Chapter Text
As though sensing that Thorin might be growing too accustomed to his dreams of the ramparts, Thorin’s mind conjured fresh terrors for him to face that night. He did not even feature in this dream, only able to observe, unheard and unseen.
It was the battlefield, though not as Thorin had ever dreamt of it before. His nightmares of the battle were plentiful and varied: Azog rising again after Thorin failed to kill him a second time, the thousand terrible fates that could have befallen his sistersons, occasionally blurring time so that he fought beside Frerin as they had at Azanulbizar or watched Smaug torching his path of destruction at the same time. Those dreams were filled with screams and clashing steel, frantic movement, losing sight of his allies in the crush…
This was different. This was utterly silent. The ground was churned to mud from the blood that had been spilt, though there was hardly a patch of bare earth to be found, the bodies lay so thickly upon the ground. In some distant part of his mind, Thorin knew that his dream was recycling what he recalled of Azanulbizar. He’d never seen the destruction after this battle, the Battle of the Five Armies, as they were calling it. He’d been too wounded, barely conscious (let alone sane ) until the worst of the mess had been cleared away.
His mind’s eye presented him with the sight of a scavenger, a faceless Man, slowly picking over the battlefield. Thorin watched him ransack corpses with grim efficiency, plucking arrowheads from dead flesh, decorative buckles from the armor of Elves and Dwarrow alike, anything that was light enough to stuff his pockets with.
He knew before he saw that his dream would force him to look on Bilbo once again. This too was different. Thorin had seen the body of his beloved broken on the rocks before, or else smothered by his own hands, but he’d never seen him bloodied . There was so much of it that Thorin could not tell where the fatal blow had been struck and Thorin let out a silent moan of horror and grief. Bilbo looked like a ragdoll dropped in the mud by a careless child, forgotten.
But not forgotten by the scavenger.
Get away! Thorin tried to scream. Don’t touch him! But it was useless. Thorin was nothing more than a ghost in this dream. His hands passed through the scavenger when he tried to pull him off Bilbo by force, but it made no difference.
The scavenger let out a surprised chortle when he found the ring, the seal of Durin, dangling from a chain around Bilbo’s neck. He snapped the chain easily and held the heavy ring up to examine his find. When he turned his face toward the light, Thorin recognized Baldor. He cursed and shouted and clawed uselessly at Baldor.
Finally, Baldor turned to Thorin, as though seeing him for the first time. He reached toward Thorin and clapped a heavy hand on his shoulder.
“ Thorin!”
Thorin’s fist was already flying by the time he opened his eyes and it was only quick reflexes that saved the intruder from a black eye. Thorin’s chest heaved and he blinked hard to clear the dream.
He was sitting up in his own bed, the one in Erebor that was too big and too soft. His throat ached and the scars across his chest throbbed. Dwalin stood beside the bed, one large hand around Thorin’s fist where he’d caught it in the knick of time.
Dwalin. Thorin’s heart leapt in his throat and he fell back against his thousand pillows and pressed the heels of his palms over his eyes. He wondered if Dís had finally made good on her threat to summon the sons of Fundin or if his traitorous guards had been the ones to summon him. The guilt of it welled in Thorin’s throat so suddenly that he felt as though he might choke on it.
“Apologies,” he said gruffly, still breathing harder than he’d like. Dwalin just grunted and slowly released Thorin’s fist.
Thorin pulled his hands away from his face to look Dwalin over. At first glance, he appeared battle-ready as ever, but Thorin knew him too well for that. His hair was frazzled from sleep and Thorin could see the collar of his nightshirt askew beneath his pauldrons.
“I woke you.” Thorin swallowed. “I apologize. They needn’t have summoned you.”
Dwalin gave another incredulous grunt, his disbelief transcending the need for words. Eloquent , Thorin thought with equal parts fondness and bitterness. He didn’t seem to have trouble finding words when he told me off before the Battle. Not that they’d spoken of the incident since.
“I’m certain you’ve better things to do than coddling me. Sleeping for one.” Thorin continued. His heart still pounded against his chest, the self-loathing wrapping its claws around him as it so often did. “It’s a wonder that you came at all, considering.”
“It’s a wonder that your memory is so bad, y’daft ninny, ” Dwalin barked, startling Thorin out of his downward spiral.
“My- memory?” Thorin echoed in utter bewilderment. Was there something else he’d done to Dwalin that he had no memory of? Something he’d done in the throes of madness that was even worse than threatening Dwalin’s life?
“Aye.” Dwalin grunted. “Typical Durin. So busy being majestically tormented that you forget to use what little you were gifted between the ears.”
“I’m sure I don’t know what you mean,” Thorin said stiffly, only this time he truly did not.
“You fool,” Dwalin huffed, punctuating the words with a sharp prod of a finger to Thorin’s forehead. “You’re not mad. You’re Battle Fatigued.”
“I am not-“ Thorin began to protest only for Dwalin to flick him sharply and talk right over him.
“Yes, you are. Even if I didn’t have a touch of it m’self, I’d know it. I’ve seen you with it before, you old coot.”
“What?”
“ Memory, ” Dwalin growled again. “Have you completely forgotten how it was after Azanulbizar?”
Thorin fell silent as he tried to process Dwalin’s words. The truth was that Thorin’s recollection of the direct aftermath of that battle was fragmented. Kingship had been thrust on him so suddenly and there had been a thousand things that needed his attention that instant. Including offering what meager comfort he could to the sons of Fundin for the fall of their father.
“Y’woke up screaming for a year afterward,” Dwalin told him. “Unless you had Dís with you. I know of what I speak, Thorin.”
At Dwalin’s words, Thorin finally caught a fragment of forgotten memory. He had dreamt of the battle afterward. He had not been able to keep from fixating on what he might have done differently. He’d defeated Azog that day, but it wasn’t enough. He should have been able to stop Azog from killing Thror. He should have kept track of his father. He should have been by Frerin’s side. If he’d been a better grandson, son, brother- perhaps one of them might still be with them.
“That was-“ Thorin began but Dwalin spoke over him again.
“If you say ‘different,’ I’m going to crack your skull,” Dwalin warned. He caught and held Thorin’s gaze for a long moment before he deflated slowly.
“Do you think you are the only dwarf I’ve seen it in? Do you think it did not affect Balin and I after that?” Dwalin asked. “It is known. You needn’t have an ax in your skull for Battle Fatigue to set in.”
Thorin couldn’t think of a single thing to say in response. Dwalin knew him too well; his next retort was going to be that others, like Bifur, had it far worse. Thwarted, Thorin could only gape like a fish.
“Durin’s beard, you did the same damned thing with your father, did you know that? Not letting him be listed among the honored dead, sending out the ravens… I’m not saying you’re wrong to grieve like that, but don’t tell me it’s some “new madness.” I can tell ore from slag.”
Dwalin finished his rant with a scowl that made his mustache twitch. Thorin wished desperately that Dwalin wasn’t right, but of course he was. Thorin knew that he spoke the truth, it was only that Thorin had never thought to make the connection before.
“Thank you,” he said softly. Dwalin shrugged his shoulders, suddenly awkward in the face of Thorin’s sincerity.
“It’s what I’m here for,” he grunted. “Now, tell me what had you screaming your head off.”
Thorin opened his mouth, ready to refuse, but Dwalin cracked his knuckles. Thorin relented. “The ring. I cannot help but wonder how it was separated from Bilbo.”
Dwalin made another wordless noise, thinking it over. Thorin appreciated that he didn’t jump straight into empty platitudes. He’d missed his friend terribly in the time he’d been avoiding him.
“Whatever the case, I don’t think you’ll have to wait another fifty years to find out,” Dwalin said after some thought. “Nori’s too sneaky for his own good and Yuna seems sharp as an axe. Even if you’re too thick-headed to figure it out, those two will dig up some answers.”
It wasn’t much comfort given the circumstances and Thorin couldn’t think of how to respond. Then Dwalin smirked, slow and sharp.
“And when we find the culprit, I’d be honored to hold him down while you find out exactly what you need to know.”
Thorin let out a sharp breath that might have been a laugh if it weren’t so relieved. “I thought you’d be telling me to reign in my temper.”
“ Me? ” Dwalin scoffed derisively, but even this slipped away quickly, leaving only the sad sort of smirk in its wake. “He mightn’t have been any of our Ones, Thorin, but he was our friend. We would see justice. And if not justice, I’ll settle for vengeance.”
The following day, Thorin’s silver bead - the same he’d given Bilbo in Laketown - appeared stuffed inside a sticky bun.
Thorin did not bother raiding the kitchens this time. For once, as he stormed from the dining room, his kin followed without trying to sway him from his current path. If he’d had the space to think about it, Thorin might have felt vindicated to have them on his side. As it stood, Thorin’s nerves were howling too loudly to think anything beyond screaming with equal parts fury and dread.
“Someone get me Nori, now!” He roared. His hand was sticky where it clutched the bead, though he hardly noticed. “Dwalin, muster the guard! Balin, close the gates, no one leaves this damned mountain!”
“I’ll alert the Blacklocks,” Fíli said, dragging his brother with him. It was quick thinking that Thorin ought to have praised.
His kin scattered to obey his commands and Thorin himself stormed back to his chambers. He’d grown complacent the past two years. He’d fallen out of the habit of carrying his sword. He needed Deathless in his hand for whatever came next.
In his rooms, Thorin cast aside most of his layers, dropping his crown atop the crumpled pile. He would be ready to give chase if the occasion arose. Whatever sick game someone played, it would end today, he swore it.
With his sword at his hip, Thorin stormed to the council room. Dís met him there though, wisely, she did not attempt to speak to him. Thorin paced, the bead still clenched in his fist.
He could find excuses for the ring, but the bead… His dream of scavengers pulling the treasures from Bilbo’s lifeless body flashed before his eyes. Was that how it had happened? No, Thorin couldn’t believe it. The bead was so small and Bilbo’s hair hadn’t been long enough to braid. If he had the bead with him during or after the battle, then it would have been stored in a pocket or pouch. Somewhere too concealed for a scavenger to pick off coincidentally.
But then how? A dozen scenarios flashed through Thorin’s mind. Bilbo had never made it home. If he’d survived the battle, he would have tried to return to the west, wouldn’t he? What if he approached a dwarf for help, trying to use the ring as collateral, and it turned out to have been one of Thorin’s enemies? Someone who lulled Bilbo into revealing the bead, revealing that he was even more precious to Thorin than the ring already implied? Or perhaps he’d been detained in Mirkwood. Thorin had barely spoken to Thranduil since the battle. He did not know if the Elven King knew that Bilbo was responsible for their escape or how petty he might be in taking his revenge for the embarrassment. The few surviving orcs from the battle surely weren’t clever enough to piece together Bilbo’s importance from such paltry evidence if he had somehow fallen into their hands, right? And this approach was far too subtle for orcs - they’d be more likely to send Thorin the ring with a severed finger still in it, not slip it into his tea.
What if whoever took the relics still had Bilbo? What if he lived ? Thorin could hardly stand to even contemplate the idea. The hope was too painful to bear.
The door to the council room opened but it was not Nori. It was one of Yuna’s handmaidens. Thorin couldn’t remember her name. All of Yuna’s maidens dressed identically.
“ What? ” Thorin snapped, not bothering to soften his tone. The handmaiden didn’t startle. She just bowed low to Thorin.
“Your majesty, my lady sends an urgent message.” She said without raising her head.
“Later.” Thorin barked.
“It is with regards to her investigation, my lord,” the handmaiden insisted. Dís beckoned her into the room and bade her to speak before Thorin could cut her off again. The handmaiden straightened and addressed her words to Dís, though Thorin could hear her quite plainly.
“She discovered that the suspect is employed in the kitchens. She has made an arrest. She has detained the suspect in her quarters and awaits your reply.”
Thorin’s stomach flipped. All the evidence against Baldor that they’d already gathered and now the identity he’d been so keen to keep secret was revealed as having connections to the kitchens? After Thorin had been finding relics of his lost One in his food? There was no coincidence there.
“Stay here,” Thorin told Dís when she stepped forward. “Inform the others where I’ve gone when they arrive.”
Thorin knew roughly where the Orocarni delegation was being housed and the handmaiden led him to Yuna’s suites without another word passing between them, which was just as well.
Thorin’s rage was like a blade lodged in his chest (and he should know, having been stabbed there before). He wasn’t sure who he was more angry with: himself or Baldor. To think that he’d been trying to absolve Baldor of suspicion just last night. Baldor had very nearly gotten away with whatever scheme he was a part of and it would have been Thorin’s fault if he’d succeeded.
Thorin’s mind buzzed, trying to comprehend why Baldor would do such a thing. He was still young. Even if fortune had dealt him a poor hand, he had decades to improve his lot in life. Thorin could have helped him, if he’d only asked. Somehow, Thorin doubted that gold was Baldor’s aim. Surely he would have put greater care into his appearance if he cared so much about riches. Revenge then? For whoever Baldor had shorn his hair for? Or plain old power? But how could he possibly gain power from terrorizing Thorin over mealtimes?
Yuna greeted him with only a curt nod when they arrived.
“Where is he?” Thorin growled. Yuna led him to a chamber with four guards posted by the door. They stepped aside when Yuna made a small gesture and she pulled a key from the folds of her skirts. She fitted it to the lock, pushed open the door. And gasped. Thorin had never heard anything like it from her and he moved past her into the room without waiting.
The room was empty. It was furnished simply in the Orocarni’s preferred style. The furniture was built low to the ground with no space to conceal a dwarf beneath. Neither was there any sort of wardrobe or chest for anyone to hide in.
“My king-” Yuna said, still sounding a little breathless. “I swear to you, I had him in custody. I do not understand. The guards have not left their posts and I hold the only key to that room. There are no other doors or windows.”
“Spread out,” Thorin barked at the guards, though they were not his to command. “Find him. I want him alive. ”
The guards glanced at Yuna for approval before rushing to obey.
“Thorin,” Yuna said, her composure shaken even as she tried to pull it back into place. “I am sorry. He truly was here. And I would never aid his escape, I swear it.”
“I know,” He said shortly. He did not doubt her loyalty, but he could not spare time to assure her of as much. They had a rat to catch.
Dwalin joined him wordlessly in the street and soon the neighborhood was flooded with guards. Thorin ran among them. Even knowing that his presence did little to aid the search, Thorin could not have sat idly by.
Time seemed to shrink and stretch, each breath lasting a lifetime even as Thorin blinked, finding himself running down a different corridor each time he reopened his eyes. He did not know how long he chased after the imposter before a shout of triumph sounded nearby and Thorin turned to storm in the direction of the sound.
“Baldor '' would rue the day he stepped foot in Thorin’s mountain. He would know the consequences of betraying Thorin’s trust but, most of all, he would learn what happened to those who threatened his luzun lansel.
"Where is he?" he roared, barely recognizing his own voice. "I want to watch his face when I pluck his fingers off like berries off a bush! I want his beard mounted above my throne!"
He pushed through the crowd of soldiers when they did not part quickly enough, Deathless still unsheathed in one hand. Baldor hung between the two guards that held him. He was stripped to his shirt sleeves and positively covered in ash and soot. There were shiny pink burns scattered across his hands and face. Well, it explained how Baldor had escaped Yuna’s quarters.
Baldor did not even look up at him and somehow that only fueled Thorin’s rage. How dare he play at being so pathetic after he’d proved himself capable of such treachery? If he thought to gain Thorin’s sympathy with the act, then he was sorely mistaken.
"You!" Thorin growled, watching the prisoner flinch. Good. Let him fear. "You will tell me how you came by this. If you lie to me again, I shall have you disemboweled while you live and make you watch as I feed your entrails to the ravens."
Thorin thrust forward the silver bead, shoving it so close to Baldor’s face that he could feel Baldor’s panting breaths against his fingertips. Even now, Thorin could not bring himself to look directly into Baldor’s face. If he looked and was reminded once more of Bilbo, he would lose his resolve. He couldn’t bear the thought of shouting threats such as these at Bilbo again, not even someone who resembled him.
And yet Baldor remained silent, defeated in the guards’ hold.
"Speak!" Thorin demanded, his patience snapping. Finally, Baldor opened his mouth.
To his shock and mounting fury, the prisoner began to laugh. The sound pierced Thorin like a blade, familiar yet impossible. He felt his face flush hot with rage and confusion.
"You think this funny? I shall rip your beard from your chin!" Thorin cried.
"You might not have to," someone said, “Look.”
Thorin finally let his eyes settle on Baldor’s face. Something strange was happening to the manic dwarf. His face was- melting? No, that was absurd, it was only his beard. Thorin’s vision tunneled until all he could see was Baldor’s hysterical face as his beard began to fall away from his chin. Thorin’s heart stopped. Deathless dropped to the ground with a clang.
"I... I know your face." The words escaped him in a whisper.
"You had better, you daft dwarf."
Thorin’s hand shook as he lifted his hands to Baldor’s- to Bilbo’s face, gently peeling away the false beard that still clung to his jaw. Baldor did not merely resemble Bilbo. Thorin could not have looked away if he tried. He feared to blink, lest the illusion shatter. Thorin's fingers hovered over Bilbo's cheek, craving the warmth of his skin to believe this wasn't another cruel dream, yet terrified to wake if it was.
"You are here. In Erebor." He breathed.
"As though I'd be anywhere else," Bilbo said simply, and Thorin's heart clenched.
"Your kin thought you dead when we wrote them," Thorin managed, his voice cracking. He watched in bewilderment as Bilbo chuckled again.
"You wrote to the Shire after me?" Thorin could only nod, still staring at Bilbo as if he might vanish at any moment. Bilbo’s only response was to shake his head, his shoulders still shaking with mirth. With his beloved in front of him, Thorin thought he should feel joy or at least relief, but somehow he felt as though his heart was breaking anew.
"You've been here this whole time," Thorin’s voice cracked on the words like brittle shale. Years of screaming himself awake at night, of tears and terror and regret and helplessness, all seemed to bear down on him at once. Bilbo seemed well. Had he been laughing this entire time? Seeing how Thorin needlessly tormented himself? "How could you do that to me, lansel ? For two and a half years, I thought- I thought-?"
"Did you think me dead?" Bilbo asked softly.
"I did not know what to think," Thorin replied, pulling away sharply. "We could find no trace of you after the battle, and your kin told us you had perished. There was nothing. No evidence that you had fled the battle or stayed. No..."
He trailed off, unable to voice the horrors his imagination had conjured in Bilbo's absence. Thorin took another step back.
"Never mind," he said at last. He wished suddenly that he had worn his crown. Its weight was a burden, but a grounding one. It made it easier to discard Thorin Oakenshield in favor of becoming King Thorin. "It doesn't matter now. Guards, see to it that he is given a suite in our wing and that our people know that he is to be cared for appropriately."
