Actions

Work Header

thunder and the riversong

Chapter 7: something in the orange

Notes:

hello bffs it’s only been three months and not six i know you’re all as surprised as i am

i had to split this chapter in half as it ended up being almost 20k (lol) so you will notice the overall chapter count of the fic has gone up!

title taken from the song “something in the orange” by zach bryan (specifically z&e's ver, it’s one of my main songs for these two and always makes me cry)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

After their Laketown send-off followed several days of sailing, then riding, then walking, then trudging, and then complaining before the Company of Thorin Oakenshield made it up the rock-face to the westerly Hidden Door and were waiting in the fading sunlight for the face of the moon to rise. Bilbo had very even-temperedly bitten his tongue and held off from pointing out the staircase built into the side of the Lonely Mountain, even when it meant they’d all been bumbling around like fools for far longer than they should have, but he’d had to sidestep all confusion about the last light of Durin’s Day for sheer peace of mind and simply pretended to have a rather inspired epiphany.

“Now what’s that line it says again?” he’d said, cocking his head to the side for a little extra believability. “About the light upon the keyhole? Do you suppose it could mean any light at all, rather than daylight? Perhaps the moon, for instance?”

The looks blinking back at him had been almost comical, and Balin had smiled at him in gratitude. “Every day I remain so glad Gandalf chose you for our Company, Bilbo.”

They huddled in to wait, passing around cram and the last of their Laketown apples, and sure enough, of course, once the silver moon had climbed high enough it was peeking its nose out from behind the scattered clouds, the key had gone in and the door had been opened, and thirteen faces had turned towards him with a trepidation that bordered on unease if not outright alarm. Bilbo pushed his shaking shoulders back and strode forward.

He felt as though he had reached a terrible, inevitable fork in the road, which was a little ridiculous, really, since this was in some ways the simplest task he had yet to achieve. He had done every bit of this before, knew exactly what to expect from the Mountain and the pesky parasite that lived within.

But this would also be the biggest change he had made so far to their journey, and to the fate of the world. 

He was one hobbit. He did not have the physical strength to fight off a dragon. If Smaug got the better of him, Middle-Earth would likely fall to ruin within a matter of months.

(But the dragon had not before, so he would not again.)

Bofur hugged him before he left, and the rest of him waved him off, all of their faces fighting a war between hope beyond hope at the prospect of finally being so near, and abject dread at the thought of what was to come. At the thought of their hobbit, all alone in the dark, nothing but his Sting to bear aloft before him. There were whispers of goodwill and hearty claps on his shoulders as he walked, and the grim little smile he gave everyone did not seem to be doing anything to quell either their fear or their hope.

“If you — well, if you hear any sort of noises, dragon-like or otherwise,” Bilbo said with a grimace, turning to face them with one hand on the door, “whatever you do, don’t all of you come running in, or I will have a much harder time doing what it is you have hired me to do. I have a plan, should anything go sideways, but with any luck the old thing will be asleep, and I can escape with all the hair on my head!”

He was spouting absolute tosh right through his teeth and knew it, and Bilbo wondered privately whether it had occurred to any of them at any point that should Smaug be asleep they would still have had to find a way to get him out of Erebor, but it wasn’t to be helped, and it wasn’t going to happen, anyhow.

“We will follow your lead, Master Burglar,” an unmistakable voice murmured nearby.

His head was bent, the shine of the moon catching the silver streaks in his hair and causing them to appear almost luminescent in the fading twilight. His voice had been so soft, so quiet over the breeze. He was looking at Bilbo steadily, arms folded in front of his body as if to brace himself; from the wind, from the cold, from apprehension or fierce anticipation, who on Earth knew.

Bilbo looked at Thorin for a moment longer, and let his mouth quirk up at one of the corners, feeling so nervous he could barely even think to speak. Thorin did not make a sound, just held his gaze with those heavy eyes like boulders, like pools, and gave a very slow nod.

Bilbo swallowed, eyes flicking between both of Thorin’s, and then turned away, pushing open the door in the rock-face with splayed fingers and slipping inside. The heavy door swung closed with a crunch, shutting out the moonlight and the frozen faces of his friends so he was submerged in utter darkness. Only the faintest, faintest streaks of jasper-orange light against the far entrance to the stairway gave any suggestion at all that Bilbo was not alone.

He took one more moment to pause and close his eyes, taking a breath, calming himself, clenching his jaw very tightly so it would cease the trembling his body would not stop exhibiting, even though his mind was set. His heart was beating fast as a hummingbird’s wings.

(All that apprehension and anticipation and so on and so forth.)

He exhaled. He adjusted his fingers, one by one. He wrinkled his nose.

He began to creep down, down, down.


Bilbo remembered all too well how he’d felt the first time he’d walked this path, and how he’d had to stop, standing stock-still with his eyes squeezed shut and willing his weary feet to move — to move forward, to turn back, to charge onward, to flee. How the terror had clutched at him, how it had brought guilt and bitter regret, and a stinging sense of determination. How he had taken a single step, and then another, the crimson light flickering against the wall, the smell of ash growing and filling the caverns until all he was breathing in was thick hot soot.

He did not stop this time, but it was a near thing. The red was like blood against the walls. The stench was all but ruin.

He very nearly even reached for the Ring, then, trekking through the darkness, touching cautiously at the walls with the pads of his fingers, and only when his hand was already half-outstretched towards the front pocket of his coat did Bilbo remember himself with a jolt.

He would not. He’d made a promise.

Nearly a century of sneaking in the shadows and you still haven’t figured out how to do it without your little magic trick? I don’t think so, old lad.

A plan had formed in his head, back at Bard’s, and even earlier, and Bilbo knew it was grisly and dangerous and would get them all slaughtered if, heaven and hell forbid, something went wrong, but it would save the people of Esgaroth from peril, and so he would have to try.

I am not a fighter, and I am small and defenceless, and so I must use the tools at my disposal to best my enemies instead. How long ago had he said that to Thorin? And now it had finally come time for him to honour his word. Hah!

He slipped his fingers inside one little jacket pocket, and then the other. He did not intend to use the Ring, and never would again.

But that did not mean he was not going to put it to work.


It was far too soon when Bilbo reached the accursed door, beyond which lay the Great Hall of Thrain; the glorious Hall of Treasures. Somehow, he was sure he’d remembered the tunnel being longer, taking him hours and hours to crawl down as if it were a doorway to the underworld and he was willingly marching to his own doom.

Oh, the smell. It smelt like smoke, like the tang of blood, the way blood tasted like metal. Like a tomb.

The door did not creak when he opened it; the air did not move, the stillness did not shift. Gargantuan walls loomed a faint scarlet on all sides, higher than any ceiling Bilbo had ever seen before or since, and they were lined with great marbled pillars that had blackened in the bitter air. The scale of such a room was not to be conceived by either Bilbo’s eyes or thoughts.

And nothing could be seen by the eye except gold upon gold upon gold.

Bilbo held his breath as he tiptoed gently down the stairs, plunged into the gold and began searching, wading through endless rivers of coin and scooping them between his fingers in a vain search for his prize. He remembered very vaguely where he thought it might be hiding, and it was a monumental ask for a person of his size to cross a hall this grand even without the obstruction of what surely must be thousands of tons of treasure blocking his path. But he kept at it, and he squinted here and there in the sinister light, and he did not let himself make a single sound.

Of course, it did not matter. Soon enough — far too soon — he heard it.

“Are you going to keep me waiting, Thief in the Shadows?”

The horror of his growl reverberated around the hall like a tremor of the earth itself, ricocheting off all the walls and into Bilbo’s skull until there were a thousand Smaugs laughing cruelly at the little hobbit and the nightmares that clutched at his shoulders. His throat was dry. He opened his mouth, uselessly; nothing came out.

“Don’t be shy — come into the light,” the dread rumble sounded. “And let me lay my eye upon he who dares steal from the King Under the Mountain.”

Bilbo stepped out from the darkness of the pillar he’d hidden himself behind, and a sliver of glowing red-gold light was cast down his side, though his torso still lay in shadow. He held Sting before him in both of his trembling hands and gripped the hilt tightly.

“I am no thief, O Smaug the Golden-scaled,” Bilbo called, his voice surprisingly steady and strong in the great awful silence of the golden hall. “I am but a traveller who has come to look upon your magnificence. Truly, no stories in all the world hold a candle to your magnitude, Most Radiant and Renowned of all the beasts of the North.”

There was silence, a silence so tense Bilbo dared not break it, dared not look upward at where he knew the dragon was unfurling from his nest and rising slowly into the air.

“A traveller?” Smaug hissed.

Bilbo nodded earnestly, head wobbling on his shoulders like a fool. He stepped entirely out from behind the pillar and let himself be seen in full by the monster, not letting his own gaze falter as he did.

“If I may be so bold, Smaug, mightiest of the drakes of Morgoth, I am in fact not just any humble traveller, but a seeker with knowledge and riches that I sincerely desire to bestow upon you. I have travelled from incredibly far away to have such an honour. And — and even now, your magnitude is beyond any I had scarcely imagined, O Smaug, Greatest and Most Terrifying of All Beings.”

“For I am so lacking in riches,” Smaug drawled, lashing his tail. Obsidian spines the size of three lengths of Bilbo’s body peppered the sides. Bilbo hastily drew his eyes away from them as Smaug spoke again. 

“And who are you to bestow such things upon me?”

Bilbo pulled his shoulders back and bit down all his fear.

“I am he who is blessed with long life. I am Luckwearer, Treasure-finder, Ringbearer, and Death-defier. I have seen the shores of immortality and turned aside. I have given my friends to mighty beasts to be eaten, and I have drowned them and drawn them alive again from the water. I have remade the very universe for my own satisfaction.”

“Such grand titles. Most impressive, Luckwearer,” Smaug remarked, and Bilbo could tell that the dragon did not believe a word he’d said, but that he had succeeded in piquing his interest all the same.

He had intentionally left out his title of Barrel-rider, for it had been his greatest fumble during his first encounter with Smaug, and he’d felt horribly guilty for long days afterwards about alerting the dragon to the people of the Lake and the aid they had given the Company, feeling that their blood was now on his hands because he had not been able to keep his warbling mouth shut.

Smaug did not have any reason to move on Laketown, this time, and though Bilbo knew he could still well assume where they’d come from and who was closest to the Mountain, he felt confident that the lure of the treasure in his pocket would be stronger. His fingers brushed once more the cloth the Ring was wrapped in.

“I am here for one other reason. I wish to offer to you, O Smaug, the Tremendous and the Terrible, something singularly worthy of such a mighty king. Something worth far, far more than all the treasure in this mountain put together.”

The drake drew himself up to his full height, his long neck arched up to the roof and the folds of his great red-black wings opening as he pushed himself above the churning sea of gold. Bilbo could do nothing but watch on, helpless, knowing with absolute certainty that he was no bigger than one of the claws on Smaug’s toes, and gritting his jaw hard against the terrifying glint in his eye. The hilt of Sting was slick between his sweaty palms.

“You doubt my wealth?”

The sound was terrible in the desecrated, lifeless hall. Bilbo started, his eyes wide.

“No, never, Your Magnificence! All have heard tell of the deeds of Smaug, the Greatest of Calamities, and even in far-away places we have heard of your unimaginable hoard of glittering gems and iron-encrusted armour.” He’d heard absolutely no such thing before he’d set foot out his door, but he wasn’t about to tell Smaug that. “That is why I have brought you such a gift. I assure you, I do not exaggerate its importance. Only you, of all beings in Middle-Earth, are fit to bear such treasure, wealthy and wondrous as you are. I can think of no other.”

The plan he’d concocted was beyond dangerous, and it was the first time in this journey that Bilbo had been truly terrified of what could happen if all went wrong. He'd more or less trusted himself so far, but now he was playing with much, much more than his own life by making a gamble such as this.

But he could not think of any other way, and so there was nothing else for it but to hold fast to the same trust.

Now was the time, when he had Smaug’s attention, when he’d been adequately bathed in flattery. He closed his eyes briefly to let out a breath and muster up his nerves, more shudder than exhale, and then quickly pulled out the Ring. 

The recoil that went through the dragon at the sight of it drew all the blood from Bilbo’s skin, until the chamber felt cold as an icy wind. His bloodshot eyes were filled with a sudden hunger, and he dragged his hulking body up through the chamber, closer and closer to the prize, nostrils flared and baring black-yellow teeth sharp as blades. His claws hooked onto the walls on either side of the room, making an awful grinding noise as they clambered up and up. His eyes were locked right on Bilbo, who stood fast against his own terror, the Ring still aloft in his hand and glinting in the chamber-light.

The fork of Smaug’s tongue lashed out like a serpent’s. He licked his lips.

“Surely you don’t need such a little thing, Luckwearer? Such a little ring. And yet, I think it will do finely in my collection. You are wise to bring it to me.” His eyes were beady, barbaric. The air was thick as melting molasses and smelt of festering smoke; it was making Bilbo’s head swim. “It is quite… precious.”

Bilbo pulled his arm down, though he kept the Ring visible, and prepared himself to invoke the dragon’s rage with every bit of stubborn determination he could muster.

“I am glad you think so,” he called out cheerfully. “But I shall not part with it so easily, Smaug the Colossal, the Wicked. I worked rather hard to find it, and I shall have to see if you quite deserve it first.”

The air itself grew warmer between one breath and the next, all of a sudden stifling within the high stone walls. Bilbo felt more than ever the oppressive sense of being underground, of being alone. It was as if he was trapped within a volcano that had not yet erupted, but was brewing and bubbling deep beneath the ground. Smaug’s underbelly was a glowing amber, each scale revealing a glimpse of the hellish insides. His chest heaved, and he crept closer still. Steam burst from his nose. Heaven, but it’s warm in here.

“Deserve it, you say?” the dragon hissed, black as ice, red as flame.

“This is no mere trinket. I cannot pass it out to anyone but those who wholly understand its worth. And actually —” Bilbo said, feeling wild now, forcing the words out through his teeth with his heart hammering so loudly it was in his ears, “I have decided that I am still quite partial to my little treasure, so you shall have to take it from me by force!”

He threw the Ring high in the air, tantalising — Smaug’s expression twisted into a righteous, bloody fury, and his wings spread; Bilbo took a running leap, jumped in the air, caught the Ring and landed hard among heaving hordes of treasure. And then he began to run.

He skidded down the mountain of gems and threw himself at the next crest, fingers grasping at the coins sliding slick out from under him like a deadly golden tide. There was crashing all around him, the dragon’s roar cacophonous, deafening, bursting through his eardrums, shaking the ground below him. Flames engulfed the chamber at his back; the heat quickly became dizzying, and Bilbo could feel himself becoming frantic. The gold was moving, churning, and Smaug was airborne, was flying, was chasing, and stone was crumbling, and Bilbo was desperately, desperately running, and before he could think at all he had made it to the stairs and was hurtling out of the Front Gate down into the water below. The cold of the plunge stole the breath right out of his lungs.

He dragged himself upright, stumbling in the moat that lay beneath the battlements and pushing sopping-wet hair from his eyes to look upward for his pursuer. His heart was in his mouth, and he half-felt as though he were having some sort of attack where the air would simply not enter his lungs. He kept himself still as a statue, trusting the blackness of the water to conceal his small shape as all at once a dreadful shadow from the depths of the earth itself flew right over his head and blanketed the night.

In the deepest distance, Bilbo could see a row of tiny figures lined up atop the ruins of the city of Dale, their silhouettes blotched against the sky. All of them were still, and each seemed to be holding a bow drawn against the great face of the Lonely Mountain. 

Bard had come.

They had devised a plan between the two of them, a plan far too flimsy and reliant upon both the skill of Men who were fallible and the desires of a creature far more ancient than they, but a plan that flared to life as the monster drew ever closer, searching in vain for the thief in the shadows.

“Dale is an old city. There will be an archer’s tower, and that is where you must go. The belly of the Mountain opens out right in front of it.

Nock your arrows. Wait as long as you can to shoot, because when you do, he’ll see you, and he will come. If… if it doesn’t work, hide as quickly as you can, and do not move a muscle, whatever you do. I will try and distract him again.”

If Bilbo planted Bard right in front of the dragon’s lair and he somehow did not hit it, there would be no one left in Laketown to defend it, and all would fall utterly to ruin. He was deeply unsettled by the fact that he had chosen to veer off the course of his first lifetime, but there was no other way about it. He had only this chance to save Laketown from the dragon-fire, and he had Bard and his black arrows, and he would have to hope that it was enough. There was nothing more he could do.

As he watched, the first arrows rained down against the iron of Smaug’s armour, and slipped straight off as if they were made of water. Not one of them did a lick of damage; Smaug did not even appear to have felt them, though he’d certainly seen them, and his rage only grew more terrible at the sight.

“Thief! Luckwearer! I will have my prize, and no Men of the Lake can stop me!” He howled, voice shaking the darkness and crashing against the face of the rock behind them so it filled every inch of Bilbo’s mind. More arrows were nocked; more were loosed. None hit their mark. Bilbo felt sick with dread; his bones felt like they had become stone. He could hear distant yells, the Men on the tower calling wildly to each other and trying to form new plans.

He’d ruined it. He’d doomed them all. Bard would be the first to go, and then so would everyone else. All because he’d tried to be so terribly clever. Because he’d thought himself above Fate itself.

Every man and woman and child in Esgaroth. Every one of his dwarves. Bilbo felt his knees buckle, and he crashed back down into the water.

The shouts grew louder, their desperation clear. He could hear the wings of the dragon beating, as deafening as a thunderstorm that cracked the heavens open. He forced himself to drag his head upward and keep on watching the massacre.

Smaug seemed to have pinpointed the ringleader of his attackers, where Bard was standing right in the middle of the line, and there he began to swoop lower, angled so his speed grew as he descended. His chest glowed red-hot with the brewing of his flame, and Bilbo’s heart thudded like three hundred drums were beating at once inside him.

He was too close now. They were goners. Freezing water seeped like needles into the legs of Bilbo’s trousers and crept up into his very soul as Smaug opened his great mouth and —

A scream like out of hell split the air asunder, shaking the Mountain and the lake and all those who dwelled in between. The dragon fell from the sky.

Bard had shot the black arrow.

Smaug’s body crashed to the ground in a terrible quake, the ruins around him collapsing to the ground under the sheer force, his cries of lamentation echoing underneath the dark, dark sky.

The Men upon the walls began to collapse against one another in relief, surely sapped of all their strength by sheer terror but blessedly — and beyond hope — alive. Bilbo could hear faint shouts again from Dale, this time of joy, and almost fell right onto his hands with the sudden force of his exhaustion and colossal, unimaginable relief.

The foul stench of brimstone was passing over the landscape, and steam was rising from the enormous carcass as the glowing chamber in his chest finally cooled.

The tiny figure that was Bard lowered his mighty bow, backlit by the shallow moon coming out of hiding once more from the clouds. He seemed to turn, back toward the Mountain, and after a long moment he raised one arm to Bilbo. 

Bilbo could do nothing else but raise one back.


The water of the River Running was freezing, and as the panic ebbed from Bilbo’s body he became aware of his lower legs growing utterly numb with cold. He clambered out of the moat awkwardly, trousers saturated and already beginning to stiffen in the chill wind at the foot of the mountain. Foamy mists rose off the water and thickened in the air with the cold, and Bilbo hunched his shoulders down against it, already berating himself for not thinking such a foolhardy plan all the way through.

Oh, yes, he thought, rolling his eyes, shaking out the water from his sleeves and wondering with a grimace if it would possibly make the situation better or worse if he took off his jacket to wring it out. Jump over the ramparts into the river and leave yourself without a way back in. That’s the way, old lad. He’d already been grievously lucky that the river had not frosted over yet.

Perhaps he could try to signal to Bard’s men? But Bilbo could already scarcely see their silhouettes as it was, and he knew he would shout himself hoarse before he could make himself heard over the wind a mile away.

It had been a weak thought anyway. He was going to have to bite down his nerves, cut all of his losses, and wait for his chance to strike.

Bilbo knew the noise of all the fire and death would have sent the dwarves into a tizzy, and that even with their vow to him they’d surely by now have abandoned their post at the Hidden Door and come dashing down into Erebor to see whether he was all right or was nothing but a charred pile of ash.

Surely enough, after a little while, Bilbo’s ears began to catch the very faintest calls drifting from the mouth of the Mountain, the smallest suggestions of his would-be rescuers racing down to join him, though they quickly became louder and louder, and grew only more frantic the nearer they came to the Gate. 

“Bilbo! Bilbo! Dori, he can’t’ve —”

“Be quiet, Nori, you’re hardly helping! Oh, if only I could get through this damnable gold —”

“Bilbo!” 

That was Fili, sounding utterly torn through with fear, and Bilbo’s still-sodden heart cracked neatly in two. He sprang to his feet from his little riverbed patch opposite the Gate and began to cry out with every bit of breath his flimsy old lungs could muster.

“Here, Fili! I’m down here! I’m alright, I’m alive, I’m in the moat, I’m —”

“Bilbo?”

“Bilbo!”

“Where’s it coming from?”

“Lads, he’s here, he’s —”

“Out of the way, you idiots!” Bilbo heard Dwalin growl, and he felt silly for being so touched.

And then faces appeared one by one over the side of the battlements, high up in the air, and Bilbo held one hand to his eyes to block out the wind and squinted up at them with a daft smile on his face. All thirteen of them were talking over each other, spluttering and shoving and shouting their what-fors and why-haves down at him with frazzled looks of panic still half-stuck to their faces. Very rarely had he seen so many eyes so wide.

“What the blazes are you doing down there?” Gloin cried, a rowdy chorus of agreements tumbling down after him. Bilbo held up his sopping-wet jacket with one hand in explanation.

“I had to give the old thing the slip!” he called back up, and heard not a few short barks of laughter at his honesty. He wrung out the jacket once more, though it didn’t do him a lick of good, slipped it on and then looked back up at his captive audience.

“I don’t suppose anyone has a rope?”

There were several grunts, and some shuffling out of sight, and then Dwalin and Thorin tossed a thick cord of black rope over the wall of the Front Gate, and Bilbo began to climb.

The wind could really only have been described as vengeful as he climbed, icy fingers battering and buffeting him every which way, eagerly pulling at his hands and clothes. The stone, too, was freezing against the soles of his feet, and his fumbling fingers felt stiff and stupid grabbing at the knots of the rope. At first, they tried to haul him up themselves, as if he were a pail of water at the bottom of a well, but the jolting movement only caused Bilbo to slip, and he very nearly dropped like a stone. He swore snappishly up at them.

They rather let him get on with it, after that.

His arms ached like he’d himself been hauling around mountain-peaks when he reached the top and clambered wearily over the battlements only to very nearly stumble right down onto the floor below, but Thorin reached out with one arm and caught him gruffly around the middle, setting him down so that he was facing all of his dwarves, white-faced and stricken, and they were all facing him.

They converged on him like a particularly lumbering hive of bees — a herd of horses, perhaps — and grabbed at any part of him they could reach, pinching and poking at his skin and hair in wondrous relief, and then Bilbo was scooped up by all of them into an enormous and distinctly dwarvish embrace, and his ears flushed right up to the points.

“Enough, enough, dear me, you’re going to crush me until there’s nothing left!” he cried, feeling suddenly giddy with relief and abated terror and probably no small amount of hysteria woven in. He couldn’t seem to pull the grin from his face if he tried.

“There’s already nothing left,” Dwalin of all people grumbled with the sort of churlish disposition that Bilbo knew secretly meant he was exceedingly relieved. “How is it you weigh so little when you eat so much, hobbit?”

Bilbo fixed him with a mighty stare and very graciously did not mention the rudeness of such a question. “Because we hobbits are not so very hardheaded,” he said pointedly, and a great roar went up around the group as they laughed at his audacity. Bilbo rather suspected there was a little delirium in their joy just as was in his, no doubt from the anticipation and fear they must all have been sitting on for several hours.

He turned back to face the battlements, and there was Thorin, watching him with an intensity that knocked Bilbo backward. His eyes were very wide, his mouth parted on a breath, and he seemed to be combing Bilbo all over, eyes skittering rapidly up and down Bilbo’s waterlogged trousers and sorry excuse for a jacket as if he might find someplace where Bilbo was concealing a mortal wound.

“It’s dead?” he asked after a moment in a gravelly voice. Bilbo nodded wordlessly, unable to summarise, and instead waved a hand in the direction of the enormous black shape marring the gentle spill of moonlight that poured out onto the barren moors between where they and Dale stood. 

Thorin looked upon what had become of Smaug for a long moment, his chest heaving. Then, he turned back to face them, and his face was lined with streaks of gold, his eyes like diamonds, every inch of it blown wide open in a way Bilbo had scarcely ever seen. He felt the bottom of his stomach do a traitorous little flip.

“You are extraordinary, Master Baggins,” Thorin said, and his smile was as radiant as the sun. “I have never met anyone like you in all my life.”

Mad Old Baggins. You’d do it all over again just to see that look, wouldn’t you?

Their celebrations went on for hours, though they had no drink, no guests and only their slim rations of food. Bilbo insisted to them over and over that he had not killed the dragon, but cries of “Our hobbit has done it!” washed over him everywhere he turned after they’d made their way back down into the great chamber of treasure, and soon Nori was gathering up dainty little gemstones of emerald and opal and alexandrite and pelting the lot of them, and Oin and Gloin were singing a raunchy drinking song with their arms linked and imaginary ales raised while the rest of them laughed and laughed. Fili and Kili dragged out all kinds of armour and long-lost cloaks of royal make from hooks upon the walls, and Thorin bestowed one upon each of them with a bowed head, donning himself his ancestral attire and that magnificent raven crown.

He turned last to Bilbo. Cloaked in blue furs and twinkling mail, he looked resplendent. Bilbo’s mouth felt rather dry, and several moments trickled past in which neither of them spoke, simply watching each other instead with seemingly-stilled breath. 

“This hobbit,” Thorin said suddenly, his voice a resounding boom around the vast hall of marble and gold, every one of the twelve remaining heads snapping towards him, “I am indebted to for all of my life. It is he who has brought the Mountain back to us. Our hobbit.” He smiled. “Our excellent burglar.”

Thorin’s eyes were alight, his smile contained but bursting at the edges with gratitude and fondness. He looked down at Bilbo, entire face lit with nothing short of wonder.

It was a peculiarly sort of expression, really, that Thorin wore on his face, like he had been awestricken by Bilbo’s craftiness and at the same time was marvelling at the fact he could still be surprised by such a strange creature. It was one Bilbo had become well-accustomed to, in both his first and second lifetimes, and had always been one of his favourites.

Bilbo looked back at Thorin, there amongst hills and pillars and endless towering piles of gold, and, beaming, said back to him, “Didn’t I tell you? The crownless again shall be king.”

There was such deep warmth in Thorin’s expression that Bilbo had to turn away.


Far, far later, when the hall had stilled and the lights extinguished, a smallish sort of creature could just barely be spied making haste across the tides of gold as silently and strategically as he was able, heart thump-thumping against his ribcage.

He cast his eyes about, racing between piles of coins and frantically levelling them as he searched for the accursed Arkenstone, knowing far too well that he was working on a very scant amount of borrowed time. The hall in the dark seemed ghostly, and the size did not help; Bilbo would have bet a fine sum of money that if you plucked the village of Hobbiton up from its place atop the Hill and lay it down again where he stood, it would have fit rather snugly inside.

After several long, tense minutes, where Bilbo likely disturbed every single prized piece of treasure in the place in his inane search and one of the Company might well have awoken and entered the room for all that Bilbo could hear over his heart drumming a death-march in his ears, a sliver of fragmented rainbow caught the very edge of his eyeline, and slowly, slowly, he turned. 

There it lay, winking at him with a thousand colours, tucked surreptitiously amongst goblets and gemstones a hill-crest or two from the far end of the hall. The opening of night air above the Front Gate had bathed the Arkenstone completely in moonlight, making it seem as if it had been placed there by all-powerful hands simply to ensure that he would see it. 

Had Bilbo been a normal burglar with no dragons or lifetimes to contend with, it would surely have taken him days upon days to find it. But as it was, he clambered his way up to the ridge and plucked it ever-so-gently from its resting place, the crystal cool under his fingertips. It was just large enough that he could hold it with one hand if he splayed his fingers wide, though it was a near feat.

Bilbo gazed upon it with trepidation, swallowing around his suddenly-dry mouth. He held no love for the jewel that had rested with Thorin in his grave, and remembered only the destruction it had wrought amongst his friends, the disaster that had befallen every one of them at the sight of it. He knew the reverence Thorin and the others held it in, that it was sacred as few other things had ever been to the folk of Durin. He did not care.

And it truly was magnificent, as if capturing the stars themselves within their own heavenly case of glass, displaying the wonders of the earth to all those who were blessed enough to see it, but looking upon it, clutching the treasure with his own hand, brought him only a deep and uneasy foreboding.

Bilbo’s eyes wandered up again to the opening of the Front Gate above the hall and atop the stairs, watching the face of the moon watch him back.

Without looking down at it, he slipped the Arkenstone into his pocket.


The last time, Bilbo had felt the touch of a pull at the sight of all that gold, coaxing him towards the tidepools of coins and cups and trinkets scattered through the halls. It was why he had first pocketed the Arkenstone; for his own gain, the dizzying lure of its enchantment and the way the pearlescent gleam of it split into a hundred thousand different colours in his fingers. He had soon shaken it off, and spent the long weeks locked up in the Mountain with the pit of dread growing heavy in his stomach, but the pull had been there all the same.

This time, he felt nothing, and for a slight moment, the very slightest of moments, he was glad to have held the Ring, if only to have had the chance to let it go. 

(For what call could gold and bright gemstones give, when you had once held the power of the whole world at your fingertips, and had cast it aside?)

He knew the ways your mind began to rot away, and your thoughts became one steady beating black heart, whispering precious, precious, precious. No piece of treasure would hold sway over him again.

They’d made camp in one of the entrance halls to the Hall of Treasures so as to be close enough to both the Front Gate and the Hidden Door, but Bilbo of course had his own suspicions as to their proximity to such twinkling treasure, and just as he’d feared, it was not long after that the fall began.

Within days of their victory, Thorin had fallen into the habit of shutting and bolting himself within the rooms of his grandfather with only Balin or Dwalin for company, sitting at what desks to be found that were unscathed by dragon fire and smoothing his hands over the wood. When he would emerge, he passed through the halls as if a spectre from a lost time, heavy cloak blanketing the ground after him and lavishing the gold as he went, and he would stand for long hours upon the platform overlooking the hall of his father, gazing out at his sea of gold and wringing his hands behind his back, over and over and over.

His expression when he did this was a puzzle; he could not seem to capture what it was that entranced him so, but rapt he was all the same. Bilbo wondered with an understanding he reviled what it was his mind could be whispering to him. He wondered if their whispers had ever sounded alike.

Thorin had become both quicker to laughter and quicker to anger with every one of them; he would smile, and just as soon as it had come that smile would fall, and his face would darken. It was as if blackening clouds had begun to gather above the Mountain, circling, spitting thunder and lightning that threatened to smite the ground where they stood.

Bilbo’s own mind was a swirling, tangled snarl of emotion from both his exertion and exhaustion, so many thoughts seeping into one another and colouring his every waking moment that he could hardly begin to pull them apart. He felt more fatigued than he ever had on the quest thus far with the burden of what he had to do, what he must try to prevent. Battle-weary, though there had been no battle, and so very tired of feeling the pressure behind his eyelids that he was almost sick with it.

The others had slowly begun to notice his hesitation, his grim, forlorn disposition, and they would look warily to him or to Thorin, and to each other, sensing that something was looming on the horizon but not quite knowing why. Bilbo’s fierce love of them caused his very bones to ache at the sight, and he felt stretched thin as a cotton thread, heart brimming so much and in so many directions that he could not do much of anything for anybody. For the very, very briefest of moments, he envied that Frodo had passed on from the shores of Middle-Earth, where the darkness could still touch.

(Later, he was so aggrieved at his own carelessness for someone he dared to call a loved one and whose time with him had ended so catastrophically that tears sprang to his eyes.)

Anger would burst forth from him in such sharp, lancing strikes that it alarmed Bilbo, and he would have to stop himself from clutching a hand to his own chest. And he knew well that it was anger borne of self-hatred, anger borne of unfairness, and guilt, such guilt, and fear, and silliest of all, anger borne of grief. How preposterous it was, to mourn someone alive and well in front of you. Why are you so sad, you mad hobbit? he would think to himself as he walked the halls, reluctantly miming his own desperate search for a jewel he already very well knew the location of. Why is it you are always feeling so terribly sorry for yourself?

But he could not help it. The gold hummed all around him, like it sensed its brethren that lay in his pocket and sang for them to be reunited. He heard Thorin’s murmurs as they echoed along the walls, my right, my prize. My precious. He could hardly stand to listen to it.

Watching him deteriorate this way was far worse that Bilbo knew now with exact recollection how it felt to fall.

He saw the pull it held over Thorin, and felt it himself like a mirrored echo. He would watch desire grow in Thorin’s eyes and feel sick at the familiarity it brought.

He would sit atop mountains of gold, turning gemstones over in his hands and wracking his faulty old brain for some way to ease Thorin’s gold-sickness, all the while knowing that the only way to break free of the hold was — impossibly — to break out of it yourself. And that was the tallest ask in all of Middle-Earth.

(Bilbo, of course, did not know that beings far greater than he had fallen to the lure of gems and treasures, and cities had been wrecked, and mountains destroyed, and the shape of the very world changed. He did not know this, and so he could not register that every bit of empathy he rightfully held for Thorin Oakenshield and Frodo Baggins should have also been turned toward himself.)

Worse still was the way Thorin would look at him. There was such tenderness in his expression when their eyes met, and he would smile softly like he’d seen something wonderful, and Bilbo could not bear to hold his gaze even once. The feel of it burned against his skin, knowing that the treasure of his heart was an arm’s reach and yet a lifetime away, knowing that it was not real, it was not him, knowing the greed and anger that lurked beneath that gentle smile. He did not know how much of it was genuine and how much was the dark possessiveness of the gold whispering over Thorin's shoulders. He could not watch something that should have been warm and lovely and secret become warped by smudged and creeping fingers.


“Enter.”

Bilbo gave the heavy door he’d been knocking at a push with his shoulder and made his way into the room, knuckles still smarting on one hand from how solid the wood had been.

Opposite him and alone sat Thorin, upright in a bareboned chair and bent forward over a muddled pile of papers that lay on the knee-high table in front of him. It was still quite early in the morning, and uncommonly dark, even as far underground as they surely were; the torches in each corner of the room burnt low, and clouds of dust floated listlessly through the pools of light they left.

One half of the room was bare of all belongings save Thorin’s little table and chair and, in the far corner, a gorgeously lustrous mahogany desk quite commanding its own attention, and the other half appeared as though a giant had woken up and taken a mighty swing at it with a battering-ram. Pages and pages of parchment and scrolls and what had once been cabinets and drawers lining the right-hand wall were cluttered about the floor, and whatever other grandness had once existed inside this room lay obliterated amongst the ruins.

It was clear in this chamber that what had not been incinerated on impact had rotted away in the century-and-a-half since the dragon had come and the dwarves had either fled or perished. It looked as if a demolishing had taken place and been only half-finished, and Bilbo was quite thunderstruck at how sad the sight made him. Even in their happiness, in their reclamation of their home long-lost, everywhere his dwarves turned lay tragedy.

This had been Thror’s study chambers in the highest days of Erebor’s splendour and majesty, and suddenly, though he had not the faintest idea at all what dwarven fauntlings looked like, Bilbo could not help but imagine a much smaller Thorin leaning up to look over the desk at his grandfather, blue-eyed and serious, determinedly watching the King Under the Mountain in all his glory and taking note of everything he did so that he might be a great king too.

“Bilbo?” Thorin said, looking up from his reading to watch as Bilbo slipped through the door and strode forward. His smile was slight, but soft, and he only let his eyes fall again once Bilbo had reached his side.

Bilbo looked over Thorin’s shoulder with cautious interest, grasping the back of the chair slightly so he could lean forward to squint down at the documents Thorin held, but upon seeing them, he turned away, jaw tensing.

He’d been half-heartedly hoping that Thorin had started to look over Balin’s contracts and calculations for their future alliance with and compensation toward the Lakemen, that somehow he had pulled himself back from drowning and was choosing of his own right-minded volition to honour his word and his deeds. 

But not one of the dozen scrolls that Thorin had in front of him contained numbers. Instead, every available space was stained with a scrawled, hasty font, like the author’s mind had been working far too erratically for his penmanship; lines and lines of text lay atop and in between one another, were cramped into corners and smudged black into the page, and every word he could see was not Common but written instead in the Khazad-runes of Angerthas.

“We have still not yet found it,” Thorin said, gaze roaming hungrily over every meaningless word on the parchment in front of him.

Even if Bilbo had not been painstakingly aware of it, there was little question what it was he was talking about; each and every member of the Company had been alternating their time on hands and knees, eagerly feeling around for the sacred jewel they so craved and brimming still with false hope. It had touched all of them, Bilbo knew, but Thorin had been taken hold of worst of all, and one by one they would wake from it until only he was left. His mind had bent utterly to it, and Bilbo knew miserably well that nothing he said from then on would turn it away.

“Well, there are rather a lot of things in this Mountain of yours,” Bilbo said shrewdly. “It’s no wonder it’s taking some time.”

Thorin chuckled, throwing his head back for a moment from his scouring of his grandfather’s last testaments. “I do not mind,” he said, thumbing the side of a faded scroll. “We are close to truly retaking our homeland. And it is you, Master Baggins, who have brought us this close.”

There was a shuffle of fabric and the creak of a chair, and Bilbo knew that Thorin had turned to look at him, but he only bit the inside of his cheek and kept his eyes trained on the rest of the room, floating about the wreckage, over the desk and the little chips in its wood. A silence grew between them.

It had not yet been so long that they had begun to feel stifled within the Mountain and its muggy, stagnant air, that they could not still take joy in the suggestion of sky and clouds and cool breeze showing itself over the distant battlements of the Front Gate, but they were a far way from the Front Gate, and no light penetrated here. He itched to free himself from this, to open up a window and look out at the world beyond for just one moment of peace.

(But they were so very deep within the Mountain.)

Instead, Bilbo ambled over to one of the torches lining the wall to watch the shadow of the flames dance languidly against the stone, a strange mirror of reeds in a riverbed. He likely should have felt terrified at the sight, considering the very recent nature of his brush with dragon-fire, but he felt only mesmerised.

“What would you have me give you, Master Baggins?” Thorin said then.

Bilbo’s attention was pulled quite away from his wallowing with haste. He spun around at once to where Thorin was watching him quietly, startled. 

“I beg your pardon?”

Thorin had risen from the chair and was making his way over to Bilbo slowly, enshrouded as he was in his navy kings’ cloak. “In gratitude,” he said, tilting his head downward and looking at Bilbo with those twinkling eyes. He seemed a tad amused, but it soon ebbed into a look of imploring, his face open and trusting and all the more painful to look upon for it. “For what you have done. What would you have me give you?”

What on Earth are you talking about, you silly creature?  

“You can’t possibly think — you have given me more than I have ever asked for, Thorin.”

Really, he’d signed a contract, and as far as Thorin was aware, Bilbo was to be receiving some sort of portion of riches equal to the rest of the Company, and no more or no less, though he was of course perfectly happy to simply swipe up that chest of troll-gold for a rainy day and be on with it.

Thorin frowned, his face darkening, illuminated strangely in the flickering light. “I have given you nothing,” he said, voice low, and Bilbo swallowed.

Perhaps this was the worst of it. That Bilbo could still see him somewhere in there, so golden-hearted, so sacrificial. Warm, and clear, and coloured with life. 

Not gone, yet. But going all the same.

Bilbo smiled, though it felt like clouds had gathered over his face, and tilted his head to the side, looking up at Thorin’s brows bent together crookedly. 

“Your friendship,” he said simply. 

The countenance of the King Under the Mountain cleared, and at length he turned and strode back toward the chair and table, stooping to gather the scattered papers and making his way back to place them on his grandfather’s desk. Though he seemed calm, his gaze had clouded over, like his thoughts were descending downward, and Bilbo trailed after him unsurely, both of them coming to a stop in front of the desk and facing each other. Thorin reached out and leant upon it with one hand, his eyes trained on Bilbo.

“Perhaps we could plant you another garden,” he said.

I beg your pardon? Bilbo had to force himself not to say yet again, stupidly. His expression must have betrayed his thoughts somehow, however, because it was then that Thorin’s eyes creased with a smile like daisies sprouting, and earthworms very suddenly dug their way up through Bilbo’s insides and burrowed themselves into his chest.

“Your garden, back in the Shire. You said it had meaning to you,” Thorin said quietly. “Will you tell me?”

One of the torches crackled gently behind them, though the rest of the room was utterly still; no noise had filtered through the door at all, and Bilbo had not the faintest idea where anybody else was, but he was surely glad there were no Balins or Dwalins around to see him becoming all afluster. He might have even been convinced once more that all was miraculously well and the tendrils snaking their way across Thorin’s chest had somehow loosened their hold, if not for the brightness of Thorin’s eyes, the fondness of his smile. 

Too bright. Too trusting. Bilbo wilted, stubbornly, painfully, and then pushed on.

“Oh, my little garden was beautiful. I planted it such a long time ago, the rings had all bled together,” he said, pushing down his ridiculous tangle of thoughts and pretending he could not hear the wobble within his own voice. “The outer circle was full of red carnations and rosemary, for symbolising remembrance and an aching — aching heart. Then white hyacinths, to carry your prayers, and in amongst them were gardenias, which tell of a secret love. Poppies for eternal sleep. Blue salvia to mean ‘I am thinking of you’, and red to mean ‘forever mine’. Purple hyacinths for forgiveness and sorrow.” 

He ducked his head. He could not look Thorin in the eye.

“Sweetpeas, which mean a blissful goodbye, and butterfly weed, which means ‘let me go’. Lilacs for moving on. And, at the very heart, well — I’m sure you can guess what forget-me-nots mean.”

When Bilbo looked up once more, Thorin was still watching him, no longer a smile on his face but the look in his eyes such that Bilbo knew if he had been given a thousand lifetimes to search for it, there would not have been a jewel within the earth he could have found that would have come close to the shine of Thorin’s expression.

It was this, oddly enough, this gentleness, that shook Bilbo out of whatever slumber he had begun to fall into, the spell Thorin was under clutching at him too, and he scrunched up his nose, letting his eyes fall from Thorin’s transfixed ones.

Enough, he thought. Enough, you simpering fool. They were not two hobbits in their twenties falling over each other with giddy smiles and silly promises. Whatever glimmered in Thorin’s eyes was not affection but fever, and whatever fanciful musings Bilbo had been letting himself fall into in this tucked-away room were nothing but fiction. An undercurrent of danger and dread lay beneath this conversation, underneath every step Thorin took in these halls that should have done nothing but welcome him home, and that wild spark of anger shot through Bilbo again so quickly it stunned him.

He closed his eyes. He turned away.

“But I’m not so sure that it would work — most of the plants are accustomed to milder climates, and you cannot find much milder than the Shire,” Bilbo said, imagining himself picking the conversation with one hand like the petal of a flower and crushing it under his heel. He turned more firmly to the doorway and made to leave — it was a foolish decision, really, to come here in the first place, and he wasn’t sure what in the world he been expecting — but again, that voice arrested him.

“The snapdragons will still grow.”

Bilbo trotted to a halt, the soles of his feet skimming the dust in the quiet of the room, and then turned back to face Thorin. “I’m sorry?”

Thorin took a step forward, so that they were once more angled towards each other. He looked over Bilbo’s face, across his hair and neck and ears, down at Bilbo’s chest, gaze glancing over the lines of his lapels and the dusty handkerchief stuffed in his breast pocket before climbing up again.

“You spoke of snapdragons, in Beorn’s garden, as did I,” he said, the baritone of his voice a crackling hearth as it settled over Bilbo. “They have grown here in the past. My sister will like them.”

He walked forward once more, until they stood booted foot to bare toe, and looked for a long-stretching moment to the now-empty table at the foot of the chair before fixing his eyes intently on Bilbo’s. “We can plant them here, Bilbo. We can transport them right from the Shire. You will have your garden all to yourself.”

Bilbo’s cheeks flushed far too warmly with affection, and with dagger-sharp anguish, and he bent his head to fumble for a moment in his jacket pocket — the right one, not the dreaded left — for his handkerchief, not pulling it out but clutching at it tightly enough that his knuckles went white.

“I’m very grateful, Thorin, but I do not much think there would be any point,” he said, brushing his fingers over the silk, scrunching, smoothing, scrunching again.

He’d completely forgotten about this handkerchief, truth be told, until he’d woken up in his little bedroom in Bag End again. He’d made all that fuss about it the first time around, hadn’t he? All that and it hadn’t mattered one bit in the grand scheme of things.

Sleek and satiny, it was, and one of his old favourites, though as he rubbed it he could feel the build-up of months and months’ worth of grime and filth from their long days on the road, and his nose wrinkled. Not good, not good at all. A wash, he thought diplomatically, smoothing, scrunching, smoothing. Needs a good wash, that’s all.  

But they had very little water and even less supplies with which to clean down here in the Mountain, so really, it was pointless to think on it at all. All that fuss! All that over a handkerchief and he hadn’t even thought to bring a spare in case it got ruined, hadn’t thought at all. He hadn’t thought, had he? He scrunched, smoothed —

— and jerked his head upward as quite without warning Thorin Oakenshield had begun to brush the unruly curls back from Bilbo’s face and up across his temple, forge-rough fingertips lingering over the point right where the skin of his cheekbone met his hair.

Immediately, Bilbo stumbled back and brought his hand up to ruffle at his own hair nervously, hoping the ridiculous length it had grown to would hide how bright his cheeks had gotten. “Oh!”

“There you are, Master Baggins,” Thorin murmured, and oh, why were his addled eyes always so confusticatingly earnest? 

Thorin pulled his hand back, though it hovered between them rather than falling down to his side. They gazed at each other for one long moment more, Bilbo making a rather valiant attempt at keeping his head aloft while his fingers fumbled and every bit of blood in his body seemed to be trying to make its way to his cheeks. Thorin looked at him steadily.

”Where do you go?” he asked quietly, warm eyes gleaming in a face so cold. “When you are remembering?”

Bilbo smiled lopsidedly at him, bright with embarrassment and tearfulness both. His face felt like paint that had cracked on a wall. Or perhaps the roots of a tree that had broken through long-dry earth to find that they had missed the rain.

“Nowhere, Master Oakenshield.”

Nowhere at all, for there was nowhere to run. All he could do was watch, and all he could do was wait.

Thorin frowned, and it changed his face, the caverns deeper, the lights extinguished. The diamond-bright smile was no more.

This time, when Bilbo turned away and made to leave the room, Thorin let him.

Notes:

thank you to everyone for your well-wishes on the last chapter! everyone who has been reading this is so endlessly lovely to me and i am so, so grateful for you all :( and thank you thank you also to my beautiful angel fairytekoo who has betaed chapters six, seven and eight for me and is a saint

i hope you all enjoyed and my twitter is here <3

next chapter up in a week!