Actions

Work Header

Strange Alloys

Chapter 3: The Road to the Fey King

Chapter Text

The days passed slowly on the road, especially at the beginning when the hills and woods all looked the same after the first hour of trees and more trees. Then when Bilbo lay down to sleep, the time would pass too quickly, and soon enough he would be woken by the sun and the sound of Gandalf humming as he fed and tended the mounts. But in between, there was breakfast time and supper and when he could, Bilbo cooked up a second supper at dusk, and that meant there was time to sit and enjoy each other’s company. Gandalf was as good-humoured and full of interesting songs and stories as Bilbo remembered from his childhood in the Shire. These days Bilbo had plenty of stories of his own, of course, and was not afraid to boast, especially in front of a client.

Thorin seemed content to let them parry and posture. After that first long tale in the office, and the brief mention of his family on the first day, he mentioned little of himself or his home. He would sometimes speak in a voice of wonder about his journey to and from the Blue Mountains. But he seemed somewhat apart from Bilbo and Gandalf, as if his thoughts were only ever half in their current location, wherever that happened to be.

At the beginning, Bilbo had asked him about the City and his life there, but his answers were short and factual, the sort of thing you might read in a book. Perhaps a civil engineer’s guide, even. This was particularly frustrating for Bilbo, whose trade was at least half in the stories he could learn from people, and what they revealed about the ways into a place - both in the form of secret tunnels but also gaps in the social boundaries; who might accept a bribe, who was allied with who, who could be played off each other with subtle jibes. Thorin’s plan seemed to be to focus on the Lonely Mountain as Bilbo’s first point of call, but Bilbo was very determined that it would be his last stop in solving his client’s mysteries. He did not plan to enter the mountain if the dragon could be studied from a distance instead. But trying to get any interesting information out of Thorin seemed as productive as trying to squeeze gold out of a rock with his bare hands.

They had passed through the Trollshaws without incident and in the distance, the misty mountains were rising above their faces, growing closer each day. Gandalf and Thorin seemed to have decided on a route together and Bilbo could only trust their confidence.

As the road grew rougher, Thorin kept himself remarkably clean and tidy, combing and rebraiding his hair each morning and trimming his beard almost daily, using a small polished glass and scissors wrapped together in a small leather wallet. One morning, they camped close to a small, clear stream. While he ate breakfast, Bilbo was able to watch Thorin’s morning rituals without looking like he was spying.

“You said your grandfather was the King Under the Mountain,” Bilbo said, as Thorin put his mirror away. “Is that why it’s so important that you… well, how do I put it? That you look your best, even though we’re in the middle of nowhere and Gandalf and I are covered in road dust?”

Thorin had just washed his hands off in the stream and he shook the drops off as he stood up. He didn’t answer for a moment, and Bilbo wondered if he was offended, but it seemed he was just thinking because he said at last, “No. It must be something about the Woodland City that has driven it into me, like a fencepost. Everything there is about maintaining the mask. But no, in Erebor I had servants to dress me, even when I was plenty old enough to dress myself,” he gave a bright, deep laugh like it was an unthinkable idea now. “Many of the older dwarves I know can plait their hair and beards into forms as elaborate as lace, but do you know, I never learned more than the simplest braids? I always had someone else to do them for me. That’s what I get for being born with a silver hammer in my hand.”

It was more than he’d said on any personal topic since their journey had begun some weeks earlier. Bilbo thought about his sudden loquaciousness all that morning, and he came to the realisation like a slow but inevitable turn of a clock: it was because Thorin had started talking about Erebor. A time before the dragon came, before the City even existed. As they took the ponies up a winding sheep-path through the foothills, he asked Thorin. “So, when you lived in the mountain, did you actually live in the mountain, or did you have nice holes like us hobbits, and just dig up gems there?”

“Holes!” Thorin cried, and for a moment Bilbo thought his jibe had gone too far, but then the dwarf grinned at him. “No offense to whatever you call a ‘nice hole’ Mr Baggins, but Erebor was far more than a gem-mine. I wager the front hall alone would be large enough for all of Bree to squeeze inside. Beyond that lay a city of a thousand homes, streets of the finest workshops in the dwarven world, and above it all the great palace built by my grandfather, every angle of its columns and lintels as beautiful and precise as the movements of the stars. The Woodland City is large, but it is an overgrown back-garden compared to the beauties of Erebor.”

He went on like this for not a short while. It was more than he’d said in one go since the entire journey had started.

Bilbo felt extremely self-satisfied that he had finally cracked this small but tricky puzzle. In between his lyrical musings on childhood memories of his grandfather and all the kings and courtiers who had come to visit them and see the wonders of the Mountain, Bilbo gleaned quite a lot about not just Erebor, but Thorin’s life in the Woodland realm since the dragon came. Reading between the lines, it sounded like something of a tinderbox sitting inside the veneer of a utopia. And there was more to learn, he was sure, that Thorin was not telling.

–

They crossed a pass through the Misty Mountains in good weather, mostly having to walk uphill for two days, leading the ponies, as the path was too narrow and rough to ride. At last they reached the apex of the pass. There, a wide saddle of wind-blown, green-grey tussock made a nice pasture for the ponies, and they were able to sit down low out of the wind and have some lunch. Nearby was a brown tarn of brackish snow-melt that buzzed with dragonflies. Though Gandalf insisted this was the highest point of their journey, it looked to Bilbo like the mountains ahead still went on forever in every direction that he looked.

“Is this the way you and my mother went, on her great adventure?” Bilbo asked Gandalf.

Gandalf chuckled. “Oh, we never made it so far. We were caught by goblins halfway up the mountain, with our companions, and through various turns of luck both ill and good, Bella and I made it through their tunnels to the far side and came out further north, near what they called the Carrock.”

“Companions?” Bilbo sat up a little. “It wasn’t just the two of you?”

“No, there were five of us.”

“Well, who were the others? What happened to them? Mother never mentioned anyone except for you.”

Gandalf was quiet for a moment, then he said. “Their luck was all ill and no good. They never made it out of those tunnels.” Gandalf tapped at his pipe, which seemed to have gone out due to the wind. “Bella and I went on together for a year, to give the news to their kin and return by the far south through the Gap of Rohan. We got ourselves into many more scrapes along the way, and often getting out of them only by Bella’s quick thinking and light footsteps. I think your mother might have gone on adventuring for the rest of her days, but the loss of our companions in these mountains was a wound that never really healed. She was always looking for someone, someone who she could only see in her imagination after that, and in the end I suppose she went back to the Shire to find them. And a good thing for you, or she’d never have met your father!”

Bilbo took a moment to process this. Although Bella had told him various fairytales, woven into the barest hints of her time outside the Shire, she had never given him the full picture nor written any of it down. It was lost with her when she passed, and part of him felt a little like he was betraying her by letting Gandalf reveal her secrets. At last he said, “I don’t think my father was her great love story, though they got along well enough.”

“She seemed very happy, when I visited,” Gandalf said.

“She was happy to see you, you daft old wizard,” Bilbo laughed. “But I do wonder if she married my father in the hopes that her children would turn out more like him than like her. Homebodies in Hobbiton.”

“Ah, a fool’s errand, trying to shape young ones,” Gandalf said. He’d got the pipe alight now and tried to blow a smoke ring, but the wind tossed it away into nothing before it had even formed.

They still had to walk and lead the ponies, but now at least the way was mostly downhill. At last, the peaks parted and into view came the flatlands east of the mountains and beyond that, a great, dark fur of woodland that seemed to go on and on forever like an ocean.

As their path converged with a more visible, well-kept road that led east, Gandalf made the sudden announcement that he would be leaving them. Bilbo attempted a weak protest, though he knew he had no say in the matter.

“I always said I would keep you company while we were heading in the same direction, but now my business is to the north.” He glanced at Thorin. “Are you still planning to take the Old Forest Road? You are not in a hurry, as your dragon is either alive or dead and a few weeks won’t change that. You could still make your way south, take the Woodmen’s paths through the narrow forest neck and find passage on a boat up the Celduin.”

“I don’t fancy spending winter out of doors. The Old Road has been kept clear and passable by all accounts,” Thorin said. “And I’ve never heard of spiders setting their ambushes directly on the road.”

“I was not worried about spiders,” Gandalf narrowed his eyes. “The Woodland Traders were thick on that road last time I went that way, along with the City’s Guard. Do you think none of them will know your face?”

Thorin shrugged. “I’ll keep my hood up when we meet company. Besides, Mr Baggins will do the talking, won’t you?” He slapped Bilbo on the back, almost knocking him over.

Bilbo recovered his breath and nodded. “I’ll play the part of the eccentric Hobbit tourist, travelling with my brooding dwarvish bodyguard. No one will look twice at Thorin.”

Gandalf laughed. “A part you were born to play.”

“Watch that cheek, it’ll get you into trouble one day,” Bilbo held out his hand. “May we meet again soon, Gandalf.”

Gandalf shook his hand and climbed back onto his fine horse with far too much grace for the form of an old man.

“Farewell. And do let me know what you find. I would very much like to know what has become of Smaug the terrible,” Gandalf said, turning his horse. “Farewell again!”

Thorin and Bilbo watched him canter off across the grassland, and then mounted their own ponies and headed towards the distant forest. It was hidden by the foothills now, but Thorin seemed confident about their direction.

“So, perhaps I should have asked earlier, how are we actually planning to get into the mountain?” Bilbo asked. “I’m assuming we can’t knock on the front door.”

“I believe there is another way in.”

“A secret tunnel?” Bilbo asked. “I like the sound of that.”

“That’s the plan. My father told us about it, before he left the Woodland,” Thorin glanced around as if to make absolutely sure there were no spy in the empty grasslands. “This was after the disastrous attempt to retake Moria, and Thranduil’s backlash against weapons within the city. My father was trying to find a way to restore the dwarves to strength as he saw it, and he thought reclaiming Erebor was one way to do that. He showed us a map and a key that my grandfather had given to him, which Thror had used to escape the dragon’s wrath the day he destroyed our home. My father planned to leave the map with us, and go to the mountain with the key to see if the secret entrance was still open and if the way was safe. But he left that night without even a farewell, and we never saw him again.”

“So you have the map?” Bilbo asked.

Thorin shook his head. “We had something of a disagreement before he left. In the end, he took it with him. Perhaps he feared the risk if someone outside our family discovered it. Perhaps he…” Thorin’s head sank a little. “Perhaps he did not trust me with it. He knew that Thranduil held me in his confidence, in those days. My father may have believed I would betray our people and hand Thranduil the secrets to our home and our riches. Who knows? It was a difficult time for all of us. He had lost a father and a son, and the burden of kingship weighed heavy on him. Even moreso because we had no kingdom.”

“So he passed the burden to you,” Bilbo said softly. “Though you’d lost just as much.”

“I didn’t know his mind, at the end,” Thorin said. “I went looking for him, after I exiled myself, but no one had news of him. Perhaps he found the secret door. Perhaps he didn’t. But it does exist,” Thorin looked at Bilbo. “And I memorised that map well enough. We’ll find it, and if my father has gone ahead of us and opened the door, then maybe you’ll have a chance to earn your fee, Mister Baggins.”

–

Thorin had been quiet as he listened to Bilbo and Gandalf banter about Bilbo’s mother during their lunch. He tried to remember what it was to be so young you could still be easily shaped by the world. Before Smaug came to the mountain, he supposed, and the fire set him hard, glazed his colours, like clay in a kiln.

He had made his first visit to the Woodland perhaps four or five years before Erebor fell. A diplomatic trip, with a mind to further contracts for gem-setting and metalworking. Balin was supposed to be the king’s representative on the trip, but right at the final hour he had gotten sick, and Thorin had asked his grandfather if he could take Balin’s place. His first chance to be a prince beyond the boundaries of Thror’s realm. The first time Thror really put his trust in him.

Thror agreed. Thorin could see Dwalin was outrageously jealous, as he’d been sure he’d be picked; but Dwalin was not a diplomat, even then. Balin had been too indisposed to give Thorin any guidance, but Oin was part of the group, and as they rode out of the mountain he’d leaned over and said quietly. “Watch yourself. The wood elves aren’t like those delicate folks from the West that came through here last winter. They look skinny and pretty, but they’re wild once there’s food and wine on the table.”

Thorin could not imagine any creature that could out-drink Oin, so he was sure this was merely an exaggerated warning that he should not embarrass himself on his first serious outing from the Mountain.

The Woodland was as different from home as a trip to the bottom of the ocean. Though there was a great palace surrounded by a hodgepodge of rough halls and treetop homes, Thorin was told that these were only used during bad weather or the extremely rare incursion of enemies into the forest. Although it was mid autumn, nothing was indoors, not the summit or the private meetings with the trade ministers. Even their guest quarters were temporary structures of wicker and woven creepers and grasses, built from the detritus of the clearing season, for the elves explained that they wasted nothing if a use could be found for it. Besides, there was no way to get rid of waste except by burning, which they abhorred.

The elves spoke in a mix of languages, all the time, thoughtlessly and - it seemed to Thorin, when he could understand them, for his Sindarin was very basic - often rather mockingly. But he soon realised they spoke to each other like that as well as to the dwarves, even elves who seemed to be dear friends. They even spoke up teasingly to their elders. There did not seem to be much of a social hierarchy, or if there was, it was not much respected.

The boring parts of the trip had gone well, and Oin had slapped him on the back as they headed to their ‘bedrooms’ to refresh themselves before the feast. “I will tell your grandfather how you spoke well, my prince,” he beamed at Thorin. “Now we can let ourselves relax a little.”

The festivities, like everything else, were outside. They were held in a huge clearing surrounded by towering trees, strung with lights of many colours. The air was filled with some kind of dark-winged moth that clustered around the lights and whose huge wings cast shadows across the tables and guests, enhancing the sense that they were feasting on the bed of a rushing river. Music filled the air, not from a corralled orchestra up on a balcony, as it would be at a dwarven feast. Instead, individual musicians roamed around the clearing space, so that even when sitting still Thorin found himself treated to first a rather saucy love song, than a tragic crooning battle hymn, then a jaunty jig, all before he’d finished his first course.

The party of dwarven envoys had been seated at a low table near the centre of the gathering, and were attended by what Thorin guessed were the most mild-mannered and polite of the Woodland diplomats and servants. Thorin tried to nurse his flagon and listen more than he spoke. But at some point the king’s golden son, Legolas, appeared at his elbow and said, “Come to our table, Prince Thorin, go on. Leave your elders and betters.”

Thorin glanced quickly at Oin, who raised his eyebrows at him as he took a deep draught of his flagon. Thorin felt like it would be rude to refuse, but he was determined to keep both his head and his manners. He let Legolas lead him to the high table, though it was distinguished from those around it only by the particular density of wood elves dancing and singing nearby. The king sat on a chair no larger than his subjects, dressed in flowing silver and crowned in autumn leaves. Thorin bowed to him, and did his best to give a formal introduction of himself, and speak honour towards his host. Thranduil stood and poured wine and served it to Thorin, asking him to join for the evening. So of course, he couldn’t refuse to drink.

He’d been so young that night: old enough to be a captain in his grandfather’s guard but not technically of age, not old enough to marry. He was giddy with the foreignness of it all. And as the evening wore on, he found the wood elves were so much fun. He never went back to the dwarven envoy.

He spent the night at the king’s table, and later, dancing in the woods as the party spread into the forest like a splash of wine on cloth. Somewhere among the colourful lights and the laughing elves, he remembered sitting in the grass and talking to their king, answering question after question about wine, and music, and beards, and boots, and politics, and about the differences between the wood and the mountain, and why art was beautiful in one place but would look ugly on the walls of a different home; the sort of things you talk about lying in the grass, drunk, with a king - or so Thorin assumed. He couldn’t remember if at the time, he’d thought this was just how all diplomatic missions were supposed to go. He didn’t remember at what point he left the gathering. He awoke in his own bed in the wicker-and-grass guesthouse with the worst headache of his life.

He went back to Erebor, and if the object of the mission had been to cement friendship between their kingdoms, it seemed to have been a great success. Twice, Thranduil came himself to see the halls under the Lonely Mountain, and two or three times, Thorin and an entourage were sent back to foster the Woodland’s acquaintance into a true alliance with signed treaties and royal gifts exchanged to symbolise their union. And later, he was able to smooth over the spat over the necklace of white gems. Thror’s sickness was already creeping through his mind in those days, and it might have gotten very ugly, but Thorin spent hours talking him around.

“We may need the elves,” Thorin told his grandfather. “We cannot throw away their friendship because of a petty argument over an invoice.”

“Why would we need them?” Thror growled. “The world is at peace. And if it were not, nothing can harm us, behind these walls. Why would we need a gaggle of prancing twig-fondlers who can’t build a wall straight or lift a war-hammer to save themselves?”

“Did you build Erebor alone?” Thorin replied. “Did you carve every tunnel with your own hands, set each stone in each mosaic from your own design? None of us creates good things alone, grandfather.”

In the end, Thror relented, and gave Thranduil the gems he wanted for the agreed price. And when the dragon came, Thorin wanted to believe that Thranduil would have helped them and welcomed them no matter what. But it was true to say that when the refugees arrived in the Woodland and Thranduil arranged the first council of two kings, he listened to Thror, and he listened to Thrain, all without comment, and then he turned and said, “And Prince Thorin, what do you think?”

There was no doubt that he saw Thorin as more reasonable than his grandfather, and that he wanted Thror to know it.

As it became clear that the mountain would not easily be reclaimed, and that they would rely on the elves for their survival, no one had complained about the influence Thorin had with Thranduil. It was seen only as an advantage in those days. Thror and Thrain used Thorin’s friendship with the king to their own ends. They would act bullish and stubborn in any negotiations, and then send Thorin in afterwards, or simply stand back and let him step into the conversation right there in the room, to walk the middle ground that their pride would not let them tread on. Though the dwarves called Thror their king, even the oldest folks checked with Thorin before they made any petition to Thranduil, and asked him first to advise before any dealings with the elves, and went to him if they had grievances. He was the power behind his grandfather’s diminished throne, and they all knew it.

So it went for years, and years, the hard years and the difficult years as the City laboured to be born out of conflict and destitution.

After his grandfather died, after weapons were forbidden in the City, Thrain was named King Under the Mountain by the remnants of the Erebor council. But the elves did not use the title, and Thranduil did not acknowledge it in his court. That was when Thrain began to talk to Thorin and Dis about reclaiming the Mountain. Thorin tried to discourage him; to go in there alone was a vanity, a wasted and suicidal attempt at glory. But Thrain would not be dissuaded.

“I’m not ready to lead our people without you,” Thorin begged him. They sat in front of the fire in a home more humble than the simplest artisan in Erebor had owned. He reached out, across the table where the map of the secret door lay, and touched his father’s hand. “If you won’t stay for me, stay for Dis. She’s still a child.”

“Maybe I should stay for Dis,” Thrain said bitterly. “Maybe I should stay until her naming ceremony, and then declare Dis my heir when I leave. She would be a good queen.”

Thorin withdrew his hand sharply. “What have I done to offend you, father?”

Thrain looked at him with his scarred, single-eyed gaze. “I love you, my son. But your proclivities with the elven king are a danger to all of us.”

“What are you talking about?” Thorin snarled. “I have never acted against you. I have never so much as spoken a word in his presence without thinking first of the welfare of our people.”

Thrain nodded. “I know. Yet still you believe you can bend him to your will, with sweet words, by wearing the clothes he offers like courting gifts, by giving him your companionship at his feasts. He has always been the one holding the reins, Thorin. You will see that soon.”

“Your prejudices blind you,” Thorin countered. “We are allies, nothing more. We are already laying the foundations for a kingdom greater than the sum of our two realms. For our children, and their children.”

“Your children?” Thrain asked. “You know you will have no children, my dear son. I care not, your grandfather cared not. But do not, in your barrenness, in your kingly beneficence, lay claim to all of Erebor’s children and give their care over to Thranduil. He will never love them as I love you and Dis, as I loved your brother.”

The next morning, Thrain had gone, and so had the map and the key.