Actions

Work Header

All-Kinds-of-Fur

Summary:

Thorin emerges from his gold sickness to find that the battle was won, but all that mattered was lost. For two years, Thorin reaps the consequences of what his madness wrought: broken relationships, harrowing self-doubt, an isolated kingdom and, worst of all, a missing Hobbit.

Unable to determine whether Bilbo is dead or alive, Thorin is unable to mourn or to move on, tormented by the slim hope that his One has survived. Thorin has nearly accepted that he will live in ignorance for the rest of his life when someone begins to hide Bilbo’s lost keepsakes where Thorin is sure to find them. Suddenly, answers seem within reach.

Companion piece to Catskins (Full disclosure - Bilbo is mentioned frequently, but does not appear until the final chapters).

Notes:

Hail and well met! Seven years ago I promised Thorin’s POV of the events of "Catskins"... Better late than never? Part of what took so long is that "All-Kinds-of-Fur" is nearly twice as long as "Catskins." It covers more time, both before and after the events of the original.

One does not need to have read "Catskins" to read this.

If you have, you may notice that the corresponding scenes are NOT identical. Memory is a funny thing. Anyone with siblings can attest that two people can be present for the same event and come away with completely different experiences of it. This is Thorin's experience and recollection and neither he nor Bilbo are completely unbiased narrators.

Fic is already complete, will be updating daily until all is posted, projected completion date: Aug 11, 2024

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: A Crisis in Erebor

Chapter Text

Shortly After the Battle:

 

Thorin had survived, but it would have been a gross exaggeration to say that he had healed.

 

He could not stand for much of the day or exert himself to any shortness of breath, lest he undo all Oín’s hard work repairing him. Nothing was the same. He could finally walk on his own, but he hadn’t dared go far.  His grip was too weak to write legibly most days, let alone hold his sword. He’d been comatose (and then bed-bound) for so long, subsisting on whatever thin soup the healers poured down his throat, that his stomach rebelled if he attempted to touch drink or anything too rich. 

 

Yet he did not rebel against these new limitations. They were his due for the Battle and everything that came before. The challenge weighed on him, but it did not frighten him. He could accept that his body would never be the same; it was his mind that scared him. Worse than his body, Thorin knew that it was his mind that had been truly shattered. There was fear inside him, so binding as to render him paralyzed where he sat on his throne. 

 

Dís stood behind him, one hand on the back of his chair. 

 

“What is your will, my lord?” Balin asked again. He seemed like he had aged a century since Thorin had awoken after the battle.

 

“Get rid of it,” Thorin hissed. He could not look into the box Balin held out for his inspection. Even without looking, he felt the pull as though he were a lodestone and the contents were due north.

 

“Thorin,” Dís was firm, as always. She was like a pillar, the bedrock of the mountain. Where once he would have been ashamed to do so, Thorin now leaned heavily on his sister. “You cannot get rid of it. It is our birthright. It is a treasure of our people.”

 

The breath seemed caught in Thorin’s chest. He wanted it gone. He wanted it destroyed. He could not stand to look on it, not when it had cost him so much: his mind, his body, the trust of those around him, his One… What if he fell to its power once more? Erebor could not afford to have a mad king. 

 

“Thorin,” Dís’ voice called him back. Her hand on his shoulder was a reminder to remain in the present. He was needed here and now, not lost to the misty past or the unknowable future.

 

“Lock it away.” He said. His mouth felt dry. “Lock it away where it may never come to light.”

 

“As you wish, my king.” Balin bowed his head and closed the lid of the box, shutting the Gabil Arkenstone out of sight. 

 


 

Thorin knew that he dreamt. He’d had this dream, this nightmare, a thousand times but knowing that the scene was not real was never enough to wake Thorin.

 

The battlements that he and the company had hastily constructed before the battle had never truly been as high as they were in his dreams, the wind never whipped so harshly through his hair. Even the rocks below were never as jagged as they appeared in his dreams. 

 

You are changed, Thorin.

 

He watched, a phantom in his own dream-body, as he seized Bilbo by the shirt, his knuckles grazing the mithril beneath. Even in his dream, he had half a mind to tear the shirt from Bilbo’s body. 

 

He held him aloft above the battlements for all the assembled armies to see, determined that all would witness what became of those who betrayed the line of Durin. He knew of what passed between them that day, but the truth was that he did not truly remember it. He’d been so lost to the dragon’s hold that he did not know if Bilbo wept and pleaded as he sometimes did in these dreams or whether he looked on Thorin with stubborn resolve. He’d seen everything on Bilbo’s face from smug satisfaction to terror, but the worst was this grim resignation. The Bilbo he held in this dream showed no surprise that Thorin would turn on him thus. This Bilbo would not try to reason with him, so certain that his words would go unheeded. He would simply brace for whatever Thorin did next, showing no sign that he held any hope left for Thorin’s mercy. 

 

Thorin prayed this dream would be one of the nights he hurled Bilbo to the unforgiving stone below. The dream ended most quickly on these nights. He was not so lucky. Tonight he held Bilbo by the throat, pinned him to the battlements, and held on until the veins in Bilbo’s eyes burst, until his lips lost their color, until the life drained slowly from him. 

 

Only when Bilbo was limp and lifeless beneath his hands did the dream release him. 

 

He awoke choking on his own breath, flailing against his blankets as though they were elven manacles. He threw them aside. The scars on his chest burned with phantom pain, as though the Pale Orc had skewered him anew. He coughed and retched, as though he could purge the dream from his lungs. The air of his chambers felt stifling after the phantom wind of his nightmare.

 

There was a rapid knocking at his door. Thorin knew by now that ignoring it would not be enough to make it stop. 

 

“I am well!”

 

“Horseshit,” Dís snapped. Thorin fought the urge to bury his face in one of the hundred useless pillows they’d stacked on his bed.

 

“Go back to bed!” He called.

 

“Thorin, open this door or I swear I’ll wake Dwalin.”

 

Thorin stood. When he opened the door a crack, Dís was standing with her arms folded over her chest. His sister was in her nightshift, her hair and beard in the simple plait she slept in with only a robe tossed over top for modesty.

 

“The stone is not so thin that you could have heard me,” Thoring grumbled. “Which of the guards alerted you? I’ll shave them in front of the court myself.”

 

“You’ll do no such thing. Let me in.”

 

Thorin stepped aside. The King’s Apartments had been destroyed by the dragon and Thorin had refused to begin work on them before they’d even finished repairs to the hydraulics that assured sanitation and potable water for the rest of the city. He and his kin dwelled in rooms originally built to house foreign dignitaries: fine quarters but not the suites they were expected to occupy. 

 

Thorin had dreamed so long of the rooms he’d lived in as a young prince, or even of moving to his grandfather’s old apartments. He’d expected to feel disappointment or impatience at being relegated elsewhere. In truth, Thorin would have preferred to sleep on sister’s floor, if he’d been permitted such a thing. She and Balin had insisted (and they’d been right to) that doing so would send the wrong message to their people. He was supposed to be well now. No one would believe that he had recovered if they thought he slept on the floor of another dwarf’s room. 

 

There was a reason his guards were chosen from those most loyal, those personally vetted by Dwalin and Dís and himself. None of them were certain what would happen if it was widely known that the king could not go more than a few days without screaming himself awake at night. 

 

“You would not truly tell Dwalin, would you?” Thorin frowned as Dís made herself comfortable. 

 

The suite only consisted of three rooms: a parlor and, beyond that, a bathing chamber and a bedroom. Thorin had hoped that sleeping with the door closed might be enough to keep his guards from hearing him in the night, but his hopes were apparently in vain. 

 

“That depends,” Dís told him, settling herself on the settee nearest the fireplace. The embers cast a reddish glow over her features, turning the silver strands in her beard to molten gold. 

 

“You needn’t have come,” Thorin said. He sat opposite her and wondered if he ought to find a dressing gown. He was king now, as she was so keen to remind him. Something about propriety and standards that seemed unimportant when he could still feel the fragile skin of Bilbo’s throat beneath his fingertips. 

 

“Your guards didn’t know what else to do. If I had not come, then they would have woken someone else. Would you rather I let them fetch the sons of Fundin? Or the healers?”

 

“No,” Thorin said quickly. He wasn’t sure which of those options would be the worst. Healers were never quite as tight lipped as he hoped and they didn’t need any more rumors swirling about him and his health. The sons of Fundin wouldn’t say a word to anyone outside their inner circle, but Thorin did not think he could stand another weary, sorrowful look from Balin. Dwalin’s uncharacteristic hesitance would be even worse. 

 

There was so much Thorin had to atone for, but the damage he’d done to Dwalin ranked high on his list. Thorin wondered if it would have been easier if Dwalin had been angry with him. He did not know what to do with the caution, the way his friend handled him carefully, like a wounded animal liable to bite the hand that helped it. 

 

“You should speak to them, Thorin,” Dís said sternly. “They are your friends. They want you to confide in them.”

 

Thorin merely shook his head. He did not deserve their friendship. He did not deserve the comfort they would attempt to offer him, not for this. Dís sighed, sensing Thorin digging in his heels. 

 

“If not for them, then for yourself,” Dís urged him. “It will not take away the pain, but will keep it from devouring you.”

 

“I know not what you speak of,” Thorin said stiffly. 

 

“You do. I know that you do not wish to hear it, but you know that what I say is true.”

 

“Dís,” He warned, but his little sister was never much good at heeding him. 

 

“I never wanted this for you, nadad . It would have been kinder never to meet. But since you did, you must find a way to live on.”

 

“He is not dead!” Thorin snapped.

 

“How would you know?” Dís demanded. 

 

“There is no evidence that he is dead.”

 

“There is no evidence that he lives either!” Dís cried. “Write to his kin, Thorin. I know what you fear, but delaying it will not change anything. You cannot go on like this.”

 

“Dís-”

 

“I will let you be once you have done so.” Dís said. “Truly. I am not saying so to hurt you, but not knowing, imagining what might be… it will destroy you as surely as the dragon’s hold and you are not allowed to perish so soon. Fíli is not ready and if you place that crown upon his head before he is at least one hundred and twenty five, I’ll never forgive you.”

 

Thorin made no oath but he did not attempt to silence her again. Eventually, she sighed. 

 

“Forgive me, Thorin. It seems my words have not been received as I intended them when I spoke. Naidrithi astû. ” 

 

I mourn with thee.

 

Thorin flinched at the ritual words. It was different, he wished to tell her. Bilbo was not dead. Thorin surely would have sensed it if it were so. But if anyone knew what it was like to lose her One, it was Dís. He remembered her inconsolable howls of grief at Víli’s death and now more than ever he did not know how she’d found the strength to carry on. He could not succumb to such a thing. Bilbo could not be dead. Thorin would not survive it if he was. 

 


 

To the Esteemed Dwarves of Erebor,

 

Regarding your inquiry about the whereabouts of Bilbo Baggins, we regret to inform you that he has not returned to the Shire. It is our firm belief that he met his unfortunate end on that reckless adventure he so foolishly embarked upon. Given the dangerous nature of his journey, it is no surprise to us, or to anyone with sense, that he has perished.

 

We must also take this opportunity to affirm that we have come into possession of Bag End entirely within the bounds of the law. Any insinuation to the contrary is baseless and will not be tolerated. We are prepared to defend our claim with the full force of the law, should the need arise.

 

We trust that this clarifies matters. We have no further interest in discussing the fate of Mr. Baggins or the legitimacy of our residence at Bag End.

 

Sincerely,

 

Otho & Lobelia Sackville-Baggins



—

 

To the Honorable Dwarves of Erebor,

 

I trust this letter finds you well. I am writing in response to your recent inquiry regarding my cousin, Bilbo Baggins. With a heavy heart, I must inform you that there has been no sign of his return to the Shire. Many of us fear the worst, believing that he may have perished during his unexpected journey.

 

While it is our hope, however faint, that he might yet be alive and return to us one day, the laws of the Shire declare that he is presumed dead until proven otherwise. In his absence, his property, including Bag End, has been legally transferred to Lobelia and Otho Sackville-Baggins, as per the customs of our land.

 

Please rest assured that should Bilbo miraculously return, I will personally see to it that his property is restored to him. However, I confide that I hold little hope for such an outcome. The Shire's laws are clear, and there is nothing more I can do regarding the current fate of Bag End.

 

Thank you for your understanding and compassion during this difficult time.

 

Yours sincerely,

 

Fortinbras II Took  

Thain of the Shire

 


 

Thorin refused to believe Bilbo to be dead. The Shirefolk had no more proof of it than he did, and he would accept nothing less than irrefutable evidence. 

 

He rewarded the Ravens handsomely for their service in carrying the missives so far and sought out Gloín. Gloín was meant to return to Ered Luin to fetch his family and anyone else who hoped to rejoin them in Erebor and the road led past the Shire. Gloín was a mite bit cleverer than the Ravens. Perhaps he could gather something that the birds could not. 

 

Gloín returned just before Durin’s Day, nearly the anniversary of the battle. His beautiful wife, his handsome young son, and a handful of newcomers from Ered Luin accompanied him. When Thorin greeted him at the gate, Gloín’s mouth went thin and his eyebrows knit and he shook his head before Thorin could ask. There was no sign that Bilbo ever returned to the Shire. 

 

For the anniversary of the Battle a memorial was held. All hands were needed to help rebuild the kingdom, so there was no monument to mark the occasion, but the names of the fallen were sung and hallowed. In the preparations, Thorin poured over the records of the dead yet again, but he found no descriptions to match his hobbit – a relief and a burden all at once. 

 

He sent what aid he could to the fledgling city of Dale, though their resources did little to feed or clothe the Mannish people there. In among the coin, Thorin sent word to the new king, all but begging him for news. In between trade meetings and treaty negotiations, he and Bard spoke. Hope, which flared knowing that Bard was among the last to see his Hobbit, twisted when Bard admitted to losing sight of Bilbo once the battle had begun. He had eyed Thorin suspiciously, saying lightly he was surprised Thorin was searching for a traitor instead of caring for his own people, wondering aloud if Thorin’s heart still clung to vengeance so fiercely.

 

The accusation ached like an old wound. He knew just how much he deserved Bard’s suspicion, all too aware that the last he’d ever spoken to Bilbo was to call for his death, the last he’d ever touched him was to wrap his hands around his neck. Shame and remorse burned his lungs like smoke, and he found himself unable to find a single word in his own defense. 

 

They found no information from the Men of Dale, although Thorin was unsure if they were being truthful or concealed information on the assumption that Thorin still wanted no more than Bilbo’s head on a spike. Even with brief attempts to make clear his motives, Thorin would not be surprised if he was not believed. He had not done enough to re-earn the trust of the Men of Dale.  

 


 

One Year After the Battle:

 

There was a crisis in Erebor.

 

Not the sort of immediate danger that Smaug or an approaching army brought on, but something slow and sinister. 

 

“The healers are placing another request for herbs,” Balin was saying, barely glancing up from the long scrolls of parchment in front of him. 

 

“The answer remains unchanged,” Thorin sighed. He felt heavy, as though his bones had been filled with lead. “They will get their supplies when the snows melt and the passes open again for the caravans.”

 

Balin pursed his lips and Thorin knew what he was thinking. They’d had this conversation before, after all. Winter brought illness. The spring caravans might come too late for those who fell ill in the dark days of winter. Thorin did not have any other answer to give. He could not will the snows away. The Men of Dale needed their stores for their own people and would not barter them away no matter what gold he offered, and the elves would never take such a risky journey for such a pitiful cause. 

 

“The jewelers have placed a complaint that sales are low.” Balin continued. Thorin shut his eyes. Sales were low because food was low. They had the coin for it, certainly, but they could eat gold. They’d starve just as quickly bedecked in jewels as they would in rags if a solution was not found. He wrapped his furs more tightly around him and said nothing. 

 

It was Balin’s turn to sigh at his King’s silence. He too was more than aware of the kingdom’s hardships. He hesitated before drawing Thorin’s attention to the final inquiry. 

 

“The miners would like permission to reopen work on the Nibzurul Tunnels.”

 

Thorin’s eyes snapped open.

 

“No.” It came louder, more forcefully than he’d meant, but he did not apologize. His heart had fallen into his stomach and he could feel it pounding painfully through his chest, up into his head. He kept his hands clenched in his furs, afraid that if he let go his hands would begin to shake.

 

“Thorin-“ Balin started but Thorin pushed his chair away from the table. 

 

He could not stay. He would not stay. If he stayed, then he would have to think of the Nibzurul mines. If he thought of the mines he might think of the Arkenstone. If he thought of the Arkenstone, he might…

 

Thorin fled without a word.

 


 

There was a crisis in Erebor. 

 

He kept Dís and Fíli close at hand. He was King, but he knew how much the two had taken on while he recovered…while he continued to recover. He listened to them closely and drew on their suggestions to surround himself with advisors. 

 

He guarded these decisions behind a veil of taking precautions to ensure a fair rule, but he knew those closest to him could see it was a ruse. 

 

Just as his body was slow to regain its strength, his thoughts too seemed disordered and feeble from disuse. It frightened him. Thorin had never had the opportunity to be weak before; always, it seemed, that all relied on his strength of will. Now that he had faltered and the world had not stopped turning, Thorin found it difficult to keep his feet under him. 

 

Knowing it was possible for him to slip so far so fast, Thorin no longer trusted his own decisions. He had never been afforded self-doubt or second-guessing before, and now that it had begun he cannot seem to stop. 

 

He showed himself to the people, made himself the symbol they craved, and just barely stopped himself from becoming a figurehead King. He might have ceded the throne to Fíli willingly if not for Dís’ warning and the guilt that gnawed at him. Though it was sometimes hard to remember, Fíli was still young. Thorin could not rob him of even more of his youth simply because he was afraid of himself. Not when he had taken so much from his nephew already.

 

When Dís sat across from him with steel in her eyes, Thorin already knew he would agree to whatever she next suggested. 

 

There was a crisis in Erebor. They were too few. They could not sustain themselves. Daín had already sent all those who were willing to rejoin them in Erebor. It was not enough. All the gold in their vast treasury could not buy the power to populate their kingdom, but there were other ways to entice dwarrow to come to Erebor. 

 

“You know how best to unite two kingdoms?” Dís’ voice was nearly a warning as much as a question. 

 

Thorin’s heart rebelled. His mouth opened, but found he had no word of protest. He clenched his fists on the table. Dís looked as though she were about to remind Thorin of what he already knew. His One was gone. There was no trace of Bilbo anywhere. Thorin might have buried his heart along with him, wherever he lay, but Thorin’s life as King had not ended with it. 

 

“I will do whatever I must to provide for Erebor,” He assured Dís. He could not bear for her to say all those things aloud. 

 


 

Before:

 

It was said that finding your One was like hearing a song that no one but the two of you could hear. Hobbits did not have Ones and Thorin had not thought to listen when he’d met Bilbo. Whatever desire he’d felt in the beginning was overshadowed by the weight of his task, his doubts, his suspicions. Why should he trust an outsider to help them, no matter how comely he was or how Gandalf vouched for him?

 

He’d held the belief like a lifeline to keep his eyes away from their Burglar until Bilbo had shattered it all at once and then nothing could stop him from pulling Bilbo into his arms on the Carrock. He did not understand how so small a creature could contain such bravery or such conviction, but with Bilbo in his arms the land between him and the Mountain no longer seemed desolate and empty, their fate no longer seemed so grim. He wanted to hold on, as though he could weld Bilbo’s optimistic certainty to his bones and carry it with him if he just held on a little longer.

 

Knowing he must release the hobbit, yet loath to part with him, Thorin removed the heavy ring from his finger and pressed it into Bilbo’s hand. Bilbo protested – the ring had belonged to Thorin’s father, and his grandfather before him. It bore the seal of Durin. Surely it was far too much, Bilbo insisted. But Thorin was stubborn as a mule. It was the least he could do to acknowledge that he owed Bilbo his life in addition to a 1/14th of the treasure, and now any Longbeard who he encountered would know he carried the favor of the Line of Durin. 

 

Bilbo never wore the ring. The hobbit wore no jewelry at all (a pity). But he knew that Bilbo kept it from the look the Hobbit cast at him when he thought Thorin could not see.

 

In the days that followed, Thorin looked at Bilbo anew. He was soft, in so many ways, from his uncalloused hands to the way he held his little letter-opener to the way he had complained of a sore backside after a day’s ride. He was untrained and had never left his kindly home in the west before. 

 

And yet he was not a fool. He had wits about him, learned more quickly than anyone could have expected him to, and had as sharp a tongue as any seasoned dwarf – sharper without the compulsion to emulate stone so often. He’d saved them twice already and somehow Thorin Oakenshield doubted it would be the last.

 

And so Thorin listened. He’d known by then that Hobbits had no Ones, no soul-songs to hear, but Thorin listened nevertheless. He did not know which he feared more: to hear something and know with certainty that he suddenly had much more to lose or to hear nothing and be left wondering whether it was because they were not fated or because they were and Hobbits had no song. 

 

The answer was infuriating because it was neither. There was something. Thorin felt certain of it. But it was no song, no tune or melody but for the rustle of bare feet over well-tread garden paths, of gently babbling brooks and the sizzle of a frying pan over the fire. 

 

The song only seemed to grow louder. Thorin could no longer deny that it was a song, in its way: a song of the Shire, he concluded, for no dwarven heart-song sounded like this. This was no time for courting, and Thorin did not even know for sure if he intended to court. They were on a journey. The mountain loomed largest in Thorin’s mind, overshadowing all else. There might not even be room in his heart for anyone but Erebor.

 

But that did not keep him from stealing time where he could. 

 

He had first tried at Beorn’s home and had his intentions turned firmly on their head. No longer would Bilbo tolerate the near-slur “Halfling,” and the fight with the orcs seemed to have banished any compunctions he’d had about telling Thorin so. Loudly and in no uncertain terms. No, not half of anything indeed, Thorin had agreed quickly, if not grumpily for his pride was bruised. 

 

In Beorn’s home, Bilbo’s forgiveness seemed to come as easily as breathing. And though Thorin could not bring himself to find Bilbo’s descriptions of his garden entirely interesting, and Bilbo was awful at feigning interest in Thorin’s descriptions of how Deathless had been forged, they eagerly passed an afternoon sketching family trees in the dirt. At least dwarves and hobbits had one love in common, even if it was only genealogy. And if Thorin could make Bilbo laugh trying to pronounce the names of his Tookish cousins, then perhaps the bridge between them was not so impossible to cross.

Chapter 2: A Pragmatic Solution

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Two Years After the Battle

 

“We have received an acceptance from the Orocarni.” 

 

Thorin was grateful that Dís was 

the one to tell him. She would never couch the truth in sugary language and he needed the absoluteness of a straight answer. When Thorin said nothing, she continued. 

 

“King Nami’s two eldest are already married, but his third is not. She has agreed to the match.”

 

“She?” Thorin suddenly blanched. He had, of course, known that his future spouse might be a woman (it mattered little when Erebor was at stake), but he had not truly considered the implications. 

 

“You need not consummate the marriage,” Dís looked somewhat unimpressed with his nerves. “And if you do choose to, there shall be no children from the union.”

 

Relief flooded him. Of course, there was still a risk of children, if his spouse had been a man, but it was statistically less likely. And children… Thorin was willing to bend to his kingdom’s needs, but he already had an heir. And to imagine the possibility of children from a loveless match… It was overwhelming, but it seemed cruel, unfair to those unborn children as well as to Fíli and Kíli. If there had been children, then the succession to the throne could have become messy. Fíli had a fair claim as Thorin’s named heir, but so would a theoretical first-born. Multiple claims was a recipe for disaster and they could not afford a civil war. 

 

“Honestly, Thorin,” Dís rolled her eyes at him. “Have a little faith in me. As though I would jeopardize Fíli’s place like that.”

 


 

Dáin arrived precisely on time, shortly before the second Durin’s Day since the Battle. His timing was awful.

 

The heralds announced “Dáin II, called Ironfoot, son of Náin, son of Gror, Lord of the Iron Hills, King of–” before Dáin gave a shout of impatience and shoved the doors to the throne room open himself. 

 

“Hail, cousin!” Dáin called cheerfully before he noticed Gloín and Kíli, standing before Thorin’s throne. They turned on their heels, faces stormy as thunderclouds, and marched past Dáin with hardly a glance. Thorin shut his eyes and prayed for patience. Dáin put his hands on his hips with a scoff.

 

“Who stuck soft coal in their forge?” Dáin asked aloud. “ Iraknadad , what have you done now?”

 

Thorin knew that it was said in jest, but he felt the sting of Dáin’s words nonetheless. 

 

“I will not allow them to honor Bilbo in this year’s tribute to the fallen.” 

 

Thorin could practically see Dáin working through the statement, frowning as he put the pieces together. 

 

“You are not still angry with him?” Dáin asked. “The Arkenstone is returned. Or, most of it anyway. I do not believe he could have broken it on purpose, even if he’d tried to. Surely, you cannot hold him accountable for damage done by the Great Wyrm? The Luzun Arkenstone is not his fault.”

 

“I agree,” Thorin said. He was so tired. The weight of the crown on his brow was so heavy that he felt as though it might pull him to the ground. 

 

“Well, then, what reason could there be to exclude him? To hear the Company tell it, the halfling is a hero.”

 

“Do not use that word,” Thorin told him sharply.

 

“Company?” Dáin looked at him as though he thought Thorin might be falling to madness once more.

 

“ Halfling. They consider it an insult.” Not half of anything , Bilbo’s voice echoed in his ears. Dáin made a noise of protest which fell away at a glare from Thorin. 

 

“Be that as it may, wouldn’t it be better to honor your half— your Hobbit ?” 

 

“Not among the fallen,” Thorin insisted. Dáin’s sigh was pitying. 

 

“Oh, Thorin…”

 

“He is not dead.”

 

“No, for you hold him in limbo!” Dáin shook his head. “This cannot continue. You dishonor him by refusing to acknowledge his sacrifice. Even his own kin have accepted it.”

 

Thorin’s head snapped to Dáin. “How would you know such a thing?”

 

“You are not my only kin in Erebor,” Dáin told him flatly. “Do you think I do not correspond with Balin? With your sister? They worry for you.”

 

Traitors. Schemers. Going behind his back. Whispering his secrets to unworthy ears. How dare– Thorin pushed aside the poisonous words. They sounded too much like the dragon’s hiss. He could not afford to give in to them. 

 

“They know not of what they speak,” Thorin grit out. 

 

“Mayhap, but I know of what I speak.” Dáin said. His normally jovial expression had faded. “You know that I would rather have Aurin cowardly and alive than among the glorious dead, but I would never hide his brave deeds to soothe my own grief.”

 

The Battle of Five Armies, as they were now calling it, was not the first time orcs had harnessed were-worms for use in battle. They’d practiced on Dáin’s kingdom for decades with unpredictable raids. Aurin, Dáin’s One and the sire of Thorin Stonehelm, had perished in the defense of the Iron Hills along with many other brave dwarrow. 

 

“It is different,” Thorin insisted. 

 

“I do not see how. Show some pride, for Mahal’s sake. If your half— your Hobbit was half as brave as the tales, then you tarnish his memory to keep him from the annals of our people. And if you do not write his history then someone else will write it for you and you might not like what they have to say. Have you heard what some of the traditionalists are saying about his role with the Luzun Arkenstone?”

 

“They are nattering old fools. No one of any sense believes what they have to say.”

 

“And yet, your silence seems to confirm their suspicions!” Dáin cried. “They think he must surely have done something truly terrible if their king refuses to acknowledge him on the day of remembrance.”

 

“Dáin, stop. I do not wish to hear any more of this.”

 

“But you want me here to bless your new union,” Dáin scowled and Thorin took a deep shuddering breath. 

 

“Please, Dáin.” Thorin said. “I do not tell you how to honor Aurin. Do not tell me how I must honor Bilbo. When I desire your counsel, I will ask for it. And when I ask, I swear that I will listen to what you have to say, but until then, please leave the matter.”

 

Dáin had been puffing himself up to keep arguing but he deflated at the mention of Aurin. He let out the breath he’d been saving up to yell and dropped his arms. 

 

“Aye. I suppose, so long as you don’t say I didn’t warn you.”

 


 

Despite Dáin’s warning, Thorin still could not bring himself to include Bilbo in the ceremonies on the second anniversary of the battle. He felt the disapproving eyes on him and a large part of him wanted to capitulate. Bilbo was a hero. He deserved to have his accomplishments celebrated. A larger part feared that it might break him to do so. Weighing the anger of Kíli and part of the company against the risk of relapsing into madness, Thorin chose to take their resentment.

 

After the memorial, Kíli began avoiding Thorin. When they were forced into a room together, Kíli complained loudly of… everything. The ongoing repairs were being done in the wrong order, relations with the Men of Dale were not being tended to properly, the treaties with the Blacklocks hadn’t been considered well enough and, above all, their spending was ludicrous. Thorin suspected that Kíli was more unhappy with Thorin than with any individual issue, but his youngest nephew would not allow himself to be cornered and so Thorin had no way of knowing for sure. He wondered what offended Kíli more: that Thorin was going to wed someone who was not his One, or that he’d been forbidden from going farther than Dale. 

 

The worst of it was that Thorin did not inherently disagree with Kíli. Their relations with Bard were being neglected because all hands were needed to help assimilate the Blacklocks; the treaties with the Blacklocks were caught up in endless negotiations because there were slight cultural differences that neither side had anticipated, and it did indeed feel absurd to spend so much on lavish banqueting when they had yet to finish inspecting the structural integrity of all the old mines.

 

And Thorin certainly understood his nephew’s distress in regards to romantic matters. He had not had the chance to assure Kíli that he was not entirely against his devotion to the guard captain (elven though she might be); just the timing. Things were too precarious. They needed to concentrate on settling Erebor and her people before they rocked its foundations by introducing an elf to the royal household. If they tried such a thing now, Thorin had no doubt he would be deposed before spring arrived. But a few years more must seem like an eternity to one so young as Kíli. Thorin could understand how dismal Kíli’s prospects might seem if Thorin would not even allow himself to marry for love. 

 

Thorin tried to take comfort in the fact that, though Kíli had turned away from him, there was a sudden influx of young dwarrow that Kíli could turn to. Growing up in Ered Luin, Kíli and Fíli had practically been one another’s only playmates. Though they were perhaps too old for playmates, Thorin still thought it was good for his nephews to have some friends who weren’t at least fifty years their senior. 

 

Though Fíli had too many responsibilities now to fully take advantage of the fact, Thorin knew that Kíli had taken to Gimli (intrigued by the novelty of getting to be the eldest for once) and to young Stonehelm. Thorin could not bring himself to call Dáin’s son “Thorin,” though he was consoled that young Stonehelm seemed equally mortified to meet his namesake as Thorin was. 

 

Thorin could only hope that Kíli eventually allowed Thorin to say his piece before he cemented his grudge for life. 

 

“I simply do not understand why there need be three nights of foolishness!” Kíli complained from his place at the dinner table. It was a relatively intimate dinner with only the descendants of Durin present. This still amounted to a fairly sizable group: with the children of Thráin, Fundin, Gróin, and Náin all represented there were at least a dozen of them. 

 

“No, you refuse to understand,” Dís scolded her son. “Balin has explained time and again why the celebrations are important. You just haven’t been paying attention.”

 

“I was .” Kíli sank lower in his seat, glaring at his fork. “I just think all of that could be accomplished in one night.”

 

“ One ? It’s bad enough that it’s only three! You know, it’s seven traditionally.” Gloín said from across the table. He had not been present for most of Kíli’s complaints and he hadn’t tired of the argument yet. Gloín wasn’t wrong either. They were barely getting away with limiting things to three nights: one for the Longbeards of Erebor, one for the Blacklocks of the Red Mountains, and one for the Broadbeams who’d sheltered them in the Blue Mountains. The other four clans would have to have their celebrations privately.

 

“Tradition, tradition, tradition,” Kíli wrinkled his nose. “I’m sick to death of tradition! Just because something’s always been done doesn’t mean it’s the best way to do it.”

 

“For craft and artistry, certainly, but it’s Mahalmerag .” Young Stonehelm said. “It’s the making of the Seven Fathers, not a plain old sword!”

 

Kíli opened his mouth only for Fíli to put a hand on his brother’s leg under the table. Kíli gave a start and Fíli silently gave a tiny shake of the head. Thorin was silently grateful. He did not wish to reprimand Kíli for whatever blasphemy he might have spoken next, especially not while Kíli was still so angry with him. Dís, however, had no such compunctions about her son’s ire.

 

“You know, kin of mine, I think Kíli might benefit from a lesson in our traditions,” She said slyly. “In fact, I think the court could benefit from seeing my youngest son’s devotion to those traditions first hand.”

 

Kíli had gone pale, eyeing his mother warily even as Dwalin smirked and Balin raised a bushy eyebrow. 

 

“What did you have in mind, my lady?” Balin asked.

 

“What better way to introduce our guests to a taste of Longbeard culture than to stage an exhibition of our most beloved dances? And who better to perform them than one of Durin’s heirs?” 

 

“ Ammad- ” Kíli gasped in horror. Dáin stroked his beard, not bothering to hide his smile. 

 

“You’ve a sharp mind, cousin,” He said. “What dance did you have in mind?”

 

“A Kalinka.”

 

“Mother, no, I cannot–”

 

“On second thought, a Trepak.” Dís said, speaking over Kíli’s protest. She shot him a warning look, daring him to continue to protest and see what fresh horrors she could devise. Kíli let his face fall into his hands with a groan. Fíli patted his shoulder in a conciliatory manner.

 

“I shall dance with him.” Fíli announced. 

 

“You don’t have to, Fi,” Kíli grumbled into his hands.

 

“I most certainly do. Someone should be there to catch you when you fall flat on your face,”

 

That got the chuckle from around the table that Fíli had obviously been hoping for. Even Kíli lifted his head to nudge Fíli’s shoulder with his own. 

 

“I think you mean when you fall… though perhaps falling on your face might improve it, somewhat.”

 

The two dissolved into good natured bickering and for a moment it felt almost like the nights in Ered Luin, dining by Dís’ hearth. Then Balin spoke again. 

 

“What say you, my king?”

 

It was the first anyone had addressed Thorin in some time and the mirth fled his nephews as soon as attention was drawn to him. All eyes turned to him and Thorin took his time to consider. In the silence, servers arrived to clear away the plates of their first course and present them with a soup.

 

“I say… this soup is very green. ” Thorin frowned, utterly distracted by the dish placed in front of him. Sure enough, the soup placed before them was a bright, opaque green, the color of new spring shoots. 

 

“What elven boarshite is this?” Dwalin fumed. Thorin privately had to agree. In truth, it smelled appetizing enough, but the color was decidedly off putting. He frowned at it some more, as though he could intimidate it into giving up its secrets, but when he moved to taste it, Gloín stopped him. 

 

“Wait! I don’t trust it. I’ll taste it first, lest it hide poison.” Gloín said. The servers, who had not yet retreated, looked as though they might all simultaneously faint from the mere suggestion of such treason. 

 

“Father, no,” Young Gimli protested, but Gloín squared his shoulders and took a bold spoonful of the soup, bracing as though for a strike. They all waited with bated breath for several minutes until Gloín finally shrugged. 

 

“That’s soup, alright,” Gloín admitted. 

 

“Could be a slow-acting poison,” Óin suggested, but Thorin had had enough of this foolishness and ignored the rest of his kin in favor of tasting the strange dish himself. 

 

The flavor burst across his tongue. He froze, feeling as though everything had gone silent around him, for all that he knew that his kin continued to bicker nearby. Only, silent was not quite true. He felt as though he could hear something. Birdsong beneath the mountain. Bare feet tapping over comfortably worn carpets. The cheery whistle of a kettle. Thorin took another bite. It wasn’t that it was so delicious, though it was very good, but it tasted like… He didn’t know how to explain. It tasted the way the air had smelled the night he first saw that round green door, like grass damp with dew and the subtle perfume of warm tilled earth and ripening fruit. Which was absurd. Logically, it tasted of onion and broth and vegetable, but it didn’t . 

 

“Thorin,”  Dís said sharply and his head snapped up. From the look in her eyes, he knew she’d called his name more than once. 

 

“What is it, lad?” Óin asked, as though he really expected Thorin to begin suffering convulsions from some unseen poison. Thorin could not stop himself from gaping for a moment, feeling the server’s fearful eyes on him. Finally, he swallowed.

 

“It is good,” He murmured. The servers breathed a collective sigh of relief, but Thorin found himself rising to his feet, chair scraping against the floor. “I must meet its maker.”

 

Thorin did not wait for his kin to follow as he marched from the dining room. The servers scrambled to get ahead of him to warn the kitchen staff of his imminent arrival. He did not care. His mind was empty save for the echoes of the heartsong he’d assumed had gone silent with Bilbo’s disappearance.

 

“Thorin, stop! What do you think you are going to find down there?”

 

Thorin slowed to a stop, allowing Balin to catch up to him and gently take him by the arms. Thorin did not look at him. He was ashamed but could not stop himself from acting.  Balin seemed to know it too.

 

“This is bordering on obsession.” Balin told him slowly. He did not mean it to be cruel but still Thorin flinched at the implication. “It’s been years and still you jump at the slightest hint…”

 

Thorin gently pulled Balin’s hands from him. The rest of the dinner party was beginning to catch up to them. Thorin set his jaw, but when he looked at Balin it was with sorrow. 

 

“I have to know.” He said. 

 

Only when Thorin had confronted the kitchen staff, learned the reason behind the fresh green soup served at dinner, did his resolve weaken. 

 

Thorin knew he left the kitchens at a reasonable speed but it felt like fleeing. He needed to be out of sight. He was king. He could not fall apart where anyone might see. 

 

Because falling apart was how it felt when at last Thorin had a locked door between him and the rest of the kingdom. 

 

He held his head in a vice grip. Was something wrong with him? Was this some new form of madness?

 

In the depths of the dragon sickness, Thorin had sensed things differently. His memories of the time were tinted, as though they were not quite his own. His eyes had fixated on different things, his ears on different sounds, and when anyone had spoken to him it was as though their words had another meaning to him. Was this a sign of the madness returning?

 

Thorin could not explain the mania that had seized him in response to the soup. This couldn’t be happening. He was supposed to be well. He was supposed to be beyond this. Was it grief? Was the grief of not knowing Bilbo’s fate causing him to see signs where there were none? 

 

It must be so. It must be so. It must be so. 

 

And he must be a fool for asking for the soup again, just to trip that false sense memory.

 


Before:

 

There was no time for soft and delicate desires in Mirkwood. Thorin hated the forest. They all hated the forest, but Thorin thought it might drive him to throwing himself on Orcrist, he hated it that much. In one moment the dark place seemed to hollow them out with hunger and in the next the sickness upon the forest seemed to fill them up again, like a gas they could not help but breathe in. 

 

Thorin could not fight madness with his sword any more than he could fight hunger with his ax. During the day he felt the helplessness clawing at him, knowing he would be unable to keep them from starving if it came down to it. But at night it was worse; the voice of his grandfather (his father, himself) hissed that the company slowed him down, that he would be better off to abandon them. They were being unhelpful and lethargic on purpose, they wanted to keep him here in the darkness forever away from Erebor. The hunger ate at him and the fear ate at him and the resentment ate at him until Thorin was unsure what there was left of him at all.

 

It was nearly a relief to be taken by spiders, who would at least bring numbness before they killed them, but Thorin was too exhausted to feel relief or anger at being taken by elves. He was half-mad when he stood before Thranduil, repeating only that they’d been starving as much from deranged hunger as from stubbornness.

 

In the dark days in prison in Mirkwood, Thorin listened with a ferocity that he never had before. For Bilbo was not among their captured band, which could only mean he was elsewhere: perhaps the Spiders had devoured him, perhaps he still wandered the forest alone. He did not know how long it took a hobbit to succumb to hunger. And yet beyond his fear, Thorin felt hope. His hobbit had survived every other impossible challenge set before them and succeeded against all odds. He had survived and saved the company every time. What was to say he could not do so again?

 

And so Thorin listened. He heard the sounds of his jailers as they passed and dripping water somewhere and silenced them all so that he could listen for the sound, unmade, of young grass rustling in the wind and of a cool clear stream hundreds of miles away and of feet walking friendly and familiar paths. It kept him from despair until Bilbo found him. 

 

The time they stole there was purely accidental. They had both spent so long alone in the dark that the sound of a familiar voice was welcome no matter what it said. In the days when Bilbo still planned their escape, they spoke just for the sake of speaking, just to have some proof that they were not muttering to themselves alone in the darkness. Most of the time it was pure nonsense. Bilbo drilled Thorin on his family tree until Thorin thought he’d be able to recite, “Gerontius Took, his wife, Adamanta Chubb, and their children, Isengrim, Hildigard, Isumbras, Hildigrim, Isembold, Hildifons, Isembard, Hildibrand, Belladonna, Donnamira, Mirabella, and Isengar” even if he forgot his own name. 

 

But at times Thorin found himself saying things he’d never meant to say to anyone. He told Bilbo of the blue lupines on the slopes of Ered Luin. He told him of going with Dwalin to get their first tattoos together and how Dwalin had laughed at him mercilessly when Thorin found he could not stand the needle. He told him of the strange feeling that crept over him sometimes, the hunger for something he could not describe, something precious. He told him about Balin teaching his nephews to play the fiddle.

 

It was not long after that Bilbo got them out. Of course he did, clever fellow he was, and if the barrel-ride was hellish at least they were free at the end of it. 

 

There were so many things Thorin Oakensheild had meant to say in Laketown. “You got us out, you miraculous burglar,” and “Your words kept me sane in that prison, thank you,” and “Your voice sounds like home and I don’t know why.” But somehow, he never did. Instead he found himself cornered by a very staunchly resolute hobbit. 

 

In the snatches of time he had allowed himself to picture courting Bilbo, he had imagined that he would be the one to approach Bilbo. Somehow the civil, mannerly creature seemed the sort to be approached, rather than do the approaching. As always, his burglar toppled Thorin’s expectations, demanding an explanation for everything: the stolen glances across the fire, the soft words exchanged, the ring Thorin had given him atop the Carrock. 

 

When Thorin could not answer his questions quickly enough, Bilbo shut them away in his room together and had Thorin explain with his hands and mouth and tongue instead. And Thorin found himself eager to answer anything that Bilbo asked.

 

Those days in Esgaroth were stolen bits of time. Having fulfilled the want to draw them together, Thorin found the heart-song growing quiet and still in contentment. It was no longer necessary to link them. Laying in bed, propped up on his elbows, Thorin unclasped one of his hair beads, offering it to Bilbo. It was not much, but signifying all he hoped to offer Bilbo for in those days Thorin would have offered all that he was in a heartbeat. Bilbo had laughed at him, revealed that Thorin had already fulfilled Hobbitish customs by offering him a ring, and accepted the bead.  

 

And yet his surrender to this peaceful time was incomplete. 

 

The mountain loomed large on the horizon and, soon, began to loom even larger in Thorin’s mind, crowding out all the quiet corners Bilbo had claimed there.


Now:

 

Yuna was beautiful. 

 

She was also too young for him.

 

This was only partially true. She was no child, a fully-grown dwarrowdam in her own right. If he had to guess, Thorin would place her as too old to be Dís’ child but too young to be Fíli and Kíli’s mother. More than that, however, Thorin felt too old for her . 

 

He had seen too much of the world. He’d been broken too many times. For the first time, he felt guilty in asking for Yuna’s hand (even if he had done so indirectly). She had so much life ahead of her still. A chance to find her One, to live a long life with them… Thorin could offer her gold, but little else. His heart would never be entirely open to her. 

 

To his shock, she seemed to know this already. 

 

They were granted a private audience together shortly after the arrival of the Orcarni entourage. 

 

Thorin could not say what her first impression of him was. His name preceded him easily, and though Thorin knew his feats were renowned, he could bring himself to feel little pride in them. He was no longer the dwarf who headed those tales. His illness after the battle had not been well publicized. It made a better story for him to be the Durin who finally refused to succumb to the madness of his blood than for him to have nearly been destroyed by it. 

 

Yuna was less than star struck. 

 

She reminded him a bit of Dís in her wit, although she seemed to consider her thoughts and words more carefully and carried herself with the unbreakable composure of smooth granite. 

 

“Your One,” She had said to him. “Your Luzun Lansel .”

 

Thorin had flinched at the mention. She said it with no malice, however, and Thorin found he was glad someone had provided her with the information so that he did not have to recount it himself. 

 

“I understand. I too am parted from my One now. Naidrithi astû.” I mourn with you.

 

For a moment, Thorin did not know how to respond. 

 

“Why did you agree to a union with someone who is not your One?” He couldn’t stop himself from asking. If he knew where Bilbo was, if he had some chance at a life with him, Thorin did not know that he could forfeit it so easily. Her eyes left no room for hesitation. 

 

“Why did you?”

Notes:

Khuzdul mostly from Dwarrowscholar

Luzun Lansel - Lost Love[of all loves]
Naidrithi astû - not literal, but essentially, "I mourn with you"

In case the discussion of heirs was unclear: Yuna would be a trans-woman in contemporary society. I like to think gender is handled differently among dwarves, maybe with more emphasis on behavior than on physical bodies. I think this could also play into Gimli's offhand comment about there being very few dwarven women: perhaps 'man' is just the most popular gender, with no correlation to what physical characteristics people possess.
In this case, if there were just an abundance of men in dwarven society, I think it makes sense m/m couples would be fairly common among. I think that many m/m couples would be perfectly capable of having biological children together (in this case, like Dáin and his made-up One, Aurin. Which of them carried Thorin III to term? None of our business).

Chapter 3: What Was Lost

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

It came to the surprise of no one when their engagement was formally announced. 

 

The timing was strategic. The first snows had begun to fall, promising that the Orocarni delegation would stay at least until the passes had cleared in the spring. This would give the people of Erebor time to acquaint themselves with their new partners and it would give Yuna time to adjust to Erebor with the support of her own people. It was, perhaps, an overly cautious timeline. The Blacklock dwarrow of the Red Mountains were nearly as desperate for the union to succeed as the Longbeards of Erebor. The only ones who stood opposed to it were staunch traditionalists who griped about Yuna not being a Longbeard and about there being no children from the union. If they’d been a larger group, Thorin might have worried about an insurrection, but they were few. 

 

The general whispers that Nori brought back to the royal family, was of excitement and curiosity. A few brawls had broken out between the Blacklocks and the Longbeards, but as far as anyone could tell, they were ultimately good natured and the result of too much drinking and merrymaking rather than deep-seated conflict. 

 

The Blacklocks had brought a very large delegation. Besides Yuna, her guards, her lady’s maids, and the rest of her staff, they had brought handfuls of ambassadors and barrelfuls of 

Artisans of every kind: weavers and masons and jewelers and carpenters and tailors and musicians and cooks and cobblers and smiths and all their families who were eager to see Erebor and find fresh markets for their wares and lives for their children.

 

 And, where craft was concerned, curiosity and collaboration was more natural than conflict. Thorin could already taste the Orocarni influence in the dishes being served at the joint dinners.

 

Overall, the match seemed overwhelmingly popular, though it had little to do with Yuna and Thorin and more to do with the upcoming celebrations. 

 


 

“Tell me about him.”

 

No one dared ask Thorin this. No one even dared speak Bilbo’s name around him. Thorin hated it. It made it feel like Bilbo was a hallucination he’d had when he was under the dragon’s hold, instead of the living breathing person he was. Had been. Might be? Thorin had longed to speak of him, but now that the opportunity presented itself he did not know where to begin.

 

“There is… so much,” Thorin said, suddenly unsure of himself. 

 

“Tell me his name,” Yuna prompted as though he were a small, overwhelmed dwarfling. And Thorin felt young in this moment.

 

“Bilbo,” he told her. “Bilbo Baggins.”

 

The name fell oddly on dwarven ears. Thorin had balked at the name himself, just as Yuna was struggling not to do now. He watched with some amusement as her eyebrow twitched.

 

“Bag-In? He lived… inside a bag?” She asked finally, incredulously. And for the first time in what felt like years, Thorin began to smile. 

 

“No. Well, actually, he did.” Yuna’s eyes widened a fraction – practically all out horror on her. “His home was called ‘Bag End’.”

 

And suddenly it became easier to speak. He told her about the Shire and its rolling hills and grassy meadows, about the smials built into the hills, and about Bilbo’s garden which he had loved so dearly. He told her what he knew about hobbits, since they were unheard of in the Red Mountains. 

 

He told her of their journey, of Bilbo’s bravery and ingenuity: how he’d saved them from trolls and wargs and dungeons. He told her how he had gone from skeptical, to cautiously optimistic, to enthralled, how he had given Bilbo the seal of Durin on the Carrock. He told her that by the time they had reached Lake Town, Thorin had offered him his bead.

 

“And what of your One?”

 

Yuna hesitated. Stoicism was considered a feminine virtue and in this regard, Yuna was an exemplary dwarrowdam. She showed only what she wished for others to see and Thorin could already sense what a powerful force that would make her in court.

 

“My Suzu,” she said finally and it was a testament to how deeply she missed her One that Thorin could hear any emotion in her voice when she spoke. “She is… Amsum . She is swift as the Rakhâl , as graceful as smoke on the breeze, as deadly as dragon fire. Anything she takes in hand becomes the most lethal weapon, she is so skilled. She once killed someone with one of my hair combs.”

 

Yuna was far too practical to give in to lovelorn sighing, but her lips twitched in a sad smile.

 

“We could bring her here,” Thorin offered. Perhaps he would feel less guilty for wedding Yuna if she was at least reunited with her One, but Yuna shook her head.

 

“No. If she were here, I could not keep away. I would not disrespect her by asking her to watch me wed another while she waited around like a kept woman. Besides, if I sired children with her, then it would complicate things dangerously.”

 

“But-“

 

“I thank you, Thorin, for your consideration,” Yuna said firmly, “But it is done. I will not sacrifice my people for anything. Not even for her.”

 

Thorin admired her conviction. He wished he could claim the same with any certainty.

 


 

Thorin was not surprised to find that Kíli avoided Yuna nearly as much as he avoided Thorin. At the very least, Thorin didn’t think it was personal. Kíli would have been equally unhappy with anyone Thorin was betrothed to (or, almost anyone). Yuna made a small effort to engage with Kíli, but seemed to have no interest in forcing him to change his opinion of her, which almost seemed to put Kíli out more than if she’d bent over backward trying to befriend him. 

 

She was pleasant to all, if not a bit serious and difficult to read, and Thorin felt certain that the tentative friendship between Yuna and Dís was the only thing keeping Kíli from throwing another fit about it. Kíli was still reaping the rewards of his last outburst, practicing his Trepak with Fíli for the first night of the Mahalmerag celebrations. 

 

Yuna had been intrigued (apparently dancing was a completely different affair in the Orocarni) and she and Dís had spent a long afternoon in deep discussion over the differences. Dís was delighted to learn that there were apparently multiple art forms that combined mastery of a weapon with dance: sword dances, staff dances, and Yuna’s favorite, fan dances. Thorin had finally joined the conversation to express confusion - a fan was not a weapon, after all. 

 

“The edge is razor sharp,” Yuna explained, “And the guard and the ribs are reinforced, usually steel. A master could use one to shave your beard smooth without nicking the skin.”

 

“You should do a demonstration for us,” Dís said with genuine enthusiasm. 

 

“Ah, well, I am no master,” She demurred, “Suzu could make the fans dance as gracefully as butterflies, but I’m afraid I am more akin to the flapping of a hungry gull.”

 

“Then I’m sure you’ll think the lot of us are little more than angry grasshoppers, jumping around as we do,” Dís laughed. Even Thorin found himself cracking a small smile as Yuna hurried to reassure them that she thought no such thing. That was a surprising thing about Yuna: she was terribly clever and serious… and not very good and discerning when someone was giving her a good-natured tease. 

 

“Truly, though,” Dís insisted, “Please consider a demonstration. We Longbeards should learn about our new kin just as much as they learn of us.”

 

“I shall consider,” Yuna said gracefully, but Thorin knew that with Dís at the helm, a performance was all but assured. The pair were truly a force to be reckoned with.

 


 

The first Mahalmerag in Erebor, there had been no celebrations. The battle had been too recent, the mountain still in ruins. Thorin had not even been fully conscious, still fighting off infection from his wounds with a stubborn determination that shocked the Mannish healers who’d come to aid the dwarvish survivors. Last year, enough progress had been made to hold the seven nights (one for each of the seven fathers), but they were still mired in repairs and had little to spare on celebrations. They’d been so few in number that they’d held a public feast, not even bothering to separate along aristocratic lines. 

 

This year was different. The raven crown felt immeasurably heavy on Thorin’s brow as he surveyed the ballroom. Thorin could not help but feel that he was playing pretend, putting on his grandfather’s crown and acting out a pantomime of what Erebor had once been. 

 

The ballroom looked just as he remembered it, bathed in sparkling gold and blue-green light, music and laughter echoing up to the cavernous ceiling high above. He half expected to turn and see his father grumbling about the weight of his ceremonial robes, but it was only Fíli to his right. Although, since losing his eye, he looked more and more like Thráin every day.

 

He, like Thorin and Kíli and Dís, had been laced, buckled, and buttoned into full royal regalia. All of them were in the rich Durin blue of their house, though Fíli and Kíli had shorter surcoats so that they could dance more freely as the evening progressed.

 

Yuna sat to Thorin’s left, ostensibly where she was likely to remain for the rest of their lives. The thought made something in Thorin’s stomach swoop unpleasantly and he didn’t know whether or not to be grateful that she looked so entirely different from his One. There would be no mistaking her from the corner of his eye. 

 

Thorin persevered through the banquet and then through the interminably long line of courtiers, dignitaries, and honored guests, before Fíli and Kíli opened the dancing just as Dís had insisted. For all Kíli’s complaining, he seemed to be enjoying himself now that he had the chance to burn off some energy with his brother. 

 

It felt as though it had been too long since he saw his nephews laughing, especially Fíli. He was doing an exceptional job settling into his role as heir to a kingdom that was finally more than figment, soaking up information like leather took to a good oiling, but since the battle Fíli smiled less. Thorin could not help but feel as though he had personally stolen the ease of Fíli’s smile along with his eye when he allowed him to join the quest. 

 

When the boys had finished and the rest of the crowd had streamed onto the dance floor, Yuna finally tilted her head toward him.

 

“Do you not dance, my lord?” She asked. If it had been Dís, Thorin would have thought that she was teasing, but if she was joking then Yuna was doing a very good job at concealing it.

 

“I shall leave that to the young folk,” he grumbled.

 

“Your beard is still more black than silver,” she arched an eyebrow at him. “And I see several who are far older than you.”

 

“Do you dance?” He shot back.

 

“I do.” Yuna said evenly and Thorin blinked in surprise. But then, of course, she danced. It was part of a royal education, after all. “Though I only know the dances of the Orocarni.”

 

“Then it would be thoughtless to partake while you could not,” Thorin said quickly, seizing on the opportunity. He did not know what made him feel so averse. He still remembered the steps, for all that he was certainly rusty. 

 

Everything was so similar that Thorin could not help the irrational fear that if he stepped off the dias where they’d placed him that he would find himself back in the days of his childhood. The thought should have brought him joy, to recapture days when his family had been whole and their people had prospered, but all Thorin could feel was the impending sense of doom that none of them had seen yet. 

 

“Thorin,” Yuna said, pulling him from his thoughts. “Go. Dance.”

 

Thorin opened his mouth to protest again but Yuna gave him a withering look and spoke over him. “Show them that you are not a statue rolled out for decoration. Speak to people. Build affection. It is a valuable currency.”

 

Thorin had lived with Dís’ stubbornness long enough to recognize when he’d been defeated and he begrudgingly shed his heavy cloak. It was impractically long and fur lined and Thorin couldn’t take a single step while he wore the damn thing. Thorin had a sneaking suspicion that the master of ceremonies had thrust it upon him as petty revenge. The poor dwarf had nearly wept when he realized that no one in the royal family had an appropriately full beard ( Dís came closest with Fíli’s whiskers coming in at a close second). Apparently if he could not be counted on to grow his own fur, then fur would be forcibly provided for him. 

 

Thorin didn’t know whether it was a good sign or a bad one that Yuna was proved right so quickly. He felt better at an eye level with his subjects, without the weight of the cloak on his shoulders. He spotted Gloín already dancing with his wife in a small cluster, Balin and one of the Blacklock ambassadors with their heads bent together on a couch beneath the arcade, and Daín clinking his glass against Dwalin’s by the buffet table. He found Fíli and Kíli with their cousin, young Stonehelm, nearly in tears for laughing so hard. It took him a moment to find the source of their amusement: young Gimli had found the courage to ask another young dwarf to dance. His dance partner, however, was apparently much lighter on his feet and Gimli was red in the face with the exertion of trying to keep up. 

 

Something about the scene made Thorin think inexplicably of summer breezes in leafy oak branches, the image so sudden and clear that he had to blink hard to rid himself of the twinkling lights dangling from the phantom tree. Perhaps it was just the season. He’d heard that some Men hung lights from tree boughs for their midwinter festivals. Perhaps he’d seen something similar the last time he was in Dale.

 

When the dance ended, Gimli finally accepted defeat, sketching a sweaty bow to his partner and retreating to his laughing kinsmen. Thorin glanced back at the dias to find Yuna watching him expectantly. She did not actually wave her hand at him, but there was no mistaking the expectation in her eyes. 

 

Thorin joined the next dance. This one was not made for pairs, but in large groups, inner and outer rings rotating so that partners shifted and changed in time with the beat. Thorin was out of practice, but even a century could not entirely rid him of the steps drilled into him by his childhood dance master. 

 

He clasped hands with his own courtiers, with a few brave Blacklocks who tried to learn the dance on the spot, with dwarves from Daín’s entourage. He even found himself opposite Gloín at one point. He tried his best to at least greet them, as Yuna had suggested, inquiring after names, giving his thanks for their attendance. 

 

He reached for the next dancer and was swamped with that same sensation of warm wind through leafy trees, the chime of glass lanterns hanging from its boughs, only- no, it was his new partner that chimed. The dwarf kept his head down, giving Thorin a clear view of the tiny silver bells braided into his hair. This was the cause of the sound in his ears. Nothing else. 

 

“Have we been introduced?” Thorin asked, momentarily forgetting his King’s Voice. The words sounded nearly accusatory rather than inquisitive and the dwarf flinched. He - Thorin assumed the dwarf was a he- said something, but between the music and the stomping of dancing feet and the jingle of the bells, Thorin could not catch the words.

 

“You are not one of my courtiers,” He said, frowning as he tried to place the head of tawny hair. 

 

“No, your majesty,” the dwarf agreed. His hands were unusually small. Thorin caught the dwarf stealing glances up at him from beneath his bangs and caught a glimpse of wide eyes and a short beard. He must be quite young, perhaps. Thorin finally realized why he seemed familiar; this was the dwarf that young Gimli had danced with earlier.

 

His curiosity was satisfied as the dance spun them away from one another once more. Strangely, Thorin could have sworn he could still hear the bells tinkling in the young dwarf’s hair, even as they were swept to opposite sides of the room. Perhaps it was a new fashion. Perhaps Gimli’s dance partner was not the only one with such fanciful taste. 

 

Thorin had meant to ask about the bells when their hands finally met again, but when he opened his mouth all that came out was, “If you’re not a part of my court, then you must belong to Daín’s party.”

 

To Thorin’s surprise, the dwarf stifled an undignified snort of laughter. “No, your majesty, I most certainly do not belong to Daín’s company.”

 

There was something odd about the way the dwarf stressed it and he must have realized how strange it sounded because the young dwarf stumbled over himself to add, “I would never presume to hold an invitation to Lord Daín’s traveling party.” 

 

“But you have merited an invitation to this party,” Thorin pointed out, “So you cannot be completely without status.”

 

“Your majesty is kind to say so,”

 

Again the dance whisked them apart, into the hands of other partners, circling beneath the blue and gold lights above, and eventually delivering them to one another once again. 

 

“Then, do I know your kin?” Thorin asked when they met again. 

 

“I would be very surprised if you did,” the dwarf said, ducking his head again. All false modesty and platitudes. 

 

“Durin’s beard, is it so difficult to provide me a name?” He groused, the words once again slipping out in his typical voice. Rather than offense, his grumbling drew a sharp chuff of laughter from the young dwarf.

 

“Certainly not, Majesty, I can provide you with a dozen names if you choose. Just off the top of my head, I can think of “Daín,” “Hannar,” “Róaldur,” and “Nipar.” Do any of these names please you?”

 

Annoyance surged in Thorin’s chest but it was an undignified snort of laughter that came out, rather than words of rebuke. They were parted once more and this time the dance came to an end and Gimli’s dance partner melted into the crowd. 

 


 

Thorin had meant it when he said that he never wished to lay eyes on the Arkenstone again. His wishes, in this case, were not meant to bear fruit. Thorin was too stunned to do more than stare down into his plate, deaf to his family’s increasingly frantic questions.

 

It was only that one didn’t usually expect to have their spoon hit something entirely solid in their porridge, much less to find a priceless heirloom of their family half-hidden and sticky with stewed oats. And yet, there it was. Somehow, even smeared with the remains of breakfast, the Luzun Arkenstone sparkled and shone as though lit up from within. It was only a shard. One side had been polished smooth, shaped by expert hands, while the other was jagged as knapped flint where it had broken off from its greater half. 

 

Around him, his kin were in an uproar. 

 

“Is it truly-? But, how did it come to be in Uncle’s breakfast?” Kíli gawked, all frustration with Thorin forgotten. 

 

“You there, lad, do you know anything about this?” Dáin demanded, pushing his chair out from the table to corner the young dwarf who’d placed the dish before Thorin. 

 

“Someone summon Nori, we need his eyes and ears,” Dís ordered. “And Dwalin. It may be meant as a threat.”

 

“Someone should inform the Blacklocks,” Fíli said, “Or Lady Yuna, at least.”

 

“No, don’t tell them anything,” Young Stonehelm said, leaping to his feet, “It might have been one of them that did it!”

 

“We should question everyone involved in the preparation of this meal,” Dáin was still looming ominously over the poor server, who seemed to be doing his best not to cower. 

 

“Or, perhaps it would be better to keep it a secret. To keep whoever did this wondering as to whether or not they succeeded,” Dís frowned.

 

“I just don’t understand when it could have happened. Bombur would definitely sniff out a traitor in his kitchen. He’d never allow anything through the doors that might hurt someone.” Fíli’s eyes darted between the Luzun Arkenstone and the rest of the family. 

 

“Unless he knew about this,” Kíli’s voice rose with excitement. “Uncle, do you think he– Uncle, are you alright?”

 

Thorin pushed his chair back from the table so hard that it toppled over behind him. The crash silenced his family and made his footsteps echo as he whirled, dead set on the kitchens. He could not breathe. There was not enough air. His chest burned and Thorin reached for the fury before he could think twice. 

 

He did not wait to be announced this time, merely threw open the kitchen doors, bellowing for Bombur. Bombur, for once, was not on duty but Thorin was too far gone even to be grateful for the alibi. He seized on Bombur’s second in command as a viable alternative to vent his fury. To his credit, the cook held onto most of his composure, even with Thorin shouting at the top of his lungs, waving the Luzun Arkenstone about like a dagger. 

 

Then Dís and Dáin caught up to him, his shame following shortly after. They did not have to convince him to cloister himself away in his room. Thorin did not know if he could have faced anyone at all, even as King Under the Mountain, after such a display. He allowed Dís to pry the Luzun Arkenstone from his hands without complaint; his one victory among his otherwise wretched failures.

 

The rage dissipated, dropping from Thorin’s shoulders like a cloak. Thorin felt bare without it, exposed to the truth of his own inner turmoil. His fear. Thorin paced his rooms, feeling caged but too shaken to leave them. He’d not had an outburst like that in quite some time. Was it the stone? Did the madness threaten to take him again after a single glance at the stone? He ought to be doing something to find the culprit or to make decisions about who to tell and what to tell them. They couldn’t keep such a thing secret for long. Durin’s beard, what would the kingdom think? He should be helping strategize at least, but what if the madness had him once more? What if his judgment was clouded? What if he hurt someone?

 

He did not know how long it was before the knock on his door came. It was Yuna. Thorin nearly snapped at her to leave. What if he had to explain himself? What if he turned on her ? What if their dealings with the Blacklocks fell apart because he couldn’t keep a hold on his tongue. 

 

Thorin did not speak, but Yuna must have seen his agitation for she held up a hand as though to quiet him. 

 

“Peace, my lord,” she said evenly, “I am not here to interrogate you, merely to discuss the next steps.”

 

So Dís and Dáin had decided to share the news with the Blacklocks after all. Thorin gave a curt nod, only belatedly remembering to offer her a seat. The couch she sank onto was plush, but her back was so straight that she might have been perched on hard marble. 

 

“The matter has been discussed and we have put forth an announcement,” she told him.

 

“No one discussed this with me,” he bristled. He could feel his temper flaring once again. Am I not king? You have all sworn fealty to me , but you would plot and scheme behind my back? There was a time when the words would have leapt from his mouth but he had more practice now keeping them behind his teeth. 

 

“It is your wish to seal the Luzun Arkenstone away with its other half, is it not? It shall be done. Your wishes were considered. As was your… health.” She said delicately.

 

“What announcement have you made?” He growled, prickling at the unspoken insinuation. 

 

“Only a proclamation that it has been found,” Yuna assured him. “Obviously, the manner in which it was discovered has not been announced. Nori has put forth whispers that an apprentice to the treasurer may have noticed it while taking inventory. Those closest will know that such a thing is not true, but it should be enough for most people.”

 

He should have known that Nori would have a heavy hand in the affair. If Thorin weren’t completely convinced of Nori’s loyalty, if he hadn’t been a member of the original company, Thorin had no doubt that Nori would be a wanted dwarf by now. 

 

“Balin suggested that we hold a reunion ceremony after Mahalmerag,” she continued. “Just in case the symbolism was lost on anyone.”

 

“The symbolism?” Thorin finally echoed. Yuna sighed heavily.

 

“Two parts coming together to form a whole? You and I know the truth, naturally, but anything that solidifies the image of a happy union is a blessing in disguise. Nori is helping to ensure that this is the message observers come away with. We could not have asked for a better portent if we staged it ourselves.”

 

“Did you?” Thorin asked sharply. Yuna shot him an unimpressed look.

 

“I would have warned you of my intention to do such a thing,” She said, her mouth twisting into the first sign he’d seen of something resembling a scowl as she muttered. “And I would never desecrate the Heart of the Mountain with porridge .”

 

Thorin felt something relax in his shoulders. It was good to be suspicious but if he and Yuna were to spend their lives together then he needed to trust her. 

 

“Is another ceremony really necessary?” Thorin grumbled. “I’d rather have it locked away now. ”

 

“You have to think about appearances, Thorin.” Yuna chided. She sounded like Dís.  “Why now? Why on the eve of this marriage? Why in such a public fashion? They sent the Luzun Arkenstone to you at a time when you would be in the company of others and it could not be kept secret. They sent it to you in a personal way, where it could easily have been something that hurt you.”

 

“You think whoever it is means to kill me?” Thorin was not as alarmed as he probably ought to be by the suggestion. 

 

“No, I think they want to attract your attention. I think they want to make it impossible for you to ignore them or hide from them. It could very well be a threat, I don’t know yet.”

 

“So why not announce it as such? We could increase security measures, tell people what to look for.”

 

“You want to increase suspicions among people now?   Thorin, our people have never been enemies, but this is the first time many of them have ever interacted. If we want this union to succeed, we need to build trust between our people. Throwing something like this between them so early on could damage those relations, perhaps forever.”   

 

This much was true. Dwarrow were not known for their quick and easy forgiveness. A grudge formed was a grudge kept.

 

“You were protecting me?”

 

“I was trying to protect all of us… Orocarni cannot afford for this to fail.”  Yuna stood, smoothing out her skirts. She gave Thorin a long hard look before she left. “Please do not dispute it, Thorin. Keep your wits about you, remain alert, but please allow this explanation to remain in place. We need the approval of the people and we need them to continue working together.”

Notes:

Translations:

Amsum - [a] marvel

Rakhâl - a river that flows near the red mountains

Chapter 4: The Relics

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Sitting on the dais in the ballroom that evening, watching Yuna and her ladies in waiting perform their Orocarni dances for the crowds, Thorin felt unmoored. It was hard to believe that just this morning he’d held the shard of the Luzun Arkenstone. It did not seem right. Thorin felt as though his world had shifted, just a little, and it was disorienting that no one else seemed to see it. 

 

He waited until the crowd was well and truly captivated by Yuna before he slipped out of his heavy cloak - a golden brocade with heavy beaded embellishments that weighed at least as much as the furs from the previous night. There would be no subtle escape dragging that in his wake. 

 

Thorin didn’t flatter himself to think that he slipped into the crowd unnoticed. More than one guest did a double take when he passed them. By the time Yuna had retaken her seat, Thorin was safely ensconced by the buffet table. 

 

He picked idly at the offering. He had no stomach for it, but doing so allowed him to keep his back to the room. When he’d slowly negotiated his way past piles of baked goods and platters of perfectly arranged canapés, he was blocked by a dwarf about a head shorter than him. The young noble was so distracted watching the crowds that he took no notice that anyone was trying to pass him, let alone the king. 

 

Thorin was surprised to realize that he recognized the oblivious guest. It was the dwarf who’d danced with young Gimli the previous night. Binimnâl. Nameless One. 

 

The music from the Orocarni musicians seemed to grow louder in Thorin’s ears. He was not familiar with all of their instruments. There seemed to be an unusual one that sounded much like the patter of gentle spring rain, and another like the quiet clink of porcelain being set upon a table. He’d have to remember to ask what made the oddly comforting sound when he got the chance.

 

Binimnâl, as Thorin had decided to call him in his head, was distracted enough that Thorin was given a chance to observe him in peace. Given how long he’d danced the night before, Thorin was a little surprised that he wasn’t back on the dancefloor. He wore a fur-trimmed surcoat of a deep ochre color. At his neck sat a small broach in the shape of a butterfly, the wire filaments of its wings so delicate that they fluttered with every breath Binimnâl took. His hair and beard were relatively short. The beard could be excused by age but his hair only brushed his shoulders. Curious. Perhaps he’d cut it in mourning. Given the length, the death would have occurred around the time of the Battle, which made sense. There was something familiar about the upturn of Binimnâl’s nose and in the honey brown color of his hair. 

 

Thorin sucked in a sharp breath as soon as he realized who he’d been comparing this dwarf to. Far too many times in the months after the Battle, Thorin had caught himself turning after anyone whose hair was a similar shade, who was of the correct height. It was never Bilbo, of course, but he felt as though he’d driven himself halfway back to madness imagining him out of the corner of his eye. Thorin averted his gaze but his harsh gasp had already drawn Binimnâl’s attention.

 

Binimnâl startled, jerking and hastily trying to swoop into a bow.

 

“Your majesty-“ He began, but Thorin waved him off.

 

“Quietly now,” Thorin said quickly, “It was not easy to escape and I have no wish to be placed back on my pedestal just yet.”

 

Binimnâl straightened but Thorin kept his eyes directed over Binimnâl’s shoulder rather than on his face. He only caught the impression of a small smile from the corner of his eyes.

 

“Your secret is safe with me.” Binimnâl assured him. Durin’s beard, but he even sounded a bit like Bilbo now that Thorin’s mind was preoccupied with conjuring him.“I shall not reveal you.”

 

“Nor yourself, it would seem,” Thorin huffed, “Do you truly withhold even your name from me?”

 

“With my deepest apologies, my lord,” The laughter was more pronounced in Binimnâl’s voice now and Thorin could practically hear Bilbo’s sarcastic deadpan, I’ve some skill at conkers. Thorin tried to banish the thought with limited success. 

 

“What of your purpose in Erebor? Surely you can tell me that, at least.” Thorin said. 

 

“I am here to see my kin,”

 

“Who are your kin?” Thorin asked.

 

“No one of great importance, I can assure you,”

 

“And how do you gauge such a thing?” Thorin asked, a little more sharply than he’d meant to. “There were coal miners, cooks, tinkerers, toy-makers in my Company when we reclaimed the mountain. I’d say that all were greatly important, though they did not trace their lineage to any of the Fathers.”

 

There were gentle hobbits, burglars, barrel-riders, riddle-makers. He was important.

 

“I— I had not thought of it like that, your majesty.” Binimnâl said, clearly taken aback and Thorin tried to reel in his urge to hammer the point home.

 

“And besides, whoever your kin are, the Master of Ceremonies deemed them “important” enough to warrant an invitation, if you are here to see them.” 

 

“I doubt you are familiar with them,” Binimnâl said quickly. Thorin sighed heavily. He had no wish to interrogate Binimnâl. He had heavier matters to think on.

 

“If you refuse to tell me about yourself, Binimnâl, then at least entertain me.” Thorin commanded. 

 

Binimnâl was silent for a beat, thinking. Then he spoke:

 

“A heart, though I do not beat ,

Inspiring hunger, though I do not eat,

Softly glowing, though I do not burn,

To the King, I shall always return.

What am I?”

 

Thorin turned the riddle over in his head for only a moment before he gave up. Again, he had more important matters to spend his energy on. “I do not know. What is it?”

 

“The Heart of the Mountain. The King’s Jewel… The Arkenstone.” Binimnâl said. Thorin stiffened and Binimnâl hesitated before he added, “It is said the Luzun Arkenstone has returned.”

 

Thorin’s heart swooped. Yuna had said that it had been announced. It might have been more strange for Binimnâl not to inquire about it. And yet the tension lodged in Thorin’s chest made him unable to keep the grimace from his face.

 

“Returned,” he said between gritted teeth, “Only to be sealed away as soon as possible.”

 

He had practice being diplomatic. It was his job now to step lightly, speak politely, but the damned jewel had cost him too much. Only, that wasn’t quite right. The Arkenstone was a cold, mindless jewel. Thorin had been responsible for his actions, no matter how he wished to lay the blame elsewhere. 

 

“They are saying it is a sign,” Binimnâl said and Thorin did not think he was mistaken about the note of surprise in his voice. “That what was lost has now been recovered.”

 

Nothing worth having has been recovered, Thorin nearly snarled. Fíli’s eye, Kíli’s steady stride, Dwalin’s confidence in him, Dis’ trust— Bilbo. Mahal, he did not even know if his madness had cost his beloved his life. None of these things could be returned to him.

 

He took a deep breath through his nose. “ Nothing” was a bit of a stretch. He and the Company had survived. Erebor was restored. The Longbeards who’d followed Thror into Azanulbizar finally had a home. They had gold enough that they would never again have to stoop and scrape just to avoid starvation. If the union with the Blacklocks succeeded, then Erebor would flourish, might again be filled with the laughter of children , rare and blessed as such things were. This was not nothing.

 

“It should have stayed lost,” Thorin finally growled. 

 

He did not hear Binimnâl’s stuttered excuses as Thorin turned away from him and made his way back to the dias. His expression must have been thunderous, for none dared to stop him on his way back. The Orocarni’s music felt like it was echoing in his ears, though he could see the musicians had stopped playing: something about that comforting sound stuck with him, like someone in an adjacent room making a cup of tea on a rainy day. 

 

Yuna had returned to her seat as well and she leaned toward him when Thorin had settled the heavy brocade mantle back over his shoulders.

 

“Who was the dwarf you spoke to just now?” She asked, her voice low. Thorin would have shrugged if the cloak hadn’t been so heavy.

 

“The lad refused to say.” Thorin said, “I’m calling him Binimnâl until he does.”

 

“What did you speak of?” Yuna’s voice was neutral but Thorin was beginning to recognize the exact shade of neutrality that she called upon. This was not genuine, this was cautious, tapping the ice with a foot to see if it would hold weight. 

 

“What else? The Luzun Arkenstone. ” It was on the lips of every dwarf who’d heard of its reappearance. How could it not be? Yuna was silent until Thorin finally asked, “Did you notice something unusual about him?”

 

“His belt.” Yuna said finally. “And his boots. He wore a fine surcoat and jewels, but his belt and his boots were plain. Workman’s wear.”

 

Truthfully, Thorin had not noticed. He’d tried not to look to closely at Binimnâl

 

“And he refused to share his identity.” Thorin said slowly. On its own, neither piece of information was incriminating but together it did raise an alarm (if only a small one).

 

“I’d like to inform your Master of Whispers.” Yuna told him,  “I want to know more of this Binimnâl.”

 

Do you truly think that necessary? Thorin wanted to ask. Binimnâl was an odd one, but Thorin sensed no animosity in his peculiar behavior. But he was hiding something. Thorin could not deny that. 

 

“I trust your judgment,” he said.

 


 

That night Thorin dreamt of the ramparts again. Again the wind blew harsher and colder than it had ever done in real life. Thorin threw Bilbo to the rocks below, but instead of a sickening crunch, the Hobbit shattered like crockery. 

 

Thorin stared at the fragments of his Luzun Lansel where they glittered, a thousand shards of the Arkenstone out where any treacherous Man or Elf could snatch away.

 

In his dream, Thorin screamed for the shards to be collected and reassembled, as though he could put Bilbo back together again if they only found all the pieces. The wind whipped his words away and he woke to Dís knocking at his door once more.

 

“I do not understand,” he confided to his sister, too shaken to turn her away. “I do not understand.”

 

He had not dreamt of Bilbo since Durin’s Day, though he did not doubt why the dreams had returned. The ache of uncertainty was a fresh wound in his chest. Or perhaps it was only the old scars acting up. Thorin felt as though he were the Gabil Arkenstone , cracked, incomplete, his edges jagged and fragile. 

 


 

Thorin woke without any memory of falling asleep. In fact, it hardly felt as though he’d slept either, though the foul taste in his mouth and the crick in his neck suggested otherwise. 

 

He dined with his kin for breakfast, but there was a general pall over the group compared to yesterday. When breakfast was served, Thorin bid his server to remain. The young dwarf’s eyes went wide as saucers but he didn’t dare disobey a direct order from his king, though his hands shook the silver platter he held. 

 

There was no porridge today (he’d forbidden it after yesterdays), but he stabbed viciously at his eggs, determined to root out any secrets they might hold. The eggs remained innocuous and Thorin breathed a sigh of relief. He lifted his tea to begin the meal… and felt something clink against the bottom of the teacup. 

 

Thorin swore ferociously, reaching into the cup, heedless of the heat and the mess. His fingers closed around something small and metal, warm from sitting in the tea and concealed by the cream that had been added. Thorin swore his heart stopped when he uncurled his fist to see what lay on his palm. 

 

It was his signet ring. In truth, he’d known it when his fingers brushed the finely wrought cirth . How could he not? He’d carried it on his own hand for more than half a century before he gave it to Bilbo. The silver was still warm from sitting in the tea, warm enough to feel as though someone had only just slipped it off their fingers. 

 

Someone gave a low wrenching groan and it took a moment for Thorin to realize that the sound came from himself. And then Thorin lost track of time. 

 

He knew on a factual level that he had stormed out of the room, his hand an iron band on the unlucky server who’d brought his meal. He knew that he’d hauled the lad down to the kitchens and shouted himself hoarse. He could not remember what he’d said, though he remembered the color draining away from the kitchen staff’s faces. He knew that It had taken Balin and Fíli plying him with logic and placations to lead him away before he did irreparable damage. 

 

Thorin came to himself in the afternoon. He was in his own parlor, seated on a couch by the fire. He was shaking from head to toe, breathing as though he’d just led a charge in battle. His fingers ached, his knuckles white from how tightly he still gripped the ring. 

 

Balin knelt in front of him, speaking softly, his hand resting over Thorin’s closed fist. 

 

“Come now, lad, let’s see it now. No harm will come to it, we only want to see.” Balin kept up a low murmur of placations as he gently tried to pry open Thorin’s fist. 

 

Thorin jerked back instinctively, pulling his fist to his chest, and Thorin saw the exact moment the fear and heartbreak threatened to overwhelm Balin. Thorin gave another wounded sound. He was doing it again. He was losing himself to the madness of his bloodline. He was failing the people he loved once again. 

 

“Balin-” Thorin’s voice cracked, but he could not give voice to anything that might have followed. Balin, I am afraid. Balin, help, I don’t know what to do. Balin, do what you must, protect the kingdom from me, do not let me destroy everything we’ve worked so hard to build. He couldn’t say any of it. A king was not afforded such vulnerabilities.

 

Balin stayed before him, still kneeling as though he were in the midst of swearing fealty, and the thought of Balin doing so even with the madness sinking its claws back into him made the scars on Thorin’s chest burn. 

 

With a shuddering breath, Thorin unclenched his fist. He held out his palm, the ring trembling right along with Thorin’s hand. 

 

Slowly, Balin lifted it from Thorin’s outstretched palm. He held it toward the firelight, squinting and running his fingertips over the cirth, just as Thorin had done. 

 

“It is genuine,” Someone said and Thorin realized suddenly that they were not alone in the room. Dís and Dwalin sat slightly further away. It was Dís who had spoken. She held out her hand and Balin passed her the ring. She turned it over before passing it in turn to Dwalin. 

 

“It is genuine,” she repeated solemnly. “The small dent in the corner. It saved Thorin from losing a finger to Kíli’s attempt at mastering the dagger.”

 

Thorin remembered the incident. Kíli had been very young, but old enough to begin training. He’d still idolized Fíli so much, wanting to emulate him in all things - including his penchant for knives. Thorin had managed to keep the finger, thanks to the weight of his ring, but he’d still needed three stitches. Kíli had cried and cried, as though he were the one who’d been injured. It was not long after this incident that Kíli abandoned blades in favor of the bow.

 

“Balin,” Thorin said again, ashamed of how unsteady his voice sounded. “That ring. I gave it- I gave it to- It should not be here.”

 

Balin and Dwalin’s faces both grew solemn, the silence stretching out unbearably.

 

“It might not have anything to do with him,” Dwalin finally grunted. “He could’ve lost it in the battle. Anyone might have picked it up.”

 

Thorin didn’t know whether he wanted the ring back, to cradle against his chest, or whether it ought to remain in safer hands than his own. His mind was finally anchored here, to this room, but he feared that his wits might leave him once more if given the chance. 

 

“I’m going to consult Nori,” Dís finally said, rising from her chair. “He should know about this.”

 

 Dwalin silently stood to follow her, passing the ring back to Balin before he left. Guilt tugged at Thorin for being glad to see him go. He felt scraped raw, like a tanned hide, stretched thin and taut. He did not wish for either of them to see him like this any more than they already did. 

 

“Balin,” Thorin swallowed, “Will you stay with me?”

 

He felt incredibly foolish to ask, like a dwarfling still scared of the dark, but he didn’t know what else to do. Balin had already seen him at his most broken and somehow still called him ‘king.’ Balin nodded.

 

“Would you like me to… hang onto this?” Balin asked delicately. “Only for safe keeping.”

 

Thorin wasn’t sure what he ought to do, but he knew what he wanted. His voice was very nearly timid when he said, “I’d like it back. Please.”

 

Balin dropped it back in Thorin’s hand without reproach and Thorin once more closed his fingers around it. The ring was just as heavy as he remembered, a grounding weight both physically and emotionally. The ring was hardly the be all and end all of legitimacy, but it was one of the trappings that came with heading the Line of Durin. Any who bore the ring would be recognized as, at the very least, a valued friend and ally if they sought help from another dwarf (at least, any dwarf friendly to the Line of Durin). Thorin hooked his thumb through the ring and spun it over and over in his hands.

 

He and Balin sat in silence for a long time before Thorin spoke again. 

 

“Is it the madness again? The gold sickness?” He asked finally. “Tell me plainly, Balin. If it is, then we must take precautions sooner rather than later.”

 

Balin pondered the question for a moment, bushy brows furrowing before he asked, “Might I see the ring a moment?”

 

Thorin reluctantly handed it back and Balin broke into a genuine smile. He held it for only a moment before passing it back. 

 

“No, lad, I don’t think it’s the gold sickness.” He said confidently. “If there is madness, it is not the curse of your line or lust for gold.”

 

“How can you be certain?” Thorin asked, once again spinning the ring in his fingers. 

 

“Firstly, I’d like to think I know the difference, having borne witness to how such a thing manifests in you before. There was pride in you before. This time I feared you’d take shears to your beard again if Dwalin hadn’t wrestled you into place.” Balin explained. “Furthermore, your wishes have been phrased as requests, not commands… Even that aside, you parted with the ring when I asked it of you.”

 

Thorin hadn’t thought of that. The idea of losing the ring pained him deeply and he hoped to keep it in his hands for as long as he could, but he could not deny that it was… different. In the throws of his gold lust, Thorin had felt the Arkenstone’s absence like a severed limb. The sight of it in any hands other than his own had filled him with such fury that he’d felt as though he would burst into flames with it. The ring had no such pull. Only sorrow.

 

Before Thorin could inquire further, there was a sharp knock on his door. It had not been long since Dís had left, but far be it from Thorin to question how Nori might travel so swiftly. Only, rather than Nori, it was Yuna who appeared when Thorin called to enter. 

 

She was dressed down, which Thorin had only seen a handful of times before and still took him by surprise. Her dark hair was twisted into a knot on top of her head with only a few braids of distinction. 

 

“What is it?” Thorin asked and it spoke to how well she’d gotten used to him that she didn’t blink at his blunt tone. She stepped in and shut the door behind her without further invitation. Only when she saw Balin did she sweep into an appropriately formal bow, which Balin stood to return. 

 

Yuna glanced between Thorin and Balin before raising an eyebrow in question. 

 

“Balin knows all that there is to tell,” Thorin said, “You may speak freely in front of him.”

 

Yuna inclined her head respectfully, “I wished to discuss the findings of my investigation thus far, but I can see that there are other matters at hand. What has happened?”

 

Balin did Thorin the courtesy of explaining the ring and its significance both as an heirloom and as a courting gift. Upon request, Thorin allowed Yuna to inspect the ring and was satisfied that she handled it with the utmost reverence. 

 

“That is troubling,” she said, handing the ring back to Thorin. Coming from Yuna, it might as well have been a cry of outrage, she so rarely voiced her opinion unsolicited. “I wonder…”

 

“You said your investigations had borne fruit,” Thorin prompted. Yuna nodded. 

 

“Investigations?” Balin asked. Yuna raised a single unimpressed eyebrow at Thorin as though to chide him. He knows all there is, does he? Thorin was too exhausted to do more than sketch the broadest outline for Balin. Balin seemed unconvinced but held his tongue until Yuna shared what she learned.

 

“I had him trailed last night when he left the festivities. Your Binimnâl is not of noble birth. He resides in the lower district. Or else has dealings there that would keep him through the night. ”

 

“Being common is not a crime,” Thorin said, “Nor is gate crashing, for that matter.”

 

“No. But do you believe it is mere coincidence that this Binimnâl has appeared at the same time as the Luzun Arkenstone? As the seal of Durin?”

 

“We cannot even be sure the two are connected,” Thorin said, but it sounded weak even to his own ears. 

 

“It stretches credibility to believe that they are not,” Balin shook his head glumly. “The method of delivery was the same, the same time of day, to the same location… What are the odds that two dwarves thought to bestow these heirlooms the same way at nearly the same time?”

 

“I don’t like it,” Thorin said finally. If the two were truly connected, what did it mean that the same person had been in possession of both the Luzun Arkenstone and the ring? How long had this person had them? And why relinquish them now?

 

“I still have people watching him,” Yuna assured him. “Hopefully Binimnâl will return again tonight and we can learn something more.”

 

“Tonight?” Thorin echoed, brow creasing. Both Yuna and Balin looked at him expectantly.

 

“The final night of festivities,” Balin finally said. Thorin opened his mouth to protest. He could not possibly attend a ball after all that had happened today. All that had happened yesterday. Even if they did not have concerns about plots brewing right under their noses, Thorin was still shaken. He felt like a dishrag that had been wrung out too fiercely. How could he possibly appear in front of his people in such a state? Yuna cut him off before Thorin could raise any objections.

 

“Appearances, Thorin.” She said firmly. “You need not leave the dias if you do not wish, but you must show your face.”

 

Thorin shut his eyes and took a deep breath. One night. He could pretend for one more night.

 


 

Thorin could not pretend for one more night. He felt as though his formal robes were suffocating him. The crown was making his head ache and the beads woven into his hair felt too heavy, tugging at his scalp. 

 

He should not have brought the ring with him to the festivities, but he was gripped by the irrational fear that it would vanish if he left it behind. He knew that his endless fidgeting was putting Fíli and Kíli on edge and he did not blame them for excusing themselves the moment Dís granted them permission. Thorin would have done the same if he could have, but he was bound to his chair by duty. 

 

The line of guests waiting to greet him snaked out the door and it took every ounce of diplomacy that had ever been drilled into Thorin to keep his tone cordial as the procession dragged on. Thorin knew he was not doing as well as he’d hoped when Yuna flicked him a sharp look, eyes darting between Thorin and the ring he still turned over and over in his hand. Just as Thorin was about to give up and throw propriety to the wolves, Yuna straightened - an impressive feat, considering her already immaculate posture. 

 

Naturally, this was also the moment the musicians decided to strike up. He was fairly certain it was a fiddle, though the tune was a bright, merry one that he did not recognize. People were clapping along to the tune, though Thorin couldn’t spot where they were, nor why they all seemed familiar with the decidedly un-dwarvish song. It was very distracting and Thorin had half a mind to holler for them to keep it down.  

 

Binimnâl approached. It was only now that Thorin realized that it was the first night the young dwarf did so. After so much discussion, Thorin could not help but glance at Binimnâl’s belt and boots. It was as Yuna said: they were plain. The leather was not even tooled. It looked especially odd now against his surcoat, a shot silk that looked nearly white from a distance but which shimmered green and pink and blue as he moved. Thorin knew the material alone cost a fortune. Why on earth would someone go to the lengths needed to secure such a garment only to neglect all else?

 

“Greetings, your majesty,”

 

Binimnâl ducked his head when he bowed and his hair sparkled with tiny crystal beads with the same iridescence as the surcoat. Thorin’s fist clenched around the ring. If Binimnâl had anything to do with it’s sudden reappearance- if he had anything to do with the Luzun Arkenstone’s reappearance- and then to have the nerve to tell him riddles about it last night! Thorin grit his teeth. 

 

“I’ve no patience for games tonight, Binimnâl,” Thorin growled, “Give me your name and be done with it.”

 

Binimnâl started, nearly standing up only to dip into a lower, more reverential bow.

 

“Baldor, son of Gildor, your majesty,” Binimnâl- Baldor said, addressing his words to the floor.

 

While Baldor’s head was down, Yuna shot Thorin a warning look. If he kept grimacing and snapping, he’d alert Baldor to their suspicions. If Baldor was involved, it wouldn’t do to send him into hiding by giving anything away too soon. Thorin forced himself to take a deep breath.

 

“Thank you for your attendance this evening, Lord Baldor,” Thorin’s words were still unnaturally stiff. Baldor (if that was even truly his name) took a step backward without raising his head, but when Thorin made no move to call him back, he peered up at Thorin through his fringe.

 

“Forgive me, your majesty, if I am too bold,” He said quietly, “But you seem to carry a heavier burden than usual. I am at your service, should you require it.”

 

Thorin felt his frustration surge. If Baldor was guilty then the taunt of this could not be endured. He would not stand to have this imposter , this rat , stand there and innocently offer to help Thorin when he very well knew that he was the cause of his strife. 

 

“You are right, Lord Baldor. You are too bold.” Thorin managed to control his volume, but not the venom that laced his voice. Baldor flinched at the open hostility and made his exit without further comment. When he was well and truly out of earshot, Yuna spoke.

 

“ Thorin. ” She said. She did not need to say more, her warning and reprimand clear in her voice. Thorin tried not to sink lower in his throne like a pouting child. 

 

When the line finally came to an end, Thorin sat up, ready to shrug off his latest robe and escape into the crowd, but Yuna placed a gentle hand on his arm.

 

“Allow me,” she said calmly. Thorin tilted his head in confusion. “You are too obvious. You’ve been growling like a bear all evening. Stay here, at least for now.”

 

Thorin sat back in his chair, defeated, while Yuna made her way down to the dancefloor. He watched impassively, still spinning his ring in endless circles around his thumb. 

 

He had to give credit where credit was due. Yuna joined the dancing without being noticeably out of place. She must have worked hard to learn their steps so quickly, even if she had not mastered them yet. That damned fiddle was still playing. How anyone was meant to keep time with two songs going simultaneously was beyond Thorin, but no one else seemed to struggle with it. Thorin was likely just too overwhelmed to cope with what was a perfectly normal arrangement. 

 

He watched, trying not to glare too obviously, as Yuna danced her way slowly across the room, moving from partner to partner until she stood opposite Baldor as though it were the most innocent coincidence in the world. 

 

Baldor’s hair really was the same dark honey color. Thorin wondered if this was why it set his nerves alight to imagine Baldor as the architect of his current predicament. The situation was bad enough without reenacting the feelings he’d had on the ramparts. He understood, of course, why Bilbo had done it and he could not fault him, but Thorin’s body still remembered the pain of what he’d believed to be a betrayal. 

 

Thorin wanted to bury his head in his hands. After tonight, he would take a step back, he thought to himself. He was not fit to sit on the throne, if he was so affected by the mere suggestion that someone resembling Bilbo might have betrayed him. Seven Fathers, Thorin didn’t even know if the boy was guilty. 

 

The evidence certainly suggested it as a possibility, but what if they were wrong? What if Baldor was exactly what he seemed: unaccustomed to courtly life, somewhat dazzled by the spectacle, unaware of proper dress, shy about his origins but well-meaning in his inquiries, and too young to even braid his beard? If that turned out to be the case, Thorin would be miserable with himself for jumping to such harsh conclusions. They had no real proof of Baldor’s guilt at the moment. Perhaps it was unfair to suspect him on circumstantial evidence.

 

It wouldn’t be the first time Thorin had turned on someone without sufficient reason. 

 

The seed of doubt burrowed under his skin, bringing up every instance of Thorin’s judgment proving too hasty. If he was wrong about this… When Thorin could stand it no longer, he shed his outer robe and crown, despite Yuna’s instructions, and sank into the crowd below. 

 

He found Baldor perched on one of the couches below the arcade of columns. The young dwarf was still watching the dancefloor in some sort of reverie, just as he’d been the night before. Thorin wondered what about the scene kept Baldor in such rapt attention. His expression didn’t look particularly scheming or even especially nervous. He looked… melancholy. Thorin wondered if his sharp words had contributed to that.

 

The fiddle had finally subsided, giving way to raucous laughter, the knocking of tankards, the stomp of feet on wooden boards- but, no, the floors were solid stone. He must be mistaken.

 

When Baldor finally caught sight of Thorin he just blinked, as though not truly believing that Thorin was before him. By the time he seemed to realize that it was Thorin in the flesh, he was too close to execute a proper bow. Baldor tried valiantly nonetheless to scramble to attention, but Thorin waved his hands. 

 

“Peace, son of Gildor.” He said. He sounded exhausted even to himself. After a moment’s hesitation, Thorin sank onto the couch beside Baldor, though there was an appropriate space between them. 

 

Baldor opened and closed his mouth several times, obviously searching for words, but it was Thorin who spoke first. “Please forgive my words earlier this evening. You are right. Much weighs on my mind of late.”

 

“No, no, you were right,” Baldor said quickly, “I was far too bold. Forgive my presumption.”

 

They fell back into silence that was not quite companionable. Thorin burned with too many questions to be at ease. He wanted to demand answers, but he didn’t know if he would believe anything Baldor told him. Why bother to conceal your name? He wanted to ask, Why bother to hide who your kin are or where you are from? If you are all that you seem, what was the point? If you are something else, why is it so hard to mistrust you? 

 

“Although,” Baldor said, slowly this time, “If the weight of your troubles becomes too heavy, I am at your service. Hearing it would be no burden to me.”

 

Thorin wanted to take him up on the offer. He wanted to spill the fear that had grown roots in his heart just to keep the sorrow at bay. He wanted Baldor to have a reasonable explanation for everything and he wanted to accept it and be soothed by the knowledge. Instead, Thorin heaved a heavy sigh. 

 

“You are a generous fellow, Lord Baldor,” Thorin said. “What do you plan to do after Mahalmerag? Shall you remain in Erebor?”

 

“No, your majesty. I leave at dawn.”

 

Thorin hesitated for only a moment. He already had regrets of banishing one he should have held close. Why not counter it with an ill advised invitation when he ought to hold someone at arm’s length?

 

“Erebor’s gates are open to you, should you wish to return.”

Notes:

Binimnâl - literally “without name”, here used to mean “Nameless One”

Chapter 5: An Unexpected Discovery

Summary:

(except for y'all. Y'all have probably been expecting it for a while)

Chapter Text

 

As though sensing that Thorin might be growing too accustomed to his dreams of the ramparts, Thorin’s mind conjured fresh terrors for him to face that night. He did not even feature in this dream, only able to observe, unheard and unseen. 

 

It was the battlefield, though not as Thorin had ever dreamt of it before. His nightmares of the battle were plentiful and varied: Azog rising again after Thorin failed to kill him a second time, the thousand terrible fates that could have befallen his sistersons, occasionally blurring time so that he fought beside Frerin as they had at Azanulbizar or watched Smaug torching his path of destruction at the same time. Those dreams were filled with screams and clashing steel, frantic movement, losing sight of his allies in the crush…

 

This was different. This was utterly silent. The ground was churned to mud from the blood that had been spilt, though there was hardly a patch of bare earth to be found, the bodies lay so thickly upon the ground. In some distant part of his mind, Thorin knew that his dream was recycling what he recalled of Azanulbizar. He’d never seen the destruction after this battle, the Battle of the Five Armies, as they were calling it. He’d been too wounded, barely conscious (let alone sane ) until the worst of the mess had been cleared away. 

 

His mind’s eye presented him with the sight of a scavenger, a faceless Man, slowly picking over the battlefield. Thorin watched him ransack corpses with grim efficiency, plucking arrowheads from dead flesh, decorative buckles from the armor of Elves and Dwarrow alike, anything that was light enough to stuff his pockets with. 

 

He knew before he saw that his dream would force him to look on Bilbo once again. This too was different. Thorin had seen the body of his beloved broken on the rocks before, or else smothered by his own hands, but he’d never seen him bloodied . There was so much of it that Thorin could not tell where the fatal blow had been struck and Thorin let out a silent moan of horror and grief. Bilbo looked like a ragdoll dropped in the mud by a careless child, forgotten.  

 

But not forgotten by the scavenger. 

 

Get away! Thorin tried to scream. Don’t touch him! But it was useless. Thorin was nothing more than a ghost in this dream. His hands passed through the scavenger when he tried to pull him off Bilbo by force, but it made no difference. 

 

The scavenger let out a surprised chortle when he found the ring, the seal of Durin, dangling from a chain around Bilbo’s neck. He snapped the chain easily and held the heavy ring up to examine his find. When he turned his face toward the light, Thorin recognized Baldor. He cursed and shouted and clawed uselessly at Baldor.

 

Finally, Baldor turned to Thorin, as though seeing him for the first time. He reached toward Thorin and clapped a heavy hand on his shoulder.

 

“ Thorin!”

 

Thorin’s fist was already flying by the time he opened his eyes and it was only quick reflexes that saved the intruder from a black eye. Thorin’s chest heaved and he blinked hard to clear the dream. 

 

He was sitting up in his own bed, the one in Erebor that was too big and too soft. His throat ached and the scars across his chest throbbed. Dwalin stood beside the bed, one large hand around Thorin’s fist where he’d caught it in the knick of time. 

 

Dwalin. Thorin’s heart leapt in his throat and he fell back against his thousand pillows and pressed the heels of his palms over his eyes. He wondered if Dís had finally made good on her threat to summon the sons of Fundin or if his traitorous guards had been the ones to summon him. The guilt of it welled in Thorin’s throat so suddenly that he felt as though he might choke on it. 

 

“Apologies,” he said gruffly, still breathing harder than he’d like. Dwalin just grunted and slowly released Thorin’s fist. 

 

Thorin pulled his hands away from his face to look Dwalin over. At first glance, he appeared battle-ready as ever, but Thorin knew him too well for that. His hair was frazzled from sleep and Thorin could see the collar of his nightshirt askew beneath his pauldrons. 

 

“I woke you.” Thorin swallowed. “I apologize. They needn’t have summoned you.”

 

Dwalin gave another incredulous grunt, his disbelief transcending the need for words. Eloquent , Thorin thought with equal parts fondness and bitterness. He didn’t seem to have trouble finding words when he told me off before the Battle. Not that they’d spoken of the incident since. 

 

“I’m certain you’ve better things to do than coddling me. Sleeping for one.” Thorin continued. His heart still pounded against his chest, the self-loathing wrapping its claws around him as it so often did. “It’s a wonder that you came at all, considering.”

 

“It’s a wonder that your memory is so bad, y’daft ninny, ” Dwalin barked, startling Thorin out of his downward spiral. 

 

“My- memory?” Thorin echoed in utter bewilderment. Was there something else he’d done to Dwalin that he had no memory of? Something he’d done in the throes of madness that was even worse than threatening Dwalin’s life?  

 

“Aye.” Dwalin grunted. “Typical Durin. So busy being majestically tormented that you forget to use what little you were gifted between the ears.”

 

“I’m sure I don’t know what you mean,” Thorin said stiffly, only this time he truly did not.

 

“You fool,”  Dwalin huffed, punctuating the words with a sharp prod of a finger to Thorin’s forehead. “You’re not mad. You’re Battle Fatigued.”

 

“I am not-“ Thorin began to protest only for Dwalin to flick him sharply and talk right over him.

 

“Yes, you are. Even if I didn’t have a touch of it m’self, I’d know it. I’ve seen you with it before, you old coot.”

 

“What?”

 

“ Memory, ” Dwalin growled again. “Have you completely forgotten how it was after Azanulbizar?”

 

Thorin fell silent as he tried to process Dwalin’s words. The truth was that Thorin’s recollection of the direct aftermath of that battle was fragmented. Kingship had been thrust on him so suddenly and there had been a thousand things that needed his attention that instant. Including offering what meager comfort he could to the sons of Fundin for the fall of their father.

 

“Y’woke up screaming for a year afterward,” Dwalin told him. “Unless you had Dís with you. I know of what I speak, Thorin.”

 

At Dwalin’s words, Thorin finally caught a fragment of forgotten memory. He had dreamt of the battle afterward. He had not been able to keep from fixating on what he might have done differently. He’d defeated Azog that day, but it wasn’t enough. He should have been able to stop Azog from killing Thror. He should have kept track of his father. He should have been by Frerin’s side. If he’d been a better grandson, son, brother- perhaps one of them might still be with them.

 

“That was-“ Thorin began but Dwalin spoke over him again.

 

“If you say ‘different,’ I’m going to crack your skull,” Dwalin warned. He caught and held Thorin’s gaze for a long moment before he deflated slowly.

 

“Do you think you are the only dwarf I’ve seen it in? Do you think it did not affect Balin and I after that?” Dwalin asked. “It is known. You needn’t have an ax in your skull for Battle Fatigue to set in.”

 

Thorin couldn’t think of a single thing to say in response. Dwalin knew him too well; his next retort was going to be that others, like Bifur, had it far worse. Thwarted, Thorin could only gape like a fish.

 

“Durin’s beard, you did the same damned thing with your father, did you know that? Not letting him be listed among the honored dead, sending out the ravens… I’m not saying you’re wrong to grieve like that, but don’t tell me it’s some “new madness.” I can tell ore from slag.”

 

Dwalin finished his rant with a scowl that made his mustache twitch. Thorin wished desperately that Dwalin wasn’t right, but of course he was. Thorin knew that he spoke the truth, it was only that Thorin had never thought to make the connection before. 

 

“Thank you,” he said softly. Dwalin shrugged his shoulders, suddenly awkward in the face of Thorin’s sincerity.

 

“It’s what I’m here for,” he grunted. “Now, tell me what had you screaming your head off.”

 

Thorin opened his mouth, ready to refuse, but Dwalin cracked his knuckles. Thorin relented. “The ring. I cannot help but wonder how it was separated from Bilbo.”

 

Dwalin made another wordless noise, thinking it over. Thorin appreciated that he didn’t jump straight into empty platitudes. He’d missed his friend terribly in the time he’d been avoiding him.

 

“Whatever the case, I don’t think you’ll have to wait another fifty years to find out,” Dwalin said after some thought. “Nori’s too sneaky for his own good and Yuna seems sharp as an axe. Even if you’re too thick-headed to figure it out, those two will dig up some answers.”

 

It wasn’t much comfort given the circumstances and Thorin couldn’t think of how to respond. Then Dwalin smirked, slow and sharp.

 

“And when we find the culprit, I’d be honored to hold him down while you find out exactly what you need to know.” 

 

Thorin let out a sharp breath that might have been a laugh if it weren’t so relieved. “I thought you’d be telling me to reign in my temper.”

 

“ Me? ” Dwalin scoffed derisively, but even this slipped away quickly, leaving only the sad sort of smirk in its wake. “He mightn’t have been any of our Ones, Thorin, but he was our friend. We would see justice. And if not justice, I’ll settle for vengeance.”

 


 

The following day, Thorin’s silver bead - the same he’d given Bilbo in Laketown - appeared stuffed inside a sticky bun.

 

Thorin did not bother raiding the kitchens this time. For once, as he stormed from the dining room, his kin followed without trying to sway him from his current path. If he’d had the space to think about it, Thorin might have felt vindicated to have them on his side. As it stood, Thorin’s nerves were howling too loudly to think anything beyond screaming with equal parts fury and dread. 

 

“Someone get me Nori, now!” He roared. His hand was sticky where it clutched the bead, though he hardly noticed. “Dwalin, muster the guard! Balin, close the gates, no one leaves this damned mountain!”

 

“I’ll alert the Blacklocks,” Fíli said, dragging his brother with him. It was quick thinking that Thorin ought to have praised.

 

His kin scattered to obey his commands and Thorin himself stormed back to his chambers. He’d grown complacent the past two years. He’d fallen out of the habit of carrying his sword. He needed Deathless in his hand for whatever came next. 

 

In his rooms, Thorin cast aside most of his layers, dropping his crown atop the crumpled pile. He would be ready to give chase if the occasion arose. Whatever sick game someone played, it would end today, he swore it. 

 

With his sword at his hip, Thorin stormed to the council room. Dís met him there though, wisely, she did not attempt to speak to him. Thorin paced, the bead still clenched in his fist. 

 

He could find excuses for the ring, but the bead… His dream of scavengers pulling the treasures from Bilbo’s lifeless body flashed before his eyes. Was that how it had happened? No, Thorin couldn’t believe it. The bead was so small and Bilbo’s hair hadn’t been long enough to braid. If he had the bead with him during or after the battle, then it would have been stored in a pocket or pouch. Somewhere too concealed for a scavenger to pick off coincidentally. 

 

But then how? A dozen scenarios flashed through Thorin’s mind. Bilbo had never made it home. If he’d survived the battle, he would have tried to return to the west, wouldn’t he? What if he approached a dwarf for help, trying to use the ring as collateral, and it turned out to have been one of Thorin’s enemies? Someone who lulled Bilbo into revealing the bead, revealing that he was even more precious to Thorin than the ring already implied? Or perhaps he’d been detained in Mirkwood. Thorin had barely spoken to Thranduil since the battle. He did not know if the Elven King knew that Bilbo was responsible for their escape or how petty he might be in taking his revenge for the embarrassment. The few surviving orcs from the battle surely weren’t clever enough to piece together Bilbo’s importance from such paltry evidence if he had somehow fallen into their hands, right? And this approach was far too subtle for orcs - they’d be more likely to send Thorin the ring with a severed finger still in it, not slip it into his tea. 

 

What if whoever took the relics still had Bilbo? What if he lived ? Thorin could hardly stand to even contemplate the idea. The hope was too painful to bear. 

 

The door to the council room opened but it was not Nori. It was one of Yuna’s handmaidens. Thorin couldn’t remember her name. All of Yuna’s maidens dressed identically. 

 

“ What? ” Thorin snapped, not bothering to soften his tone. The handmaiden didn’t startle. She just bowed low to Thorin.

 

“Your majesty, my lady sends an urgent message.” She said without raising her head. 

 

“Later.” Thorin barked. 

 

“It is with regards to her investigation, my lord,” the handmaiden insisted. Dís beckoned her into the room and bade her to speak before Thorin could cut her off again. The handmaiden straightened and addressed her words to Dís, though Thorin could hear her quite plainly. 

 

“She discovered that the suspect is employed in the kitchens. She has made an arrest. She has detained the suspect in her quarters and awaits your reply.”

 

Thorin’s stomach flipped. All the evidence against Baldor that they’d already gathered and now the identity he’d been so keen to keep secret was revealed as having connections to the kitchens? After Thorin had been finding relics of his lost One in his food? There was no coincidence there. 

 

“Stay here,” Thorin told Dís when she stepped forward. “Inform the others where I’ve gone when they arrive.”

 


 

Thorin knew roughly where the Orocarni delegation was being housed and the handmaiden led him to Yuna’s suites without another word passing between them, which was just as well. 

 

Thorin’s rage was like a blade lodged in his chest (and he should know, having been stabbed there before). He wasn’t sure who he was more angry with: himself or Baldor. To think that he’d been trying to absolve Baldor of suspicion just last night. Baldor had very nearly gotten away with whatever scheme he was a part of and it would have been Thorin’s fault if he’d succeeded. 

 

Thorin’s mind buzzed, trying to comprehend why Baldor would do such a thing. He was still young. Even if fortune had dealt him a poor hand, he had decades to improve his lot in life. Thorin could have helped him, if he’d only asked. Somehow, Thorin doubted that gold was Baldor’s aim. Surely he would have put greater care into his appearance if he cared so much about riches. Revenge then? For whoever Baldor had shorn his hair for? Or plain old power? But how could he possibly gain power from terrorizing Thorin over mealtimes?

 

Yuna greeted him with only a curt nod when they arrived. 

 

“Where is he?” Thorin growled. Yuna led him to a chamber with four guards posted by the door. They stepped aside when Yuna made a small gesture and she pulled a key from the folds of her skirts. She fitted it to the lock, pushed open the door. And gasped. Thorin had never heard anything like it from her and he moved past her into the room without waiting. 

 

The room was empty. It was furnished simply in the Orocarni’s preferred style. The furniture was built low to the ground with no space to conceal a dwarf beneath. Neither was there any sort of wardrobe or chest for anyone to hide in. 

 

“My king-” Yuna said, still sounding a little breathless. “I swear to you, I had him in custody. I do not understand. The guards have not left their posts and I hold the only key to that room. There are no other doors or windows.”

 

“Spread out,” Thorin barked at the guards, though they were not his to command. “Find him. I want him alive. ”

 

The guards glanced at Yuna for approval before rushing to obey. 

 

“Thorin,” Yuna said, her composure shaken even as she tried to pull it back into place. “I am sorry. He truly was here. And I would never aid his escape, I swear it.”

 

“I know,” He said shortly. He did not doubt her loyalty, but he could not spare time to assure her of as much. They had a rat to catch. 

 


 

Dwalin joined him wordlessly in the street and soon the neighborhood was flooded with guards. Thorin ran among them. Even knowing that his presence did little to aid the search, Thorin could not have sat idly by. 

 

Time seemed to shrink and stretch, each breath lasting a lifetime even as Thorin blinked, finding himself running down a different corridor each time he reopened his eyes. He did not know how long he chased after the imposter before a shout of triumph sounded nearby and Thorin turned to storm in the direction of the sound.

 

“Baldor '' would rue the day he stepped foot in Thorin’s mountain. He would know the consequences of betraying Thorin’s trust but, most of all, he would learn what happened to those who threatened his luzun lansel. 

 

"Where is he?" he roared, barely recognizing his own voice. "I want to watch his face when I pluck his fingers off like berries off a bush! I want his beard mounted above my throne!"

 

He pushed through the crowd of soldiers when they did not part quickly enough, Deathless still unsheathed in one hand. Baldor hung between the two guards that held him. He was stripped to his shirt sleeves and positively covered in ash and soot. There were shiny pink burns scattered across his hands and face. Well, it explained how Baldor had escaped Yuna’s quarters. 

 

Baldor did not even look up at him and somehow that only fueled Thorin’s rage. How dare he play at being so pathetic after he’d proved himself capable of such treachery? If he thought to gain Thorin’s sympathy with the act, then he was sorely mistaken.

 

"You!" Thorin growled, watching the prisoner flinch. Good. Let him fear. "You will tell me how you came by this. If you lie to me again, I shall have you disemboweled while you live and make you watch as I feed your entrails to the ravens."

 

Thorin thrust forward the silver bead, shoving it so close to Baldor’s face that he could feel Baldor’s panting breaths against his fingertips. Even now, Thorin could not bring himself to look directly into Baldor’s face. If he looked and was reminded once more of Bilbo, he would lose his resolve. He couldn’t bear the thought of shouting threats such as these at Bilbo again, not even someone who resembled him. 

 

And yet Baldor remained silent, defeated in the guards’ hold. 

 

"Speak!" Thorin demanded, his patience snapping. Finally, Baldor opened his mouth.

 

To his shock and mounting fury, the prisoner began to laugh. The sound pierced Thorin like a blade, familiar yet impossible. He felt his face flush hot with rage and confusion.

 

"You think this funny? I shall rip your beard from your chin!"  Thorin cried.

 

"You might not have to," someone said, “Look.”

 

Thorin finally let his eyes settle on Baldor’s face. Something strange was happening to the manic dwarf. His face was- melting? No, that was absurd, it was only his beard. Thorin’s vision tunneled until all he could see was Baldor’s hysterical face as his beard began to fall away from his chin. Thorin’s heart stopped. Deathless dropped to the ground with a clang.

 

"I... I know your face." The words escaped him in a whisper. 

 

"You had better, you daft dwarf."

 

Thorin’s hand shook as he lifted his hands to Baldor’s- to Bilbo’s face, gently peeling away the false beard that still clung to his jaw. Baldor did not merely resemble Bilbo. Thorin could not have looked away if he tried. He feared to blink, lest the illusion shatter. Thorin's fingers hovered over Bilbo's cheek, craving the warmth of his skin to believe this wasn't another cruel dream, yet terrified to wake if it was. 

 

"You are here. In Erebor." He breathed.

 

"As though I'd be anywhere else," Bilbo said simply, and Thorin's heart clenched.

 

"Your kin thought you dead when we wrote them," Thorin managed, his voice cracking. He watched in bewilderment as Bilbo chuckled again.

 

"You wrote to the Shire after me?" Thorin could only nod, still staring at Bilbo as if he might vanish at any moment. Bilbo’s only response was to shake his head, his shoulders still shaking with mirth. With his beloved in front of him, Thorin thought he should feel joy or at least relief, but somehow he felt as though his heart was breaking anew.

 

"You've been here this whole time," Thorin’s voice cracked on the words like brittle shale. Years of screaming himself awake at night, of tears and terror and regret and helplessness, all seemed to bear down on him at once. Bilbo seemed well. Had he been laughing this entire time? Seeing how Thorin needlessly tormented himself?  "How could you do that to me, lansel ? For two and a half years, I thought- I thought-?"

 

"Did you think me dead?" Bilbo asked softly. 

 

"I did not know what to think," Thorin replied, pulling away sharply. "We could find no trace of you after the battle, and your kin told us you had perished. There was nothing. No evidence that you had fled the battle or stayed. No..."

 

He trailed off, unable to voice the horrors his imagination had conjured in Bilbo's absence. Thorin took another step back.

 

"Never mind," he said at last. He wished suddenly that he had worn his crown. Its weight was a burden, but a grounding one. It made it easier to discard Thorin Oakenshield in favor of becoming King Thorin. "It doesn't matter now. Guards, see to it that he is given a suite in our wing and that our people know that he is to be cared for appropriately."

Chapter 6: An Overdue Conversation

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

Thorin wanted nothing more than to fly to Bilbo’s side, but the Kingdom and his duties to it had no respect for business hours and had never acknowledged such trivial things as ‘lunch breaks’ or ‘sick days’ or ‘loved ones mysteriously returning from beyond the grave.’ 

 

For several hours after the discovery, Thorin was trapped in meetings. It felt as though everyone under the mountain and all their kin suddenly had very urgent business to discuss with him. In truth, it was only the delegates from Orocarni, Thorin’s most trusted ministers (including Balin and Dís), Yuna, and Thorin himself. Thorin had rarely been more grateful to Yuna. Their goals aligned perfectly, but Thorin was so overwhelmed by recent events that he could hardly find the words to champion their cause. 

 

Blessed Yuna swiftly outlined all the reasons why a marriage was no longer an option and followed up just as quickly with all the reasons  why a more general alliance should still be perfectly achievable. Really, in Thorin’s opinion, he hardly saw why he even needed to attend the meeting, he contributed so little of value. He envied Yuna immensely for her ability to excuse herself after the first two hours, citing an urgent need to write up the latest developments for her father. And her Suzu, no doubt , Thorin thought wryly. 

 

They only broke once it became clear that negotiations would not be concluded in a single day. It was just as well. Tempers were fraying, especially once the Orocarni delegates started to point out that Thorin had two eligible nephews, even if he himself was unavailable. They parted with promises to resume discussion the following day and Thorin dragged himself back to the wing where he and his kin resided - the wing where Bilbo should have been brought. 

 

Thorin felt as though he’d aged a decade since that morning when he knocked at the door and cracked it open without waiting for a response. 

 

Bilbo sat inside, polishing off the last of an afternoon tea set and looking much better than he had earlier. His face was smooth once more, free of false beard and sap, and his feet were free of the heavy dwarven boots he’d worn before. He’d been scrubbed of all the ash and soot and, if not for the decidedly dwarven tunic and long trousers he wore, he looked very nearly like a proper hobbit again.

 

“May I come in?” Thorin asked wearily, leaning against the door.

 

“That depends. Are you here to shout at me again?” Bilbo lifted his chin to look at Thorin down his nose. The snide tone caught Thorin off guard, trapped between wincing and laughing. He’d forgotten how petty his hobbit could be. 

 

“No,” Thorin said flatly. Then, under his breath, “Though I hardly think I was overreacting.”

 

Bilbo made a disgruntled sound but didn’t deny it. Instead he sighed and waved a hand at Thorin. “Go on then, your majesty , take a seat. They’re your couches anyway.”

 

Thorin did as he was bid. His body ached. The exhaustion of the day was finally catching up to him and he felt as though his boots had been lined with lead. He watched Bilbo in silence, drinking in the sight of him. He looked well. His hair had grown out since they’d last met. It suited him, Thorin thought. It was nearly long enough to braid. He looked a little odd in dwarvish clothing, admittedly. He’d grown so used to the sight of Bilbo in his short trousers that he seemed excessively bundled up with his dwarvish trousers falling past his ankles. 

 

Bilbo did not speak. He seemed to expect something from Thorin, but Thorin’s head was still buzzing from negotiations and his thoughts moved slowly. 

 

“So. You’ve been here, hiding in my kitchens,” He said with a heavy sigh. “How long have you been here?”

 

“For nearly all of it, since the battle,” Bilbo admitted. He didn’t quite meet Thorin’s eye. Thorin’s heart ached. He knew that he should feel nothing but awe and delight at Bilbo’s reappearance. He should be falling to his knees, thanking Mahal and every other force that had sheltered Bilbo since last they spoke. But it hurt to know that Bilbo’s concealment had been deliberate.

 

“Will you tell me what happened?” Thorin asked. “I have done little but ponder your fate since we parted.”

 

Thorin would have begged if Bilbo asked it of him. The question had tortured him for two years. He would have promised almost anything in that moment to get the answers he so desperately craved. Bilbo blinked and gave a huff that sent his hair fluttering out of his eyes. 

 

“Goodness, Thorin, where to begin?”

 

“The battle.” Thorin said. “I saw you at the wizard’s side but after that…”

 

“Ah, yes. Well, I can’t say I performed any exceptional feats. Truth be told, I was unconscious for most of it. One good knock on the head and next thing I know it’s all over!”

 

“You were there? In the battle?” Thorin’s heart dropped.

 

“I couldn’t have very well gotten away that quickly, now could I?” Bilbo wrinkled his nose. He still wasn’t meeting Thorin’s gaze. “And, like I said, it hardly feels right to say I did anything.”

 

“You could have been killed.” Bilbo was no coward, but he was so small . All the clever tricks in the world couldn’t change the fact that Bilbo had been more or less an untrained civilian surrounded by battle-fueled warriors who were all at least twice his size. In their bloodlust, one of the big folk might not have even noticed if they’d crushed Bilbo on their way to pummel their next enemy.

 

“Oh, like you’ve got any room to talk.” Bilbo grumbled. He chanced a quick glance up at Thorin from under his fringe but looked away just as quickly. His next words were mumbled.  “I can’t be certain, but, for what it’s worth… I believe your mithril might have been part of why I came out of it alright. I had my little ring, of course, so it wasn’t as though anyone saw me, but. Well, I wasn’t in much position to dodge if there had been anything.”

 

Thorin had never before been grateful for something he did in his madness. He hadn’t been sure that Bilbo had kept the mithril shirt, what with his sudden departure. They hadn’t found it anywhere, but it could still have been buried in the treasure for all Thorin knew. Thorin drew a deep breath, trying to calm his racing heart. The battle was behind them. Bilbo sat across from him now, years away from the bloody fates Thorin had feared.

 

“And then? Afterward?” Thorin asked, swallowing hard, “We looked for you amongst the fallen.”

 

“But, of course, I hadn’t fallen.”Bilbo sighed. “Well, I started out with Gandalf in the Elvish camp - oh, don’t make that face at me, they hardly even noticed me there. I’d thought of slipping away home, but then I heard about Fíli and Kíli’s conditions… and about yours.I thought to myself, “if I leave and they die and I’m not there and I never get the chance to say goodbye…”  I didn’t think you’d want to see me again, of course, but I’d still have liked to pay my respects if I had the chance.” 

 

“Only I didn’t perish.” Thorin said flatly. He had not died, though not for lack of trying, if his healers’ complaints were to be believed.

 

“No, you didn’t.” Bilbo agreed.  “And by then Gandalf had found out about my little ring. He was quite suspicious of it, seemed to think it might have some sort of curse. He asked me for it so that he might look into it. I was loath to part with it. It’s so handy, you know? But he thought there might be some harm in it, so I gave it to him in the end. He vanished after that and I wasn’t about to start the journey home alone, especially once winter set in. So then I thought, I’ll just wait until the spring. Just until the snow melts and I can be sure that everyone is well . I was in Dale that winter with Bard-“

 

“That wretch! “ Thorin snarled his first interruption. “He did know something! I asked him about you!”

 

“Don’t blame him ! I told him not to let anyone know that I was still about. I was banished , remember?” Bilbo said, so pointedly that Thorin couldn’t do much but shrink in his seat like a chastised dwarfling. “Right, so I was in Dale, trying to keep an eye on you lot, only it turns out that it’s awfully difficult to keep track of folk in the mountain when you’re not allowed inside. I thought of a dozen ways to try to ask after all of you, but it kept coming back to my appearance.”

 

“Your appearance? ” Thorin echoed.

 

“Well, how many other shire-folk have you seen around these parts? Everyone here insists on shoes. The Big Folk might have mistaken me for a dwarfling, but you dwarrow would think it odd that someone my age doesn’t have a beard. And if they caught sight of the ears… all of that is to say, If I asked someone for information and they happened to relay what I looked like, I thought I’d be too recognizable.”

 

“So you made your disguise.”

 

“Indeed. It took some trial and error. I’m afraid Bard’s ponies suffered the brunt of my experimentation. Their tails have fully grown out now, though, I’m sure.” Bilbo gave a wry smirk. “Bard helped me find a cobbler to make shoes the right size - everyone here has such dainty feet! Even the Men! I told him it was for the journey home through the mountains. And then the spring came, and there were troops of dwarves coming from the West, so I just sort of… slipped in. There were so many new people arriving, no one looked too hard at me.” 

 

Thorin made a mental note to bring this to Dwalin’s attention. Bilbo was one thing, but no one else should be able to enter unnoticed so easily. Bilbo continued his tale.

 

“They gave me a place to stay without any issue. It was finding work that posed a problem. I’ve no craft, you see, not like the rest of you. “Landlord” isn’t really a profession, now is it? I’ve certainly dabbled in a number of things, but not enough to pass as someone with real artistry. And it couldn’t be something where one of the Company might have seen me. My first thought was the mines, because they are so extensive, but I’ve no stone sense. Real miners would’ve sniffed me out right away. I’d try gardening, but you don’t have much in the way of horticulture. So I ended up in the kitchens, trying to avoid Bombur.”

 

“The soup.” Thorin took a sharp breath and let it out through his nose, shaking his head. “I should have known.” 

 

“The soup was recent.” Bilbo admitted, “Mostly, I’ve been washing dishes and keeping an ear out. I know I ought to have gone a long time ago, once it was clear you were back in your right mind, once I was sure everyone was safe, but every time I started gathering myself to go… And then suddenly it had been two years. I’m not sure how long I would’ve stayed down there if all this hadn’t happened.”

 

“Why did “all of this” happen?” Thorin couldn’t stop himself from asking, “What changed?”

 

“Well, I mean… I heard about– That is…” Bilbo fidgeted . “You got engaged.”

 

Thorin blinked at him. His heart did a funny sort of stutter in his chest, as though he’d tripped over a tree root and only just caught himself.

 

“I did.” He said slowly, trying to curtail any hope before it could run wild. Bilbo, however, still wouldn’t meet his gaze. He sank lower in his chair.

 

“I didn’t mean to ruin it for you,” Bilbo muttered. He looked so petulant that Thorin couldn’t help but smirk.

 

“Yes, you did.”

 

“Alright, it might’ve been floating around in my subconscious, but I wasn’t trying to- to win you back or anything.” Bilbo said quickly, sitting up once more. The hope that Thorin was trying so viciously to contain whined at the words.

 

“You weren’t?”

 

“No, I… I don’t know what I was doing.” Bilbo ran a hand through his hair. His face was flushed, Thorin realized. “I suppose it seemed wrong to return to the Shire with the treasures you’d given me. Despite evidence to the contrary, I’m not usually a thief, you know. And those things were given to someone that you… well, I didn’t think they were really meant for me anymore.”

 

“They will always be yours.” Thorin said firmly.

 

“Well.” Bilbo averted his gaze, clearing his throat. “Well, what about you? I know a little, but what have you been doing all this time?”

 

Thorin fell quiet. What was there to say that Bilbo didn’t already know? Thorin had been wounded in the battle and, after recovering just enough of his body and mind to stand, he’d gotten to work trying to piece the kingdom back together. What else could he say? Thorin would not tell him about the turmoil, the doubt, the guilt that plagued him. The nightmares. Those were Thorin’s to carry. When he didn’t answer, Bilbo tried another approach.

 

“How about this, then: are you cured of your dragon sickness?”

 

“Not entirely.” Thorin said quietly.  “I’m not sure it is the sort of thing that is ever… cured . Only managed.”

 

“But it is managed for the moment, yes?” Bilbo prodded.

 

“Yes. And I’ve got many eyes to watch me, to inform me if that ever changes.”

 

“How did you break it’s hold?”

 

“I don’t know,” Thorin admitted. “Balin once told me he hoped that my injuries, or Fíli and Kíli’s might be enough. Or your… disappearance. I’m sorry to say that none of them were. It was like recovering from a cold. First you’re sniveling in bed and then one day you realize you can breathe freely again.” 

 

Bilbo made a curious humming sound, but it was all Thorin could bring himself to say on the subject. Any more than that and he might start to reveal the cracks in his kingly facade, his jagged edges. He did not want his broken parts to hurt anyone, least of all Bilbo. 

 

“And… Yuna?” Bilbo asked when he realized that Thorin would say no more on the matter.

 

“What about her?” 

 

“You are betrothed to her!” Bilbo flung out a hand. 

 

“Not anymore,” Thorin told him. He tilted his head curiously. “Why did you think I was in negotiations for so long?”

 

Bilbo snapped his mouth shut, his cheeks going pink. He fidgeted with the edge of his sleeve. “Well, you were betrothed. I thought— That is to say, in Esgaroth– It’s only that I was… surprised. Given what I was led to believe about dwarrow. And their- monogamy.”

 

Bilbo was too cruel, Thorin wanted to complain. It was unfair to say he hadn’t been trying to win Thorin back in one breath, only to follow it up with jealous pouting that Thorin had entertained a union with someone else. The hope in Thorin’s chest stretched against the self-restraint that he’d leashed it with. 

 

“You were not mistaken,” Thorin said simply. “Dwarrow love only once. And that love is lifelong.”

 

“Then why…”

 

“You were gone,” Thorin said, his voice small and tight. “We- I searched. And searched. No one seemed to know your fate. I… There has not been a day I have not craved answers. And now I come to find that you were here all along…”

 

The silence between them was taut as a bowstring. Thorin wrestled with himself. Grateful as he was for Bilbo’s presence, it felt like a slap in the face to learn that he needn’t have tortured himself with guilt and fear and regret. 

 

“Why did you not tell me you lived?” Thorin finally asked. 

 

“I did not know you thought me dead,” Bilbo said. His face twisted then, as though he’d eaten a spoonful of fresh horseradish. “And I had no reason to think that you’d rejoice to learn that I was alive. You might remember threatening to kill me if you ever saw me again, when last we spoke.”

 

“I would have taken back my words at the gate had you given me the chance,” Thorin said, his voice rising with frustration. Just a word. Just a sign . 

 

“And what chance did I have to offer?” Bilbo snapped. He met Thorin’s eyes now and Thorin was taken aback by the fury in them. “You threatened my life , Thorin! You told me that you’d hang my head by the front gates if I ever set foot in Erebor again!”

 

Thorin’s stomach dropped. He was right. Of course, Bilbo was right. Thorin couldn’t blame anyone else for the consequences of his own actions. He could hear Bilbo’s harsh breathing as he collected himself once again. 

 

A thought began to dawn on him slowly and Thorin frowned at his hands, trying to force it to take shape. 

 

“You believed that we would have punished you for what happened before the battle,” He said slowly. 

 

“That and breaking my banishment.” Bilbo’s mouth twisted as though fighting the frown that came to his face. “It’s not as though it was ever formally revoked.”

 

“You believed that your life would be forfeit if you were discovered,” Thorin reiterated. “And yet you still took the risk to live among us? You chose to stay, despite the danger. For two years.”

 

“Well, when you say it like that… ” Bilbo muttered. His cheeks were burning again.

 

Thorin tried to reckon with the information, but couldn’t seem to work through it. Bilbo had, in his own mind at least, placed his very life in danger just by showing his face every day he stayed in the mountain. And for no other reason than to assure himself that his friends were well. In Thorin’s mind, that did not speak of mere friendship. In Khuzdul, Thorin would have called it Bassu Munsel . It implied a deep loyalty, one whom you would follow through darkness, one who allowed you to show weakness and one who inspired you to feats of strength. It was the word Thorin had used for Dwalin, at least until he’d ruined Dwalin’s trust in him. It was the word Balin used when he told the story of how Thorin earned the name ‘Oakenshield,’ though it didn’t sound quite right in Westron. There is one I could follow, there is one I could call king.

 

Thorin’s heart ached. Even when he believed himself banished, unwanted, Bilbo had stayed by their sides. Truly, they did not deserve the love he offered them. Only, that wasn’t quite right. It was Thorin who was the most unworthy. It was too late, though. The hope in Thorin’s heart had snapped its leash and was running rampant. 

 

“And you put a stop to my wedding,” He said aloud. 

 

“I suppose I did, didn’t I?” 

 

Thorin still carried the bead. He hadn’t been able to let it out of reach since it was returned to him and he produced it now, offering it to Bilbo palm up. 

 

“Returning this to me is a sign of rejection among dwarrow.” Thorin said. “Is that what you meant by it?”

 

“Well, I- I don’t really know.” Bilbo stammered

 

Later- years later- Thorin would admit that he had maybe, possibly, perhaps gotten the tiniest bit ahead of himself in his response to this. 

 

“Then, if I offered it to you anew, would you accept?”

 

“ Thorin!” Bilbo cried, and not really with the overflow of joy that Thorin might have hoped for in response to a proposal. Actually, Bilbo sounded more thunderstruck than anything else. Thorin should have taken this as his cue to slow down, but his tongue was much too far ahead of anything else to stop now.

 

“It wouldn’t be as grand an affair as people might expect for a royal wedding but, if you agree, we could be bound in less than a fortnight.” Thorin said in a rush, while Bilbo continued to gape at him. Just beginning to sense that perhaps Bilbo might have some reservations, Thorin plunged on. “I know the people would accept you as consort. You are a member of the original Company and your deeds are well known-“

 

“Heavens, Thorin, consort ?”

 

The words were so loud and shrill that Thorin was finally brought to a halt, blinking at Bilbo in bewilderment. 

 

“Well, I suppose if you object to the title, we could style it as something else. “ Prince ” maybe. Or are there Hobbit titles you’d prefer?” Thorin offered.

 

“The title is not the issue! For heaven’s sake, Thorin, I was raised to manage a couple dozen acres, not an entire bloody kingdom! A kingdom whose people and customs I’m still learning about and– that’s not the point! We haven’t spoken in years! You still haven’t apologized for what you did back then. I don’t even know your real name!”

 

“It is Mabbadûn,” Thorin said faintly, stopping Bilbo mid-rant. Bilbo made a wheezing sound halfway between a sigh and a gasp and practically choked on his own breath as he tried to catch up to the admission. Thorin did not give himself time to feel the shock of speaking his Inner Name aloud, determined to use Bilbo’s momentary silence to his advantage. “And I am. Sorry. I- I know that words are not enough. I do not ask your forgiveness, but I want you to know. I regret… everything.”

 

Bilbo stared at him for a long time before fidgeting with the hem of his sleeve once more. The tips of his ears were bright pink and his voice was quiet when he spoke again. 

 

“ Everything? ” He asked.

 

“Not you. Amrâlimê, ‘ukhjam, ghivashel.” Thorin breathed. “Bilbo, not you. Never you. Only the ways I’ve hurt you.”

 

“Ah,” Was all Bilbo managed. “That’s- good. That’s good then.”

 

“You told me once that hobbits don’t have Ones,” Thorin said slowly. “If your feelings have changed since… back then , I understand. Tell me so, and I shall never speak of it again, if you wish.”

 

“Oh, you lelkhar salsazmîn Mibilkhags!” Bilbo swore. Thorin’s brows shot up. He was too stunned by the profanity to even ask where Bilbo had learned it (nevermind that he shouldn’t know any Khuzdul, let alone such vulgarity). Bilbo glared at him, but the effect was ruined by the pink tinge of his cheeks. “You daft dwarf! Did you think I’d do all this if I didn’t still—”

 

Apparently it was too much to ask Bilbo to voice his feelings aloud so soon and the hobbit snapped his mouth shut over the words. He looked as though he were trying very hard not to squirm. Even so, Thorin felt as though he could hear the unspoken words. He wasn’t sure what his face was doing. Probably something foolish, if the ache in his cheeks was anything to go by. 

 

Bilbo continued to grumble, “It’s just- really, Thorin, asking a fellow to marry you after you’ve only just met again! And it’s not as though I’m rejecting the offer, not really, I just think we ought to go at a more respectable pace. Perhaps we could try strolling down this path rather than barreling forward head first? Not all of us have such hard skulls, you know!”

 

Thorin took Bilbo’s hands in his own and Bilbo stopped abruptly. 

 

“I would be honored, Bilbo, son of Bungo, Baggins of Bag End, to follow where you lead,” Thorin said earnestly. “At whatever pace you set.”

Notes:

continual shout out to DwarrowScholar and their dictionaries

Bassu Munsel - Bond + loyalty of all loyalties, here used to describe a specific sort of intimate friendship, something that combines “BFF” with the sort of “courtly love” a knight and their liege might share. Frodo and Sam would absolutely have their friendship described with this word. Sharing this sort of bond does not exclude the possibility of romantic/sexual love, it would just be an additional word.

Mabbadûn - He who continues to climb (excessively)

lelkhar salsazmîn Mibilkhags - Supreme Idiot lusting (for an) elf (vulgur: literally stiff necks/swans)

Amrâlimê - [my] beloved
‘ukhjam - greatest gift
ghivashel - treasure of all treasures

Chapter 7: A Decent Place to Start

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

That night, long after Thorin and Bilbo had parted for the evening, Dís shook Thorin awake. He startled into awareness with a gasp, his eyes streaming, and his hands shaking. 

 

“You did not answer your door,” Dís said without him having to ask. It was just as well, for Thorin could not find his voice, nor could he stop his tears.

 

Dís set a hand on his back and rubbed soothing circles while Thorin heaved and sobbed as he had not since the first days after the Battle. 

 

“I do not understand,” He choked out, when he recovered his voice. His dreams had not been as nightmarish as they usually were. He was not forced to relive his actions on the ramparts, nor the battle, nor Bilbo’s death. It had only been Bilbo’s slowly retreating back as he walked away from Thorin, disappearing into the distance. 

 

But Bilbo was alive. He was in the suite down the hall at this very moment. There was no need for these dreams to continue and there was certainly no need to bawl over it like a frightened dwarfling.

 

Thorin grimaced at himself. Dís should not have to keep doing this. She’d already been helping him like this for two years. And it was one thing to accept her comfort when it seemed likely that they shared a similar grief in the loss of their Ones and it was another thing entirely to sob over Bilbo when he was alive and well and Vili was still dead and buried half a continent away.

 

“I am sorry,” He said, taking deep shuddering breaths to calm himself. 

 

Dís didn’t say anything for a long time, just kept her hand on his back until his breathing was steady and even. 

 

“Does he know about this?” Dís finally asked. Thorin shook his head. 

 

“No,” He said, “No, it didn’t come up.”

 

If Thorin had anything to say about it, it might never come up. Dís frowned and Thorin could sense her disapproval even without her voicing it aloud. 

 

“Thorin,” She said but Thorin spoke quickly.

 

“It’s just too soon, that is all. It’s only been a single afternoon.”

 

Dís made a sound of disagreement, but she did not press further.

 


 

The following days were strange beyond belief. A great deal happened very quickly, so much so that Thorin hardly remembered how any of it managed to get done. 

 

First, the business with the Blacklocks needed to be attended to. In the end, both parties were desperate for some sort of treaty and neither of them were willing to walk away empty handed. There were complaints, of course, that without the bonds of marriage, contracts could be broken and either side would find it less difficult to break the terms of the agreement. Given how sorely they needed each other, however, Thorin was hard pressed to think of a good reason why they would turn on one another. The business was concluded with a redrawn treaty, this time excluding his and Yuna’s marriage, but reluctantly promising that the eligible children of King Nami’s line would be hosted in Erebor at a future date, just in case one of Thorin’s heirs happened to take a liking to them. 

 

Thorin didn’t have the heart to tell them how unlikely he thought this. Kíli, for one, already had his heart dead set on that dratted guard captain. Or ex-guard captain, as he mulishly reminded anyone who would listen. A few days after an exuberant reunion with Fíli and Kíli, Bilbo had asked after the elf. When Kíli lamented how she was barred from the mountain, Bilbo had sensibly asked why Kíli hadn’t gone to her instead. Naturally, Thorin was quick to release Kíli from his confinement at the slightest hint of Bilbo’s disapproval. Dís shook her head disparagingly and told Kíli to be back before summer solstice…but also warned him that they’d better not see him before the snows all melted either. That should give him plenty of time with his beloved (and plenty of time for Erebor to settle before they introduced another major change).

 

The rest of the Company too clamored to see Bilbo for themselves. Introducing Bilbo to young Gimli properly had been particularly entertaining. One could almost see the moment each new horrifying realization dawned on the poor lad: that his dance partner had not even been a dwarf, that Bilbo was (at least in terms of maturity) nearly as old as Gimli’s own father, and finally that he, Gimli son of Gloín, had attempted to flirt with Thorin Oakensheild’s One. The boy looked like he might faint dead away by the end of it. 

 

It was not all laughing reunions. Most of the Company, calmored to see Bilbo, but a good portion had already known about his presence. Thorin had been distraught to learn that he was not the first to discover Bilbo in the mountain. Bombur had discovered him first, (naturally, since they worked together in such close proximity in the kitchens) though he rushed to assure Thorin that he’d only known since just after Durin’s Day. What Bombur knew, Bifur and Bofur inevitably knew as well. Dori was the final traitor (Thorin should have guessed where Bilbo had gotten such fine clothes for the Mahalmerag balls). 

 

“An entire third of the Company!” Thorin blustered to Dwalin after everyone else had declined to listen to his ranting yet again. “How could they keep such a thing from me?”

 

“Well,” Dwalin lifted a single bushy eyebrow. “You haven’t exactly been in touch, have you?”

 

That shut Thorin right up. The deeds of the entire Company were well known, of course, and none of them were short changed their due portion of honor and respect, but they had broken along class lines after Erebor had been reclaimed. Fíli and Kíli, the sons of Gróin, and the sons of Fundin - these were the members of the Company that Thorin had regular contact with and all could trace their lineage back to the line of Durin within just a few generations. He spoke to Nori on a semi-regular basis, but they only ever talked business, Thorin realized. And though he occasionally saw Ori hard at work in the library, the archives, or the court, Thorin could not remember actually exchanging words with him.

 

“I don’t understand,” Thorin admitted to Gloín after turning the problem over for a day or two. “They were awarded their share. Why do they continue the lives of artisans when they could live like princes beside the rest of us?”

 

Gloín, to his credit, didn’t call Thorin an idiot to his face. He only tentatively suggested that, since there was such extensive work to be done to restore Erebor, that none of the Company had truly taken a full fourteenth’s share. There would be nothing left over for public works and the like if they had. That perhaps some had been more generous than others. That, unlike the scattered descendants of Durin, not every dwarf had resources to fall back upon without the treasure. 

 

Thorin thought he’d known about poverty, Hadn’t he too been left homeless after the dragon? Hadn’t he had to work as a lowly blacksmith in Mannish towns just to feed his family? Then Thorin remembered how Dís had carefully cut the pearls from the beaded hem of an old dress, how he’d pried gemstones from the settings of rings. He remembered the grudging hospitality that the Broadbeams had offered his family in light of their status. He hadn’t thought of how things might have been different if he hadn’t had heirlooms to barter or allies to beg from. 

 

It didn’t change the fact that no one had told him. 

 


 

Thorin would have liked nothing better than to hide away with Bilbo in his quarters to reacquaint themselves. He even would have agreed to leave the mountain for a time if it would have pleased Bilbo to do so. As it stood, however, Thorin was king first and foremost. 

 

The first few days after his return, Bilbo had joined Thorin and his kin (minus Kíli) for breakfast, but he’d quickly stopped. Thorin often took supper with him in private, but there was little time to spend together during the day. When Bilbo stopped coming to breakfast, Thorin couldn’t help but feel disappointed to lose out on some of the little time they spent together. When Thorin asked after it, however, Bilbo grew sheepish. 

 

“I don’t think your family likes me very much,” he admitted.

 

“Have they said anything to you?” 

 

“No, not at all!” Bilbo said quickly. “I suppose that’s what made me think so. They seem… a tad quiet. But I am not familiar with dwarvish customs! And they are your kin, so perhaps it should only be expected that they’re quite good at brooding majestically.”

 

Thorin’s mouth twitched at the good natured tease, but he still worried. He too had noticed Dís and Dáin’s chilly reception of the hobbit. He did not want to say so aloud, lest he drive them further apart by insinuating that they did not like Bilbo, but even Fíli had moments where he simply stared at Bilbo as though he couldn’t quite believe the hobbit was sitting among them so casually.

 

“I just expected them to be a bit more- well, a bit more like when the Company descended on my larder,” Bilbo concluded. “Really, I’m very grateful for their table manners.”

 

“They are just protective,” Thorin said finally, without specifying who they were protective of. 

 

Bilbo nodded like he understood, but somehow Thorin suspected that he did not quite grasp the extent of it. That was fine. He did not need to burden Bilbo with the battles he still fought inside his own head. He was well enough , and that was what mattered.

 


 

Their first argument came just a few weeks after Bilbo’s reappearance, though in truth it had been brewing almost since they reunited. 

 

First it came as Bilbo’s complaints that his former kitchen colleagues would not allow him to resume his duties and kept treating him deferentially. Thorin had been quick to assure Bilbo that he needn’t work in the kitchens any longer, that he was free to enjoy his leisure. When Bilbo confessed that he enjoyed cooking (and eating) recreationally, Thorin was quick to move him into accommodations that had their own pantry and kitchen, though somehow this did not please Bilbo quite as much as Thorin had hoped. 

 

Next, Ori came to him, wringing his hands, asking how he should deal with Bilbo’s attempts to aid Ori in his work. Ori seemed to be of a similar mind to Thorin that it would be appalling to have a hero like Bilbo toiling away among dust-covered tomes, bending his back and sitting for long hours, pouring over paperwork. When Thorin told him as much, Bilbo protested, asking if he really was disturbing Ori’s work. Thinking of how much time the scribe spent worrying about Bilbo’s whereabouts, Thorin said ‘yes.’ 

 

Still later, Balin and Yuna approached Thorin cautiously to ask exactly what information Bilbo could be privy to. He’d apparently taken to trailing first one, and then the other, about, taking notes, listening in on meetings, and so on. He wasn’t underfoot, they assured Thorin, but he was not a dwarf either. They did not know how much Bilbo was permitted to learn about the inner workings of the kingdom. 

 

The answer, naturally, was that there was nothing to which Bilbo should be forbidden, but by Mahal’s glowing forge, why was he taking on such menial tasks?

 

This was the point at which the argument erupted. 

 

“I did not put you through all of– that just to have you toil like a servant in my house!” Thorin cried. 

 

“And I did not put up with all of it just to be put on your mantle like a china doll!” Bilbo shot back. 

 

“You’re no doll but, Durin’s beard, why can’t you just sit quietly for a change?”

 

Bilbo’s laugh was devoid of mirth. “So that I can stop causing trouble, you mean? Because I keep mucking up everyone else’s work, is that it?”

 

“No, you excel at everything you try your hand at, but why must you insist on sticking your hands in so many places? Thorin demanded. 

 

“How else am I supposed to learn it all, Thorin?” Bilbo snapped, “Or am I not allowed to learn it because, despite everything, I am still an outsider and I always will be?”

 

‘That’s not it.”

 

“Then what? I am trying, Thorin! I thought ‘consort’ meant something more than becoming a prized pet in a gilded cage!”

 

Thorin was struck dumb by the outburst, stuck on that word: consort. Bilbo, however, continued his rant.

 

“How can I prepare myself if I’m not permitted to learn how to do the ruddy work? I told you, I know that I am still ignorant of a great many things, but I cannot educate myself cloistered away here! How can I ever be your partner if I am not permitted to do anything? That is what ‘consort’ means, isn’t it? Because if I’m mistaken and it really just means another pretty jewel to be displayed, I want no part in it.”

 

Despite the frustration in Bilbo’s words, Thorin’s heart leapt. They had done little more than converse since they reunited. Thorin had been following at Bilbo’s pace and his proposal had not been mentioned again since that night. He had begun to believe that ‘later’ might be polite Hobbit code for ‘never.’ 

 

“Oh, madmel ,” Thorin nearly moaned the word as the extent of the misunderstanding began to dawn on him. “ Budgel, it is not. I swear to you, it is not merely decoration. Please allow me to explain.”

 

Bilbo narrowed his eyes, but grudgingly dropped onto the couch opposite Thorin. He crossed his arms over his chest, “Well, go on then. Explain.”

 

“We- that is, dwarrow - we value…” Thorin tried to think of how to word it.

 

“Pig-headedness? Secrecy?” Bilbo suggested dryly. “ Gold? ”

 

“ Security ,” Thorin bit back. It was a low blow, even for Bilbo and something about the way he said it rankled Thorin beyond the usual fits of guilt and regret. “The ability to provide for ourselves and our families. And, yes, sometimes that is demonstrably material.”

 

“What’s that got to do with anything?” Bilbo seemed thoroughly unimpressed by his explanation thus far, but Thorin pressed on. 

 

“By the standards of my own people, the way I… approached you during the journey was shameful.”

 

“If you’ll recall, it was me that approached you ,” Bilbo grumbled. Thorin ignored him. 

 

“I did my best with what we had,” Thorin said, trying not to sound too defensive. He ought to have given Bilbo his sword, Deathless, if he was doing things properly, but since Bilbo did not know how to wield it, Thorin had given him his second most precious belonging: his signet ring. “But, it was paltry. Unworthy of you and certainly unworthy of a king .”

 

He had tried to rectify his pathetic suit once they’d reached the mountain. The most precious thing in the mountain, the Arkenstone, was lost and was not truly Thorin’s to give away. The mithril was the next most precious and a far more worthy gift. 

 

“You accepted my gifts then, when I had nothing. It implied a level of faith in me that few have ever entrusted me with. That you accepted spoke of your confidence that, despite the dangers we faced, you were confident in the future we might build together.”

 

“If you think sweet talking will get you out of this…” Bilbo wrinkled his nose and heaved a sigh. “You might be onto something. Go on, then. Keep flattering me.”

 

“I do not say it to flatter, merely to explain why we- why I - have not understood your behavior,” Thorin said. “From the outside, from a dwarrow perspective, your insistence on the need to work…” 

 

“I think I begin to see,” Bilbo said slowly. 

 

“I know that I have lost your trust,” Thorin’s hands clenched on his thighs, “It is only right that I should earn it back slowly. You need not accept anything you do not wish. Only, I suspect that you mean something entirely different when you decline than what I and other dwarrow see.”

 

“Because it looks as though I am unsatisfied with your… ability to provide? Like I have no confidence in the stability of our future.” Bilbo surmised. Thorin nodded. Bilbo let out a long breath, running a hand through his hair. “I see… Well, I suppose that does explain it.”

 

“I do not intend to keep you caged, as you so aptly put it. I only wish to provide you with every comfort. I did not know that you were working toward– that .” Thorin couldn’t quite bring himself to repeat Bilbo’s reason aloud, as though he would jinx Bilbo into changing his mind if he said it. Consort! That Bilbo took the possibility so seriously made Thorin’s heart soar.

 

“Bollocks,” Bilbo let his head fall back. “Confusticate and bebother you dwarves, every time I think I’ve finally got a good grasp on you… How am I meant to learn all I would need to know then?”

 

“No one would think twice about my betrothed doing such work,” Thorin said quickly, nearly pointing out that Yuna had done so before he realized that speaking of his former betrothed to his prospective one might be somewhat tactless. “It is only understood to be so discouraging because you have not accepted my suit.”

 

“But I’ve got your bead,” Bilbo frowned, nearly making Thorin choke on his own breath. Had Bilbo accepted without him even noticing ? 

 

“It is more complicated now that I am enthroned,” Thorin cleared his throat. “And you don’t wear the bead publicly.”

 

“I wasn’t sure I was permitted,” Bilbo admitted. “Goodness, Thorin, this is a right mess, isn’t it?”

 

“I would be honored if you wore my bead,” Thorin told him seriously, “But perhaps it might be better to refrain before you make up your mind for sure.”

 

“Oh, for heaven’s sake, Thorin, I’m not trying to prepare for consortship or what have you just for fun . You and I both know that it’s a foregone conclusion.” 

 

“I did not,” Thorin stammered. “Know, that is. I– it is?”

 

“Oh, Thorin,” Bilbo finally softened, the last of his anger draining away. He stood and closed the scant distance between them. Bilbo cupped Thorin’s face in his hands and Thorin tilted his head back in silent assent. Bilbo’s thumbs ran small circles through the wiry hair of his beard as he looked down into Thorin’s face. 

 

“You really are quite daft,” Bilbo said quietly before he dipped his head to kiss Thorin. Their lips met, tentative after so long apart, and Thorin felt a shiver run through his entire body. He cautiously raised his hand, resting his fingertips lightly on Bilbo’s neck. The skin there was not so vulnerable as it had appeared in Thorin’s nightmares. Bilbo was sturdy beneath his touch and Thorin could feel his pulse hammering against his fingers.

 

Bilbo drew away first. There was a glint of mischief in his eye as he continued to run his hands through Thorin’s beard.

 

“Would it send the wrong message if I failed to return to my quarters tonight?” He asked quietly. 

 

At that moment, Thorin could not have cared less about appearances. Appearances could go hang. He’d given enough of his life to crown and kingdom, he wanted one damned night with Bilbo. Luckily, propriety was in agreement with Thorin’s wishes for once. 

 

“Stay,” Thorin breathed. Bilbo chuckled as he bent to kiss him again. Stay.

 


 

“Thorin? Thorin! Oh, for goodness sake, wake up! Your guards are going to think I’m trying to murder you!” 

 

Thorin woke, reaching for a weapon he hadn’t slept next to since before the battle. He was grateful for that fact when, instead of cold steel, Thorin’s hand landed on warm skin. He clutched at Bilbo’s shoulder, breathing hard as he tried to shake off the remnants of the dream.

 

“Thorin? Are you alright? What’s going on?” 

 

Thorin could not find enough air to breathe, let alone answer. He should not have allowed Bilbo to spend the night in his bed, knowing it was possible that Bilbo might be exposed to one of Thorin’s episodes. He should have sent him back to his room, where he could sleep peacefully. 

 

Despite the shame burning his face, Thorin was glad of Bilbo’s presence. He ran his hands over Bilbo’s bare chest, his arms, his face- everywhere he could reach to assure himself that Bilbo was whole and unharmed. Bilbo continued to pelt him with questions, but Thorin could not summon answers.Thorin’s face was wet, he realized with horror. Not only shouting then, but weeping as well, though the tears had stopped with his waking.

 

Bilbo’s endless questions were cut off by a sharp knocking at the door, followed by Dís’ voice. “I’m coming in, Thorin!”

 

Before Thorin had the chance to call out, his door was swinging open. Bilbo gave a small yelp and pulled the covers up to his chin as Dís appeared. She stopped short, eyes jumping from Thorin to Bilbo and back. What began as surprise quickly dissolved into suspicion. 

 

“ I did not know you had company,” She said in Khuzdul. Her eyes flicked to Bilbo once more. “Shall I remove him?”

 

“There is no need. He is doing no harm,” Thorin replied in kind, watching Bilbo’s brow furrow in confusion.  Dís gave a disbelieving huff,and Thorin heaved a sigh. His eyes felt swollen and his throat hurt from shouting and he wanted to crawl into a hole and die of humiliation. He did not want to argue with his sister. “ Please leave it, Dís. ”

 

“ As you wish,” She nodded once, but hesitated before leaving. “ If his presence makes things worse in the long run…”

 

“Good night, Dís,” Thorin said sternly, in Westron this time. 

 

He and Bilbo sat in silence for some time after her departure, Bilbo still with the covers pulled up to his chin, Thorin flopped back against the hundred thousand unnecessary pillows, trying to control his breathing. 

 

“What did she say?” Bilbo finally asked.

 

“She was checking on me,” Thorin mumbled. He’d thrown an arm over his eyes, as though concealing his face could salvage some of his dignity. 

 

“I see,” Bilbo said, and Thorin could practically hear his frown. “And what exactly was she checking on you for? What just happened?”

 

Thorin wanted to sink into the cushions and never reemerge. His voice was a quiet mutter when he finally admitted, “Bad dream.”

 

“Bad dream,” Bilbo echoed incredulously. “Thorin you were screaming and crying in your sleep ! I’d say that’s a mite bit more than a ‘bad dream.’”

 

“A very bad dream,” Thorin conceded. 

 

“You don’t say!” Bilbo finally flopped down beside Thorin on the million and one pillows. Thorin did not have the strength to resist when Bilbo gently peeled his arm away from his face. Bilbo might be onto something, Thorin thought to himself. It was much better being able to see Bilbo’s face like this, even though it was pinched in concern.

 

Bilbo sighed and dropped his head to Thorin’s shoulder, pulling Thorin’s arm around his shoulders like a blanket. Thorin allowed himself to be maneuvered without complaint. The dream was already fading in the face of Bilbo’s warmth at his side, the tickle of his hair against his shoulder. 

 

“She did not seem surprised,” Bilbo said after some time, shattering Thorin’s hope that they weren’t going to talk about this.

 

“No,” Thorin admitted.

 

“This has happened before?” Bilbo asked. Thorin hummed his confirmation. “How often?”

 

Thorin would not lie to Bilbo but, goodness, he did not want to tell him the truth either. He braced himself to do so anyway. Their recent argument had been the product of their assumptions about one another, after all. 

 

“Depends,” He said quietly, trying his damndest not to sound defensive. “Sometimes only a few times a month.”

 

“And the rest of the time?”

 

Thorin sighed heavily and wished, not for the first time, that Bilbo was just a smidgeon less clever. “A couple times a week.”

 

“But- I slept beside you for months on the quest,” Bilbo said. “I don’t remember you waking like this back then.”

 

Thorin’s silence spoke volumes. He was unwilling to admit that the night terrors had not yet manifested when they were on the quest, but Bilbo seemed to surmise as much anyway.

 

“How long has this been going on, Thorin?” Bilbo asked, propping himself up on an elbow to look down at Thorin with narrowed eyes.

 

“Since I woke from the gold lust,” Thorin admitted. He did not want to look at Bilbo - he could practically see him connecting the dots - but he did not want to look away either. Part of him still thought he might blink and find Bilbo gone.

 

“And what do you dream of?”

 

“This and that,” Thorin said evasively. “My family. The battle.”

 

“ What do you dream of, Thorin?” Bilbo demanded. Thorin winced, but he was not willing to argue with his hobbit twice in one night. 

 

“You.”

 

Bilbo sat up in bed, the covers pooling around his waist. He twisted to frown down at Thorin. His face was doing something strange that Thorin could not precisely decipher: something in the brows and the corners of his mouth that tugged at his expression. 

 

“Do you mean to tell me,” Bilbo said far too evenly for the determination he’d just displayed in prying answers out of Thorin, “Do you mean to tell me that you’ve woken screaming every few nights for the past two years? After dreaming of me?”

 

Thorin did not want to say “yes,” so he didn’t say anything at all. Bilbo made a strangled noise. His hand flew to his mouth. 

 

“This is why your family dislikes me,” Bilbo murmured. “They see what I’ve done to you.”

 

“No, gêdel, you haven’t,” Thorin said quickly, “You’ve done nothing wrong.”

 

“I’m not debating whether I did anything wrong,” Bilbo snapped, “I am saying that I hurt you.”

 

“Your presence is a balm,” Thorin laid a hand on Bilbo’s arm, trying to gently pull his hand away from his mouth. He wanted to gather Bilbo in his arms again, but Bilbo was agitated and restless now.

 

“How can that be? We parted because I betrayed you . And now I’ve lied to your face for years, pulled whatever nonsense I was thinking with the relics, ruined your relations with the Blacklocks– I don’t blame you for having nightmares about me, I’d have nightmares about me.”

 

“Bilbo,” Thorin finally sat up. He took both of Bilbo’s wrists, gently prying them out of where he’d been raking his hands through his hair. “ Satdûn, I do not fear your betrayal.”

 

Bilbo stopped trying to wriggle out of Thorin’s grasp. It must be quite difficult for him to see, Thorin realized, given how dark the room still was. Hobbits didn’t have vision as sensitive as a dwarf’s in the dark. Thorin took one of Bilbo’s hands and pressed it to his own cheek, turning his head to kiss the palm. Bilbo drew a sharp breath but he did not pull away.

 

“I told you, I did not know your fate all that time. My dreams are not of your past actions. My dreams are of all of the ways in which you might be lost.” Somehow, knowing that Bilbo likely had trouble seeing his expression made it easier to speak the words. “Having you here, alive and safe , does more to dispel those fears than any words my sister might speak. That is how I can “stand” to have you in my bed, lukhdel. ”

 

“I am sorry,” Bilbo whispered.

 

“You’ve nothing to be sorry for,”

 

“I do . Just– just let me say it. For my peace of mind.” Bilbo finally let his head fall to Thorin’s shoulder once more, though Thorin suspected it was only to hide his face. He must have remembered dwarvish night-vision as well. “I am sorry. I didn’t know- I mean, I did hope that you would miss me. And I suppose I did want a little payback at the beginning. But I never thought it would…”

 

Bilbo trailed off and Thorin was unwilling to finish the thought for him. Hadn’t thought it would destroy Thorin? Hadn’t thought it would break his heart? Hadn’t thought it would haunt him? Thorin would not admit to any of it, not unless Bilbo said he needed to hear it. He did not want to add guilt to guilt. 

 

“I did not know it would hurt you like this,” Bilbo said finally. “I didn’t know I could .”

 

“You have more power than you know, mudtel,” Thorin told him. He found Bilbo’s chin to raise his face but, rather than kissing him, Thorin brought their foreheads together in a gentle mimic of how he might greet another dwarf. 

 

“I don’t know how to fix this,” Bilbo said.

 

“You needn’t. I am responsible for my own emotions.” 

 

“ Stubborn dwarf, ” Bilbo grumbled, “Fine, then, how can I support you while you manage all of that. And don’t you dare say “nothing,” I’ll bite your chin.”

 

Thorin had been about to say ‘nothing,’ but upon request he stopped to consider. 

 

“I enjoy this,” Thorin said tentatively. “Having you in my arms. I enjoy hearing you speak. Just being in your presence, I suppose. I appreciate that you choose to take supper with me so often. I’m glad for the chance to see you.”

 

“Alright, I’ve got: erasing your personal space, talking your ear off, and monopolizing your time. What else?”

 

“Your honesty. That you tell me when I am making a mess of things. When you are unhappy, so that I might try to address it. I’ve the utmost confidence that you will continue to do so. You’re very good at it already.”

 

“That’s one way of putting it…”

 

“And, I suppose, if you were amenable, if it would please you-”

 

“Spit it out, Thorin.”

 

“There will be a Reuniting Ceremony of the Gabil and Luzun Arkenstone. I would be honored if you would attend. If you would partake.”

 

Bilbo gave a burst of laughter that ruffled Thorin’s beard. “Is that all?”

 

“You thought I was going to ask you to marry me again,” Thorin guessed.

 

“I thought you were going to ask me to marry you again,” Bilbo echoed wryly. 

 

“I have learned my lesson,” Thorin said, pressing a kiss to Bilbo’s brow, “I have already asked you. Now I will wait for you to ask me.”

 

“Awfully confident that a proposal is forthcoming, are we?” Bilbo teased, but Thorin just hummed in agreement as he coaxed them back onto the bed, keeping Bilbo’s head pillowed on his shoulder.

 

“I’ve been told it is a foregone conclusion,” Thorin said against Bilbo’s hair.

 

“Now, who could have told you such a thing? You oughtn’t believe everything you hear, you know.” Thorin could feel Bilbo’s breath warm against his neck when he spoke. It tickled, but in an oddly comforting way. Bilbo shuffled to get himself situated just so with his head under Thorin’s chin before asking, “What is a Reunion Ceremony then?”

 

“When the Luzun Arkenstone reappeared, I wanted to throw it in the vaults immediately. However my infinitely wise and strategic advisors-”

 

“Balin and Dís?”

 

“Balin and Dís,” Thorin agreed with a chuckle and wasn’t that strange? He never thought he’d be able to laugh during a conversation concerning either Arkenstone. “They reminded me that, however I felt about it, the Heart of the Mountain is valuable to all our people. If I treated it so carelessly, I would never hear the end of it. They suggested holding a ceremony to formally reunite the Luzun and Gabil Arkenstone before interring them once more. If you are comfortable, I’d like to have you with me when it occurs.”

 

“Are you worried that seeing it will trigger the gold lust again?” Bilbo asked.

 

“A little,” Thorin admitted. Only a few weeks ago the thought had terrified him, but a few weeks ago he hadn’t known his luzun lansel was so close at hand. “You make me feel braver. And, well, the symbolism…”

 

“A reunion,” Bilbo guessed correctly. 

 

“You told me once as Baldor that people took it as a sign that what was once lost had been found. I did not think so at the time, but now…” Thorin considered his next words carefully. “It need not be a promise of forever. I do not expect it to be. But, if you are amenable, I’d like to announce your return. Something to show that however far you wander, you are not lost to us. To me.”

 

“Mmm, not all who wander are lost,” Bilbo mused. He yawned, forcing Thorin to tilt his head to accommodate the stretch. “That could be the start of a nice little verse.”

 

“An excellent place to start.” 

Notes:

Enjoy my headcanon that Thorin is incredibly sappy in Khuzdul

madmel - comfort of all comfort
budgel - dream of all dreams
gêdel - joy of all joys
Satdûn - [man of whom I am] enamored
lukhdel - light of all lights
mudtel - heart of all hearts (emotional sense)

Notes:

Fun fact: the title, "All-Kinds-of-Fur," is an alternate name for the original fairy tale ("Catskin")

In case it was unclear, for the purposes of this fic, the Arkenstone was damaged by Smaug before Bilbo was able to recover it. The dwarves are only in possession of the much larger half, called the Gabil (great) Arkenstone.

Please let me know if there are any content warnings I've missed!

Series this work belongs to: