Actions

Work Header

thunder and the riversong

Chapter 8: don’t you remember

Notes:

:)

title taken from the song “don’t you remember” by adele

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Days went by.

It was never-ending, Bilbo thought, and the thought was a dismal one. The lure of a dragon’s hoard, and the torment of its crown jewel; so strong, and so sickly.

Night and day bled and blurred into one another, smearing the mountainside in an endless, endless grey-gold haze, and a growing tremble began under foot as the Mountain began to murmur. The warm wooden halls and salt-bitten air of days past seemed nothing but a dream that had floated in and out again between Mirkwood and the Mountain. They had simply exchanged the canopy of leaves for stone.

On and on the dwarves combed the halls, weary and stumbling on their feet, sharing the burden of stalking up and down among towering pillars of gems and knocking them over to dig their fingers through the takings in the hope of finding the Arkenstone. Bilbo could scarcely stand to watch it, and had to turn his face away when it was not he himself who was putting up the flimsy front of hunting back and forth for the accursed thing. 

Each day the crevice of Thorin’s brow bent deeper, and his smile became shadowed and sunken as they came to him one by one with no news of his cherished prize. Dull bruises began to paint themselves underneath his eyes, and his head bent ever downward, so that when he would look up his gaze became menacing, and he lurked more and more in shadow.

But for Bilbo alone the clouds would part, and he would smile and say Bilbo or Our hobbit so tremendously fondly it stung at Bilbo’s sides. He could hardly bear to look at the way Thorin’s eyes darkened every day, the way he’d become twisted into a bare shadow of what he used to be, and the way his gaze fell further and further to the floor, searching endlessly for his prize and not caring at all that he was home.

He slunk as if snakelike; he had donned his raven crown permanently, and it was as though the very light in the Mountain had dimmed, as if a rot had stirred awake in the beds of the stone. The air felt sick, and rooms were thick with decay, and everything smelled moth-eaten, like a fire had long blown out and grown cold.

The Men had not yet come to bother any of them. Bilbo supposed that they’d likely been waiting on one of the dwarves to exit the Mountain themselves to make the offering of goodwill they had promised only days beforehand, and to begin discussing what sort of portions of gold they could extend to begin rebuilding Dale and the North in exchange for food and aid. They had been given no reason yet to think that Thorin Oakenshield and his kindred would not keep the word he had offered so freely. They did not yet know. 

But Bilbo did, just as he knew that this time Bard was aware that he, at the very least, had not perished in the dragon-fire, though the dwarves themselves were of course not aware of this information.

It was inevitable, then, that after one full week and then some had passed with only silence from the Mountain, the Men of Esgaroth made their first approach at twilight. Nori had espied the congregation from afar with his shining new Erebor-made eyeglass all rimmed with bronze, and called down that many of the apparent Lakemen were looking suspiciously Elven.

Just as with the reading of the moon-runes in Rivendell, Bilbo did not make his presence known at their parley through the wall and instead hid himself away in a little nook nearby, knowing already that it was only going to fan the growing flames of Thorin’s rage.

(Rather shamefully, his absence was also because he did not want to witness the look of reproach that would surely blotch all over Bard’s face at the sight of him cozied-up and cowering within the arms of the Mountain. Never mind the fact that he’d just saved dozens of Bard’s people from death by tossing himself over the battlements.)

It was true that the people of Laketown had given the dwarves aid they would have suffered dearly without at the expense of their own livelihood. They had been instrumental on the journey, sheltered them, fed and watered them, celebrated their return and given their blessing where others had only scorned or stopped them.

It was true, also, that approaching the Lonely Mountain with an army at your back and nothing of any sort of treaty beforehand could be very well perceived as a threat, and that a threat overshadowed by a dragonspun desire to protect what had once been taken so viciously would be perceived as an act of war.

The Men were right, and had every right, and yet if Bilbo thought about it at certain angles, so too did the dwarves. And so there was nothing for it, and nothing that would come of it, and a sharp revulsion curdled in Bilbo’s belly at his constantly-having to pull at the strings of his friends to move them the way he desired as if he were a terrible puppet-master. 

As it was, he heard their back and forth from the crevice in the wall he’d nestled himself in to eavesdrop; Bard’s bullheadedness and Thorin’s greed, the threat of arrows and the answering besiegement. The stamping of the feet of hundreds of Elves and Men and horses outside rocked the mountain to its roots, sending tremors skyward on all sides so that inside the walls it shuddered with a dreadful anticipation, and Bilbo’s mood soured even further. 

Truly, there were few things he found more tedious than the incessant peacocking all these Big Folk felt obliged to in order to get through business. The pomp and performance, the bruised egos and lashing of unkind tongues to lick the wounds. Curse the stubborn pride of all the races of Middle-Earth! He had not the slightest bit of time for it, cooped up as they were with nothing but reminders of what lay ahead, naught but faint flickers day in and day out that told him he could not change a thing, not just now, not just yet.

Finally, Thorin shouted down his threats of death and struck the bitter blow, and Bard stormed away with fury no doubt etching deeper lines into his ever-stony face. There was much muttering and murmuring from the Company as he departed, and Bilbo shifted impatiently inside his little nook with an exasperated huff, watching the wall for the slightest signs of movement so he could calculate the perfect approach.

After what seemed an age and a half, the dwarves trickled back down the battlement staircase and into the Hall, cursing blackly under their breath and their faces shrouded in anger, though Bilbo could see too the lingering unsteadiness that patchworked every one. 

Only three remained atop the ramparts. Thorin himself, no doubt looking out in distaste as the Men turned tail and marched back to their lines drawn in the sand, his brow pressed steeply downward by the thumb of the crown against his forehead. Standing on either side of him were not Fili and Kili, as Bilbo had first assumed, but each of the sons of Fundin, both of his seconds at the hand of their King.

When all was quiet and still, Bilbo crept out from his hiding-place, hating and yet relishing how exceedingly good at it he had become, as if all of Erebor were a maze and he alone had discovered the secrets it stretched out. Voices began to echo out once more from the Front Gate, bluntly hewing the silence.

“Thorin, you have given your word. You gave it on behalf of our kindred. That is no small detail.”

Calm and measured, Bilbo thought approvingly. No less than what he would expect from Balin. He imagined the old fellow patting his wispy beard, fixing Thorin with one of those clear-as-day looks that somehow turned your thoughts to glass in your face while he watched you with twinkling eyes.

The sudden boom of Thorin’s response was an avalanche against the mountainside. 

“You would wish me beholden to the words I made to a people who approach us unprompted with weapons and armies behind them? Who bring Elves before me, as if Thranduil and his kindred have any claim at all over what lies in this mountain?”

The stone steps wound their way back and forth, threading a stitch up the spine of the Gate until they plateaued at the top and gave way to the upper ramparts. Bilbo reached them and settled one, then both of his feet atop them as he began stealthily to climb, pressing one hand wide against the wall so he would not stumble and give himself away. He listened with a lowered head and a twisted-up face as Balin’s voice and demeanour did not change, steady as he had ever been in the face of danger. 

“If we wish to reestablish Erebor as the stronghold of the North,” he said matter-of-factly; rather bravely, to Bilbo’s ear, “it is a fact you must consider very heavily. The Lake and the Wood are our neighbours, no matter how much you may resent it. We will need them as greatly as they need us.”

Thorin’s pacing back and forth was heavy against the stone, so heavy it beat a rhythm against the floor in terrible time with Bilbo’s skipping heart.

“One hundred and seventy years I have been parted from what is mine,” Thorin whispered lowly, and the wind began to whistle louder than before, until he was almost inaudible over the din. He seemed pained, tormented, as if the yearning and grieving and gold-lust had intertwined within his very blood and become instead one terrible, monstrous hunger. As if Thorin had run his loving fingers along the edge of the ramparts and they had come back stained.

Balin made an objecting noise. “Thorin —”

Thorin spat something harshly in Khuzdûl rather than deigning to grace him with a response. There was a great sigh, and then a silence that seemed balanced on the point of a dagger, no sound at all but the eerie wail of the wind.

Bilbo crept up and up until he had reached about halfway and angled his ear to hear more clearly through the stone, tilting his head this way and that and squinting up at the ramparts far above as if it might make any difference whatsoever. 

He turned once more and abruptly came face to face with Balin opposite him, descending the stairs in the dim dusk-light.

Bilbo blanched, eyes blowing wide, and Balin held up a steady hand to put him at peace, giving him a placating sort of smile, though it was tight, and very plainly did not reach his eyes; it barely lingered upon his mouth.

A gruff voice broke the weeping wind above them.

“Are we to waste away in here until we starve?” Dwalin said, his voice darker and hoarser than Bilbo had ever heard it.

“A small price to pay, is it not?” the response bit back.

The two of them looked up from the staircase, as if there they would find the thunderstorm of Thorin’s wrath spilling over the battlements and enveloping them both in a thick fog. Bilbo pressed his mouth together and looked back down at Balin, whose face had grown even wearier between one glance and the next.

“Balin,” he whispered, “this is madness.”

Helpless. They were helpless, he felt helpless. Balin took another step down so that they were level with each other.

“Aye, laddie. I know.” Worry bloomed bright and oleander-soft in Balin’s gentle face, and Bilbo swallowed rather showily.

He could not have said what possessed him then to ask it. Perhaps it was that more than ever he felt half-lost in a memory, every moment following one another just as it had once before, a tumbling stack of cards; no matter what he did or said, an unchanging omen of coming doom. 

Drumming, drumming, in the deep.

“Have you found it?” Bilbo said. He did not need to specify what. 

“No,” Balin answered quietly, shaking his head minutely. “No, I’m afraid we have not.” He bowed his head but kept his eyes on Bilbo, imploring, and Bilbo’s breath had caught somewhere in his throat, entangling in his chest before it could find its way out of his mouth. 

They stared at each other, poised upon the half-step.

”Have you?” Balin said. His voice was softer than snowfall, and quieter than the grave. 

Bilbo opened his mouth, and nothing came out.

“We need aid, Thorin,” Dwalin ground out far above. “Allies of our own. Do we not wish to send ravens to Dain in the Iron Hills, and your sister in Ered Luin? To our kin?” 

There was a plaintiveness to his words, the bitter air half-obscuring them from Bilbo and Balin’s eavesdropping ears, that touched Bilbo far more than he had expected. If Thorin’s heart was crafted from gold, Dwalin’s beat as if lined with iron, unbroken, unyielding, and Bilbo was grateful for his fortitude.

Balin watched him, no judgement on his face, his eyebrows gently raised as if trying to coax the answer from Bilbo’s careless tongue, and Bilbo felt split in two, one half ahead, one looking back, always, always, never sure enough, never satisfied.

(For every bit of this had been horribly familiar. Bilbo remembered it, in another room, another day, and he could have whispered along to everything Balin said as if he were reciting a final testament.)

Oh, what was the point? What good could he do, when the pieces had all started to fall the same way no matter how he pushed them? It was Mirkwood all over again, it was the goblin-fight in the trees, it was the trolls and their hoard. All he touched in this mountain stayed as stone, and would not bend beneath his un-dwarven fingers.

One final rumble rang out from atop the Gate, and Bilbo’s heart drummed in time with every wretched word Thorin spoke. 

“Aye,” he said, and the clouds gathered, and dusk gave way to midnight, and still Bilbo could not alter the path that snaked through the beds. Could not turn back the fall. 

“I will send word to Dain. I will tell him to prepare an army.” 


Bilbo was perched upon the platform that stood sentinel high above the Hall of Treasures, looking out with a tight expression at the slit of moonlight still to be seen from afar atop the Front Gate. He was quite alone, and quite muddled up in his melancholy thoughts. The world was black and white over the barricade of the Front Gate with night sky and star, awash in a monochrome film, and if he concentrated Bilbo could almost see the faraway movements that had begun in Dale, the little lights that told of the growing numbers of the army surrounding them. Even from here, they could feel the frost sweeping in and the stone walls trapping the cold, and Bilbo wondered with a shiver how the dwarves had kept Erebor warm through every winter in the past. All those forges, he supposed.

A crunch of boot sounded out suddenly behind him, and he spun with his stomach somewhere down around his knees to find Thorin Oakenshield on the step, one silver-cuffed hand grasping the doorway and his eyeline following Bilbo’s out across the golden expanse below them.

Bilbo’s hands went to his pockets in a panic, nonsensically, until he remembered he had hidden the stone away days beforehand and tried to play off the movement as if he was readjusting his lapels with what must surely be a primrose-pink face. He settled, then squinted.

Thorin looked terrible. Dark hollows had settled themselves underneath his eyes, and though they had not yet been locked away long enough to feel the effects of hunger, his cheeks were becoming gaunt, everything about him seemingly sharpened beneath a whetstone. His skin was pale and greying in the perpetual shadow of the closed city, so much so that it appeared almost waxy, and his hands were closed to fists at his sides. And still, still, he wore the raven crown.

“Bilbo,” he murmured, eyes lingering a moment more on the vastness of his riches before drawing themselves to him. Bilbo stilled, and swallowed.

“Hm?”

Thorin took a step closer, letting his hand fall from the wall. He did not move as a proud leader would, nor a warrior; every movement was stilted, hunched over, as if his kings’ cloak had brought down weights upon his shoulders.

He reached inside that cloak and drew from it a small bundle of silver, and Bilbo’s breath stuttered, his eyes surely growing to the size of tea-saucers.

Oh, he thought, rather bittersweetly. Oh, of course.

“I wish for you to have this.”

And of course he knew what it was going to be before Thorin unfolded and held up the glittering shirt of mail, dark eyes resting intently on Bilbo’s face.

It truly was beautiful, exquisite beyond any conceivable notion of the word, the mithril glimmering spectacularly in the light of the few torches they had lit along the walls. Bilbo almost reached out to touch it, to run his fingers across stones he’d so cherished, and then fought madly with himself to keep his hands by his side. He caressed it tenderly with his eyes instead.

Here is where I took a knife, he thought, and here is where Frodo took a trollspear, if he’s told me correctly. And here is where I got knocked quite hard in the back with a rock!

He looked at the collar swooping in a sleek curve underneath the back of the neck, and the shoulder woven with truesilver like silken threads of starlight. Two wounds the shirt had not saved.

Bilbo wrinkled up his nose. Enough reprimanding. He should be steeling himself against such thoughts. There wasn’t any time for them now. He’d done what he could, hadn’t he? He had not been himself, had barely been anyone at all.

And he had not made the shirt. He’d only passed it on. He would have coated every single inch of Frodo in mithril if he’d had even a smidgen of the means.

“Have what?” he said instead.

Thorin leant closer, the entire line of his body bending towards Bilbo as if he were a sunflower quenching its thirst for sunlight. His eyes were so bright, so charming, even worn down as he was. And the most awful thing was that he looked so terribly happy.

“You say you will not plant your garden, so I would ask you to take this. A token, of our friendship. It will keep you safe.”

Bilbo shot him a quick smile that must have looked like someone had trodden on his foot and did not ask Thorin what the mithril would keep him safe from. He knew Thorin would not have an answer.

He could not take it. How could he take it?

(But it was his, and it was Frodo’s. To accept it felt tainted, but he was a fool beyond all fools if he did not and then ran headlong into battle not a fortnight from now.)

“It is mithril. The most beloved metal of my people,” Thorin said softly. “It cannot be pierced by blade, bow or spear.”

He was holding it aloft, expression glowing as he watched Bilbo, and Bilbo cast his eyes downward, feeling suddenly far too tired.

“Thorin, I’m not worth all this,” he tried.

A flash of something sparked in Thorin’s eye, and as was the case more and more often these days, Bilbo could not tell what it was. Dark, and prideful, and greedy.

“You would doubt my sincerity?” The voice was cold, quiet. Something about it raced up Bilbo’s spine, one uneasy lick that had all the hairs on his arms and feet standing on end. His throat dried out, and he did not speak.

Thorin’s mouth twitched, and the facade fell, just for a moment, the fangs lengthening in his mouth, the black in his eyes. His face was half-bathed in darkness, concealed in shadow. 

The facade. But it wasn’t a facade, was it?

“You are loyal, Bilbo,” Thorin said, and Bilbo could almost see with his own eyes the warring within him, the bobbing of his throat, the shoulders so stooped it was as though vultures had preyed themselves upon his raiment. “You — I am… drawn to you. I cannot trust any other, it seems.”

He held out the shirt of mail again, and Bilbo took it with trembling fingers, removing his coat and slipping the mithril gently over his head. It lapped at his skin like water at the banks of a stream, and Bilbo marvelled at it even still, that forged steel could be so delicate and yet so strong.

He pulled his curly head through the collar, replaced his jacket and looked back up, feeling inexplicably lost at sea, and it was then that Thorin curled down over Bilbo and whispered, as Bilbo had known and dreaded he would, “One of them has stolen it.”

His eyes lowered to Bilbo’s chest, to his collarbone, where the diamond gleamed from beneath his jacket. They lingered there, dark and heavy, before Thorin pulled them up once more to rest them on his face.

“Thorin,” Bilbo said, steadying himself, “how can you be sure?” Speaking with Thorin like this felt as if he were sneaking around the den of a bear. Thorin’s lip twisted in disgust, and he shook his head, striding towards the edge of the platform and staring out unseeing at the golden sea and its black horizon above.

“I cannot make treaties with Elves nor Men nor my own kindred,” he said, with such venom in his voice that had Bilbo not heard it before he would have flinched. “They would all seek to steal from me. Allow enemies to gather at my door to pick at my spoils.”

There was no our in his speech, no camaraderie or care for the Company any longer. There was light in his eyes, but only in bursts, and only for that which had grown itself from evil. A dread-filled sort of resolve began to unfurl itself deep in the pit of Bilbo’s stomach.

He looked to Thorin once more, his broad shoulders and back to Bilbo, standing arrested at the sight of the Hall of Treasures. Lit by the light of but a few lanterns, hands clasped behind his back, dark cloak, dark hair, dark circlet atop his head, dark sky looming before him. He was blinded, deafened, to everything around him but his terrible, terrible fixation on the gold.

(Oh, but he looked like a painting. A painting of war. Of when the world fell apart.)


Bilbo found himself almost scampering away in his haste, chest heaving like he’d run a mile in a millisecond. He did not know if Thorin had even heard him go.

He tucked himself away in some offshooting corridor — where it was exactly he didn’t know and did not much care, as long as he was far away from that unbearable hall and its dreadful platform — and leant his head backward until it pressed against the cool stone, closing his eyes.

There was nothing lovely about Thorin like this, no matter how saccharine his words might be. The gold had run its slippery fingers all over him, had drawn him entirely under, and it was more difficult than ever to watch him when Bilbo now knew how it felt to succumb, too. 

He longed to draw Thorin into the circle of his arms until his head was pressed against Bilbo’s own chest, to kiss his nose and mouth, to pull his mind from his head somehow and wash it clean with his own fingers. Lay down your head, my dear, he wanted to whisper. Close your eyes, just for a moment. 

But this helplessness was familiar and counted upon, and Bilbo grounded himself with it. His fingertips tapped against the wall gently, and he concentrated until he had slowed his breathing, and thought with a pang of the mantra of years long passed, the waking thought that had beat in his sternum and speckled all of his memories.

What do I do now?

Laying the table for one and wondering why it felt like he’d forgotten someone when nobody else had ever been there. Watching the colours in his garden bloom, the petals floating through the air as they fell from their stems at the change of the seasons. 

What do I do now? 

Feeling like every day had come to a complete stop, like he was holding his breath until the next adventure, like his house was far too still with quiet he wasn’t used to, and wondering how he was ever meant to move through the space when something was now so clearly irreplaceably missing. 

What do I do now?

At first it had been helpless heaving, sobbing, choking, and water had filled and flooded his lungs, and it was all he could do even to take a step. Over time, it changed, to a cry, then a stutter, then a whisper, and then to a thought, and the thought had changed its shape as it travelled companionably along through the years with him.

I love him.

I love him.

One foot in front of the other, that’s the way.

Oh, I do miss you terribly some days, Thorin. I hope you’re sleeping soundly.

I spoke to the oak tree today.

And today.

And today as well. She’s always kind to me.

The sweetpeas were a nice touch, I think. You’d have liked my lilacs, too.

Frodo-lad, if you had done that to a pair of Thorin’s boots, he’d’ve glared at you so hard you’d have fallen over, and I would have laughed and laughed.

Isn’t it warm in the sunshine, my dear?

He could bear it no longer. He had to go.

Bilbo would not argue himself away this time with talk of shares and a fourteen-way-split. He knew it did not matter. And he would not keep on waiting around again and wasting precious time feeling sorry for himself so that they could all half-starve in the siege. If less time had passed for Thorin to stumble around and gorge himself on the sight of gold, there might have been less time for the gold-lust to grow, and it might be easier to snap him out of it.

(Wishful thinking, he knew, but he wished for it nevertheless.)

He did not truly know what had woken Thorin from the stupor the first time. Whether it had been the roaring of battle, or the real danger of masses upon masses of his kin falling among the slain, or the force of Bilbo’s betrayal itself, the way the film over his eyes had seemed to tear in two as Bilbo spoke. He did not know how to go about waking him again, but he’d spent the entire second journey relying on luck and the grace of a second chance, the peace promised to him at the end. So though he had been able to change nothing in all their time in the Mountain, he supposed he could not very well shake his faith now. 

He’d done what he could. He was doing all he could. The world would just have to do the rest. 

Bilbo knew he had fortitude enough that to betray Thorin a second time would not break him. But seeing him this way was like drinking a wine when you knew it had been poisoned; he seemed half-drunk on his own gluttony, and Bilbo felt half-drunk on watching him. It caused him to wonder how foolish he must have been when he’d chosen to do this the first time.

Yes, I’ll just pop down to the enemy’s tent and slip them the most prized possession in all of Middle-Earth backwards or frontways and be on my merry way because I hold this flimsy little paper contract that tells me I’m allotted some coins of my own.

He had known Thorin would be angered. But he could never once have guessed at the depth of betrayal Thorin would feel, with dragon-sickness and gold-hunger amplifying every emotion a hundredfold, like a cord between them had snapped and every memory the fourteen of them had ever shared vanished like smoke.

You naive hobbit. You utter, utter fool. 

Bilbo looked down at his hands. Hands shaped for tilling earth, and which had instead spent their time touching paper and pen, the leather spines of books. Hands that stole jewels and wielded swords and wore rings.

How cruel of stories, that the worst had to come so near to the end. How cruel that he could not simply turn the pages faster.


Later that night, Bilbo crept up to the battlements of the Front Gate to find that it was Bombur’s turn on watch, and he was sitting with his back against one of the outer pillars, watching the sky span out above the ramparts and puffing pleasantly on a pipe. 

Bilbo’s nose twitched at the sour tang of the smoke. Awful taste in pipeweed, these dwarves. He would have to get as large a shipment of Old Toby to the Mountain as he could manage, when everything was all over, and then see what they thought of that.

“Evening, Bombur.”

Bombur’s face was red and jolly when he turned around, and he smiled at Bilbo brightly. 

“Hello, Bilbo!”

These dear friends, Bilbo thought. The dearest friends a hobbit could ever ask for. The Arkenstone he’d retrieved earlier that evening felt even more like a leaden weight in his pocket, a ticking clock counting down to the dreadful fall.

“I was just coming up to see how you were faring. I can take the early watch, if you’d like. I haven’t been sleeping well, and I may as well put it to some use, I think.” He could sense the dark coil of rope tucked behind the wall of stone like a grease-burn against his back. He’d already secured it to one of the pillars the very night Smaug had fallen.

Bombur sat up straighter and adjusted the braided loop of his beard against his front. “Are you quite sure? I am tired, but I don’t mind taking my turn watching, even if it is dreadfully cold up here.” 

He was right. It had still only just turned winter, but the cold bite of the wind was relentless, and tore at the sides of the Mountain as if trying to scrape them all away and leave the rock exposed. It only set Bilbo’s resolve more that he had to get the whole thing over with as soon as he could. He couldn’t stand to keep all of them cooped up in the dark for longer than they needed to be, with no food or water or warmth to be found.

“I am sure. I’m likely to be awake all night, at this rate, and it is quite useless if more of us go without sleep than we need. Get some rest, my dear fellow.” He’d sat down next to Bombur against the pillar, and he brought his hand up to rest lightly on the dwarf’s shoulder. “I can wake you at sunrise, if you’d like. Somehow, I don’t think we will be hiding out in here much longer.”

“I hope you’re right. What I wouldn’t give for a stiff drink and a bed to lie down on after a hot meal!” Bombur exclaimed heartily. He clambered to his feet and peered down at Bilbo, looking suddenly worried. “Try to stay warm, Master Baggins. There aren’t any blankets down in the Mountain, but you might freeze up here.”

Bilbo crossed his legs on the ground in front of him and pulled his pipe out of the inside of his coat, fiddling with it in his hands. He’d run out of pipeweed to smoke in Mirkwood, and he wasn’t setting a single toe near that horrid stuff his dwarves used. He smiled wearily up at Bombur, not really focusing on the conversation anymore. 

“I’ll be okay.”

Bilbo waited until Bombur had left and the quiet had settled to tiptoe over to the turret-edge and slip down the rope, his feet utterly silent against the stone, barely breathing until he was far, far down the face of the battlement wall and hidden in the shadows.

He made the slightest splash as he hit the water, and he stilled, not even daring to exhale, knowing there was every chance one of the dwarves would come to check on him and peep over the wall to see him making a hasty and very visible escape. Then, when nothing had happened, he waded over to the edge of the moat and climbed out, eyes fixed on the lights of the camp in the distance, and he began to walk.


“Bilbo Baggins.”

The long-awaited voice of Gandalf the Grey rumbled over him as Bilbo lifted the flap of the largest tent in the camp and was met with the faces of three of the most important persons in Middle-Earth. The Elvenking and the Dragonslayer both watched him shrewdly, though Bard’s gaze held a touch more trust within it, but Gandalf’s eyes were warm with relief as they looked upon him. He shook his head, his face far wearier than it had been only weeks before, the ancient grooves somehow deeper. But he smiled tiredly at Bilbo, and said only, “You are a sight for sore eyes.”

“This is the halfling, then,” Thranduil said coolly, angling his head downward to gaze upon Bilbo, who came to only his hip. His eyes held a strange, potent sort of glow in the flickering light of the lantern placed on the table between the three of them, and his crown no longer held berries and autumn leaves; instead, it was tipped with everlasting droplets of ice, crystalline and silver-white against the long shards of oak. Bard, clad in a dark, ramshackle sort of winter coat, simply nodded at Bilbo in lieu of any greeting, and Bilbo could hardly blame him; a Glad to see you haven’t been burned to a crisp, dear fellow would have felt a little weak after having been on such extreme tenterhooks. He cleared his throat and stood very straight.

“You’re all gathered here already, so I shall get this over with as quickly as I am able,” Bilbo said stiffly. No use drawing out the inevitable with talks of suspicion and distrust and how many archers to line the walls of the Mountain with. He bowed his head quickly to Thranduil, a little abashedly, glanced once more at Bard, who simply watched him back, and then drew the Arkenstone from his pocket. In the torchlight, it looked as if it had been set ablaze.

All of their eyes snapped to him, and Bilbo was struck in the chest with equal gazes of confusion, worry and fascination. Thranduil took a step closer to the table, the sweep of his green-gold robe circling at his feet, and tilted his head to the side so the icicles upon his crown glimmered as if in flame.

“The Heart of the Mountain,” he said curiously.

Bard's eyes lay upon it for several long moments, and then they slid slowly to Thranduil, and then to Bilbo and Gandalf. His expression was solemn, grim, yet starkly determined. Bilbo could almost see the cogs working inside his head, and he did not pull his own gaze away, swallowing down his own apprehension.

“How is this yours to give?” Bard asked.

Bilbo reddened at once, and stubbornly ignored it. “It is — well, it’s not, if you truly must know, but I hope you will forgive me for it. There is nothing else to be done, and there is no other way to go about it. I have been thinking on it for far longer than you know.” He clasped his hands firmly behind his back and began to pace.

“I was hired as a burglar, and a burglar I have been. I am afraid I, uh —” he coughed, “burgled a set of keys and a dozen barrels from your halls so as to escape with,” he said delicately, looking to Thranduil as untouchable as amber opposite him, the shadows flickering across his angular face in the candlelight. “I have stolen this so that you may make an offering of peace and trade with it. I cannot watch much more of this nonsense go on, and I will not let them starve needlessly in that mountain when I can put a stop to it anytime I please by handing over that jewel. I cannot bear to lengthen their pain. It is tearing me apart inside, to see him this way and know there is nothing I can do or say that will pull him back from such madness.”

To know that I must betray his trust, he thought, but did not say. That I must watch whatever care he held for me break apart in his eyes.

“You have become quite wise, in all your adventures, Bilbo Baggins,” Gandalf said, looking down upon him intuitively, and the corner of Bilbo’s mouth tugged upwards.

“Oh, I’ve been wise for quite a while, Gandalf,” he said, managing the smallest of teasing tones as their eyes met fondly. “You ought to pay more attention.”

Thranduil was staring at him strangely, and Bilbo’s throat seized up, and he thought for one dizzying moment that maybe the Elvenking sensed it, that he knew. That he saw through all of Bilbo’s grand declarations dressed up in pretty words and knew what it was they concealed underneath, just as Elrond had known.

But Bilbo held his gaze, and tried to challenge him with his eyes as best he could, and Thranduil did not speak, though he watched Bilbo for the rest of the night as they discussed in muttered voices what they should do with their sudden hobbitish advantage.

When Thranduil came to stand beside him much later that night, the two of them silent figures in the doorway of the tent and looking out across the still-coming dawn, Bilbo’s poor stomach had just about set up a permanent residence in his mouth, and he dared not say a word for fear it would fall out on the floor.

He’d braced himself as much as he was able, and tensed at the inevitable bearing of his secrets from another’s mouth as if he had no right to his own mind and whatever oddities lay inside of it. No Elf was going to catch him unawares again, that was for sure, not even the King of the Greenwood.

“You love him.” 

Oh, dear. A clever little fool you are, aren’t you?

Bilbo was suddenly exceedingly glad for the atrociously messy state of his hair at that moment; it lent him a discreet cover so the Elvenking could not see his ears staining themselves red as raspberries.

He hadn’t ever once considered the possibility of somebody else speaking it aloud, least of all Thranduil himself. Not the truth of Bilbo’s mind but the truth of his heart, the rich green blooming within his chest.

And really, it was entirely unsurprising, now that he thought about it properly. Bilbo knew he was not subtle with his feelings and gave them away freely, and he knew that the only reason more hadn’t figured it out was that they’d barely had the time to sit down and notice. But it was clearly not a question, in either Thranduil’s words or in Bilbo’s mind, and he was glad. It had been a truth of his life for nearly a hundred years, and it was relieving, so relieving, to hear the truth aloud.

The sky is blue, the grass is green. The Green Dragon is packed on Sunday afternoons. Thorin Oakenshield is dead. 

But by the heavens, did Bilbo Baggins love him.

“Yes,” Bilbo said quietly, his arms folded. “Very deeply.” He glanced at Thranduil surreptitiously out of the corner of his eye.

“Does he love you?” He seemed intrigued, if not entirely invested. A simple question of bland curiosity that nevertheless hit Bilbo between the shoulderblades as though it were an arrow.

“I’m not sure.”

No.

Bilbo was very sure. He had never had Thorin in the first place, not as the bearer of his heart, not as one who loved Bilbo with all the quiet intensity that Bilbo had loved him. It didn’t matter at all.

“If I were you, halfling, I would not think the worst,” Thranduil said, his voice thick and syrupy, “but then again, neither would I think the best.” 

A typical Elvish answer. Bilbo smiled brokenly and tilted his head back to look up at the stars, glimmering like fireflies against the great cloak of midnight. It was some time before he spoke again.

“It’s quite all right. It’s nothing I haven’t dealt with before.”

And to Bilbo’s surprise, when he looked up at the King, his ancient eyes held in them true sadness.


His venture back to the Mountain was swift, and he climbed the rope quick as a dormouse, tucking it away and tip-toeing down into the sleeping area to rouse Bombur with the guilt pressing steady as ever on his chest. It was almost as if it had started to congeal, or tighten, vines twisting in all amongst his lungs and weighing down the beating of his heart so he could hear each individual thump slow in his ears.

No more was there time for garden-flowers and stories, or smiles that lit the air like they held in them magic. The precipice was fast approaching.

All the next day Bilbo sat chewing the skin off his lips, gnawing his thumbs to the quicks of his nails as the waters churned, brewing and brimming till they were about to break. He stumbled around in a haze, trying to keep out of sight, and shying away from anyone who cast a fond look his way. He could not bear it.

He concealed Sting in the same crevice where his rope lay and then stared out across the ramparts at the ground far below, the white Elven tents that dotted the desolate land intermingling with the beige-and-brown marquees of Men. The Elvenking’s sat in the very centre of the camp, larger than any other and drawn with thin golden lines along the edges and down through the folds, and as he watched Bilbo saw a pointed grey hat emerge from within and make its way nimbly into a russet-coloured tent nearby. Above them all ravens had begun to circle, their inky pinpricks against the sky indistinguishable from carrion-birds.

A wretched hopelessness came over him then, perhaps brought on by the wind, and his face crumpled.

Oh, all of this was pointless. It had been pointless the first time, and he had tried to stop it as best as he could, and yet it had happened anyway, to nothing but sorrow and ruin. Bilbo wished with an acrid bitterness that he could have done something more to prevent the coming confrontation, that the cleverness he’d been so boastful of their whole journey here had come to any amount of use at all, blessed as he apparently was with foreknowledge. Perhaps he should have beaten everybody’s heads together until his message somehow got through their thick skulls!

(But he knew well by now that that was not the way of things, much as he might resent the fact. And it would have been no small feat, to change the tide of a war, let alone to prevent one altogether.)

He remained atop the battlements, too sick with dread to even consider climbing back down the winding staircase, until at long last horns were blown and the two armies outside the Lonely Mountain called once again for their parley. Bilbo grit his teeth and made his way over to gather with the rest of his dwarves on feet that felt instead like heaping bags of sand.

Thranduil and Bard rode to the front and called their greetings up to the Company; Thorin met them with jeers and scathing condemnation, the cloak of his forefathers hanging limply across his shoulders and gathering like a dead thing at his feet.

“You would return so soon after your first attempt to pillage us, then?” he snarled. Bright anger leapt into all the lines of Bard’s face.

They questioned back and forth — exchanging blows, as it were — of debts and alliances to uphold, and of unjust shows of force against a small people with no army. The voices of the three parties all rather washed over Bilbo, who instead was trying in vain to calm his hammering heart, feeling his sweaty palms slide against his trousers.

It would be all right. It was going to be all right. He would be fine. He remembered this moment more clearly than almost any other, and had come out the other side, hadn’t he? No matter how it went, they were nearing the end of all this.

Bilbo heard them, then. The dreadful words. The intakes of breath all around him.

The Elvenking held aloft a white jewel that caught the daylight and cast it all about, like sun-golden leaves unfurling from the most divine of flowerbuds. It was bewitching, and more than beautiful, and seemed to chill the very air.

“And what of the Arkenstone?” Thranduil’s voice rang out as he clutched their most sought-after prize, the sacred, stolen, beating heart of the Mountain and its King.

The sight sent a recoil through the thirteen he stood with, as if they had all been lashed as one. Outrage broke upon their faces, and they began to call down to the Elves and Men who had besieged them, calling them thieves and backstabbers and betrayers.

A cold and bone-deep resignation filled Bilbo to bursting, and he let all of the screwed-up tension leave his body in a flood. 

“It is impossible,” Thorin hissed.

Never had Bilbo so felt the severance of his two lives as profoundly as he did then.

Oh, dear one. My dear one.

Forgive me.

“It’s quite possible, actually,” Bilbo said. He stepped forward, and his voice did not waver, not even as every eye above and below turned onto him until he had a captive audience all to himself. “They got it from me.”

It was as if what little sun they could see winked out, and all that was left was a cold light, as Thorin turned his look of loathing from his attackers and onto Bilbo.

“You.”

The malice in him was indescribable, and the downpour drew ever closer, its long fingers touching the tips of the clouds and crackling like lightning in the air. Bilbo kept his chin upright and looked Thorin in the eyes evenly as he spoke, not raising his voice, not cowering in fear as the cold-marbled face bore down on him.

“I promise you, Thorin, that I did not take the stone as an act of betrayal. Only as an act of necessity.”

The air was still around them, and yet it was howling, weeping, whipping at them with a viciousness Bilbo could hardly feel, caught as he was in the eye of the storm. Thorin’s fingers had curled into fists, and his shoulders and head were bent deeper than ever.

One last wobble tried in vain to run a thumb across his jaw, but Bilbo squashed it before it could with the stubborn grit of his teeth. He had dug the roots in. He would see it through to the bitter end.

“Kili, nock an arrow,” Thorin said.

Bilbo watched Kili’s eyes widen in panic and his head whip sideways to stare at Thorin next to him, whose blade-tipped gaze was levelled on Bilbo with such contempt that Bilbo felt thorns growing in his lungs and threading all through his stomach, strangling the breath from him as they wound their way around his ribcage and burst through his chest.

What do I do now? What do I do now?

Almost there, old lad. It was this he’d been preparing for all this way, this that he had tripped and stumbled through every futile attempt at changing the course of the journey for, though he may as well have been wailing on the wind himself for all the good he had done since the ghastly dragon had been dealt with. It had been like Thorin was dying in front of him, his valour and selflessness and his ability to ceaselessly endure all ebbing away as the dragon-sickness sapped at his mind.

And Bilbo had had him back for so little time before he’d been taken away again.

“Kili.”

Kili stepped forward guardedly, boots crunching on the rock in the aching silence, and drew his bow, pulling the arrow taut against the string. Bilbo could see his lip trembling, and the subtle shake of his hands.

“It’s alright, Kili,” he said softly, looking Kili right in the eyes.

“Shut up, thief,” Thorin spat.

“Thorin,” Kili murmured, his lips pressed against the string of the bow, his eyes never leaving Bilbo’s. “Thorin, think for a moment. This is Bilbo we’re talking about. Bilbo. Our hobbit.”

“Our hobbit,” Thorin laughed, humourlessly, the words dripping like venom from his tongue. “This rat, this sneaking, festering vermin, is nothing of mine.” He turned to look at Kili, and his face had never been so cold as it was then. He had become utterly encased in stone once more.

“Get rid of him.”

Kili was staring at Bilbo, and his fingers were shaking terribly on the string now, his whole face white like he would faint at any moment. Bilbo watched him apologetically, and tried to give him a thin-lipped smile. 

Then, quite suddenly, Kili took one step to the side and shot, the arrow sailing over the battlements and away into the distance of the mountainside. All the Elves and Men gathered in front of them watched it fly as one.

Kili lowered his bow and stepped backwards, never lowering his gaze, and never looking at Thorin. “I won’t do what you ask,” he said quietly, and Bilbo felt his heart splinter inward.

Thorin’s rage at once seemed to swell before them, his jaw harsh and unyielding against his face as he stalked towards Bilbo, shoulders back, head aloft, a portrait of the King Under the Mountain that had been blurred in water. He reached to his side and drew the long Elven blade he carried from its sheath, the curve of it almost beautiful in the pale winter light. Orcrist.

He stopped only a couple of paces away from Bilbo, sword held straight out in front of him like a line directly to Bilbo’s heart where it was hammering away inside his chest. They stood facing each other, Thorin’s eyes black as the moon, Bilbo’s shining with emotion that had been cooped up in his weary heart for so long, so long.

Bilbo took one last shaky breath, and then stepped up until the point of the sword was pressed directly against his chest.

He looked Thorin dead in the eyes. They were wide and frenzied in his sallow face, his lips just barely parted in disbelief, and the raven crown sat high on his brow, pulling the dark hair back from his forehead so it spilled out behind him in a never-ending sea. But when the tip of the blade pressed against his clavicle, there came a crystal chord like the clinking of windchimes, and all the tendrils ensnared them both as the look in Thorin’s eyes contorted down to a knifepoint.

“You wear the mithril I gave you.” He said it like he’d said everything in recent days, half-hearted and hollow with paranoia and callously barked out, like he was ever trying to figure out which of his Company would betray him next. Bilbo held his head high as he answered, and did not let his voice falter.

“It was a gift from you, as much as you may regret it now, for not so long ago you believed I had done enough to be deserving of it. It would be rude of me not to.”

Thorin’s lips pulled back in a hellish snarl, and the washed-out white of the sky behind them only illuminated his bared teeth, lengthening the longer Bilbo could stand to look.

“It is too good for you, traitor.” And he lunged forward and grabbed Bilbo by his collar, yanking him upwards until they were nose to nose and Bilbo had to rise up on the balls of his feet to touch the ground. Thorin’s gaze flickered between each of Bilbo’s eyes, fenced as they were behind ridiculous curls, and it truly was as if a wild animal had taken over. A monster wearing Thorin Oakenshield’s face.

I cannot wake you up from this, love, Bilbo thought brokenly, even as he tried to wriggle free of the iron grip Thorin had on him, and as he drew Orcrist upward once more in a graceful, gleaming arc until it was pressed deftly against the line of Bilbo’s throat. You have to find yourself again. Find your way out of the hold it has on you.

It was like watching a mirror of what he himself had almost been, what he could have turned Frodo into, what he had seen in the dreadful, sickening creature that lurked beneath the depths of mountains far away, and against all his wishes Bilbo began to feel tears run hot and glassy down his face.

They had all become so very entwined, and he could not watch one more moment, could not bear to see every inch of his lifelong guilt play out like a nightmare in front of him.

“Don’t you dare cry, like you deserve to, miserable sneak,” Thorin hissed. “You, who are spineless, and lack all faith, and still you cower in front of me like a dog!”

Bilbo bent all of his will into a glare, aconite anger catching and alighting within him even as tears still ran down his cheeks. “I am not cowering in fear, King Under the Mountain,” he said defiantly. “I simply cannot watch you tear yourself apart.”

He slid his fingers up to the wrist of Thorin’s hand that held the blade, feeling his thundering pulse, grasping it underneath his own and squeezing, trying in desperately-familiar vain to wake him up.

“You do not need this gold, Thorin. It will do nothing for you that it cannot do for the people of Laketown.”

“That is very well for you to say, burglar, when you have never known hardship or hunger a day in your life! I have spent decades in the Blue Mountains, working tirelessly for my people, and I deserve —”

“Then where is that king now!” Bilbo cried, and he hadn’t meant to raise his voice, but he could not help it, could not watch Thorin decaying before his very eyes like this a moment longer. “Where is he, Thorin, because he is not you!”

At once, Thorin stumbled back, letting go of Bilbo’s collar and swinging Orcrist away so it hung pathetically at his side. His chest was heaving; he looked as if he had been knocked backward. Great moons for eyes hung in the hollows of his face, huge and tormented and lost in the fever that had taken him, and a milk-pearl sheen had engulfed them, almost as if he were… as if he…

Bilbo reached up to brush his fingers quickly over the skin of his own throat. He pulled his hand away and looked down. It came back clean. 

Even after all that had happened, he still had not drawn blood.

He looked up determinedly, marching forward a few steps. If Thorin Oakenshield was going to shake the beds of the mountain, then he was going to burst its banks right back. “There is a sickness upon that treasure, Thorin. It lies heavily upon the Arkenstone, and you must let it go to heal your mind! It is destroying you!”

Those beloved eyes narrowed in hatred. “And what would you know of sickness, of gold?”

“More than you!” Bilbo screamed. “More than any of you, how many times have I told you, I know what I am doing! I had to take it from you!”

His breathing was ragged, the frostbitten air screaming and shredding at his lungs, throat raw and stitched back together with white-hot needles. His head had begun to swim, and he started to thrash as Fili grabbed him from behind and held his arms tightly. Tears sprang anew to his eyes like lost dewdrops.

“If I had to steal from you a thousand times, I would! I didn’t know what else to — What was I supposed to do, Thorin? You don’t know — you stubborn fool — I had to watch them bury you, and then I had to walk away!”

He clawed at the grip Fili had on him, stamping on his foot, not tearing his gaze away from Thorin, always Thorin, who had stilled quite suddenly and was staring at him as if he had never met him before, the fire in his eyes all but out.

“You have to wake up, Thorin Oakenshield, or this madness is going to take you, and it’ll be too late to save you, and I am going to lose you again, I cannot watch you fall again!”

The arms wrapped around him let go, and Bilbo stumbled forward, the force stinging his feet. Fili’s face was utterly white. All of their faces were suddenly like bare sheets of paper, translucent in the morning sun.

“Bury him?” Fili asked brokenly.

The wind’s screams had ceased. The crying of the ravens above was no more, and Bilbo felt cold, as though he were watching from a distance, floating high above the ground and wondering if he was being blown back to the shores of the Grey Havens, that now he’d spat out the second chance he’d been given like it was a curse, it would be taken away.

All around him were shoulders heaving with laboured breath, and misted exhales rising like steam into the air. Everyone seemed to have stumbled back in shock. Even the armies of Bard and Thranduil were still, silently watching as Bilbo fell apart.

He had told Thorin of his death. 

He’d told all of them. All of them. 

He hung his head in sickened shame.

Thorin was not facing him any longer. He was standing flush up against the battlements, staring out at the rows and rows of armies lined up and on guard, their arrows raised to the sky. His eyes were huge and unseeing, knuckles pale and rigid against the rock and long tendrils of hair whipping against his face in the wind.

“Leave us,” the King commanded. 

Wake up, Bilbo thought. Wake up, dear heart. 

Come back to me.

Bilbo did.

Notes:

LMAO imagine if i kept this all one chapter

next one might be a while again because it’s obviously going to be a long and important one but i shall see you all when i see you :] much much much love to my beautiful betas & please come and find me on twitter!