and still alive, but his eyes were barely open, and there was a ghastly, blackening bruise staining his collarbone and the base of his throat. All he seemed to be able to do was keep breathing in and out, unable to move his head at all, or pull his eyes away from Bilbo. They had precious few moments before the goblins would set in.

Bilbo looked up at the skyline again, and then threw himself forwards, grabbing at the front of Thorin’s coat and screaming out, “Help! We’re here!” He could see Gandalf, high up in the fir tree and calling to the eagles, who were plucking the dwarves out of the trees one by one.

The greatest of them all, a grey-feathered and regal creature with wise, ancient eyes, flew down and clasped Thorin’s body in its huge yellow-black talons, lifting him off the ground. Thorin’s eyes fell down to Bilbo as the eagle began to rise up into the sky, and Bilbo realised a split-second before the others did that the eagle had not seen him, small as he was, and that he would find himself left behind on this goblin-infested cliff if he didn’t do something fast. He picked up Sting, sheathed it, and took a running leap forwards, as high as his legs could carry him and only just managing to grip onto Thorin’s dangling arm below the talons of the eagle.

Thorin’s only reaction was a pained grunt. It seemed to be all he could do not to pass out, his chest rising and falling in great gaping breaths like he was drowning in his own lungs. Bilbo had no way of knowing if he was well enough to even speak, or if his rapid breathing was using up all of the air in his chest, and cold fear clawed at his throat. He squeezed Thorin’s arm even tighter.

He clung on for dear life the entire flight, one of his hands around Thorin’s bicep just below his shoulder and one clutching at his forearm, his grip so tight he was sure the blood wouldn’t be able to run to Thorin’s head and he really would pass out. There were no words for how biting the wind was, this high, and his fingers began to go numb. He did not let go.

They landed on the Carrock, Bilbo’s toes stinging after so long in the air with nothing but a terrifyingly sheer drop below him, and the eagle laid Thorin down on a flat plateau of rock. The other dwarves all crowded around him as they landed one after the other, clambering to get nearer and watching on with tight fear in their faces. Gandalf had to fight his way through the circle to reach him.

“Accursed dwarves! I need to see to him, and you are all blocking the way!”

They parted, though their expressions were stormy, and Bilbo could see them all glaring at Gandalf in expectation that he would fail, doubting that he could do anything for their leader. It wasn’t all too surprising. They hadn’t yet seen wizardry up close, and they still only knew Gandalf as a guide and a fighter, not as a tender of wounds or weaver of magic.

Thorin was lying on his back and staring unseeing at the sky, his breaths coming in stuttered gasps as he tried to choke the air down into his lungs. He seemed awake, still, but something was clearly wrong, and grim pressure began to build in Bilbo’s throat and eyes and jaw. Gandalf knelt at his side and passed a withered hand over Thorin’s face, and then rested his palm gently against Thorin’s chest, his fingers splayed out right across the centre. There was a dreadful moment of utter stillness.

Then, Bilbo could see Thorin starting to come back to himself, the rapid rising of his chest slowly evening out. The bruise across his neck was fading into a green-tinged yellow before their eyes, and Gandalf continued to murmur quietly above Thorin’s body, one hand clutched tightly around his staff as he knelt.

Thorin blinked, and his eyes came into focus. Everyone’s shoulders visibly loosened.

“Master Baggins?” Thorin croaked out, blinking away the glare of the daybreak and looking up at Gandalf leaning over him. 

Gandalf's voice was gravelly and sounded tired, but soft, when he replied, “It’s all right. Bilbo is unhurt, and quite safe.”

Even amongst the wild bloom of giddy relief that went up like a flare in his chest, Bilbo found himself frowning, and had to restrain the petulant urge to cross his arms. The cuts and scrapes all over his face might have said something quite different, not to mention the state of his knees after his tumble out of the tree! 

Bilbo decided to ignore Gandalf, and instead watched on restlessly as Thorin rose with some effort onto his elbows to look back at him. His face was the same stone mask it ever was, and his mouth was set into a tense line.

“You should not have done that,” Thorin said quietly. He gripped the arm Dwalin was offering to him and hauled himself to his feet, staggering a little unsteadily and catching the dwarves closest to him by the shoulders. But he held his head high, and his expression did not change. 

Bilbo felt rooted to the spot by the intensity of those eyes on him atop the rock-face. They looked lighter, almost, in the early morning.

“You are a risk for us to have in this Company. You are reckless, and irresponsible, and you rely far too much on your own cleverness than you should.”

Thorin paused for a moment. His balance still seemed a little off, but his eyes were clear. Possibly a little concussed then, or maybe just weak from effort and having the breath knocked right out of him. 

It was a hard thing for Bilbo not to roll his eyes at all the theatrics. He tried to look like he was being properly chastised, but in actuality he was wondering if Thorin would be able to muster up the nerve to hug him again, and quite wishing he would get on with it already.

I know your tricks this time, you ridiculous thing. You can’t fool me.

“And you have saved my life.” 

Finally, they were turning towards each other like faraway ships in the night.

Thorin took a step forward, and the whole world exhaled with him. The way he approached Bilbo was hesitant, not like the last time, when he’d marched forward in a blaze after scaring Bilbo half to death and pulled him up into his chest before Bilbo had quite known what on Earth was going on. This time Thorin’s steps were slower, more unsteady, and his eyes seemed to open up the closer he got to Bilbo. The vulnerability on Thorin’s face stunned him quite into silence.

Thorin stopped in front of him, and his throat moved as he swallowed, looking down at Bilbo with his mouth parted slightly, his whole face moving and alive. They stood in silence for a moment, and then a few more moments. 

It was right as Bilbo decided he was sick of waiting that Thorin wrapped his arms around him and pulled Bilbo into his chest.

Immediately, it all came rushing back to him. Bilbo clutched at Thorin tightly, drawing one arm up around his shoulders and tugging at him like he was trying to pull him down to his own height. There was no astonishment, this time, only warmth, so much of it, and the feel under his fingers that he was home, that his heart had joined together again.

Oh, my love, he thought. Oh, my love.

This broody, moody, ridiculous creature of his heart, the one who spoke little but listened to everything, who barely slept but never faltered, who had borne every burden of the hardship of his people for longer than a century. Whose smiles were rare and sacred, and who wore his beard short as a sign of eternal mourning, and whose closed-off heart had once opened so completely to Bilbo he could not quite remember the way he walked through the world without the memory of Thorin by his side.

He felt Thorin’s hand drag up his back and gently grasp the back of his neck, touching at his brown curls with more gentleness than Bilbo could have imagined. The other hand brushed at the top of his spine, and Bilbo did the same, feeling sleek ends of hair amongst the fur beneath his fingers on Thorin’s back.

He could barely hear the din behind them until Thorin pulled away from him, and then the outlandish cheering of the rest of the dwarves hit his ears with embarrassing clarity. He could see them all past Thorin’s shoulder, and they were shaken and a bit battered, but unharmed. He had to fight back the calibre of the grin that threatened to spring across his face.

“I am sorry I doubted you,” Thorin said, in his slow baritone, and his head was tilted with a clear new tenderness now, a reluctance towards everything Bilbo did that had become gratefulness the longer they’d travelled together. “I am truly thankful you have joined us.” 

“Oh, dear, Gandalf, I think you might have to take another look at Master Oakenshield here. I think he’s gone round the bend!” Bilbo called, smiling, and the whole Company roared with laughter.

Someone soon took out some pieces of their trusty jerky, and they all flopped down on various bits of mossy rock, utterly worn out (and not the least Bilbo, who had not been able to rest his eyes for well over twenty-four hours).

Bilbo sat facing southward, looking far along the line of the distant, roaming mountain range, stretching further than hobbit eyes could see and down to where Bilbo knew was a country of horsemen, and past that, to where the White Tree would stand in years to come.

Lothlórien lay along the path, too. Bilbo spared a thought for the Lady of the Golden Wood. He had never visited her realm, and wondered if this time around he just might have to. He’d heard the flowers there were beautiful unlike anything else that had ever been in this world.

He’d heard all too much about the Elvish waybread they made there, too, from his nephew and younger cousins and little Sam Gamgee. Lembas. His stomach growled, and he looked down at the jerky forlornly. Bilbo wondered if it would make him a terrible person to ask one of the eagles if perhaps they had any spare eggs lying about.

His pulse was still thudding from the aftermath of the fight, and from Thorin’s dramatic display, and Bilbo clutched his own wrist in his hand gently, taking a deep breath to calm himself and then shaking his head.

They’d crossed what he saw as the first real hurdle that lay in their path, and quite successfully, all things considered. He’d managed to steer them from the goblins’ doorstep, and they’d all held their own in the battle beautifully once more.

And Thorin was all right. Dreadfully winded, and probably dazed, and if they were any of them sensible hobbits he probably would have been told to rest for a day before journeying on, but they were distinctly lacking in any of those, so Thorin’s stubborn resolve would have to win out.

Bilbo firmly believed that Thorin would not die again. He’d clung to it with unshakeable fortitude their whole journey so far. He would not ever have been given this life back if it was to go the same way, and Bilbo trusted to his own mind that he would be able to see them all through to the end. But this first brush had been a test, and it had been close, and Bilbo did not want anything to brush closer than it already had.

There was no need to worry, however. He felt he might have an inkling of what he was going to do about it.

Notes:

as always, my twitter is here!

also full disclosure, i'm worried that my aim to get chapters out as quickly as possible has meant i've been burning myself out, and i don't want to force myself to post anything i'm not happy with or didn't enjoy writing. because of this, i'm not sure when the next chapter will be out, and it might not be for a little while (although it shouldn't be too long, i promise!) thank you all for understanding!

UPDATE 05/05/2023: hi guys! i have no idea if anyone checks these notes, but i just wanted to pop in and say thank you all so much for being so patient and so sweet to me after i said i’d be back and then dipped for months. i absolutely promise that i will come back to this fic and i will keep posting chapters once i feel up to it - i do have a lot of the fic written including the epilogue, but it’s been a hectic year and i don’t want to force out subpar content just for the sake of posting on time.

i’m also in my final semester of uni and have accidentally fallen headfirst into a new hyperfixation so my brain isn’t really focused on this at the moment, but i promise i will be back and i will keep posting when i can. i’m so sorry i’ve kept you all waiting so long, but everyone being so lovely has made me smile a lot and i’m very grateful. feel free to find on twitter if you want to! i’m so sorry again!