Chapter Text
“Do you have much experience in throwing knives, by any chance, Nori?” Bilbo asked through a mouthful of stew.
They’d set up camp at the foot of the Carrock after the long climb down the staircase, and the fire was crackling away in the dusky light, Oin and Gloin poking and prodding at it with drywood sticks. Nori was at present picking at his teeth with a dried-out reed from the riverbank nearby, and he pulled it out of his mouth to properly ponder Bilbo’s question, tilting his head to the side.
“Suppose I’ve got a bit, if you want to know,” he said. “More than anyone else here, at least.” He spun the reed between his fingers for a moment, then dropped it into the grass and leant back on both of his hands.
“They’re more of a sneak’s weapon. Most of us would gladly go charging off into battle with all sorts of hammers in our hands, but I’ve never been as inclined to brute strength as others, like Dori or Dwalin, for instance.” Nori paused for a moment. “Or Thorin.”
“Well, I’m sure even the strongest hobbit in all the Shire would be a great deal weaker than you lot,” Bilbo said astutely, and they all snickered.
“Why do you ask, Bilbo?” Balin questioned, pipe in hand and blinking at him over the flickering fire. Bilbo scrunched up his eyebrows in a frown and stared back the way they’d come.
“I saw Nori throw one when we were up in the trees. I would like to learn.”
This was met with some splutters from all directions, and a great deal of murmuring, though Bilbo could see when he cast his eyes around the camp that most of it was considering rather than doubtful.
“One taste of battle for that sword and you’re out for more orc-blood, Bilbo! Who knew!” Bofur cried, and the others all began to holler in agreement. Bilbo rolled his eyes, and was certain they were going to fall out of his head before journey’s end if he kept the habit up at such a pace.
“You are all utterly hopeless,” he mocked, and they chortled and cheered, and he could not quite keep the grin off his face.
“Really, though, I cannot go rushing off into the thick of battle every time we get ourselves into trouble. I was lucky today, but I am bound to be knocked down easily if I lose my sword, and I would rather have multiple ways of defending myself from danger. And," he added, "I am not a bad hand at conkers, as I have already made sure you all know.”
There was a moment of silence. “Have you?” Bombur asked unsurely.
Oh, Bilbo thought. That was the first journey, not the second. Well, no matter.
“Perhaps I haven’t, then,” Bilbo said, trying not to seem flustered. “The point is, I have something of an eye for throwing and aiming, and I would rather rely on something I can become skilled at than something I will never master, like Dwalin’s axes.”
He gestured vaguely off to the side, where Dwalin was propped up on the ground and running a sharpening tool along the curve of Grasper.
“I cannot wield great weapons, and Sting is enough for me, but I would still like to be sure.”
“Sting?” Thorin asked quietly.
His sudden voice startled Bilbo, his skin prickling with the memory of arms around him and whispered words in his ear. He had hardly been able to look at Thorin all day.
He cleared his throat, shaking his head into focus and pulling back the frayed edge of his coat to reveal the little sword sheathed in his belt. Thorin’s eyes were utterly unreadable over the fire as he watched the movement, and Bilbo had to swallow.
Kili’s eyes, however, brightened immediately.
“You really are out for blood now, aren’t you, Mr Bilbo! Naming your blade and all!” He looked around at the others, who were all still laughing merrily, and called out, “Orcs shall tremble at the thought of the mighty Sting!”
Bilbo flushed and looked back to Nori, who was grinning roguishly and looking quite pleased at the turn of events.
“So?”
“Ah, I wish you had asked me earlier, Bilbo,” Nori said, smirking. “I could have made off with a few more odds and ends from that Rivendell lot.”
Dwalin scowled.
“That’s all right,” Bilbo said. “We can make do for the moment, and I’m sure we can ask around once we arrive in Laketown. Or I’ve no doubt something will be lying around under the Mountain in this supposed treasure hoard of yours.”
“Aye, indeed,” Dori interjected, quite pointedly. “Lying around under a dragon, it seems.”
“Oh, bother old Smaug!” Bilbo said vehemently. “I don’t want to think about him until we absolutely have to!” He only felt a little guilty about how affronted Dori looked.
“It is a good idea, Bilbo,” Thorin said. He was holding one hand outward to the fire now, warming it up against the night air. His eyes flickered up to Bilbo’s once more, and his expression mellowed out, as though almost making one final peace offering.
Bilbo’s heart stuttered very momentarily in his chest. It was the first time Thorin had said his name.
Nori pulled three little flyblades from a hidden pocket in his cloak, and held them out to Bilbo. The sight of the sharp knife-edges was a little daunting, but Bilbo shook himself and took them with a sort of grim determination, clenching his jaw and trying to get used to the unfamiliar weight and curve in his fingers.
They could be quite hobbitish weapons, he supposed, the flyblades and Sting. Like one could be his pins and the other his needles. He chuckled at the thought.
Nori was by no means an expert, but all the dwarves at least knew how to throw, and so each of them helped him. Bilbo gradually learnt how to grip the handle of each knife, how to angle and direct them and throw with enough power that they would lodge in a tree, or hopefully, a throat, though he was still far from accomplished at that. By the end of the night his wrists were sore and could hardly move, and Bilbo felt almost bleary-eyed with exhaustion, but there was a warmth in his chest that would not settle, and he fell asleep in his bundle with a smile on his face.
It was short-lived. They were at it again the next morning, Nori letting Bilbo amateurly flick his knives as they walked across the broad plains and Fili and Kili making a game of who could find them in the grass the quickest, when Thorin seemed to materialise in front of them like a looming cloud.
(Bilbo’s feelings about him were still very muddled. He could still feel roughened fingers on the back of his neck. Having Thorin back to him was one thing, but having Thorin look at him with gentleness instead of disdain had completely floored Bilbo all over again.)
“I think you have practised enough for now, Master Baggins,” Thorin murmured, falling into heavy step beside him. Nori had mysteriously disappeared almost immediately, and after some searching Bilbo found him far on the other side of the Company, seemingly in heated discussion with several other dwarves, including both of Thorin’s nephews. Fingers were pointing and flying in all directions, and at one point Nori turned back to him and smirked.
Peculiar.
Bilbo’s eyebrows creased in the middle. “It’s barely been a day.”
“It is not good for you.”
Thorin’s tone was low and decisive, and made Bilbo turn to look at him. His face was utterly still, betraying no emotion, and he did not look back at Bilbo, only trudging on forwards and keeping his eyes very firmly on the road.
“What in the world do you mean?” asked Bilbo crossly. “I’m not totally useless, you know. In fact, you do know now, so what exactly is the problem with me throwing a blade or two?”
You’d quite think having one's life saved would be enough to wake someone up.
He could see the sinews in Thorin’s jaw clench, the angle of his face tightening as he adjusted his shoulders and still did not look at Bilbo.
“It can be dangerous to practise too intensely with weapons when you are unused to them. You will hurt yourself.”
He said it quite stiffly, almost like he was forcing it out through his teeth. Bilbo frowned, now quite confused, and more than a little incensed.
“Shouldn’t I be trying to learn as fast as I am able?” I would have thought you would want me to help you on the journey, Thorin, my dear.
Thorin did not speak for a moment.
“Of course,” he said, after Bilbo had all but given up on him ever responding, “but you are going to damage your wrists if you keep at it like that. It is no good if you overwork yourself and cannot move at all.”
“I’m sure I can manage,” Bilbo bit back sarcastically.
Then Thorin’s mouth moved, and Bilbo realised in utter amazement that he was smiling very, very faintly. It changed all the lines in his face, smoothed them out and softened him so he was no longer the cool granite of the impervious King Under the Mountain; he was Thorin, Bilbo’s Thorin, and it was difficult not to draw a hand closer to brush the hair from his face.
“You should bind your wrists with cloth when you’re practising.” It was only in that moment that he finally looked back at Bilbo, eyes unusually open and that softened quirk of the mouth still there, and they walked side by side, studying each other’s faces. “You should be taking care of all the tools you have at your disposal, including the ones you use to wield your weapons.”
“Alright,” Bilbo conceded, not quite managing to keep the crossness out of his voice, “but there’s no need for you to hover over me like I cannot manage my own problems.”
“You have been hovering over us the entire journey.”
“Yes, well, I feel quite responsible for you all, and especially you, since… since you are the leader.”
Thorin brought his face back up to the path in front of them. “And we are all grateful for it, Master Baggins," he said, "but we can take care of ourselves.”
Bilbo’s nose twitched upwards, and a crease formed between his eyebrows. “Yes, that’s very evident after you nearly got yourself beheaded by orcs not two days ago.” His eyes cleared, and he looked over again to Thorin, who grunted in lieu of responding, because apparently he was now able to be sincere and lovely while still behaving as rude as ever.
His face was quiet and still, and his hair was blowing every which way in the wind.
(Bilbo could have watched Thorin’s hair for hours, though he couldn’t say what drew him so deeply to it. It spilled over everything like forks of dark lightning, what Bilbo imagined the sea in the West must look like on moonless nights, like ink spilling out across the vast expanse.)
He reminded Bilbo of the night, slowly coming into the day. And if Bilbo heard a murmured “Thank you”, too under his breath to say for certain, well, then, that was neither here nor there.
They walked by day and stopped only once the sun was fully set, the Great River of Anduin behind them and the creeping shadows of the treeline of Mirkwood inching closer and closer.
Quite a few of their Company had started to complain of aching limbs, weary from the battle and the lack of real rest they’d had since Rivendell, and they were desperate to stop for a day or two to replenish supplies and tend to their wounds. Bilbo felt terrible about having to push them onward, not least because he was sore and aching too, but Gandalf blessedly took the brunt of it for him.
“They are going to come after us,” he told them, in the early morning the day after their awful brush with the goblins, when the sky was still just purple wisps on the horizon and everybody’s eyes were still half-open. “It would be incredibly foolish to imagine that the goblins will stop hunting us after the damage we have done to their armies. You killed many of them, and they will want revenge.”
He’d told them that he knew of shelter nearby, only a couple of days journey more, and that it was the safest place they would likely find this side of the Wildlands. Bilbo had quickly piped up to say that he thought it was a grand idea, and that they were clearly quite lucky indeed they’d turned up so close to someone who seemed much more likely to help than hurt them.
He was deeply glad that he would get to see Beorn again. The part of Bilbo that came straight out of the Shire had been utterly enamoured by the gardens around the skin-changer’s house, and the painstakingly tender care he took of them, of all his creatures and seeds and fruits and flowers in equal measure. On his later return to Dale, Bilbo had even brought a little pocket-sized book and pencil to jot down the names of Beorn’s flowers in, in the hope that he could somehow give the information to Frodo or perhaps convince the Rivendell Elves that they needed to plant more than whimsical trees and green-leaved plants.
He’d been quite devastated to learn that Beorn had passed away some years before, and though his son and the rest of the Beornings had taken lovely care of his gardens, they hadn’t been the same. Then, Bilbo had felt awful that he was worrying about flowers and gardening upon hearing such news, and awful that he hadn’t ever written Beorn after their journey, so sure that one way or another he would see him again.
But then again, Beorn would likely have fallen in the War of the Ring, and Bilbo would have lost another friend anyhow.
He shook his head. No more of that. He blew the tangled locks from his face.
Each night they sat around a crackling campfire, and Bilbo told his stories, and the dwarves all sang songs, and they would patch clothes and sharpen blades for the day to come with their heads propped against each other’s legs, or a log, or the ground. Gandalf sat on the outskirts of the group and smoked his pipe with an unchanging expression of serene but sharp watchfulness.
He seemed to do that a lot, quite content to sit back and let the rumbling chatter of thirteen dwarves and one hobbit wash over him, only interjecting when one of them asked him a question, or they needed steering or saving. Bilbo was glad for the ease in his demeanour, for he was sure that Gandalf would have picked up on the true extent of his oddities if he was paying any closer attention.
Bilbo remembered a hardened wizard, weary and worn from the long years of the Third Age and the trials and tribulations it took to close them. He liked being able to see again a Gandalf who fell asleep against the trunks of trees with his hat over his face.
One night several of them went around and spoke fondly about their partners, telling Bilbo with such vividness about the homes they’d left behind and the little ways each of them had found their loved ones. Bombur asked Bilbo if he had anybody back at home, and Bilbo dropped his eyes and politely answered that no, he didn’t, that most of the hobbits in the Shire thought he was strange, and that truthfully he had never really been looking for any love he had not found already. He pretended very stubbornly that he could not see Balin watching him intently through the spirals of smoke floating upward.
To Bilbo’s complete and utter surprise, it was Thorin that spoke next.
“When our maker carved us from the mountains,” he said softly, “he split each of us in two, that we may be drawn back to our other half and become one heart in the stone again.” He seemed distant as he spoke, detached, like he could not feel any of the emotion his words evoked. Like it was all but foreign to him.
A few of the others echoed what he’d said, a chorus of soft ayes floating about the camp, like Thorin had said something heavier than Bilbo could tangibly feel. He kept on watching Thorin’s darkened face in the shadows.
“It is what we are told, when we are children, but I have never felt the pull the way others have described it to me. I do not think I was ever intended for it. I have been given responsibility instead.”
If others had been watching, they might have wondered whether the dwarf quite believed the words he’d spoken, when they saw the way the hobbit angled his body toward Thorin’s, their figures outlined in charcoal against the glow of the fire, their silhouettes bowed unconsciously and ever so slightly towards each other.
Others, perhaps, might have noticed that the hobbit’s body made gentle points of contact with the dwarf, at their hip-and-knee, at the brush of their shirts, chainmail catching on worn cloth, at the ends of Thorin’s hair and the top of Bilbo’s arm, dark threads kissing lightly at brown skin loved by sun. They might have noticed, even, that the dwarf had tilted his head ever so slightly downward, and that his eyes were resting unreadably on the line of the hobbit’s face, and his nose cutting bluntly against the darkness, his lips quirked in a soft smile and his hair hanging in his eyes.
The skyline was indigo and orange and deep hazel-pink, and it was like someone had upturned pots of syrupy-soft paint onto everyone’s heads, and still Bilbo and Thorin watched the fire flicker and let their gently mingling shadows cast into the colour behind them.
It was the last light of dusk the next day when Bilbo spotted the cottage in the distance, and around it, the fields of flowers in every colour imaginable.
They’d approached from behind, and Bilbo was sure only he and Gandalf had seen the intimidating figure hacking at the wood in the front garden, for they knew what to look for. The axe Beorn held was so large it made a great swooping noise through the air as he brought it downwards and split the trunk in two. Then he stepped back with one foot, lifted his head, and turned very suddenly to look them dead in the eye, like he’d heard them on the wind.
The sheer size of him was so intimidating Bilbo had to swallow and pull his shoulders up about him, even when he knew Beorn as a friend and not a danger.
“Good morning!” Gandalf said jovially, no tinge of apprehension or worry in his voice, though Bilbo knew it was very present in both of their minds. He lowered his head just slightly, and Bilbo followed suit by bending his back at far too deep an angle than was probably healthy for his body even at this age.
“Who are you,” said Beorn, in that booming voice, like the boughs of trees crashing down around them, “and what do you want?”
“I am Gandalf the Grey, kindred of Radagast the Brown of Rhosgobel, whom you know, I believe. I am counted as one of the Wise,” Gandalf said. Beorn’s mighty expression tweaked into one of shrewdness.
“A wizard, you say? And you have brought a rabbit with you!”
Oh, for heaven’s sake.
“We have come seeking shelter after a spot of bad luck in the mountains. We were ambushed by the goblins who dwell there, and our party is in need of rest and recuperation before we journey onward to the Long Lake.”
“Your party?” Beorn said, immediately suspicious, and here we go, Bilbo thought with a grimace, remembering the tedious way Gandalf had revealed them all, one after the other. Beorn’s incredibly bushy brows had already risen halfway up his forehead. “I do not call two a party, wizard.”
Bilbo watched Gandalf assemble his wrinkled, ageless features into an appropriately abashed expression, tilting the brim of his hat just so.
“I did not want to startle you with so many companions all at once and overextend your hospitality, but we -”
“Dwarves!” Bilbo blurted in a rising panic.
Gandalf and Beorn both peered down at him with mirrored expressions of curiosity, though Gandalf’s was far too eager, and Beorn’s far too hostile.
Bilbo decided that cursing under his breath about his blunder was going to be rather useless, so he didn’t bother. He’d dug the grave, and now he would simply have to lie in it.
“There are dwarves, accompanying us,” Bilbo said. “Thirteen of them, you should know, no point beating around the bush about it, and of course we’ve heard that you don’t like dwarves all too well, and you’re probably quite right to be wary of unfamiliar folk around these parts, I should think, but they are kind dwarves, and I rather think they might surprise you!”
Beorn did not even acknowledge a single word Bilbo had said.
“He is not a rabbit at all,” he said, immediately turning towards Gandalf, his voice quite even-tempered for one so easy to aggravate the way Bilbo just had. “He is too chattery. A squirrel.”
Bilbo bit the bottom of his lip quite hard, urging himself not to roll his eyes. It really was becoming a terrible habit.
“I am not a squirrel, Master Beorn, I am a hobbit, and I have been hired for a most important task, but we’ve run into some trouble on the way, and I would like it if my friends were safe for a day or two, if you please. I promise you they will be on their best behaviour.”
Beorn bent at the knee and knelt down closer to Bilbo, so his enormity was more apparent, and Bilbo’s lack of even more so.
“You are a very long way from home, little halfling. Why do you travel with a band of dwarves?”
“Quite right, my dear fellow. I think it is only fair that our burglar should tell you the story,” Gandalf said, immediately putting Bilbo on the spot, no doubt in retaliation, and only glancing down at him with a cryptic smile when Bilbo looked upwards in betrayal.
And so he began, using every bit of his wits, and the traces he could remember of Gandalf’s tale the first time around, and what little skill he still remembered from when he was young and Belladonna had told him stories of all her days out in the wide world beyond. He told Beorn of trees miles tall, towering in the gully with goblins all around like a ring of terror closing in. He told of wargs with pink-stained teeth like knife blades, and the frantic dash from the front door of the caves all the way to the cliffside, and the last hope of the eagles coming for them like a beacon in the night.
By the end of it all, he was quite out of breath and his voice was sore. He watched Beorn mouth at a pipe clasped between his large fingers, leaning back against several bales of hay and eyeing them both with renewed interest.
“Your tale is a grand one, even if there might be untruth in it, and I am glad of your courage against those foul goblins in the mountains. I do not like them. I will let you stay.”
The following morning brought spaces next to him amongst the hay that were body-warm and smelt like straw, and a bleary-eyed Bilbo tottering into the larger room to find his dwarves strewn about the place, the table laden with thickly dripping honey-cakes and warm white bread and fresh fruit like rubies in large wooden bowls. The tea leaves Beorn had in jars lining the walls were loose and leafy-green, not like any sort of tea Bilbo had tasted before, and they left a sagey sweetness floating in his mouth.
(The gargantuan size of the house made Bilbo realise how utterly strange it had been to stay somewhere made for his own size, that single day he’d spent back in Bag End. He’d been living for far too long amongst Big Folk. Even the staggering enormity of the Lonely Mountain didn’t seem so intimidating anymore, though Bilbo was sure he’d change his tune once he was face to face with the dragon living inside again.)
Gandalf disappeared for much of that first day, of course, as did Beorn, which was probably fortunate for everyone in their Company who was not Bilbo, since that way they would not be able to see the disgruntled expression Beorn had been wearing since the dwarves had entered his house. The rest of them spent most of it lazing around, resting aches and knuckling at knots in their backs from twinged muscles. Poor Oin was rushing around all day with herbs clasped in his hands, now that they had time to spare and a place to heal for a little while before the journey had to carry on.
Bilbo mostly spent his time, and, indeed, the few days after that, in the meadows surrounding Beorn’s house. The green plains and heatherfields stretched impossibly on for miles, unbroken by rolling hills or streams like the ones of his home country.
He’d forgotten how big the bees were.
A few times, Bofur or Kili or Ori wandered outside and visited him for a chat, and Bilbo spent quite a lovely afternoon walking Bifur through the thickets of flowers and teaching him the meanings of each and every one. Bifur had been delighted to discover that not only did each flower tell them something different, but that the colours of flowers told different stories, too. He had been utterly taken by all the yellows in every variety of rose and pansy, and he and Bilbo had picked yellow carnations in Beorn’s garden to give to all the other dwarves as a token of strengthened friendship, to much cheer and gratitude.
He lived within the promising smell of rain, welcome now in the fading of summer rather than the dreary trudging through mud and muck they’d struggled through back in the West. The gentle golden showers that lit the morning in fragments of sunlight reminded Bilbo of the Shire of his childhood, and of easy moments with his mother in their garden, touching at the dewdrops that rested on every leaf in wonder and listening to her spin tales of faeries living in mushrooms and acorns while holding her hand in his fingers.
One morning, he’d even woken up to Thorin Oakenshield peering down at him from where he was standing above.
“What on earth are you doing? It's very odd to watch someone while they’re asleep, you know.”
“You had your mouth open,” Thorin said. He seemed inquisitive. Bilbo bristled.
“And you’re the picture of serenity when all your defences are down, are you?”
“Fili and Kili wanted to put things in it.”
“Oh, that’s -”
But most of the time, Bilbo was alone in the sun, the dew cool under his feet and his eyes closed to the warm air. It felt like years were falling off his shoulders.
He could not explain what drew him so dearly to the flowers and the breeze, except that it felt like he was standing among friends. His friends in the house, and his solace in the flowers that had been a comfort where there’d been nothing else, and the love that had blossomed in his chest so long ago and bloomed still every day.
There were many happy moments in Bilbo’s long life where he had stopped in the thick of them and realised that they would be gone far too soon, that they would fade from present tense to past tense, like fingering through a journal and touching at the worn pages with a bittersweet smile. The night he’d left Frodo and the Shire had been like that, and he’d felt it deeply, the knowledge that their strange little semblance of a family would become something that had once been rather than something that still was. It was something he had only become conscious of after the first journey, when he hadn’t realised the importance of every tiny moment with the thirteen of them, or the three of them, or the one that flickered in his heart like gentle trees in the breeze.
It was very slowly dawning on Bilbo that he didn’t have to exist on only memories anymore.
(Unbeknownst to Bilbo, there was a dwarf that would sometimes sit on the steps of the house, leaning against the bannister and silently watching the little figure far away in the fields. He was quite perplexed by the hobbit, and the way he would stand utterly still for hours, just breathing, hearing the wind whisper and the bees buzz.
It was very probable that Thorin Oakenshield did not know what to make of Bilbo Baggins, especially after he’d finally succumbed enough and let down his guard. He was a curious creature, and Thorin almost felt compelled to study him, wondering what in the world it was he could be doing out there amongst the grass and sky.)
It was on one such occasion when Bilbo Baggins was standing in a meadow of deep pinks and pale blues and greens and dazzling oranges, eyes closed, the content smile he always seemed to wear resting on his face.
Nearby, a dwarf cloaked in furs and mail and royal blue slowly made his way up to the hobbit, paying close attention so as to not disturb him, so peaceful did he look among the amber-lit blossoms blowing gently in the wind.
As the dwarf watched, a lone tear slipped down Bilbo’s cheek, and though he had not spoken, the hobbit sensed him anyway.
“It isn’t allergies.”
He did not turn around, but brought his hand up to wipe at his cheek and nose before letting it drop again.
“I was just - thinking,” the hobbit said. “I had a beautiful garden, back at home, and sometimes I miss it very much.”
“I remember.”
Bilbo’s eyes flickered open and focused on Thorin, and the ends of his hair were blowing gently in the breeze, and his eyes must have seemed an even richer brown, somehow, in the late afternoon sun. Thorin Oakenshield continued, more slowly.
“You told Fili and Kili of it once. I remember.”
“I didn’t realise you were listening.”
Bilbo Baggins bent at the waist, bringing his face closer to the rows of colour and the pollen dust spiralling up from them, so slowly it was like they were suspended in water. His entire body seemed to soften as the dwarf watched, and all the lines in his shoulders and face disappeared.
“Yes, well, the flowers are simply reminding me of it, somehow. Do you know what it is any of them are for? ” He turned to look inquisitively at Thorin, who shook his head slowly.
“Not many dwarves deal with plants,” he said, angling his head a little so he was facing away from the glare of sunlight. “Oin is one of the few I have known who do, and he works mainly with medicinal herbs, not with plants grown for beauty. I... suppose not many of my people ever stop to see the beauty in living things.”
Bilbo Baggins let his mouth tug upward, looking up at the face now cast in cool shadow, the eyes washed out in grey and angled down to him.
“Oh, I don’t know. I think that jewels and precious stones are living things, in their own way,” he said. “They’re shaped by the world, the same way rivers and hills are.”
“I would not think you had seen many beautiful stones in the Shire.”
The hobbit closed his eyes. “Well, there’s always my imagination.”
He brushed his fingers gently up the stem of a flowerbud, till he was cupping the petals in his palm.
“They’re tulips.” He spoke softly, and there was a small smile on his face, and Thorin looked away, squinting out at the horizon in the distance instead. “I used to love tulips, when I was a lad. They mean passionate and romantic love, and some say they symbolise love that is maddening, all-consuming. I would run all around the little hills and gullies and pretend that I was in a storybook, and that someone was going to fall madly in love with me after I saved them from dragons and trolls.”
That soft smile hadn’t moved from Bilbo’s face, and the warmth of the sunset flecked in his hair and made his eyes glow as he rose to his feet. “Sometimes my dear dad would say that I was being completely silly, and that love should mean you have your head set on your shoulders properly and you don’t go batty when you look at them, or they look at you. But my mother thought he was full of tosh, and they were more in love than anyone I knew.” He smiled wider. “Ah, but Bilbo, she would say, if you are not a little mad about your dear heart when you find them, then what is the use of anything at all? She used to gift him tulips, red ones, just to make him laugh.”
“She sounds charming.”
“She was friends with Gandalf.”
Thorin cut his eyes to the side at once, and Bilbo laughed.
“Yes, I know. It is a wonder I took so much convincing to accompany you on this quest when I was raised by Belladonna Took.”
Thorin kept looking at him. “I do not recall you taking much convincing at all,” he said quietly.
Bilbo blinked, and his eyes softened. He was beginning to get the look he got when things far away were whirling gently through his mind, and he became lost in them.
“No. No, I suppose I did not, in the end.” He looked away, squinting into the distance at the setting sun and the gold film it created over everything they could see. “I must have known that I would need to follow you, Thorin Oakenshield.”
Thorin’s gaze dropped to the field of flowers before them, looking very intently at the red tulips by his knees. His face was contemplative. He furrowed his brow.
“Before the dragon came,” he said, lowly, hesitantly, “there were flowers that grew around the Mountain. Snapdragons. My sister loved them, and she used to make us pick them with her.” He paused. “I remember the way that they smelled.”
This made Bilbo laugh and tilt his head upward, though his eyes had somehow become inexplicably sad.
“Snapdragons were one of the flowers in my garden.”
Snapdragons for strength, grace and power, for they grew in barren and rocky places when no other life would, and nothing had ever reminded him of Thorin Oakenshield so much.
He closed his eyes again. Anyone watching the two would have noticed the way Thorin’s eyes passed over the freckles on Bilbo’s nose, sure that there had been less the last time he’d looked, the flecks dark against his brown skin. They ran down the wide slope of it to spread outwards along his cheeks, and spanned further out across his forehead and down around his mouth and chin.
“Thorin,” Bilbo said finally, after neither of them had spoken for more than a couple of moments, “why did you come out here?”
The dwarf was quiet, for a moment, perhaps because he did not have the answer himself, perhaps because to speak too soon would disturb the silence.
“You have come out here each day since we arrived,” he settled on, watching Bilbo out of the corner of his eye. “I wished to know why. I wished to… atone for my actions, Master Baggins.”
“Thorin, I have not taken your wariness of me personally. Please don’t feel guilty. I am not upset, and you don’t need to try and make nice with me over it.”
At that, however, a touch of the old anger crept into Thorin’s face.
“I would not speak to you out of obligation, or for some shallow reason you seem to think I am capable of,” the dwarf said, his voice like embers, his gaze unbreaking. “You are part of our Company. You saved my life. And somehow, you are more steadfast and loyal than even I feel leading my own people.” He seemed to steady himself, watching the grassblades in the breeze beyond Bilbo for a moment before his eyes focused on the hobbit again. “You seem as though you have a lot to teach people, Master Baggins, and I would like to learn.”
(It could be said, some might suggest, that the dwarf was starting to feel some sort of something about the hobbit. Kinship, perhaps, or rare, true friendship he had never thought to search for beyond the borders of his own kind, for no one had ever shown it to him in return. Awareness, certainly. A presence of the hobbit in his mind where he hadn’t been before, of where he stood in the group and where he was at Thorin’s side, bare-footed, tousle-haired, and as chirpily cross as ever. A Bilbo-Baggins-shaped thought in his slow breaths and quiet contemplation, and an unfurling in his chest.)
So long living in Elven halls of clear cold air with streams and flowers and birds all around had left Bilbo very ill-prepared for their journey into Mirkwood, and once they’d gone in, his head immediately began to swim.
They had left Beorn’s cottage at first light, each armed to the teeth with stockpiles of food and water, as much as Bilbo had been able to force them all to carry, and they’d bid farewell to Gandalf at the border; an ordeal that had been much less dramatic with two voices rather than one reassuring them all that they would be fine.
(Bilbo was very sorry to see Beorn and his honey-cakes go, and he was sure not a few of the dwarves were feeling similarly downtrodden about it, but he’d auspiciously asked his old friend for the recipe, and he was planning a mighty surprise for them once this whole mess was over and done with.)
The last time he’d travelled through the forest, in the later days of his life, the air had been clean and fresh through the trees, and the memories of eyes in the dark and horrors in the shadows had faded out like gentle running water through his fingers. It made going back into the endarkened forest a great deal harder than it had been then.
Bilbo tried his hardest to keep the cheer of the Company up, knowing they would have no fires and no warmth and nowhere that was quite safe for some time, and it did work for a little while. He told them stories and jokes, and he asked each of them about all the little parts of their lives, and he threw knives at the moss-covered ground with Nori because they were both wary of throwing them at the trees and accidentally angering whatever was lurking behind or within. And Bilbo had never heard tell of it, so he was sure he was acting quite paranoid, but he felt that the trees in this forest were alive, too, and he would not make himself an enemy of them.
He watched Bifur and Bofur whittle down twigs and old bits of branch into tiny wooden toys, delicate and lovely resting in their hands, and he resolved to ask them for help on a birthday present once Frodo was born in this lifetime. He lent Ori his pencils when Ori dropped his own on the forest floor and a prowling limb crept out from below a tree root and snatched them away.
But the darkness ate away at them slowly, and Bilbo had to work harder and harder to keep their hearts light and looking ahead, to the peak of the Lonely Mountain so far in the distance. It was no form of darkness they were used to, either; dwarves were borne of the safety and sturdy endurance of stone and rock, and they felt at home deep beneath the earth, but this darkness was thick and muggy in their throats and wet on their breaths, and the twisting canopy of the trees that reached out with creeping fingers above them made it feel as though they’d been trapped below the surface of a lake. Every day, eyes would gather in the gloom and watch them, faint yellow and grinning menacingly at their camp all huddled together in fear. They did not dare light a single fire or use a single flint, and they lived on all the additional bread and nuts Bilbo had been able to beg off Beorn.
The air became stagnant and foul, and all the while it grew darker and darker, as if they were being boiled in a pot of soup and had started to drown. The trees shuddered all around them. It was as though the darkness in the ruins of Dol Guldur was slithering up through the forest, and they could do nothing but trudge onward, stumbling and choking on the tepid air like a black breath all around. They slept in piles huddled up against each other, hiding from the cold and the dark and using their own bodies for what little safety and warmth they could find.
Every now and again they would see traces of spiderweb skirting the path, dewy against the damp leaves coating the floor and twining through all the tree roots like a net cast over everything. Bilbo would hurriedly lead them as close to the other side of the path as he dared when this happened, and the few strange or questioning looks he got did not worry him nearly as much as the thought of those hulking black bodies and limbs and eyes, everywhere.
He knew his Sting could handle them, and that if he must, he would brave the spiders as valiantly as he had before, but the thought of legs crawling all over had plagued his dreams long after he had set foot in Bag End again, and the memory of Sam and Frodo’s hushed whispers of nightmares that lurked in the high passes of Mordor were still fresh and painful in his mind.
Sometimes Bilbo glumly wondered why he couldn’t have woken up a little closer to the Mountain, in a nice cosy bed in Laketown, perhaps, or even inside of a barrel floating down a river. And then he would sit under the black canopy with nothing but looming shadows all around, and think about the darkest places of the world, ones he could scarcely imagine and yet ones his loved ones had had to brave, and he would muster up the courage to keep putting one foot in front of the other.
“Do you remember the story I told months ago around the fire, the one about the Three Hunters?” Bilbo asked, yawning, leant backwards against the damp log he was resting on.
“How could we forget, Bilbo?” Bofur called back.
“Indeed,” Balin said, smiling fondly at Bilbo from where he was sitting nearby. “The marvel of hobbits.”
“That traitorous dwarf,” Kili said feistily. “What I wouldn’t do to get my hands on him and give him a good shake!”
“What about the Three Hunters?” Thorin asked. He was sitting further along Bilbo’s log, near Fili.
“Well, I was thinking about whether there were any other songs of mine I could teach you all, perhaps once we’re out of here. The Man in that story was descended from the High Kings of old, and I made up a song for him.”
He looked up at them all blinking at him, and only when Thorin extended his hand out in a silent gesture to begin did he belatedly realise it was in anticipation. He cleared his throat.
“All that is gold does not glitter
Not all those who wander are lost,
The old that is strong does not wither
Deep roots are not reached by the frost
From the ashes a fire shall be woken
A light from the shadows shall spring,
Renewed shall be Blade that was Broken
The crownless again shall be king.”
The dwarves all applauded, but quietly, still wary of things following them in the woods. “That was beautiful, laddie,” Balin said, and he got quite a few noises of approval.
“It was a good story, and well-told,” Thorin agreed, and Bilbo very carefully did not think about what a contrast it was between how he’d reacted upon hearing the story the first time, and he very carefully did not let the tips of his ears turn pink. For a small second, he was rather thankful it was so dark in this dreadful, nasty forest.
“Oh, it’s nothing special,” Bilbo said, waving Thorin away. “I’ve been tinkering with it for years.”
“Why did you choose an Elf and a dwarf?” Fili asked, from Thorin’s other side. Both of them were watching him, their silhouettes so similar; Fili’s gaze curious and Thorin’s heavy as always. Bilbo decided to ignore the latter for the moment.
“I think that in times of peril,” he said, “old hatreds will always be cast aside, and I think there are more important things in the world than spite from long ago.”
“You sound like the wizard,” Thorin said gruffly. Bilbo laughed in delight.
Thorin seemed to peer at him through the gloom, and it was infuriating how inscrutable he was. He was watching Bilbo calmly, his eyes trained steadily on Bilbo’s, though sometimes they would fall to the sides of his face or flit upwards whenever Bilbo blew a lock of hair out of his eyes. The intensity of his stare had not faded through time, and Bilbo occasionally got the feeling that Thorin was watching on long after Bilbo lost the courage to hold his gaze.
“You knew we would not take so kindly to it,” he said. Bilbo scoffed, though he meant it good-naturedly.
“Well, then, it’s good that I have a backbone, isn’t it?”
The sides of Thorin’s mouth quirked upward slightly, and Bilbo looked away.
So strange, how such a small smile could change a whole face so completely, just the smallest tug at the corner of the lips. So strange how he’d remembered every detail of it so perfectly, and yet even still it managed to capture his breath.
“Indeed,” Thorin was saying, a dash of humour in his voice. “They might start to call you Bilbo Braveheart, if you’re not careful.”
Bilbo chuckled, feeling his face warm and cursing his ridiculous Baggins genes for granting him the gift of being perpetually flustered. Belladonna Took would be ashamed of him, crumbling completely at the first sight of any affection at all. He must chase you into the hills, Bilbo!
He’s not going to be chasing me anywhere, Ma, except out of his mountain very soon whilst brandishing a sword.
“I’m glad you think so now,” Bilbo said.
Thorin looked at him sharply. “What?”
“Well, when you hated me -”
“I didn’t hate you.”
Bilbo blinked at Thorin, his face only half-visible in the overgrown darkness. Thorin swallowed softly, and spoke again.
“I did not hate you, Master Baggins. I didn’t… understand you. You were not at all what I expected.” He seemed to look up at Bilbo then, though Bilbo couldn’t be sure. His head had not moved.
“You were much kinder. It unsettled me. And I did not listen when you told us you were capable.”
His mouth made a strange movement sort of akin to a smirk, more a flash of teeth in the dark, really, and he turned to the side to look through the shadowy trees. “I know now what a blunder that was. You’ve never let any of us forget it, have you, Bilbo?”
Bilbo felt equal parts affronted and stupidly pleased.
They kept on the path. Bilbo had no idea how far in they were. To his memory the journey had only taken a matter of days the first time, but the sprawling darkness was so thick in their eyes and noses and mouths that all his thoughts of Mirkwood dragged on and on, until he wasn’t sure whether they were even taking the right path at all, and started to feel sure they must have been inside for months on end.
He wondered if he should climb up into the treetops once more, but all of them were so very tired, and he was terrified that he would wake the spiders by touching their webs without meaning to.
The darkness was suffocating. It almost felt as though the cold silence of the leaves above were dripping down around their necks, along their shoulders and in their eyes so their heads became heavier with it. The exhaustion was potent, and all of them could feel it creeping into their conversations with more and more sharpness.
“This forest is not well.”
They were marching in a line, in a pack, the bags strapped to their backs now all but empty. It was Bilbo who had spoken, his quiet voice going unheard by most of them in the muggy nothingness. He cleared his throat and called out again. “We have to ration our food better, or we are going to starve.”
A few of them looked around, or hesitated, looking back at the path ahead, but Thorin trudged on, not looking down at Bilbo or even making any acknowledgement of the fact he had spoken for a long moment until he gruffly replied, “We are already starving.”
His browbone was so deeply bent into a frown that it looked as though he were perpetually carrying around boulders that hung from his forehead. The line between his eyebrows was carved like a scar.
Bilbo kept on stubbornly. “I know that, but this forest is bigger than you think, and the road is long. It is better to conserve what we have.”
“How can you know that?”
“Because I read, Thorin,” Bilbo said, bristling immediately. His already questionable temper had shortened to a nub in this forest.
“There is much more to embarking on a quest than reading books, Master Baggins,” Thorin said in that low, unwavering voice of his. “Your resolve is admirable, but we cannot afford to sacrifice any more than we have already. We are weak enough as it is.”
“I’m hungry, too! But I would rather be hungry now and alive later, than starved and lost in the woods until I crumble away into dust. We aren’t yet close enough to the edge.”
Bilbo marched faster, right up to Thorin and in front of him before whirling himself around so Thorin had no choice but to stop.
“It is the forest that’s draining us,” Bilbo insisted, now wholly aggravated. “There is a shadow upon it, which you well heard Gandalf and Beorn say, too, so don’t you frown at me with those irritating eyebrows of yours!”
“You have never even seen this forest before, much less travelled through it -”
“All the more reason to rely upon my common sense! You can’t think you know everything just because you lived in the North once upon a time, you stubborn -”
A heavy object thwacked against Bilbo’s arm, and he cried out, startled. Both his and Thorin’s heads whipped around to see Fili watching them a little guiltily, arm aloft, but with a determined frown on his face.
“Sorry, Bilbo, that was intended for my uncle, but - will you two give up? You are both being much too loud, and we aren’t safe here. You’re attracting danger!”
Bilbo cleared his throat at once and shuffled away from Thorin, embarrassed. Thorin scowled at Fili. Every one of them had stopped walking, now, and were gathered in a cluttered little circle in front of the guilty party. They all looked exhausted down to their very bones, and Bilbo swallowed down the rush of guilt it brought to fix his frown on the vexatious creature to his right.
“If Bilbo thinks we should ration, then we should ration,” Nori said.
“Ration what? We are living on scraps as it is,” growled Dwalin, crossing his arms and turning his gaze to their leader. The others all followed suit.
Thorin’s expression was not angered, but he held his body very still, as though he was trying to restrain himself, or keep some semblance of calm. His eyes hadn’t strayed from Bilbo’s, who shot back a triumphant glare and tried not to push out his jaw too much in satisfaction.
“Thorin,” Balin said, somewhat placatingly, “we can replenish when we are safely out of these woods, fill our bellies all we want, but Bilbo is right. We are of no use to anyone if we run out of supplies before we reach safety. We will fade away into nothing.”
Thorin watched Balin with an utterly unreadable gaze, and then looked back at Bilbo standing impudently in front of him. They stared each other down. Bilbo wished he could have been standing on an incline so he could have given Thorin a good and proper eyeing, but he’d made do so far.
“Trust me,” he said, never letting his eyes move from Thorin’s face.
Thorin was very still for several moments. “Very well,” he said quietly, eyes thunderous, clearly restraining himself, watching Bilbo with the weight of those boulders on his brow. “I will trust you.”
Bilbo took a step back, nodding once and huffing out an exasperated sigh. Good, then. At least he was finally listening to some outside opinion instead of simply charging on like a mad bull.
“I trust your books tell you what to do when we’ve lost the path, Master Baggins?”
Oh, that was it. And really, he’d had quite enough of dwarvish tempers in his first lifetime.
“Oh, you’re one hundred and ninety-five, Thorin,” Bilbo snapped. “Stop acting like a fauntling without his breakfasts.”
“Breakfast,” Dwalin of all people corrected automatically, before frowning and looking to Bilbo like he was aggravated Bilbo had snuck his way into his train of thought.
“Breakfasts. We have two in the Shire.”
Thorin’s eyes widened, just barely, and Bilbo knew him well enough to know this was an expression of alarm.
“Have we not been feeding you properly?” someone cried from across the opposite side of the group. Bilbo thought it might have been Ori.
It was so bizarre and out of place in the festering darkness and the near-argument they’d all found themselves in that Bilbo laughed, loudly, throwing back his head and chuckling towards the weak slants of light fingering their way through the treetops. It sounded unnatural in the ringing quiet of the forest.
“I am quite all right, don’t worry. I make do with what we all have." He smiled at them all. “And second breakfast is more for the littluns anyway, while they’re young and still growing. I’d make do with nothing but a cup of tea every now and again, if we had any to spare.” He crushed a handful of dampened leaves under his toes until they flaked into pieces, mourning briefly the loss of a good brew of tea leaves, or better yet, a solid batch of pipeweed.
“You are not starving me, Thorin. I’m tougher than nails, little old me.”
“Yes," Thorin said, the fight all but gone from the frame of his body, "I’m beginning to think you are.”
They began to walk again. After some silence, Thorin said, “I had not realised that I had told you my age.” When Bilbo hummed and looked up at him, the dwarf was already watching him in guarded curiosity.
“Oh -" well, then "- you hear things, here and there, you know. You didn’t think I spent all that time chatting with the entire Company just to twiddle our thumbs and talk about different types of grass, did you?”
“How old are you then, Bilbo?” piped up Bofur, and Bilbo scratched at his throat absent-mindedly as he walked, debating on his answer for a moment.
“Well, I suppose I am fifty, and very nearly fifty-one.”
Before the dwarves could do much more than blanch at his words, their eyes wide in identical expressions of shock, Bilbo held up his arms to placate them.
“Please don’t all lose your heads, you silly things! Hobbits live for much less time than dwarves. I am well into adulthood, and well on my way to my greying years, if you must know. But the oldest hobbit that ever was lived to be one hundred and thirty-two, and he was a Baggins.”
He tried very hard not to sound too pleased with himself. It really was one of his proudest achievements, if Bilbo was being honest.
(Which of course, he was not.)
Perhaps the worst of the long, dragging days in the chasm of the forest was its utter stagnancy. Each day was the same, and each the same as the nights. They had no way of knowing whether it was dawn or dusk or the smallest hours of the morning for certain. The trek became one single suffocating pull into the darkness; no reprieve, and no replenishing.
“I suppose I should simply learn to deal with it, shouldn’t I, my lad?”
There was no wind to carry his words to Frodo, and so Bilbo would have to hope that they’d find their way on the leaves. He hoped they wouldn’t curdle with sickness the way the forest had. He didn’t want Frodo to worry about him.
He was sat a small ways away from the rest already dozing, staring down the dark, face tilted upwards to give his whispers the best chance of finding their way.
“I can’t help but think of you and Sam, out there in the cold, up in the mountains with the wind battering you.” He looked down at his hands, buried again in the remains of leaves, brown like mulch against his fingers. “I’m barely able to imagine it, Frodo. I would have curled up until the wolves found me. I hope you aren’t still plagued with nightmares.”
“You are whispering again,” Thorin’s unmistakable voice said softly behind him.
Bilbo startled and pulled his shoulders up, glancing back to the shadowed figure looming close by. They watched each other for a moment, barely even black shapes in the darkness, before Bilbo looked again out at the unknown void.
“Were you praying?”
The rumble of his voice felt almost like the floor was shaking underneath their feet. Like the air was shaking. Bilbo shook his head lightly and ground his fingers into the soil.
“Not praying. Remembering.” He didn’t mind as much, now, if the others saw him talking to the wind, but to explain it to them was much too heavy an ask.
“You were remembering then, too, weren’t you?” Thorin asked. “In the Misty Mountains.” Bilbo looked over at him and nodded wordlessly.
The silence held for a few more moments, and then: “I am sorry I did not show you empathy.”
There was a crease between Thorin’s brows when Bilbo looked towards him, and his eyes were wide and open in his face. It took Bilbo a moment to recognise it as regret, and the gesture as an apology.
He knew Thorin carried his own dead with him, brother and mother and lost father, and that he understood now the burden Bilbo had shouldered. He wished he could smooth that little crease away with his fingers.
“It’s quite all right, Thorin. I cannot spend all my time thinking over things that have already passed.”
If he told it to himself enough times, one day he might even believe it.
Thorin turned to watch the trees the way Bilbo had been, the fabric of his trousers brushing the skin of Bilbo’s leg.
“We dwarves speak to our dead sometimes, too. We believe that our forefathers are watching over us, and that their guidance will lead us to where we need to go.”
Bilbo’s mouth twisted and he dropped his eyes to the ground. “Well, I don’t know about that,” he said, “but I find talking to the wind more helpful than keeping everything all bottled up inside.”
“Is there somewhere in particular you wish for it to carry your words?”
Bilbo looked down at the darkness in front of them. “If there is, I don’t know if they will find it.”
He turned his head to the side and looked back at their camp not far away. A thin slice of moonlight had cut its way through the canopy and illuminated the pile the Company had haphazardly assorted themselves into, making them all look too still, too eerie for Bilbo’s liking. He watched their breaths, counted them. Tried not to think of Frodo, and of every other person he had ever known who had been lost. He wished with almost a burning ferocity that just once, they could have lit a fire in the forest, given themselves warmth and light and brought cheer amongst all of it.
“Thorin?”
Bilbo turned back to see Thorin looking in the same direction he had been, watching over them, ever his way. He made a quiet noise of acknowledgement, and Bilbo swallowed.
“Do you remember your mother?”
Thorin looked back at him, and Bilbo felt his own expression contort in pity. Thorin’s face looked as though it were being held together by porcelain in the dim light; his eyes were heavy and his mouth thin.
“You were very young when she passed, weren’t you?”
“I remember her,” Thorin said quietly, his voice deep and rasping. He ducked his head, and strands of hair fell forwards to hang around his face. Together they looked down at the forest floor, watching a line of black ants crawl past in the dirt.
“She looked like my brother. She acted like him, too; my sister and I were graced with much more of our father’s bearing.” There was such reverence in the solemn way he spoke that Bilbo could feel how much Thorin missed them as deeply as if the dwarf had wept openly in front of him.
“Did you have siblings, Master Baggins? Do you?” He did not look at Bilbo as he spoke.
“No,” he said quietly, watching Thorin watch the forest move with trepidation. Their breaths felt thick in the silence and the darkness of each leaf and vine congealing above their heads. He wished again that they could be far, far away from Mirkwood. “I have lost family that I love with all my soul, but it was only ever me growing up in my hobbit-hole.”
“Is it that which makes you seem so lonely?”
They looked at each other.
“Not quite, I don’t think,” Bilbo said gently.
Their supplies dwindled, and the fourteen of them continued to portion out what precious little they had, bare sips of water from skins that eventually dried up and nibbles here and there of the blandest nuts they still had left. The hunger was not any easier to bear the second time.
Bilbo let himself bear the brunt of it, trudging on and telling himself that it would soon clear, that continuing on was all they could do while the hunger crept in, and so continue on they must. He kept his head down and his hand clenching gently at his sides, clutching at the strap of his pack with tense, pale fingers like it would somehow anchor him to the ground in case his weakening knees got the better of him.
It was why when, one night amongst their pile of huddled dwarves-and-one-hobbit, he heard a murmured, “There’s a light in the distance,” from Dwalin, he was so awfully, terribly, drastically unprepared.
“Keep your head down”, you complete ninny, well now it’s not going to matter at all whether you held out from starving when you’re all locked up in the dungeons again!
Bilbo was utterly furious with himself, and he pushed himself up from the wet forest floor with the intention of stopping the conversation before it began, staggering a little before he made it upright. But to his horror, Dwalin was already on his feet, one sturdy hand against the bark of a tree as he leant forwards to peer into the gloom at the devilish little ray of light, and others were following him, musing sluggishly about whether they might find food or aid, and how they had better just go check, just in case. They were all moving in a complete daze, endless days in shadow and the lack of food or water eating away at them, and everything seemed to slow down as Dwalin beckoned with his other hand.
“Come on.”
Oh, no. Bilbo hadn’t realised how close they were to the Elves, how close they were to -
How could you have not planned for this? What on Earth did you think was going to happen when we reached the Elves, or god forbid, the spiders?
They were stumbling, then racing, through the strangled tree-roots and the sodden leaves rotting in the darkness, towards that faint, flickering glow.
Bilbo could barely raise his own voice, weak and weary as they all were, and he chased after them uselessly on feet that felt like leaden weights attached to his legs. He called out to them over and over, begging them to stop running, please, it’s not safe, Fili, Oin, Gloin, we have to stay together, you don’t know what that light is! But not one of them turned around.
They were getting closer now, and Bilbo could see the lines of logs in the fire, and the dancing of the light as the Elves twirled round and round. The Company were beginning to reach the edge of the clearing; heads of light and dark hair were receding into the trees, ready to pull the darkness over their eyes, and with a mounting sense of dread, Bilbo pushed himself hard against the dizziness creeping in and threw himself at Thorin.
It wouldn’t ever have worked on a normal day, when the both of them were rested and fed and Thorin had the wits of a warrior about him, but Thorin’s knees buckled under the sudden weight and the two of them went crashing down. He immediately began to thrash around, going for his belt, his boots, the inner pockets of his coat for weapons, but Bilbo clapped a surprisingly strong hand over his mouth and clung to him with all four limbs like a stubborn insect making a home on Thorin’s back. Slowly, he stilled, and Bilbo kept his fingers firm across Thorin’s mouth, and the two of them watched from amongst lichen-sprawled roots as every elven torch was suddenly extinguished and the night went utterly dark.
