Actions

Work Header

All-Kinds-of-Fur

Chapter 4: The Relics

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Sitting on the dais in the ballroom that evening, watching Yuna and her ladies in waiting perform their Orocarni dances for the crowds, Thorin felt unmoored. It was hard to believe that just this morning he’d held the shard of the Luzun Arkenstone. It did not seem right. Thorin felt as though his world had shifted, just a little, and it was disorienting that no one else seemed to see it. 

 

He waited until the crowd was well and truly captivated by Yuna before he slipped out of his heavy cloak - a golden brocade with heavy beaded embellishments that weighed at least as much as the furs from the previous night. There would be no subtle escape dragging that in his wake. 

 

Thorin didn’t flatter himself to think that he slipped into the crowd unnoticed. More than one guest did a double take when he passed them. By the time Yuna had retaken her seat, Thorin was safely ensconced by the buffet table. 

 

He picked idly at the offering. He had no stomach for it, but doing so allowed him to keep his back to the room. When he’d slowly negotiated his way past piles of baked goods and platters of perfectly arranged canapés, he was blocked by a dwarf about a head shorter than him. The young noble was so distracted watching the crowds that he took no notice that anyone was trying to pass him, let alone the king. 

 

Thorin was surprised to realize that he recognized the oblivious guest. It was the dwarf who’d danced with young Gimli the previous night. Binimnâl. Nameless One. 

 

The music from the Orocarni musicians seemed to grow louder in Thorin’s ears. He was not familiar with all of their instruments. There seemed to be an unusual one that sounded much like the patter of gentle spring rain, and another like the quiet clink of porcelain being set upon a table. He’d have to remember to ask what made the oddly comforting sound when he got the chance.

 

Binimnâl, as Thorin had decided to call him in his head, was distracted enough that Thorin was given a chance to observe him in peace. Given how long he’d danced the night before, Thorin was a little surprised that he wasn’t back on the dancefloor. He wore a fur-trimmed surcoat of a deep ochre color. At his neck sat a small broach in the shape of a butterfly, the wire filaments of its wings so delicate that they fluttered with every breath Binimnâl took. His hair and beard were relatively short. The beard could be excused by age but his hair only brushed his shoulders. Curious. Perhaps he’d cut it in mourning. Given the length, the death would have occurred around the time of the Battle, which made sense. There was something familiar about the upturn of Binimnâl’s nose and in the honey brown color of his hair. 

 

Thorin sucked in a sharp breath as soon as he realized who he’d been comparing this dwarf to. Far too many times in the months after the Battle, Thorin had caught himself turning after anyone whose hair was a similar shade, who was of the correct height. It was never Bilbo, of course, but he felt as though he’d driven himself halfway back to madness imagining him out of the corner of his eye. Thorin averted his gaze but his harsh gasp had already drawn Binimnâl’s attention.

 

Binimnâl startled, jerking and hastily trying to swoop into a bow.

 

“Your majesty-“ He began, but Thorin waved him off.

 

“Quietly now,” Thorin said quickly, “It was not easy to escape and I have no wish to be placed back on my pedestal just yet.”

 

Binimnâl straightened but Thorin kept his eyes directed over Binimnâl’s shoulder rather than on his face. He only caught the impression of a small smile from the corner of his eyes.

 

“Your secret is safe with me.” Binimnâl assured him. Durin’s beard, but he even sounded a bit like Bilbo now that Thorin’s mind was preoccupied with conjuring him.“I shall not reveal you.”

 

“Nor yourself, it would seem,” Thorin huffed, “Do you truly withhold even your name from me?”

 

“With my deepest apologies, my lord,” The laughter was more pronounced in Binimnâl’s voice now and Thorin could practically hear Bilbo’s sarcastic deadpan, I’ve some skill at conkers. Thorin tried to banish the thought with limited success. 

 

“What of your purpose in Erebor? Surely you can tell me that, at least.” Thorin said. 

 

“I am here to see my kin,”

 

“Who are your kin?” Thorin asked.

 

“No one of great importance, I can assure you,”

 

“And how do you gauge such a thing?” Thorin asked, a little more sharply than he’d meant to. “There were coal miners, cooks, tinkerers, toy-makers in my Company when we reclaimed the mountain. I’d say that all were greatly important, though they did not trace their lineage to any of the Fathers.”

 

There were gentle hobbits, burglars, barrel-riders, riddle-makers. He was important.

 

“I— I had not thought of it like that, your majesty.” Binimnâl said, clearly taken aback and Thorin tried to reel in his urge to hammer the point home.

 

“And besides, whoever your kin are, the Master of Ceremonies deemed them “important” enough to warrant an invitation, if you are here to see them.” 

 

“I doubt you are familiar with them,” Binimnâl said quickly. Thorin sighed heavily. He had no wish to interrogate Binimnâl. He had heavier matters to think on.

 

“If you refuse to tell me about yourself, Binimnâl, then at least entertain me.” Thorin commanded. 

 

Binimnâl was silent for a beat, thinking. Then he spoke:

 

“A heart, though I do not beat ,

Inspiring hunger, though I do not eat,

Softly glowing, though I do not burn,

To the King, I shall always return.

What am I?”

 

Thorin turned the riddle over in his head for only a moment before he gave up. Again, he had more important matters to spend his energy on. “I do not know. What is it?”

 

“The Heart of the Mountain. The King’s Jewel… The Arkenstone.” Binimnâl said. Thorin stiffened and Binimnâl hesitated before he added, “It is said the Luzun Arkenstone has returned.”

 

Thorin’s heart swooped. Yuna had said that it had been announced. It might have been more strange for Binimnâl not to inquire about it. And yet the tension lodged in Thorin’s chest made him unable to keep the grimace from his face.

 

“Returned,” he said between gritted teeth, “Only to be sealed away as soon as possible.”

 

He had practice being diplomatic. It was his job now to step lightly, speak politely, but the damned jewel had cost him too much. Only, that wasn’t quite right. The Arkenstone was a cold, mindless jewel. Thorin had been responsible for his actions, no matter how he wished to lay the blame elsewhere. 

 

“They are saying it is a sign,” Binimnâl said and Thorin did not think he was mistaken about the note of surprise in his voice. “That what was lost has now been recovered.”

 

Nothing worth having has been recovered, Thorin nearly snarled. Fíli’s eye, Kíli’s steady stride, Dwalin’s confidence in him, Dis’ trust— Bilbo. Mahal, he did not even know if his madness had cost his beloved his life. None of these things could be returned to him.

 

He took a deep breath through his nose. “ Nothing” was a bit of a stretch. He and the Company had survived. Erebor was restored. The Longbeards who’d followed Thror into Azanulbizar finally had a home. They had gold enough that they would never again have to stoop and scrape just to avoid starvation. If the union with the Blacklocks succeeded, then Erebor would flourish, might again be filled with the laughter of children , rare and blessed as such things were. This was not nothing.

 

“It should have stayed lost,” Thorin finally growled. 

 

He did not hear Binimnâl’s stuttered excuses as Thorin turned away from him and made his way back to the dias. His expression must have been thunderous, for none dared to stop him on his way back. The Orocarni’s music felt like it was echoing in his ears, though he could see the musicians had stopped playing: something about that comforting sound stuck with him, like someone in an adjacent room making a cup of tea on a rainy day. 

 

Yuna had returned to her seat as well and she leaned toward him when Thorin had settled the heavy brocade mantle back over his shoulders.

 

“Who was the dwarf you spoke to just now?” She asked, her voice low. Thorin would have shrugged if the cloak hadn’t been so heavy.

 

“The lad refused to say.” Thorin said, “I’m calling him Binimnâl until he does.”

 

“What did you speak of?” Yuna’s voice was neutral but Thorin was beginning to recognize the exact shade of neutrality that she called upon. This was not genuine, this was cautious, tapping the ice with a foot to see if it would hold weight. 

 

“What else? The Luzun Arkenstone. ” It was on the lips of every dwarf who’d heard of its reappearance. How could it not be? Yuna was silent until Thorin finally asked, “Did you notice something unusual about him?”

 

“His belt.” Yuna said finally. “And his boots. He wore a fine surcoat and jewels, but his belt and his boots were plain. Workman’s wear.”

 

Truthfully, Thorin had not noticed. He’d tried not to look to closely at Binimnâl

 

“And he refused to share his identity.” Thorin said slowly. On its own, neither piece of information was incriminating but together it did raise an alarm (if only a small one).

 

“I’d like to inform your Master of Whispers.” Yuna told him,  “I want to know more of this Binimnâl.”

 

Do you truly think that necessary? Thorin wanted to ask. Binimnâl was an odd one, but Thorin sensed no animosity in his peculiar behavior. But he was hiding something. Thorin could not deny that. 

 

“I trust your judgment,” he said.

 


 

That night Thorin dreamt of the ramparts again. Again the wind blew harsher and colder than it had ever done in real life. Thorin threw Bilbo to the rocks below, but instead of a sickening crunch, the Hobbit shattered like crockery. 

 

Thorin stared at the fragments of his Luzun Lansel where they glittered, a thousand shards of the Arkenstone out where any treacherous Man or Elf could snatch away.

 

In his dream, Thorin screamed for the shards to be collected and reassembled, as though he could put Bilbo back together again if they only found all the pieces. The wind whipped his words away and he woke to Dís knocking at his door once more.

 

“I do not understand,” he confided to his sister, too shaken to turn her away. “I do not understand.”

 

He had not dreamt of Bilbo since Durin’s Day, though he did not doubt why the dreams had returned. The ache of uncertainty was a fresh wound in his chest. Or perhaps it was only the old scars acting up. Thorin felt as though he were the Gabil Arkenstone , cracked, incomplete, his edges jagged and fragile. 

 


 

Thorin woke without any memory of falling asleep. In fact, it hardly felt as though he’d slept either, though the foul taste in his mouth and the crick in his neck suggested otherwise. 

 

He dined with his kin for breakfast, but there was a general pall over the group compared to yesterday. When breakfast was served, Thorin bid his server to remain. The young dwarf’s eyes went wide as saucers but he didn’t dare disobey a direct order from his king, though his hands shook the silver platter he held. 

 

There was no porridge today (he’d forbidden it after yesterdays), but he stabbed viciously at his eggs, determined to root out any secrets they might hold. The eggs remained innocuous and Thorin breathed a sigh of relief. He lifted his tea to begin the meal… and felt something clink against the bottom of the teacup. 

 

Thorin swore ferociously, reaching into the cup, heedless of the heat and the mess. His fingers closed around something small and metal, warm from sitting in the tea and concealed by the cream that had been added. Thorin swore his heart stopped when he uncurled his fist to see what lay on his palm. 

 

It was his signet ring. In truth, he’d known it when his fingers brushed the finely wrought cirth . How could he not? He’d carried it on his own hand for more than half a century before he gave it to Bilbo. The silver was still warm from sitting in the tea, warm enough to feel as though someone had only just slipped it off their fingers. 

 

Someone gave a low wrenching groan and it took a moment for Thorin to realize that the sound came from himself. And then Thorin lost track of time. 

 

He knew on a factual level that he had stormed out of the room, his hand an iron band on the unlucky server who’d brought his meal. He knew that he’d hauled the lad down to the kitchens and shouted himself hoarse. He could not remember what he’d said, though he remembered the color draining away from the kitchen staff’s faces. He knew that It had taken Balin and Fíli plying him with logic and placations to lead him away before he did irreparable damage. 

 

Thorin came to himself in the afternoon. He was in his own parlor, seated on a couch by the fire. He was shaking from head to toe, breathing as though he’d just led a charge in battle. His fingers ached, his knuckles white from how tightly he still gripped the ring. 

 

Balin knelt in front of him, speaking softly, his hand resting over Thorin’s closed fist. 

 

“Come now, lad, let’s see it now. No harm will come to it, we only want to see.” Balin kept up a low murmur of placations as he gently tried to pry open Thorin’s fist. 

 

Thorin jerked back instinctively, pulling his fist to his chest, and Thorin saw the exact moment the fear and heartbreak threatened to overwhelm Balin. Thorin gave another wounded sound. He was doing it again. He was losing himself to the madness of his bloodline. He was failing the people he loved once again. 

 

“Balin-” Thorin’s voice cracked, but he could not give voice to anything that might have followed. Balin, I am afraid. Balin, help, I don’t know what to do. Balin, do what you must, protect the kingdom from me, do not let me destroy everything we’ve worked so hard to build. He couldn’t say any of it. A king was not afforded such vulnerabilities.

 

Balin stayed before him, still kneeling as though he were in the midst of swearing fealty, and the thought of Balin doing so even with the madness sinking its claws back into him made the scars on Thorin’s chest burn. 

 

With a shuddering breath, Thorin unclenched his fist. He held out his palm, the ring trembling right along with Thorin’s hand. 

 

Slowly, Balin lifted it from Thorin’s outstretched palm. He held it toward the firelight, squinting and running his fingertips over the cirth, just as Thorin had done. 

 

“It is genuine,” Someone said and Thorin realized suddenly that they were not alone in the room. Dís and Dwalin sat slightly further away. It was Dís who had spoken. She held out her hand and Balin passed her the ring. She turned it over before passing it in turn to Dwalin. 

 

“It is genuine,” she repeated solemnly. “The small dent in the corner. It saved Thorin from losing a finger to Kíli’s attempt at mastering the dagger.”

 

Thorin remembered the incident. Kíli had been very young, but old enough to begin training. He’d still idolized Fíli so much, wanting to emulate him in all things - including his penchant for knives. Thorin had managed to keep the finger, thanks to the weight of his ring, but he’d still needed three stitches. Kíli had cried and cried, as though he were the one who’d been injured. It was not long after this incident that Kíli abandoned blades in favor of the bow.

 

“Balin,” Thorin said again, ashamed of how unsteady his voice sounded. “That ring. I gave it- I gave it to- It should not be here.”

 

Balin and Dwalin’s faces both grew solemn, the silence stretching out unbearably.

 

“It might not have anything to do with him,” Dwalin finally grunted. “He could’ve lost it in the battle. Anyone might have picked it up.”

 

Thorin didn’t know whether he wanted the ring back, to cradle against his chest, or whether it ought to remain in safer hands than his own. His mind was finally anchored here, to this room, but he feared that his wits might leave him once more if given the chance. 

 

“I’m going to consult Nori,” Dís finally said, rising from her chair. “He should know about this.”

 

 Dwalin silently stood to follow her, passing the ring back to Balin before he left. Guilt tugged at Thorin for being glad to see him go. He felt scraped raw, like a tanned hide, stretched thin and taut. He did not wish for either of them to see him like this any more than they already did. 

 

“Balin,” Thorin swallowed, “Will you stay with me?”

 

He felt incredibly foolish to ask, like a dwarfling still scared of the dark, but he didn’t know what else to do. Balin had already seen him at his most broken and somehow still called him ‘king.’ Balin nodded.

 

“Would you like me to… hang onto this?” Balin asked delicately. “Only for safe keeping.”

 

Thorin wasn’t sure what he ought to do, but he knew what he wanted. His voice was very nearly timid when he said, “I’d like it back. Please.”

 

Balin dropped it back in Thorin’s hand without reproach and Thorin once more closed his fingers around it. The ring was just as heavy as he remembered, a grounding weight both physically and emotionally. The ring was hardly the be all and end all of legitimacy, but it was one of the trappings that came with heading the Line of Durin. Any who bore the ring would be recognized as, at the very least, a valued friend and ally if they sought help from another dwarf (at least, any dwarf friendly to the Line of Durin). Thorin hooked his thumb through the ring and spun it over and over in his hands.

 

He and Balin sat in silence for a long time before Thorin spoke again. 

 

“Is it the madness again? The gold sickness?” He asked finally. “Tell me plainly, Balin. If it is, then we must take precautions sooner rather than later.”

 

Balin pondered the question for a moment, bushy brows furrowing before he asked, “Might I see the ring a moment?”

 

Thorin reluctantly handed it back and Balin broke into a genuine smile. He held it for only a moment before passing it back. 

 

“No, lad, I don’t think it’s the gold sickness.” He said confidently. “If there is madness, it is not the curse of your line or lust for gold.”

 

“How can you be certain?” Thorin asked, once again spinning the ring in his fingers. 

 

“Firstly, I’d like to think I know the difference, having borne witness to how such a thing manifests in you before. There was pride in you before. This time I feared you’d take shears to your beard again if Dwalin hadn’t wrestled you into place.” Balin explained. “Furthermore, your wishes have been phrased as requests, not commands… Even that aside, you parted with the ring when I asked it of you.”

 

Thorin hadn’t thought of that. The idea of losing the ring pained him deeply and he hoped to keep it in his hands for as long as he could, but he could not deny that it was… different. In the throws of his gold lust, Thorin had felt the Arkenstone’s absence like a severed limb. The sight of it in any hands other than his own had filled him with such fury that he’d felt as though he would burst into flames with it. The ring had no such pull. Only sorrow.

 

Before Thorin could inquire further, there was a sharp knock on his door. It had not been long since Dís had left, but far be it from Thorin to question how Nori might travel so swiftly. Only, rather than Nori, it was Yuna who appeared when Thorin called to enter. 

 

She was dressed down, which Thorin had only seen a handful of times before and still took him by surprise. Her dark hair was twisted into a knot on top of her head with only a few braids of distinction. 

 

“What is it?” Thorin asked and it spoke to how well she’d gotten used to him that she didn’t blink at his blunt tone. She stepped in and shut the door behind her without further invitation. Only when she saw Balin did she sweep into an appropriately formal bow, which Balin stood to return. 

 

Yuna glanced between Thorin and Balin before raising an eyebrow in question. 

 

“Balin knows all that there is to tell,” Thorin said, “You may speak freely in front of him.”

 

Yuna inclined her head respectfully, “I wished to discuss the findings of my investigation thus far, but I can see that there are other matters at hand. What has happened?”

 

Balin did Thorin the courtesy of explaining the ring and its significance both as an heirloom and as a courting gift. Upon request, Thorin allowed Yuna to inspect the ring and was satisfied that she handled it with the utmost reverence. 

 

“That is troubling,” she said, handing the ring back to Thorin. Coming from Yuna, it might as well have been a cry of outrage, she so rarely voiced her opinion unsolicited. “I wonder…”

 

“You said your investigations had borne fruit,” Thorin prompted. Yuna nodded. 

 

“Investigations?” Balin asked. Yuna raised a single unimpressed eyebrow at Thorin as though to chide him. He knows all there is, does he? Thorin was too exhausted to do more than sketch the broadest outline for Balin. Balin seemed unconvinced but held his tongue until Yuna shared what she learned.

 

“I had him trailed last night when he left the festivities. Your Binimnâl is not of noble birth. He resides in the lower district. Or else has dealings there that would keep him through the night. ”

 

“Being common is not a crime,” Thorin said, “Nor is gate crashing, for that matter.”

 

“No. But do you believe it is mere coincidence that this Binimnâl has appeared at the same time as the Luzun Arkenstone? As the seal of Durin?”

 

“We cannot even be sure the two are connected,” Thorin said, but it sounded weak even to his own ears. 

 

“It stretches credibility to believe that they are not,” Balin shook his head glumly. “The method of delivery was the same, the same time of day, to the same location… What are the odds that two dwarves thought to bestow these heirlooms the same way at nearly the same time?”

 

“I don’t like it,” Thorin said finally. If the two were truly connected, what did it mean that the same person had been in possession of both the Luzun Arkenstone and the ring? How long had this person had them? And why relinquish them now?

 

“I still have people watching him,” Yuna assured him. “Hopefully Binimnâl will return again tonight and we can learn something more.”

 

“Tonight?” Thorin echoed, brow creasing. Both Yuna and Balin looked at him expectantly.

 

“The final night of festivities,” Balin finally said. Thorin opened his mouth to protest. He could not possibly attend a ball after all that had happened today. All that had happened yesterday. Even if they did not have concerns about plots brewing right under their noses, Thorin was still shaken. He felt like a dishrag that had been wrung out too fiercely. How could he possibly appear in front of his people in such a state? Yuna cut him off before Thorin could raise any objections.

 

“Appearances, Thorin.” She said firmly. “You need not leave the dias if you do not wish, but you must show your face.”

 

Thorin shut his eyes and took a deep breath. One night. He could pretend for one more night.

 


 

Thorin could not pretend for one more night. He felt as though his formal robes were suffocating him. The crown was making his head ache and the beads woven into his hair felt too heavy, tugging at his scalp. 

 

He should not have brought the ring with him to the festivities, but he was gripped by the irrational fear that it would vanish if he left it behind. He knew that his endless fidgeting was putting Fíli and Kíli on edge and he did not blame them for excusing themselves the moment Dís granted them permission. Thorin would have done the same if he could have, but he was bound to his chair by duty. 

 

The line of guests waiting to greet him snaked out the door and it took every ounce of diplomacy that had ever been drilled into Thorin to keep his tone cordial as the procession dragged on. Thorin knew he was not doing as well as he’d hoped when Yuna flicked him a sharp look, eyes darting between Thorin and the ring he still turned over and over in his hand. Just as Thorin was about to give up and throw propriety to the wolves, Yuna straightened - an impressive feat, considering her already immaculate posture. 

 

Naturally, this was also the moment the musicians decided to strike up. He was fairly certain it was a fiddle, though the tune was a bright, merry one that he did not recognize. People were clapping along to the tune, though Thorin couldn’t spot where they were, nor why they all seemed familiar with the decidedly un-dwarvish song. It was very distracting and Thorin had half a mind to holler for them to keep it down.  

 

Binimnâl approached. It was only now that Thorin realized that it was the first night the young dwarf did so. After so much discussion, Thorin could not help but glance at Binimnâl’s belt and boots. It was as Yuna said: they were plain. The leather was not even tooled. It looked especially odd now against his surcoat, a shot silk that looked nearly white from a distance but which shimmered green and pink and blue as he moved. Thorin knew the material alone cost a fortune. Why on earth would someone go to the lengths needed to secure such a garment only to neglect all else?

 

“Greetings, your majesty,”

 

Binimnâl ducked his head when he bowed and his hair sparkled with tiny crystal beads with the same iridescence as the surcoat. Thorin’s fist clenched around the ring. If Binimnâl had anything to do with it’s sudden reappearance- if he had anything to do with the Luzun Arkenstone’s reappearance- and then to have the nerve to tell him riddles about it last night! Thorin grit his teeth. 

 

“I’ve no patience for games tonight, Binimnâl,” Thorin growled, “Give me your name and be done with it.”

 

Binimnâl started, nearly standing up only to dip into a lower, more reverential bow.

 

“Baldor, son of Gildor, your majesty,” Binimnâl- Baldor said, addressing his words to the floor.

 

While Baldor’s head was down, Yuna shot Thorin a warning look. If he kept grimacing and snapping, he’d alert Baldor to their suspicions. If Baldor was involved, it wouldn’t do to send him into hiding by giving anything away too soon. Thorin forced himself to take a deep breath.

 

“Thank you for your attendance this evening, Lord Baldor,” Thorin’s words were still unnaturally stiff. Baldor (if that was even truly his name) took a step backward without raising his head, but when Thorin made no move to call him back, he peered up at Thorin through his fringe.

 

“Forgive me, your majesty, if I am too bold,” He said quietly, “But you seem to carry a heavier burden than usual. I am at your service, should you require it.”

 

Thorin felt his frustration surge. If Baldor was guilty then the taunt of this could not be endured. He would not stand to have this imposter , this rat , stand there and innocently offer to help Thorin when he very well knew that he was the cause of his strife. 

 

“You are right, Lord Baldor. You are too bold.” Thorin managed to control his volume, but not the venom that laced his voice. Baldor flinched at the open hostility and made his exit without further comment. When he was well and truly out of earshot, Yuna spoke.

 

“ Thorin. ” She said. She did not need to say more, her warning and reprimand clear in her voice. Thorin tried not to sink lower in his throne like a pouting child. 

 

When the line finally came to an end, Thorin sat up, ready to shrug off his latest robe and escape into the crowd, but Yuna placed a gentle hand on his arm.

 

“Allow me,” she said calmly. Thorin tilted his head in confusion. “You are too obvious. You’ve been growling like a bear all evening. Stay here, at least for now.”

 

Thorin sat back in his chair, defeated, while Yuna made her way down to the dancefloor. He watched impassively, still spinning his ring in endless circles around his thumb. 

 

He had to give credit where credit was due. Yuna joined the dancing without being noticeably out of place. She must have worked hard to learn their steps so quickly, even if she had not mastered them yet. That damned fiddle was still playing. How anyone was meant to keep time with two songs going simultaneously was beyond Thorin, but no one else seemed to struggle with it. Thorin was likely just too overwhelmed to cope with what was a perfectly normal arrangement. 

 

He watched, trying not to glare too obviously, as Yuna danced her way slowly across the room, moving from partner to partner until she stood opposite Baldor as though it were the most innocent coincidence in the world. 

 

Baldor’s hair really was the same dark honey color. Thorin wondered if this was why it set his nerves alight to imagine Baldor as the architect of his current predicament. The situation was bad enough without reenacting the feelings he’d had on the ramparts. He understood, of course, why Bilbo had done it and he could not fault him, but Thorin’s body still remembered the pain of what he’d believed to be a betrayal. 

 

Thorin wanted to bury his head in his hands. After tonight, he would take a step back, he thought to himself. He was not fit to sit on the throne, if he was so affected by the mere suggestion that someone resembling Bilbo might have betrayed him. Seven Fathers, Thorin didn’t even know if the boy was guilty. 

 

The evidence certainly suggested it as a possibility, but what if they were wrong? What if Baldor was exactly what he seemed: unaccustomed to courtly life, somewhat dazzled by the spectacle, unaware of proper dress, shy about his origins but well-meaning in his inquiries, and too young to even braid his beard? If that turned out to be the case, Thorin would be miserable with himself for jumping to such harsh conclusions. They had no real proof of Baldor’s guilt at the moment. Perhaps it was unfair to suspect him on circumstantial evidence.

 

It wouldn’t be the first time Thorin had turned on someone without sufficient reason. 

 

The seed of doubt burrowed under his skin, bringing up every instance of Thorin’s judgment proving too hasty. If he was wrong about this… When Thorin could stand it no longer, he shed his outer robe and crown, despite Yuna’s instructions, and sank into the crowd below. 

 

He found Baldor perched on one of the couches below the arcade of columns. The young dwarf was still watching the dancefloor in some sort of reverie, just as he’d been the night before. Thorin wondered what about the scene kept Baldor in such rapt attention. His expression didn’t look particularly scheming or even especially nervous. He looked… melancholy. Thorin wondered if his sharp words had contributed to that.

 

The fiddle had finally subsided, giving way to raucous laughter, the knocking of tankards, the stomp of feet on wooden boards- but, no, the floors were solid stone. He must be mistaken.

 

When Baldor finally caught sight of Thorin he just blinked, as though not truly believing that Thorin was before him. By the time he seemed to realize that it was Thorin in the flesh, he was too close to execute a proper bow. Baldor tried valiantly nonetheless to scramble to attention, but Thorin waved his hands. 

 

“Peace, son of Gildor.” He said. He sounded exhausted even to himself. After a moment’s hesitation, Thorin sank onto the couch beside Baldor, though there was an appropriate space between them. 

 

Baldor opened and closed his mouth several times, obviously searching for words, but it was Thorin who spoke first. “Please forgive my words earlier this evening. You are right. Much weighs on my mind of late.”

 

“No, no, you were right,” Baldor said quickly, “I was far too bold. Forgive my presumption.”

 

They fell back into silence that was not quite companionable. Thorin burned with too many questions to be at ease. He wanted to demand answers, but he didn’t know if he would believe anything Baldor told him. Why bother to conceal your name? He wanted to ask, Why bother to hide who your kin are or where you are from? If you are all that you seem, what was the point? If you are something else, why is it so hard to mistrust you? 

 

“Although,” Baldor said, slowly this time, “If the weight of your troubles becomes too heavy, I am at your service. Hearing it would be no burden to me.”

 

Thorin wanted to take him up on the offer. He wanted to spill the fear that had grown roots in his heart just to keep the sorrow at bay. He wanted Baldor to have a reasonable explanation for everything and he wanted to accept it and be soothed by the knowledge. Instead, Thorin heaved a heavy sigh. 

 

“You are a generous fellow, Lord Baldor,” Thorin said. “What do you plan to do after Mahalmerag? Shall you remain in Erebor?”

 

“No, your majesty. I leave at dawn.”

 

Thorin hesitated for only a moment. He already had regrets of banishing one he should have held close. Why not counter it with an ill advised invitation when he ought to hold someone at arm’s length?

 

“Erebor’s gates are open to you, should you wish to return.”

Notes:

Binimnâl - literally “without name”, here used to mean “Nameless One”