Chapter Text
It was some time before either Bilbo or Thorin could see again. The earliest touches of dawn began to push through what little crevices they could find in the dense canopy, and dancing firelight started up again in the far distance, just enough that they could both see there was no trace of any of the other dwarves. The clearing was completely silent; both dwarves and Elves had vanished into thin air.
When they both seemed to have deemed the coast clear, Thorin wrestled his way out of Bilbo’s grip, stumbling to his feet and looking around wildly. There were twigs tangled in his hair. Bilbo could not quite bring himself to point them out.
“Why did you do that, you —”
“Shhh!”
They stared at each other, Thorin looking utterly mutinous, though the effect was rather dulled by all the aforementioned twigs. Bilbo lifted a finger to his mouth and held it there silently, his eyes wide and imploring.
“Where are the others?” Thorin said in a low voice.
“They have been taken by the Elves, and we would have been, too,” Bilbo hissed back. “I didn’t have a choice.”
Thorin muttered darkly in what was definitely Khuzdûl and swung Orcrist through the air, dried-up leaves crushing under the heavy fall of his boots as he paced back and forth in anger. Bilbo shook his head with a scoff and began sneaking through the underbrush, hoping with everything he had he’d remembered the right way to go.
It took him a few moments to realise Thorin had been so caught up in his useless, stony brooding that he hadn't even noticed he’d been quite left behind in the clearing. Bilbo called out to him, and, when there was no response, called out louder in exasperation, already well on the path down to the Elven kingdom.
“Aren’t you coming, then?”
He crept up through the grove, careful of how the trees thinned out the closer they got to the edge of the forest, the red-brown leaves fading out into murky greens that lined the roots buried deep within the earth.
From afar, Bilbo could hear Thorin stomping his way closer, and could not be bothered to even roll his eyes about it, instead hiding himself behind a great beech tree not far from the Elven Gate. The bark beneath his fingers was gnarled, and slowly withering from the sickness that lay over the forest.
(Bilbo understood now that Thranduil Oropherion held great love for the Greenwood and desired greatly to protect it, and that the blackness cast across it from the shadows of Dol Guldur was hurting him and his Elves very deeply. His journey to Dale in later years had been so green and lively in comparison that Bilbo had quite forgotten what Mirkwood had been like in the clutches of the Enemy, and he longed to escape from it as soon as they possibly could.)
Very carefully, he let a sliver of his face peek out to watch the great Gate beyond the bridge just below them, the curls of his hair half-falling in his eyes and his own breath warm against his fingers touching the tree. He could see no sign of the rest of the Company; they’d very likely already been tucked away in their cells below the surface.
Two Elven guards were stationed on either side of the entrance to the kingdom, each bearing long oaken spears and watching the woods cautiously. Bilbo watched them a moment longer, exhaling slowly as if all the air around him had gone completely still, and then turned and tucked himself behind the trunk again, facing Thorin with his back against the wood and his mind whirring.
“Thorin,” he murmured, barely even breathing out the word, for he was all too conscious of the fact Elves had abnormally enhanced hearing and several of them were only a stone’s throw away, “we have no way of breaking them out that will not also get ourselves captured.” He paused for a moment. “You have to make the Elvenking an offering of peace.”
Thorin’s eyes flashed, and his face drew at once into a rather ugly scowl. “You —”
“I know there is tension between your two peoples,” Bilbo interrupted urgently, his voice a whisper in the quiet, “especially with the Mirkwood Elves — believe me, I know — but we have no other choice at the moment. They will not yield. You know they won’t.”
“So,” Thorin said slowly, half of his face still in shadow under the shade of the beech tree, “you would have me walk in there of my own free will?” His tone was wary, dark, leaning into the old brimstone from when they’d known each other less, but his stance and gaze had steadied, and he waited for Bilbo to speak. Bilbo sunk backward with a sigh, feeling his spine press up against the trunk of the tree.
“These Elves keep to themselves," he said slowly. "They are wary of outsiders and protect their own. Do you not also know what that is like?”
Their gazes held, the only sound the distant chorus of the river rushing below, and the blessedly-missed chirping of birds — Bilbo had almost forgotten what they sounded like. “Thranduil is ancient. He is not beyond reason, but he will not respond well to anger from those he perceives as a threat.”
Thorin’s face darkened, the shutters suddenly closing entirely, and he looked to the side, back the way they’d come from the clearing. His jaw was tight.
“I understand… what it is you are trying to do, Master Baggins. I do,” he said, looking back to where Bilbo was pinned like a butterfly, heart tick-ticking away inside his chest in tepid anticipation. “But their King turned from us long ago. I owe him no allegiance, no false niceties. I cannot do what you ask.”
Bilbo exhaled, the front of his hair fluttering, and tried in rather questionable vain to restrain his temper, or think of any other solution he possibly could to Thorin’s almighty stubbornness. Each one of his fingertips alternated between drumming against the trunk of the tree and scrunching at the bottom of his jacket.
“Give me Orcrist,” he said very suddenly. Thorin was still for a moment, and then alight with rage.
“Bilbo,” he growled out, but Bilbo gave him a look of such petulant defiance that he fell silent. He turned from Thorin again to lean forward against the tree, peeking his curly head round the side to gaze down once more at the bridge below them, and after a moment felt Thorin come up to stand beside him.
“I have a plan for if it doesn’t work,” he said, so very quietly, “but it requires a distraction. He will hear what it is you have to say, Thorin. You are a king. And it truly does not matter if you mean one lick of it or not — you can go back to loathing him and his Elves to your heart’s content tomorrow, but they… I cannot sneak in there and get them out myself.”
They looked at each other then, and after a long moment, several long moments, in which Bilbo had almost started wondering whether it would be more prudent to just knock Thorin out and throw him in the river (and whether their fledgling friendship would even withstand such a thing), Thorin bowed his head the slightest bit and asked, “What will you do?”
“You must keep him talking, for as long as you can.” Bilbo said quietly, conscious of where it was they were, conscious of who it was they were. “You must, Thorin. Explain that there has been — a misunderstanding, and that we bear them no ill will. We were passing through. We wish for peace between you and they.” He took a long breath and scrunched his eyes shut for a moment. “You cannot lose your temper. You must try, as best you can. There is more at stake here than a feud with Thranduil.”
He opened his eyes and looked directly into Thorin’s face as he said it, and after a moment, Thorin nodded, expression firm.
“Give me Orcrist, and I will keep it safe for you,” Bilbo said again, holding out a hand. He could see Thorin’s jaw twitching, knew that this request was forcing even Thorin to his utter limits, and pushed on stubbornly.
“Thorin, they will take it from you. It is an Elvish blade, and we have no proof at all that Elrond bid you keep it, and anyway, it is a sign of goodwill that you walk into their kingdom with no weapon on you.”
After a moment of more tedious jaw-twitching, Thorin drew the blade and held the hilt out toward Bilbo, who took it delicately, holding it high in front of his face. The silver shone in the quiet of the forest clearing.
“Keep it safe.”
“I promise.”
It was long, much longer than Sting — almost twice the size if he had to hazard a guess — and the weight of it was such that it made his wrist ache, but Bilbo held it steadily, his shaky exhaled breath misting the flat of the blade. He looked up at Thorin, who was gazing at him with the most peculiar sort of expression all of a sudden, his eyes focused only on Bilbo’s face rather than on the sword and standing utterly still. Bilbo’s eyebrows furrowed.
“What?” he needled.
“It is odd,” Thorin said quietly, his mouth just barely moving. There was no word to describe the strangeness of the expression on his face. “It suits you.”
And then he smiled, a genuine glow in his face and his eyes suddenly alight in the undergrowth.
(It was the first real one in this lifetime, and it made Bilbo think of acorns and hallways and the hair pulled back from Thorin’s face.
His heart ached.)
They slipped out of the clearing soon after that, Orcrist strapped haphazardly to Bilbo’s back beneath his coat and Thorin’s rasp ringing in his ears. He crouched down, moving noiselessly through the brush and never tearing his eyes away as he watched Thorin calmly walk down to the end of the bridge. The Elf-guards moved as if lightning at the first sight of him, and Thorin brought his hands up, arms wide and head bowed in surrender.
“I am the leader of the company of dwarves you hold within your walls,” his booming voice rang out over the roaring river. “I wish to negotiate peacefully with your King.”
One of the Elves lowered her spear and looked upon Thorin with a scrutinising expression, though she held herself with such quiet grace that Bilbo saw Thorin pull back his shoulders and lift his head to meet her dark eyes. They studied each other for a moment, the Elf and the dwarf.
“You bear no ill will?” she said, her voice challenging, and loud over the rushing water below.
“I am not armed,” Thorin replied lowly, and he opened his heavy coat outward to reveal his empty belt.
The Elf turned to exchange looks silently with her other guards, who looked sideways at each other, and then lowered their spears in unison and marched forward through the gargantuan doors of the Gate.
Not one of them noticed the little figure that, when all was clear, darted out from the foliage nearby and tiptoed unnoticed after them, slipping silently through the crack in the door just before it swung closed.
“You would walk into my halls and ask for the release of those I have imprisoned, with nothing in return?”
“They have done nothing wrong. We are weak and starving, and they saw your merriment in the forest and hoped to find safety and shelter. Instead, they have found bars.”
Too harsh. Gentler, dear heart.
The voices of Thranduil and Thorin were so sonorous and clear in the Woodland realm’s winding walkways that Bilbo could hear them quite easily from where he was creeping in the shadows towards the guards’ room. He’d remembered vaguely where it had been, and he’d watched from within a hidden little nook in the wall as the guards had escorted Thorin through the doors and then made their way downwards. He could picture the scene above, the colours of autumn twisting through the branches overhead, the great throne of the Elvenking basking on the raised platform and draped in silks of fine gold. Thorin standing below him on the outcrop, head bowed and cool stoicism painting his face, his hair falling long and bedraggled in his eyes. Bilbo could almost see the working of Thorin’s jaw as he tried to keep his promise to stay calm, to keep his cool and find their way out of here with nothing but his words.
It was a long shot, and Bilbo had his original plan in motion just in case, but safe passage from Mirkwood and an ally in the King of the Woodland realm may yet be able to change the tide of the battle to come. Bilbo had to trust in Thorin that he would do what he could. The Elvenking was calculating, and held great patience where others would be rash. They would have to get the balance exactly right.
“I do not consider ensuring the safety of my people from intruders an unjust action.” Thranduil did not sound angered, but assessing, and his voice flowed like water through the halls, as if rustling green leaves in the wind.
“We have no quarrel with you, Elvenking. We do not threaten your safety.”
In his mind’s eye, Bilbo could see the berries threaded through the long shards of oak that made a circlet atop Thranduil’s head, and how in the autumn half-light underground they would glow a deep plum-red when he moved.
“Three times your people attacked my Elves,” said Thranduil.
“What other path is there that would let us travel east? There is danger all around. Goblins in the north, and darkness in the south. Your road is the only one where passers-by can still hope to live, and if that is displeasing to you, then I would question your judgement, Thranduil.”
Bilbo bit his lip and let his head fall forward against the arched wall nearest him.
Please, Thorin.
He knew Thorin had realised the same thing when he began to speak again, his voice quieter and almost monotonous, ringing out into the curving corridors. Bilbo’s heart was in his throat, and his mouth twitched despite his worry at how deeply Thorin was trying.
“I am sorry for the harm we may have caused your Wood-Elves," Thorin said slowly. "I did not intend it, and I do not wish for distrust to build between us.”
The dark laughter in Thranduil’s voice at that was chilling. “What is your purpose through my wood, nogoth? What brought you into the forest at all?”
Thorin sighed. “I cannot tell you that,” he said.
“I am owed an explanation for why you continually harassed my people in their merrymaking. You ask for safe passage from my realm, and for your folk to walk free, and yet you will not even confess for what purpose you are here?”
Bilbo could almost see him rising from the chair then, the throne, the golden robes descending to the floor and enveloping all but the two of them in a radiant shadow.
“I am demanding payment from you in truth,” Thranduil said simply. Thorin took some time to answer.
“I will give you your jewels, if you will allow me my silence.”
Bilbo started, and the memory flashed by. White gems, of pure starlight.
“And how," the King said, "will you get those?”
Thorin did not speak.
Thranduil’s voice became cold as frosted glass, and his words bit at Bilbo like ice. “You have no way into the Mountain where my jewels are kept, and you will never find one. You cannot give me anything but what I have asked for.”
Still Thorin stayed silent. Bilbo’s fragile little plan was crumbling all around him, but he knew that even if Thorin spoke now to Thranduil like spun sugar rested on his tongue, there was nothing more he could say.
He huffed out a sigh. Once more into the fray, then.
“Time in my cells with the rest of your kin may change your mind. I will keep you safe and secure until you are ready to talk, no matter how long it may take.”
All at once, a struggle of people appeared, a walkway or two below where Bilbo crept, and there he could see that mane of hair as Thorin tried and failed to wrench his forearms from the grip of the Elf-guards. Bilbo began to walk faster, as fast as he could without the pads of his feet making noise as they hit the ground. The sounds of Thorin’s protests were fading away as he ran, as they carried Thorin deeper and deeper.
It had taken him days to find where Thorin had been imprisoned last time, and Bilbo had no guarantee at all that the Elves would lead him to the same cells, or whether Thorin had managed to incur less or more of Thranduil’s wrath this time around. He darted past offshoots of branches and hallways, feet making no sound at all on the oakwood floors, keeping as great a distance as he dared between him and the guards who were handling Thorin none too gently by his arms, but hovering close enough that they stayed in his line of sight. He would not have another chance like this one to pocket the keys without the Ring, and he would not be able to keep them for much longer without alerting anyone to a thief in their halls.
Bilbo reprimanded himself gently. You are a burglar, not a thief, he thought. No need to lower yourself to the level of common criminals. After all, he was rather skilled at the job.
He dashed nimbly down into the guards' room, nabbed the keys, tucked them into his belt and then settled in to wait with ears pricked and eyes alert, until his foot was cramping something rather awful and he was pretty sure his back had molded itself to the shape of the doorway he’d been hiding in. Eventually, however, there were no murmurs of robe or voice; the coast was clear, and Bilbo practically trotted down the swirling staircases, creeping up on where each of his dwarves were caged and frantically hushing the celebration that erupted from every cell he unlocked. It took time, perhaps too much time if one was considering changes in guards and the fact that even a single sighting would unravel his entire cobbled-together plan, but soon they were all following Bilbo in a neat little line, boots clobbering the steps of the Elven halls in a racket that made his hobbitish ears wince, though the path remained mercifully empty.
He had no choice but to follow the trail he only vaguely remembered to the caverns where the deeper dungeons were, wondering how long it would take to find Thorin buried so far underground, hoping with all his might that there were no guards lingering, but it was a shorter journey than it had once been to find Thorin kneeling in the corner of his cell, the air decaying and dusty and the dim light all but gone.
Bilbo held up a hand to the others to wait, and crept slowly forwards, his feet silent against the ground. Thorin’s head was bowed, the curtain of dark hair hanging limply in his face; it hid everything but his eyes watching the floor, unseeing.
(He looked beautiful, even barely visible, even as disheveled as he was locked in an underground cell. It was truly becoming a problem how little Bilbo cared about the state of Thorin's appearance. How easily he could have let himself push the hair back from that stony, striking face.)
Bilbo cleared his throat, and Thorin’s head whipped up.
“You can start feeling sorry for yourself after we’re safely out of here, Master Oakenshield,” he teased softly, keeping his voice quiet in the dark.
“Bilbo?”
Thorin stood, hurrying to the door of the cell and throwing his hands against it. He’d been stripped of his coat, his beautiful blue coat, and he stood much like the others in only the underlayers of his clothes. His hair was still bedraggled from the forest, and his eyes were bright.
“Yes, hello,” Bilbo said, a bit bashfully, pulling the great loop of keys from the notch in his belt and quickly getting to work.
“You have them?” Thorin asked, his voice quiet, a little unbelieving.
Bilbo’s eyes flickered up, not replying, and he watched as Thorin’s travelled from the set of keys to the trail of dwarves waiting at the stairs, all making motions at him that fell somewhere between strained relief and wild celebration. Thorin's eyes fell back onto Bilbo as the lock clicked.
Bilbo lifted a hand and let his fingers close around where Thorin’s own were clutching the bars of the cell tightly, and he leant his forehead against the door. They watched each other silently through the bars, unmoving.
Bilbo’s heart was thudding in his throat, a wild, ceaseless rhythm of get the keys, unlock the doors, into the barrels, get him out, get him out, get him out. The line of Thorin’s entire body was pressed against the bars of the door — his fingers had not moved underneath Bilbo’s; neither had his eyes.
He did not speak, seemingly stunned into silence. Bilbo soon took pity on him.
(In fact, Bilbo could not even begin to put the depth of the expression on Thorin’s face into words, and it did not occur to him in that moment outside the cell in the dark halls of Mirkwood to wonder exactly why that was.)
“Your quest is not over yet, Thorin Oakenshield,” he whispered. He squeezed the bar their fingers were wrapped around once, gently, and then stepped back to pull the door open.
The fourteen of them raced as quietly as they could through the corridors, taking several wrong turns with muttered curses and climbing back up toward the main chamber so they could creep down into the cellars.
Once they had made it to the offshoot they’d have to travel through to reach the belly of the Mirkwood cellars — close enough that he could have thrown a stone through the doorway and heard it bounce — Bilbo ushered them all into an adjacent hidden corridor and then took a steadying breath, leaning against the curved wall and closing his eyes for a moment.
He would have to do this utterly perfectly. To make a slight misstep would mean a life sentence in the deepest depths of the Elvish realm, and he did not have the luck of timing or invisibility on his side this go around, but luck he still had, and so he would make do. He turned to the others with a grimace.
“I am going to get us out of here, I promise you. But you have to hide, and you must trust me.”
The Company all shuffled further into the shadows, watching him with their uneasy, curious eyes, and Bilbo swallowed as he turned toward the doorway, closing his own eyes for a moment.
He knew Elven ways, and knew them well. The last twenty years of his life had been spent among the last lines of the High Elves, and he knew the lull and lilt of their voices, the musical cadence with which they spoke.
The Sindarin rolled off his tongue with almost practised ease.
“The Elvenking requests an audience with the Chief of the Guard and his people.”
The strength of his voice in the cavernous wood-carved hall surprised even Bilbo, and his eyes opened to find a huddle of dwarves, all watching him with axe-sharp eyes and looking quite clearly flabbergasted.
(He could not even blame them. He hadn’t sounded like himself at all; his words had come out with such rich, woody lightness that he might have even been convincing.)
He took a controlled breath and continued.
“The dwarf has chosen to speak rather than stay silent in his cell. The King wishes to discuss this with you. Go now. He is waiting in the upper chamber.”
They watched from the shadows as only a few moments later, the Keeper of the Keys and four others in his guard stepped past them and rose up and out of sight. Bilbo hadn’t the faintest idea where Thranduil was, but as long as the King wasn’t anywhere near here, then all would still be well.
The murmuring started up almost immediately, all of them pressing him with questions and raised eyebrows and disgruntled mumblings and pointed interjections until Bilbo could do nothing but send a helpless look towards Thorin, who called to them once in Khuzdul in a deep voice. The lot of them fell silent at once.
“You speak their tongue?” Dwalin ground out, his voice like a sledgehammer against Bilbo’s increasing headache. His eyes were narrowed.
Oh, we do not have time for this!
“Yes,” Bilbo said with equal parts exasperation and mounting panic, pulling at Dwalin’s elbow and trying to hurry the rest of them through the entrance with frantic eyes, “and I really do not think we have the time for an argument about it just now, so keep it to yourself for a moment, if you please!”
It worked, and the fourteen of them staggered into the guards’ chamber at the mouth of the cellars, blinking around. A great hollowed-out space had been carved so delicately it was as though the walls were made of marble, and tree-roots from the forest far above stretched from floor to ceiling in gigantic twisting patterns, interspersed among the tables and chairs scattered about. Almost all of the lanterns had been doused in a hurry, and Bilbo could see the extinguished smoke wafting up in lazy white tendrils, but the few that had been left lit the room in an unusually cozy ambient light. It reminded Bilbo of his room in Rivendell, almost, the one with the fireplace and the armchair where he had written his silly songs and sung them to a king.
It was clear he’d been convincing enough — there wasn’t a soul in sight, and Bilbo almost felt all of their shoulders sink as one in exhausted relief. Oin and Gloin leant back against a wall and closed their eyes in tandem, seemingly trying to take a nap right then and there. Bilbo’s mouth twitched fondly, and he clapped them both on the shoulder to wake them up, managing a sheepishly apologetic smile.
Fili turned back to the doorway to peer up through the empty corridor.
“Well, that’s lucky,” he said thoughtfully.
There was a single beat where nobody moved, and then thirteen pairs of eyes turned suddenly to focus on Bilbo in unconcealed accusation. He flashed them a bemusedly crooked little smile.
“I have been telling you all, haven’t I?”
“You must speak like a native, if they responded to you in such a way,” said Oin. Bilbo felt his ears flush.
“Yes, well, I am quite good at it.”
“What did you say to them?” Kili asked curiously, staring. Bilbo waved a dismissive hand and carried on walking to the other side of the room.
He guided them all further down the winding oak paths of the lower Woodland realm, and when they came to the door of the cellars, Bilbo repeated his show of Sindarin, this time telling old Galion the butler that the King had requested some of his best wine be brought to his rooms in the upper halls, and ignoring the torn stares of all the dwarves as the unfamiliar words floated off his tongue and through the air.
Galion soon hastened past their hiding-place with two large flasks of Elven wine, and Bilbo felt his mouth twitch imperceptibly at the sight. Mustn’t’ve been taste-testing them today then, Galion, old fellow?
As soon as he was gone, Bilbo rushed them through the wide arching doorway and down the steps to the familiar and not-altogether-welcome sight of a large, warmly lit room lined with nothing but bottles and flasks and, on the far side from where they stood, two dozen empty mead barrels, all neatly lined up against the side of the cellar in rigid rows and with their lids propped open as if enticing the Company to take a dip in the river below. There sat nearest them a lone table and chair, upon which was scattered a plate of half-eaten bread and cheese and a still-filled glass of ruby red wine. The scoundrel! Bilbo thought with a chuckle.
He took a breath, then hopped down the last couple of steps onto the wooden floor and turned with reluctance to face the dwarves all watching him expectantly in their underclothes, still standing in the entranceway. He was thankful they all liked him well enough by now, because he surely was not going to be making any friends in a moment.
“I am really very sorry, but there’s simply no other way I can think to do this. I’m afraid you are going to have to get into the barrels.”
The outcry was instantaneous, and all of the shouting over the top of each other rang around the walls and was surely floating up the stairs to alert any one of their captors as to their plan and whereabouts. Bilbo quickly put his foot down.
“Now, look, there are dozens of guards between here and the Gate, and I cannot simply talk them all away without anyone becoming curious about the disembodied voice echoing through all of the halls, and who it belongs to!” he shouted, and was faced with thirteen abashed-looking faces, though some still grumbled, and some still eyed the barrels with vast amounts of disdain.
Bilbo walked over to the barrel closest to him and wrenched the lid aside to reveal the deceptively spacious interior designed for holding the supplies the Lakemen traded with the Wood-Elves, and pretended he was not trying to convince himself the whole situation was far better than it was.
They had no other choice. They’d done it before. And really, this was one of the easiest things they’d had to do the whole journey, if one looked at it from a certain angle (and one squinted very, very hard). He pointed into the inside of the barrel he’d revealed.
“They will not realise we are gone instantly if we go quietly through the river, and we will very easily wash up at Laketown. It is faster than going by foot, and I’m sure you will all be moaning and groaning by the end of it, but if anyone else seems to have any bright ideas, then I am sure I would love to hear them!”
They fell silent, glancing at each other. Bilbo tried not to feel too smug.
He packed them up neatly into each of their barrels, putting in as much straw and spare cloth as he could find so it would not be as rough a journey as it had been the last time. And all the while, Bilbo was fretting, wondering whether doing as he had before was even wise, and then wondering why he was so eager to change his plan when it had gotten them safely to Laketown in the first place.
He did not know if his distraction had been a good enough ruse, and he did not know if the noise of the lever being pulled would alert the guards from high up in the Mirkwood halls. But he could not think of anything else to do, not when Thorin’s meeting with Thranduil had fallen so cleanly to pieces even after Thorin had tried to stay peaceable. He supposed that he had had to choose between barrels and spiders, and Bilbo knew his Sting was good in a pinch, but he did not want to have to put it to work if he could avoid it. The thought of black legs crawling and creeping and climbing even now still made him shudder.
When footsteps and irritated voices began to echo above them, Bilbo tucked Orcrist inside and then climbed into his own barrel at the end of the pile, sealing the lid shut and breathing out slowly. The action fluttered some of the straw nearest his nose, and he spent the next few moments fighting back a catastrophic sneeze as Elves made their way into the room, grumbling back and forth.
Where has Galion gotten to now?
You can never know with that one. He’s always rushing off somewhere or asleep on his feet.
Or at his table!
Here, see, he hasn’t even sent back these empty barrels yet, and now they’re going to be late!
Bilbo realised that he was again the only one who could understand them, and imagined with a lopsided pang the others all tensed up inside their barrels, hands pressed against the walls and barely taking a breath for fear of Elven ears. Not knowing whether they were about to be caught, or whether the Elves were becoming suspicious; whether they’d even noticed that any of the dwarves were gone. He closed his eyes and hoped they would hold out.
Quite without warning, there was a clanking sound, and a muffled grunt, and then the doorway below them opened so quickly they barely had time to gasp in alarm before the fourteen of them were splashing down into the raging river and away from the captivity of Mirkwood at last.
(And if a couple of the barrels shouted as they dropped, well, the Elves were just going to have to wonder about it in vain until the stars winked out of the sky.)
Bilbo had tried as best he could to pack them all securely, but all of the dwarves were still aching and waterlogged and hungry by the time he peeled back the lids of the barrels the next day, and there was as much grumbling as ever, though he did not take it to heart. They stumbled up onto the bank and threw themselves against the shoreline in utter exhaustion, and Bilbo waited patiently until a few of them had started to come to their senses and he could hasten them on.
Fili and Kili were as spritely as ever and seemed eager to start the next leg of their journey, though they complained as much as the rest.
“We reek of apples,” Fili had said immediately after stepping out of his barrel, shaking out the golden mane of his hair and wrinkling up his nose in distaste.
Bilbo had, as usual, rolled his eyes. “Then I suppose you shall have to hope you don’t run into any horses.”
One by one he managed to drag them up onto a wooden wharf extending out into the water not too far from where they stood wringing out their drenched coats and cloth, but the grumbling all at once stopped as each of them turned to the north and gazed at long, long last upon the Lonely Mountain.
The tip of it loomed purple-grey in the distance of the sky stretched out before them, and clouds were gathered all around, like gentle arms reaching across its face, sheltering it from the view of the world. It sat like a forgotten beacon watching over the lake of Men; an ancient giant. The silence at the sight was almost holy.
Bilbo hated to tear them away from it, but they needed to move; it was almost dusk, and the first grasps of winter were already in the air. He urged them up, and moved them on, gently touching at shoulders and giving them each a strained smile, and soon they were plodding along the boardwalks of outer Laketown, the wood damp and rotting under their feet. Men, presumably guards, spotted them in the distance, and by the time they had made it to the edge of town they were met by no small number of people all watching on curiously.
The Master of Laketown pushed through, scowling, and Bilbo wrinkled up his nose at once. The reality of seeing the man again with his own two eyes only soured Bilbo’s memories even further; the pompous sneer that stretched across his mouth, the decadent robes that had become old and moth-eaten, the battered-yet-priceless jewellery that adorned each of his stubby fingers. Bilbo wished that he could knock that silly hat clean off the ridiculous shoulders it sat on.
“Greetings to the Master and the Men of Laketown! We do not wish to trespass, but are seeking shelter and food, if we are able,” Balin said amicably, bowing a little. The Master’s face twisted even further; he looked as if he had suddenly eaten several lemons.
“And who, may I ask, are you?” he spat, looking to the front of the group.
Thorin’s words came out just as Bilbo had remembered them.
“I am Thorin,” he said, stepping forward, his voice like quiet thunder, “son of Thrain, son of Thror. King Under the Mountain. And we have come to reclaim our homeland.”
It was like he’d fallen into a memory, the ring of people in the dusky light, the damp, creaking steps up to the Master’s house where he would sit sneering down at his people living in squalor. Bilbo remembered the songs, the cheering, the chanting of his wealth shall flow in fountains and the rivers golden run! He remembered thinking for the first time that his little part in their quest might be much bigger than he’d imagined, that he might have come for more than a little treasure and helping his new friends find a home again.
And of course, he remembered what a disaster all of that had become. But now was not the time.
All of the faces around them looked tentatively, sincerely hopeful at Thorin's words, as though a blessing in their desperate favour had come at long, long last. All but one, and Bilbo found him instantly.
Bard had not spoken, and Bilbo knew he would not, but he knew at the same time that Bard was both his greatest danger and greatest ally in preventing the catastrophe on the Long Lake. For some time he’d been thinking over whether approaching him was wise, or whether knowing the true extent of their intentions would force Bard to try and stop them even more intensely. But it was he who would listen to Bilbo’s warnings that all was not well in the Mountain, and it was he who would be the asset Bilbo had not had last time. He was going to have to reach into Bard by force and pull out the Dragonslayer.
The feast that night was grand and merry; all of them had been draped in gilded fineries of red and gold, and seated at the High Table beside the Master and his attendees. Bilbo could not seem to stop himself thinking how beneath his pompous robes and false smile was a heart of utter selfishness, who did not care one bit for his people and who would leave them to starve and die, and so he avoided the Master as much as he could. He chose a seat as far away from them all as possible, and although it meant he was not close to Thorin or Fili or Kili or Balin, he sat comfortably and chatted with Dori, Bifur and Bombur, and they all turned quite a few heads with the roars of their laughter.
The Company was given the same house to stay in as before, though all of them more or less ended up nestled on the floor amongst each other’s limbs the way they had been during the long days in the forest; half because they’d quite fallen asleep on their feet and hadn’t made it into any the beds scattered about the house, and half because the sleep-pile was a blanket of safety, protection they’d desperately needed and felt too wary to give up.
They spent the better part of a fortnight resting, washing, singing, working out knots in their muscles, eating their fill after so long deliriously underfed, sitting in a circle with the map of Erebor in the centre and attempting to work out a plan to approach the Mountain. There were several conversations with the Master and his accursed advisor about the specifics of payment for their kindness and support for Erebor’s old ally, but these were few and far between; the man had made no efforts to masquerade as anywhere near politically gifted, and he did not care about anything but the gold.
Bilbo propped every one of his limbs up at every moment he was able and spent his days lounging around, curly head buried in books thicker than his arms or simply gazing at the cover of the red-leather journal pulled from his pack, never opening it but not wanting to part from it all the same.
He really was beginning to need a haircut, too. He’d had to keep tossing his hair right out of his eyes, and he was sure it looked nothing short of ridiculous.
Once, only a few days after they had arrived and settled in Laketown, Thorin Oakenshield walked into a mostly-empty room in the Company’s staying-house to find Bilbo Baggins standing on a stool with his hands on his hips, quite intently staring up into the shelves on the wall. When the dwarf looked further, he spotted the little stack of books collecting dust high in the corner, and the way Bilbo was eyeing the rest of them with an almost challenging intrigue. It must have tweaked a memory in his mind of something the hobbit had told them, for he asked with some hesitation, “Are you doing research?”
Bilbo did not even turn his head, utterly focused on peering at the spines of each book one after the other like they were making a bid for whichever he deemed most worthy. A shrewd sort of expression rested upon his face.
“Of sorts,” he said, after the quiet had lingered for a little while. He turned to look over his shoulder at Thorin. “These Laketown Men don’t have their own tongue, and I don’t think their books can teach me anything I do not already know.” There was such a clear annoyance in his voice that the corners of Thorin’s mouth lifted slightly.
“You do not wish to lower yourself enough to read anything in Common Speech?” he asked, amused. The hobbit squinted at him, disgruntled, though the dwarf knew they had both been only teasing.
Bilbo glanced back up at the shelves with the books, so much taller than he. The entrancement was clear upon his face.
“I love languages,” he said. “The translation of texts has always been one of my favourite things to write.” His nose wrinkled. “I don’t want to waste time or page space writing down things I’ve read so many times my eyes will fall out.”
Thorin Oakenshield took a step closer to the bookshelf, the wood below them creaking under his boots. He gazed up at the sight that seemed to so captivate his companion.
“It is a pity you cannot learn Khuzdûl.”
Bilbo scoffed. “Yes, well, even if I did know it, I could not translate any of your texts, because you are all so secretive,” he pointed out in a nettled sort of tone, wobbling on unsteady feet as he reached up for another book.
(Warm brown skin crept out from beneath the half-untucked shirt he wore. Eyes were lowered.)
“And the Elves are not?” Thorin asked quietly.
The hobbit turned back from the bookshelf with a thick leather-bound volume in his hands. The tome had to have been decades old, one of the few remnants to have made it out of the ruin that had become of Dale in the wake of the dragon.
“Well, I suppose they are,” Bilbo said thoughtfully, “but they have never seemed to mind with me.” His brows furrowed in the centre of his face, and Thorin’s eyes seemed drawn to the little crease they left between them. “Maybe it’s because I am a hobbit, and they do not wholly think of me as an equal. It’s the same everywhere you turn. It’s why we are known by others as halflings, although hobbits greatly resent that name. We are not half of anything, thank you very much.”
The dwarf swallowed, and the line of his throat seemed to bob, the sunlight falling through the window and pooling on the floor as their bodies faced each other. The air was so brisk outside that the little room in the upper floor of the house felt almost stifling. Dust particles drifted through the air, splintering in the light from the window, though that too was fading day by day as winter descended upon them.
“If I'm honest, I’ve read more than anyone else I know," Bilbo said absent-mindedly, almost to himself. "I’ve had a lot of time for it.”
“Is that why you can speak their language?”
Bilbo looked at Thorin, and his expression was not quite placeable; to anyone else, he might have even looked a little upset. “Sindarin, it’s called. And only somewhat. I made an effort to speak to as many Elves as I could find, when I was younger.”
The hobbit looked back to the dusty shelf for a moment more and then hopped off the stool. His feet made no sound at all when they hit the ground, and Thorin seemed to realise this, like if he hadn’t been able to see Bilbo, the hobbit would have been nothing but a shadow.
“Aren’t you going to lecture me for it, then?” Bilbo asked, and the dwarf seemed perplexed.
“What?”
“Thorin, I saw your face in the Elven-tunnels. It pains you that I involve myself with them.”
A twinge appeared in Thorin Oakenshield's jaw, though he did not raise his voice. “You should have told me your plan in full. We were working together.”
“Are you so sure you would have trusted me to be able to do it?”
“Yes,” Thorin said simply. Bilbo’s ears went pink. He looked away.
Thorin took a step towards the hulking bookshelf, circling round the side of a table and chairs resting in the centre of the room until he was in line with Bilbo. They stared at each other.
“You are clever, Bilbo, and I fear we may all still be stuck in prison or have weapons lodged in our backs, if not for you,” Thorin said, in that rumble of his. His eyes were trained so very intently on Bilbo it must have been almost hard to look at him. “But you do not tell us everything.”
Bilbo laughed, tucking the books more securely under his arm. “I should think I’ve been boring you all to pieces enough with how much I talk as it is. I don’t believe for a moment any of you want me to talk even more.”
“You’ve been leading us more even than I. But you cannot rely on luck alone in order to survive. Not even you can do that, Bilbo.”
Bilbo let out a huff. “That’s what you dwarves think.”
Thorin frowned. “This is a company, not a person in charge and the rest of his followers. If you have ideas, we want to hear them. We want to know.”
“And I told you months ago that I know quite well what I am doing and how exactly I am doing it!”
His face and ears had flushed a rosy red, if not quite in anger then certainly in irritation, and he placed the books down on the table in order to adequately point a finger at Thorin Oakenshield.
“I think, Thorin, that you’d better remember that it is me who has to face Smaug alone in the dark, so it doesn’t much matter what my plans are, does it?”
Thorin’s expression became unreadable, and his eyes flickered down for a moment to where Bilbo’s index finger hovered in the space between them.
“I would offer you aid in that, as much as we are able. You are our burglar," he said lowly.
A weary sort of appearance crossed the hobbit’s face; his eyes seemed to soften, and the lines that rested on his skin mellowed until they were smooth. He lowered his hand, turning to the side and brushing his fingers over the embossed cover of the book resting at the top of his little stack.
“I’m sorry — I shouldn’t have raised my voice. It’s not your fault — not any of your faults. And I agreed, didn’t I? I knew what it was I was signing up to do.”
The dwarf looked at him with a piteous sort of expression.
“Bilbo —”
“Oh, please don’t worry, Thorin. I’m all right.” And he smiled, creasing the corners of his eyes and the apples of his cheeks blooming rosy as Thorin watched. The hobbit took up his books once more and shook the unruly hair from his face, making his way importantly from the room with a farewell and leaving the dwarf standing alone among the faded pages of books.
(A dwarf, who had lost so much and given all of himself to his people, and who would sit in the corner of the room in the lavish little house they were staying in on the water and watch Bilbo Baggins as he wove rich stories through the air, his hands fanning out in front of him and his eyes alight, not noticing the way his audience would sit enraptured by how he could paint pictures in their minds, and the way he seemed to fit amongst them without thinking, hobbit though he was.
And sometimes Thorin Oakenshield would close his eyes, and lay his weary head against whatever he was resting on, and listen to the sound of Bilbo’s voice; for you could hear the Shire in every lilt of it, the sound like cups of tea and well-loved pages of books, his words floating around the room the way the smell of home would when you opened your door at the end of the day.
It was strange, one might feel, for someone who had gone so long without the feeling of home to hear it in a child of the kindly West. And yet, Thorin would listen to the stories in the wood-slatted house on the lake, and every day he thought of how deeply he had underestimated Master Baggins of Bag End, and of all that they might have lost had it not been for their burglar. Of all that they might have gone without. He was a statue whose blood had begun to sing again.)
Another such day saw Bilbo sat and watching each set of brothers rebraid each other’s hair with such profound tenderness, such care, that it almost made even him homesick. Dwalin and Balin, Oin and Gloin, Dori and Ori placating a rather reluctant Nori, Bofur and Bombur each braiding one side of their cousin’s hair and sniping back and forth about whose was better, Fili and Kili laughing at each other throughout. Thorin had done his own, the usual two long strands that hung by his ears, though he let Fili close the clasps that bound them together.
Most hobbits, if it could be believed, did not have cause to know how exactly to weave their fingers through each other’s hair; almost each and every one of them wore their hair loose, preferring to let it tangle and muss wildly in the air, and even the lads and lasses who wore their hair long and curly scrunched it into ponytails or plaits more tangled than the wind left it. But Bilbo had often, on lazy afternoons when the breeze lulled and the pollen kissed at evergreen leaves, sat in his mother’s favourite patchworked chair and let little Frodo lay back against his legs while Bilbo carded his fingers through the boy's dark hair.
Bilbo had never had any ability to braid, although the style always brought a dear fondness to him, so he wouldn’t ever do much of anything with Frodo’s curls but pull them apart from one another and brush his fingers through them as tenderly as he was able.
(Frodo had his mother Primula’s hair, who’d had her father’s, and the Brandybucks always seemed to grow their offspring with hair that was thin and wispy rather than the more unruly Tookish thickness or the Bagginses’ ever-present suggestion of auburn. Whenever Frodo let him tend to his hair like this, it always reminded Bilbo exactly of a duckling’s down.)
“...and then Mirabella and Gorbadoc had your mother, who had you, so really, my lad, we are even more related as Tooks than we are Bagginses.”
“Bilbo?” Frodo’d said once, maybe a year after he’d come to live with Bilbo — he’d still been quite young, then, and Bilbo had already started keenly mourning the fact that he had not cared enough to know this bundle of curiosity and playful wryness since the day he’d been born; he would surely have spoiled him rotten.
“Hmm?”
“Why did you never come to any of the gatherings our family held? I never saw you. Everyone in Brandy Hall had to remind each other who you were when you came to get me.”
Bilbo huffed out a half-laugh through his teeth and shook his head, though Frodo could not see him. “I’m not a very nice hobbit, I’m afraid, my boy. None of them like me all too much.”
Frodo had sat with this for a moment and then piped up, “But all the littluns like you.”
Bilbo smiled, a twinkle in his eye. "That’s because I tell them stories."
He smiled again now. There were such similarities between the ways dwarves and hobbits showed their love that he mourned their peoples’ separation from each other, and each of them in turn from the outside world. He’d noticed the same thing months ago, when they’d first set out from Hobbiton, though now it felt as though the whole world had shifted since then. But time together, and physical touch to show one’s affection, and community rather than loneliness; he could see every single one of them in the way all of his dwarves interacted, and in why he had flocked so desperately to them the first time without ever quite knowing why. He loved the Shire with all of his heart, but he had never matched Shire life, never found the companionship of any other hobbits aside from Frodo the way he had with rough and roguish dwarves out on the road.
So, one day, once their stay was nearly up and once they’d recuperated enough to no longer worry, he decided to tell them so.
“Would any of you take offence if I told you you all behave quite hobbitishly?” Bilbo had said. It was late afternoon, and the autumn wind had picked up a little outside, a chill rising off the water under all of their feet and through the cracks in the floorboards. Bilbo had found himself surprised that the lake had not already begun to frost, this far north.
Not one of his dwarves seemed to know how to respond to that. Bilbo saw Kili scrunch up his nose, and a few of them seemed to raise disbelieving brows, like maybe they were surprised he had the nerve to say something so bold or so blasphemous, but he set his jaw, and he pushed on stubbornly.
“It’s not that I think you’re snobbish and softhearted like me, but more… well…”
Bilbo trailed off and settled back into the Man-sized armchair he was curled up in, tilting his head back against the dusty velvet and glancing up at the ceiling. Unfortunately, he was well aware of the delicacy of dwarven sensibilities, stoic as they might seem.
“You set store on family, much more than Elves or Men seem to. That is how we live, too. I’ve always found the independence of the Big Folk strange.” Cold and pristine. You had to work hard to pull grins from Elven faces, and they fell from dwarvish ones like honey. “I like it much better here with you.”
He could see quite a few of them smiling now. “And we are glad to have you, Master Baggins,” Balin said, against a chorus of assenting noises echoing round the room, though some of them seemed a little bemused. Bilbo hastened to explain himself, waving his hands, feeling a little silly for being so sentimental. He couldn’t help it. He felt sure anyone in his place would have been exactly the same.
“Oh, you must all think I’m a complete sap, but I don’t think any of you understand! You — you didn’t see me before that day in the Shire, the way I lived before. It was… I lost my parents quite close together, and I've been alone for a long time, almost a lifetime, really. I have other relatives, and my mother had ten siblings, but I was never a huge worry to them, and so they never thought to check up on me much, I suppose.”
Oh, dear. He could feel himself ramping up into a story, all his unspoken words starting to fall out at once, ever the grand gesture over quiet fondness. Here we go, then.
So he told them all of how exceedingly strange he’d been to them, prim and proper and burying himself in books as he’d always done, never talking to the neighbours much to the ghastly horror of his extended family. How he’d despised — still despised — how much everybody else’s noses were always in your business, how it had been the bane of his and Frodo’s existence when they’d still been new to each other, a still-young Frodo tottering about the garden and everybody but the Gamgees trying to stickybeak at him about his poor parents or whatever those silly Brandybucks had been getting on with over in Buckland. He told them of how he’d begun to be called odd, and though he hadn’t minded the names or the space it had given him to hide away in, it had always been quite a large hobbit-hole, and he had always been quite a small hobbit.
Bilbo looked up at the room, his captive audience, his dear, lovely friends. He wished with everything he had that he could tell them how dear, just once. Pieces of my heart to bring my heart peace. He smiled inwardly.
“What I am saying," he finished, "is that you are my family now, in a way. All of you.”
There was a moment’s pause as the confession swept around all the walls and settled on everyone’s ears. Bilbo twiddled his thumbs and acted rather awkward, worrying more and more that they were all thinking he’d fallen right off the deep end, wondering for a mad moment if he’d somehow made them think he should be left behind from the journey to the Mountain on account of his sudden softness.
Then, slowly, each of the dwarves rose and moved forward, one by one, to gently kneel and press their foreheads against his, cupping the back of his neck and closing their eyes with a look of such peace that Bilbo found he could not speak.
Dori, Nori, then Ori, then Bifur and Bombur, and Oin and Gloin, and Bofur, and Balin, and Fili and Kili with identical grins streaked across their faces, and then Dwalin, solemn and almost glaring at Bilbo but showing his gratitude all the same.
Then last in the line was Thorin, and he did not bring his face towards Bilbo’s or touch their foreheads together, but he reached forward and grasped Bilbo’s wrists, facing them upwards so their hands were linked together like the slots of a chain. The feel of Thorin’s fingertips were worn and rough against his skin, and anchored Bilbo in that one moment, amongst damp wooden slats and the smell of barrels of fish and his heart alive in front of him.
“You honour us, Master Baggins,” Thorin said, his voice low and sincere. “Each of us are indebted to you a lifetime over. And all of us are glad to have you.”
Oh, heavens, Bilbo could feel the waterworks propelling towards him at full force, and he pushed the heels of his feet hard into the floorboards to bite them down, deliberately looking away from Thorin’s gaze. He’d done so well, not a tear in weeks! Don’t lose it now, you fool, not when finally you are happy and not grieving!
He managed a shaky smile, looking up at the thirteen of them in front of him, feeling Thorin’s fingers still on his forearms. “I do not know who chose this path for me, but they have been too generous. I know others who deserve this more than I.”
He had carried them with him all this way, thinking always of Elrond’s guidance that he must let go of things that could not be helped, and knowing that it was much harder to do than it was to simply know one should. How could he think of those he had loved without feeling the threads of guilt and sorrow ever tightening around him, when he had long learned to live with such threads in the years following Thorin and Fili and Kili?
Thorin’s eyes heavy on his felt as if a line ran directly between them, tying them to each other. The way he was knelt, down on one knee and Bilbo’s hands in his - Bilbo felt utterly flustered, and felt a flush bloom across his skin up to the roots of his hair.
“We would not wish for anyone else," he said.
“I know,” Bilbo murmured. He closed his eyes, reminding himself that he was here, and very obviously here to stay. It did not quite matter whether he deserved it or not.
He’d long torn out the page he’d written in, that first day he’d come back, but he thought then of the Red Book, a quiet comfort to him on days where his mind drifted to all that he had done in his first life, and he found himself imagining his and Frodo’s spidery handwriting mixing on the pages. Two chapters of the same story. Would there be three chapters now, Bilbo wondered? He mourned the fact he would never get the chance to write this adventure down alongside its predecessors.
He’d simply have to tell Frodo all about it one day, when they saw each other again.
Thorin pulled his hands away and settled back, an odd smile on his face like he wasn’t completely sure what to make of Bilbo’s spectacular outburst. Bilbo very stubbornly refused to feel embarrassed.
“Having thirteen dwarves and a wizard inside must have seemed awfully crowded after so long alone in Bag End,” he said after a moment.
Bilbo felt his face break into a smile, just as Thorin's turned away.
“I’m sure it did, once,” said Bilbo, tilting his head as if he had to even think about it, “but now, I think thirteen dwarves and a wizard fit rather perfectly.”
Several of the dwarves audibly groaned at the mention of Gandalf, which Bilbo thought was quite hilarious considering how desperate they’d all been to keep him at the entrance to Mirkwood.
“You know," said Thorin, "for someone who seems so lonely, you have a very big heart, Master Baggins.”
Bilbo laughed gently. Pieces of his heart to bring his heart peace, indeed.
“Oh, but the room in my heart has all been taken up by you lot.”
It was fast-fading twilight when Bilbo slipped out through the crack in the door and started out towards the other side of Laketown. It took almost no time at all for him to pick his way across the docks and piles of fishing nets and rope, and he was knocking at the battered-looking door before he’d entirely worked out what he was going to say.
It swung open, and there was Bard, gruff and imposing the way he’d always been, his dark hair bedraggled in the dim light. Bard-not-yet-the-Dragonslayer. He looked down at Bilbo.
“You are the halfling that has come with the King,” he said.
“The hobbit, yes,” Bilbo said, a little crossly, and Bard seemed amused, though the grim lines of his face ran far too deep. “My name is Bilbo Baggins. And you’re Bard. I’ve come to ask you for help.”
Bard watched on silently, still holding the door half-open. Bilbo felt his ears flush red and stubbornly surged onward.
He cast his eyes to the floor. There was no other way about it.
“Do you know that we are planning to march upon the Mountain by winter’s coming?”
Bard’s expression darkened at once, his face becoming grisly and his teeth clenched, and Bilbo saw in the set of his shoulders the warrior and king he would become. He thought with some guilt that he dearly wished he’d visited Bard once more, before he died and Bain had become king of Dale.
“You are going to wake the dragon,” Bard said lowly. He had not pulled his gaze from Bilbo’s once, and it was becoming unnerving. Bilbo furrowed his brows.
“Yes, I think so too,” he said. “I fear it greatly. It is what I have come to discuss with you.”
Bard let him in.
“Where are your children?” Bilbo asked as he made his way inside, looking around curiously and not realising his mistake until he trotted almost directly into Bard’s back, who had come to a stop in the middle of the room.
“How would you know if I had children?”
“I, ah — well, I’m sorry, but I assumed —” Bilbo stammered, cursing his own stupidity, and angered that he’d let his guard down so fickly after so long in perfect pretence. The man was sharper than a whip, and he had no reason to trust Bilbo; in fact had every reason not to, after what Bilbo had just asked him.
Bard was eyeing him with some suspicion, but Bilbo could see in his face that he was not angered, and was perhaps even a little impressed at Bilbo’s apparently astonishing display of intuition. He sighed.
“You guessed correctly. I have three; two girls and a boy. They’re visiting with one of the ladies in town who helps care for them while I am working.” He said everything with a vague neutrality, like everything in his life happened with a sort of dull resignation and weariness. Bilbo could see premature lines on his forehead, and felt suddenly incredibly guilty at the extent of his own age.
They sat across from each other, and Bilbo explained the plan he’d been constructing in the edges of his mind, one he still wasn’t sure he should dare to try for all that could go desperately, disastrously wrong. He was choosing to play his cards very recklessly, but something inside his chest could not envision a single other way.
Bard was incredibly dubious, and that ever-present pessimism he’d always shown flared out again as their discussion went round and round in circles. How will someone as small as you ever be able to lure a dragon from its hoard? How will you control it? How can you guarantee you won’t die before you can do so? How can you be sure there is a way to kill it at all?
It was very tiresome, and Bilbo’s long admiration for Bard’s stoutness in the face of danger began to wilt like a cut sprout.
(There was nothing in this world quite like the distrust of Men. Bilbo had never had qualms with them the same way those like Elrond did, but it seemed the universe had decided to thoroughly test that theory.)
“Look, Bard, my apologies, but you are going to have to trust me either way, because we don’t have much of a choice!” Bilbo cried after a while, and Bard’s gloomy eyes fixed on him sharply.
“We do not have any choice if you and your Company do not back down from this. You are putting lives at risk.”
Bilbo noted the dull jab of guilt it was meant to cause and resolutely ignored it, gripping the arms of the chair more firmly and setting his jaw.
“I’m sorry,” he said stubbornly, feeling awful and defiant both, knowing he might be terrible for saying it but already resolving that his friends had always, would always, come first, “but that is not a deal I can make. I’m trying my best to keep you all safe, but it is them that are my priority.”
He sat forward in his armchair and glanced out the window, not wanting to keep eye contact with Bard as he laid out just how dire the situation was. A row of termites were creeping along the windowsill, no doubt looking to burrow down into the wet rot of Bard’s ramshackle house. Bilbo wondered how long each of the buildings on the lake would have lasted had he and the dwarves not barged their way through and reignited the long-ago people of Dale. He wrinkled up his nose for a moment and reluctantly continued.
“I can’t tell you how or why I know, but the dragon has two weaknesses, and we are using both of them. It will come regardless of what we do. This is the only plan we have, and I trust you more than anyone else to be able to save your people. Your Master is going to do nothing, and I don’t believe the dwarves have truly realised the danger that lies in the Mountain. We’ve all been putting it out of our heads until the final steps of the journey.”
Bard’s stoic expression softened so slightly Bilbo very nearly missed it. He leant back in his chair and swung an arm over the side, watching Bilbo with a reserved sort of curiosity. It was clear he found Bilbo exceedingly peculiar, and perhaps a little suspicious, but the time was long gone for any of them to be acting based on wariness. Bilbo knew they had one shot to free the Mountain and the Long Lake, and that that one shot was Bard the Bowman.
“I believe you, hobbit, and I will do what I can. We will not let the lake burn. But I confess,” and here he stretched a leg out, and really, Big Folk were all sorts of strange, “I cannot seem to understand how you are going to exploit the beast’s weakness for gold. He has all the gold he wants; far too much of it.”
Bilbo smiled grimly. Bard had found his way to the heart of the problem, the part that worried him more than anything else ever had.
“Not all of it,” he said quietly.
Two days later, under an increasingly dreary mid-morning, Thorin gathered the fourteen of them and looked at each of them very seriously in turn.
“I wish to tell the Master of this town that we are departing tomorrow for Erebor,” he said. “Durin’s Day is in three days’ time. We need to gather supplies, transport; ponies, to make the journey between the shore and the Mountain. Get what things you have together. Balin,” he said then, looking to his side, “come with me.”
Balin followed, collecting several papers he’d spent their last few days painstakingly drafting up — contracts and predictions of tallies of money and other such things — and making careful eye contact with Thorin, who turned back and called, “Dwalin! Bilbo! With us!”
The two of them moved forward — one marching, one scurrying — at once.
This was the third meeting they had attempted to call with the Master, and the first he had deigned to actually attend himself instead of sending his snivelling assistant to make his excuses. Bilbo had no idea what it was exactly the Master thought he was achieving by doing this; Laketown was not large, and if he was expecting to negotiate some sort of donation of goodwill or mutual assistance, he certainly had not endeared himself to any of the dwarves thus far.
He sat before them now, lounging on the threadbare remains of what had once surely been a grand armchair in such a disrespectful manner that Bilbo furiously refused to maintain eye contact with him and stared right out the window instead.
Balin lowered his hood and bent at the neck and the waist.
“We humbly ask you now for assistance in our approach to the Mountain,” he said, eyes resting steadily on the Master’s dreadful sneer below that thin moustache. “Of course, this will be recompensed as soon as we are able.”
The other three of them did not bow with Balin; Bilbo did try to make himself smaller and more unthreatening than he already was despite his determination to not look upon the man, but Thorin and Dwalin stood with their hands clasped behind their backs, tough as towers, and neither moved a muscle.
Bilbo thought warmly to himself that it was rather sweet that each of the Fundinson brothers had become Thorin’s second in different ways; Dwalin the warrior and Balin the intellectual. He felt sure, however, that for all their camaraderie and closeness this thought would be a touch too sentimental to share, even for him. But then, aren’t they all?
“And I suppose you are just going to wish the dragon away?” The Master sneered. All of the man’s syllables were drawled out in an infuriatingly aristocratic slur, and all of them could hear with their own ears as the words dripped right down the Master’s nose onto the floor by their feet.
Balin kept his gaze steady. His wispy white beard did not even quiver. “Smaug is our responsibility, your Highness.”
“I should hope so!” The Master spat, spraying all their faces with the putrid stench of his saliva. “It’s your damned fault he lurks in the first place! Your greed brought him here - don’t deny it!” He emphasised the point by wagging a finger in all of their faces, the fingernail yellowed and bitten. Bilbo had to bite down very hard on the inside of his cheek to resist the temptation of rolling his eyes. “Is it not said that the downfall of the dwarves is their relentless greed?”
“Is this greed you are somehow immune to, Master?” Thorin said quietly.
The room felt suddenly stiller, like all the candles had paused in their breathing to watch, like the Master and his slimy shadow Alfrid had quite frozen in time, so shocked were they by his nerve.
Thorin took a mighty step forward, the warped floorboards screaming out underneath his boots, and like this he was glorious, and he was captivating, and Bilbo knew at once that he'd been right when he’d thought as they talked in the flower-fields outside Beorn’s cottage that it was an honour to love him. It was an honour every day. He held it against his chest like a flame.
“We are not blind, and we have spent more time amongst your people these past weeks than I predict you have in as many months.”
And Thorin, the way his name had always sat on Bilbo’s tongue, the roll of it like the strength of trees and the gleam of polished wood. Thorin Oakenshield. He could still feel the weight of Thorin’s already-cold hand in his like a phantom breath from long ago, the two of them frozen to the ice, one single heart now beating in a chest made for the both of them.
It was not even remotely the time, but Bilbo could not help but think it.
It has been an honour to carry you with me all these years, Thorin Oakenshield. There has been no honour higher.
The Master’s pursed mouth was gaping open like a fish, and he’d sat upright in his chair, like he had only just now thought to pay attention once somebody had dared to reprimand him in his own house.
“I would see Dale and Erebor prospering again," Thorin said with finality. "We do not have to agree on anything else but that.”
Bilbo looked to the front of the room then, and watched real anger flash across the Master’s face before it settled again into a pristine mask of smug serenity. He was sure none of the others had caught it, and he was sure he knew why. If Dale rose again, the Master would lose every bit of his power and prestige, and his unpopularity would have him scrounging in the streets. He only wished he could tell the Master right to his snobbish face that he’d be scrounging no matter what, and that his days were numbered. Bard was the true King of Dale.
“We will bring what fortune we can. The lake will shine again.”
Perhaps realising what a blunder he had begun to make, the Master insisted on throwing another feast for them, with more merriment and platters of food and gold-strung lights that flickered above their heads once twilight fell. Bilbo could almost smell the ploy to buy their good favour in hopes of recompense; or perhaps, a public spectacle of the Master’s sheer good-naturedness, so that if the dwarves’ promise to share their gold fell through, he could appeal to the people of his town, because every one of them had borne witness to his oh-so-selfless treatment of them. It was vile, but there was nothing they could do for the people of Laketown yet.
There was music that played long into the night on fiddles and flutes, and Bilbo ran all around asking uselessly if anybody had a harmonica on them so he could finally show Bofur. Everywhere he was met with disappointment, and Bofur started to poke and prod at him with a cocky grin on his face, telling him that he’d made up something that didn’t exist, to much protest from Bilbo.
He’d never been a social drinker, or much of an ale drinker at all, preferring a glass of rich red wine if he ever deigned to partake in it, but the atmosphere drew him like a moth to a flame; the anxious anticipation of what lay ahead in the coming days, the headiness of being with his dwarves and being able to see the love of his heart, day after day, the knowledge that soon, finally, finally, it would be over and they could rest by each other’s sides for a long while. He clashed his mug with everyone else’s, and they all slopped beer everywhere, and that final night was spent roaring tunes from Ered Luin, songs of cheer and hope and happiness.
Of course it wasn’t long before the Company all began to beg Bilbo for a song, and not your one about the road going ever on, Bilbo, we’ve all started hearing it in our sleep, and he couldn’t seem to say no to them any longer. He longed to give the simplest parts of their quest a send-off, to the Shire and the Misty Mountains and Beorn’s lovely garden before their dastardly reality began to creep up on him.
“Oh, you’ve all asked for it,” he said, laughing and rolling his shoulders back. If only his little cousins Merry and Pippin could have seen him now! He made them clear a circle, and he began to twirl round and round.
Oh, you can search far and wide
You can drink the whole town dry
But you’ll never find a beer so brown
Oh, you’ll never find a beer so brown
As the one we drink in my home-town!
As he was dancing, he threw his mug up to the sky and his head backward, and he looked to see Thorin standing quite still in the middle of the group, arms folded across his chest and his eyes slightly wider than normal. He seemed astonished at the sight of Bilbo.
Bilbo felt a giddy grin crack across his face as he closed his eyes and sang with all his heart. He hadn’t felt so young in decades.
You can keep your fancy ales
You can drink them by the flagon
But the only beer for the brave and true
Comes from the Green Dragon!
