Actions

Work Header

All-Kinds-of-Fur

Summary:

Thorin emerges from his gold sickness to find that the battle was won, but all that mattered was lost. For two years, Thorin reaps the consequences of what his madness wrought: broken relationships, harrowing self-doubt, an isolated kingdom and, worst of all, a missing Hobbit.

Unable to determine whether Bilbo is dead or alive, Thorin is unable to mourn or to move on, tormented by the slim hope that his One has survived. Thorin has nearly accepted that he will live in ignorance for the rest of his life when someone begins to hide Bilbo’s lost keepsakes where Thorin is sure to find them. Suddenly, answers seem within reach.

Companion piece to Catskins (Full disclosure - Bilbo is mentioned frequently, but does not appear until the final chapters).

Notes:

Hail and well met! Seven years ago I promised Thorin’s POV of the events of "Catskins"... Better late than never? Part of what took so long is that "All-Kinds-of-Fur" is nearly twice as long as "Catskins." It covers more time, both before and after the events of the original.

One does not need to have read "Catskins" to read this.

If you have, you may notice that the corresponding scenes are NOT identical. Memory is a funny thing. Anyone with siblings can attest that two people can be present for the same event and come away with completely different experiences of it. This is Thorin's experience and recollection and neither he nor Bilbo are completely unbiased narrators.

Fic is already complete, will be updating daily until all is posted, projected completion date: Aug 11, 2024

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: A Crisis in Erebor

Chapter Text

Shortly After the Battle:

 

Thorin had survived, but it would have been a gross exaggeration to say that he had healed.

 

He could not stand for much of the day or exert himself to any shortness of breath, lest he undo all Oín’s hard work repairing him. Nothing was the same. He could finally walk on his own, but he hadn’t dared go far.  His grip was too weak to write legibly most days, let alone hold his sword. He’d been comatose (and then bed-bound) for so long, subsisting on whatever thin soup the healers poured down his throat, that his stomach rebelled if he attempted to touch drink or anything too rich. 

 

Yet he did not rebel against these new limitations. They were his due for the Battle and everything that came before. The challenge weighed on him, but it did not frighten him. He could accept that his body would never be the same; it was his mind that scared him. Worse than his body, Thorin knew that it was his mind that had been truly shattered. There was fear inside him, so binding as to render him paralyzed where he sat on his throne. 

 

Dís stood behind him, one hand on the back of his chair. 

 

“What is your will, my lord?” Balin asked again. He seemed like he had aged a century since Thorin had awoken after the battle.

 

“Get rid of it,” Thorin hissed. He could not look into the box Balin held out for his inspection. Even without looking, he felt the pull as though he were a lodestone and the contents were due north.

 

“Thorin,” Dís was firm, as always. She was like a pillar, the bedrock of the mountain. Where once he would have been ashamed to do so, Thorin now leaned heavily on his sister. “You cannot get rid of it. It is our birthright. It is a treasure of our people.”

 

The breath seemed caught in Thorin’s chest. He wanted it gone. He wanted it destroyed. He could not stand to look on it, not when it had cost him so much: his mind, his body, the trust of those around him, his One… What if he fell to its power once more? Erebor could not afford to have a mad king. 

 

“Thorin,” Dís’ voice called him back. Her hand on his shoulder was a reminder to remain in the present. He was needed here and now, not lost to the misty past or the unknowable future.

 

“Lock it away.” He said. His mouth felt dry. “Lock it away where it may never come to light.”

 

“As you wish, my king.” Balin bowed his head and closed the lid of the box, shutting the Gabil Arkenstone out of sight. 

 


 

Thorin knew that he dreamt. He’d had this dream, this nightmare, a thousand times but knowing that the scene was not real was never enough to wake Thorin.

 

The battlements that he and the company had hastily constructed before the battle had never truly been as high as they were in his dreams, the wind never whipped so harshly through his hair. Even the rocks below were never as jagged as they appeared in his dreams. 

 

You are changed, Thorin.

 

He watched, a phantom in his own dream-body, as he seized Bilbo by the shirt, his knuckles grazing the mithril beneath. Even in his dream, he had half a mind to tear the shirt from Bilbo’s body. 

 

He held him aloft above the battlements for all the assembled armies to see, determined that all would witness what became of those who betrayed the line of Durin. He knew of what passed between them that day, but the truth was that he did not truly remember it. He’d been so lost to the dragon’s hold that he did not know if Bilbo wept and pleaded as he sometimes did in these dreams or whether he looked on Thorin with stubborn resolve. He’d seen everything on Bilbo’s face from smug satisfaction to terror, but the worst was this grim resignation. The Bilbo he held in this dream showed no surprise that Thorin would turn on him thus. This Bilbo would not try to reason with him, so certain that his words would go unheeded. He would simply brace for whatever Thorin did next, showing no sign that he held any hope left for Thorin’s mercy. 

 

Thorin prayed this dream would be one of the nights he hurled Bilbo to the unforgiving stone below. The dream ended most quickly on these nights. He was not so lucky. Tonight he held Bilbo by the throat, pinned him to the battlements, and held on until the veins in Bilbo’s eyes burst, until his lips lost their color, until the life drained slowly from him. 

 

Only when Bilbo was limp and lifeless beneath his hands did the dream release him. 

 

He awoke choking on his own breath, flailing against his blankets as though they were elven manacles. He threw them aside. The scars on his chest burned with phantom pain, as though the Pale Orc had skewered him anew. He coughed and retched, as though he could purge the dream from his lungs. The air of his chambers felt stifling after the phantom wind of his nightmare.

 

There was a rapid knocking at his door. Thorin knew by now that ignoring it would not be enough to make it stop. 

 

“I am well!”

 

“Horseshit,” Dís snapped. Thorin fought the urge to bury his face in one of the hundred useless pillows they’d stacked on his bed.

 

“Go back to bed!” He called.

 

“Thorin, open this door or I swear I’ll wake Dwalin.”

 

Thorin stood. When he opened the door a crack, Dís was standing with her arms folded over her chest. His sister was in her nightshift, her hair and beard in the simple plait she slept in with only a robe tossed over top for modesty.

 

“The stone is not so thin that you could have heard me,” Thoring grumbled. “Which of the guards alerted you? I’ll shave them in front of the court myself.”

 

“You’ll do no such thing. Let me in.”

 

Thorin stepped aside. The King’s Apartments had been destroyed by the dragon and Thorin had refused to begin work on them before they’d even finished repairs to the hydraulics that assured sanitation and potable water for the rest of the city. He and his kin dwelled in rooms originally built to house foreign dignitaries: fine quarters but not the suites they were expected to occupy. 

 

Thorin had dreamed so long of the rooms he’d lived in as a young prince, or even of moving to his grandfather’s old apartments. He’d expected to feel disappointment or impatience at being relegated elsewhere. In truth, Thorin would have preferred to sleep on sister’s floor, if he’d been permitted such a thing. She and Balin had insisted (and they’d been right to) that doing so would send the wrong message to their people. He was supposed to be well now. No one would believe that he had recovered if they thought he slept on the floor of another dwarf’s room. 

 

There was a reason his guards were chosen from those most loyal, those personally vetted by Dwalin and Dís and himself. None of them were certain what would happen if it was widely known that the king could not go more than a few days without screaming himself awake at night. 

 

“You would not truly tell Dwalin, would you?” Thorin frowned as Dís made herself comfortable. 

 

The suite only consisted of three rooms: a parlor and, beyond that, a bathing chamber and a bedroom. Thorin had hoped that sleeping with the door closed might be enough to keep his guards from hearing him in the night, but his hopes were apparently in vain. 

 

“That depends,” Dís told him, settling herself on the settee nearest the fireplace. The embers cast a reddish glow over her features, turning the silver strands in her beard to molten gold. 

 

“You needn’t have come,” Thorin said. He sat opposite her and wondered if he ought to find a dressing gown. He was king now, as she was so keen to remind him. Something about propriety and standards that seemed unimportant when he could still feel the fragile skin of Bilbo’s throat beneath his fingertips. 

 

“Your guards didn’t know what else to do. If I had not come, then they would have woken someone else. Would you rather I let them fetch the sons of Fundin? Or the healers?”

 

“No,” Thorin said quickly. He wasn’t sure which of those options would be the worst. Healers were never quite as tight lipped as he hoped and they didn’t need any more rumors swirling about him and his health. The sons of Fundin wouldn’t say a word to anyone outside their inner circle, but Thorin did not think he could stand another weary, sorrowful look from Balin. Dwalin’s uncharacteristic hesitance would be even worse. 

 

There was so much Thorin had to atone for, but the damage he’d done to Dwalin ranked high on his list. Thorin wondered if it would have been easier if Dwalin had been angry with him. He did not know what to do with the caution, the way his friend handled him carefully, like a wounded animal liable to bite the hand that helped it. 

 

“You should speak to them, Thorin,” Dís said sternly. “They are your friends. They want you to confide in them.”

 

Thorin merely shook his head. He did not deserve their friendship. He did not deserve the comfort they would attempt to offer him, not for this. Dís sighed, sensing Thorin digging in his heels. 

 

“If not for them, then for yourself,” Dís urged him. “It will not take away the pain, but will keep it from devouring you.”

 

“I know not what you speak of,” Thorin said stiffly. 

 

“You do. I know that you do not wish to hear it, but you know that what I say is true.”

 

“Dís,” He warned, but his little sister was never much good at heeding him. 

 

“I never wanted this for you, nadad . It would have been kinder never to meet. But since you did, you must find a way to live on.”

 

“He is not dead!” Thorin snapped.

 

“How would you know?” Dís demanded. 

 

“There is no evidence that he is dead.”

 

“There is no evidence that he lives either!” Dís cried. “Write to his kin, Thorin. I know what you fear, but delaying it will not change anything. You cannot go on like this.”

 

“Dís-”

 

“I will let you be once you have done so.” Dís said. “Truly. I am not saying so to hurt you, but not knowing, imagining what might be… it will destroy you as surely as the dragon’s hold and you are not allowed to perish so soon. Fíli is not ready and if you place that crown upon his head before he is at least one hundred and twenty five, I’ll never forgive you.”

 

Thorin made no oath but he did not attempt to silence her again. Eventually, she sighed. 

 

“Forgive me, Thorin. It seems my words have not been received as I intended them when I spoke. Naidrithi astû. ” 

 

I mourn with thee.

 

Thorin flinched at the ritual words. It was different, he wished to tell her. Bilbo was not dead. Thorin surely would have sensed it if it were so. But if anyone knew what it was like to lose her One, it was Dís. He remembered her inconsolable howls of grief at Víli’s death and now more than ever he did not know how she’d found the strength to carry on. He could not succumb to such a thing. Bilbo could not be dead. Thorin would not survive it if he was. 

 


 

To the Esteemed Dwarves of Erebor,

 

Regarding your inquiry about the whereabouts of Bilbo Baggins, we regret to inform you that he has not returned to the Shire. It is our firm belief that he met his unfortunate end on that reckless adventure he so foolishly embarked upon. Given the dangerous nature of his journey, it is no surprise to us, or to anyone with sense, that he has perished.

 

We must also take this opportunity to affirm that we have come into possession of Bag End entirely within the bounds of the law. Any insinuation to the contrary is baseless and will not be tolerated. We are prepared to defend our claim with the full force of the law, should the need arise.

 

We trust that this clarifies matters. We have no further interest in discussing the fate of Mr. Baggins or the legitimacy of our residence at Bag End.

 

Sincerely,

 

Otho & Lobelia Sackville-Baggins



—

 

To the Honorable Dwarves of Erebor,

 

I trust this letter finds you well. I am writing in response to your recent inquiry regarding my cousin, Bilbo Baggins. With a heavy heart, I must inform you that there has been no sign of his return to the Shire. Many of us fear the worst, believing that he may have perished during his unexpected journey.

 

While it is our hope, however faint, that he might yet be alive and return to us one day, the laws of the Shire declare that he is presumed dead until proven otherwise. In his absence, his property, including Bag End, has been legally transferred to Lobelia and Otho Sackville-Baggins, as per the customs of our land.

 

Please rest assured that should Bilbo miraculously return, I will personally see to it that his property is restored to him. However, I confide that I hold little hope for such an outcome. The Shire's laws are clear, and there is nothing more I can do regarding the current fate of Bag End.

 

Thank you for your understanding and compassion during this difficult time.

 

Yours sincerely,

 

Fortinbras II Took  

Thain of the Shire

 


 

Thorin refused to believe Bilbo to be dead. The Shirefolk had no more proof of it than he did, and he would accept nothing less than irrefutable evidence. 

 

He rewarded the Ravens handsomely for their service in carrying the missives so far and sought out Gloín. Gloín was meant to return to Ered Luin to fetch his family and anyone else who hoped to rejoin them in Erebor and the road led past the Shire. Gloín was a mite bit cleverer than the Ravens. Perhaps he could gather something that the birds could not. 

 

Gloín returned just before Durin’s Day, nearly the anniversary of the battle. His beautiful wife, his handsome young son, and a handful of newcomers from Ered Luin accompanied him. When Thorin greeted him at the gate, Gloín’s mouth went thin and his eyebrows knit and he shook his head before Thorin could ask. There was no sign that Bilbo ever returned to the Shire. 

 

For the anniversary of the Battle a memorial was held. All hands were needed to help rebuild the kingdom, so there was no monument to mark the occasion, but the names of the fallen were sung and hallowed. In the preparations, Thorin poured over the records of the dead yet again, but he found no descriptions to match his hobbit – a relief and a burden all at once. 

 

He sent what aid he could to the fledgling city of Dale, though their resources did little to feed or clothe the Mannish people there. In among the coin, Thorin sent word to the new king, all but begging him for news. In between trade meetings and treaty negotiations, he and Bard spoke. Hope, which flared knowing that Bard was among the last to see his Hobbit, twisted when Bard admitted to losing sight of Bilbo once the battle had begun. He had eyed Thorin suspiciously, saying lightly he was surprised Thorin was searching for a traitor instead of caring for his own people, wondering aloud if Thorin’s heart still clung to vengeance so fiercely.

 

The accusation ached like an old wound. He knew just how much he deserved Bard’s suspicion, all too aware that the last he’d ever spoken to Bilbo was to call for his death, the last he’d ever touched him was to wrap his hands around his neck. Shame and remorse burned his lungs like smoke, and he found himself unable to find a single word in his own defense. 

 

They found no information from the Men of Dale, although Thorin was unsure if they were being truthful or concealed information on the assumption that Thorin still wanted no more than Bilbo’s head on a spike. Even with brief attempts to make clear his motives, Thorin would not be surprised if he was not believed. He had not done enough to re-earn the trust of the Men of Dale.  

 


 

One Year After the Battle:

 

There was a crisis in Erebor.

 

Not the sort of immediate danger that Smaug or an approaching army brought on, but something slow and sinister. 

 

“The healers are placing another request for herbs,” Balin was saying, barely glancing up from the long scrolls of parchment in front of him. 

 

“The answer remains unchanged,” Thorin sighed. He felt heavy, as though his bones had been filled with lead. “They will get their supplies when the snows melt and the passes open again for the caravans.”

 

Balin pursed his lips and Thorin knew what he was thinking. They’d had this conversation before, after all. Winter brought illness. The spring caravans might come too late for those who fell ill in the dark days of winter. Thorin did not have any other answer to give. He could not will the snows away. The Men of Dale needed their stores for their own people and would not barter them away no matter what gold he offered, and the elves would never take such a risky journey for such a pitiful cause. 

 

“The jewelers have placed a complaint that sales are low.” Balin continued. Thorin shut his eyes. Sales were low because food was low. They had the coin for it, certainly, but they could eat gold. They’d starve just as quickly bedecked in jewels as they would in rags if a solution was not found. He wrapped his furs more tightly around him and said nothing. 

 

It was Balin’s turn to sigh at his King’s silence. He too was more than aware of the kingdom’s hardships. He hesitated before drawing Thorin’s attention to the final inquiry. 

 

“The miners would like permission to reopen work on the Nibzurul Tunnels.”

 

Thorin’s eyes snapped open.

 

“No.” It came louder, more forcefully than he’d meant, but he did not apologize. His heart had fallen into his stomach and he could feel it pounding painfully through his chest, up into his head. He kept his hands clenched in his furs, afraid that if he let go his hands would begin to shake.

 

“Thorin-“ Balin started but Thorin pushed his chair away from the table. 

 

He could not stay. He would not stay. If he stayed, then he would have to think of the Nibzurul mines. If he thought of the mines he might think of the Arkenstone. If he thought of the Arkenstone, he might…

 

Thorin fled without a word.

 


 

There was a crisis in Erebor. 

 

He kept Dís and Fíli close at hand. He was King, but he knew how much the two had taken on while he recovered…while he continued to recover. He listened to them closely and drew on their suggestions to surround himself with advisors. 

 

He guarded these decisions behind a veil of taking precautions to ensure a fair rule, but he knew those closest to him could see it was a ruse. 

 

Just as his body was slow to regain its strength, his thoughts too seemed disordered and feeble from disuse. It frightened him. Thorin had never had the opportunity to be weak before; always, it seemed, that all relied on his strength of will. Now that he had faltered and the world had not stopped turning, Thorin found it difficult to keep his feet under him. 

 

Knowing it was possible for him to slip so far so fast, Thorin no longer trusted his own decisions. He had never been afforded self-doubt or second-guessing before, and now that it had begun he cannot seem to stop. 

 

He showed himself to the people, made himself the symbol they craved, and just barely stopped himself from becoming a figurehead King. He might have ceded the throne to Fíli willingly if not for Dís’ warning and the guilt that gnawed at him. Though it was sometimes hard to remember, Fíli was still young. Thorin could not rob him of even more of his youth simply because he was afraid of himself. Not when he had taken so much from his nephew already.

 

When Dís sat across from him with steel in her eyes, Thorin already knew he would agree to whatever she next suggested. 

 

There was a crisis in Erebor. They were too few. They could not sustain themselves. Daín had already sent all those who were willing to rejoin them in Erebor. It was not enough. All the gold in their vast treasury could not buy the power to populate their kingdom, but there were other ways to entice dwarrow to come to Erebor. 

 

“You know how best to unite two kingdoms?” Dís’ voice was nearly a warning as much as a question. 

 

Thorin’s heart rebelled. His mouth opened, but found he had no word of protest. He clenched his fists on the table. Dís looked as though she were about to remind Thorin of what he already knew. His One was gone. There was no trace of Bilbo anywhere. Thorin might have buried his heart along with him, wherever he lay, but Thorin’s life as King had not ended with it. 

 

“I will do whatever I must to provide for Erebor,” He assured Dís. He could not bear for her to say all those things aloud. 

 


 

Before:

 

It was said that finding your One was like hearing a song that no one but the two of you could hear. Hobbits did not have Ones and Thorin had not thought to listen when he’d met Bilbo. Whatever desire he’d felt in the beginning was overshadowed by the weight of his task, his doubts, his suspicions. Why should he trust an outsider to help them, no matter how comely he was or how Gandalf vouched for him?

 

He’d held the belief like a lifeline to keep his eyes away from their Burglar until Bilbo had shattered it all at once and then nothing could stop him from pulling Bilbo into his arms on the Carrock. He did not understand how so small a creature could contain such bravery or such conviction, but with Bilbo in his arms the land between him and the Mountain no longer seemed desolate and empty, their fate no longer seemed so grim. He wanted to hold on, as though he could weld Bilbo’s optimistic certainty to his bones and carry it with him if he just held on a little longer.

 

Knowing he must release the hobbit, yet loath to part with him, Thorin removed the heavy ring from his finger and pressed it into Bilbo’s hand. Bilbo protested – the ring had belonged to Thorin’s father, and his grandfather before him. It bore the seal of Durin. Surely it was far too much, Bilbo insisted. But Thorin was stubborn as a mule. It was the least he could do to acknowledge that he owed Bilbo his life in addition to a 1/14th of the treasure, and now any Longbeard who he encountered would know he carried the favor of the Line of Durin. 

 

Bilbo never wore the ring. The hobbit wore no jewelry at all (a pity). But he knew that Bilbo kept it from the look the Hobbit cast at him when he thought Thorin could not see.

 

In the days that followed, Thorin looked at Bilbo anew. He was soft, in so many ways, from his uncalloused hands to the way he held his little letter-opener to the way he had complained of a sore backside after a day’s ride. He was untrained and had never left his kindly home in the west before. 

 

And yet he was not a fool. He had wits about him, learned more quickly than anyone could have expected him to, and had as sharp a tongue as any seasoned dwarf – sharper without the compulsion to emulate stone so often. He’d saved them twice already and somehow Thorin Oakenshield doubted it would be the last.

 

And so Thorin listened. He’d known by then that Hobbits had no Ones, no soul-songs to hear, but Thorin listened nevertheless. He did not know which he feared more: to hear something and know with certainty that he suddenly had much more to lose or to hear nothing and be left wondering whether it was because they were not fated or because they were and Hobbits had no song. 

 

The answer was infuriating because it was neither. There was something. Thorin felt certain of it. But it was no song, no tune or melody but for the rustle of bare feet over well-tread garden paths, of gently babbling brooks and the sizzle of a frying pan over the fire. 

 

The song only seemed to grow louder. Thorin could no longer deny that it was a song, in its way: a song of the Shire, he concluded, for no dwarven heart-song sounded like this. This was no time for courting, and Thorin did not even know for sure if he intended to court. They were on a journey. The mountain loomed largest in Thorin’s mind, overshadowing all else. There might not even be room in his heart for anyone but Erebor.

 

But that did not keep him from stealing time where he could. 

 

He had first tried at Beorn’s home and had his intentions turned firmly on their head. No longer would Bilbo tolerate the near-slur “Halfling,” and the fight with the orcs seemed to have banished any compunctions he’d had about telling Thorin so. Loudly and in no uncertain terms. No, not half of anything indeed, Thorin had agreed quickly, if not grumpily for his pride was bruised. 

 

In Beorn’s home, Bilbo’s forgiveness seemed to come as easily as breathing. And though Thorin could not bring himself to find Bilbo’s descriptions of his garden entirely interesting, and Bilbo was awful at feigning interest in Thorin’s descriptions of how Deathless had been forged, they eagerly passed an afternoon sketching family trees in the dirt. At least dwarves and hobbits had one love in common, even if it was only genealogy. And if Thorin could make Bilbo laugh trying to pronounce the names of his Tookish cousins, then perhaps the bridge between them was not so impossible to cross.