Actions

Work Header

All-Kinds-of-Fur

Chapter 2: A Pragmatic Solution

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Two Years After the Battle

 

“We have received an acceptance from the Orocarni.” 

 

Thorin was grateful that Dís was 

the one to tell him. She would never couch the truth in sugary language and he needed the absoluteness of a straight answer. When Thorin said nothing, she continued. 

 

“King Nami’s two eldest are already married, but his third is not. She has agreed to the match.”

 

“She?” Thorin suddenly blanched. He had, of course, known that his future spouse might be a woman (it mattered little when Erebor was at stake), but he had not truly considered the implications. 

 

“You need not consummate the marriage,” Dís looked somewhat unimpressed with his nerves. “And if you do choose to, there shall be no children from the union.”

 

Relief flooded him. Of course, there was still a risk of children, if his spouse had been a man, but it was statistically less likely. And children… Thorin was willing to bend to his kingdom’s needs, but he already had an heir. And to imagine the possibility of children from a loveless match… It was overwhelming, but it seemed cruel, unfair to those unborn children as well as to Fíli and Kíli. If there had been children, then the succession to the throne could have become messy. Fíli had a fair claim as Thorin’s named heir, but so would a theoretical first-born. Multiple claims was a recipe for disaster and they could not afford a civil war. 

 

“Honestly, Thorin,” Dís rolled her eyes at him. “Have a little faith in me. As though I would jeopardize Fíli’s place like that.”

 


 

Dáin arrived precisely on time, shortly before the second Durin’s Day since the Battle. His timing was awful.

 

The heralds announced “Dáin II, called Ironfoot, son of Náin, son of Gror, Lord of the Iron Hills, King of–” before Dáin gave a shout of impatience and shoved the doors to the throne room open himself. 

 

“Hail, cousin!” Dáin called cheerfully before he noticed Gloín and Kíli, standing before Thorin’s throne. They turned on their heels, faces stormy as thunderclouds, and marched past Dáin with hardly a glance. Thorin shut his eyes and prayed for patience. Dáin put his hands on his hips with a scoff.

 

“Who stuck soft coal in their forge?” Dáin asked aloud. “ Iraknadad , what have you done now?”

 

Thorin knew that it was said in jest, but he felt the sting of Dáin’s words nonetheless. 

 

“I will not allow them to honor Bilbo in this year’s tribute to the fallen.” 

 

Thorin could practically see Dáin working through the statement, frowning as he put the pieces together. 

 

“You are not still angry with him?” Dáin asked. “The Arkenstone is returned. Or, most of it anyway. I do not believe he could have broken it on purpose, even if he’d tried to. Surely, you cannot hold him accountable for damage done by the Great Wyrm? The Luzun Arkenstone is not his fault.”

 

“I agree,” Thorin said. He was so tired. The weight of the crown on his brow was so heavy that he felt as though it might pull him to the ground. 

 

“Well, then, what reason could there be to exclude him? To hear the Company tell it, the halfling is a hero.”

 

“Do not use that word,” Thorin told him sharply.

 

“Company?” Dáin looked at him as though he thought Thorin might be falling to madness once more.

 

“ Halfling. They consider it an insult.” Not half of anything , Bilbo’s voice echoed in his ears. Dáin made a noise of protest which fell away at a glare from Thorin. 

 

“Be that as it may, wouldn’t it be better to honor your half— your Hobbit ?” 

 

“Not among the fallen,” Thorin insisted. Dáin’s sigh was pitying. 

 

“Oh, Thorin…”

 

“He is not dead.”

 

“No, for you hold him in limbo!” Dáin shook his head. “This cannot continue. You dishonor him by refusing to acknowledge his sacrifice. Even his own kin have accepted it.”

 

Thorin’s head snapped to Dáin. “How would you know such a thing?”

 

“You are not my only kin in Erebor,” Dáin told him flatly. “Do you think I do not correspond with Balin? With your sister? They worry for you.”

 

Traitors. Schemers. Going behind his back. Whispering his secrets to unworthy ears. How dare– Thorin pushed aside the poisonous words. They sounded too much like the dragon’s hiss. He could not afford to give in to them. 

 

“They know not of what they speak,” Thorin grit out. 

 

“Mayhap, but I know of what I speak.” Dáin said. His normally jovial expression had faded. “You know that I would rather have Aurin cowardly and alive than among the glorious dead, but I would never hide his brave deeds to soothe my own grief.”

 

The Battle of Five Armies, as they were now calling it, was not the first time orcs had harnessed were-worms for use in battle. They’d practiced on Dáin’s kingdom for decades with unpredictable raids. Aurin, Dáin’s One and the sire of Thorin Stonehelm, had perished in the defense of the Iron Hills along with many other brave dwarrow. 

 

“It is different,” Thorin insisted. 

 

“I do not see how. Show some pride, for Mahal’s sake. If your half— your Hobbit was half as brave as the tales, then you tarnish his memory to keep him from the annals of our people. And if you do not write his history then someone else will write it for you and you might not like what they have to say. Have you heard what some of the traditionalists are saying about his role with the Luzun Arkenstone?”

 

“They are nattering old fools. No one of any sense believes what they have to say.”

 

“And yet, your silence seems to confirm their suspicions!” Dáin cried. “They think he must surely have done something truly terrible if their king refuses to acknowledge him on the day of remembrance.”

 

“Dáin, stop. I do not wish to hear any more of this.”

 

“But you want me here to bless your new union,” Dáin scowled and Thorin took a deep shuddering breath. 

 

“Please, Dáin.” Thorin said. “I do not tell you how to honor Aurin. Do not tell me how I must honor Bilbo. When I desire your counsel, I will ask for it. And when I ask, I swear that I will listen to what you have to say, but until then, please leave the matter.”

 

Dáin had been puffing himself up to keep arguing but he deflated at the mention of Aurin. He let out the breath he’d been saving up to yell and dropped his arms. 

 

“Aye. I suppose, so long as you don’t say I didn’t warn you.”

 


 

Despite Dáin’s warning, Thorin still could not bring himself to include Bilbo in the ceremonies on the second anniversary of the battle. He felt the disapproving eyes on him and a large part of him wanted to capitulate. Bilbo was a hero. He deserved to have his accomplishments celebrated. A larger part feared that it might break him to do so. Weighing the anger of Kíli and part of the company against the risk of relapsing into madness, Thorin chose to take their resentment.

 

After the memorial, Kíli began avoiding Thorin. When they were forced into a room together, Kíli complained loudly of… everything. The ongoing repairs were being done in the wrong order, relations with the Men of Dale were not being tended to properly, the treaties with the Blacklocks hadn’t been considered well enough and, above all, their spending was ludicrous. Thorin suspected that Kíli was more unhappy with Thorin than with any individual issue, but his youngest nephew would not allow himself to be cornered and so Thorin had no way of knowing for sure. He wondered what offended Kíli more: that Thorin was going to wed someone who was not his One, or that he’d been forbidden from going farther than Dale. 

 

The worst of it was that Thorin did not inherently disagree with Kíli. Their relations with Bard were being neglected because all hands were needed to help assimilate the Blacklocks; the treaties with the Blacklocks were caught up in endless negotiations because there were slight cultural differences that neither side had anticipated, and it did indeed feel absurd to spend so much on lavish banqueting when they had yet to finish inspecting the structural integrity of all the old mines.

 

And Thorin certainly understood his nephew’s distress in regards to romantic matters. He had not had the chance to assure Kíli that he was not entirely against his devotion to the guard captain (elven though she might be); just the timing. Things were too precarious. They needed to concentrate on settling Erebor and her people before they rocked its foundations by introducing an elf to the royal household. If they tried such a thing now, Thorin had no doubt he would be deposed before spring arrived. But a few years more must seem like an eternity to one so young as Kíli. Thorin could understand how dismal Kíli’s prospects might seem if Thorin would not even allow himself to marry for love. 

 

Thorin tried to take comfort in the fact that, though Kíli had turned away from him, there was a sudden influx of young dwarrow that Kíli could turn to. Growing up in Ered Luin, Kíli and Fíli had practically been one another’s only playmates. Though they were perhaps too old for playmates, Thorin still thought it was good for his nephews to have some friends who weren’t at least fifty years their senior. 

 

Though Fíli had too many responsibilities now to fully take advantage of the fact, Thorin knew that Kíli had taken to Gimli (intrigued by the novelty of getting to be the eldest for once) and to young Stonehelm. Thorin could not bring himself to call Dáin’s son “Thorin,” though he was consoled that young Stonehelm seemed equally mortified to meet his namesake as Thorin was. 

 

Thorin could only hope that Kíli eventually allowed Thorin to say his piece before he cemented his grudge for life. 

 

“I simply do not understand why there need be three nights of foolishness!” Kíli complained from his place at the dinner table. It was a relatively intimate dinner with only the descendants of Durin present. This still amounted to a fairly sizable group: with the children of Thráin, Fundin, Gróin, and Náin all represented there were at least a dozen of them. 

 

“No, you refuse to understand,” Dís scolded her son. “Balin has explained time and again why the celebrations are important. You just haven’t been paying attention.”

 

“I was .” Kíli sank lower in his seat, glaring at his fork. “I just think all of that could be accomplished in one night.”

 

“ One ? It’s bad enough that it’s only three! You know, it’s seven traditionally.” Gloín said from across the table. He had not been present for most of Kíli’s complaints and he hadn’t tired of the argument yet. Gloín wasn’t wrong either. They were barely getting away with limiting things to three nights: one for the Longbeards of Erebor, one for the Blacklocks of the Red Mountains, and one for the Broadbeams who’d sheltered them in the Blue Mountains. The other four clans would have to have their celebrations privately.

 

“Tradition, tradition, tradition,” Kíli wrinkled his nose. “I’m sick to death of tradition! Just because something’s always been done doesn’t mean it’s the best way to do it.”

 

“For craft and artistry, certainly, but it’s Mahalmerag .” Young Stonehelm said. “It’s the making of the Seven Fathers, not a plain old sword!”

 

Kíli opened his mouth only for Fíli to put a hand on his brother’s leg under the table. Kíli gave a start and Fíli silently gave a tiny shake of the head. Thorin was silently grateful. He did not wish to reprimand Kíli for whatever blasphemy he might have spoken next, especially not while Kíli was still so angry with him. Dís, however, had no such compunctions about her son’s ire.

 

“You know, kin of mine, I think Kíli might benefit from a lesson in our traditions,” She said slyly. “In fact, I think the court could benefit from seeing my youngest son’s devotion to those traditions first hand.”

 

Kíli had gone pale, eyeing his mother warily even as Dwalin smirked and Balin raised a bushy eyebrow. 

 

“What did you have in mind, my lady?” Balin asked.

 

“What better way to introduce our guests to a taste of Longbeard culture than to stage an exhibition of our most beloved dances? And who better to perform them than one of Durin’s heirs?” 

 

“ Ammad- ” Kíli gasped in horror. Dáin stroked his beard, not bothering to hide his smile. 

 

“You’ve a sharp mind, cousin,” He said. “What dance did you have in mind?”

 

“A Kalinka.”

 

“Mother, no, I cannot–”

 

“On second thought, a Trepak.” Dís said, speaking over Kíli’s protest. She shot him a warning look, daring him to continue to protest and see what fresh horrors she could devise. Kíli let his face fall into his hands with a groan. Fíli patted his shoulder in a conciliatory manner.

 

“I shall dance with him.” Fíli announced. 

 

“You don’t have to, Fi,” Kíli grumbled into his hands.

 

“I most certainly do. Someone should be there to catch you when you fall flat on your face,”

 

That got the chuckle from around the table that Fíli had obviously been hoping for. Even Kíli lifted his head to nudge Fíli’s shoulder with his own. 

 

“I think you mean when you fall… though perhaps falling on your face might improve it, somewhat.”

 

The two dissolved into good natured bickering and for a moment it felt almost like the nights in Ered Luin, dining by Dís’ hearth. Then Balin spoke again. 

 

“What say you, my king?”

 

It was the first anyone had addressed Thorin in some time and the mirth fled his nephews as soon as attention was drawn to him. All eyes turned to him and Thorin took his time to consider. In the silence, servers arrived to clear away the plates of their first course and present them with a soup.

 

“I say… this soup is very green. ” Thorin frowned, utterly distracted by the dish placed in front of him. Sure enough, the soup placed before them was a bright, opaque green, the color of new spring shoots. 

 

“What elven boarshite is this?” Dwalin fumed. Thorin privately had to agree. In truth, it smelled appetizing enough, but the color was decidedly off putting. He frowned at it some more, as though he could intimidate it into giving up its secrets, but when he moved to taste it, Gloín stopped him. 

 

“Wait! I don’t trust it. I’ll taste it first, lest it hide poison.” Gloín said. The servers, who had not yet retreated, looked as though they might all simultaneously faint from the mere suggestion of such treason. 

 

“Father, no,” Young Gimli protested, but Gloín squared his shoulders and took a bold spoonful of the soup, bracing as though for a strike. They all waited with bated breath for several minutes until Gloín finally shrugged. 

 

“That’s soup, alright,” Gloín admitted. 

 

“Could be a slow-acting poison,” Óin suggested, but Thorin had had enough of this foolishness and ignored the rest of his kin in favor of tasting the strange dish himself. 

 

The flavor burst across his tongue. He froze, feeling as though everything had gone silent around him, for all that he knew that his kin continued to bicker nearby. Only, silent was not quite true. He felt as though he could hear something. Birdsong beneath the mountain. Bare feet tapping over comfortably worn carpets. The cheery whistle of a kettle. Thorin took another bite. It wasn’t that it was so delicious, though it was very good, but it tasted like… He didn’t know how to explain. It tasted the way the air had smelled the night he first saw that round green door, like grass damp with dew and the subtle perfume of warm tilled earth and ripening fruit. Which was absurd. Logically, it tasted of onion and broth and vegetable, but it didn’t . 

 

“Thorin,”  Dís said sharply and his head snapped up. From the look in her eyes, he knew she’d called his name more than once. 

 

“What is it, lad?” Óin asked, as though he really expected Thorin to begin suffering convulsions from some unseen poison. Thorin could not stop himself from gaping for a moment, feeling the server’s fearful eyes on him. Finally, he swallowed.

 

“It is good,” He murmured. The servers breathed a collective sigh of relief, but Thorin found himself rising to his feet, chair scraping against the floor. “I must meet its maker.”

 

Thorin did not wait for his kin to follow as he marched from the dining room. The servers scrambled to get ahead of him to warn the kitchen staff of his imminent arrival. He did not care. His mind was empty save for the echoes of the heartsong he’d assumed had gone silent with Bilbo’s disappearance.

 

“Thorin, stop! What do you think you are going to find down there?”

 

Thorin slowed to a stop, allowing Balin to catch up to him and gently take him by the arms. Thorin did not look at him. He was ashamed but could not stop himself from acting.  Balin seemed to know it too.

 

“This is bordering on obsession.” Balin told him slowly. He did not mean it to be cruel but still Thorin flinched at the implication. “It’s been years and still you jump at the slightest hint…”

 

Thorin gently pulled Balin’s hands from him. The rest of the dinner party was beginning to catch up to them. Thorin set his jaw, but when he looked at Balin it was with sorrow. 

 

“I have to know.” He said. 

 

Only when Thorin had confronted the kitchen staff, learned the reason behind the fresh green soup served at dinner, did his resolve weaken. 

 

Thorin knew he left the kitchens at a reasonable speed but it felt like fleeing. He needed to be out of sight. He was king. He could not fall apart where anyone might see. 

 

Because falling apart was how it felt when at last Thorin had a locked door between him and the rest of the kingdom. 

 

He held his head in a vice grip. Was something wrong with him? Was this some new form of madness?

 

In the depths of the dragon sickness, Thorin had sensed things differently. His memories of the time were tinted, as though they were not quite his own. His eyes had fixated on different things, his ears on different sounds, and when anyone had spoken to him it was as though their words had another meaning to him. Was this a sign of the madness returning?

 

Thorin could not explain the mania that had seized him in response to the soup. This couldn’t be happening. He was supposed to be well. He was supposed to be beyond this. Was it grief? Was the grief of not knowing Bilbo’s fate causing him to see signs where there were none? 

 

It must be so. It must be so. It must be so. 

 

And he must be a fool for asking for the soup again, just to trip that false sense memory.

 


Before:

 

There was no time for soft and delicate desires in Mirkwood. Thorin hated the forest. They all hated the forest, but Thorin thought it might drive him to throwing himself on Orcrist, he hated it that much. In one moment the dark place seemed to hollow them out with hunger and in the next the sickness upon the forest seemed to fill them up again, like a gas they could not help but breathe in. 

 

Thorin could not fight madness with his sword any more than he could fight hunger with his ax. During the day he felt the helplessness clawing at him, knowing he would be unable to keep them from starving if it came down to it. But at night it was worse; the voice of his grandfather (his father, himself) hissed that the company slowed him down, that he would be better off to abandon them. They were being unhelpful and lethargic on purpose, they wanted to keep him here in the darkness forever away from Erebor. The hunger ate at him and the fear ate at him and the resentment ate at him until Thorin was unsure what there was left of him at all.

 

It was nearly a relief to be taken by spiders, who would at least bring numbness before they killed them, but Thorin was too exhausted to feel relief or anger at being taken by elves. He was half-mad when he stood before Thranduil, repeating only that they’d been starving as much from deranged hunger as from stubbornness.

 

In the dark days in prison in Mirkwood, Thorin listened with a ferocity that he never had before. For Bilbo was not among their captured band, which could only mean he was elsewhere: perhaps the Spiders had devoured him, perhaps he still wandered the forest alone. He did not know how long it took a hobbit to succumb to hunger. And yet beyond his fear, Thorin felt hope. His hobbit had survived every other impossible challenge set before them and succeeded against all odds. He had survived and saved the company every time. What was to say he could not do so again?

 

And so Thorin listened. He heard the sounds of his jailers as they passed and dripping water somewhere and silenced them all so that he could listen for the sound, unmade, of young grass rustling in the wind and of a cool clear stream hundreds of miles away and of feet walking friendly and familiar paths. It kept him from despair until Bilbo found him. 

 

The time they stole there was purely accidental. They had both spent so long alone in the dark that the sound of a familiar voice was welcome no matter what it said. In the days when Bilbo still planned their escape, they spoke just for the sake of speaking, just to have some proof that they were not muttering to themselves alone in the darkness. Most of the time it was pure nonsense. Bilbo drilled Thorin on his family tree until Thorin thought he’d be able to recite, “Gerontius Took, his wife, Adamanta Chubb, and their children, Isengrim, Hildigard, Isumbras, Hildigrim, Isembold, Hildifons, Isembard, Hildibrand, Belladonna, Donnamira, Mirabella, and Isengar” even if he forgot his own name. 

 

But at times Thorin found himself saying things he’d never meant to say to anyone. He told Bilbo of the blue lupines on the slopes of Ered Luin. He told him of going with Dwalin to get their first tattoos together and how Dwalin had laughed at him mercilessly when Thorin found he could not stand the needle. He told him of the strange feeling that crept over him sometimes, the hunger for something he could not describe, something precious. He told him about Balin teaching his nephews to play the fiddle.

 

It was not long after that Bilbo got them out. Of course he did, clever fellow he was, and if the barrel-ride was hellish at least they were free at the end of it. 

 

There were so many things Thorin Oakensheild had meant to say in Laketown. “You got us out, you miraculous burglar,” and “Your words kept me sane in that prison, thank you,” and “Your voice sounds like home and I don’t know why.” But somehow, he never did. Instead he found himself cornered by a very staunchly resolute hobbit. 

 

In the snatches of time he had allowed himself to picture courting Bilbo, he had imagined that he would be the one to approach Bilbo. Somehow the civil, mannerly creature seemed the sort to be approached, rather than do the approaching. As always, his burglar toppled Thorin’s expectations, demanding an explanation for everything: the stolen glances across the fire, the soft words exchanged, the ring Thorin had given him atop the Carrock. 

 

When Thorin could not answer his questions quickly enough, Bilbo shut them away in his room together and had Thorin explain with his hands and mouth and tongue instead. And Thorin found himself eager to answer anything that Bilbo asked.

 

Those days in Esgaroth were stolen bits of time. Having fulfilled the want to draw them together, Thorin found the heart-song growing quiet and still in contentment. It was no longer necessary to link them. Laying in bed, propped up on his elbows, Thorin unclasped one of his hair beads, offering it to Bilbo. It was not much, but signifying all he hoped to offer Bilbo for in those days Thorin would have offered all that he was in a heartbeat. Bilbo had laughed at him, revealed that Thorin had already fulfilled Hobbitish customs by offering him a ring, and accepted the bead.  

 

And yet his surrender to this peaceful time was incomplete. 

 

The mountain loomed large on the horizon and, soon, began to loom even larger in Thorin’s mind, crowding out all the quiet corners Bilbo had claimed there.


Now:

 

Yuna was beautiful. 

 

She was also too young for him.

 

This was only partially true. She was no child, a fully-grown dwarrowdam in her own right. If he had to guess, Thorin would place her as too old to be Dís’ child but too young to be Fíli and Kíli’s mother. More than that, however, Thorin felt too old for her . 

 

He had seen too much of the world. He’d been broken too many times. For the first time, he felt guilty in asking for Yuna’s hand (even if he had done so indirectly). She had so much life ahead of her still. A chance to find her One, to live a long life with them… Thorin could offer her gold, but little else. His heart would never be entirely open to her. 

 

To his shock, she seemed to know this already. 

 

They were granted a private audience together shortly after the arrival of the Orcarni entourage. 

 

Thorin could not say what her first impression of him was. His name preceded him easily, and though Thorin knew his feats were renowned, he could bring himself to feel little pride in them. He was no longer the dwarf who headed those tales. His illness after the battle had not been well publicized. It made a better story for him to be the Durin who finally refused to succumb to the madness of his blood than for him to have nearly been destroyed by it. 

 

Yuna was less than star struck. 

 

She reminded him a bit of Dís in her wit, although she seemed to consider her thoughts and words more carefully and carried herself with the unbreakable composure of smooth granite. 

 

“Your One,” She had said to him. “Your Luzun Lansel .”

 

Thorin had flinched at the mention. She said it with no malice, however, and Thorin found he was glad someone had provided her with the information so that he did not have to recount it himself. 

 

“I understand. I too am parted from my One now. Naidrithi astû.” I mourn with you.

 

For a moment, Thorin did not know how to respond. 

 

“Why did you agree to a union with someone who is not your One?” He couldn’t stop himself from asking. If he knew where Bilbo was, if he had some chance at a life with him, Thorin did not know that he could forfeit it so easily. Her eyes left no room for hesitation. 

 

“Why did you?”

Notes:

Khuzdul mostly from Dwarrowscholar

Luzun Lansel - Lost Love[of all loves]
Naidrithi astû - not literal, but essentially, "I mourn with you"

In case the discussion of heirs was unclear: Yuna would be a trans-woman in contemporary society. I like to think gender is handled differently among dwarves, maybe with more emphasis on behavior than on physical bodies. I think this could also play into Gimli's offhand comment about there being very few dwarven women: perhaps 'man' is just the most popular gender, with no correlation to what physical characteristics people possess.
In this case, if there were just an abundance of men in dwarven society, I think it makes sense m/m couples would be fairly common among. I think that many m/m couples would be perfectly capable of having biological children together (in this case, like Dáin and his made-up One, Aurin. Which of them carried Thorin III to term? None of our business).