Actions

Work Header

Strange Alloys

Chapter 5: Stargazers

Chapter Text

In the cell deep beneath the royal palace, Kili thought back on that moment on the archery range when Legolas had shaken his hand and welcomed him to the Guard. He wondered if he had ever been so happy, and if somehow his hubris had been the cause of all the grief that followed. Six months after that day at the archery range, Thorin had been accused of theft, and disappeared before a trial could sentence him to banishment.

He never got a proper conversation with Thorin before he left. Thorin left no note for Kili, nothing to promise he still felt the pride he’d shown that day. The night he must have been preparing to flee, Kili had walked in on Thorin and Fili in some quiet conversation, but they’d gone silent as he opened the door. And Fili never told him what that last conversation was about, even though Kili told him everything, everything, he even told him about Tauriel before he had told Tauriel herself. When Kili asked, Fili just said “It was nothing,” but Kili knew he was lying.

Kili understood now that it wasn’t that they didn’t love him or trust him, but that they were trying to protect him. In making himself a model citizen and warrior of the Guard, he had also made himself a target. He had to be above suspicion in all things.

But he hadn’t figured that out until it was too late.

His mother had been the one to step in and stop him, but she was too late as well. He had been in the Guard for two years by then. He had kept up with the other recruits, he had made friends, he had killed spiders, everything that was expected of him and which as his uncle had been hoped would prove him worthy. Dwarves recognised him on the street, even without his uniform, and wanted to talk to him, tell him that they, or their son, was thinking of applying at the next call for recruits. And as he’d hoped at the beginning, the dams had taken notice too. He was never short on drinks at the pub, or conversation from pretty dwarves who’d added a little gold powder to their brows for the night out; dams, dwarrows, everybody wanted a smile and a chat.

But he’d made one stupid mistake. He’d gotten arrogant in the worst possible way. With all those choices laid out before him, he’d fallen in love with the absolute worst person he could have found, for more reasons than he could count: his superior officer, a personal friend of Commander Legolas, and an elf.

When he was at home the second summer after he joined the Guard, he lay on the deck under the distant stars, smoking a pipe with Fili. “I’m in love with Captain Tauriel,” he said dreamily. Two years he had been training under lieutenant Fainthel, who reported directly to Captain Tauriel, so he had had plenty of time to think about Tauriel as she walked around calling the recruits to order and barking at her lieutenants. The surety of his statement was beyond doubt in his own mind.

Fili gave such a sudden burst of laughter he nearly shoved his pipe stem up his nose. “Did you fall out of a tree and crack your skull?”

“No,” Kili murmured. “And she’s in love with me too. I haven’t asked her, obviously, but I can sense it. We have a connection.”

“By all that’s green, you are an idiot,” Fili laughed. “Just keep quiet about it. Find someone nice round this neighborhood to bury your fever in. This will pass.”

But it didn’t pass, and unfortunately for Kili, he was right. She felt the same. And for a few brief and blissful months that summer and into autumn they had carried on in secret, meeting in the forest or in deep halls beneath the roots of the City, where the water of the underground forest river covered the sound of their voices. They were both trained Guards; they knew how to keep a straight face, how to hide when they needed to and bluff their way out of suspicious questions. Maybe some suspected, but no one knew - except Fili, and he would never tell. But there was one person Kili couldn’t fool forever.

Dis was incandescent when she figured it out. Thorin had been gone for more than two years, and she had been steadily rebuilding their family’s reputation, crafting herself as the legitimate heir to Thror’s rule of their people. She had picked up so much that Thorin had left off, abandoning her business to focus on mediating dwarvish spats, raising funds for libraries and repairs to the temple roof, holding community meetings and bringing their petitions to royal councils. Kili was supposed to be part of her propaganda campaign, a proof to both races that there could be peace even as the dwarves could prepare for war, that dwarves could be trusted with weapons in defense of their home. And Dis was furious that he was going to throw it all away on an elf that frankly, even as elves went, Dis did not like.

“At least pick one that laughs and drinks,” she growled at Kili, in between shouting at him. “Not the snobbiest one in the whole damn City.”

“She’s not snobby,” Kili snapped back. “She’s shy.”

“Not shy enough!” Ma crowed. “You’re seventy-six. She’s - what? A thousand? Ten thousand? For shame!”

Kili said, furious but also a little tempted to goad her, “Fourteen hundred and seven, next month.”

“I’ll wring her bloody neck for doing this to you!” Ma roared. “She should know better! She’s your superior officer, how is this not disgraceful conduct?”

“She’s not even really my boss,” Kili said. He’d never seen such a gale of fury from his regal mother, and it took everything in him not to laugh at her because he didn’t know what else to do. “We report to Lieutenant Fainthel. Fainthel’s the one who reports to Tauriel.”

“That makes it worse, Kili!” Dis practically shrieked. “Does the Guard have no standards? I’ll see to it she loses her position! She’ll be sweeping leaves off the streets for the rest of her long days, if I have anything to say about it!”

“Ma, calm down,” Kili said, which was definitely not the right thing to say. But after some time, she did calm down, and hugged him, and apologised for the worst of her words.

“I’m afraid for you,” she said, cupping his face with her hands. “You’ve worked so hard. You are forging a new path for our people. They will use this against you, if they find out.” Kili nodded and ducked his head, but Dis waited for him to meet her eye again. Now her voice was low and clear, its anger expended. “Kili, someone destroyed your uncle because he stepped over the line one too many times. Because he was sticking his big nose where it didn’t belong. I don’t know who it was but it goes deep, and it goes high. You do not get the luxury of breaking the rules when you are in the middle of trying to beat them. Do you understand me?”

He couldn’t argue. He did understand. She’d shaken him, with the mention of Thorin, who everyone else refused to talk about. Kili had only ever known the Woodland, he had only ever lived in a comfortable city house. He’d never even been as far as Laketown. If he had to run for it like Thorin, he’d be leaving everything and everyone he knew. And maybe love was worth that risk if he’d been ordinary, but Ma was right: he was Thror’s great-grandson and he had a responsibility to his people.

The next night, he managed to get a message to Tauriel. They met outside the city as she was coming back from patrol and he was going out, on the great mound to the North and East that was known as the Stargazing Hill. It was a smooth, gently inclining walk to the top, which was bare of trees. There was a ring of great, rain-weathered boulders low around its crest like a crown, each one at least twice the height of a dwarf and broad like molar teeth, forming a rough and gappy three-quarter circle. The grass inside the stone ring was long and soft and perfect for lying on under the open sky and watching the heavens. They’d been here many times.

Tauriel joined him as he waited on the crest of the hill for her, and tried to take his hands. He tucked them under his arms and he told her he’d let his youth lead him astray, but now they had to end it. The moonlight was bright enough to see her face as she broke, silently wiping the tears away and trying to tell him she understood and she would of course treat him as fairly as any other member of the Guard. He felt sick and miserable and his head ached like he had suddenly come down with a raging cold. He felt a moment of daring, and raised his sword to cut a thin braid from behind his ear. When he had done his hair this morning he’d closed the end with a little silver clip, stamped with the crest of Durin, a naming-day present from Thorin some years earlier. He’d worn it in the hopes of channeling some of Thorin’s dignity for his conversation with Tauriel tonight. He sealed the cut end of the braid into the clip, to make a circle of woven hair the size of his palm.

“Keep this. So you know I’m not doing this as a cowardly way of escaping you,” he said, putting it in her hand and closing her fingers over it. “Things are changing in the City. Maybe this doesn’t have to be forever.”

She nodded, and touched the little circle of hair to her mouth, and hid it in an inner pocket of her bodice. They said goodbye, but didn’t kiss, and went down the hill in different directions in case anyone saw them. Kili felt himself putting the shades around the flame he carried for her, but knew he’d never stop loving her, never.

They avoided meeting alone after that. Their duties rarely overlapped, so it was easy to avoid each other. A few times, they passed in the headquarters and nodded a greeting, barely making eye contact, as if they’d never been anything other than comrades in arms.

Two weeks later she was dead and Kili was in the cell beneath the palace, accused of her murder.

—

“When we get to the Mountain—” Thorin began.

“We’re not going to the Mountain yet,” Bilbo cut him off.

They were standing on the deck of a small ferry, slowly making its way up the River Running, south of the Long Lake. There were about a dozen other passengers, mostly travelling with rare materials; amber, incense-gum, sea oils, and Rhûn silks, to sell in Esgaroth or direct to the Woodland City. In the quieter, wider parts of the river, the crew poled the boat, and when the water was narrow and fast they threw thick tow-ropes to teams of oxen on the shore that heaved the vessel along well-built tow-paths. It was slow going, but still somewhat faster and easier than walking.

They had met the ferry after almost two weeks along the Old Forest Road, thankfully a less exciting journey than their first two days to the Anduin. At the end of the road, the marshes had been drained across a large area to build a comfortable and busy town, made to manage the flow of goods in and out of the three great city-states of the central east; the Woodland City, Esgaroth, and the Iron Hills. That meant the settlement was absolutely lousy with Woodland merchants and their attached Guards. After the relatively peaceful trip through the forest, Thorin was forced to skulk at the edges and hide his face whenever anyone wearing grey-green uniforms passed nearby, but Bilbo was happy to step in and prove his use. He left Thorin hiding in a small, disreputable-looking tavern, little more than a three-walled shack at the edge of the town. Within an hour, he had returned, having sold the ponies for a decent price, restocked their travelling supplies, and found them passage on the ferry first thing in the morning, which he scouted in advance to check it was crewed by Lakemen rather than elves from the Woodland. He’d also managed to pick up a new set of clothes so that he could finally replace those lost during the fight with the bandits; a set of dark blue, dwarven children’s clothes, a little baggy in the arms and shoulders and tight around the waist but warmer than his increasingly foul and fraying Bree clothes.

Now they were out on the water and could simply sit and rest for the first time in weeks. Bilbo had folded his bag under his head and slept for the first few hours. His stomach woke him up at lunchtime, and he and Thorin ate and sat on the edge of the ferry and watched the forest pass in endless rows of dense, tall trees on the west side of the river.

Now Thorin looked at him.

“I’m paying you as a professional burglar to enter Erebor,” Thorin said quietly so the other passengers didn’t hear, his hand propped up on his hip. “Are you saying you won’t go into the mountain?”

Bilbo finished his bite of chewy day-old bread and wiped his mouth. “You’re paying me to find a dragon and the source of King Thranduil’s mithril. The latter is hardly something I can learn in the Lonely Mountain, and the former may be answerable by other means. I know you have a plan, but as you said, I am the professional.” He turned to hold Thorin’s eye, waiting to see how he’d react.

“We’ve come all this way,” Thorin said, with an angry edge to his tone.

“Yes. And we’re exactly on track,” Bilbo smiled cautiously. “I want to talk to the Lakemen. They live nearest the mountain. They may know more about the dragon. After that, I may have to go the Woodland.”

Thorin shook his head. “You can’t be seen in there. It’s far too dangerous.”

“I have my ways of staying unseen,” Bilbo patted Thorin’s thigh. “Trust me.” He squinted a little. “Everyone I’ve spoken to talks about the Woodland as a haven of peace and plenty. What is it that you’re so afraid of in there? Why do you insist it’s so dangerous?”

“It’s hard to explain,” Thorin said testily.

“I’m not saying you’re mad or lying,” Bilbo assured him. “I just need to understand.”

Thorin watched the passing trees. Bilbo remembered something he’d said weeks ago, when he’d asked Thorin why he always kept his beard so neat. …it was driven into me, like a fencepost…

Bilbo tried to prompt him. “My mother used to say, 'Go not to the Elves for counsel for they will answer both no and yes.’”

“In the City we say, ‘Careful which end you’re speaking to, they both wear masks’,” Thorin raised an eyebrow at him. “If you catch my drift.” Bilbo laughed but Thorin sighed. “They used to say it about the Wood-elves. Now I hear it said about anyone in the city, elf or dwarf, who says one thing and does another.”

“Your people are blending together,” Bilbo said. “And you don’t like what that means.”

“No, it’s not that,” Thorin shook his head. “The City wants us to believe we are blended, that we are the same, but then it treats us as if we are not. I thought once that in entwining our fates, Thranduil and myself, we were creating something new, something of great craft and spirit that would survive the coming ages.” He drew in a long, shuddering breath. It seemed like he couldn’t find the words to explain what he meant. At last he said, “You cannot trap a wolf with fire and iron and hope to get anything from it but its skin and teeth. But you can lure a starving wolf pup, with meat and shelter, and it will forget how to hunt, and its grandsons will become the dogs that beg and fetch on your command, for nothing more than scraps.”

Bilbo waited until his stomach settled a little. He said, “Dogs don’t tell stories or make plans. You can’t tame a person.”

Thorin rumbled. “No. The only thing you can do with a disobedient dog is put it down.”

—

Thorin did not understand his father’s warning until many, many years after Thrain had disappeared.

Everything had changed since those dark days. The City was young but beginning to take shape. Thranduil had sourced enough Mithril to get them through the lean times. Back then, Thorin never questioned where it had come from; it was a blessing from the Valar. He was simply glad to see the teams of dwarves and elves working together, labouring - arguing, teasing, laughing as they went - to build new homes and new defensive walls and new streets paved in stone but lined with trees. The rivers had been redirected into canals to carry goods from one side of the realm to the other, the reservoirs tapped to bring clean water up from the depths of the earth, and every new home and path hung with the Mithril-touched lights, carrying the sun’s glow and warmth into the shadows and shelters of their halls. The Erebor council, a dwindling collection of noble cousins and guildmasters from before the fall of the Mountain, was shrinking as its members aged, but the consortium of trade and business was growing as money began to fill dwarvish coffers. Dis was married, and happily living with her husband in a beautiful house near the edge of the City. She had not made any announcements yet, even to Thorin, but Balin had started talking about “when she’s given the line of Durin new princelings,” as if they were ordered and paid for like an ironmonger’s shipment.

Thorin sat on Thranduil’s small council, and sometimes when the long and dreary business of state was over, the two of them would take tea or wine in one of the quiet parlours of Thranduil’s palace, on a balcony overlooking the city. Thorin had stopped using any title of ‘King’ for himself some years earlier, but he also didn’t use it for Thranduil: he addressed Thranduil only by his name, and was never corrected even in public.

That day, Thranduil said, “Give my congratulations to your sister.”

Thorin raised his eyebrows. “She has not told me any news of note.”

Thranduil chuckled. “Ah, then my apologies to her for spoiling the surprise. I saw her yesterday at the trade meeting.”

“She told you she was with child?”

“No, but a healer knows these things.”

Thorin took a large sip of his wine. “That is wonderful news, I almost wish you hadn’t said anything. It’ll be a hard job for me to keep my mouth shut.”

“And I hope our family, too, will be so blessed,” Thranduil smiled. “My son still acts like a young bachelor, but he has affections for one elf in particular. I think he is too proper to act on it while he is Commander of the Guard, though, as she is one of his captains and is beholden to his orders.”

“He will speak when he feels ready. These are good times to be young. A time for marriages,” Thorin said.

Without warning, Thranduil’s long arm reached across the table and snagged a lock of Thorin’s hair, near the temple. “You have some grey.”

Thorin pulled away without thinking. The hair fell away from Thranduil’s fingers. Thorin brushed it behind his ear.

“I can give you something for that,” Thranduil said softly.

Thorin laughed. “Absolutely not. I’ve just started to get the old fellows to call me ‘Your Majesty’ instead of ‘Laddie’. I need the grey.”

There was a look on Thranduil’s face that he did not expect, a flicker of anger and disgust. And then it was gone and they moved on to other topics of discussion.

But a week later they were having supper, talking about something to do with food imports. Thranduil offered him a glass, but as soon as he sipped it, he put it down in a hurry.

“Ugh, this wine has gone bad.”

“It’s distilled with a remedy,” Thranduil said, folding his cloak across his lap and leaning back in his chair. “Finish it, it will do you good.”

“A remedy for what?”

Thranduil said, “For your grey. And those wrinkles around your mouth.”

Thorin stared at him. “I’m not drinking this.”

“It’s just herbs, and a simple spell of renewal. It will make you feel and look younger. It’s not dangerous, it’s an old recipe of mine.”

“Why would you do that? Without asking me?”

“Because you’re my favourite, and I’d like to delay the inevitable,” Thranduil said. “Drink it, it will go to waste otherwise.”

Thorin could not find any words to answer. He put the glass aside, and tried to turn the conversation back to grain stocks. He left the meeting with his food untouched and his heart racing.

All those years later, when he walked into Bilbo’s office in Bree, he told the tale as if Thranduil was the one who had pushed him out of power on a whim. But the truth was, Thorin was the one who turned cold, who stepped away from their decades of friendship. He no longer met Thranduil in private, and was more cautious in what he promised in council meetings. He never again took any food or drink that Thranduil gave him.

He could tell that Thranduil was offended, and soon Thorin’s invitations to the palace dried up and it was clear to everyone that his days of influence over the elven king had waned. But the horror of the attempted violation stayed in Thorin’s bones, in his marrow, and when he spoke to Thranduil it was with all the deference and distance of two rulers meeting for the first time, unsure and wary of any alliance.

—

Bilbo had been in Laketown for about a week, living out of a single room in one of the many inns, when he found their breakthrough.

The inn, called the Black Arrow House, was run by a tall, jolly landlady named Inga, with some help from what seemed like innumerable children, as her dour husband seemed to be away on his boat most of the day. They had picked this particular inn because the ferrymen that had brought them recommended it. Not because it was the best, but because for a few extra coin - some of the last they had left - Inga said she would forget to record them in the records all innkeepers sent to the Master, the records of travellers coming and going from the large town. They didn’t give their real names anyway, of course. They went by Mr Underhill and Mr Luznâ from the Blue Mountains, but pseudonyms were not enough for Bilbo; he wanted no trace of them to be written down for anyone who might come snuffling around later.

Thorin did not stay in Laketown past the first day. He was determined to make a trip to the Lonely Mountain, even if it was alone and on foot, to search for the hidden doorway he remembered from his father’s map. To this end he hitched a ride to the north shore of the lake with Inga’s husband, Bard, under the cover of dusk. Bard was apparently picking up some cargo from there, though Bilbo didn’t ask what had to be picked up at night from the least inhabited side of the lake. He let Thorin go, and hoped to Yavanna he would see him again.

Then, making his way around town, he began to ask about dragons. He played the part of the excitable eccentric where possible, feigning the effects of drink where necessary. But he soon discovered that the people of Esgaroth were the worst kind of informers: they talked too much about the dragon. Bilbo could not get a consistent story out of any of them. Everybody claimed to have seen the dragon, although sometimes he took the form of a strong wind on the lake, sometimes a bolt of lightning and thunder on a dry day, sometimes a distant roar that might have just been a stag in the hills but surely was actually Smaug the Terrible. Everybody had a second cousin’s friend who had snuck up to the front door and glimpsed the dragon lying on his hoard, or who had been out with his sheep and was snaffled up in the night leaving only a smear of blood and entrails. Everybody knew an old song that foretold where and when the dragon would strike next, or described him in particularly lurid detail. It was amazing how quickly stories about a dragon became boring, when told by a lot of boring fisherfolk with nothing else to do but regale you.

After several days, Bilbo skipped his usual evening questioning old men at the pubs, and had his dinner in the Black Arrow instead. Inga served him a lovely meat pie and boiled vegetables, as Bilbo decided he had earned a proper meal. It was necessary for his hobbitish health. He told her to put it on Thorin’s tab and retired to a quiet table in the corner of the Inn, going through the pencilled notes he’d made of the dragon rumours.

“My wife tells me you’re a pleasure-seeker,” said a voice. Bilbo raised his head quickly. Inga’s husband, Bard, was sitting in a chair by the fire, smoking a pipe and repairing some piece of child’s clothing with a thick needle. The eponymous Black Arrow for which the inn was named, apparently a relic of the destruction of Dale, hung above the mantelpiece behind him, as dark and brooding as the bargeman himself.

“Sorry?” Bilbo asked.

“You know. Come to see the sights. Get a bit of local colour. Things you can’t get at home,” Bard said without looking up. “Inga said you’ve given a false name and been out at a different establishment every night since you arrived.”

Bilbo raised his hand. “Oh, no, no, no, it’s absolutely not what you think.”

Bard raised an eyebrow. “We may be considered the backwater of the continent but we’re not so conservative as I hear they are in the West. We get so many people through this town, you see a bit of everything.”

“No, no, honestly, I’m not here for—” Bilbo winced, and tried to think how he could salvage the reputation of his invented Mr Underhill. “I’m actually writing a book. About dragons.”

Bard looked up from his needlework at last. He took the pipe from his mouth. “About dragons?” He asked.

“Yes. I’m sure you can tell me all about how you friend’s wife’s father-in-law once saw Smaug tossing sheep into the lake one Sunday—”

“I’m sure I could. People talk a lot of rot about things they fear but have never seen,” Bard said grimly. After a moment he added, “I don’t know anything about dragons. But you’ll want to talk to the Starwatcher.”

Bilbo sat up a little. “And who’s that when he’s at home?”

Bard waved the stem of his pipe vaguely towards the window. “Old fellow, lives at the end of the pier off Roe End, in a tall house you can’t mistake. He’s batty as a belfry, but if anybody has really seen the dragon, it’s him. Go in the evening, he sleeps during the day.”

Bilbo nodded. “Thank you. I’ll try him tomorrow.”

“If he can’t help, head to the Woodland. Their scholars are wiser than any folk you’ll find in these parts,” Bard said, going back to his darning. “Even their King himself. He comes through Laketown sometimes, to treat with the Master about trade and hiring men to build roads. He knows about the dragons of old, when the drakes of the North were more numerous than starlings.”

“Have you met him?” Bilbo asked. “I don’t know anything about him, honestly.”

“I have,” Bard bit off the thick thread with a rip that made Bilbo wince. “I owe him everything precious to me, in fact. When my wife was in labour with our second son, he was passing through on some errand. She and the babe were dying and my sister-in-law found him and begged for his help. He is a great healer, and he saved them both, though she was a common boatman’s wife in a leaking, rough house by the canal. He is a good king, who cannot turn his heart from the poor and wretched, and he has a skill in healing unmatched even in his own realm.”

Bilbo listened curiously. It was such a different character after the impression he’d got from Thorin, who had outlined the picture of a callous tyrant. But he reminded himself that Thorin and Thranduil must have been friends, once. Perhaps it was this side of Thranduil that Thorin had once seen, the king that Bard knew.

“‘Both ends wear masks’,” he said, half to himself.

Bard looked up at him with a canny eye. “They say that in the City,” he said with a careful tone. “But I thought you and your companion were newcomers here?”

Bilbo gave a little laugh. “Oh, just something I heard on the boat up the river. I don’t remember who said it.”

—

Thorin spent five days around the Lonely Mountain, walking the slopes and trying to recognise the ridges and valleys that he remembered when they were thick with pines and alive with birds and deer. He climbed high up until he reached sheer rocks that still held sheets of ice and frost until late in the afternoons. He felt the stone there with his hands, pressed his cheek close and listened to it. It had the texture and colour and scent of the heart of raw stone that made up the walls of the hidden kingdom below his feet, and just to be near it was a balm to the spirit.

He found the doorstep outside the hidden tunnel on the fourth day. He was sure this was the place, a level stoop leading to a grassy clifftop step between high walls of crumbling stone and carved masonry. The wall at the back looked natural but was just a little too smooth, the lichen growing in a way that suggested different ages of stone in the rough outline of a door. But as he’d feared, it was closed, and there was no sign of a keyhole, handle or hinge. There was no sign at all that the door had been opened for over a century, since Smaug had taken the mountain. Thrain had not made it this far. Like all the other places Thorin had searched, no trace of him could be found.

Thorin sat on the step outside and contemplated the door for some time. There must be a secret he hadn’t seen on the map, which his father had not revealed or perhaps did not know himself. He had felt sure that when he came here, he would find some sign of his father, or a sense of his presence even if he was long dead. But the place was empty and wild, untouched by dwarvish hands since the day Thror must have closed it long ago.

“Where did you go, Father?” he whispered to himself as stared over the lake, back towards Mirkwood. He could just make out a different texture to the trees in the place where he knew the City lay under the canopy. It looked so close from this vantage point, a straight line as the raven flies. How had Thrain lost his way?

There was nothing more to do but return to Laketown, especially since his food was running low. He was disappointed but not bitterly so. It had always been a long shot, breaking into the mountain through a secret entrance that no one else had found all these years. He was glad he’d come, but he had gained more questions than answers.

He walked the rough road around the lake to the bridge on the east shore, and slipped through into Laketown by tagging close behind a group of merchants, past the watchmen who were sleeping or laughing to each other without checking who was coming and going into the town.

It was late afternoon when he walked into the Inn and found Bilbo in their room looking through a pile of papers. Bilbo jumped up and practically ran to greet him. Thorin felt a warm glow at such a welcome.

“Did you find the secret door?” Bilbo asked.

“Yes, and no,” Thorin said. “It is shut. Without the key, we cannot get in that way.”

“Nevermind, nevermind,” Bilbo took his arm and tugged him to the small table under the window. “Take off your boots, sit, you’ve come at a perfect time. Inga is bringing up tea and some cakes shortly.”

“You’ve found something?” Thorin guessed.

“Yes, although it may not be all good news,” Bilbo sounded rather too cheerful for someone giving bad news.

Thorin pulled a second chair up beside him and sat down. The table was small and he and Bilbo were sitting practically knee to knee. He could faintly smell a woody soap-smell coming off him, from the Inn’s bath. He already looked better fed than after their weeks on the road. Thorin hated to think what he smelled like after five days wandering the mountain eating hard tack and dried fish.

“There’s an old man, an astronomer, who’s lived in Laketown his whole life. His great-grandfather was a renowned scholar in Dale, and the family has lived as teachers and wisemen here since Dale was destroyed. But they’ve always watched the skies, tracking eclipses and comets and so forth, and their records are exemplary.”

“I don’t think we need to know about comets,” Thorin said. “Only fools believe comets precede a change in fortunes.”

“They watch the skies, Thorin,” Bilbo repeated. “The old man was very happy to talk to someone curious. He let me look through all the record books of any notable changes in the night sky. I found more than two dozen times where the dragon was seen flying from the mountain, since the family came to Laketown, including one only fifteen years ago,” looked up at him. “That means Smaug was alive recently.”

Thorin felt his stomach sink. “This is grave news. So my theory that Thranduil is slowly robbing the mountain cannot be true.”

“Unless he has some magic that allows him to pass unseen,” Bilbo suggested. “Such things do exist.”

“There is some wood-elf magic that might allow him to pass stealthily, unnoticed to weak minds, but even his strongest spells could not make him invisible to a dragon’s keen eyes and nose,” Thorin shook his head.

Bilbo opened his mouth, but at that moment there was a knock on the door and Inga came in carrying a tray with tea and two slices of a thick, chewy rectangle-thing that was sweet and somewhat cake-like. Bilbo fell silent as Thorin took the tray and thanked her. Once she’d gone, he pulled out his notebook again and showed Thorin a scribbled list of dates and notes.

“The old man thinks the flights are when the dragon is hungry. But there’s a somewhat regular pattern that he pointed out to me - these are the dates I wrote down. It’s a bit all over the place for the first few decades after the fall of Erebor, but after that it’s almost exactly every seven years in the same direction. Other years he goes all everywhere, there’s no rhyme to it, but this seven year pattern he repeats. Look at the compass direction the dragon flies.”

“West by South-west,” Thorin said. It took him a moment to picture the map in his mind. Then he looked at Bilbo with wide eyes. “Directly towards the City.”

Bilbo nodded. “How often would you say those mysterious Mithril shipments arrive?”

Thorin shook his head. “Less than once a decade is not far off, but it’s hard to say. I did try to find records, before I fled the city, but unlike most palace imports the mithril doesn’t end up on the court’s books of state. Mithril stocks are not managed by the trade guild, they seem to be handled by…” Thorin looked back at the notes Bilbo had taken and felt a creeping cold in his limbs. “By the praetorians. The king’s personal guard. Half of them are made up of the twenty elves who survived entering Erebor the day it fell. They’re considered heroes to the dwarves. The only ones who faced dragon fire to save our people.”

He was quiet for a moment. Bilbo was still fidgeting with excitement. “Do you see what I’m thinking? Perhaps Thranduil doesn’t have to rob the mountain. Perhaps the treasure is delivered to him.”

Thorin propped his elbow on the table and rested his head against his hand. “It makes no sense. Why would the beast do Thranduil’s bidding? The monster has no honour or mercy. It would not gift a coin from its hoard to buy any creature’s friendship, even another dragon.”

“I don’t know. Perhaps Thranduil has some way of threatening it?”

“My sister and I have tried proposing weapons for killing dragons, over the years, something like the old Windlances, designs improved by the City engineers and the elvish magicians together,” Thorin rubbed his brow. “Thranduil always found a way to delay paying for such a weapon. I don’t know how else you would threaten a dragon.” He shook his head. “I don’t know, Bilbo. Perhaps it’s nothing. You got this list of dragon sightings from a mad star-gazer’s inherited weather-almanac, and on this happenstance you’re trying to answer both of my questions in one strike of your hammer—”

He stopped, staring at the top of the paper, at the first date on the list which Bilbo had indicated. Bilbo, heedless, said defensively, “I’m not saying I’ve solved the whole mystery, I’m just saying it’s something to look into further…are you alright?”

“This date,” Thorin pointed. “The first flight towards the City.”

“Oh, yes, I don’t know about that one,” Bilbo peered at it. “It’s more than twenty years before the pattern really gets going, so that might be nothing.”

“I remember this day,” Thorin said faintly.

Bilbo glanced at him. “Are you sure? That was a long time ago. I barely remember what date my milk bill is due in Bree, and that comes every month.”

“I know it,” Thorin whispered. “Seven days before the winter solstice. He left the first night of the winter festivities. I know the year because my sister came of age the next year, and I had to do the ceremony. Because I was her only family. Because my father had left us a week before the solstice,” and then, feeling his chest shudder as he tried to breathe, he corrected himself. “Because my father disappeared that day.”

The silence fell between them for a very long while. At last, Bilbo said, “I think it’s time I went into the City.”